Document 8Vx6yJRZDBywQEz6zLwrjBg2a
FILE NAME Brakes BRK
DATE 1935 Jan 4
DOC BRK004
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Public Health Report - Effects of the Inhalation of Asbestos Dust on the Lungs of Asbestos Workers
Medical lel
ae]
SIGH
l we ch lch
lch
-
PUBLIC HEALTH REPORTS
VOL. 50
JANUARY 1935 1935
NO. 1
EFFECTS OF THE
THE LUNGISNHAASBESLTOSAATSIBOENSTASBOESTOSS WORKERS DUST ON
WORKERS
;
Preliminary Preliminary Study
By A. J. LANZA Assistant
ant Medical
Medical FEHNEL Chemist ,
Insurance Co. Director and WILLIAM WILLIAM FEHNEL ChemiztM,etMreotproolpiotlaintanLiLfifee
INTRODUCTION
Metropolitan In 1929 the
officials
asbestos industry United United
were
representing desirous of
the
asbestos asbestos asbestos
dust
States
was occupa-
by
tional hazard in establishments establishments so what
who
of this
their should to prevent
the nature nature
hazard and several articles articles
prevent or control it medical
had appeared appeared English medical medical
coniosis had been quite uninformed
appeared occupational disease disease
uninformed existence existence any itself
uninformed of reference reference lungs
occupational silica
with reference
lungs has
The been appreciated appreciated and great deal str and
long been applied problem problem
certain other other
the been industries in Great
the metal m st
Britain , the United
British Do-
minions and the dust expressed
other
countries
countries
of
nature the
expressed in term silicosis
tuberculosis
effects silica
resultant extraor- extraor-
dust
predisposition predisposition predisposition to
tuberculosis is well known known
These effects been pulmonary tuberculosis inhalation inhalation con-
associated taining taining silica in varying
effects upon upon pul-
monary monary tissue of
amounts combined silica silicates silicates
^'
still fertile
dusts investigation evidence accumulating
are
ae: Still certain certain thesefielddustfs or investigation pathological
accumulating accumulating that
produce distinct aA true silicosis silicosis asbestosis asbestosis pathological pathological is pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis
true The
been applied the pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis
caused caused asbestos commerce commerce hydrated hydrated magnesium
ically ically asbestos primarily of silica silica combined
magnesium
consisting consisting
combined combined silica 44.1
primarily primarily water 12.9
percent mag-
nesia percent in small
a percent ferrous variety
Nesia nickel
quantities This commercial
are present water 12.9
commercial variety
nickel are 101954-35--1 101954-35- 1 101954-35--1
1 while ferrous iron and
quantities. This
101954 _35_
commercig] variety of
(1)
January 4, 1935
2
January most
January one of the cfooumrmoenncoluynte2 red encountered encountered is designated as chrysotile and
asbestos most commonly commonly
designated chrysotile chrysotile and it
varieties
one the four varieties varieties
usually occurs
of mineral mineral (and
presumably asbes-
seams mind that silicosis and and presumably presumably
presumably asbes- asbes- 25
hazard there does does
there
appear to present clear true cut
which unescapable unescapable communities with
silicosis
such hard rock mining mining
may true silicosis some the the
asbestos plants plants are
communities communities may may typical effects a
recent origin for would
a
not
silicate dust dust to become become manifest
apply the the
manifest plants
fabricating only industry dust on the
are Data the fabricating
plants
are included in this study
designated designated
report as plants A B C D and E.
the
This
is preliminary preliminary
more extensive study of the asbestos
report
and industry a
DUST STUDIES
Apparatus Apparatus methods methods sampling Both
the Apparatus precipitator precipitator were
the impinger samples samples
for the electric electric
used for the collection of air
for
Both
dusts
breathing levels
these
levels
and
close proximity
to
the
workmen
forms apparatus apparatus adapted for this
workmen
taking taking the
the solution some c some
might present present The The j driven rotary pump and and t]
means of resistance resitance type type of
measuring measuring measuring pressure pressure .
dust collected from volum volum volum
electric precipitator precipitator is de:
used for recovering recovering di
electrifying depends on electrifying
through through clectrostatic clectrostatic fic
upon sheet sheet of celluloid operating
draw of transformer transformer transformer
alternating Air draw draw dray
fan run by motor motor the the
meter
.
Samples dust brushed chemical from | were secured hygiene chemical laborator ap
accordi industrial industrial made
a counts were Bureau Mines
States Bureau Particles size 1 Service Particles counted in size i diameter analyses were
Chemical accepted stand :
according plant plant studied stand:
the were counted counted has (A)
silica particles particles exceeding mic mic be
silica meter thousand thousand mic
diameter diameter enter the lung tissu
usually considered considered when when : appeared from from some p
asbestos particles much larger larger in p
decided count particles and in
microns and under under foot : Total particles particles cubic
in milligrams were obtained obtained ;
dust counts and correspond
correspond not included in the
and
Table Table shows by plants
milli minimum minimum dust dust counts plant a
Although counts plant plant a
Samples microphotographcsollected both impinger impinger and a
microphtographs
slide projector enlarged enlarged particles
particles measu th
measurement ) was easy calculate
logarithmic logarithmic probability paper logarithms
of en!
plotted ordinates against
logarithms occi
the probability probability occi th
plotted Plotted
Probability paper, the logarithms of
as ordinates against the
Probability of occ.
