Document 7Rm1XoMpMnbL1KoweXXXqjNxj
FILE NAME Talc TALC
DATE 1960
DOC TALC221
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Book Excerpt - Talks from Symposium on Industrial Pulmonary Diseases in 1958
TALC 221
1960
INDUSTRIAL PULMONARY DISEASES
A Symposium held at The Postgraduate Medical School of London
20th September 1957
and 25th March 1958
EDITED BY
E. J. KING M.A. D.Sc. F.R.I.C.
Postgraduate Medical School of London and
C. M. FLETCHER C.B.E. Cantab F.R.C.P.
Postgraduate Medical School of London
With 98 Illustrations
LITTLE BROWN AND COMPANY
BOSTON
LIBRARY UNIVERSITY UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
DAVIS
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED This book is protected under the Berne Con-
vention It may not be reproduced by any means in whole or in part without permission Application with regard to reproduction should be
addressed to the Publishers
'J. & A. Churchill Ltd. 1960
8
Printed in Great Britain
This bo
industrialc
School |
symposiun symposiun
wishing to In plann
and co op Dr. R. I the Londo whole field
aspects fr experiment
studies to the patient intensive it able to cal associated several several sek our knowle
Flint gri
were amon
Great Brit sumong the of more ch
practically
trial proces stitution of ards have a
pulmonary Among th
With the g which occi disease has others ence
e several t disease ountered received
ope that sufficient
um was
and parould be
Ive conis a co-
" record of their
egrated
it com-
liscases
Brown
4 nes for paring
aration
IER
CONTENTS
CHAPTER
PAGE
1. Industrial Pulmonary Diseases in Great Britain Meiklejohn 1
22.. The Pathology of the Pneumoconioses J. Gough and A. G. Heppleston 23
3. Reaction of the Lung to Dust J. King and C. V. Harrison
37
4. Deposition of Dust in the Lungs a Physical Process-
N. Davies 44
5. A Review of Theories of Silicosis Nagelschmidt
72820
6. Problems in Taking and Reading Chest Radiographs Simon 72820
7. Radiological Diagnosis of Pneumoconiosis M. Fletcher
72820
8. Radiography in the Field J. Chapman
72820
9. Normal Lung Function and its Measurement Hugh
94
10. The Disturbance of Pulmonary Function in Industrial Pulmonary
Disease C. Gilson 110
11. The Use of Pulmonary Function Tests in Epidemiological
Work B. McKerrow 127
12. Pneumoconiosis in Cornwall W. Hale
139
13. Iron and Other Opaque Dusts I. G. McLaughlin
146
1.1 Pneumoconiosis due to Tin Oxide John Robertson
168
18. The Epidemiology of Byssinosis S. F. Schilling
~
185
16. An Approach to the Problem of Bronchitis in Industry Studies in Agricultural Mining and Foundry CommunitiesI. T. T. Higgins 195 ~~
17. Occupational Lung Richard Doll
208
18. Epidemiology of Coalworkers Pneumoconiosis L. Cochrane 221
vii
viii
CONTENTS
CHAPTER
19. Rheumatoid Disease and Pneumoconiosis Caplan
PAGE
232
20. The
Natural
History
and
Management of Coalworkers
Pneumoconiosis Donald Ball 241
21. The Prevention of Silicosis Donald Hunter
255
Index
271
INI
fh
Din earliest
Great Butau
painter Hur
br use in C
process was
process
healthfull Gi
The discuse
Johnstone Redditch "
entury the occupations occupations occupations
Summutia
was describ
and pathol
pneumonia
arose out
sandstone t from certan dust inhaled
accordingt
the lungs sively differ
others Th
particularly
i
i
i
patients patients du
11
Many iit earlier Re
w comparilyses how-
y notable is
* Division uded that
he relatively
sion merits
creased by
rously to my
nd criticism Coal Board
unstinting in
Occupations
J. 2 843 J. 371 1. J. industr ial Worker
ASES 1907 ns from the
by Noel A.
m No. 243
C. T. The
ity p 94
2.279 2.279
d Counties mary 1958
CHAPTER 2
THE PATHOLOGY OF THE PNEUMOCONIOSES
By
J. Gough and A. G. Heppleston
Department of Pathology Welsh National School of Medicine Cardiff
IN discussing the pathology of the pneumoconioses it is essential to distinguish asbestosis a variety which is caused by minerals with a librous structure from those varieties due to particulate nonJibrous minerals such as silica coal and h^matite Numerically the second group is the more important and will be considered first taking as types classical silicosis and coalworkers pneumoconiosis each of which assumes a simple and a massive form
Simple Pneumoconiosis By simple pneumoconiosis is meant the pulmonary reaction to dust uncomplicated by any other factor and the term thus refers to the essential manifestation of the disease Characteristically it takes the form of numerous small focal lesions composed basically of dirt and fibrous tissue in various proportions These lesions are Increte and measure up to about 5 mm in diameter they are more o less evenly scattered throughout the lung substance but may be somewhat larger and more numerous in the upper than in the lower parts To appreciate the mode of development of dust lesions eference must be made to the normal anatomy of the respiratory
portion of the bronchiolar tree The terminal bronchiole that is the
last order of nonrespiratory bronchiole gives rise to three successive onders of respiratory bronchiole i.e. those bearing alveoli before the single order of alveolar duct is reached the alveolar ducts then lead lead to atria and alveolar sacs Heppleston 1953 Dust deposited in the alveoli is ingested by phagocytes which attempt to eliminate the dut up the bronchiolar tree or to transport it to the lymphatic system Dust may also move along airways and into the interstices ot the lung as free particles but evidence of this is not easily
obtained Small accumulations of dust are found in relation to the
23
Sc
SI
ay J. GOUGH AND G.
