Document BZQEJB3Zw1No184q2ky1E4bj

American Journal of Industrial Medicine 17:553-565 (1990) Mortality and Cancer Morbidity in Workers Exposed to Low Levels of Vinyl Chloride Monomer at a Polyvinyl Chloride Processing Plant Lars Hagmar, md, Bengt Akesson, BSc, Jorn Nielsen, md, Christina Andersson, b$c, Katarina Linden, BSc, Robyn Attewell, MSc, and Torgil Moller, md To study whether exposure to low levels of vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) causes increased risk for cancer morbidity and death from ischemic heart disease, a cohort study was performed among 2,031 male workers at a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) processing plant who had been employed for at least 3 months during the period 1945-1980. An almost significantly increased total mortality (SMR =116, 95% Cl 99-136) was found. Deaths caused by violence or intoxication were significantly increased (SMR = 153, 95% Cl 109-213), but not deaths from ischemic heart disease (SMR = 100, 95% Cl 73-135). A significant increase in total cancer morbidity was observed (SMR = 128, 95% Cl 101-161). Respiratory cancers were significantly increased (SMR = 213.95% Cl 127-346). Furthermore, six brain tumors (vs. 2.6 expected) were observed. This increase, however, was not significant (SMR = 229. 95% Cl 84-498). No liver hemangiosarcoma was observed. Applying a latency period of 2:10 years from start of employment did not change the risk patterns. There were no significant exposureresponse associations between exposure estimates for VCM, asbestos, and plasticizers and cancer morbidity. Key words: asbestos, brain cancer, plasticizers, phthalic acid esters, respiratory cancer, ischemic heart disease INTRODUCTION it is well-established that vinyl chloride monomer (VCM) may induce angio sarcoma of the liver, but there have also been suggestions of increased risks for lung cancer [Buffler et al., 1979; Waxweiler et al., 1976], brain tumors (Beaumont and Breslow, 1981; Cooper, 1981], melanoma [Storetvedt Heldaas et al., 1984], and hematopoietic malignancies [Weber et al., 1981] in workers producing VCM or polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The exposure levels for VCM had, however, been very high in the latter workplaces. In contrast, the exposure to VCM has been substantially Department of Occupational Medicine. University Hospital. Lund. Sweden (L.H., B.A.. J.N.. C.A., K.L., R.A.). Regional Tumor Regisiry. University Hospital. Lund, Sweden (T.M.). Address reprint requests to Dr. Lars Hagmar, Department of Occupational Medicine, University Hospital, 5-221 85 Lund. Sweden. Accepted for publication November 28, 1989. 1990 Wilcy-Liss. Inc. R&S 001884 554 Hagmar et al. lower in the PVC processing industry. No excess cancer mortality or morbidity was observed in a Swedish cohort study of employees from four PVC processing plants [Molina et al., 1981]. On the other hand, a proportionate mortality study of employ ees in PVC fabricators showed an excess in total cancer mortality, particuiary that of the digestive system [Chiazze et al., 1977]. Thus, whether low-level exposure to VCM increases the cancer incidence is not known. However, it should be remem bered that there also has been exposure to other carcinogens, such as asbestos and certain plasticizers, in those working in the PVC processing industry. A much used plasticizer, di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP), has been regarded as carcinogenic in mice and rats by the I ARC [1982], An increased mortality due to myocardial infarction was observed in the pre vious Swedish cohort study of PVC-processing workers, which, hypothetically, was ascribed to a damaging effect on the blood vessels by VCM [Molina et al., 1981]. We report here on mortality and cancer morbidity in a cohort of workers from a PVC processing plant in which PVC. after addition of various chemicals, is heat-treated for fabrication into floor and wall coverings, pipes, sheets, and food packaging. The present plant is one of the four included in the previous Swedish cohort study [Molina et al., 1981]. As we have extended both the inclusion and observation period for the study and also obtained information from previously neglected company records, fewer than 50% of the subjects in the present cohort were included in the previous study. One aim of the present study was to investigate whether there was an increased risk for cancer among employees in the PVC processing industry and whether such risks could be associated with specific chemical exposures. Furthermore, it was regarded as important to clarify whether there was an increased mortality from my ocardial infarction or other cardiovascular diseases. SUBJECTS AND METHODS The Plant The plant was founded in 1945. Initially, both the production and the number of employees were limited, but. since the mid 1950s, the production has been more extensive. The three main products manufactured in the plant arc the following. 