Document B5ebENqwDLoG50eqKRaj8RKkE
THE SOCIETY OF THE PLASTICS INDUSTRY OF CAMADA
LA SDCIETi= DS INDUSTRIES DU PLASTIE'JE DU CANADA
1262 DON MILLS ROAD. SUITE 62. DON MILLS. ONTARIO M3B 2W7
TELEPHONE 449-3444
October 7, 1974.
Dr. V. L. Tidey, Acting Director, Occupational Health Branch, Ontario Ministry of Health, 15 Overlea Blvd., Toronto, Ontario.
^ ^a/ <,//} dfct'fArS yews' sts-j/o
Dear Sir:
The Canadian VCM/PVC Industry "Ad Hoc" Committee has reviewed the vinyl chloride data sheet draft number 5 prepared by the Occupational Health Branch, Ontario Ministry of Health.
The Committee has a number of comments and suggestions (attached) for your consideration in preparing the final draft of this data sheet.
The Canadian VCM/PVC Industry "Ad Hoc" Committee was formed on May 31, 1974 and consists of technical representatives of Dow Chemical of Canada Limi ted, Esso Chemical Canada, B. F. Goodrich Canada Limited, and Monsanto Canada Limited who are knowledgeable in the technology of producing and handling of VCM and/or PVC.
This Committee acts under the auspices of The Society of the Plastics Industry (SPI) Canada and is active in the rapid communication of information which will assist the members in the early resolution of the VCM health prob lem, and in liaison with governmental and other agencies concerned with the VCM situation.
The activities of. the "Ad Hoc" Committee do not restrict direct commu nication between the individual companies represented and the Ontario Ministry of Health or with other government agencies.
Our activities are intended to complement such direct communication and to assist the individual companies involved to implement the techniques essen tial to the resolution of the problem.
We believe that it is to the mutual advantage of the Ontario Ministry of Health and to the VCM/PVC industry and to the public that a document such as the subject vinyl chloride data sheet be factually accurate, effective in
con t*
24659001
Dr. V. L. Tidey
2 October 7, 1974.
controlling the health problem, concise and still remain technically feasible.
It is with this belief and in this spirit that we offer the attached suggestions for preparation of the final draft of this document.
Respectfully yours, * VCM/PVC "Ad Hoc" Committee
E. J. Arnold Esso Chemical Canada
Si R. S. Deakin Monsanto Canada Limited
E. R. Evason The Society of the Plastics Industry of Canada
Enel.
D. A. Brooks B. F. Goodrich Canada Limited
Sills Dow Chemical of Canada Limited
o
Q
o
Oj ID
10
Oua
VO OczU?d).
o oz
fc 5o
aKOurel:
sC>J
c X2
>
9 O 3 3 O X CU P o c re V O *o
i) e ft>
>s J2 X ft)
44 O c* o .X X re c H x p 0)
re X
re O H C
X .x4 To3 oc
0 0 3 Cre j Oo
--
O O V) > e -h
rt X UJ C *J o
e> c X *0 H o re 6 XX >s, X o rH 3 O X V) o* u O 3 V) o *o (ft
o X ft) C O. M o3
? X O V) rH Q X C *X
xv X CU o
<y z >
HOP X6
C in E rt .x o V* oo u re > ) l/l X X
> o o X X X X V4 rH xo ep *0X*- r0e 0cu0x ft) O O E
3*0 U 4 p4 +> > O O
oo
cu
re g
ft> o
tH 4) . TJ o
3H
e x c *4 e rex o o x
O XX 44 re x O ptu O o
O O rH x
SC Cw o O 44 *X X
x4
r
x
mi
eA
Xcoo c
EXX 6 o o re e
c -4 c X X
o x *x o ore 5-: o x 44 x h
o o x re
O X *-4 o O *H
3 *0 X X 4* X X O X ft>
XX O *3 XX
o o x o h re
HT3 w J E
X X*x
U
--I
re
X
X o
*3 O o .h
rH e X fi rex
xxx x*h re
C )
rH X re
r4 X X O O <*H
> X O P< e cu
rXH CX O-X O ft) re* c .ore.* o ocux >o re > c x>
re o x x o c re x > **4 0 3 of w CU 3 OX x cu re re
re *roe *roe
re duu zee tj *H *r4 >
o *o CJ5 ft) O C re go x 3 re re .* 3 *3 O O
c re 3
6 6 re X O *X
X ft) X re .x re U h P -H cu re o x M SCP
X re X cu V)
3 ft) re 3 e o > x
re X X M
o o
c ft)
x:
C re oX
re o
c
O -H x re ft) X *H C ft) o ao
mr,XoXo>oHrHie> 3X3 -rif3set) re ,--s >CJ XoocGe
*H3 o uX
rH*
4Oh roe *3rXOXoOXurXH32He
xXi Xo rof2-tt) xXo:
o roe X re
rXr>xCoHHeU 4xoa4
xO orXroao6ee
XO *rO3e
3XXfO2t)
X -XX
X
Ocu re
3o3 ruree rXH
.*oXtcfoG-xti)u
rxfCrXf'ntJtel*j): *r-OogfXH3THt)
rnXe.