2
2 ules
js
designated
as
chrysotile
and
of the designated designated chrysotile chrysotile
and
of dust included included
zht might the
fourth variable variable
variations susceptibility susceptibility
ght the assumed that
those
in os ght rence asbestosis
asbestosis North America
communities with true
0communities communities communities It
silicosis some of
recent recent origin
be some effects of
for typical
ne manifest but this
apply apply to
plants he fabricating fabricating
wing service
Metropolitan Insurance
Metropolitan Metropolitan period period
1931, wing investigation during
litions 1931 which included mines and mills Canada
alonlgitions asbestos Seaboard Seaboard in
United
ons of of
asbestos workers including including
austaust systems designed eliminate asbestos
$ g plants only are included included
ort as plants plants plants A B D and this study
oreort
E. This This
extensive study study the asbestos
DUST DUST STUDIES *
3 of sampling Both
2) were were were used
the impinger samples
levels levels levels and the collection collection workmen
Oparatus pparatus pparatcusloadaptsed aedapteprdoximity proximity work
set up set and adjusted
this taking taking
level,
adjusted efficient efficient .
level
ca ovn eredd extremely container the dust the
then
surface
aspirating aliquid in container
surface covered covered containing aliquid
Ued
lled water containing
percent alcohol
containing percent to
pie
ch
cally driven a resistance resistance
resistance of flow meter with an sample represents represents
ter dust collected from
sample air
volume volume 100 cubic Cottrell Cottrell precipitator
representg
precipitator
Samples of dust brushed analysis
also were secured for
analysis All samples were shipped shipped
dtuhsetindustrial hygienelabaocrcatoorrdy it nghtoethe Metropolitan Metropolitan Co. thtehteo
counts were Bureau
methods Public Health the
United States Particles in Mines the United States greatest
Service were
counted insisizzee up 360 microns in greatest ggrreateestattehste up to 360 and
diameter Chemical analyses
combined combined silica
Chemical the accepted standard standard method of microns
and under
usually are considered considered when when determining published
ii t t appeared appeared some the
articles 4 English that
published asbestos particles much larger larger
found lung was was
make
decided count all particles and
differential
counts
all
those
10 microns microns under under
make were differential in lung weight it
10 Total particles
foot and corresponding
the
particles
corresponding weight of the
dust milligrams
milligrams were corresponding corresponding weights
found the weights weights
Ain plotted ordinates against
plotted easy to calculate the
logarithms Probability Paper, the
of original Particle size (5), By the
the function to be
use of Hazen s(6)
measureg (in this case
microns) are
vanuary 4, 1938 4
all and in the other plants are 4
January as in no
Particles, direct
sample 4 were the
comparison ig
January and plants plants for all
comparison comparison comparison 19
particles direct direct comparison
no possible
sample taken percent
than than 94 percent peo rcent f whthoe wlheole Particles per cubie foot
and minimum
air
Plant D
Plant E
Department
E
ee
ber Million
ber of
Num- Milion Million
ber of Million
Milion sam-
parti-
| ples ples cles
| per per
cubic cubic
Million
parti-
cles per
cubic
foot of
air
Preparation...
foot
Hegrene
Ring tra
aoe
Preparation
wong)
spin ing frame
Ring spinning
Mule spinning
Mule
.
Twisting band
Weaving Weaving
;
162 -43 - oa e a8 ir
34-434 32-151
J
-82
~82 -76
515-10
512-10 7
367 106-1934
13-442
percent asbestos be higher
principally In
asbestos
correct
but
other
consisting
of
of mately the insulating
material consisting consisting asbestos is but cotton
lining In the total material udsepare tmentd s departments of molded
percent percent
and clutch
division of plant
comprises about 25 percent of
material material material The actausabelstexoposurse expcoompsriuserse adsubsetstos dust therefore isthceontsoitda-l
counts in table 1
CONDITIONS CONDITIONS THE
PLANTS
The processes in these
mills in The
plants were very similar
processes
to those preparation
illustration of mills mills in general
illustration process process the
room
plant plant
For detailed length
preparation room
the
here received in
Asbestos Asbestos received shoveled
These These emptied for about minutes minutes
in the asbestos asbestos crush
into pug mills and run about asbestos
in order into and open the From there
asbestos
trucks wheeled wheeled
either horizontal horizontal
hoppers passing textile mills
Pr e
trucks which which which are
into trucks these in sa in the
fed discharged from from thesaol
shaking shaking screen where where
suction hood blown into a into
a
fibers fibers falling through the th,
making making asbestos asbestos cement
cotton received received
cement
bales in bale
openers discharged discharged discharged
vertical and horizontal
opener j)
opener cotton cotton the waste mate
opene:
As needed
a mate
these materials mixture
proportion proportion proportion through through
materials passed passed
mixture
discharged from picker tbhyrough a ;
material then taken
m it is
Two the by a m
the card card system
conveyor
while th of thy
which conveys the
device which the
a th:
room grades material
two the
two grades
material the sa two Ss!