%op/ -u0o -UI THE
euraskydurs situaed HEPLSTON sojquiesr normal HeplestonHepleston THE intrapulmonary A. peribonchial peribonchial normal PNEUMOCNIOSE PNEUMOCNISE emphysema intrapulmonary lymphoid HEPLESTON HEPLESTON ouryeXy AND intrapulmonary
lymphoid tissue situated
peribronchial peribronchial
size
The perivenous
simple later chanels conetraionintrapulmonary lymphatic lymphatic lymphatic
but considerable considerable
silicosis
is
ocurs stil proerty conetraion Axeurpso The conetraion perivenous glands some- surfedy dust Jo
of
glands contended
some- proximate though
proximate uonsonb acumlation is which property vogue acumlation leads the hilar contende thatcauses
with
uey) still undecide the For
SHOINDWAd glands lymph and asociated probaly retrograderetograde onoris years silca in acumlation both idea from idea solution sy parenchymal parenchymal acumlation lymph dust but evidence
pidi] Heppleston
in respiratoyThe typical to many howevr that over soluble parenchymal howevr syodsar Gardner by Gardner Nagelschmidt situated contradicts (1S61 1954b Strachan out question Strachan contradicts Irresvpiinraetory however yoafnouulr FHL are situated relation relation
IO
and they solubity thoughatention incostencis animals phagocytes have Gardner solubilty bronchial LP6l
and
evicted
traped traped Once the bronchial phagocytes theory pathogensi they theory the by
surondig bronchioles
Hepleston Heppleston
ADOTHLd uo\satdy) openig 1954b respiratory Hepleston bronchioles(
view
respiratory
route
into
and foci
pas ages
therefore
and
respiratory
physiological
called
that
silicates
fibrogenic
pue asoy
become [[@
fibrogenic fibrogenic
drawn
with
respiratory UL fibrosis fibrosis
developed developed
hyalinization
process proces
evidently bronchioles surondig aeipAyoqie secondary hyalinzto imunolgicalimunolgica evidently the where alveolated has mechanism norespiratoy bronchiole bronchioles proces respiratory alveolated block onsH secondary exists FHL ozis
bronchiole
pro tion chemical difers those detrmined nature determined determined free
norespiratoy leading the devlopment aAToeuUOD physiolgca containga tisues patholgical aproximately true jeuou leading high of devlopment specific proportion lesion lesion the clasical silicotic silcotic
i.e.
those
dustthose
and devlopment
course course
containing s10Ul
development sure}
sug ested
its chemical
tisues conective
conective conective
physiological physiolgical are are are
PNEUMOCONIOSES PNEUMOCNIOSE PNEUMOCNIOSE PNEUMOCNIOSE question
question
emphysema
emphysema Jo free
silica induces induces fibrosi fluids fibrosi fibrosis surface is
solubility has been
but
fluids mediated mediated
when twenty
when
pointed
years were
than Nagelschmidt more and quartz were
incositencies incositencies to the
pathogenesis
inconsitencies
silicosis
silica
the silica
pathogensi silcoticfor
imunolgicaloften hyalinzation
mechanism
demonstraed silcotic demonstratedconstitution demonstrated
hyaline
constiution other other hyaline hyaline conective
composed patholgical aproximately aproximately aproximately 80 colagen collagen
Llyye serum serum andand protein protein protein globulins a being globul globi ulin n globulin globulin
nodule thes Silcosi nodule devlops respiratory tisue respcts Simple UBUI
relation yorq yng He B vw
sa
Jo
retyouiqedSimple bronchiles Silcosi silcoti devlopsfibrolastic fibrolasticfibrolasticrelation reactiontheapears conective imunolgica imunolgicalimunolgica mechanism presumptive respiratory amyloid Vigliani mechanism in gensi amyloid morebronchioles silcotic
yi odurst iasglreegattess agregates eacaelrullary sfitbraougse evntualy
apears
which
formation
one hyaline and
demonstraed aceluar munolgicaly arranged
proges whorled tisue a
NOLST1dH silcotic around conetricaly gensi serum posiblity fashion zone observationsobservations silcotic islets Suoje nodule nodule rather these
fashion In fully
enclosed
enclosed
tisue role relationshp silcosi there conective fibrous aranged iregularly celular celular tisue
payenqis Simson to raise the disposed zone iregularly conective
Belt disea s preations Simple disease field DY Incinerated 1939 Incinerated
show
developed developed developed clasical classical
of concentricaly
which
il umina-
illumina-
zone preations The islets simple Coalwrkes distnguishng central ilumina- Pneumocnios Coalworkes typical ash central variable onsy contain UNF
typical
pat ern
amount coalworkes amount of
largelylargely Belt particles distncive contain andfrequntly frequntly presnce iregulary HOND while while toaly fibrous fibrous smal devoid distnctive halo external zone spaces results dust enlarged enlargemnt results
dust
particles
distinctive
Increasing
Increasing
of existing nodules
ones devlopment devlopment 1947 enlargemnt SIOTIS Hepleston silcotic of nodule devlopment the overshadowed
simple silicotic
large
contain
zone is vartihabele or
dust siliceous
and
siliceous
the amount
which
pose spose sposes charteisc nodule conis regads charcteristc large It important importan recoursestructral structralstructral serial coalwrkes pneumo- harcteristc note that tisue spaces dispositon characteristic
disposition
VC
spaces
the fully
nodule note that
tains more carbohydrate
connective con ective
carbohydrate
more more lipid ordinary ordinary hyaline
ordinary and In respects
hyaline
respects Pernis resmbles 1958 There resmbles
presumptive of
1956 mechanismand
and
demonstraed demonstraed presnce munologicaly munologically
silcosi presnce the
hyaline tissue
observations the in
the of the
relationship