re J3GC rXrXXHrc>eee4; UXEO4
3G XHf2t) o tXXrrooet *=XTOrX>e3 xXo: c
*NfOXXrrX333tee) rXe Xc3 rf3OHt) 3 rt rree
*or3oe XoCG) jrPre3
,rnri3et*) 2rl XOc
rXrreee Xre GJ Xr*j
l-uH 43P W3i
X *4
*4 rH
3 re p
3 O
3
re
3 O
o3
re
r4 re x
re r4 *r4
a X -> X
o H ft) c *3
x3
X33
re x
o
re ft) *r4
re X 3
to 3 a-
P> *r4
re i-H
Ho
X x re
re cu U re 2 3 re
rH re *3
44 ft) 4)j
re X X
re 3 O
ft) X rH re
CU re
X x e ft)
3 4> re X
rreeO cu X 3
rH E x o ft)
o X *3 ft)
cX
re 44 re cu
o
re 3 X
<H re o 3
exo
X o o cu
CJ H X re
> x re >
*XrorroGXX3eee
Xreoree Xre rruee Xo> CntreJj Cm >rroX3o-ee4 oG re rXe -X4
xrrXr1eee rrXr3rHHee rXe JX33 x1) rrXCoeeU re3e XfX3eX0tf)t XfEt) 4g4
O*^*X**r-X_--VXcrXorX4X3WoXoc3rc(C3rGMOOHc333eefee)))tUur*, XH-*^M/XXXrrCrXforrrr3OoxOorrOC-VUhCG3xteeeeeeCee>t.)i..Uuj,rr-Jr-Xrrr-xOX<XrorXxf3Or3rro3e3HrhHHC'rXcHxDxHeteeeeel)3t))u)HXaJ*-*^x*-XxGfoxCXrXfoxroroO3Oogr-x33H4tteeeel:))*
x
3P rH
reCU re re *4 o
> X
XE
o X V
rec re x 4)
6
X
X
X re
2i >*4* *
G o
3X *x re
o O 3
> *o
o ^ c
X X X
3X
U. cr
o 0)
X rH
*ep4 X
x -o >o
X
XX
1 ft) I/O -t re i
o re X
,,44 3 QVO
o O ft)
p re
X -o <0 0)
re *3-4 X>
X X x re
re3
G rH
x re x
3 re
3 > x 6 VO X *3
c h u rt
o O X r4 re
Xre
UX 4) **4
re x X o re x
re
x re c
**4 ft) CU O 44
rH 1
ft) > a *o
x x re U) X to
X *4 re
re. * CJ o *" o r4 o cu o --. O o o E cn w 04 r3H r* B. -4 o
6> X X. CJ X o < rH
CS lO rH cs *o H o cs rH ' 1 1 CS o
i*\ CO
&2
o
VO
wX
X
*3
re X
X
3o
X H 3
rec uu U* rt
rH H
o cu
>
-4
ft)
CO X
> H
cX H rt ^4 re H c o ft)
re
o
rH
CU X
00 u
Ui
rXXe
CX
OCtOuOv
CJ `O II mors
vo f-So
OCfN3. rrHo
VrXox0EHX0 lvOO n
OrCCorH--OU1X\ OCaxi))
owrtC0C--uOO"!> OtcXs)
J>Xo33xo 5nk CovPv tcos
rr3He 'JOm rGHrrHe: CJ
XrCyX*O rXrG3QHe O
X a-oX. rucHXo iXo
X
3XX0"XA1)
aoX. rUr-re4e
CSU
{- X
co --EX1*
coXHft 0
Gr>oXe
<3 UXJ
/
`T T tJg /> . *-- i
s
o
CD
in
CD
w
c o y M
fMt
X M MO > C X > O U 44 >4 O *- c u 300 o +j
60 V) MC C -H 73 H -O C MCO oo *-1 CU M
oc U 73 *H
> -4 a. - -a
6C C C- rt w a*x
so * C3 O V) > O trf