with an spray 1 the
equipped entrap small small asbesto g,
cotton fiber throughout throughout theasbp esto J
weaving cotton Incidentally Incidentally appa the
p
amount material is s
this point but the
appa
diminished diminished to
time is s.
than percent percent percent time
mineral mineral was used eficaious
apparently not efficacious
efficacious
efficacious attemp in the
du ustsed was there Carding machin as
exhausting exhausting humidifying Carding
there was
ventilat ventilat
humidifying plant depended depended
natural hun
equipped machines were equipped plant cardid n uhusn
relative spinning percent percent One One plant C
humidity department department and also the humidity humidity 76 percen C
Weaving room of plant A,
4
re for all particles direct comparison is
taken were the number of particles 10 an 94 percent of the whole
num dust counts in million particles
by plant and department
per cubic foot
Plant B
Plant C
Plant D
Plant E
J
| Num- Million Ser of cles parti-
sam-
ples taken taken
Num- Million
ber of
|| sam-
particles per
ples taken
cubic foot of
air
Num-
| Num-
ber of
cles | sam-
Million particles per
ber of
sam-
ples
| { ples
cubic| cubic taken
fo t | foot of air
cubic foot of
air
Million
parti-
cles per
cubic
foot of
air
13-1 weeeee
Me 4
8 334-10
334 fT
3
6-7
10-1934
pepe
2 16-34 16-34
* Includes broad loom weaving
preparation room is
he case in the
practically all due to
other departments In the
aving rooms asbestos
ised
comprises about 25 On special jobs the
ut in general the figure
percentage of
material
quoted is approxi-
ents of consisting principally of cotton
plant A asbestos is but 5
In the molded
percent
lining and clutch
os comprises about 25
percent of the total
osure
d in
to
asbestos
dust
therefore
is
consid-
the dust counts in table 1
TIONS IN THE PLANTS
lants were very similar to those in
ration the process in the
cotton
at length
preparation room /
ags These are emptied upon the floor
to pug mills and run for
and
n the fibers
about 5 minutes From there the
wheeled to
asbestos is
hoppers with either horizontal
to those used in textile mills After
naterial is discharged into trucks passing
first
Waste
run through a garnet machine and
Ne 5 January 4 1935
dumped discharged into trucks which are wheeled to
material is fed into these in the
the openers and the
After
being
discharged
from
same manner as is the
the new material
vibrating or shaking
opener the material is put onto a
a suction hood and screen where the long fibers are picked off by
blown into a bin to be used
The short fibers falling through the
again in textiles
used in making an asbestos cement screen are either sold as such or
The cotton is received in
vertical openers It is
bales opened and also run through
the vertical and horizodnitsaclharged into trucks The filled trucks from
fiber the cotton or the
openers containing either the asbestos
bins
waste material are taken to
As needed these materials
separate storage
are weighed and
onto the
floor in proportion to the mixture desired and the
materials are then passed through a mixing picker is discharged from the picker it is
resulting mixed
As this mixture
The material is then taken by a mecshparnaiyceadl with a light mineral oil
bin in the card room Two of these
conveyor to the storage
this conveyor
mixing pickers discharge onto
system while a third machine is
suction device which
equipped with a
conveys the material to a
card room The object of the two
storage bin in the
of two grades of material
systems is to facilitate the handling
not equipped with
at the same time The third machine is
an oil spray The object of the oil
marily to entrap the small asbestos fibers
spray is pri-
in the cotton fiber
and hold them enmeshed
weaving
throughout the processes of
Incidentally it is
carding spinning and
amount of dust The
apparent that it also diminishes the
oil at this
material is saturated with about 4 percent of
point ; but by the time it reaches the
diminished to less than 1
looms the oil had
percent
exhausting While mineral oil was used in the
apparently was not
preparation room of plant C it
as efficacious as in plant B. In plant E oil
not used nor was there
was
of dust
any attempt at humidification or
any system
there was a
Carding machines were fed by hand In plant A
humidifying plant B depended
ventilating and heating system while
on natural humidity In plant E the
machines were equipped with a exhaust
carding
efficiently used In plant C
system but it was not
which was equipped with
carding was done in 2 buildings 1 of
an
buildings conditioning Two the machines had exhaust equipment system and in both
plants B and C had artificial
spinning rooms In the former the humidity installations in their
humidity 78 percent One
temperature was 76 F. relative
the twisting department plant C had a humidification system in and also in the weaving department where
the relative humidity was 76 percent with
69 F. as
a bulb temperature of
compared with a relative humidity of 44 percent in the
weaving room of plant A.
