Document DGavydEJ6ZX19oLXJkZNgVLNn

T (DraTt) / ` A /- AS33ST0S TEXTftLE INSTITUTE Minutes - GENERAL MEETINGV^Beifruary I)., 1971 The RED CARPET INN, Charlotte, N.C. In attendance: 1* AMERICA!? ASBESTOS TEXTILE CORP. JTvTI Chris tenbury" Wm. Maaskant H.H. Walter , ASBESTOS CORPORATION L1HITKTT G.P.A. Brink P.E. Leclerc GARLOCK INC. A. Kuzmuk W.F. Brainerd BELL ASBESTOS HINES LIMITED Wei. J. W. Smith "" Walter II. Smith JOINTS -MANY ILLE CORPORATION N.D. BROWN E.A. SCHUMAN K.A. Roberts C.L. Sheckler ' H.K. PORTER COMPANY,INC. L. E. Moody D.E. Childers J.W. Echerd E.C. Bratt J.D. McCluer (Ret'd) Nicole t INDUSTRIES , INC. Geo. Griswold, Jr. / E.W. Russell f rayb:ESTOS-MANHATTAN,INC. C.E. Sti iefken f .Turner-.bros.asbestos ' W.M. Deokman ^--.. H.J. Corson /* ..--- .. - . co..Ltd. ' ' ^ \` ,, \' .\ UNIROYAL, INC. ,'E.A. norris R.C. Hunt H.H. Willingham Dr.J.H. Wolfsie S.J. Peels, Jr. ' T.H, Newby L.F. Dieringer (Guest) !I ; : CADWALADSR , WICKERSIiAM H TAFT J.W. Hawkins . Dr.J.L. Goodman" J.W. Frampton (Guest) ASBESTOS TEXTILE INSTITUTE H.E.Sunbury (Secretary) Si Minutes SrvHH?-* Vs } > L. President ''Moody, .-called the meeting to order at 1 :L)_5 P.I1. 2. Those present were asked to stand and identify themselves and to give theircompany affiliation. 3. President Moody asked that a moment of prayer be observed in memory of Ralph B. Smith who passed away on January 21,1971 at his home in North Charleston,S.C, Mr. Smith had attended A.T.I. meetings for about twenty years, and served as Chairman of our Air Hygiene & Mfg. Committee during I960 and 1961. 1|. The minutes of the last meeting were presented for reading. On motion by Mr.B.A. Schuman,seconded by Hr. K.A. Roberts, it was voted to omit the reading of same. ' (Draft) / ASBESTOS TEXTILE INSTITUTE Ai- Minutes - GENERAL MEETING - February 1+, 1971 The RED CARPET INN, Charlotte, N.C. In attendance: AMERICAN ASBESTOS TEXTILE CORP. J.W. Christenbury Wm. Maaskant H.H. Walter ASBESTOS CORPORATION LIMITED G.F.A. Brink P.E. Leclerc GARLOCK INC. A. Kuzmuk W.F. Brainerd ' JOHNS-MANYILL2 COR FORATION N.D. BROWN E.A. SCHUMAN K.A. Roberts C.L. Sheckler ' H.K. PORTER COMPANY,INC L Moody D.E. Childers J.W. Echerd E.C. Bratt J.D. McCluer (Ret'd) Nicolet INDUSTRIES,INC. Geo. Griswold,Jr. / E.W. Russell ; , BELL ASBESTOS MINES LIMITED Wm.J.W. Smith Walter H. Smith * I1 LAKE ASBESTOS OF QUEBEC,LTD. C.E. Stiefken >t .TURNER'BROS.ASBESTOS CO.,Ltd. W.M. Deokman _ H.J. Corson ' UN I ROYAL, INC.- ' ;E.A. norris ' R.C. Hunt ' ' H.H. Willingham Dr.J.Ii. Wolfsie S.J. Peele,Jr. T.H, Newby ' L.F. Dieringer (Guest) rayb:3ST0S -MAINE ATTAN , INC M.<i. Scowcroft ' J.W. Hawkins Dr. J .L. Goodman^ J.W. Frampton (Guest) CADWALAD5R , WICKERSKAM h TAFT II, C, Roosevelt (Legal Counsel ASBESTOS TEXTILE INSTITUTE II.E.Sunbury (Secretary) !i /SKHHHC- Minutes ttiKrK-* \\ // L. President''Moody.-called the meeting to order at l:Lt-5 P.M* 2. Those present were asked to stand and identify themselves and to give their company affiliation. 3. President Moody asked that a moment of prayer be observed in memory of Ralph 5. Smith who passed away on January 21,1971 at his home in North Charleston,S.C, Kr. Smith had attended A.T.I. meetings for about twenty years, and served as Chairman of our Air Hygiene 6: Mfg. Committee during I960 and 1961. I4.. The minutes of the last meeting were presented for reading. On motion by Mr.E.A. Schuman,seconded by Hr. K.A. Roberts, it was voted to omit the reading of same. Kinutes - GENERAL MEETING continued.: Nags -2- 5. Treasurer Kuzrauk presented the Financial Report. Dr. J.II. Wolf3ie moved that it be accepted, motion seconded by Hr. P.S. Leclerc, and so voted unanimously. A copy of the report is attached to these minutes. s 6* President Moody referred to "The History of the Asbestos Textile Industry in the United States1' by J.A. Bettes,Jr., now appearing in installments in tho ASBESTOS Magazine, and said that