Document DM51naayL9dqvwqGG7YEp9BqM
|
|
En
unoaome UUNNIIVVEERRSSIITTYY
TVVlN CITIES
OOFF
MMIINNNNEESSOOTTAA
OtSaaDvnnieivddihisOioaocnnocouoifpf oaCEEecupattnofnnia!oivFnriraaHuolnnaebmHmsoatieenatentlthathall
:
B43MSBoi25con0x0hxno1GD1auo99eatl77lpaoaMofwMwaiaPaaysruryoaebo,MliSSicntrrHaeeesetatoltSSths.EE$. 5455
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455
AAppririll 66,, 11998899
SLLtaaarrfrryfy pRR.h. ysZZioocbbieealln,, MM..DD.. S3M3MeMtdaiCCfcefeannltPteehrDryespiacriatnaent M2S2t02e.0-d-2i2Pc6Eaa-ul-00l2,2DeMp0artm55e1n4t 4-1000
St. Paul, F~ 55144-1000
DDeeaarr LLaarrrryy;;
wEEinntcchlloossteehdde Mpplileenaansseeesotffiainnddpoptthhueelatttaiaobbnlle.ess cAcsoonntItaamiinneininntggiontthehede orrenessutulhltetss toeoflfeptthhheeonecc,oommptpaharerisisseoonnmust
MwbbieeinthniinenstttehoeertrpaprrMeerittaneetnddeessccoaaptaurutitiopioorouupstsulolylya1tbb9io5ee9ncc.aa. uusseeADesaootfIfhsmtthheeeanmtouuionnnngcceeedrtrthtaeoaininnstttthyyuedyrreetegcgloaaehrrpoddhriinotngngeoctt,hcheeuthrerseed
must
in
M4411innsstetaasttoeetass;; ratthhteeesrreefpfoorrrioee,r, ttthohee 1UU9.5.SS9... rraDatteeeassthsmmaayyambboeengmmotohrreee asaptpuppdrryoopprcrioiaahttoeer..t occurred in
AApssreyyvooiuuouswwlilyilll whsseieeechffrruoosmmedtthhteehettaUa.bbSlle.ess,,rattthehese. rreesTsuhuellttssonlaayrreecossniim smiiisllataerrntttoofitthnhodosiseneg ppbrreeetssweeennettneedd" tpithhnreeietvittiwaowloousCcrlyooempmwopprahatrir.ciihssoonnFussosrediisscathnffeocoerrrUpp.Srorfoo. ssttrtaahatetteiiccsdi. cgcaeanTsncthceeiervreowwnhohlyiriccghhacnoswwneesainaasdddteddrpnreeetssrssifieetnddodnieiinnungnootubuhreretwreeen wwtinahasesitaieaanltssittraraeettiipscsototirhictoc.araltl~.lFyyorHssoicigwgaennnvicieffeirirc,caaonntfthtithseeexxwcceaedsssigssneo((sStStMiMvRfRe=o=1u17no76dr6,g,aan9m95s5o%n%gaCnC.dt.LhL.ep.==e1CrI.ii.t00oi99nn,i,ecua22mi..6699Dth)i)evirffeosoirron ewethammespplloeeoylyneeeteveisrase.t. edcFFousuhrurotgthrhgteee.rrsmntoiHornroegew,,etvhnneoaort', ssittinhnhggiisslleewwassasisitteenprowwotibitaftohhbuilinnnydtdthhuaeeemoggfnogaassctththrreaooniicnnCettl.eeinsstitciAinnalaasllol Dwttirorvaraistcchitton wcnnhoaoesttmiininegcglaelviisas teettxhdhpeeossfufuaagrccgettes.sttthhinaagtt ttthhheaesstee thaarirsee nwnoaotst pssiritoteebssabttlyyyppidiccuaealllltyoy acahsssasonocccieiaa. tteeddAlswwoiitthhworth
chemical exposures.
1Iff yyoouu hhaavvee aannyy qquueessttiioonnss pplleeaassee ffeeeell ffrreeee ttoo ccaallll mmee aatt 662266--44881100..
~ Yogss~sincerely, sI ncerely,
J~SSoc_Si.a.teMMaanPndrdeoelfl,e, ssPPohhr..DD..