the
( Vazquez
genesis
1957 have have now
lying
silicosis These globulin
observations possibility
genesis
possibility
col agen
relationship Aqiny relationship
Simple
Coalworkers Coalworkers v
Pneumocnios Pneumocnios thre The
Pneumocniosi
coalworkers coalworkers three distinguishing distinguishing
features has features amount disposed
tis ue spaces
the focal emphysema spaces and Heppleston
frequently
is dust
amount of
of
enlarged
lesion 1951 silcotic under- that coalworkers coalworkers
Hepleston contrast
1951
the
silcotic these nodule
To
contrasts the precise
with nodule
coalworkers simple pneumo-
stand
e[dus sections recourse recourse
made to serial
. These clearly
GOUGH AND HEPLESTON HEPLESTON
oy} jo oy) 0} Jo Jo THE
OF
PNEUMOCONIOSES
01
disposed the silica contributesis and Hepleston disposed around PNEUMOCNIOSE PNEUMOCNIOSE PATHOLGY PNEUMOCNIOSE and by Lz kq
consolidated
0}
inconspicuos
tisue respiatory bronchiles contribues this conslidated aor0j and
inconspicuous
conclusion (
espcialy those the and ( silca incospicuos specifc provide rspiratory dust litle around Crucial bronchioles bronchioles evidence second especialy those
second
oy}
evidence supporting suporting
provided
conclusion highly highly
carbon dilate conlusion that years these respiratory
pue
exposed exposed for
to
purified
pojiusen Aroyetdsu form known dust preartions and man carbon focal Hepleston emphysema duce the saptpeaartanece focal emphysema 1953
of The employed
years the
Hepleston The these indviduals histolgical two of Hepleston elctrodes indivduals these the
section random
histological
according
ay} no
dust lesions
electrodes those
these
R^...ttner
SHIONDWAd ducelesion plane surondig random uoresidurApuaprae of Aufdermau elctrodes also simple lesions transversetransverse coalwrkes coalworkes apearnce transverse acording this has
typicaly exposed to found remakbly remakbly graphite milerconte runing through wheras Aufdermaur pue runing through
the
section When this
typicaly
stel ate
with dilated
the
longitudinal
no 0} Jo
st
y
graphite
with remarkably
ash
the bronchioles outlined pasges graphite their longitudinal UOTVL] UOTIpe 085 dust exposed contained AHL respiratory section
respiratory bronchioles
in
To aye bronchioles cinephotography
silica contained quartz posible cinephotography
sections
concluded
formform transver outlined the lung necsary continuity cinephotgraphy to JO
serial
possible longitudinal
Ol} Ue pure
conlude dust pneumo- cinephotgraphy longitudinal longitudinal
devlopment posible coalworkes pasages transverse air asey pasages
se
lesion mechanil manifestaions coniosi dustefects acumlation acumlation JOpUN simple fundamental difernt as manifestaions reconilng pasages diferent apearnces reconcilng fundamental ( manifestaions planes Hepleston same UO planes fundamental
structure
apearances Hep leston
structure
1955
degree
ADOTHLYd coniosi amount mechanical focal Hepleston suficent OMsty degre emphysema from
sometimes
sometimes
focal emphysema features compresd howevr and importanimportan of peuedxasaToyIuqg The mechanics emphysema easily dilated emphysemarespiratory alveolar widely compresd LE[NOISA inspration inspiration varies widely betwen emphysema emphysema Hepleston FHL It tion that respiratory
radiolgca amountto Ayjeu0m.Aroyendsaz coalwrkesHeplston 1954a wideshown tisue recognize radiolgical ofsimple fairly disposedisposed vesicular vesicular recognize the pneumocnios radiolgical features due coalworkers coalworkers
conslidated coalworkes a coalworkers the small consolidated fibrous
anddue
bronchioles
radiological
itself
the
compres ed
simple
small amount
SHE
that free
coalworkers
irespective irespective
imbalance of
emphysema
between
As
efect
and fibrous
necesary
that that
mechanical
of
most
tis ue
development
form pneumo-
acumlation
interpetd interpetd interpreted
and and
6
tions tions entailed entailed mining
must generated in the various various opera- opera-
min g instance vary considerably Nagelschmidt
instance
in sometis coal seams certain Welsh YyUomusA bronchiolar smoth adjacent strat Nagelschmidt Nagelschmidt that the sometimes
coal the apears expiratoy expiratoy varied adjacent total dividing from content our experience
minerals wil minerals exprienc minerals face our all Moreover
in
%% to
face workers
total puv
pneumocniosi
yettype pneumocnis pneumocnis movents expiratoy exprienc Moreover in ses same
NOLSTdH simple inspratoy permanet Morevr identical pneumocnios coalworkers
identical
pneumocnios
of
rank
bituminous bituminous
coalwrkes irespctive sema permant focal coalworkes features and anthracite or anthracite
emphy- whether y8noyH) the 1947 British
coalfield carbonceus irespctive silcoti whether whether Hepleston DV contains b1951
airborne
bituminous Heppleston
fre
contains a litle with mean than Wales Wales Nagelschmidt this
fractionBecause coalSouth esntial Nagelschmidt wer ewuskydura at same indets the regarde ben Nagelschmidt regarded the GNF been fraction 1943 conslidation this pure
dust specif coalworkesresmblance thesilcanospecif clasicalbelive already indcated distnct respiatory emphysematous howevr enlargment inspra- HOND morphlogical and alreadyexpected spmoerpchilogficalc resmblance simple ]voj Sf
lesion
be
lesion coalworkers
resemblance resemblance
clas ical
But
resemblance
exists
resmblance resemblance
lesion
coalworkers we nonspecific nonspecific
some
that some indicated no is simple jo that
a iZap of
reaction of
lesion coalwrkes whatevrmajor Emphysema with nodule iregular segmnts isdevoid free whatevr the fraction which which and devoid the and 9
