Document DGnZjGBrYQ77x87woZ3eYYL6o

juenos Aires, November 13th, 1936, ftLJL-. Ar. Aehoe, unirei'sity of Qinpinatti, Kettering Laboratory, School of Physiol<j>gy, OITCII-IATTI, Gaib. ; /i 'A, Dear Dr. ^.ehoe, VJ I Your letter of September 28 just recently arrived at it '.vas carried b y ]steamer rather than air nail due to insufficient postage. I realize now that 4y letter of September 16 was not in sufficient detail to allow you to make propel* decision on this natter and shall therefore set down the complete story. j j ' I LIr. Hunpstone ( President .Vest India Gil Co. ) expressed considerable conce rn and was worried because a doctor from what corresponds to Aorkman' s Union ea amined the men at the San Antonio plant and claimed that at least one definitely had lead poisoning and others showed signs of lead intoxication. Fortunately none these men 'mere blenders. The West India Company doctor claimed the men did not ha ve lead poisoning but his word did not carry much weight and a complete delegatic n of doctors, Health officials etc. from the union were going to make a thorough in spection of the whole plant. I understand that the' inspection has since been nad e but a report has not been rendered. Hr. Hunpstone believes that the inspector may be sincere but doubts it because the .Vest India has it's own safety system and medical facilities and does not belong to the union to which the examining doctjor is connected. He thinks this may be a move to attempt to force the company to' joijn. this organization ana that the idea may have blossomed from a widespread whispering campaign that Esso gasoline is poisonous. j On another occasion the Superintendent of the plant who had assisted in some of the early reckless blends started to lose his teeth and claimed that he hab lead poisoning - the company doctor in this case could not affirm or deny this and it was necessary to call in a consulting doctor from the Telephone Company,iwho found legitimate reasons for the loss of teeth and no evi dence of lead poisbning and he was able to convince the man that he did net have lead poisoning. The ft.ct that the Company doctor was unable to back up his contention that the men at the plant do not have lead poisoning is in itself not necessarily a sign of weakness on the part of the doctor as considerations other than medical were undoubtedly involved especially if Hr. Humpstone's idea on the subject is correct Hoxvever, in the case of the plant Superintendent a weakness seems indicated, unless of course the fact that the second doctor was an outsider was the deciding point with the man being examined. Also the second doctor was cor roborating the Company's doctor's opinion. In any event the above would suggest that ability to defend his contentions and inspire confidence is not one of the Company doctor's main points. Thi 3 has also been checked by verbal opj nions. Itwas because I considered this point to be very important from Ethyl Export standpoint, that I made the ori ginal recommendation that a doctor possessing this ability (together with the ott ers I learnt from you), be appointed by Ethyl Export to supplement the Company doctor s examinations and be consultant in cases similar to the above where men working n the blending plant are involved. Tor the work at San Antonio assuming no complic ations the Company doctor is perhaps quite satisfactory, but he ./ , is the only' dical representation Ethyl Export has in the whole of Ghile ' where motor boline is being marketed and it seems to me that a more capable tan ''is required preferably one not working for Y/est India also. If The extent of my investigation in Santiago was to ask for re commendations/from Dr. Armado Tarragiuibel, who is head of the Iledical School of University of Chile and who has reputation of being the best and most well informed dootor. in Chile. He recommended a Dr. Cruz Coke, who has a very excel lent reputation and is professor of Physiology Chemistry at the University of SC' hile. I inade no commitments and confined my statements that usually the Ethyl Corporation designed a consultant to work under your supervision to examine men for control 'purposes periodically. In Argentina there Is a somewhat similar problem, only of course motor gasoline is not being sold at present. The two present aviation plants TPE and Standard have their own doctors. Shell Mex is just completing an aviation plant but does not maintain a medical staff so that it will be necessary to appoint "a doctor. Assuming lead will eventually be allowed for motor gasoline, first class'medical representation will probably be desired. There is no great hurry in this matter as Shell estimate one blend will be nine months supply. They have just ordered the fluid ( one 10 gallon drum ) and I can make the first blend for them if medical arrangements have not been previously made. I shall be glad to be of any service if you will advise what you care me to do in this matter and if you wish further information regarding the Santiago situation. - During my visit with Yiest India Santiago sl young medical student happened in and requested published information in Spanish and Trench on lead poisoning is writing a thesis on this general subject and has done some re- search. His results on gasoline lead poisoning he says indicate that motor gasol- ine is alright due to its low lead content, but aviation is slightly harmful to the:average Chilian. His point being that the average Chilian not being I O O 5 C physically shows signs of lead poisoning at a lower level of intake than other average healthy people. . I have received and wish to thank you for the copy of lead studies you recently snt me also the papers in German and Spanish you sent sometime ago. .... -V:. , w; Ke .0010540