,~,~sociate Professor
Hea sciences HEALTH SCIENCES
`MMSauabddjeeecAAtvvtaaoiillPaarbbollteeebbcyiyv33eMMOrffodorrerIInnIssnppPeeccattliioomnneaavrnn.dd3CCMo,oppNyyoii.nnggC2aa.ss0CC4o-on6nf3ifid0de9enntitiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:
Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309
11335577..00000011
Exhibit 1357
State of Minnesota v. 3M Co., Court File No. 27-CV-10-28862
33MMAA0000663322331133
28g
.
TTAADDLLEE 55..
95 PERCENT CONFIDENCE OOBBSSEERRVVEEDD AANNDD EEXXPPEECCTTEEDD
95 PERCENT CONFIDENCE
LIMITS DDEEAATTHHSS
LIMITS
AND CHI SQUARE VALUES, BBYY CCAAUUSSEE,, SSTTAANNDDAARRDDIIZZEEDD
AND CHI SQUARE VALUES,
WALES. CHEMICAL MMOORRTTAALLIITTYY RRAATTIIOO
MALES, CHEMICAL
DIVISION ((SSMHRR)),,
DIVISION
(COMPARED TO MINNESOTA DEATH RATES)
i
EomT
suk ran mses OALL CAUSES OF DEATII
JAIL I~LECI|AIIT HEOPLASHS 2ALL IHFETIVE MID PARASITIC DISEASE
9ALL ~ERCULOS[S
160EM[ER OF B~CAL CAVITY AIID PIIARYI~
GE
I~gCAI~ER OF DIGESTIVE ORGANS ArID PERXTOIIEIJI! ]50CM~ER OF ESOPIIA~ ( 1925-APPRO~]HATE ) ]5]CMRER OF ST~-I~CII
(1925-APPROXII.IATEI
Eu corsa tmnt a cn sss
170CAI~ER OF BOI|E (1925-p1930,19~5-APPROXZHATE)
172CAI~ER OF SKIt!
!_6~ER OF PROSTATE 186CAI~ER OF TESTIS (OTIIER GEI|ITAL ORGAI|S-1925-~9) (1925-~]9~O_APPRO~[tlA ]08CAI~ER OF BLADDER |192~-APPROXZ|~TE)
]89CAt~ER OF K/DNEY ! 1925-APPROXEHATE)
190At~ER OF EYE
11950-1969 ONLY)
19IM~ER OF BRAZt] AfJD OTIIER CEHTRAL fiERV~S SYSTEH 11925-APP~OXELIATE )
~ 19ICkiER OF TilYROID 11950-1969 OHLY)
~ ZOOLYIIPIIOSARC~A MID RETZCULOSARCOHA o
11950-1969 OtlLY]
~ ZO|IIODGKIII'S DISEASE (19~O-~19~5-APPRO~II.|ATE)
o.1
seco voceres as OBSEItVED EXPECTED OBS/EXP
LL
BCowns nne ew 100 23 0
69.79 16.39
0,68
1.11 1.~o 0.00
0.91 0.89 0.00
o
O.ZO
o.oo
o.oo
o
o.oo
o.oo
tJL 1.35 Z.ll 5.41 18.~8 7.05
CIIISq 1.05 Z.27 o.os 0.46 o.oo
1
0.~0
o
0.71
3
1.~0
0
0.45
0
0.27
Z
0.88
5
Cem 1
0.19
0
0.12
1
0.40
1.42
O.~Z
~.o9
o.~8
A Z.49
o.oo 2.1~
0.03 o.oo 0.~3
13.83 5.16 6.25
O.oZ
0.06
0.86
0.00
0.00
8,23
0.01
0,00
0,00
13.68
0.20
Z.20
O.g6
8.Z3
0,~4
1.07
en5.16
0,91 O.O0
0.3~
em0.07
0.24 0.00
2.50
am28.7~ Z,3Z 29.60
0.01
em0.48
0.00
1.14
Z.~9
0.03
13.8~
0.02
.7~80
2.10
1.9,~
17,39
1
0.~8
Z.61
0.03
14.55
0.04
o
O,26
0.00
0,00
14.08
0.22
0
0.~
0.00
0.00
6.91
0.00
0
0.02
0.00
O.OO
181.~6
11.39
1
0.87
1.15
O,OZ
6.42
0.15
0
0.0~
0,00
0.00
93.44
5.41
0
0.SZ
