Document 8REr8jdon5R35YGG6bK2v8YZe
718
CHAPTER 45
1965 Guide And' Data: Book
the valve to open wider. The increased flow rate will result in
a higher evaporator pressure (Px) and a balanced control point
will again be established. Conversely, a decrease in the heat
load on the evaporator decreases the temperature of the re
frigerant gas.leaving the evaporator.and causes the thermo
static expansion valve pin to move in a closing direction.
Under certain circumstances there-may be little or no
pressure response, and the thermostatic expansion valve then
controls on temperature alone. This would be true if the evap
orator were part of a. multiple evaporator system, or if.it
were also controlled, by, an evaporator pressure regulator..
The new control point, following an-increase in. .valve
opening, is at a slightly higher superheat because of the spring
rate of the diaphragm and the superheat spring.- Conversely,
a decrease in load results in a slightly lower superheat thanthe
original control-point!
,:
These superheat changes in response to changes in load are
best illustrated by the gradient curve of fig. 6. Superheat at
no load A, or static superheat, assures sufficient spring force to
keep .the valve closed during equipment shutdown. An in
crease in valve capacity or load is roughly proportional to
superheat increase until the valve is fully open. The superheat
gradient,' represented by - the distance AB, may be defined
as.the increase in superheat required to open the valve to the
capacity at which it is intended to operate, or at -whichii is
rated.
Capacity
- Thaifactory superheat setting (static superheat setting) of thermostatic expansion valves is made with the valve pin just starting to move away from the seat. Valve manufacturers establish capacity ratingson'the basis of superheat gradient
by the distance BC, in fig. 6, for manufacturing tolerances
and application contingencies.;
- System design should not be based on utilization of-the re
serve capacity of the thermostatic expansion valve,- which is
obtained only at the expense of higher superheat:.The added
superheat gradient may have an adverse effect on valve per
formance. Valve gradients used for rating purposes generally
produce optimum modulation for a given valve design, and'it
is not wise to deviate widely from manufacturers'^ recom
mendations.
v.
Thermostatic expansion valve capacities are normally
published for various evaporator temperatures and valve pres
sure drops.' Nominal .capacities, apply :at 40 F evaporator
temperature. Capacities are reduced at lower evaporator tem
peratures. These reductions in capacity are due to the change
in the refrigerant pressure-temperature relationship at loyer
temperatures. For example, if Refrigerant 12 liquid charge' is
used, the change in saturated pressure between 40 F and 45 F
is 4.7 psi, whereas between -- 20 F and -- 15 F, the change is
only 1 .Q psL Although the valve responds to pressure changes5,
capacities are based on superheat gradients. Thus,'the valve
opening, and consequently the valve capacity, is less for a
given superheat change at the lower evaporator temperatures.
Pressure drop across the valve port is always the net pres^
sure drop available at the valve itself, rather than the dif
ference between compressor discharge and compressor suc
tion pressures.'
Allowances must be made for the following:
-J
1. Friction loss through condenser, liquid lines, and fittings.
2. Liquid line accessories, such as fiitem, driers, solenoid valves,
etc.
3. Static head in a vertical liquid line. If the thermostatic ex
pansion valve is at a higher level than the receiver, there
will be a pressure loss in the liquid line due to the static head
of liquid.
1
4. Distributor pressure drop. .
.
5. Evaporator pressure drop.
6. Suction line accessories, such as evaporator regulators, sole
noid valves, etc.
7. Suction line friction losses.
Although the mass flow rate through the valve is greater for higher pressure drops, the capacity increase is not propor tional The mass flow rate through the valve varies as the square root of the pressure drop, but, due to the greater enthalpy of the entering liquid refrigerant, a'greater mass flow rate is required to obtain a given refrigerating effect. At high liquid temperatures, the capacity increase' due to higher pressure drops may be completely offset by the loss in net refrigerating effect, resulting in no change in capacity.
If liquid refrigerant subcooling is increased along with the liquid pressure, the capacity changes differ from those previ ously discussed. Subcooling, in addition to increasing the net refrigerating effect per unit of mass flow, reduces the amount of flashing in the valve port and thereby also adds to valve capacity. Most manufacturers publish subcooling factors to be applied to valve capacity ratings.
Thermostatic expansion valve ratings are based on vapor* free saturated liquid entering the valve. If flash gas is present in the entering liquid, the valve capacity is' substantially reduced, because the gas must be handled along with the liquid. Flashing of the liquid refrigerant may be caused by pressure drop in the liquid line due to friction losses, vertical lift, or both. If the refrigerant subcooling at the receiver out let is not adequate to prevent the formation of; flash gas, additional subcooling means must be employed to remove it. liquid-to-suction heat 'exchange "will provide a moderate
i
Refrigerant Control Devices
719
degree of subcooling, -but,-; for extremeirequirements, a geparate liquid-cooling coil is necessary.