rH 0) <- o OO O 3 >4 73 ft, H O V) 44 CO e> o> c 4 N -H
U t*4 6 3 O O 4J
Vi O V <4-4 rt *H <44 0X3 > V* c o O CS J> 6
B p o c
u o 73
e 3
V* 3 o o o
4-4 O c
(A
O
o
73
trt
Uc
>o
ft
4-4
<4-4 H
O 73
C
eo
oo
H
4J oa
H c
w r4
offit
to 40
ou
oo
V
C3 ft
^ to U *H 22
X y C4-H CX
O 4-4 u X3
*o oo >^ H ft V) V) c oo C4 H X 4- *H
(0 V. o O ft
E O v> u H >W 73 iH
X u-i e O *H 4-
ou 4-4 Es C 4-4 > X 73 4-4
X CJ <0 <--< X *H *H *-* 73
to O CO h CO u
e
VJ 3
O *H
XV) 4-4
'-'MU
to C 4-4 >H 4-4
C 4 O
3 to 3 V, O C 4-4 ft
e oo
CS -H rt
4-4 *+4 V
*H 3 -H
a *o c ft /-%
oco
Vi O Z *3 O
(4 U
CX
* o
c o --
H rt
X
H ft 4-4
73 O 3 CN
O *4- -H
4-4 ft Vi
O J <3 ) X f-
Vt
C Vi
C to o rt
X rt -H S 4J (- V
^O<W-HO 73
X 0 0 4-4
to o rt
x <o *o
rt Vi Vi (0
C -W O <
3ft
cr to
C O Vi 4-> 4-4
Vi
to 4-
60 4-> *H >H
to to C G S O m-4 .h E XX OX O
ft !" CJ U
Gm
>Hto O
^.5
<640
E1 4-
(A C r} (A O
CO V)<4
4-1 44
co c
C 3h
Vi u H O 0 O rt *0
ft X,
xHOe C
Vi rt *oooo
4-> 44 E
O
O *rt
O *H o US u
60 O <0 v y
S C <1 3
ox
<J H U Is 10 Vl vi
U 4- DT3 O
>3 0X0X
rt X. X 44
I (H *h , O
l>W ox' 4t G <44 VJ O to
lo
+ (4
4)
ocu
x o rt
rt M
bO O 3 > 3> *rt 4) W U
H C >4 h e *o
6073 to C c
woo
*44
oo
3 tO X ts
rt US73 C
rt U1 X *rt
rt
UX
V) v* V) 6fl-
o
-r4 C
c
K S Vl .H U C -
*3 o o
O e
t-*
ort f>t
3o
uo
4J CJ (S
rvt 3f>t XO
r-i a. O 52
CVi eS ^4j oo u
i Vrti
\ >4 V
'y
^2
nj4 *^
^ V5 ^ V. \\ W.s
\, Vi
$^
\*
$
\<4 C \
\^
*N
V-
>' 5>
I
\ s
^^
Vi
3 (0
ft u H
c
X X *o 4-4 Vl c
3O
e x Vi H 4-1 to
oo
73 Vi O
O ft Vl
4-i 10
o
Vl V> VJ
O *M 3 to
ft o O
to ft C
C 4-1 rt
n to >
Vi
4-i
4J C c
O 5
*3 4-4 O E
cC
3 *H to Vi 4-4 OS
73 H +i
X
V)
Vi Vl
O X
vi e *3 C
to -H C O c
3o : o -H
X v>
Vi V>
rt
rt
Vi 4-4 10 -4 v
to (0 o o V
ft3 o
E 73 X V)
H ft c W
S3
c
o cr to rt
> *H X to Vi
H V Vi
US
V u 3 t(O0 oV4 3 M (A ft V) o U3 fht o ft ft O6 > 3ft
73 V> G M3
2$
\
\3 "3
O' O
u 0,
rt >-h3 1\
v>o '
. 10 X
I -S X 3 73 PG
O
pl
(0 Vl
rt
to
,
> rt to
O
to V. 73
3 to V
ft c
or.
to
o
C *h rt
xo
o o 73
73 rt
to X
rt U U u< -H z o c
H ft.
