Document B8zEbBenyao68YY0KzBOBKXM8
JOSEPH E. XELLEB JEBOME H. HECKMAN CHARLES M. MEEHAN VSTLLIAM B. BOBOHESAN1, JB. BOBEBT B. TIEHNAN WAYNE V. BLACK DAVID L. HILL MARTIN W. BEBCOVICI PETEH M. NEMKOV JOSKPII E. HAD LET, JB. CAROLE C. HABBIS PETEH THOMAS SMITH MICHAEL P. MOHHONE TABBY S. SOLOMON JOHN B.DUBECX CHRISTINE A. MEAOHEB
John B. Stohlton, Esquire Hoge/ Fenton/ Jones & Appel P.0. Box 791 Monterey/ California 93942
TELEPHONE 202 457-UOO CABLE ADDBESS 'K ELMAN** WRITERS dxbect DIAL NUMBER
202-457-1116
RECEIVED AY ' 9 1977
Re: SPI-PAC--California; Occupational Carcinogens Control Act of 1976--Proposed Vinyl Chloride Regulations
Dear John:
The purpose of this letter is to acknowledge receipt of your letters dated May 11, and May 13, 1977, and, by means of their copies hereof, to inform those that have been following this matter that the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board has adopted the amend ments to the vinyl chloride standard subject to final approval in Los Angeles on May 26, 1977.
As we understand it, the final, official approval in Los Angeles is a formality. Since the final amendment which you detail in your May 13 letter does not affect the regulation of exposure to vinyl chloride per se, no difficulty should be expected relative to the approval of the final language. Also, the closing of the public hearing means that no more changes may be made unless a hearing to discuss changes is re-noticed and held prior to their adoption. As a result, the end seems very near indeed.
With regard to your May 11, 1977 correspondence, we appreciate receiving and are passing along herewith copies of the letters mailed by the California Department of Health to California employers relative to implementing the Gregorio legislation.
We were also pleased to see that, following up on our letter of April 29, 1977, you wrote to inquire about priorities for inspections. Since the above-referenced
letters from the Department of Health highlight asbestos and vinyl chloride, it would seem reasonable to speculate
SPI-08001
John B. Stohlton, Esquire May 17, 1977 Page Two
that those subject to the newly revised vinyl chloride regulations may well receive no-notice inspections at an early date. If and when you do get the information about inspection priorities, please let us know so that we can pass the word along at the earliest possible time.
Pending any questions, comments or suggestions that you or anyone receiving a copy hereof might have, we await your report that the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board has given final approval to the amended standard.
Cordially yours.
cc (with enclosures) :
Mr. {Lloyd N. Darden
Mr. E. S. Nuspliger Mr. John R. Lawrence
Mr. D. C. Neuchterlein Mr. John T. Barr Ernest K. Bean, Esquire Gary Ford, Esquire
Mr. Ron Martis Mr. Richard D. Savage Ms. Frank Voke Mr. Donald W. White Mr. Robert L. Ferrante Mr. Matthew M. Swetonic Mr. Martin Ryan Haley
SPI-08002
Hoge, Fenton, Jones & Appel, Inc.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW A O. BOX 7l
MONTEREY. CALIFORNIA 93940 373-1241 AREA CODE 400
May 13, 1977
Joseph R. Hadley, Jr., Esquire Keller and Heckman, Suite 1000 1150 - 17th Street, N. W. Washington, D. C. 20036
Re: California Polyvinyl Chloride Standards
Dear Joe:
Confirming our telephone report of May 12, 1977, the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board has tentatively approved the amendments to the vinyl chloride standard.
The Board approved all of the changes that we previously sent you and additionally approved the placement of a new sentence to be inserted at the conclusion of the existing subparagraph (4) . The insertion would read:
"However, the reporting requirements set forth in this subparagraph shall not apply to the use, processing, storage, packaging, or re-packaging of polyvinyl chloride."
We are, of course, very pleased with the insertion of the new language. We had attempted to gain approval for the new language, throughout the entire drafting procedure, but up until the day before the hearing, the staff was un willing to make the insertion because they believed the existing language did not cover polyvinyl chloride. How ever, representatives of Johns-Manville also contacted the staff and managed to convince the staff that some users were likely to be confused by the requirements of the sec tion unless the exemption was clearly set forth.