0.00
0.00
7.0~
0.00
0
0.~5
0.00
0.00
6.62
0.01
1357.0002
ioo 20~LEI~EIIIA AIID ALEUKEIIIA
| BOTTIen 208CMICER OF OTIIER LYllPI|ATIC TISSUE (]950-1969 OHLY) Z09ALL LYIIPIIOPOZETIC CAtlCER ZIOBEIIIG#I HEOPLASIIS IP[US ~SPECIFZED) ZqOALLERGIC ~EtiD~RItlE ~tlE~ABOLIC ~t~TRITIOtlAL DISEASES ( 1950-1969 OrlI.Y )
250DI~BETES HELLITUS
3 HBOALL DISEASESOF BLOOD MI BLOOO-FONIING 280ALL DISEASES OF BLOOD AIID BLOOD-FORItIIIG ORGAI]S (IgZS-~lg]O_APPROXIIIAT OAGNIS(1925, 1750-AreacKUT ]IgI~I~AL~PSYCII~IEUROTIC~ AIID PERSOHALITY DISORDERS (1950-1969 OrlLY)
ml ]20ALL DISEASES OF /IERVOUS 5YSTEII AHD SEIlSE ORGANS
]90ALL DISEASES OF CIRCULATORY SYSTEH
Barer ]9]CIIR~IIC RIIE~IATIC IIEART DISEASE (1925-APPROX[HATE)
~IO~RTERIOSCLEROTIC IIEART DISEASE~ IHCLUD]I~ CIID (]92~-APPRO~IIIA/E)
Ei ~5OALL VASCULAR LESIOIIS OF CNS
~60ALL RESPIRATORY DISEASES {1925-=19]O_APPROXIHATE)
} ~80ALL PIIE~I~IIA I 1925-tlg]O-APPROXIffATE ) ~gZEItPIIYSEIIA ( 1950-~ 1955 APPROXItIATE )
qg~ASTIIItA I ] 925- s 19]O-APPROXIHATE I 5ZOALL DISEASES OF DIGESTIVE SYSTEIf ~I]ALL GASTRIC ArID D~DEIIAL ULCER 5~]CIRRII~IS OF LIVER 580ALL DISEASES OF GEtiITO-URINARY SYSTEtl -682cIIgOtllC IIEPIIRITIS
709ALL DISEASES OF TIlE SKIP( MID CELLULAR TISSUE
739ALL DISEASES OF TIlE BOllES AND ORGAt|S OF tlOVEIIENT
"799SYIIPTOIIS,SEIlILITY~AI|D ILL DEFII|ED COHDITIOIIS DOOALL EXI"ERllAL CAUSES OF DEATII
7 801ALL ACCIDEIlTS 8]OI~OR VEIIICLE ACCIDEtlTS )>.~'~959SUICIDE 0 0
TOTAL RESIDUAL
Commo 0
2.63
0.00
0.00
1.40
1.7~>
1.42
2.11
6.15
0.81
pomommn 6.69
O. 90
0.33
1.95
0.01
om 0.~9
0.00
0.00
7.50
0.00
4.74
0.8~
0.23
2.16
0.01
3.71
1+ om
1
1.86
lOre
momo 3
o~
nm 7
3.21 96.73
2,89 72.88 10.58
0.81
28 Z.Z8
0.SqO. 9~ 1.08 1. o~. 1.15 0.66
0.16
0L.E0T3
0.01
om0.19
0.88
O.Z1
0.92
0.26
2.36 ]2.68
3.00 Z.73 1.30 3,03 1.43 1.36
0.01
eton 0.01
O.07 0.03 OJ',7 0,05 1.55
0.90
7
8.68
0.81
ramon 3.09
0,97
1
0
1
O.q3
2.34
12
11.45
1.05
z
1,12
1.78
3
6,88
o
2.16
0.00
o
0.91
D.OO
o
0.1~
0.00
1
0.52
0.32
1.66
nom 0.~0
0.01 0.03
Z.8~
Z.86
13.02
0 0.20
1.83
0.09 0.00 0.00
1.27 1.70 ~.0~
0.00
0.03
10.78
0.16 0.05 O. 10 O,Ol 0.00 0,13 1.66 1.27 0.18 0.92 0.00
1
1.66
0.60
o.o1
0.01
~2.17
0.88
0.65
venom 3~,27
27
21,~2
9
10,86
0.89 1.26 0.83
0.62
0.83
0.38
1
-6~,D8
-O.OZ
1.18
om1.2~
1.83
1.57
0,6Z 0.37 1.20 0.17
ron (.~ 1357.0003
HT in C.4tlCER RE~ZDUAL
7i[4
2%
4
i
bi
i
:
g
11335577..00000048