O Vi
EO
!0
E ^ H IM
Mo rt 3>
vo ft
`V
u
u <3
Vi
ft -7 E rt
XC u o w
Cf
X --t rt
H 60 -- clx 3
o UX
Vi O Vi M O C rt Htr: rt Vi
a
ft u y vi h 3 73 H v> O
C 44 3 Vl p '-M X 73 r. > v2
*4 O o 3 X
Vi `H 3
t-A
c O h w 3 i,' o
--H
73 c 5
to O H C
M Vi CO ft W 0 c
OX
US
3 CX
ft*--4 CS E
o rt
>4
y c *rt C rt X o V o x
y -h -J
h vi v*
<i
rt a c
o rt c rt X C
r x cs
o o S vi O C
X c
XM H
U >H 60 ft 73
o
~4 C w co
rt c rt Q 73
E CS 3 4i X C X(*i Vl rt v> i i
ft Vi
c
'*4 o
o
4-1
O 73 73 3
C *-l O 4-> -- rt '
X -r4
073 C C 'A o rt rt
to B
H Q rt rt 3 c
C
+i Vi rt
Vi
V Irt -A 73 ft w
CC
irj o u co
o y 3 > c c -H
c-*
'HOC X E *H
VI O
rt
vi
fl ro
rt
T
X 3
c
o O
oo x
y O 73 (0 *.i O
C 3 rt rt D
Vi
c rt
OX : X O 73 % v> 3-
73 O
ft -7 0 0 rt U u X -- *rt
X rt
XeU
ft --I
.j <4H
j--
C u
XC
w >. o rt ts 'rt 21 3 O
H
-i ft -rt v. o
> .e
O -H
l_. -)
4-4 to 3 .-4 rt V4 ft --
c -l oX
73 73 O V> to
O to 4J tj- ^
4i '! X rt o <-4 rt 'i H* ft
>
/i
o r:
ft 4-4 y
o
oo
to V
60 rt r o to 3
0 rt ft to c: ft
M <_
rt 7J
f"-
v< u
Vi 'O -rt -^1
3
3 V* ft rt O
*0 O vi C f*.
O (0 l\ Vl 73
ru
to 3 o *-
c
u t*
-4 X -t j u
rt X
3 t-4
J-; o
o
J ft M :7
O
au o y -7
vi *h y
i
M
>: rt .r<
O 3 O .7 rt rt x. v
o > rt
o Ui '4-4 *J rt ft lO ,'4 U ft b 73 ci V^. UU X
73 *3d cr rt rt
G rt
lO US y 3 Vi v
Vi o
to V4 rt y
us c rt M
c rt
73 rt r4
fftt
y to
>- o -i rt
ftCu SM :d U 0 CO > '44
3
e>
\ e or
4i w4 rt ^ H x, y t' O Ji to ^ to <^
e V) H 4J CO V Xo X ft
a H lO Vi Vi -H to Vi
3 73 to C vi
73
O3 yo H >4 y t* sc <
H
Xx pX
Vi art o i-i O 3 X Vi 73 3O
Vl ft C3 rt to o E O vi 3 ft XXX
Vl 44 rt O 73 W
to tO 60 O
XO 3 -H C to o O U to
X e
rt ft
Vi Vi 3O C 73 O H O E Vi VO
rt t/1
O to X rt
to H
o> 03 Vi
/
I _ p *0
V) tO
a G to
C
O >H OCO
X O VI
(AMrt OC
030 u; 44 C
C3 Xo ooo > vi O 73
G 73
>o4 0 0
5
t
SO *o o H
U O M ooo 3* O 73 oc >4 0 0 AOH ax o o -H 44 o
73 >4 o cx
- X _ >4 M-O Om *rH- cM
^c* X\ v
r* ^ i
rt
E
X 73 Vi
Co
rt vi
e rt - c V4
o rt X rt &
to to
to 3 rt 'rt Vi XG
O Vi y *rt
X
> 73 rt o G to
rt to
v< o
o to ft to
aX ft G V* p. rt rt
H* oM
o rt to
o 3 to --4 O
c M y 71
rt 3 3 73 o
o rt (A V, **- y
u to 6
ftX o 2 <3 ft rt r
Si >* 3
71
--
o li 4i
l- u b
j o -rt
-c
y C3
X cU
ifi ZD O
CD in to
V) p 0 00 a. w
g.*
V) *c-40 H
6 r * Cm O --t 0 4- M
u3 3u*>
-H S X 04 o cm o m z
CH Oo M O 44 44 \0 3 OHM
M OO
BWC
O- O *H
(0 *0 O
O 73 wO
O
OO UX 00 a 0 CO
Ow w0
c
0 *-4 -4 X> r-l
VI -X
30> M
4x"4*~ui toe4.
h a w
CO
O S 44
h cm o
C CM
uin
*o0
c
0 0
0 1-4 O JO W -r4 Mi w O CO a. a.