The staff will now put the section in final form and the matter will be considered at the next meeting of the Standards Board, on May 26, 1977.
/
SPI-08003
Re: California Polyvinyl Chloride Standards
May 13, 1977
The public hearing has been closed and we do not anticipate any further problems with the standard.
Sincerely,
HOGE, FENTON, JONES & APPEL
JBS/h
John B. Stohlton
/
-2 SPI-08004
Hoge. Fenton, Jones & Appel, Inc.
ATTORNEYS AT LAW F. O. BOX 7l
MONTEREY, CALIFORNIA 939-40 373*1241 AREA cooe 408
May 11, 1977
Mr. Joseph R. Hadley, Jr., Esquire KELLER & HECKMAN 1150 - 17th Street NW Washington D. C. 20036
Re: Society of Plastics Industry - California
Dear Joe:
I am enclosing a photocopy of recent letters that were mailed by the California Department of Health to California employers. The letters were of course prompted by Senator Gregorio's bill of last year, SB 1678.
If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to let me know.
Sincerely",
JBS:ep
&.- > John B. Stohlton
Enclosure
SPI-08005
LEW'S L- fCMTON COW1M o. JONES, JR. JOHN W. ACL CHARLES M. MOCK MUl J. TIN DOCSSCHATE CHARLES M. PAGE w. r. ROSCCRANS H. T. MOMKOW
jamcs eoocrt PHILIP YOUMO JOHN L.NCNONT JOHN . STOMCrOM ALDEM C- OAMNER CHARLES R. KELLER WILLIAM JL CVFVIMO
RICHARD . HARRAT RANDALL C. WILLOUCnDY HOWARD R. LLOYD, JR. ROKALO M. WHYTE MICHAEL a HCSWCCNCY Raymond w. haworth OtRALO V. SARROM NQLAM m.KENNEDY THOMAS M. R. OCMVtR MICHAEL M. RRAOSHAW CHARLES . OCAM. JR. SRfCK C. MCINTOSH RONALD f. SCHOLL
ricmaro j. Lorrus,jR.
J. HAMPTON MOOE pr COUNSEL CHARLES R. MCMARRV Of COUNSEL
Hoge, Fenton, Jones & Appel, Inc.
May 9,
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
t*OI MONTEREY-SALINAS HIGHWAY POST OFFICE BOX 781
MONTEREY, CALIFORNIA 93940
1977
373-1241 AREA COOC AOS
Fred Ottoboni Occupational Safety and Health Division California Department of Health
455 Golden Gate Avenue San Francisco, CA. 95814
Ret Poly Vinylchloride Standards
Dear Fred:
I read with great interest Senator Gregorio's recent memorandum concerning the efforts that were being made to implement his bill of last year. I was particularily interested in his request for priorities for inspections. Have priorities now
been established? If they have I would certainly be interested in what the Department considers priorities to be.
Sincerely,
JBStep
JOHN B. STOHLTON
John B. Stohlton
U
SAN LUIS OBISPO OFFICE 1043 Pacific Strict
San LUIS OlISFO* CALIFORNIA 93400 (SOS) 344-3030
,/
SPI-08006
SAN JOSE OFFICE 4 North Sccono Strict San JOSC. California 93113
(400) 207.9301
STATE Of CALIFORNIA--HEALTH ANO WELFARE AGENCY
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
714-744 P STREET Sacramento. California 9J8ti
(415) 843-7900 Ext. 306
fOMUND C. BROWN J . Gowrnor
May 1977
TO: Official and Voluntary Health Agencies and Organizations All Other Interested Parties
FROM: Office of the Director
SUBJECT: Open Letter to California Employers Concerning the Occupational Carcinogens Control Act of 1976
I would like to call your attention to the enclosed "Open Letter to California Employers" which is being mailed to approximately 7,000 employers,whom we believe are potential users of regulated carcinogens within the State of California. That letter outlines the general provisions and definitions of the new Occupational Carcinogens Control Act of 1976 as well as standards, exemptions, reporting, in spections and penalties. The legislation resulting in the Act was carried by Senator Arlen Gregorio, Chairman of the Senate Health and Welfare Committee.
The Act specifically mandates notification of employers and an information and education program to alert them to their reporting responsibilities when using any of the regulated carcinogenic materials. The information and education pro gram will begin once the enclosed letter is mailed to employers and will consist of newspaper coverage, public service announcements, notices in professional journals, trade magazines and the general press, and informational seminars.