1) Thick film floor sheeting, floor tiles, and homogenous mats, have been produced since 1947 in calenders from PVC containing phthalic acid esters, mainly DEHP, as plasticizers. Asbestos, mainly chrysotile, used as rcinforccr, was added to the PVC in the mixing department until 1977. 2) Thin film has. since 1952, been calendered from PVC, containing mostly DEHP, diisodecyl phthalate. and butylbenzylphthalate as plasticizers. The film was cut into diapers or ribbons for mat production or ex ported in rolls for use as packing material. 3) Pipes have, during the period 19521975, been extruded from PVC. containing mainly DEHP as a plasticizer. Further more. lead and cadmium compounds have been added as stabilizers. Exposure Estimates For each calendar year 1945-1980, each work operation in the plant has been classified by an occupational hygienist in cooperation with technical and safety staff of the plant, with regard to the estimated mean exposure levels of VCM, asbestos. Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 555 and plasticizers. A four-grade scale, "none." "low." "moderate." or "high" ex posure level, was used. The exposure to VCM was rather stable until 1975. when the exposure levels rapidly decreased due to the first repons of the association with liver hemangiosarcoma. Before 1975, the mean exposure level among "highly" exposed workers (workers in the mixing departments and calender operators) was estimated to be about 10 ppm, among "moderately" exposed workers (e.g.. machine attendants) about 1 ppm. and among workers exposed to "low" levels of VCM (quality inspectors and packing personal) about 0.1 ppm. Based on this information, the individual cumu lated exposure (ppm-years) was calculated by adding the exposure estimates for each calendar year. The cumulated exposure data were used in dose-response calculations. The estimates for asbestos were partly based on measurements of breathing zone levels. In 1971. the mean exposure level among "highly" exposed workers (raw material transport workers, workers in the mixing departments and PVC crushing, and calender operators) was 1-3 fibers/ml. among "moderately" exposed workers (machine attendants and repairmen) >0.1-0.5 fibers/ml. and among workers ex posed to "low" levels of asbestos (quality inspectors and packing personnel) up to 0.1 fibers/ml. Measurements were performed over a total of 108 hr. No measurements of asbestos were performed before 1971, but. based on the best available judgements, the time-weighted average exposure levels after 1969 were estimated to have been about 40% lower than those in the period 1956-1969. Air sampling in 1975 indicated that the mean exposure level in all exposed workplaces had decreased by a factor of 3 compared to the period 1970-1974. No asbestos was used in the manufacture after 1977. The individual cumulated exposure for asbestos (fiber-years/ml) was calcu lated, in the same manner as for VCM. by adding the exposure estimates for each calendar year. The exposure levels for plasticizers were stable during the whole study period. The time-weighted average breathing zone level of phthalic acid esters among "highly" exposed workers (calender operators) was >0.5-3 mg/m3, among "mod erately" exposed workers (workers in the mixing departments and machine atten dants) >0.1-0.5 mg/nv\ and among workers exposed to "low" levels of VCM (quality inspectors and packing personnel) up to 0.1 mg/nv'. The individual cumulated exposure for plasticizers (mg-ycars) was calculated, in the same manner as for VCM and asbestos, by adding the exposure estimates for each calendar-year. Cohort Front the company's records, name, date of birth, address, and dates of start and end of employment were obtained for 2,042 male workers who had been employed for 3 months or more during the period 1945 to December 31. 1980 (Fig. 1). The records, however, contained no data on workers who had left employment or died before 1961. Vital status was determined up to December 31. 