E OO eu 4 w no
Mi O c r4 -O M> C 73
3 o U (9 H W
M <A
3 **-4i <
V> 4> pc h y H
v> <0 O CM u y cm
3 5A
O (0 HO 'H U
3O O* O CM M.
W -4 C f-4 O H g
2O H*
X Q. O Mi g U -> <H C VI CO 3 o *H 73 w *- C CM,
why-^Hoou3 oouE CM >
4O4 O *OH (A <C4 AU
Mt r4 0 O *H M w3
w 2 O0 H >O 0a Mi w H H W
oo
H ^4
c(0 (0
o, w EX O OW o E *h
<-Hwoft
CO X
I t
?
s
0
*
OO
w 43
S (A O Mi O V) Mi O VI m " A > O
3 73 w H O
O 3 ft *-4
CO V)
CO
2 & H -x> VI Vi Mi
44 rt X O 3
XH O W
3 O H VI
O Ml *H
E %n W CO 73 H 0 V) >
CO O
to
*w O
0 0 0 O *r4
W Mi 40 W
Mi U O CO CO
O CO A -*
CM c
0.-H
O *c4
Ow
Mi -X VI vi
(A 0 O O
c zn >
00c 0 44 a X X XI **4 A .-4 Mi
0 73 73 tA CJJ
CO u O O
A ft n c
O
3(
3
0 -4 3
Mi m. y 0 CM
3 O V)
m -0 rt CM-O
O O > VI C
CM v*
c0
X0
O -4 V) rt *
l> O
V)
O VI C C **4
- r-i O O (A
O Mi CM O
O -A
O M.
Mi 3 l w jQ
40 3
X
O O VI y 44
OH * O <0
O w3
H
cO
V) O
OS C4MO
O Mt O OUg
5
<
O (A
Mi (0 to O VI H
f4 M. O Mi 0 CA
^3
O Mi H
O y O Ml
w 0 jc Mi
3 *3 Mi U OOOO
W>
O
Mi -H W
O '"I cO (A
CM u 3
0 a> H
V)
M A M. *0 Mi MOO 0
X w hi ^4 44 X Mi H w *0 ^4 O Mi
c O CM O
O 3 O g
ua
UX
0 0 44
Mi O O O
Mi O CM
3 Mi O
O (A O A 44
O OX
O
*H tJ V)
-D 3 3 V)
VI X Mi
(0 r4
O
JO
r-4 >--I
A
Z\ M n VI O
O H Li X > li VI H O
UJ 3 X < >
H
C X O *** VI JU <x Z1 H
Mi O H OW 3 CM H w Mi V) 0
WWO to Mi >n
3 3X o CM 3 VI K4 O
O*
-4 CM 73
3 OX
VI W 3
.M U 2
O O Mi
to a 0
B
r- Ox
0 73 M4
0 eH
3
A
0 M -H
00
0
44 (A
44 H U
0 C A 73 O r* ci
0 H
*H
u VI
W
3 CA
V 73CO O
Mi 2 >
O O X. E
cm 5- -h
OO
C3
O CJ O 'J r--1 -r-l
Ml u% 73 3 y /> Mi y
H WOO. (A O M C f4 r. 0 0
<y -m co
H --< 0 CO *-4 fj r' ^ -r,
HX U
1
O X*t3
O g3 O H H 73 73
w *-
0
y Mi ai
0330
W OX O CO V
Mi E CM *r4 M O
OX X
3W W -M O H U) t) J
3 *H O W
X -*3 0
A H Jl U Cj r-4 Ol
C Cl .H -H 0 y Mi
h X 3 A
W 73 a
(0 44
.-4
CM O
3 CM 3
U X CM
O Mi
G
O Ml O C O
VI *- c.
O *4
r^
. 44 uo V4
4J -H V
*-> O -r4 y^
-1 3 y *1 m. c:
O 44
0 44 O DO rj 73 ( C. O y > '<-> M< o - O
CM O
*h
Tj y
y 0 y X r* r* u
w y . 3 3 SO
Mi fl -4 t; Mi
O Mi 'V O LU 03 ^ 3 44
O P
4>
U
3
73
4> 73 H
(A O 3
O O HO
O3
M>
c c
H 0 M
y W3
30
O 7J y
73 M 73 y O r4 r4 >
u 4> Mi 3A
O 3 Mi y0
O o r4
UJ (A M> 73
C-
0 (A
3C
cX
AO
jS 3
IU CM u
V) O 73
'0
w Mi
(A y
0 O C V)
O>
OO
U3
Mi 4)
f4 r4
03
3S
- y
V 3
O
VI A
Mi y
{-
'*
O
O to a H lA
*4
CM X O r-4
r-t
O -4 OC
30 Mi M
y3 A 44
f- (U
y A
0
X u;
Oi X O
0 y. O <A fr--
Ml O
CC ;j
CM LU H
CM
/
va oo
cn
in. r'
to
G
>
>o
fOrtt
fot
(4
ui
g."