Another mass mailing will be made in June to potential users of asbestos and vinyl chloride. The mailing will be followed with media coverage similar to that follow ing this mailing; however, the number of employers and employees to be reached will be considerably greater and we anticipate a very large number of inquiries from employers, employees and the general public.
I feel that this information will be of use in the event that you or your organi zation receive inquiries from staff, other groups or the general public. Copies of the Act (SB 1678) and the carcinogen regulations can be obtained by writing to:
California State Department of Health Occupational Cancer Control Unit 2151 Berkeley Way Berkeley, California 94704
or by calling the above unit at: (415) 843-7900, Ext. 306; or (213) 620-4290.
Enclosure
SPI-08007
Official and Voluntary Health Agencies
and Organizations All Other Interested Parties
-2-
May 1977
DISTRIBUTION:
Local Health Jurisdictions:
Health Officers
Health Education Directors
Environmental Health Directors
Laboratory Directors
Nursing Directors
American Cancer Society, California Division
American Industrial Hygiene Association, Northern and Southern Divisions
California Dental Association
California Environmental Health Association
California Hospital Association
. ..
California Lung Association
California Medical Association
California Nurses Association
California Industrial Nurses Association
California Public Health Association, Northern and Southern Divisions
California State Department of Industrial Relations
California Society for Industrial Medicine
Region IX, National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health
Region IX, Occupational Safety and Health Administration
SPI-08008
state Of California--heaith ano welfare agency
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
714-744 P STREET SACRAMENTO. CALIFORNIA 95814
(415) 843-7900 Ext. 306
AN OPEN LETTER TO CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS
SUBJECT: Occupational Carcinogens Control Act
EDMUND G. SROWN JR., Governor
May 1977
This letter is intended to make you aware of major new legal responsibilities applying to California employers who use certain cancer-causing substances (carcinogens). These new responsibilities apply equally to employers in the private sector, such as commercial firms and companies, and to public employers, such as State agencies, cities, counties and public districts.
The purpose is the prevention of job-induced cancer.
The State's new Occupational Carcinogens Control Act, which took effect on January 1, 1977, requires State government to exercise strong leadership to prevent employees, employers and others from exposure to cancer-causing sub stances in the work place. A detailed list of the currently regulated carcinogens is provided on page 2 of this letter.
This new Act requires the State Department of Health to inspect work places where cancer-causing substances are used. Primary responsibility for enforcing these safety and health standards, as with all other job safety and health standards, rests with the State Division of Industrial Safety in the State Department of Industrial Relations.
Starting July 1, 1977, employers will be subject to increased civil penalties for violations of prescribed standards or orders relating to the use of the reg ulated cancer-causing substances. Penalties will include a $500 fine for failing to report to the State Division of Industrial Safety use of these substances or incidents of over-exposure, a $1,000 fine for a violation of standards or orders involving use of a carcinogen, and a $5,000 fine for.repeated violations.
The Department of Health is specifically directed by the Act to make every effort to learn the identity of existing users of carcinogenic substances, and to notify, inform and educate users about the requirements of the Act. We intend this letter to be one means of notifying, informing and educating.
Uses contemplated by the Act include the manufacture of a carcinogen, industrial uses of a carcinogen or formation of a carcinogen as a result of a chemical reac tion, the sale or transfer of a carcinogen, the storage or disposal of such substances, the use of a carcinogen for research and the transportation of a carcinogen.
SPI-08009
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS
-2-
May 1977
Carcinogen, under the Act, means and includes the following recognized cancercausing substances:
(a) Any of the following substances and any compound, mixture or product containing such substances:
Chemical Name
Common or Trade Name
(1) 2-Acetylaminofluorene (2) 4-Aminodiphenyl (3) Benzidine (and its salts) (4) bis-Chloromethyl ether (5) 3,3-Dichlorobenzidintf
(and its salts)
(6) 4-Dimethylaminoazobenzene
(7) beta-Naphthylamine (8) 4-Nitrobiphenyl (9) N-Nitrosodimethylamine (10) beta-Propiolactone (ID Methyl chloromethyl ether (12) alpha-Naphthylamine
(13) 4,4'-Methylene bis
(2-Chloroaniline)
(14) Ethyleneimine
2-AAF 4-ADP
BCME
DCB Methyl Yellow. 2-NA 4-NBP Dimethylamine Betaprone (TM) CMME 1-NA
MOCA (TM) El
(b) Asbestos, including chrysotile, amosite, crocidolite, tremolite, anthophyllite and actinolite.
