Document EdnXOKboGde9ygezYoGj0a5Qn
PLAINTlFF'S EXHIIlIT
CAM-113
THAN-279
!'i':.are has been consirlezabla huliabaloo z3cently abou~ a 1!:!IT~1l U11c'-~~ Inl:e:rn.ntional Talc t s AsbeGtice 625.
As~estine 625 pmbably do~s :re~:rasEmt the ultimatra iinenes3 to whf.r.:!1
the haz'sh No Yorit State tales Can be :;)'rcc1u.ced. 'lh:i..3, ,10"1113;;'0:;:. ,.!Ot3, ':!...:. :: .-z.a..1:ce it a l!naw" p:rocluct sines oUr cOU:;GS'I: Miot:rons J 1.39 SIlt:. .?-l2.~,
ox~~~~ox1mata the pa%tic~e size :range ascestica ~25
0:.:;1'; ~'!.m .:la~!.:t~1a~ s:;az~_cac1s oi 3:'... '::'la~
r::~90e ~!i.:;::'J:::w.c ::u ;x~- ;;0::.. ::':;
tam~:.::j.:;ae ;3~C!:~gs l'~ a ~O\1er ~::~~~3
'i:::..o~ #')i ~~~.3&..::i:"1~ :il:>: ":~ :~'~":'
.:lc'!h:.:.;:i.,.h'".._. n", ,_~"
__
--
.,;;
I,......."..S
... ..--,., - - -
".a~,-"'.,.e1,0,0.\1 .. :; ~............
I ......... Q
! ~e.,
,;"'-:
t"iO
..'.'..'....'-C.'...1
.-:.,-.~,~
:;r ..4 ......J
:~,.-.,J._,,F:";;.":_.~....:-
... ,
... e'
~~ji::'t":; :9~;..;:t3 i~ .'\sb:ast:!.ne ~25
..~:= .::r.t:J!:.at:.y p:!.S.CGS i'Z'3lr:: :!s:.a:;o:tkC.G on ::.t'c:~az-l.al tr..l~~li~l &!r..ci Z:$.W ~';..:::....:.,;:';
c:::-l:!.~~,:~:~ion. 11:. 3oz::e ';:S3e:; t~s ii!rJ!:] hSVQ ob;J~.:.=ed ~3 1&:~ ;;Oi!;;- ~:
'.:.:;;~a tina tales, W:1) ala.., oi:~e:r:iI:lpo:::t:;;nt p..-ica aclva::~<-;e5. Att:z.~~";;-':'
l1Hat: i!o. 1 of price ::0!!lp8:ri::'lOl"..s clearly illuatratea -t;.'l:.).s.
I
It .:>:::a:Jomt:, cnly t:I~a h=$&st p:ri:1t mru:.uiacture:r:J P'\l=~:;'l,;:se -3':::il:i.Z:~:;
'-c!ds ....~..._:..,....~..w_
",".' .,~.....'.I.-".,......,... '_" i " 3III. . ..~c"..'_1_~_
.:....:~;.)._"_.g.,..,.-w,,~_- ):;:''-_l!.:Ct-.i~O~#a'_J~."JJ "_,J.-...,..,_-"... ~~~~.'..!..>.._..:..-. ."-........,_-.,_.-..-...-......
;l:J:3C ";;!"J.O"'\O! ~u:~tity in its o,e=a;!on. ~i~~1 of thentl ;t!Z':::~J"! ~:-;:1,;;::.:.-.::.,-~
;!!l..-:l"aas :;)~ :::32ular and ul'1;Z'Q f~a tnlcs f:rcm ~?e:l Zo~~t ;:';61:2.
..........,.. __....._w_ :'r!'t t!tl~~ 4.r.-:-0S
~. ;.,~~~.... Oi':t---",,""1Wo
. . . . . . .'" Jo ...&:.L'~_
1.....6...~~.Q~ A'J.~i:-,:.".."..O ........_J-.....n......;..~."_:.:"r ..~.. _.r: v~.':w')-:1._-';..'.;.',"j,'.:.:1;.
_"'f'",'!J,..-.:-.'tU"""_-: !_,"_"~;..
