Document DMq0RKKkjLEVRg21pKNbvkV6a
federal public service
HEALTH, FOOD CHAIN SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENT
Ad-Hoc BCR on the Universal PFAS restriction proposal
federal public service
HEALTH, FOOD CHAIN SAFETY AND ENVIRONMENT
UPFAS restriction under REACH
History of PFAS policy actions
2006: EU restriction of PFOS (under Dangerous Substance Directive)
2009: PFOS added to the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POP regulation in EU)
2011: PFOA and APFO identified as SVHC + CLP classification
2012: ICCM3 identifies PFAS as emerging policy issue
2016: PFNA identified as Substance of Very High Concern (SVHC) + CLP
2017: PFOA added to the REACH restriction list (Annex XVII) 2017: PFDA identified SVHC + CLP 2019: HFPO-DA (Gen-X) identified SVHC 2020: PFOA added to Stockholm Convention
Well know PFAS get regulated lesser known related PFAS replace them! = regrettable substitution
2020: PFBS identified as SVHC
2021: C9-C14 added to the REACH restriction list (enters into force in 2023)
2023: PFHxS and related substances will be added to the Stockholm Convention
3
Need for faster action using grouping approach: Universal PFAS Restriction preparation
5 MS (Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Denmark and Sweden) started working on proposal in 2020
Stakeholder consultations and workshops organized in 2020 and 2021 Originally planned to be submitted to ECHA in July 2022
Due to large amount of work it was delayed until 13th of January 2023 Dossier has been made available on ECHA site 07/02/2023
DE and NL held a press conference 07/02 to give first insights: https://echa.europa.eu/-/echa-publishes-pfas-restriction-proposal
Public Consultation of the dossier started March 22nd
REACH restriction process
Limit or ban the manufacture, placing on the market (including imports) or use of a substance
A restriction may apply to any substance on its own, in a mixture or in an article, including those that do not require registration
Restriction dossier should include hazard, risk and socio-economic analysis (including alternative assessment)
EU-wide unacceptable risk has to be proven
See ECHA site: https://echa.europa.eu/restriction-process
PFAS: Main concern identified
"... the very high persistence, exceeding the criterion for very persistent (vP) according to Annex XIII of the REACH Regulation by far.
"supporting concerns are their bioaccumulation, mobility, long range transport potential (LRTP), accumulation in plants, global warming potential and (eco)toxicological effects."
"With the constantly increasing concentrations of PFASs in the environment due to their persistence and ongoing emissions, the exposure of humans and the environment to these substances will inevitably lead to negative effects"
"exposure to PFASs has a high potential for intergenerational effects"
Restriction Scope - PFAS Substances
OECD definition roughly 10 000 substances With some specific exemptions
According to DS not as persistent as "standard" PFASs See also Annex B section 4.1.4 for more detailed explanation
Restriction Scope: all possible uses
"manufacture, placing on the market, as well as the use of PFASs as such and as constituents in other substances, in mixtures and in articles above a certain concentration."
"All uses of PFASs are covered by this restriction proposal, regardless of whether they have been specifically assessed by the Dossier Submitters and/or are mentioned in this report or not, unless a specific derogation has been formulated."