1985 (Table 1) for all but 1 1 subjects (0.5%). whose ten-digit personal identification code could not be estab lished. Six of these subjects had been employed for less than I year. If a 10 year latency period was used, the total loss in follow-up was 0.7%. Thus the study cohort consisted of 2,031 subjects. Table II shows the distribution of person-years by age group and calendar year. 556 Hagmar et al. 1 -i Stan ol emoto/mem Calendar Year Fig. I. Cumulative distribution of time of starting and ending of work among workers employed at a PVC processing plant in the period 1945-1980. The cumulative number of observed deaths and tumors 1961-1985 are also shown. TABLE I. Vital Status in the Cohort of Workers in a I'VC Processing Factory All ^Ten years latency period Vital status Living Dead Emigrated Not identified-1 Total N 1.726 159 146 II 2.042 Percent 84.5 7.8 7.1 0.5 100.0 N 1.536 108 19 II 1.674 Percent 91.8 6.5 l.l 0.7 100.0 JA ten-digit personal identification code could not be established. TABLE U. Person-Years of Observation in a Cohort of 2.031 Workers in a PVC Processing Plant Age 1 years) Calendar year <30 30-59 60-79 1961-1970 1971-1980 1981-1985 Total 2.334 5.753 1,366 9.453 2.624 9.140 6.418 18.182 290 1.224 1.001 2.515 Total 5.248 16.117 8.785 30.150 Information on Causes of Death and Tumors Information on cause of death (1961-1985) was obtained from the National Swedish Central Bureau of Statistics. The death certificates were coded according to the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) by the National Swedish Central But icat ica' the die. 49< sio Sot aut' Ris em mo em ye; (Bi ant ila: ob` de; re.du V( pepn cx su it\ ci: nc co cx ca an T1 sr Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 557 Bureau of Statistics, which is responsible for the coding of all Swedish death certif icates. All codes were transformed to the Eighth Revision of the ICD. Death certifem icates regarding causes of death of special interest were obtained. A total of 50% of the death certificates were based on clinical or forensic autopsy in subjects who had died before 80 years of age. If the 10 year latency period was used, the figure was 49%. Information on up to two tumors (coded according to the ICD. Seventh Revi sion) diagnosed from 1961 to 1985 was obtained from the National Swedish and the Southern Swedish Regional Tumor Registries. Case records.from hospital as well as autopsies were scrutinized. Risk Estimates The person-year accumulation in the cohort started in 1961. Date of death. ^ emigration or 80th birthday were used as individual endpoints. With regard to cancer morbidity, date of diagnosis of a second tumor was also used as an individual endpoint. Expected mortality for the period 1961-1985 was calculated using calendar year-, cause-, and 5 year age group-specific mortality rates for males in the county (Blekingc: about 75.000 male inhabitants). These rates were calculated from death and population counts obtained from the National Central Bureau of Statistics. Sima ilarly, yearly morbidity rates for cancer in the period 1961-1985 for the county were rs obtained from the Southern Swedish Regional Tumor Register. Cause-specific standardized mortality/morbidity ratios (SMRs) and 95% confi dence intervals (Cl) were calculated according to the Poisson distribution. Exposureresponse relationships were assessed by analyses of SMRs over strata, based on duration of employment and the individual total cumulated exposure estimates for ~ VCM. asbestos, and plasticizers [Breslow et al., 1983]. Each individual contributes person-years successively to each employment and exposure estimate stratum as he progresses through his employment time [Swaen and Volovics. 1987). Thus, the exposure-response relationships were based on classified person-years and not on subjects. The correlation between age and length of employment affects the comparabil ity of the SMRs from each employment stratum. Furthermore, there is also an asso ciation between the cumulated exposure estimates and age. This may result in a negative bias in the SMRs. especially for those employed for a long time. Thus, to correct for the relationship between age and length of employment or cumulated exposure, an age-standardized SMR (SSMR) was calculated accordina to Ranstam [19841. To clarify possible interactive effects of the three different chemical agents on cancer incidence, the distribution of subjects, observed number of tumors, and SMRs are given for the eight combinations of ever being exposed (or not) to the three agents. The term "significant" refers to p ^ 0.05 or to the lower limit of the 95% Cl for SMR > 1.00. All tests are two-tailed. R&S 001888 RESULTS Mortality During the period 1961-1985. 