Thermostatic Charge
type of thermostatic charge has certain advantages and . limitations which'must be considered. The principal types of thermostatic charges and their characteristics are
described here. Gas charge. Conventional gas charges are limited liquid*
charges, which employ the same refrigerant in the thermo static element as is used in the refrigeration system. The' amount of charge, is such that,' at a predetermined tempera ture all of the liquid has vaporized, and any temperature in crease'above this point results in virtually no increase in'element pressure, fig. 7 shows the pressure-temperature relation ship of the Refrigerant 12 gas charge in the thermostatic ele-. meht. Because of the characteristic pressure-limiting feature of its thermostatic'element, the gas-charged valve can provide compressor motor overload protection on some systems by
the mxiimnm operating suction pressure. It also helps to .prevent fioodback-(the return of refrigerant liquid to the compressor,through the suction line) on starting.. Increasing the superheat-setting will lower the maximum operating.suction pressure; and decreasing .the superheat settihg.wilTraise it beceusft the superheat spring, together with the evaporator pressure, acts directly on the element pressure through- the diaphragm.,..
Gas-charged valves must be carefully applied in "order to avoid loss of control from the bulb.-If either the diaphragm chamber or the capillary tube becomes colder than the bulb,the gmftll amount of-charge in the thermostatie;element will condense:'Control at the bulb will be lost and the.valve will throttle or close.r.This matter is discussed further in the section; Application. . .
Liquid'charge. Conventional liquid charges employ the same.', refrigerant in the thermostatic element as is used in the're-. frigeration system. They are termed - cross-ambient charges because'the volumes of the bulb, capillary tubing, anddiaphragm chamber are proportioned so that'the.bulb contains some liquid under'all temperature conditions. Therefore,'the bulb will always control the valve operation,even with a colder diaphragm chamber or capillary tube.- -
The characteristics of the straight .liquid charge,' Fig' 8(i result in an increase in operating^uperheat as the evaporator
temperature decreases. This-usuaHy limits its use to raoder-
ately-high evaporator temperatures. The-valve setting re
quired for a reasonable operating superheat at a low evapora
tor temperature may cause floodback during pulldown from
normal ambient temperatures.
: '.liquid cross charges. The liquid cross charges are also cross-'
ambient charges, but, unlike the conventional liquid charges,,
they'employ a liquid in the thermostatic element which is
different' from the refrigerant in tire system. Cross charges
have flatter pressure-temperature curves than'do the system
refrigerants with which they are used. Consequently, their,
superheat characteristics differ considerably from those of the
straight' liquid or gas charges.
. Crdss charges in the commercial temperature range gener
ally have superheat characteristics which are nearly constant
or which deviate only moderately through the evaporator,
temperature range. This charge, also illustrated in Fig. 8, is
generally
in the evaporator temperature range of 40 F
to 0 F, or slightly below.
For evaporator temperatures which are substantially below
0 F, a more extreme cross charge may be employed. At high
evaporator temperatures, the valve controls at a high super
heat. As tits evaporator temperature'is reduced to the normal
operating range, the operating superheat is also reduced to
normal.-This 'characteristic prevents floodback on starting,
reduces the load on the compressor motor after start-up, and
permits-a rapid pulldown of suction pressure. Valves with
this-type of charge must be set for the optimum,operating
superheat at the lowest evaporator temperature expected, in
order to avoid floodback.
Mechanical pressure limiting means. -While both the -low
temperature cross charge and the gas charge offer compressor-
motor overload protection, each-has its limitations. For the
former, the protection offered is only partial; for the latter,'
application limitations restrict its universal use. Thermo
static expansion valves, equipped with a mechanical pressure
limiting mpftnq to limit suction pressure, may use either the
liquid or the liquid cross charge and are, therefore, not re
stricted by problems of charge condensation. Throttling of
the. valve is accomplished by a collapsible member which is
operative only when the evaporator pressure exceeds a speci
fied value. At lower evaporator pressures, there is no inter
ference with normal valve operation.
CONVENTIONAL UQUtO CHARGE (2)COkMBtCUU. TDTOIATURE UQWD CROSS CHARGE (5)UW TEWCRMW* LIQUID CWSS QWtGC
--
fig. 8 .... Superheat. Characteristics of Thermostatic Liquid and liquid Cross Charges _