Document EqxVdNKGLymYnDX7GMx2ZN1zL

L L 0D\L <H t $ L 1 !! <0 - L L 9LDL (+ ODLDL )mUL U3L (+ 'RFNHAA 1R4 L (3$+ +4+ 2$+ 1 !! <H - + !! <H !! L L 0V4 L 6DFDQy\KDL . L 'LD/LA/L L SWRFLDAH - $CPUXW\timJL 211LFH - Ri L 3RDLF\L ^ 1 !! !! L 3HXV\0vDQLDL $YFQXHQ L 1: L ODLDL 8R3HL ^ T $L :D^KLOVTO L '&L 1 H M* L L 5H L 8RPFHW V\RL (3$3VL 5HJ)CDARJ\L 5HIRJP1 7CVN- )RJFHL DBWV-\AKH- 1636L IRJ- *UDU3L L (CHYDARJVu H !! L &)5L 30W- H! $ L 6XESOW- ' '$ L 8UJLQJL 31FVSHRALYH- 5HSHDO0 L \ARL - 1 L )H3^ L 5HJ4 L <H - - T L t $9LM L ^ T $ L 1 ^ $ L 'RFNH/V1 1R< L ( L 'KUL (N4 L mv L L 7KLVL \XADAm-Q- LVL VXEPIVWG1 FQL B-KDOI L RI L DL FFCOQALFQ1 R! L VL[L QWFCDO1 WD W<H- DJULFXW<LjDOLlAjHWRft 4636L 6XESDUAA '' L SRlGOAKBEfc KDYH- B+DL ZRjNLQJ - ZIV\KLV\MHL (QOIFCFHWD1 3LFWfV\LFQL $JFCF\L J (3$ L VLFHL 1 !! !! L FQL IWL U-MJHZL Rl$ L DQGL V DFH3MWl\AR3 l m/1 1HZL 6RXSJFH- 3KJIRJFDGFH1 QADQGDUGV1 4 1636a L IRJ- JIDU3L HDJYQARJ M! 5 L eXESOJ/V1 "5 L SXLK/XTBA/- V\RL VFFALFQ1 H H H ' E RI V\KH 8CI-DQL $UUL SFW1 a &$$ - ] ^ <n a E @< L L (3$3VL SURSFMH31- INCH- D8SFDLK/L QAA - L )H3< L 5HJ4 L T 1 ^ 1 L 4 L L 1636L 6XESOW- 11L DSSOLH/1 V\RL DQ\L >DI IHWGL IDFLOIAAA L FTOOIAtMWG1 RJL FFGLIL FHJ/\DLQL JUDLQL ZQAKL DL SHJFDCHW- W\RJDJH- FD6DFIAAA L H[FFH3LQJL 1 t L PLC LLLLLLLLLLLLL LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL 111 7KHL 8FOJmmL LCPCM3-h/L V\KHL SRJ3L 5HILHJ\/L $WRFLQALR LWHL 1DALR3DOL SRCFUD1 RI L )DUFHUL 8PRS-LD/ 1CMRDD- *LDLQl DQ3l )H-Gl $\A/RFLQALKX LWHL 1QALFCDO- 2LM+GL 3LRFHARA/1 $\A/RFLQALKX LWHL 1RJAKL $R OUXHlN/9 L $V\/RFLIWKX L DQGLV\f<HL 86$L 5LFHL )H3-UMK3< L L <H L 17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production ED 001523 00008300-00001 EXVW-Q/1 RJL HI !! L PLOOLRQL EXVKFQ/L Li L CRFDWG1 Q/V- ZKHW- ICRX3J- PL0CM3 L ZH/V- RJL QU VR\B-DQL RLOL H|WjDFV\LFQL SCDW/^ L L 6LGFH- LWXDCFH- Rl L (2L HI T T |- t l Ll 1 !! HI HI $ L FMJL 8RH\ALRQL KEVL SHAZWFQ-C UHSH30L 6XESaJ/\m^SHFW.YmeTO)<VH- W<H- 1636L LVL FWfflAH3L DQGL >Q}FHA/DLM L ,QL IAAX/L LDQ-FCNLQJL SJRSFM3G) L V\KHL $JhCF\L DQ3LHA/H31- V\KHL CHJIA/\LPDF\L RI L 6XESDU/V- L BW1 I aHTOXALDAH- DGHTXWO\L WCW1 hPLWLFO/1 IUFPL JUDLQ1 VARjDJH- IDFLOLWJ-K/L