156 deaths were observed vs. 134.6 expected (SMR = I 16. 95% Cl 99-136: Table III). The cumulated number of deaths in the R&S 001889 558 Hagmar et aJ. TABLE III. Observed (O) and Expected (E) Mortality 1961-1985 and Specific Causes of Death in a Cohort of Workers in a PVC Processing Plant* Cause of death Air &Ten years latency-periodb Organ ICD-8 O E SMR 95% Cl O E SMR 95% Cl Malignant tumors Gastrointestinal tumors Respiratory tumors Cardiovascular diseases Ischemic heart diseases Bronchitis, emphysema, asthma Gastrointestinal diseases Urinary tract diseases Violence, intoxication All causes 140-209 38 30.8 150-159 14 10.7 160-163 10 6.6 390-458 60 60.1 410-414 44 44.0 490-493 4 2.0 520-577 7 4.6 580-599 4 1.4 800-999 37 24.2 000-999 156 134.6 122 88-171 29 20.7 131 72-220 11 7.6 153 73-280 6 4.6 100 77-129 47 43.5 100 73-135 36 32.3 201 55-514 1.3 151 61-312 3 2.7 291 79-745 3 0.8 153 109-213 16 10.6 116 99-136 105 86.5 140 95-203 145 72-260 130 48-284 108 80-145 III 79-156 777 47-663 112 23-328 389 80-1140 151 89-250 121 100-147 "SMR. standardized mortality ratio. '2.031 subjects. 30,150 person-years under observation. hl,663 subjects. 12.187 person-years under observation. cohort is plotted with regard to time in Figure I. With regard to cause-specific mortality, there was no significantly increased risk of death in malignant tumors (SMR = 122, 95% Cl 88-171), cardiovascular diseases (SMR = 100. 95% Cl 77-129), or ischemic heart diseases (SMR = 100. 95% Cl 73-129: Table III). Four deaths from obstructive lung diseases, vs. two expected, were observed. However, i this was far from statistically significant (SMR = 201. 95% Cl 55-514), On the other hand, deaths from violence or intoxication were significantly increased (SMR !' = 153, 95% Cl 109-213). When a latency-period of s 10 years was applied. 105 deaths were observed vs. 86.5 expected (SMR = 121. 95% Cl 100-147). The pattern of cause-specific deaths was not affected by the applied latency period. Cancer Morbidity A significant increase in total cancer morbidity was observed (SMR = 128. 95% Cl 101-161; Table IV). The cumulated number of tumors in the cohort is plotted with respect to time in Figure I. Among the specific cancers, there was a significant increase in respiratory cancer (SMR = 213. 95% Cl 127-346), consisting ot an increased incidence of both laryngeal cancer (SMR = 391. 95% Cl 81-1 140) and lung cancer, including one case of mesothelioma (SMR = 186. 95% Cl 99-318: Table IV). The increased incidence of brain tumors did not reach a statistically significant level (SMR = 220. 95% Cl 84--198). Of the six observed brain tumors, TAB Wort Site Gasf Li Resp N. La Lr Pros; Braii All `SM J2.0 1 .O five obs of 1 Tal |9: dei ^ <ni sir anw ce: sta T! es' be pc in In e> (5 in c. M Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 559 TABLE IV. Observed (O) and Expected (E) Tumor Morbidity 1961-1985 in a Cohort of Workers in a PVC Processing Plant* Tumor All1 ^Ten years latency -period1. Site ICD-7 O E SMR 95% Cl O E SMR 95% Cl Gastrointestinal tract 150-158 19 14.9 Liver, bile ducts 155. -> 1.1 Respiratory tract 160-164 17 8.0 Nose, sinuses 160 t 0.2 Larynx 161 3 0.8 Lune. pleura 162-164 13 7.0 Prostate 177 11 6.5 Brain 193.0 6 2.6 All 140-209 75 58.6 127 189 213 -U8 391 186 170 rig I2S 78-202 23-684 14 10.6 *> 0.8 127-346 11 5 6 11-2500 1 0.1 81-114 3 0.6 99-318 7 5.0 85-304 10 5.2 84-498 4 1.6 101-161 55 39.8 133 244 195 803 549 141 191 258 138 70-213 30-880 97--349 20-4470 113-1610 57-290 91-351 70- 660 105- 181 *SMR. standardized mortality ratio. `2.031 subjects. 30.150 person-years under observation. " 1.663 subjects. 12.187 person-years under observation. live were astrogliomas and one a meningeoma. Neither of the two liver tumors observed was a hcmangiosarcoma. When a latency period of > 10 years was applied, the total cancer morbidity was of the same magnitude as without the latency period (SMR = 138. 95% Cl 105-181: Table IV). The morbidity from respiratory cancer was still about doubled (SMR = 195. 95% Cl 97-349), but the excess risk for lung and pleural cancer had decreased somewhat (SMR = 141. 