January 4, 1935
6
would 1935 from plant E, it 6
January except in the
appear that the dust hazard was
appear that dust
not
hazard hazard
Aside from plant
was not The
excessive the preparation appear rooms plants and and The The the
dust counts interesting interestpirnegparation considered considered light of the
permissible permissible standard
when established established by the
standard Service granite namely about million
United
million particles
States Public Health Service
10 microns
foot However
particles
microns and per
not justified justified
available information suggests that asbes-
assuming that because available clinically silicosis of
the threshold threshold of -
DUST CONTROL
humidification exhausts Various
measures, such DUST CONTROL
Various Various measures such such
local exhausts
humidification Various Various reduce dust Nevertheless Nevertheles Nevertheles
humidification and local they they
tended only partly successful
Nevertheless was evident dustiness in
were
final
If it expected properly constructed
reliance reliance must must upon
exhaust
properly
these equipment equipment In equipment equipment equipment
plant C one department
experimental installa-
department experimental experimental
spite of
equipment on
tion basis comparative comparative some faults the dust 50 percent percent
the and
counts reduced the dust
with further further alterations will
percent effective
this such
probably satisfactory is neither neither
practicable
practicable
practicable
reduction
nor
seemed
quite
install
such
economically economically desirable desirable
equipment as
normal defensive mechanism
application when body exposed exposed
defense mechanism mechanism breaks
The
equipment to textile machinery involves
is considerable considerable considerable considerable
especially where the construction of the
is such thatdifificsulty pdoisfsfiibclueltey xespheciallay aupsptly down suction to the loploamnst
It desirable to install then apparatus in any plant on an ex-
perimental perimental basis
check its efficiency by dust
first and saving saving needless
counts
expenditure of money
PHYSICAL
EXAMINATIONS
X ray films were made of
in
ray
films
plants
in
persons
United
108
men
18
women
were
in asbestos
States All but five of these
examination The cases
less
at given physical among those
were selected more employ- employ-
at at random
having more than than years early
industry
of ment
. It was obvious that the
diagnosis
asbestosis must rest to large extent
pictures diagnosis
extent clinical pictures symptoms of
experienced experienced field . field.
minor nature and was ge was ge
films were read conservative conservative
examination age of th of {]
only when there no was no
guided their their experience experience
moconioses films classed as a:
subdivided doubtful and anc
the individuals classed a
asbestosis Particular Particular at absence indications indications indications of tub:
reviewers films films were felt in acc
silicosis silicosis mind was felt possi felt :
devoted ascertaining
infection . possi disposes tuberculous tuberculous
were cases of asbestosis first
were ,
second stage definite lung lung st
examination examination
pneumo warrant diagnosis second stage
lung
stage
symptoms second
symp , pathology also individuals
were these practicable practicable make
symp
an aci
was not disability disability any in an.
extensive pulmonary pulmonary involveme involveme in
extensive
they would total such cases found would }
Of the total of X ray
second degree asbestosis asbestosis 63 fir e: negative definite 63 ag fir
There
relation to the years expo in
numbers make it impossible
+
impossible to d
enters this increase increase to d
enters into TABLE Classificati
TABLE 2. Classificat;.
Years of exposure
active active about
One asbestos worker (second this study, but is Still active aSbtoaugte)hirsetgiarreddeonf, his
6
the vould 6 that the dust hazard
was not
vould appear that dust hazard hazard was not
, vould appear rooms plants B and The The
eparation when considered the light
2 too dust established established by
r granite granite
United
about 10 million million particles
cubic However
we not justified
available information information suggests that asbes-
clinically than
higher higher Asbestosis
silicosis threshold threshold threshold
Asbestosis appears to be patho-
icosis icosis and experience experience far does
DUST CONTROL
CONTROL 4s DUST
and local
exhausts be
oiling l. t Nevertheles Nevertheles
humidification humidification and exhausts they
Nevertheless it was dustiness they
usI tf it expected control
2 must upon properly constructed ienxsthaalulsat-
olufstone department department experimental equipment equipment
some obvious faults faults dust by percent
ons lust counts reduced be percent effective
ion ons probably satisfactory percent It neither
uly seemed seemed quite satisfactory equipment equipment
lust ally desirable desirable defensive mechanism
v fair free amount atmospheric pollution
ed to fair amount
.
excessive amount of dust that
> ed
ust down equipment to
machinery involves
ust equipment where construction construction of
ile to Decially down
the
draft suction to the
le exhaust apparatus
1 then exhaust check
in any plant on an
0
efficiency efficiency by dust
n saving saving expenditure expenditure
money
SICAL EXAMINATIONS
f 126 126 persons 108 men women women
of United States All but five of these
nm. on The cases were selected of employ-
lose hose having more than than years
Was
diagnosis
was soon obvious that the pictures
) a o large extent on ray pictures symptoms
tages tages tages silicosis the
inconclusive symptoms
usually indefinite inconclusive
ms are ms based based
one
been readings reviewed by
rat they they have been reviewed by
if
4 Fi 3 r
7
1935 4, 1935
others experienced nature there was general minor nature were read
conservativelyindividual physical examination examination
and age of the
general agreement interpretation interpretation
individual
into account were classed as
examiners were examiners disagrement
ag
disability stage Particular were guided their their experience silicosis
of pneu-
silicosis other types further further
moconioses The films classed
subdivided into
negative negative asbestosis asbestosis can
further
doubtful and
tell
whether the individuals classed
negative progressing toward toward tell
definite asbestosis
doubtful doubtful focussed the presence a
or absence of indications
attention and this respect all
the
tuberculosis tuberculosis the unhappy unhappy
reviewers of the films were accord
of
accord
great deal
experience experience the
silicosis in mind it was felt that
care should
devoted to
ascertaining possible
whether whether not asbestosis asbestosis pre- bo
disposes to tuberculous
possible whether or not asbestosis
The
infection
cases of asbestosis first embraces embraces
pre-
and second stage The first
those who show by
ray examination
pathology pathology sufficient extent extent
definite pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis have no
by
warrant a diagnosis of
definite to
symptoms The
stage exhibit more extensive extensive lung
definite symptoms exhibit
pathology and also definite actively
more work and
All these individuals 2
it was not practicable Had make distinction distinction the basis working exhibited any individuals individuals found found who exhibited
ability or disability involvement
extensive
involvement and marked physical
disability
or total
disability would been
physical disability
were found have classified third
but Of the total 126 ray
been were diagnosed diagnosed as
second second degree asbestosis asbestosis
negative
63 degree as doubtful and
There
asbestosis 63 as the percentage percentage diagnosed
ag
diagnosed positive positive positive
There relation relation the years exposure exposure
in numbers make make impossible impossible
determine table factor age
Small enters into this increase determine determine how far factor 9.