~~.'._' .',
vi ::~:::'::!:-:~a a!:c1 !1i~~-=on, des~i::~: a f2:~:!a:lf: d;..3~z.i..J.~1i.:Cg~ ~ :r:.1il l:':~"IG:::
.i,;;o::x!:m coc~ ml1 oi~ oo~e Zdill 0:::::3&'': ~1a iu~:te%' :?i:;n'i>:r~:l :::.:l~.~i~::'''::
~:ric=:1.
~:":aG~ 2 lcc~$ ~~:l _!l :li:a3~ 01 ~-i~~'t=a~. :if!.x:e !J::cr.;i\.::r..l~~~ :~.;:: :.j ::~.~:; . :: ... ~1;t:- :."!a'13 a scu:rce ~o%' mad.:l;; (!~p4lZ:!.SChlS :>:-l 1al:'.:1a~,~.~ ~OS:;G ~~ :J~.". : ,~;:'l ~:ei::: !k.~ 'Io:i:'!-; ~q'.%i..ale:!;;s. I
I
..1:"1<3 sran!J3 following S!:e~t ;: ill"Us~~.:!ta ~:d~3 :::'~2at.i~s:1:.'..::Jil 0;; ==::'~.;:. .l'-: ::.
,)1; il?prod.mate utatc.\uas at key points in ;'ou:t' m'2=~:H;1~~ r,::i!:a, 7'3.:;';:.-; J:...... ,
"'::3 nave 1'1o~tC3a to.18 of 325 r;:Qs~ ~c:s; hor.L~nl:8n1, ':'::ZlS 0:: ult~~ ;::..~:" talc. B3.~4 Oil the del1vexed costs of the <COt4bir.a:::Lons ~ wa ha"xa ,..l!:.-z..:.;;:; <:uvC!s through th. points whe:.:aratios of :r:~aula:' :mci <.:.1~-a ::::'.ll!i ;;i:;~.;;;; ::..:,;ult in e.aual delivered COll;:fl~ .All com-!)irultions to !:b.,;! h~-:i;. c,: :;:.:.,; ~u..:ve :r~uli in ).cue!: costa ~or '.the ~.nj -.lox'-, Produe:.::::.. :;.2.1 ol i::::'~~.;) ;:0 the right a::~ :Ln our "107:.
NAP 70126557 SERIES "0"
THAN 1485
St2~~CT: ~\1~C
::#:;~;1l .2
,
Sup?OGI! one of . thg St. Loui3 pai."'lt companies C~ttE!::'ltly conOUICes 100 ~O:n3 oZ i;j''i:~l $00 and 20 tons of ti:ttal l}OC y-au1y. .A lool-t at the comp~son of ~ combination ~#ltll ?'lbrana C-SOO - DIistrcn 139 (eu.....a A) sho-JS -..e hama a delivered p:ice advantage since th1s pt)in'i.: is to tb') 'lilg~~ of th~ tm..."""78
. ~\'!at_~d. f}t~t;l .Q,.-e_:{8!:ililfl~i1-z... any '!p~oi.D!s.:ton :::'~.~ll~_
~ 1.~:3::'.. ~37:.:1ze::!!d n~z':~ !.."r, 3kaZi:....2ro.Ji~gt3.
~:-..3 ~~':O";';' ~:':OZ::!i".o;:i,,;:n
t'::il~.-= '.''''~''"-.k.-.-:.o0Iw''0;:'._""':'I 6
THAN 1481
HAP 70128558
SERIES "0"
::"f:'J
~,))::!:i ~\1'o:1 '}.:1:,1 "'7'0:1 I~
':I;":m,l
.:!)i!!J I.!:'.1':"
'.~ ~~!tl:d.: !';;. i~~r
~':;.ll<ln! !~~!.~;~ 1\
',i tnbC_!l.! :~~ ~'. 1M,.:1.~
'ilt.1.:'.C
... ~It ~'.~~Jr.t:':1.,-::!.
. ,. ,l.iIl~I;1\
" <1 Orlcm.Ul ,,: :i"mwbO:::t~
-e" '
.'1 ;'; .: ,".", '.