(Y)
free silica
oti
which which they subjected importan are A important which an adition bronchioles bronchioles as
to addition
inspiratory
important
subjected consolidation
conslidation dust atrophy atrophy theof consolidation upon expiratory
SnoleA upon and bronchioles respiratory respiratory
bronchioles wil oY} diminished both
combine bronchiolar bronchiolar movemnts expiratoy Ul movements both
inspiratory efect
although devlops samesema The simple althoughalthough coalworkes focal
progesively focal
emphysema because focal
expandig emphysema above bronchioles expanding bronchioles
and the tory
These depend
abolished Such
movements movements
interferences
expiratory
expiratory
,
lesion
dust above because is
defined
narrows
and actualy actually
same counteracts
tory traction bronchioles simple conslidaton vesicular respiratory bronchioles around distinct Emphysema emphysema emphysematous distrbution any airway (6r61Emphysema Emphysema
respiratory bronchioles
silicotic nodules nodules
from focal focal
nodule this
Sometimes however
emphysematous emphysematous but
that it segments
particular
iregular distribution distribution distrbution may
inspiratory consequence consequence force
bronchiolar smooth
shortening
therefore therefore
combine produce
focal emphy-
same
does progresively progressively
respiratory
nar ows respiratory respiratory narrows
vesicular inspira-
spaces
enlargemnt enlargement is
space
airway
atributed atributed atributed
not wel tuberculosi retraction the operate over which retraction growth 6c sey fibrous jo
jo nodule
which may
JO SI axe ut est
I
JO
Ul
years years tuberculosis
after ceas peatedly peatdly advncedadvnced the elment conept fibrous cesation nodule cease not which woym for operate This retraction exposure dust cesation to complicatng exposure elment years found those
stopnzsq} Lesions fundamentalyfundametly SIOYM[VOD stolgical South in bacteriolgca exposure workers graphite fundamentaly miners 1954 scalers from bacteriolgical similar be workers graphite miners
workers
remaing found and and workers masive coalwrkes the Aueut Marshall
ocupations workers clear Gloyne these therfore ocupations like Harding Masie Wales sieoX the dust 1951 1951
oc upations
SHOINDWAd wel lesionsshowed coal may represnt lesions healed genral tuberculosi uour and silica
Comparble evidnce patholgical content always the reasonable they features genral silica therfore QO] common
pathogenesis
lesions conclude
Comparable
pathogensi James foundry
pathogenesis
lesions
share comon lesions also ocur SIOITs re8unoX interptaion from pathogensi also in JOAO suports McLaughlin
interptaion tuberculosi % masive foundry McLaughlin 88 workers FHL 1950
1950 suports workers from showed tuberculosi reode only Masive McLaughlin therefore sip, [Jom IO ay]
OU Masive
Pneumoconiosis Pneumocniosi
Masive , masive thes 1947 [eseID Masive Pneumocnios tuberculos therefore 1947 JOJ Massive
lesions iregulary mainly Hepleston indcating the lesions coalworkes Hepleston Hepleston Endings dust ydeoxe that infection Endings indicating pue Massiveconsist
Gough Gough
mingled
ADOTHLYd hyaline vesels tend pasages Tubercle bacili diesinto existng fibrosi hyaline colagen and with the of esions tubercle tuberculos hyaline fibres bundles conceive It tuberculous esions ocur bundles inconspicuous
may
coalworkers
coalworkers coalworkers
peatedly
jo
245
245
Harding
UT
low
these
has
ING
they
occur
12
ay
UT
suports
wonder
ay}
ut
UL
conceive sB
parts
isn
James been
thoroughly thoroughly
by
James
by
evidence evidence evidence tuberculosis
complicating complicating
40
Wales coalworkers coalworkers
Although
remaining
%
Although
they
of tuberculosis
represent pathological
massive
lesions
masive masive fibrosis are
James
since was massive lesions evident
29
over
men of
indicating increasing
over We therefore
the origin
infection
interpret
fibrosis
dificult
Tubercle tubercle apear pentrating
incospicuos payesouc. pentraing pentraing and incospicuos lesions tuberclous Blod lesions many the arterioles AHL are arteries arteries
arterioles arterioles
the
previous incospu fibrous masive This the persitenc lamel^ lumina lesions the masive ysnut persitence
internal
elastic by
3
obliterated
shown SIOxMTEOR erated comuniate men totalytoaly invasion offibrous tubercle sputum sputum Carpenterthan partialy Aypareg presnt les obliterated been Cochrane 2 of fibrous fibrosis sputum acompanied
or
TheThe masive
by
foci
bronchi which explains however are
This
explains
probably
during during
bacil i fibrosis Cochrane
tuberculos do show show conclusive may
conlusive element
do
element element
production tuberculos Strachn recognized Juawesuvie hewrs abolishedabolished coal his Gardner Gardner Gardner Strachan masive
dispute extenttisues 1940 maintained coalworkes has alone formed
maintainedmaintained aduced several dust
NOLSITdH pneumocnis lungs symetrical most this extnsiondisease retarde progesion in Simple Simple pneumocnios
pneumocniosi
pneumocniosi
symetrical
to 9 due not
both human progesion only WV often
case
Numerous hand relatively without snoun factor material provide should ANY youngmassive men disease w, ithshort dust exposures
young lung tuberculos non
parts account acount
inadequate HOND with
acting poysinBusip fibrosi the Tf reason explanation
reason colapse explantion fibrosi an SAIJOUD that show acumlatedacumlated cause discharged discharged combined fact coalescne coalescne evidence from In inadequate the the 6 9q genesis
explantion
masive that evidence