2>
" G^
ft X
cn > fa
4 O fa V) kft 3G o* o o 73 fa < ft
CO
C >
Vfa *Gr9t
Vi> Nrf
l-'i s'
l
i ffat OE
4.
c fOt*
X
ft o
N. \
* rfa
*
to Wl *9 fa G
X
O
. ffraat XV
*fHt-
>I fOa r10t *CH
ft
ii *V9 > foa
I .fa O
h y
i>!
apsrt*,
fa
*efa
->H
I fa S foa
s*fa O
I:
w
>
<m
ffoaa
i o o ft
5! -A
>6.
I
vS, J-F
a *
^V \i *
00 Ok
e OOP. > fa ft fa fa <0 o
.O fa >fa
fa fa to
Offat frOfaat *ooo9 *fa X VI P.O ft rt OS fa U
^ *o >
fa G (fa O H O
fOfat
5 73 G 0* a* 3
fa (0
faft *fa
<0
<'ofa HrtOfxa 73
3CL* C fa o C OOft Crt w5
751 e
C *H O >fa G wfi
o
C 0e6
G -fa
G ft
fa fa
GO fa *fa fa
2 w
O
>
fOfaa
Gffaa .fafaa *avfai.
3
O"fa fa
3" XJ
n
i
x*
\
V.
X
x
*
\N
*$
\*
X
* $$
VI X vl
u
c rt
O
O
C6 1 fa
c
34
fa O >H
fa
G fa
1c
3 -fa
73
X
G fa
.O
G fa
> rt fa
G
73 (fa
X 06 O
(0
H (0
fa ft
uo
fa
fa 3 fa
5 C fa
H
fa
G fa
rt fa
fa
fa
0
fa H rH in 73
fa .fa
<fa O
ft o
H G
fa
o a 3e G
TJ 73 rt
eo
G fa
O ft pH
, ft n
3
O
Xc
o
G C3 o
fa O
06 G
>s
C" fa
H fa O 73 G g
fa X
O fa
X *fa
73 tj
G
C 73 fa fa fa a.
06 fa
fa
C ft G
G (0 >
ft
73
V)
o 10 C 3 fa
>GG
O -fa
ft fa
>
ft rt
fa
fa 73 cl o
O 73 fa
fa --<
fa
G fa
O G 'fa
o
fa fa u (fa fa 3
ft* *fa*
fa ft
fa > fa fa
--< fa O ft
fa U7 G ft. * to
ft fa io
O rt G O
o rt
0
V)
V) 3 fa fa G
fa O
G >H
3G
ft G fa
> ft
o
3
fa o
3
3 ft. V>
O (0
fa fa
ft
fa rt
o fa rt
fa
O fa G fa
ft O X 3
C (O
fa
a Ifa rt fa O
GOO
o
* 73
fa o O fa O fa fa .fa
73 O G (fa >-4
G
><
E fa G fa
0 0.3
e a*
10 G
's
ft ft
G
fa
to
X (A fa
fa -- C G 6 X .fa
G (O ft * to rt
fa
*fa
fa <3
X H
fa G 3
*-i
fa fa -* G
*-H 3
fa o
o G A O fa
V) >fa fa
c ft E
G ft
fa ft r- fa
OGO
o
<0
fa fa
0 fa G cj fa
fa e fa c fa fa .fa fa ft
rt o c
3
3 o*-h (fa -O
fa C - C fa
o G
O
2 /l <0 (O G G E O .fa fa 10 G rfa G GOG rt
G
G (6
00 cr 73 < G
G fa
oS
O
fa fa *fa fa o to ft
fa
V)
yG
O
O fa O fa
73 3
fa
to --
rt fa
o
06 G
U o
a 7J fa
rt
w n fa O*
P OO (A
fa 3 ft* O to
O G fa
G 73 rt *-H G fa fa O
(0 .fa fa rt
fa H G CW o X ft
fa 3
G rt to ft GG
fa rt
73 o
06 fa y> c
m a. ft 3
O fa fa 06
y 0 io
fa tfa >
C fa
u u*
fa 2 fa 73
u X fa G
fa o
ft c
G ft fa
3 O rt
rt rt
fa fa o fa A O G fa fa fa <n tO .fa
G fa
fa 73 ft
O
C -fa
v> 3
fa G
(fa fa
c --*
73
rt o to .fa
GC
to G
fa
*-i
<7
O fa
ft O fa
O fa --t (fa 3
C 2 fa
O O O ft fa
V)
G G fa (M (fa C6 o n -fa O fa
G
O -fa fa
c: 3
u
> e L> d
O -H X fa
O ft.