SFVHL DL VLJGL H3vFUR3HHWDL ULVNlV\Rl KXFDQl KHDWK- DQGL ZFDIDLH R3l Dl JRLQJ+ IRJZDUG1 HM-V4 L L ,G 1 !! HI H L FRPFHW/1 >FRS\L tW\DFKK@ L ZHL DUJMGL WOW1 V\KLVL IDLIM/H- FHXVL WW (3$l DXtAKRJIAAA L V\RL D630\L 6XESDUI/V- " LV\RL IXAWJH1- FMHW$ L XQ3HJ CR/V- FCD\L V\KHL &$$$ L EXA 5FGMWFQL SFW1 4 35$ L L ,QL 0DUFKL 1 !! HI |- 5 L ZHL FDOH- W<H- VDFH- SRLW- l_QL FRPFH3 DL WQ-Df SH33LQJL ,QIRJRWFQL 8FGCHV\LFQL 5HTXHX/V- ,&5 L IRJ- 6XESDU/V- ' L L MW- ,, \AKH- LOXADCm/L GxULAF 1 !! HI K HI L Rl L CHZL FRW\OXFWFQL RJL FR3JLRWFQ1 RI L >DI I UFCHYDW- JUDLQL HDHvtm*/1 ZRXDGL BHL jFLRQ L V\KHJFE\L XCGHJFXtAALQJ- (3$3VL XJABTOID FRWjDU\ l LQl IWL 1 !! HI \ L UXO-FCNLQJL SIRSFVDCX L L ,QL 2FV\REHJL 1 !! HI \ $ L (3$3VL SDFNDJHL WMCUL IlDOL DRALR31 R3LV\KHL 1 !! HI \ L 2CP/oL IRJ- U-MJHZL XQ3HJ (2L1i^MLL:HL KDtK- CR/V1 B+Ql VKR23l Dl FRS\ l Rl LV\KHL BW1 (3$L W\DI I L LQ3LFHV\R3L RJDOO\ LV\RL XVL Q/V- WH- V\LFH- W<DAA Q/V1 ZRXDGL LCFCXQH- CHZL FHJAO_QL JUDLQL HJHYQARJv/ L DG3L\ALRLD0L W-KXALQJC L FFQAARJLAJC L LHHRJGNHHSLQJ - DQGL LHSR GLIIHJ-QV- FRP90LDGFHL UHTXLUFFHW/1 IRJ- SHJLRG/L RI L VADUAKSS L VWGVQ1 DQGL FDOIXCRAL FHAKR31 IRJL FDCBdMOJL V\KHL FRWJLEXtALRQ- RI L WP5RJDU\L VARJDJH- I DFLOLWJ-K/L V\RL >SHJ 7KH- I LQX)L UXCH- ZRXOGL D6S0\ LV\RL JUDLQl KDQGOLQJL IDFLOWH/1 RQL ZKLFKL FRW\LKFWFQS UJTQO(AOKFWR3L EHJDQL DIWUL -XD\L LL VNKHL QWH- V\KHL SURSFMH3L DFFQ3H-Q V\KH)H3-ljD0L 5HJLWLJ L *LYFQL V\KQ/V- DUUD\ l Rl L SRAKWJXL RXtAFRFFVa L ZH \M/SFFV\H3L W<D/V- W<HL ILCDOL SDFN RJ- UHIHJFCFH- GQADL DQGL DCDO\VFK/L \mW- FDFH- UW*L H[LW\FCFH- DIV\HJ-W<H- FCFVHL Rl L V\K 'FFFPBHJ1 1 1 $ L 1 !! HH L L DQGL KFCFH- ZHJH CR/V1 RSLDL V\RL SXB3LFL FRPFHW- L FRXDGL BH- RI L FHWJX)L LPSRMCFH V\RL VRFH- Rl L (3$9VL NH\L ILDOL G-FLVLRJ/^ L :HL SHA 2CP/oL V\RL HfDPLCH- W<DA/^ SFWLELOQAA L DQffi L LI L WMF L XUJH31 WCW1 V\KHL FFPR-QA/- SHJLR31 Rl L SHAIWPQ1 QAADFKH3< @L L 23L 'hfl-PB-U- 5 L!!