the Secretary had been instructed to write Mr. Bettes a letter of commendation on behalf of the Institute and its members. Hr. Bettes, an active member of the Institute for approximately twenty-four years, served as president of ATI in -1937 and 1958* Upon retirement from Raybestos- Hanhattan several years ago Mr. 3ottes began to collect the infor- . mation for his "History of the ..Asbestos Textile Industry in the USA" and it has required countless hours and voluminous correspondence to prepare the "History" for publication. The Institute appreciates the fine contribution that Hr. Bettes has made'to the asbestos - textile industry, and congratulates him on doing an exceptionally fine job! AI30, we think that the ASBESTOSiHa'gazine is to be commended for making the "History" available to'its readers! Mr. Bettes address is:- John A. Bettes,Jr.,3100 South Ocean Blvd.,#6l8 ?xx Delray Beach,Fla. 33UUl- and we'are sure that he would welcome comments from readers of the "History".; / y / ' 7. President Moody announced the election of Mr. K.D. Brown to' the Board of Governors, replacing -Hr.- ,A. Sc hum an as John3-Manville1 s representative; and the election to the Board of Hr. J.W. Christenbury replacing Mr. J.L. Rainey.as"the representative for American Asbestos Textile Corporation. Mr. Schuman resigned because he no longer has responsibility for asbestos textilesMr. Rainey's resignation was necessary due to increased corporate responsibilities since hix he was elected President of his company in June of 1970. V \ / *' 8. The Legal Counsel Report-wa3 given by Attorney II. C. Roosevelt, of Cadwalader, ,.VTiekersham <k Taft, New York,N.Y. A resume' of his remarks is attached to.these minutes. Ii )' ' 9. The Fibre. Producerja Report was given by Mr. Wm.J.W. Smith, Director, Vice1 President & General Sales Manager of BELL ASBESTOS MINES,LTD. Mr.-.Smith began his remarks by saying that it was the opinion of the' producers that the' fibre situation should be exposed as frequently as A.T.I. meets, and proceeded to discuss the situation relative to various grades. Group 7 fibers in the shorter classifications are fairly ample, but the longer Group 7's are in tighter supply. Grou-p 6 fibers (Used in Brake Linings,etc.) very specific shortage. Group 5 fibers - Premuim classifications are "tight". Group 1+ fibers (Used in asbestos-cement products)fairly well in balanc Group 3 fibers - (Used in textiles) A year ago a shortage existed, but now the high magnetic iron fibers as produced in i^juebec mines are in good supply. By contrast the low magnetic iron Group 3 fibers, as- produced by Cassiar on the West Coast of Canada, continue to be critically short. The unusually severe winter has crippled production of Cassiar - situation may improve somewhat by June, but supply will still be short. In regard to'Rhodesian fiber the embargo has been most offective * both in tho U.S.A. and in Canada. It is a critical situation for ft Minutes - GENERAL MEETING - continued: Page -3- asbestos textile manufacturers in the U.S.A. because there is no alternative low iron fiber except Casslar. The U.3. Government has a sizeable stockpile of low iron fiber but apparently is not willing to release any of it. !' ' 10. Committee reports were giv ,n by the respective chairmen Air Hygiene : Kfg. Committee - H.M. Willingham, Chn. Technical Committee - J.l'. Hawkins (Acting chairman) Asbestos Advisory Committee - E.A. Morris, Chm. Fiber Testing Committee - D.E..Childers Their reports are attached to these minutes. 