enters into this
to determine how far the factor of
TABLE age
TABLE 2. Classificatioonf cases by years of Number
Years of exposure
10 5
years 5 to Under Under
years {lo HO Total
rte
onder 9 Total
irr
Petal exomined.
0000
ee ---
--
worker still active
7
to
One
this
asbestos
worker
(second
Stage)
Study,
but
is still
active
about
retired his
of
his
garden.
Own
Percentage
Doubtful
:
Positive 32322
Positive 11 32322
****
33815 39
58 33815
20
50 30 39 2
43 continuous 25 3
10
12
not
67
10
previous
21 not continuous.
accord, because of old age, 10 years previous
January 4, 1935
8
Of 1935 64
Persons given 8 examination and
given January positive
physical physical examination
diagnosed ag
diagnosed Of the 64 persons persons given physical
examination and diagnosed
having positive asbestosis asbestosis
examination entirely entirely free free from symptoms
while
doubtful entirely with
diag-
of doubtful symptoms and Dyspnoea Dyspnoea
negative diag- the
noses were free from symptoms symptoms none
and cough were the
symptoms symptoms most complained complained wind
these these cases exhibited the
urgent or evident type negative
seen true silicosis silicosis Several
of classed as
stated that they short winded winded "
negative and recorded subjective symptomsmuch should not placed placed the
statements statements subjective
symptoms During the progress
study study physicians
were practicing the communities communities
the
lived were
where where not
questioned asbestos workers lived of tuberculosis
stated that did The
find an unusual amount state
tuberculosis among among these workers workers
contrast between hazard
affairs
community
noteworthy with The incidence incidence of tuberculosis
noteworthy upon ray films given given in
tuberculosis based upon X films
the table The incidence
years given employ-
industry 3. nIeidence of tuberculosis
Tuberculosis (healed)
Tuberculosis (active)
Tuberculosis Tuberculosis
Positive Doubtful Negative
1 Total case was diagnosed
ag Probably active on the X-ray findings
This case diagnosed probably as to physical signs of chest
trouble
TABLE Chest findings
NPhoyspihcyaslicsai]gns of chest trouble
Not
chest
Physical
physical
signs
Not
Positive Doubtful Negative
asbestosis ' At least 6 of these
? 2 of At least
showed no
56 of At these these showed
associated associated
evidence associated with no evidence associated found with usual signs asbestosis
asbestosis
What
significance
significance any can can attached to the
What significance " on hands hands workers
presence 18
asbestos asbestos asbestos positives positives 12 out
appears doubtful others others
percent doubtful 7 out of
of and and percent such corns corns
doubtful
negative negative 2 out of showed
to
roentgenologist roentgenologist reviewed reviewed
called attention
to Each fact that these
X films unusual incidence
enlargement enlargement of
indicated indicated
that unusual
enlargement enlargement the heart It probable that upon this
compensatory compensatory
efforts due to additional additional
the
work upon upon heart heart efforts
pump blood through the the fibro
attention been paid paid paid 1 the heart attention
workers had changed fro fro
during one plant another another during
industry Since only only th this survey survey the variou variou variou: way knowing knowing the average y ; by these people over y the
x
quently not possible possible corr to corr.
amounts dust exposure exposure
INSURAN:
throw light on analysis relations of
tuberculosis tuberculosis was mad of
disability claims having availa mac
insurance insurance having involved avail;
were death claims are so
clusions years
death reached from a so the sickness sickness cla a
epi number true claims for respiratory respiratory cla
number claims for the
others
studied low 1927. However However
du a
experience 1929 there du
part records 1929 one establishm establishm establishm epic claims and of 10 perman
listed due pulmonary pulmonary pulmonary tuberc
tuberc
ordinate amount amount of tuberculosis f
employees were Negroes Negroes f; ally this section of
the end
diagnosing diagnosing pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis and sti
tuberculosis claims sti
treated and
claims investigated
the individuals includ sti
sanatorium sanatorium records includ investigated following re
with the exposed ri
1. typist
intestinal Colored Colored age
Colored
27
pulmonary
months sanatorium sanatorium mont !