95% Cl 57-290). On the other hand, the increased inci dence of laryngeal cancer reached statistical significance (SMR = 549, 957c Cl 113-1610). Dose-Response Analysis There were no significant associations between length of employment and the incidence of respiratory cancers or total cancer incidence, regardless of whether a >10 years latency period was applied or not (Tabic V). Furthermore, there were no signi(leant associations between the individual cumulated exposure estimates to VCM and incidence of respiratory or total cancer (Table VI). ''High cumulated exposure to asbestos (^3.3 fiber-years/ml) was significantly associated with respiratory can cers (SSMR = 295. p = 0.01), but the exposure-response relationships were not statistically significant for either these tumors or total cancer incidence (Table VII). There were no significant associations between the individual cumulated exposure estimates to plasticizers and incidence of respiratory or total cancer (Tabic VIII). None of the subjects in the cohort had been exposed to VCM only, 287r had been exposed to asbestos only, and 67r to plasticizers only (Table IX). Thirty-four percent of the cohort had been exposed to all three agents, but no increased cancer incidence was observed for this subcohort. However, the case of mesothelioma was from this category. Fourteen percent of the cohort had not been exposed to anv of the exposure agents. The total cancer incidence was. however, increased in this group (SMR = 183, 95% Cl 100-308). Finally, a total of 18% of the cohort were classified in the remaining three exposure combinations. A significant increase for respiratory cancer (SMR = 1070, 95% Cl 220-3120) was observed in the subcohort of 76 subjects exposed to both asbestos and plasticizers but not to VCM. 560 Hagmar et al. TABLE V. Relationship Between Time of Employment and Risk of Cancer Morbidity* Time of employment (years) Tumor Site 1CD-7 Respiratory tract 160-164 Lune. pleura 162-164 All 140-209 < 1 (mean 0.5)" O SMR SSMR 3 295 . 295 2 221 221 12 155 155 1-5 (mean 2.4)h O SMR SSMR 3 254 1 96 12 139 252 109 145 >5 (mean 12.3)'' O SMR SSMR 5 145 4 133 51 132 138 132 123 P 0.28 >0.5 >0.5 *A latency period of 10 years has been applied. The calculations were based on 1.663 subjects. O. observed cases. SMR, standardized morbidity ratio. SSMR. SMR standardized to the age distribution in the <1 year group. P for trend in SSMR, J3.579 person-years at risk. h3,553 person-years at risk. ''5,057 person-years at risk. TABLE VI. Relationship Between the Cumulative Exposure Estimates for Vinyl Chloride Monomer (VCM) and Risk of Cancer Morbidity* SJ Cumulative exposure estimates ippm-ycarsj (/) Tumor <0. 1 (mean 0.02)J 0.1 -1 (mean 0.4)h > I (mean 23)' Oo Site 1CD-7 O SMR SSMR O SMR SSMR O SMR SSMR P Respiratory tract 160-164 6 247 247 T 161 109 3 153 165 >0.5 00 (0 Lune. pleura 162-164 5 232 232 0 0 0 116 123 >0.5 All 140-209 26 149 149 14 155 148 15 112 105 0,3 The calculations were based on 1,658 subjects. A latency period of 11) years has been applied. O. observed cases: SMR. standardized morbidity ratio: SSMR. SMR standardized to the age distribution in the <0.1 ppm-vears category; p for trend in SSMR. J5.543 person-years at risk. b3.542 person-years at risk. '3.062 person-years at risk. DISCUSSION The main result of the present study is an increased incidence of total cancer morbidity, and more specifically of respiratory cancers, in RVC processing workers. Validity No preemployment health examination was performed before 1968, when the company founded its medical health service. Even after that, there has been no focus on cardiovascular or respiratory diseases in preemployment health examinations. There is not likely to have been any self-selection against employment in the plant, but this possible bias can of course not fully be excluded. Thus there is no reason to believe that there has been any significant bias in selection of employees into the cohort affecting mortality from cardiovascular or chronic obstructive respiratory dis eases. However, it is possible that workers with such diseases may have left work selectively, causing an underestimation of risk. Since 1968. the employees have been examined routinely by chest X-ray every 5 years; no tumor has yet been diagnosed by this means. No other screening test lor cancer has been performed among the workers. Thus there is no reason to believe that TA! Cat. Site Res l All *A obs the J3.s h4. \3.1- TA Ris Sit<. Re- I All A obthe J4. h3. '3. tU' pc cc cc w. cc fo re di ir tl P 0.28 >0.5 >0.5 cts. O. tlion in P >0.5 >0.5 lied, ution in cancer arkers. ten the 3 locus ations. : plant, tson to nto the try dis't work / every test for :ve Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 561 TABLE VII. Relationship Between the Cumulative Exposure Estimates for Asbestos and Risk of Cancer Morbidity* Cumulative exposure estimate (fiber-years/ml) Tumor Site ICD-7 Respiratory tract Lung, pleura All 160-164 162-164 140-209 <0.03 (mean 0.002V* 0.03 -3.3 (mean 1.2 )h >3.3 (mean 13.5V O SMR SSMR O SMR SSMR O SMR SSMR 3 162 T 121 22 168 162 1 73 121 0 0 168 14 137 51 7 290 0 5 235 I -40 19 116 295 241 112 P 0.18 0.14 0.29 *A latency period of slO years has been applied. The calculations were based on I.65S subjects. O. observed cases: SMR. standardized morbidity ratio: SSMR. SMR standardized to the aye distribution in the <0.03 fiber-years/ml category; p for trend in SSMR. *3.885 person-years at risk. b4.386 person-years at risk. l,3.875 person-years at risk. TABLE VIII. Relationship Between the Cumulative Exposure Estimates Tor Plasticizers and Risk of Cancer Morbidity* Cumulative exposure estimate Img-ycarsi Tumor <0.05 (mean 0.04)J 0.05-0.5 (mean 0,3)h >0.5 (mean 2)' Sile Respiratory tract Lung, pleura All ICD-7 160-164 162-164 140-209 O SMR I 52 1 58 19 135 SSMR 52 58 135 O SMR 5 373 168 15 153 SSMR 334 158 142 O 5 4 21 SMR 213 194 132 SSMR 224 204 138 P >0.5 >0.5 >0.5 *A latency period of 10 years has been applied. The calculations were based on 1,658 subjects. O. observed cases: SMR, standardized morbidity ratio: SSMR. SMR standardized to the age distribution in the <0.05 mg-years category; p for trend in SSMR. J4,644 person-years at risk. h3.662 person-years at risk. '3.858 person-years at risk. tumors have been diagnosed earlier in the exposed cohort than in the reference population. Diagnostic accuracy for causes of death, as well as tumors, is important for the conclusions. Information on cause of death could be obtained for all deceased. In the cohort. 50% of the death certificates were based on clinical or forensic autopsy, which is somewhat higher than the frequency of autopsy in deceased males in the county (about 36%). Thus, there arc reasons to believe that the diagnostic accuracy for causes of death in the cohort is somewhat better than average in this geographical region. The somewhat increased autopsy rate in the cohort docs not seem to have caused any bias with respect to tumor diagnosis; c.g.. no case of lung cancer was diagnosed by autopsy only. Smoking is a potential confounding factor for both lung cancer and laryngeal cancer. The smoking habits in the cohort arc not known. However, it is not unlikely that the number of smokers in the cohort, as well as in other groups of Swedish industrial workers (Hagmarct al.. 1986; Socialstyrelscn, 1986]. are somewhat higher than in the reference population. This may explain some of the observed excess risk for respiratory cancer. The exposure estimates were only partially based on measure- 562 Hagmar et al. TABLE IX. Relationship Between Cancer Morbidity and the Eight Combinations of (he Three Exposures (--, virtually never exposed: +, exposed) for 1.660 Subjects: Vinyl Chloride (VCM), Asbestos, and Platicizers* All cancer Respiratory cancer PlasticizersAsbestosAsbestos -t- Plasticizers + AsbestosAsbestos + VCMN O SMR VCM + N O SMR VCMO ... SMR VCM + O SMR 227 14 472 5 183" 79 00 70 01 00 105 0 00 99 3 180 214 5 131 1 4S7 0 76 4 193 565 24 133 3 1.070s 2 0 0 0 88 *A latency period of ^ 10 years has been applied. N, number of subjects: O. observed cases: SMR. standardized morbidity ratio. J95% Cl 100-308. "957c Cl 220-3.120. merits and were mainly based on skilled, but subjective, assessments of exposure levels. Thus, the individual cumulated exposure estimates we used arc. as in most retrospective cohort studies, rather crude. Mortality In many cohort studies among industrial workers, no increased overall mortality ratio is found. This has usually been ascribed to a "healthy worker effect" [McMichael. 1976]. On the other hand, we have, in two recent studies of workers in the chemical industry, observed increased overall mortality ratios compared with regional reference populations [Hagmar ct al., 1986: Englander et al.. 19881. The almost significantly increased overall mortality in the present study is in accordance with those findings. A major cause of the overall increase is the 50% excess in violent deaths or intoxications. This was also observed in our previous studies on workers in the chemical industry [Hagmar ct al.. 1986; Englander et al.. 1988]. The observed excess risk is probably correlated with socioeconomic factors, including alcohol abuse. No increased incidence of deaths from cardiovascular diseases, or more spe cifically from ischemic heart diseases, was observed in the cohort. This is in contrast to a previous Swedish study on the PVC processing industry, including a part of the present cohort, in which a slight excess risk for myocardial infarction was indicated [Molina et al.. 1981), but is. in