(c) Vinyl chloride.
(d) Any other substance for which standards are adopted and in effect due to cancer-causing properties and any compound, mixture or product containing such a substance, except as specifically exempted from such standards.
Specific standards for the safe use of the recognized, cancer-causing substances, listed above in subparagraphs (a),(b) and (c), have been set by the State Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and appear in Title 8, California Administrative Code, as Sections 5208, 5209 and 5210. These standards remain in effect until amended or repealed by the Standards Board.
Additionally, the new Occupational Carcinogens Control Act requires written re ports by employers to the State Division of Industrial Safety on the use of regulated carcinogens and also written reports of any incident which results in the release of a carcinogen into any area where employees may be potentially exposed. At present such reports are required for the 14 substances listed under (a), and for vinyl chloride listed under (c), above. Reporting will be required for asbestos on approximately July 1, after the State Occupational Safety and
SPI-08010
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS
-3-
May 1977
Health Standards Board has completed hearings scheduled in early May. In the future, reporting requirements for additional cancer-causing substances will be adopted by the Board as provided in (d), above.
The reporting process is easy. All an employer must do is send a postcard or letter to the Chief of the Division of Industrial Safety, 4S5 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, California, 94102, with the following information:
The name and address of the location where the carcinogen is used.
The number of employees working with the carcinogen including maintenance personnel.
The manner in which the carcinogen is present; e.g., whether it is manufactured, processed, used, repackaged, released, stored or otherwise handled.
Another feature of the new Act is that after July 1, 1977, inspection fees must be paid by employers (unless this provision of the law is changed) to the Industrial Safety Division according to a fee schedule adopted by^iflkt Division Chief. The fees range from $25 to a maximum of $500, depending on the time required and the number of employees affected. Employers will not be charged for more than one in spection for the same use in any one calendar year, though more than one inspection may be performed. These inspections must follow Cal/OSHA legal procedure, with no advance notice to employers permitted.
The Act requires the State Department of Health to respond to complaints from em ployees regarding potentially unlawful use of the regulated cancer-causing substances in their work places. The Department will give priority to investigation of such complaints.
To help employers achieve compliance with the provisions of the Occupational Carcinogens Control Act, the State Department of Health will provide penalty-free, no-charge consultative services and educational programs. These services will be provided on request by any employer or employee.
Copies of regulations on the regulated carcinogens and information on how to comply with the Occupational Carcinogens Control Act may be obtained by contacting one of the offices listed below:
In Northern California
In Southern California
State Department of Health Occupational Cancer Control Unit 2151 Berkeley Way Berkeley, CA 94704
State Department of Health Occupational Cancer Control Unit 1449 West Temple Street Los Angeles, CA 90026
(415) 843-7900, Ext. 306
(213) 620-4290
/
SPI-08011
CALIFORNIA EMPLOYERS 4- May 1977
Employers who currently have carcinogenic substances on their premises but who choose not to keep them should not hastily dispose of such substances. Employers are required by the State Health and Safety Code to contact the State Department of Health's Hazardous Waste Unit for permission to dispose of these substances. Contact the Unit nearest you:
Headquarters Office
Berkeley Office
Los Angeles Office
744 P Street Sacramento, CA 95814
(916) 322-2337
2151 Berkeley Way Berkeley, CA 94704
(415) 843-7900, Ext. 434
Post Office Box 30327 Terminal Annex Los Angeles, CA 90030
(213) 620-2380
The State Department of Health and the State Department of Industrial Relations provide this information to employers now to alert them to their major legal responsibilities under the .Occupational Carcinogens Control Act and to give max imum lead time for planning to achieve health and safety standards mandated by the law. Both Departments will work cooperatively with employers and employees
to simplify compliance with the Act in the interests of worker safety.
Sincerely,
Jerome A. Lackner, M.D. ''Director of Health
Donald Vial, Director Department of Industrial Relations
SPI-08012
0)S-4M t 4/7?) IOM 0*