mann evidence evidence
3. Colored
asbe ;
male age w
months Colored died pulmona pulmona
hospital hospital Cavitation Cavitation both lu \
hospital died of pulmon:
Ospital, Cavitation both lu
8
entirely only
ned doubtful doubtful
free from negative diag-
and out of
i ymptoms ymptoms
with were the
cough Dyspnoea Dyspnoea and
ned of none
exhibited
at " short
of these silicosis Several
lve
seen were short short
stated emphasis should
winded
ut
much emphasis emphasis
not placed placed
cre symptoms symptoms
progress the
of practicing
During communities communities communities where
teof questioned
and stated they
questioned and among these
not
these
tuberculosis
that
workers
ate affairs
noteworthy noteworthy basneotdeworuthpy otnhaXt films) is given given ray films given
> 3. Ineddencoef lubcreulosig
of Positive Doubtful Negative
-
ms
me3
9
mn 67
39
| lv active
20
on the X-ray findings,
_
ion as ly physical physical signs signs
chest ABLi E on Chest
Positive Positive Doubtful wis,
associated associated ice Associated with nfsound ace
_ asbestosi
SiN Of signs
asbestosis asbestosis
ly
.
ly
any, can any
hands of
can attached attached
doubtful doubtful
hands appears 12 out of 12 out workers
of the
sative, 2 gative gative
64 and percent percent
such
ho
2 out showed
ho reviewed reviewed the
films
'ms Ims
ray unusual
indicated indicated very this
It is It probable probable put compensatory
Iditional Iditional
heart Iditional work put upon the
efforts
9
:
knowing departments individual lungs to
pump through through fibrosed
Jenuary 4, Bscnt)
pump through been paid
It possible pneumoconioses pneumoconioses thas.
sufficient attention attention
the effects effects the pneumoconioses pneumoconioses
no
Mantyhe workers changed changed one
another
workers plant another another
department employment employment the
their years dust collected
and
asbestos asbestos industry
only the amounts
departments are
collected in the
time way knowing
survey the various departments
average average
known there ay the the atmosp^rna atmosp^rna is
their employment employment employment Once-
quently is not not possible correlate
Once-
correlate
cases with datwite,
relationship between
To throw light on analysis
disability adreaeth 36 disability nary
tuberculosis manent
claims was made
claims companies cauuying cauuying
regard companies companies
cauuying
group insurance
claims available available figures figures exposure
cauuying
and involved with total
7,009 - MRE
There were death claims
years The death reached
small number number figures figures
clusions
from any subdivision subdivision
The
det.
cannot be sickness claims
health insurance The
same number of claims for respiratory claims health two of plants
number number low for
diseases compared with
studied experience of 1927. others compared latter part part Metoprol^>tium
experience of 1929
However However during
1928 1928 and the
influenza influenza the
was first The records records one
epidemic plant showed showed that
death
establishment establishment establishment total
that 36 Bags
claims and 8
listed as to pulmonary pulmonary permanent This This appeared
ordinate ordinate ordinate
pulmonary
tuberculosis this plant
be
im- 33
amount
tuberculosis However Negroes the employees were
also
tuberculosis
many gemer-
claims are diffinity in in
the high this pneumoconiosis andcoutnthryecountry Realizing confuse with ef
tendency confuse piouns
tuberculosis treated individuals were
who who and
treated records records including interviewed
available and sanatorium with following results
investigated
results with Death claims typist
including
dust
exposed exposed
Death, intestinal
interviewed film were were
film were and the fy portal pulmony pulmony and
asbestos 1. intestinal Colored male
months pulmonary
died
pulmonary
tuberculosis
tuberculosis
following
following
2. was sanatorium evidence of asbestosis in
healing Wassur
mann mann No
was
evidence
asbestos planta planta acad
In
Colored
worked
acad
mann,
male pulmonary
months Cavitation Cavitation
tuberculosi tuberculosis tuberculosis
after month
of
3. hospital
both
asberika asberika
months;
Cavitation Cavitation
died of
Cavitation
worked
in
asbestos
Ospital,
avitationpulmonary
tuberculosis
plant, 1 Aye after
both lungs; no evidence
1
of asbesti,
:
A
10
4. Colored
6 months. male, age 34; worked in
Plicated
10
tuberculosis.
believes
asbestog plant 2
this
years
Was not
was 9 case of
and
in asbestos plant years years
uncom.
and
plicated
information
tuberculosis tuberculosis Was obtained
information information could
obtained other other
information permanent permanent
obtained claims his
two cases
disability
plant
observation
plant
physician
physician
marked
physician
observation in asbestos
years His physician estabof
states case tuberculosis tuberculosis
observation with old employ-
cervica]
lished started Also had
tuberculosis the kidney
tuberculosis glands started
tuberculosis
employed asbestos plant
kidney cervical
months
physician
physician physician
bacilli old states
finding of
sputum sputum
tuberculosis months tubercle
in
as-
available No ray
according
physician in sputum sputum physicians physicians
physician treated
employment
treated treated 1s
not
t predisposition predisposition tuberc to tuber:
predisposition . this
Asbestosis observed in observed in {
disability case in any case,
known known known how much how
pneumonia acute nontub
much
nontub nontul:
not practicable practicable practicable
yet as yet t
content air of the
amount amount dust the : in
substantialy reduced reduced, the ,
RECOM;
recommendedseriously
the industry plants
industry
seriously
Seriously
employees
Of three their
employment and time Of
employment the asbestos was
and Of were udnciomsplaicbatiedlity
asbestosis
uncomplicated
who
tuberculosis
because because of
uncomplicated diagnosis
munity tuberculosis mistaken mistaken diagnosis diagnosis
munity
due
com- were put on In this asbestosis
know one
uncomplicated
an
industry. employment employment the
asbestosis asbestosis in an
frequently 2. silicosis silicosis
be
Cases definite
2. associated
fi
Personal
with
Personal
enlargement
enlargement
found to
examination of the
chest
2
s
thi.