masive fibrosis fibrosi
silcotics tuberculosi evidenc tuberculosi tuberculosi geters Why and be massive fibrosis fibrosis
they jo kq hewers hewers
geters
evidence participate
sayje80) showed particpate the but and Simson
Strachan in
the tuberculin and do and that masive
^tiolgy masive lesions lesions therfore Mantoux reaction reaction dispute
but Ienpou the dust bacilus element tisues progesion progesion poyeul of mater Suleq for this dispute purpose disease view clearly view
James James
unlikely
coalworkers
coalworkers
in 1938
1931 Mantoux
and
alter therefore
tubercle therefore The so as
form tuberculous
equalyequaly AypeardAy ocurs fibrosi patholgical tuberculos in was
pathological
afected senpou epidemio- observations 1951 limited afected its Man progresion may occur
ayy with
without observations sometimes
satis- The sometimes view view human litle dust
Sq factory this
other sometimes seen the relatively alone
acting
alone
the tuberculos Those not dust gnst} origin fibrosi fibrosi fibrosis factor excessive fibrosis
observations observations
The study
production tuberculous production
ac ept dust
reverse
infection
masive same have infection cause discharged simple lesions bronchial fibrosis ore
masive the the aditional out made experiments experiments
colapse aditonal siolyis expriments acumlated infection factor aditonal tuberculous of Morevr the tuberculous factor aditional the oY} op
UL
younger
tuberculosi
younger men
tuberculosi should should
is ,
quartz reaction
extent
restrict the
tuberculous element sugest features
of
and
material
view
tuberculosi
masive
is cases cause
dust dust
Gough Gough 1957
tuberculous infection
many of whom whom airne
Cum ins
Cum ins Cummins
adsorbed
tuberculin
Coal-
the
progression
modified
limited
The
Cochrane )
has provided no satis-
is
complicating
Those
fibrosis may
mas ive such
may
infections
animal
combined animal
lungs
combined
with inhaltion bacili PATHOLGYof cultre PNEUMOCNISEPNEUMOCNISE inhaltion AND soyeoris goysaqeyunoure s01S2qsB bacili PATHOLGY the G.A. HEPLESTON
Te
-uasa J. intratracheal
sonefour including extnsive GOUGH injection HEPLSTON duststhe Rheumatoidinflamtory recoverd cultre fre fibrosi but various recoverd of with inhaltion intracheal induce silica
including can
extensive Gardner
tuberculous
Bid
fibrosis
regarde being fibrosi rabbits
lungs do caly colagen lungs silicotic
SIONDWAd Dworski silcoti coalwrkes atoskiyoBurUTe}UCSs[Op1o9 rabits Vorwald abnormaly gous Dworski
Massive
failed so
coalworkers
sometimes inflamtoryreaction fibrosi coalworkes infective pneumocnios oftenoften 10 pulmonary
pulmonary and tuberclosi obliteraion emphysema nodules nodulesinflamtoryinflamtory reaction fromfrom disease tuberculosi [esoUrl sapnyout ring infectivepneumocnios amino AHL
pulmonary Gough
heart
disease IO Aq
classical Hepleston
the emphysema central Hepleston central necrosi involves classical silcosi
vascular vascular obliteration
1955
1955 , whereas whereas
Strachan ) On
pesaos qemnosedumiseu r air bacil clasicaldence howevr said coalworkers In be indirectly large
mortality mortality
ADOTHLIVd such nodules tubercle part coalworkes rheumatoid tubercle in frequently
the
sq
Caviton the consequnce and frequntly consequnce masive distnct poyerpAy calcify and FHL
ischemia
procesesdevlops and tuberculosi quiescnt Asbetosi meanig unqechable The meanig meaning yoUeO Fletcher Vascular
consequence two
leads
proces Kilpatrickcoliquative pojusaidn. being ischemia necrosi results derives TE, oclusion patent cavitaion involved bronchus occurs occurs involved areas caseous
softeni g softening
caseous
ayy st
THE THE PATHOLOGY
PNEUMOCNIOSE PNEUMOCNIOSE
SNoIgy PATHOLGY various dusts [jews aN]q Rheumatoid bacilli
o}IYM we 10
Rheumatoid infection
10
that Delahant
produced disease and Delahant normal Delahnt sometimes ayy
death
death frequently
dyLOITS these in and emphysema
toid
reverse obtained
The
subsequent varies necrotic above
evi-
can ot be
disease
recoverd by Kelgren
inflamatory reaction reaction necrosis
col agen
It therefore
produced
react
abnormal y
react
pneumocnios pneumoconiosis pneumocniosi
tubercle
bacilli
component of tubercle tubercle
of peculiar
involves
rheumatoid pasage
& PNEUMOCNIOSE
guinea guinea inoculation
1952 as
suggested
et al nodules Sometimes
and the the an plays
tuberculosi the tuberculosi
coalworkesa expctorated bacili leaving coalworkers coalworkers ayy such
stage pathological patholgical patholgical Aq rheumatoid
stage patholgical Hepleston Hepleston
and and
'quiescent
St
Asbestosi Greek Yor of results Cavitation necrosis
in
enclosed
in the
expectorated leaving pasage thin
the
one
has
free from from
calcify and stil others
others Kq
Jo
sit
Jo
Asbestosis
sia[jy term
Asbestosi
derives
indestructible sense indestructible indestructible indestructible refers
sense for
stationary stationary
O8e staionary
unquenchable unquenchable
to certain certain fibrous
enclosed
silicates
caled which a asbestos amount which sjsnpA
gyi
condition
pue
Rheumatoid Pneumoconiosis
Rheumatoid by Rheumatoid
pue purthe Aq Jcaoled
recntly pneumocnis Capln atention amphiboleamphibole magnesium recognized is so croidolite blue rheumatoid
recognized
the
rheumatoid
pneumocnis Caplan atention amosite amphibole includes increasd rheumatoid ocur snolea greatly with magnesium silicate These minerals almost exclusively jo rheumatoid prevalence of mtashivee
discret quarterminers radiographs quarying South Africa masive about radiographs are mined men peculiar peculiar are rounded