u
fa o e
fa fa
4 to
fa fa G 73 i G X fa --1 o fa
oC g fa
a 73 fa O 73
o O 73 (fa G w O> cG
X) 00 c (J
o u
C3 rt
ft fa G ZA H fa
rt '-i fa rt fa G -H J-. -fa > O fa G G
X to fa 73
fa G *9 3 -fa C (fa fa G fa
ft rt 3 .fa
C CO rt c rt G -fa u
ft fa o
fa * -fa g Goe
fa -fa r? ^ 3 *3
ft rt G 3 --*
X O ft o *< C > to O G to
fa o 73 0*
X V
73 oG
in
G o o
a. H fa
yC
3 -fa C" > oo
X 0 fa y fa fa fa fa G fa o fa
fa C (0 ft fa ft
C fa G X
fa rt (0
o _< a
fa ft o O fa
o
n3 M c O^
fa o ft G
0.1 O
fa 06 ft GC
o ft (fa fa
7?
Si
>
73 fa < 0*
c (A fa
s
uu fa 2 C-. G
O O ft Zrl ft* fa
GG < ft *fa
CG -4 a ft
3 .H X c ft fa G .fa
E -fa to 114 73 -
oe fa
fa
C4 0* o
in
<3 N 00 Ok
.,
OH H --4
rt
o
9
f \
I.
i t i
CD in i9
oo
c *P 4ft H
41 64 *o X * c p rt
X c H 64 c
rt rt xx d OP >_ o
<r. X *M O 64
rt >
3 44
3O
rt X VI 64 O
uc uoo
64 H
64 O v> &0
rt rt rtC
v 64
c M
64
*4 H
a>
P Vi
X
H 64
c
X 3 <D H
O X X rt
V> 64 O
P G
Vi
H o
e sO rt 64 O cX rt -
>s
H ri
l
O
rt O- O Vt CO U
a> c c rt U oko 60 k ]f
rt o
4> X M vt (ft
mH
rt rt 64
64 X
G X 64 o 64 irt
rt o
C6 k
c v> o
rt 3 4C
uO a
uco
rt o
u o
o o
rrtt
<4 3rt
o rt HG
rt H * 64
rt 3
o
rt <-/
c
rt'O o
rt4)
X
3
64
c
f*i s
-- rt E cs
Vi rt
V) e o o Vi
Vi (J
U o rrt
H rt 3 o
64 o X 64
O o Vi CA C9
64 X o Vi G rt
V) O (ft -o
o o 2c G
1
% o (ft
rt o. rt rrt
3 G Vt
rt
-o o (A *rt
rt o 64 64
64 c G C
rt c rl rt X rt --i (ft
64 0 CV (A
G 64
CO
M O cx
Vi li rt 3 64 64
a* > (ft 6>
X rt 3
Vi 3 X
V) O o
O V. X
V)
64
OX
'X * 64 rt
o 64 G
X rt (A
X (ft rt
(A
rt 3 C
rt(ft X X Vi rt O 64 3 C .rt.
44
Vrt
X
64 rt
3 44 (ft
o 46 4rt 3
X O 64 X O'
O (A *H
r3I
Vi
X rt 64 x
(A rt
*
3 Vi rt 64
O irt 46 X
Dc rt o
rt rto o 64 64 -rt
64 *-4
o <64
OX Vi G 5
MX
P
rt
GO* -* X bO
rt 3 C *4 rt 3 G PX O
O O P 44
2 f-i OO ____ O (A
MU U 3
O>
O'
3 * *2 > u O rt "H
P.33 Po xO
cj -* <o
> ifl P X cu o o rt
P
O 44 CU (ft
3 P G G rt O
X(4 --VI5 >) -H- O3
o > o rt
X P O
a ~i
-3 P
(A, VI 6> p4
K OG- iCdJ(.Prt 66 3p- ,;.'h 3a* -C.
