Document Edw28w4DdV7pDD4Bkw1L2enxV
1 mentioned that you wrote to the author of one paper.
Page 3594
2 Have you ever written to these authors
3 asking them or suggesting to them that their verified
4 cases of asbestosis weren't really asbestosis?
5 A No, I have not.
6 Q They say it is noteworthy, however, that
7 past exposures during brake maintenance probably have
8 been heavier than the concentrations reported in this
9 study. Thus, the present exposure may indicate a
10 lowered risk of asbestosis in the future.
11 What do you understand that to mean?
12 A That means the exposures in the past of
13 garages, because the work practice might have been
14 higher, the exposure. And that is the reason why I
15 rely on those case control studies, because those case
16 control studies would include garage mechanics who
17 work in the 1920s, 1930s and 1940s.
18 It would not be appropriate today to start a
19 study, a cohort study of garage mechanics exposed
20 today and use that study to form an opinion of garage
21 mechanics who were exposed in the 1950s and 1960s.