11, Dr. J.L. Goodman, North Charleston,3.C., associated with Raybestos-Manhattan,Inc., speaking as a member of The A.T.I. Environmental Health Committee, reported that he had attended . a seminar on Asoestosis, arranged by Dr.Irving J. Selikoff, that was held at the Kt Sinai School of.'Medicine, New York City, on June 15-lG, 1970. Dr. Goodman 3aid he was'quite surprised to note a goodly number of representatives of Labor in attendance. Dr. Selikoffs staff members presented the program, which turned out to be a diatribe against industry. At opening of the'' meeting it was announced that spraying of steel framework In new buildings(with asbestos fibre) had been discontinued in New York State. Dr. Goodman was critical, of Dr. Selikoffs presentation and accusations against industry. -Y7hen questions were directed to various speakers Dr.Selikoff invariably spoke up to answer the question - sometimes quite rudely, . - The second day of the Seminar was devoted to mesothelioma, which Dr. Goodman stated was a very controveriial and debatable form of cancor (as to cause) . He; does not agree with many of Dr. Selikoff's statements and/or conclusions on this subject. Dr. Goodman-feels that. Dr,' Selikoff is a "dangerous" man and the asbestos" Industry is going to have to learn how to combat his tactics,' /We cannot and should not take Dr. Selikoff lightly as he has facilities for :getting"facts,but gets away with half-trutk3, and the only, way he can be backed down is being faced with true facts. When asked if something could be done thru the American Medical Association(to..control' Dr. Selikoff) Dr. Goodman expressed doubt. Said there was--a?."grievance committee of the AKA but it was very difficult to get this committee to act. Thought that perhaps pressure on the Mt. Sinai School of Medicine might, be effective. In regard to mesothelioma Hr. kin.J.W. Smith asked if Dr. Solikof differentiated between Crocidolite and Chrysotile fibre. Dr. Goodman said that Dr. Selikoff inferred that Chrysotile was suspect as well as Crocidolite. _ Following Dr. Goodman's comments Mr. C.L. Sheckler, Chairman of A.T.I.'s rjivironmental Health Committee, said that Dr. Selikoff was going to be around indefinitely and we might as well resign -ourselves to that fact, even though Selikoff might be prone ' . to deal with "half-truths". . Mr.- Sheckler commented on the excellent promotional type Snglis film entitled "WJIY ASBESTOS" shown to the members the previous evening, saying that there is now an Asbestos Information Association of North America. Members of this now association are some of the leading manufacturers of asbestos products in the U.S.A., but no further information wa3 given out by Mr. Sheckler. ' Kinutes - GENERAL MEETING- - continued: Page -Ip Mr. Sheckler then discussed the new Federal "Occupational Safety & Health Act of 1970" (PL91-596) that becomes effective on April 28,1971, saying that Industry and its customers can well face new exposure to penalties after the law becomes effective. Outlined some of the penalties, an.; discussed standards under the new law. For example, "the present standard for noise) is 90 jsLaih decibels maximum, and he doubts that any textile plant son show such a low noise level! Under the new law government inspectors will have free access to plants and records. An employee or employee group may request government to make inspection at any time. The employer is required to post conditions that exceed standards. All penalties are to be final unless contested within 15 days. In regard to medical and health research Mr. Shockler said that a "National Institute of Safety & Health" haxyjnrxxxlxxkuAxx has been (or will be) set up within the framework of the Health, Education and Welfare Department. X Dr. Cralley's group will be part of it. j1 Concluding his remarks Mr. Shockler said!that warning labels on products were now voluntary but probably will become mandatory at some future date. Thinks that our Industry^must give serious consideration to the use of warning labels on asbestos products. Mentioned that Common Lav; product suits are proliferating in the Thermal Insulation Industry. Date.that label U3e began could . indicate whether a manufacturer had been negligent in case of a" law suit. . .: 12. Locations for meetings in 1971 were announced: June 9-10, 1971 - Cherry Hill Inn, Cherry Hill, N.J. October 6-8, 1971 .'