O 44
P*rt >< O
P
oPo 'wUlp
Sut$* yiIco
oo
- --*
4* 2^
44 P O P
s\
aa
\ ^.
d v
\
f* X
2 V1
3X
oo u *\
G 46 ' .rt '
\ >J
X
(A
X * \\
V o. *'3
H v\
P O ^ \ .
3 33 l
s<
\. H
UrJt .Go -J\T, *> * \
(A 64
o 46
O X 40
o
X Vi
ift
rt -rt
64 G 01 64 3
64 ,o
X
X
O .rt
c rt
X o 44
0
rt to
p
64 *3
rt 3
O frt
o
46
rt <a
Vi
rt
c
3 o Vt 6 k k
kX
rt 0<
rt O
k Vi (A o o O P k k
U -
rt rt 4
p ^4
O3
46 O
3
O.
CJ rt
64 3
o O k
O Cl H ^ G 3 -
G
G O' CO
O
PX
X -H
rt P
rt
Vi ft
Oc
o k rt Vt
(ft (ft
O (A
rt
X
C rt
O v rt
-rt rt X P *rt
o rt rt
3
> vi rt
X rt X (ft X
~o X
rt Vi Vi
V. O
o
p P rt co
3 rt
ift
64 o rt
Vi *rt
V< Vi T3 o
o
2 G 4<
rt P (A
rt G 64
o rt rt
0. O C *-6
G X frt
rt o
>O
O 3 ift C 3 o
46 n
rt O
O (ft
O 3 04
rt rtc u
OO 46 (rt
o o 46 OiX
O X
V( C X
4-> ' P
P 3 *0 G
B.S
(A rt
CO 64
3
op
44 X 3
T3 P
rt 3
ei o X G rt u X
o
ok
rt
O
-(
64
(ft -rt (ft
> Vi 64
44
a k rt
X k
k
X
rt 3
rt Vi *rt
a. O
o -o
P rt -X
3 (A
3 3 Vi
(A H k
-o k vi
3 Cft 44
ox >
o X c*
64 OO
rt y CO G
rt
oO
cr 6
p rt
rt rt p rtf C -rt p
oP *
oX
X o x * > rt
rt k o
k
rt
p rt 3
46 .-i
G
X XJ
O
v> o c
oO
o p G
3O
O 6( 64
rt
rt M rt
o 3 CO
k
rt P (ft
CO
o C U* X o O Vi
(A X
6 G X VI
P3
cX
c rt
H rt
X
(ft rt
(A rt P
64 rt E *
(ft o 3
1ft
k G
'ft O 44
o -o
--i o
X
c o . O'
a
rt rt P
P cox
rt (A rt x
cG
Vi *. rt
X
k
*4
3
G (ft
P
rt rt
kU
3 > > k k >6 O k C. (ft -rt
rt X G 3
u
> 00
rt
O UH
p
rt X O
1-4 P rt rt
3 *o
3G
V) rt rt
a
o
GP
H O
3
o 64
O G -rt X -rt
rtG- O X
o
O
^6 X
Ok X 64 O
k .rt k *C5
.-i (ft o rt o <
CO 64 c -rt
(ft rt do
ft 44 X k Si o cJ
k rt G O
VI <6* O
K "
46 (ft
CO
P c
rt 6>
u
rt
X -6
w*o c -rt 3
a rt k 6- $4 u Vi
X 3
rt 3
rt (ft X
O ;s &o vi
rJ
X- G k k X-rt 3 -h x;
o
a. 46 >
kOkC
O rt
66 ;o
rt O T)
O rt rt o
-o rt
O
10 k G
u. 1 rt
X rt
u> X X
CU rt
o rt < rt
(M a* ^6
K
m-4
rt
r~~\ rt
. X *H *rt .U PP
x p o
rt
rt rt -H
rt o r-6
W -(
X3 2 U
y-- X s_O_/ *4
x d C<H rt rt P a* P rt IA 3O O' U X
k X Pirrtt
(A P 4> 6X rt G , p 44 61 Cl O O2 pP X a. p --i x pVI rt C rt OOG H "W -H 13 W X (A 33
UG Tj U fti
G rJ rt 3 (A
V) )4
P O <H OT3 U C -r6
cu 3 w
U) >> rt XX
-6 P-1 Hp
C *H < o rt i .rt p *rt <
P p. o P
3 '41
3 X. . X P CX h d.H p,
y
Clancy:
This is some correspondence which Marv got from Dave Brooks when Dave was in the office on 10-11. It looked like something you might like to see, too, 4o I made you a copy.
Id