concordance with the results of a proportionate mortality study among employees of PVC fabricators [Chiazze et al.. 1977). Fur thermore. the incidence of ischemic heart disease was not increased in previous studies on workers producing VCM or PVC. who were exposed to much higher levels of VCM [Doll. 19881. Four subjects in the cohort died.from chronic obstructive respiratory diseases compared with two expected. The numbers are still too small to allow any interpre tation. It should be remembered, however, that only a few studies on occupational groups have shown increased mortality in chronic obstructive respiratory diseases. It has been shown that men who are not gainfully employed had a highly increased risk of i mei res| gro Cat whi fab. oth' PVpar no\ inc! doc in t an\ pot rel: risl re a chr chr wo wa she sur to Pei stu the e.\| ob VC the foi ha< pr M. co si; ci; sc so hree CM), :r 'M + SMR 0 0 0 88 S MR, osure most talijA n the ional most with alent rs in rved ohol spetrast f the ated nate Fur ious vels ases preanal s. It risk Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 563 of death in chronic obstructive respiratory diseases compared to gainfully employed men in Sweden [Jarvholm et al., 1988], Therefore, it has been proposed that, with respect to these diseases, other occupational groups constitute more suitable reference groups than the general population [Jarvholm et al., 1988], Cancer Morbidity The present study showed an increased incidence of total cancer morbfdity, which is in agreement with a proportionate mortality study among employees of PVC fabricators showing an excess of total cancer mortality [Chiazze et al.. 1977]. On the other hand, such an increase was not observed in a previous Swedish cohort study on PVC processing workers (Molina et al., 1981]. However, the present study consists partly of the same subjects as in this latter study, but a longer follow-up period was now available. The increase in respiratory tumors was significant. However, the SMR did not increase when applying > 10 years latency period from start of employment, which does not strengthen the hypothesis of a causal association with the work environment in the present plant. Furthermore, no clear-cut exposure-response associations with any specific chemical agent could be established. On the other hand, the statistical power for exposure-response associations with specific tumor sites was limited by relatively few expected cases. Thus, the association between exposure to asbestos and risk for respiratory tumors, indicated in Table Vll, is noteworthy, even if it does not reach formal significance. According to Doll and Peto [1985], the incidence of chrysotile-induced lung cancer increases with 1% per fiber-years/ml. Mainly chrysotile had been handled in the present plant, and the exposure levels for most workers were relatively low (mean exposure level in the "highly" exposed stratum was 13.5 fiber-years/ml). Therefore, no dramatic effects with regard to lung cancer should be expected. The subject with mesothelioma had a cumulated asbestos expo sure of 17.2 fiber-years/ml and had a 26 year latency period from first day of exposure to date of diagnosis. A causal association is therefore probable in this case. Asbestos exposure is regarded as one of the causes of laryngeal cancer [Doll and Peto, 1985]. A significant increase in that diagnosis was observed in the present study, but this was based on only three cases. The cumulated asbestos estimates for these subjects were not impressive; 6.8, 5.1, and 1.2 fibcr-years/ml. Thus, whether exposure to asbestos contributed to the increased risk for laryngeal cancer is not obvious. It is also noteworthy with regard to previously suggested associations between VCM exposure and brain tumors [Beaumont and Breslow. 1981] that the incidence of these tumors was more than doubled in our study, even if the increase was not formally significant. On the other hand, only three of the six cases of brain tumors had ever been exposed to VCM. In previous case reports, VCM exposure in PVC processing plants has been associated with hepatic angiosarcomas (Wagoner. 