-.-Savannah Inn -cc Country Club, Savannah,Ga. The June meeting schedule will call for arrival Wednesday afternoon or evening, committee meetings Thursday morning, and General Meeting from 2:00 to Ll:00 P.M. Thursday afternoon. This shortened program will en'ab'le most. attendees-to .be back at their respective offices on Friday morning. ~ "* // f/ The October-meeting is'our ANNUAL MEETING to which company officials and members', wives are;specially invited. The meeting schedule in October will*-suggest.- arrival on Wednesday afternoon or evening, the committee meetings-will be on Thursday, and General Meeting on Friday morning. --" 13. There being no further business the meeting adjourned at 3:50 P.K. Respectfully submitted. H.i. Sunbury Secretary (Draft) / / .. - A - AS3EST0S TEXTILE INSTITUTE Minutes - GENERAL MEETING - February I4., 1971 The RED CARPET INN , Charlotte, N.C. In attendance: ' PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT AMERICA:: ASBESTOS TEXTILE CORP. J.W. Cnristenbury Wm. Maaskant H.H. Walter ASBESTOS CORPORAT^^^B^^^^ G.F.A. Drink P.E, Leclerc GARLOCK INC. A. Kuzmuk W.F. Brainerd ' JOHN S -MANVILLE COR PQRATI ON N.D. BROWN E.A. SCIIUMAK K.A. Roberts C. L, Sheckler ' H.K. PORTER COMPANY,INC. La hi* hooay D. E. Childers J.W. Echerd E. C. Bratt J.D. HcCluer (Ret'd) Nicolet INDUSTRIES , INC. Geo. Griswold, Jr. /,-* E.W. Russell ' / , ' '' BELL ASBESTOS MINES LIMITED Wm.J.W. Smith Walter II. Smith I1 lake asbestos op Quebec,ltd. C.E. Stiefken I -BURNER-BROS.ASBESTOS CO.,Ltd. W.M. Deokman __ .. H.J. Corson ' UiriROYAL, INC. ' E.A. norris R.C. Hunt y.''A' H.H. Willingham 'Dr.J.Ii. Wolfsie S.J. Peele,Jr. T.H. Newby L.F. Dieringer (Guest) RAYBSSTOS-KAN-ATTAN,INC. CADWALADER, V/ICKZRSKAM h TAFT M.^. Scowcroft H.C. Roosevelt (Legal Counsel J.W. Hawkins .. Dr.J.L. Goodman' ASBESTOS TEXTILE INSTITUTE J.W. Frampton (Guest) H.E.Sunbury (Secretary) II }\ I 1 1B-w-iHHJ Minutes irvKHfr-K- \\ * l L. President''Moody .-called the meeting to order at 1:^5 ?.K. 2. TU<|^^^pesent were asked to stand and identify themselves and to gil|pl|ieir company affiliation. 3. President Moody asked that a moment of prayer be observed in memory of Ralph 5. Smith who passed away on January 21,1971 at his home in North Charleston,S.C. Kr. Smith had attended A.T.I. meetings for about twenty years, and served as Chairman of our Air Hygiene Mfg. Committee during I960 and 1961. k.. The minutes of the last mooting were presented for reading. On motion by Mr.E.A. Schuman,seconded by Hr. K.A. Roberts, it was voted to omit the reading of Bame. Minutes GENERAL MEETING continued: Page -2- 5. Treasurer Kuznuk presented the Financill Report. Dr. J.H. V.'olfsie moved that it be accepted, motion seconded by Mr. P.E. Leclerc, and so voted unanimously. A copy of the report is attached to these minutes. 6. President Moody referred to "The History of the Asbestos Textile Industry in the United States" by J.A. i3ettcs,Jr., now appearing in installments in tho ASBESTOS Magazine, and said that the Secretary had been instructed to write Mr. bettes a letter of commendation on behalf of the Institute and its members. Hr. Bettes, an active member of the Institute for approximately twenty-four years, served as president of ATI in 1937 and 1958. Upon retirement from :<aybestosHanhattan several years ago Mr. 3ottes bogan to collect the infor mation for his "History of the .Asbestos Textile Industry in the USA" and it has required countless hours and voluminous correspondence to prepare the "History" for publication. The Institute appreciates the fine contribution that Mr. Bettes has made'to the asbestos * textile industry, and congratulates him on doing an exceptionally fine job I AI30, we think that the ASBESTOS-Magazine is to be commonaed for making the "History" available to'its readersl Mr. Bettes address is:- John A. Bettes,Jr.,3100 South Ocean Blvd.,#6l ?xx Delray Beach,Fla. 334-4i|. and we'are sure that he would welcome comments from readers of the "History". . 