NOISH1Td rounde repsent and These eAtsBul procesed blasting manu- These opacites opacites now which
in
in
represent represent
lesions
jeayosjenut nodules arthic moreparle rheumatoid siofuneg the plaster brake asbetos procesing crops and masive parle OSIS ttexhtieles and procesing lesions Charcteisaly Charcteiscaly asfidlepetrhss paper plaster brake asbestos DW of doesdoes tsevheriety apear ANY nodules
in
develop
massive arthritic mmiuncerhs
severity
changes
not necesarily necsarily
Pulmonary Pulmonary contempraneously contempraneously lesions
usually
rapidly
radiological radiological radiological
degre Ul
contemporaneously
when nodules usalymanifestaion may pozlus0da1 ,ployeum, Regulations dimnshed HONOD with manifestaion manifestaion precde 1931havesince arthrits either atending introduction exposure arthrits 40 Regulations Miall
precede precede
by
the
se
other pus
asbestos asbestos Rheumatoid rheumatoidsilcotic nodules fibres recogniton Rheumatoid nodules conetric colagen pulmonary greatlythe Rwheuhmaetoind devloped are wide concentric bcoingcegnterric than necrotic oe
ocurs rheumatoid relation UOTEIABS of conditon that 1927 designatedesignated peripheral zones lines inflamtioninflamtion which colagennecrotic conditon asbetosi relatively esignated 1927 peripheral separted by dust
patholgical reaction o colagen colagen and feature
ad ition addition
nodules relation
"(1
inflamtion nodules from
necrotic
which
tubercle
P61
represnted represnted
The
iron and
magnesium
calcium a South
Italy Africa Africa They
procesed They crushing processed
textiles
and filers
mineral particular
magnesium includes
silicate
croidolite
carding
It
chrysotile chrysotile
contain g
silicates
white
tremolite tremolite
exclusively
Canada
blasting quarying quarying and
linings cement
that
size produced and many respiratory them
In procesd of respiratory
tract
Regulations industrial
the
risks
inhaltion greatly diminished
of recognition usage pulmonary relatively
Cooke
and
can
asbestos
introduction of Asbestos Asbestos Asbestos Industry
exposure
exposure
the inhalation
as a cause
recent as only
McDonald and
the
asbestosi asbestosi The The pathological patholgical reaction
Formation asbetosi These the Zurdojasp uncomnly uncomnly 1. are within alsoalso PATHOLGY metaplsia of PNEUMOCNIOSE ANDbodies show the THE PNEUMOCNIOSE ce 32
J.
944}
GOUGH
HEPLESTON HEPLESTON Ul
00} 2 PATHOLOGY PATHOLOGY
UL} PNEUMOCONIOSES PNEUMOCONIOSES
SI
host fairly rapidly asbetosi found metaplasia asociated of Formation These uncomonly host
which body only withn fibrotic fibrotic fibrocysti usaly depositon sputm evidently 9OUIPAS changes poulation of When devlop exposure carcinoma supervens progres changes epithelial proliferation central fibre
rate of
rapidly
apearance apearance
encased deposition
deposition
the the of Jo
protein
poseses
Ysti ay}
asbestosis fibrocystic fibrocystic
asbestosis asbestosis
malignancy
malignancy
asociated asociated
pulmonary
asbestosis
supervenes
SAOINDWd derived erived tisue presnce encased iron poses and lower poulation usaly squamoussquamous from poseses the general predominatly protein general poulation protein often and
segmnted presnce bead asumes segmented
also sIojsaqe contrast Iselbacher sumarized beade pasvoru cleavages
aperance standig sevre and evidently asbetosi that These evidence asociation bronchgenic sumarized bronchogenic AHL show show disintegration
disntegraion conlude Dol disntegration asbetosi more than industrial coindenc certain carcinomathat disntegration cases hazard fisures asbestosi AO increase asbestosis average Beatie prepartions that Histolgical preartions show s}sIxe asbestosis
ap earance
with
These
1938 Gloyne
proportion proportion proportion smaler
1954a
Beatie
extremities
evidently
long long
smaller
1954b Histolgical
represent represent
or
increases
process
proces of
severe
1951
ADOTHLVd Knoxthat in groups presnce preations show exposedasbetos workers asbetosi Histolgical s[qisod industrial asbestosis
poulation singly respiratoy respiratory more years singly
tre ocur or only sIofmreqny working order employes howevr expriencd genral by tissue reaction
improved working environmet apears inocus extracted introducin since environmet the extracted AHL
from bodies thickend lungs from SUN lungs
respiratory
presence
Their
render them oc ur ed inocuous The
to inocuous
means bronchial
formation
asbestosis
formation
bodies extracted
ue evidence and
UT carcinoma
yey) carcinoma
asbestos
the
Is elbacher
et
concluded
the site of maximum maximum
( 1953 sumarized
the asociation
was
coincidence
the involvement involvement
cancer
more that
average among among
been
of ten
st
experienced
general
experienced
yt
progres ively
progresively dimnished
the
the
introduction the 1931 regulations
Endothelioma Endothelioma
in
humanhuman are unable fibrosiactivencesarily ysnoy Areuowynd,may devlopdevlop introduction thickend fibres themselvesinduce Vorwald guinea al greatly there evidencepleura of silcosi Irvine themselves that silcosi contrast asbestosis asbestosi lung 1951 the asbestos
oul
evidence
Vorwald
Jr 1935-38
Vorwald
or
coalworkers
surround
infrequntly longest formed formed dogmatic in asbetosi spaces sgoeds exist the infrequntly tuberculosi giant engulf pulmonary tuberculosi evidence which whichinfrequently
and at empt attempt attempt
fibres
the air
jo
are
even
pulmonary pulmonary tuberculosi
fragmentary
asbestosis
evidence
evidence
is though
small small
sometimes forms completly vusXyouaredsoSvydsoew asbetosi foreign body Not completly sugest body leser too smal