industry industry sponsor sponsor
as studies on
effects sponsor
as well as studies
s
ACKNOW ACKNOW of ast;
tl
making making study companies
ployees the
companies t]
gave everay sfabcileitsy tPeonsnsyclomvpaanineis asecurin possi
University University
for L
Pennsylvania and to L
preciation Charleston Charleston Charleston
C. in lis
pathology pathology pathology
the Dr.
asbestosis * Dr.
Joseph Fellows Fellows of
Wyatt assisti for ir
Dr. Paul
York
O.
for
Lancaster
+
Snoke of Lancaster
Danville Quebec Quebec
to
Cummings Cummings Cummings
Canada Saranac Lab
pathological Saranac
study pathological effects
pathological Kenn to
JourboMeddiAsseocs sputum and vol 1
* Aug. effects ,
sputum Asbestosis bodies in
Jour. Am. Med. Assoc., Aug. and lung, By Kerr
30, 1930, vol. 95, no. 9, ;
10
ige 34; 10 in
sician 10
asbestos plant 2
this
years
and
s. Was not worked asbestos was 9 case of and
Id age
asbestos plant
worked believes this was
years
ysician not
case sanatorium
5 obtained obtained the
ame isability claims claimosther two cases
isability isability asbestos
with His physician physician
d
plant years
asbestos observation observation
His
estab-
with asbestos employ-
i in culosis tuberculosis tuberculosis
had
tuberculosis
the months
kidney cervical
asbestos
months physician physician
ound fibroid fibroid plant months tubercle bacilli
available but
Sare ound sputum . apchycsiociradnsinphygsicianpshysician physician
who treated
employment
treated
>
W are inclined inclined to
z
asbestosis
of reexamined
reexamined
believe
time investigation
His
investigation
reexamined
His
fine
of
nourished
looking
diminished
color
fingers
expansion incessant
disseminated diseminated through
second
Years of tuberculosis tuberculosis Probably
' Case.
years asbestos
Is now sanato-
id
years
plant Is now he has
with
pulmonary physician
pulmonary
states
that
in
ong
with
tuberculosis
tubercle
tuberculosis
asbestos
factory long
and This patient
locate factory factory
- had locate
manner three cases of total
diagnosed pulmonary locate diagnosed
disability asbestosis uncomplicated nN
Cases, the asbestos
dIn asbestuosnis complicated
nosisof
asbestosis were were
athdue gnosis
tuberculosis tuberculosis this same
the s ath uncoemploymment pelmploiymenct ated uncomplicated asbestosis asbestosis
CONCLUSIONS
' asbestos asbestos asbestos dust
heosis
and
demonstrable licosis
pulmonary
demonstrable demonstrable milder
iac iac
enlargement were frequently to
disability standards asbestos predisposition predisposition predisposition study
indicated this observed
Asbestosis
observed this series cases cases
marked disability disability
any case .
cases had not resulted in
5.
known known much asbestosis asbestosis
pneumonia acute nontuberculous
pulmonary infections infections .
pneumonia pneumonia pneumonia practicable
nontuberculous
asbestos
6.
practicable yet to establish establish
content air .
standards for the
dust The
can
be
amount dust in the air in the asbestos
substantially reduced
asbestos plants Studied
can
It is
recommended-
1. That the
RECOMMENDATIONS
industry asbestos plants
seriously the the physically including
2. That
including ray in
new
employees and
examination of the
rejected
employment pneumoconiosis pneumoconiosis rejected for
they X-ray
tuberculosis or
3.
examined
preferably every year show
That employees years
but but least
this
examination examination
the chest chest
this
include
known
every
,
the industry industry
cases asbestosis asbestosis
4. That studies
studies effects
asbestosis
48 as well studies
asbestosis on heart
asbestosis, on effects ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
cases of
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS the heart and
Sitntearptreteinsg filCoomperastive PicherUnited expressed who followed express their sincere
aided making making this
aided ployees the asbestos study possible cooperated cooperated the fullest
and gave gave facilitycompanies securing also Dr.
extent the
and
Pennsylvania his
Pancoast advice in
University University Pennsylvania Pennsylvania
interest valuable valuable advice
interpreting
and F. Meriwether Meriwether Meriwether
United
Bureau BureauPublic Health Cooperative SCoeoprervatiiveceClsiunrgiecon Clcinichianrge charge United inteStrate-s Stiatnes
Mines pretation pretation of
listed in this report is whose whose Ap-
Smith preciation preciation preciation also Charleston C. Dr. Atmar
Kenneth
advice particularly
Lynch Lynch Charleston
information information information
and advice
particularly
as to
pathology asbestosis asbestosis 4 Dr.