7. President Moody announced the election of Mr. K.D. Brown to the Board of Governors, replacing Hr." .A. Schuman as Johns-Manville * representative; and the election to the Board of Mr. J.W. Christenbur replacing Mr. J.L. Rainey", as "the representative for American Asbestos Textile Corporation. Mr. Schuman resigned because he no longer has responsibility for asbestos textiles. Mr. Rainey's resignation was necessary due to increased corporate responsibilities since Ht-s he was elected President of his company in June of 1970. V\ / 8. The Legal Counsel Report-wa3 given by Attorney H.C. Roosevelt, of Cadwalader, ..Vfickersham t:t Taft", New York,N.Y. A resume* of his remarks is attached to these minutes. ? | i) 9. The Fibre. Producer's Report was given by Mr. Wra.J.W. Smith, Director, Vice President & -General Sales Manager of BELL ASBESTOS MINES,LTD. Mr.-.Smith began his remarks by saying that it was the opiniqigiiC; the" producers that the fibre situation should be exposed as frtdjBibly as A.T.I* meets, and proceeded to discuss the situation relatfpipb various grades. Group 7 fibers in the shorter classifications are fairly ample, but the longer Group 7's are in tighter supply. Group 6 fibers (Used in Brake Linings,etc.) very specific shortage. Group 5 fibers - Premuim classifications are "tight". Group 4. fibers (Used in asbestos-cement products)fairly well in balar. Group 3 fibers - (Used in textiles) A year ago a shortage existed, but now the high magnetic iron fibers as produced in (Quebec mines are in good supply. By contrast the low magnetic iron Group 3 fibers, as- produced by Cassiar on the West Coast of Canada, continue to be critically short. The unusually severe winter has crippled procuctior of Cassiar - situation may improve somewhat by June, but supply will still be short. . _ In regard to Rhodesian fiber the embargo has been most effective " both in tho U.S.A. and in Canada. It is a critical situation for Minutes GENERAL MEETING - continued: Page -3- asbestos textile nanufacturers in the U.S.A. because there is no alternative low iron fiber except Cassiar. The C.3. Government has a sizeable stockpile of low iron fiber but apparently is not willing to release any of it. I 10. Committee reports were giv ,n by the respective chairmen Air Hygiene i: Mfg. Committee - H.M. Willingham, Chm. Technical Committee - .T.\*. Hawkins (Acting chairman) Asbestos Advisory Committee - E.A. Morris, Chm. Fiber Testing. Committee - D.E. .Childers Their reports are attached to these minutes. 11. Dr. J.L. Goodman, worth Charleston,2.C., associated with Raybestos-'Manhattan,Inc., speaking as a member of The A.T.I. Environmental Health Committee, reported that he had attended . a seminar on Asbestosis, arranged by Dr. Irving J. Selikoff, that wa3 held at the Kt. Sinai School of.'Medicine, iiew Yortc City, on June 15-18, 1970. Dr. Goodman 3aid he was quite surprised to note a goodly number of representatives of Labor in attendance. Dr. Selikoffs staff manoers presented the program, which" turned out to bo a diatribe against industry. At o jening of the' meeting it was announced that spraying of steel framework in new buildings(with asbestos fiore) had been discontinued in new York State. Dr. Goodman was critical of Dr. Selikoffs presentation and accusations against industry. 'When questions were directed to various speakers Dr.Selikoff invariably spoke up to answer the question - sometimes quite rudely. . The second day of the Seminar was devoted to mesothelioma, which Dr. Goodman stated was a very controveriial and debatable form of cancor (as to cause). He'docs not agree with many of Dr. Selikoffs statements and/or conclusions on this subject. Dr. Goodman feels that-Dr.' Selikoff is a "dangerous" man and the asbestos' industry is -going to have to learn how to combat his tactics.'