';:-J n.fl
i/~. 7:;
(jt! .. r.~'J'
1/:. i'5 61-<.?-1) @.2lJ
"l~.~tl
'i1J.80 7/:. ~'5
:;".4.5 (.li.70
l:'f ~~~
11:. '15 m.l:.!..' 'fl 75
;:"} A
..~:\ :~
~~(-;, r:\:
H!'~, :(,'
~rj "t:..;~
,i,f){" .if~
7:;(:3 .;.~_~
~\.:.. (i()
~::, {rt ~~.' .Oi~
:"ort !.~s
'j.):!. '/n J.t.I, '!(} l03. J.O
~,Q!i. 1,{1
1<'0.1;5
,""::.\'!.
., ..
.,
. ." 1 , .
rl\ ;'~O
.. ,;:~.:<;: ,.~
r;::... i~"
l~i- ~......~,
":~ 'II',
~.'.ft (,~r
~!. /!n
u:" '....r.."..
~~!l.f}~;
.I':;). 'jCj
:.:',;L'in
~:~ .. ~.f)
:I.nt}. J.1)
95.!J5
.',' ..:. ~~~r,
:~ ( -;::;
/:i. J~~
~:7. 7::
'/"1. J:~
l7- . ?!..
f~.i.. 7:;
nJ.. 7.~;
n" ,....t
.1.....\
'!'1!. t.n
7?..,iO
11:. !;n
:~ 1... i'~,
7El. 5~i
r.n.n
~M:J.A,;rOll :FOJ,\~(:n'.~ :~o:o:n1.'l P.-.::J.c..:ll: :'':':')-
i?J.~n
'1:-0/6
".
.,. .: 0' f)
~ '"
;:'(' .. ~~!:
....!~:.~ ,P~l
(
';11,.: .: ~ (t " i:~~"!"
....,.. /: r.:
'-.' 'J
.':; ..~: ~
Ji' !;.:
r.n .f!:;;
; .. 1, ...
""? .l}..
~'1.f)5
'.. ~ ~I ~
t;;j .O~J
f1}. 'm
"t (~. ~j!;
.;:;n.~:
nf;. Gf)
1'.,., ,., t ~..
,. ! .f! r:'
r.~..:1. ?O
'~}:i. (tH
~\~. 7".)
m.,'lO
!.:Jt ./:.5
UI).(10
'...'?:.. /5
t:,".,.,.J.O..,dH
~"'~':~:'(~j"~OO';;on- -~-
~,)"I.."
'lr'" .
t~f;, !;r,
:~'H~"
~;:~: ;
.......... :.~ :I."i' .. :
'.::f~~ ~:...,... :. '.
I.i.
1.1C'.": .. 1t:r'1.. ,
:J (j .l~~!
m~1.~.'6.
'>7 J)l; 'ltt~ . I~t :1.nZ.1l1
";":;. (~(!
~~(, .l~~'}
<)7.01.1
1.00.05 11.7.70 Hl.70 103.'-0
105. J.n 100.85
~1::l .. :~5 t:)(j.Z5
G9.1O
~.r,. 25
:m8:~.
{;9.70
!,Qi. ~o
J.lH.30
~6.25
~l. 95
B7.20
(.6.50
~(i.1.S
91.95 96.25
.~ I :~
(I,)
~,
In:
a;:l ......
:: ~'" ..
~g
('1- . oJ [ \ ,I
~r!. ' CJl, ,"
00, ':
on. ii
90 . .-;,.
97. r:
~M.~:
97, 7~'
-- --.
- - - - --~--
Asbc.:H;:b.1t'! ]!'OD p't\c:,::,n:.iJJ!.~. l~. y.. rr.:f.cefl!/~J.!.i
~:'6?'~;
r"oniI(!nl)r.t:cll.~
1:::7.:'.:'.:(0';;1'1.1'. p.:c:t.cp.~ ~i7
$CO 00 {:CJll ll!;, flO (b~.nad on uuoff:1cla). :f.:.lformaUoIl)
:~!~5 "en t01.~
1'1yenJ, 40~ :~('n (~()'!1.'.:0~:t',n\t;:. ~l. y.. 1:!lC)
$35,00 I;Qn
M:tci:ol::al'~ ~:fH~~;~"n.H H<.1::1:tl.t.:tr., !~I)nf.:. .1005
W~,.t) St;'~ 1(!<!