"Grouping approach has been chosen to prevent regrettable substitution in the future"
Meaning: every presence of PFAS (above certain threshold) planned to be banned in the EU
Including import Including not yet developed PFAS or uses
Proposed concentration thresholds
After entry into force concentrations of PFAS in mixtures and articles will not exceed: 25 ppb for any PFAS measured with targeted PFAS analysis (excluding polymeric PFAS from quantification) 250 ppb for the sum of PFAS measured with targeted analysis (optional with prior degradation of precursors) (polymeric PFAS excluded from quantification) 50 ppm for PFAS (including polymeric PFAS)
If total fluorine exceeds 50 mg/kg F proof on whether fluorine measured as content of either PFAS or non-PFAS
Relationship between F and PFAS content depends on percentage of F in molecular structure
Proposed (temporary) exemptions
30+ specific exemptions Including some exemptions that will only be retained if sufficient justification is provided Exemptions include:
Personal protection equipment (PPE) textiles Certain fluorinated gasses used in heating and refrigerants Uses in automotive and electronics Medical uses Some exemptions are "unlimited" To avoid double regulation (Biocidal products, Plant Protection Products and Medical
Devices) however reporting requirements are included National safety standards for buildings (not applicable for BE) Use in analytics (internal standards)
Transition periods proposed under RO2
*
'
"
u z
- -- z
> `
w
"
Q z
>z
z
<
Reporting requirements and site management plans
For most derogated uses manufacturers, importers and formulators have to report the following information: Specifying under which derogation they fall Identify and quantity of the substance placed on the market
For derogated fluoropolymers and perfluoropolyethers site specific management plans, including: Information on the identity of the substances and the products they are used in A justification for the use Details on the conditions of use and safe disposal.
Restriction Proposal
Proposal as drafted by the DS
Same proposal into overview table
Further planning - Restriction process
22/03: Start Public Consultation In Parallel RAC and SEAC will start drafting Opinion 05/04: ECHA info webinar
22/09: End of Public Consultation RAC opinion will be finalized
2024: Draft SEAC Opinion consultation of 60 days
2024 - 2025: Final Opinions and Annex XV adopted
2025 - 2026: COM development of restriction proposal and REACH Cee (Member States) vote
2026-2027: Entry into force +/- 2030: first transition period ends +/- 2045: last transition period ends
Input in the restriction process - Public Consultation
Public Consultation is the best way to give input into the process Please provide data if:
Specific uses need to be derogated Identified derogations are not justified Alternative assessment is incomplete for specific uses
Any other comments are welcome important to substantiate them with data!
Check Info note for more detailed requests for data: https://echa.europa.eu/documents/10162/cad38c27-
ede8-2268-00c6-939ea066743c
Any data submitted after the consultation period cannot be taken into account by the RAC! Second Public Consultation on SEAC draft opinion: possible to provide input on the SEA analysis, however very
short timeline (60 days)!
Will be planned for 2024/2025
UPFAS Public Consultation - Info needs?
Information on PFAS tonnages and the fate of PFASs during the full lifecycle, especially the waste stage, is needed to allow for a better closed mass balance.
Waste stage emissions for fluorinated gas are unknown and therefore not taken into account
New data on monitoring and exposure
Link between emission source and exposure
Potential derogations justification
Studies/reports that justify that these potential derogations are (not) needed
Check whether the proposed derogations are justified and what their impacts can be
Please make sure to inform your stakeholders of this restriction and the potential impact it may have on their sector!
Documentation
Documents can be found on the ECHA page: https://echa.europa.eu/registry-ofrestriction-intentions/-/dislist/details/0b0236e18663449b
Annex XV report: this is the base dossier in which you can find a summary, the proposal and general info on the evaluation done by the dossier submitter
Annex A: Manufacture and Use of PFAS Annex B: Information on Hazards and Risks of PFAS Annex C: Justification for action on Union-wide basis - this is an empty document referring to Section 1.2.
of the base Annex XV report Annex D: Baseline - also an empty document referring to Section 1.3. of the Annex XV report Annex E: Impact Assessment Annex F: Assumptions, uncertainties and sensitivities Annex G: Stakeholder information
Appendix G1: call for evidence on restriction options Appendix G2: second call for evidence on restriction options Appendix E4: available analytical methods
Other interesting info
Annex XV report Overall Summary and Conclusion Alternative assessment: Table 8 and 9 Enforceability: section 2.5.
Available analytical methods: Appendix E.4 Uncertainty analysis: Annex F
Table F.3 alternative assessment
ECHA webinar: https://echa.europa.eu/-/restriction-of-per-andpolyfluoroalkyl-substances-pfass-under-reach