1983; Maltoni et al., 1984], No such tumors were observed in our study, however. One aim of our study was to test whether the increased cancer risks in the cohort could be associated with exposure to VCM. asbestos, or plasticizers. However, no significant dose-response associations were found, even if a tendency towards asso ciation between respiratory cancers and cumulated exposure for asbestos was ob served. Several explanations for this inability to demonstrate exposure-response as sociations are possible. The observed excess risks may be due to nonidentified. R&S 001895 56-4 Hagmar et al. nonoccupational confounding factors or may be attributable to more complicated exposure interactions between chemical agents in the plant, which cannot be analyzed with our methodological approach. Alternatively, the lack of observed dose-response associations may be due to weaknesses in the applied, rather crude, exposure esti mates. Furthermore, the statistical power for detecting significant exposure-response associations between chemical agents and specific tumor sites was limited in the present study by few expected cases. A follow-up study with more person-years under observation will provide an increased precision, which should clarify the risk pattern connected with employment in the PVC processing industry. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This project was supported by grants from the Swedish Work Environment Fund, the Swedish Cancer Society, and from Ellen, Walter, and Lennart Hessclman's Foundation for Scientific Research. Dr. T. Ax, Prof. B. Holmberg, and Mr. W. Jakobsen are gratefully acknowledged for their valuable assistance. REFERENCES Beaumont Ji. Breslow NE (19X1): Power considerations in epidemiologic studies of vinyl chloride workers. Am J Epidemiol 114:725-734. Breslow NE. Lubin JH. Marek P. Langholz B (1983): Multiplicative models and cohort analysis. J Am Slat Assoc 78:1-12. Bufflcr PA. Wood S. Filler C. Suarez L. Ktlian DJ (1979): Mortality experience of workers in a vinyl chloride monomer production plant. J Occup Med 23:195-203. Chiazze L, Nichols WE. Wong O (1977): Mortality among employees of PVC fabricators. J Occup Mod 19:623-628. Cooper WC (1981): Epidemiologic study of vinyl chloride workers: Mortality through December 31st 1972. Environ Health Perspcet 41:101-106. Doll R (1988); Effects of exposure to vinyl ehloride: an assessment of the evidence. Seand J Work Environ Health 14:61-78. Doll R. Peto J (1985): "Effects on Health of Exposure to Asbestos." London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office. Englander V. Sjoberg A. Hagmar L. Attewcll R. Schiitz A. MdllerT. Skerfving S (1988): Mortality and eancer morbidity in workers exposed to sulphur dioxide in a sulphuric acid plant. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 61:157-162. Hagmar L. BellanderT. Englander V, Ranstam J, Attewell R. Skerfving S (1986): Mortality and cancer morbidity among workers in a chemical factory. Seand J Work Environ Health 12:545-551. International Agency for Research on Cancer (1982): "Monographs on the Evaluation of the Carcino genic Risk of Chemicals to Humans." Vol 29. Lyon: IARC. pp 269-274. Jarvholm B, Hone LG. Thoren K (1988): Respiratory mortality--an underestimated occupational risk'.' Sixth International Symposium--Epidemiology in Occupational Health. Stockholm. Sweden. Au gust 16-18, 1988, Arbcic oeh Hiilsa 16. p 32 (abstract). Maltoni C. Clini C. Vicini F. Masinu A (19841: Two cases of liver angiosarcoma among polyvinyl chloride (PVC) extruders of an Italian factory producing PVC bags and other containers. Am J Ind Med 5:297-302. McMichael AJ (1976) Standardized mortality ratios and the "healthy worker efleet"': Scratching beneath the surface. J Occup Med 18:165-168. Molina G. Holmberg B, Elofsson S, Holmlund L. Moosing R, Westerholm P (1981): Mortality and cancer rates among workers in the Swedish PVC processing industry. Environ Health Perspcet 41:145-151. Ranstam J (1984): Comparisons of standardized mortality ratios. Letter to the editor Seand J Work Environ Health 10:63. Mortality and Cancer at a PVC Processing Plant 565 Socialstyrelsen (1986): "Tobaksvanor i Sverige." Socialstyrelsen Redovisar 1986:9 (in Swedish). Storetvedt Heldaas S. Langard SL. Andersen A (1984): Incidence of cancer among vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride workers. Br J Ind Med 41:25-30. Swaen GMH, Volovics A (1987): Investigating dose-response relations in occupational mortality studies: something to keep in mind. Br J Ind Med 44:642-644. Wagoner JK (1983): Toxicity of vinyl chloride and poly(vinyl chloride): a critical review. Environ Health Perspect 52:61-66. Waxweiler RJ. Stringer W. Wagoner JK, Jones J. Falk H, Carter C (1976): Neoplastic risk among workers exposed to vinyl chloride. Ann NY Acad Sci 271:40-48. Weber H, Reinl W. Greiser E (1981): German investigations on morbidity and mortality of workers exposed to vinyl chloride. Environ Health Perspect 41:95-99. R&S 001896