Merwethr Merwethr dogmatic sometimes 193-34 guinea ingest workersinhaltion 193-34 longest affect In predominatly widespread guinea pulmonary lower of predominatly sen pulmonary affect the
man several
lung
around bronchiles cause comn temporay fibrosis common
respiratoy Two The where alveolar wald have expresd fibrosi expresed alveolar SoIgY wald sacs bronchioles tuberculosi and
NOLSTdH Fibrosi also relation pleura wher uoresagford disntegraion chemicalh bronchioles thesis^tiolgy is that ocurs disntegration Fibrosis
consequnce likely the asumes leading septa in body fluids in consequnce lung and leading changes fibres disntegration of In D
souasoid J{NBue structure be
it
human changes masive liberated of is most fibrosi 1954b ( fibrosis disolve tends asbestosis obliterated
result
paounoid residues masive secondary secondary hornblende chrysotile infection ocured and human
asbestosis asbestosis
in ANF fibrosis
K^...hn exposed the infection masive exposure produce
fibrosis are
predominantly
be
secondary fibrosis guinea
formed
seen
widespread
lodge
pronounced pronunced
massive
Gardner
exposure
118 incidence
Jo oy) ( restricted
Ul
restricted
Suny
al
oy} ul ey) thesis
minerals minerals
minerals
0}
oy,
were exposed
v
In pigs
inhaltion
temporary
pigs
tuberculosis tuberculosi
oq spread
0}
views have
expresed The
on
disintegration
liberated Knox dissolve
1951 occurred
hornblende
occurred
was hornblende hornblende
Beat ie 1954a 1954a dusts
Because
K^...hn
K^...hn
to exposure thought hornbled produce changes failed yduisye chrysotile chrysotile produce alone were after thought asbestos asbestos nontuberculous
but tuberculos uoBer infection nontuberculous
fibrosi foci exprimental evidenc evidenc ofasbetosi HOND notuberculos has cystic down formation disease animals distribution exprimental disease cystic spray hornblende human
the
by Tf
were formed formed asbestosi
asbestosis distribution
distribution
change
change
0}
pue
that
hornblende
bodies The
was persisted
hornblende
experimental
broken
to
cited
formation
Vorwald
patchy evidence adjacent
honeycomb non puMosm human that Brucite develop honeycomb anlogus seaqgy oposed cause apearnce apearance
anlogus otherosvydiovyl howevrhowevr hypotesi OH lung sen givng containg injection The fibrotic honeycomb
*T
Hyperlasi manermaner fibresreaction pulmonaryComplicatons conditons sojeqs intracheal intracheal potency Hyperlasi bronchiolar epithelium may Yoryar sizes Hyperplasia epithelium with particle ce Complications
fibrosed
analogous analogous
bronchiolar bronchiolar
other
epithelium which
*Z
may
to the containing chemical
little containing
silica
very asbestos fibres increases increases
intratracheal
diminishing particle particle but asbestos
6
: *E
Yu ge
Te
oy
HEPLESTON HEPLESTON GOUH GOUGH
HEPPLESTON
long inocus OF practialy Syoipy pneuMOCNIOSE pneuMOCNIOSE the practicaly practicaly hydroxide
asbetos Aluminum (yS6) long efect quartz but asbestos
Nonfibrous
REFRENCS Virchow's paw 39 inert ; tissues WO . tisues
same chemical
9ST
8
9bd 6 TIPTL OT
BP
uas
IZL
the
PATHOLOGY
aads
REFERENCES
yay eZ o OL OT
Although compsiton xosuL Aisnpul chrysotile (961) (6P61) BCEBART 319 CPS Cochrane A
E.
same fibrous chrysotile Mial compositon they CAPLAN f
T.
SAOINDWd JarmaN compsiton they ouvapy Mial and HOCKADY fibrous ($S61) hypothesi chemical Cochrane 1956 Tubercle Tubercle Cochrane
E. 48
fT 48 hence hence
COHRANE 274 the both now 1952 The
hypothesis must of mechanical iritation
CARPENTER (
COCHRANE COCHRANE A. L. 1954 Brit
and favoured
fibres
A
Cox
T. 1952
Vorwald sems mechanicl HIMONA flexible Jarman 1024 to minimum (S61) COHRANE 1927 G. COKE W. E. L. Brit AHL J. 2 et minimum long acording
must
al
20-50
required required
IN
Brit
1952
1952
length acording required
U
OS 1931
SHONA J. Vorwald CUMINS WATERS E. pigminimum inflexible and Weatheral
and CambCamb produce the CUMINS CUMINS S. L. WATERS T. AO
produce
guinea guinea
length inflexible fibres fibres of glass OD d
WATERS
only Furthermoe Weatheral the flexible 1938 J. wo l non Furthermoe flexible fibres are Tvag CUMINS Weatheral Weatheral non fibrogenic fibrogenic fibrogenic Furthermore
the
fibres
fibres
PUBV
W
UL
S. and CUMMINS CUMMINS
WILLIAMS
1938
) 638
f
apear the E. Camb sites GARDNER Med Brit Hyg only TU peritoneum the fibrogenic Hyg in that pue in lung
peritoneum that is
normally
)
lung
peritoneum
195 U. As GARDNERGARDNER GARDNER J.industr apear considerations movement It from considerations ad 'S
ADOTHLYd actpathogensi and setled NOIsa1dyH WILAMS Silcosi Silcosi subjectd regular canotcanotfrom regarde considerations LaboratoryLaboratorySymposium movement considerations asbestosi that
settled
A Gardner GARDNER GARDNER Gardner L. U. 1937 Third Saranac Laboratory
Laboratory of regarde as Saranac regarded regarde 1938 Symposium Asbestosi pathogenesis
asbestosis
GARDNER University University University U. 1938 in Lanza
) Silicosis Silicosis
Asbestosis Asbestosis
Sugary thatthepathogensi setled. (LS61) SANE 7
pathogensi Pneumocnios GARDNER pathogensi Pneumocnios Pneumocnios (AT "VW Talc
A YU pue
331 OU
f
"4
(9S61) Pneumocnios , AL med Asbestosis Pneumocnios A'S Ass Tf and H10 V
Talc
Talc
silcate which magnesium Pure Pure talc is magnesium
S
S f f f f LE 'f
Amer
114
Lanza
Asbestosis
f
compact compacthydrated hydrated magnesiumplatessilcate comercialcomercial comercialocurs GLOYNEGardnerUniverstyUniversty UniverstyPres 1940p 235 ed Silcosi and hydrated magnesium ocursmayin Hont5009 HONH J. Lanza A. )Silcosi Asbestosi Oxford foliated magnesium Asbestosis foliated or
S.