^ hS LV\KHL 8RDOWPQL FW ZQAKL FRCFHJCV^ L 'XLILQJL W<H" FRJGLDO1 R-HALQJC L ZH DUJXHJ WW LI LV\KHL SDFNDJH- UhEXAX/L R VXEPLVWG- GxULQJL V\KHL FRPFKW- SHJLR32 L V\MDL OLNK)\L Q/V1 FRWDLO/1 hCRXJKL QHZL (M)L WJLJJHJ- DQL RBDLJDWFQ1 V\RL LHf RSFDLV\KHL FRPFKW1 SHJLRS^ L L L L 7KH- ILQDOL DFWFQL SDFNDJH1 ZLVL CR/V1 ILCD0L]H3l E\ l (3$l DQGl R3l -DQXDU\ l 1 ^ 5 l ZLVl RI I LFLDOO\L ZIWOJD031 IURPL 2CP/o< L i 6FH L mm/ 1 1 ZZZ^ LHJLQIR^ JR/1 SXB3LF1 GRl FR'HADLa/"UULG <H 1 h t ^ L L L L $A/- V\KLVL SRLCW- U3LWFHJ L ZH DLH XCFFOADLQ1- LI L V\KLVL IMK- LVl JRLOJ V\Rl BHU-MJHZ1 RJ- Li L (3$L CRL CRDJHJ- ZlGOL SXLVXH- LHVLVLRQL RI L 1636L 6XESDUI/V- "1 "D4 L 7KD V\RL VXHVFFW- CHZL JUDUDL KWOTU/1 V\RL V\KHVHL XXH=HWDU\L LHJXCD/\RJ\L EXUQ-QA) L ZH DVN CH2D\+ IRJFH3L 5HJXCDARJ\L 5HIRJP1 7DVN- )RJFH- U-FRPFFQ3- W<H- IRGCRZLQJ - DRALFO/1 V\RL \NK $CPliX\WjCmJ L L H tJR/V1 ILCDOL]H-V\m- SURSRVFGl DFH33HHW/LV\RL 1636l 6XESDU/V- " L DQGL L L L _L L 17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production ED 001523 00008300-00002 1 )RJFDGO\ LH/FLQ3l V\KHl ->0\ l $ L 1 !! <H ^ L SIRSFVH3L DFH3MWLV\RL 1636L 6XE IRJFDOO\L LH/FLQ3LQJL V\KLVL IDCHu L (3$L ZRXOGL BHL DECHL V\RL >BXN LV\KHL FRXA Ri IVRA/-W<H- FRWL Ri L DL IXARJH- IMHI L Q/L QWXH3L U3L ( L <H T - - H L 8KWR30LQJ l 5HJ>CDARJ\ l 8RW< l l L ))W<HM L ZH hCFRXLDJH - (3$L V\RL H[DPLCH L \AKH - SFVVLELOQM L Ri L L V\KLVL SLR^SKW^hBn]Gl RJ- FRGLI \LQJL IW1 H3vH3L XSFQLV\NHL 8RD0QALFQl FRPFHW1 VXEPIW\H3L U3L RI L DL CDUJHJ- UHJXDARJ\L UHIRJP1 HI IRLW L L /MH3L XSRQL RXU- R2Ql H^/m/LYH- FRPFHW1 DQGLV\KHL FRPFHW1 RI L RAKRM L DQGLV\ DQ\L FRPFHW1 IURPL CFQf JRvHJCFHWO1 RJJDCL]DALRM< L ZH BHDLFMH1 WCW1 (3$L FRXOGL HI DL UHSH301 LPFH3LD/\HD\L V\KUR(JKL ilDOL DRALFQ1 U3LV\KHL SUFMHW UXO-FCNLOJC L ZQAKRW1 J DQGL\ALR3X)L CRALFHf DQGf FRPFHW UXCFFCNLQJ^ L L L L :H- D69UFFLDAH-W<H- RSSfWDlAAA L V\RL SUR/LGH- W<HL 5HJXDARJ\L 5HIRJP1 7CVNL )RJFHL YLHZV1 FQL 6XESDU/V- " L L , I L \RXL KDYH- DQ\L TXHWFQ4 L SCFCVH1 FRWFW- V\KHL X33HLM. IVFFFGxHJQJ ICH RLMI L L L L L L L L 6lFHUFD\5 L L L L L L L L L L L IMDFKFHW L FFL Y YLDL FFDLO L L L L L L L L L L L -FKA/L 0F8CMiJL lEMFQD1 *UDLQL DQGl )FH3l $WRFLIMFQl SRDOQALFQ1 &KDLUL L L -HI IL .QLJK/V- Y SRDOQALFQ1 FRSCMHDn l WK - /HZLVL Y (3$ L LQOLDPL 6FKURFN - Y (3$ L 3HAHJ- : \FI\RI IL Y 8FCmml FRCMHDn L L L L TL 17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production ED 001523 00008300-00003