/We cannot and should not take Dr. Selikoff lightly as he has facilities for getting"factsy,but gets away with half-trutk3, and the only, way he con be backed down is being faced with true facts. When asked if something could be done thru the American Medical Association(to..contror Dr. Selikoff) Lr. Goodman expressed doubt. Said thagfeMas--^.grievance committee of the AilA but it was very diffict||^Bfc get this committee to act. Thought that perhaps pressure on the3^^gKnai School of Medicine might be effective. TBH8||gard to mesothelioma Mr. Wm.J.W. Smith asked if Dr. Solikof differeitfisted between Crocidolite and Chrysotile fibre. Dr. Goodman said that Dr. Selikoff inferred that Chrysotile was suspect as well as Crocidolite. . Following Dr. Goodman's comments Hr. C.L. Sheckler, Chairman of A.T.I.'s .-Jivironmental Health Committee, said that Dr. Selikoff was going to be around indefinitely and we might as woll resign ourselves to that fact, even though Selikoff might be prone ' . to deal with "half-truths". , Mr.- Sheckler commented on the excellent promotional type Englia film entitled "WHY ASBESTOS" shown to the members the previous evening, saying that there is now an Asbestos Information Association of North America. Members of this now association are some of the leading manufacturers of asbestos products in the U.S.A., but no further information wa3 given out by Mr. Sheckler. * Kinutes - GENERAL MEETING - continued: Page -Lj.- Mr. Sheckler then discussed the new Federal "Occupational Safety & Health Act of 1970" (PL91-p96) that becomes effective on April 23,1971, saying that Industry and its customers can well face now exposure to ponalties after the law becomes effective. Outlined somo of the penalties'^ am. discussed standards under the new law. For example, the present standard for noise; is 90 nEih decibels maximum, and he doubts that any textile plant ^an show such a low noise level! Under the new law government inspectors will have free access to plants and records. An employee or employee group may request government to make inspection at any time. Tho employer is required to post conditions that exceed standards. All penalties are to be final unless contested within lp days. In regard to medical and health research Mr. cheekier said that a "National Institute of Safety & Health" hax?inrxxxixxk)d:xx has been (or will be) set up within the framework of the Health, Education and Welfare Department. X Dr. Cralley's group will be part of it. it Concluding his remarks Mr. Sheckler 3aidt that warning labels on products were now voluntary but probably will become mandatory at some future date. Thinks that our industryi^must give serious consideration to the U3e of warning labels on asbestos products. Mentioned that Common Lav; product suits are proliferating in the Thermal Insulation Industry. Date.that label use began could -- indicate whether a manufacturer had been negligent in case of a'- law suit. .. . 12. Locations for meetings in 1971 were announced: June 9-10, 1971 - Cherry Hill Inn, Cherry Hill, N.J. October 6-8, 1971 / / "Savannah Inn -cc Country Club, Savannah,Ga. The June meeting schedule will call for arrival Wednesday afternoon or evening, committee meetings Thursday morning, and General Meeting from 2:00 to k:00 ?.M. Thursday afternoon. This shortened program will enable most.attendees-to be back at their respective offices on Friday morning. ' "* /1 ' The October meeting is our ANNUAL MEETING to which company officials and members', wives are;specially invited; The meeting schedule in October will.*'suggest.-arrival on Wednesday afternoon or evening, the committee meetings-will be on Thursday, and General Meeting on further business the meeting adjourned at 3:50 P.K Respectfully submitted. H.n. Sunbury Secretary