Charleston Charleston
pathology 48 to S.
Joseph H. Wyatt
W. and and H.
Newark S.
Fellows New
as isting
interpreting interpreting
York films Cs Fellows Paul Snoke Snoke
assisting assisting interpreting interpreting R. Stevenson
Stevenson Dr. Danville Danville Quebec CanadLaana casn ter dLancaster DDr. r. Gardner Gardner and Mr. Donald Donald
Laboratory Cummings Cummings of
undertaken undertaken dust the
Saranac study Cummings pathological pathological
Laboratory
asbestos Asbestosis bodies in sputum effects effects of the inhalation W. Atmar
dust
Study Jour Am
Kenneth Assoc
Smith Lynch D. undertaken
Asbestosis bodies
1930 no pp 659-661 of
the
Jour. Ain.
in sputum and
Mea, Assoc.,
lung. By Kenneth
asbestos dust
Aug. 30, 1930, vol, 9,
M. Lynch, M, D,, end w,
no. 9 pp. 659-697.
Atmar Smith, M. p.
ONALYY By 2935
12
12 through animal
1935 Life Insurance 12
with the aid of 4 grant from the
with
Metropolitan Metropolitan Insurance and
Paratus as
REFERENCES REFERENCES The
used
by
the
REFERENCES
REFERENCES
Publie
impinger
Health
dust
sampling
ap-
Rep., vol. 47, no. and Bloomfield
1 Greenburg Leonard
Bloomfield J.
impinger
sampling ap- Health
Leonard Bloomfield States Public
impinger dust
p Reap ratus 1932.
Service Reprint no 1528
Pub
suspensoids by suspensoids suspensoids suspensoids by June
2 Drinker and Thomson
alternating current
precipitators
precipitators
Jour Ind Hyg
vol
rocks.
carbonate (4) 1925 W. W.
precipitators
carbonate
Bull, 422,
analysis 3 Hillebrand Hillebrand W.
silicate and carbonate
rocks Dee, 38, 1927,
Geological United United States Pulmonary Pulmonary
Washington Washington Jour
1927 of
Cooke W.
( Green paint paint rubber
asbestosis
Med
determination
determination
particle
particle
pp.
size size
pigments Jour Franklin and
( Whipple 637 G. Vital statistics
Sons, New 1925 1925,
Whipple . workers
statistics John Wiley and and
Bloomfield Russel
in H. Thompson Thompson and
.: The The
Britten Britten Thompson Thompson II
Bloomfield Bloomfield J granite
Exposure
No.
ENDEMIC TYPHUS IN
By J.N. Baker, ENDEMIC ENDEMIC ENDEMIC TYPHUS
ALABAMA
D.P.H., M. JAMES TYPHUS ALABAMA D. and G. GILL
MCALPINE MCALPINE Ph
M. D. D.,
Montgomery Ala
State
INTRODUCTION
ference ference State Provincial Provincial
epidemiological ference ington the authors authors
aspects of
ington typhus it occurs discussed epidemiological epidemiological southern southern southern increase in
endemic In that report was was
this disease
typhus that there had been a rapid increase
in certain
Southern Southern States is shown incidence
That other countries have
experienced experienced experienced
incidence evidenced by the figures in
table table between
of this The distinction between
epidemic typhus and the
endemic
in of this country
recognized recognized 1898 by Brill He found
&
was first type fever
typhoid gave
resembling which itsthe United States type further
demonstrated demonstrated
character negative negative Widal typhus showed studies studies ( milder showed that was milder a
Also and
household
less contagious contagious that
Also Also he reported
was prevalent during Anderson and Goldberger
winter spring spring In
Goldberger Goldberger
Anderson
identical (4) instead of that Brill's disease
immunologically
immunologically ( proved typhus
Naturally it was Mexican louse
before 1 Read before the
5 ept. 3, 1934,
tabardillo
laboratory section section the
.
American
Naturally
Public
belief
this led to belief
Association, Pasadena,
that that
Calit.,
1
Typhus incidence incidence incidence i;
a
Gerda nnn =
nn
Georgia____--_-.
4
/
222 TITDT : Alabama.
277
a
exes ------
aan. i
only July 1 to July 1,
Incidence typh of typh
Country
South Africa exico
.
Epidemiological the Epidemiological Epidemiological
. months months months . months.
Report, Health Section
Nevertheless endemic endemic (1926)
noncontagious Brill's disease character its
noncontagious
louse
its
vector
the appeared appeared
and its
among persons persons Sinc
cases believe
rats mice migh ha
disease was carried man by fleas
emphasized the
migl;
strata fact Brill's Brill's di fleas,
society and bears no qi
was taken when
Dyer Rumre Rumre mn
to recover the virus
found found
Brill's Brill's
Rumreich Rumretiychp( hus19fo3ci3hpaoisnted pointed pointed
Maxcy's Maxcy's fundamental fundamental
athnedprobable probable vector suspect ted y
arachnids tropical rat mite t
vectors were head louse by