..II
II foll!J9!~
Q~il. ,Ilf) tm~
$70.(10 r;on
NAP 70128559 SERIE$ "D"
"
" ~.':~H:"
"I:'.:~~"i!"~' "''I', )
. ~;' ... .',~:~!),
".~:, nt."~~,~.Jl; It'.
, ,.'; ti:O;r.1:
11.;':,'.' "{or.f:. ;::: !'tnbr,Ci',b
;.'1nst~t' I::~ ~.;'''
!ttnne"p! : ':,n
.;'!'1't'; C:C-~f~", 'i.~n
;:r.. .. J..c1'!~.r.
h ":'\j~;,;'i1': ::!'!l~;' ,.",.'~',:lJ.
(~:i... 'i';: 61..75
!i~{. O!5
(,''J. -It:oJ
M. 75 c:.t6.30 '}J 15
;;'io.20 :.;'i ,/!-!i
51."~5 ~~7 ./ol-5
t.,Co. ".:'.
J
.,''~
() '.~, ~f
(iO.W: '.;~!-. i . :
{i:;.15
fiIl,l)fl
~:l. I!;
~}J .;;:0
:1:) ./!.5 !il) .l~!;
59.1:.!.;
" I :"
,',;':":1,';','
'.,-,'.,'j." 1,1
,'r: 7')
/:l,.!\'..:
'tJ!'"
\
"'
,' .'1
i'/!.l;'
'p; .r!r~
'If:,. '1~;
~!,~.::.O
70./:5 'if!, /1:'; :0 ,1~5
rli .. ~HI :!(a ."1\
:!"t .I.n
~H,;.nr. ~',(,.~n t)J."O~
M.OO
n).r~'3
0:"10 Ill. ,'0 fl). 10
i: ':1:
','
"
,..'!.;
;',
. .::; .......~ .
:..:'. Hi ~j:} ./.!;
11J~~i. J.ti' i~f') ..... 1.
I' '.. ,~ t
..... ,
',I
1~9 /~.:'~ .,....,.'1. n,_t..'
!~,D . riO
!i!). Ill'
'}~~. tt'.'
t'(~. i.'~,:r
'n, if!)
fXi.(;O
')i OIl
~;n .to
.'if:. (t~;
!;H. !~ Fj? ;"!~;
HI::', m
!.(H. {;~i
105. J.O
~ !}fl.::l,r.
.,~ ;- . .in
.' '1 , I.~.':
'Jr~. !.n 'll!/.},
t':? ('~'"
t':') /:ff
'if) r:~~}
.':fI. (jn 50.flO
'V:.,(i,')
n,lJ.1}
J7. Oil
~n.(iO
!Jl.OO
~;r.;. LO
~:l:... (\.r;
:;(;.10
-; :.; .. ~~ ~
~)3.10
9G.~,5
100.10
1}~U1!i
Wj.ll,r
,iJtO .t~!i
.c..~~ (~~
~': I:.(\ ~7.0n
95,60 ('O.O!)
J,03.W 1.0;.. (i5 ltl:';.W lOH . flJ.
.....S
! , ; , ..
I
!jLW 1.8 .I~a;
l~7. G5
4l~.r)(}
M.110 43.60 45.00
51.10
49.6.5 53.10
48.85
W 70128560 SERIES 'D"
: I
--"~''--r--~---l--~---'~--f-!-:~I----~- "'f ~
. . I :;j ;j .1. ; I'
114AH 1489
.,~"::.-.: .,'_!" - .,
o
THAN 1481
r
"
THAN 1411
. ..... -,:. ...
.,
-...
.w---
.-....
~.---.
.
.
.-...--~---,:-:
-
T.,.::~'.-.
.
~
-.-.
;
THAN 1482
NAP 70128564
SERIES "n"