pneumocnios pneumocniospneumocnios pneumoconiosis
pneumoconiosis
to diagnosed clinically
come come
accounts
aprxorpky clincaly have Poro accounts
diagnosed autopsy 1949 acounts 1951 given )
1951 Schepers and
talc
Hunt talc charcterized pneumocnios fibrosis wniurmy nodular fibrosi pneumocnis and
NOLSATdaH nodules scaterd nedles
is
pneumocniosi pneumocnios does charcterized
asbestosinumerous the
birefringent
birefringent birefringent particles
scatered asbestosis
ash from bodies
snout scaterd case McLaughlin DY showed showed
that probaly dried lung
whilst the the anlysi lung X difraction UNV on
was there
probably than
case
ray
ray difraction
tion anlysi 0.5
quartz HoOND quartzThere histolgical f ose There
histolgical may minerals pneumocnios histolgical simlarity pneumocnios talc pneumoconiosis
pneumocnios form or resemblance
constiution resmblanceresemblance
of lung residues residues
certain
UT
certain
which constitution
chemical strengthened
case
Hunt's
similarity
depend
depend minerals of the
ocurence
bodies
resmblance strengthend strengthend ocurencocurence ve bvoedies in both conditons conditons
0} the
eq)
be n GOUGH WENTWORTH 1949 )more havehave been
Jo
useq
McLaughlin
McLaughlin
saseo
aavy
Thorax Fac McLaughlin RIVERS MASIE Bact by maj
and 453 MedMed by and218 sJow HEPLESTON Aq
difuse ING
difuse AjoaTefoy Arch resmbling HEPLESTON G.1954b . sjsui resembling
Theparwiedas HEPLSTON adUIN90 67 X
Weqiose Coun ksdone puadap al uayi 0}
McLaughlin presnt in Nagelschmidt 75 the HEPLESTON 1956 awicd silica present pue pue
indicated than R. Nagelschmidt 287 Med J. sopmod Phtis paf]ty savy The
dif rac-
indicated
less
Klaus Johanesburg ISELBACHER les 1s1y
Johanesburg asbestosis
S}
KILPATRICK Brit asbetosiasbetosi Sunsnp S. HEPLESTON 152 1954 similar
and OO
responsible responsible The ayL Jay[y
siotunsud Arch &
KnoxKnox industr asbetosi asbetosi Beatie Beatie J. 1954aNAGELSCHMIDT G. Bury like asbestosi
se
OS|e st esn oye}
GOUGH J. JAMES
R. L. W. GOUGH
H. SEAL HARDING
and WENTWORTH WENTWORTH
UL ul
MASSIE 1955
J.
HEPLESTON 59 HEPPLESTON
Path
1953 Path Bact Hyg Path
E. J.
JO
oy}
HEP LESTON
HEPPLESTON
HEPLESTON HEPLESTON A.
G. HEPPLESTON
Hicks
HUNT
ISELBACHER J.
W. 1955
J. KEL GREN KILPATRICK KILPATRICK
E. ZAIDI
and F.
F.
1954b
349
BactPath
Thorax
195 374 Thorax , Path G. 1943 Med Nagelschmidt
UO
3yi Spec
Spec
Coun Rep
Miners Bureau 11 H. L. J. Hardy Tuberc Tuberc Med
and 1956ulej1091956 12
med J. FLETCHER
HEP LESTON
C.
and and NAGELSCHMIDT NAGELSCHMIDT
SI
NAGELSCHMIDT
st
Thorax
Hlth industr
%%
Hlth Arch industr industr Hyg 23 WAOJ
Uosful yuaryp Gewrbehyg soyval UGA SJasa UIBWOL yoay]o goeds jsOur eoo HEPLESTON HEPLESTON
JOYE
JO sso]
jo
s[jao
ATuwo
,
UT
HEPLSTON Foundry aSeUApe sovkoseyd yomjou Gewrbehyg Diseases 9SUBI arom .
Steel
Foundry soidno OUIBS ayinb Foundry
snp 9 IF OY} ysnp s][2d
sem s] 9o YM asop
saporyed sepoaye CHAPTER G. C. Brit PUNOIe industr Disease 1949 asay industr . 9Y} oy], SOT] Jo CHAPTER CHAPTER are oq} IasyN}p uey.
11
Dunham [BoyORNeU Z)IVN) ay}
@
[eo UT oy) ISI
e
Inq
COHRANE 69 QUITJAT] and UMOUY REACTION OF DUST APyomb Thorax
pure SB Ng
REACTION
0} JsNp qe REACTION
THE THE
TO
DUST
(soj}weIp Kilpatrick sus Tubercle 15
and
1B
REACTION
ynq
oy} DUST
Kilpatrick OldhAM REACTION CAPLAN LUNG COHRANE L. OldhAM Bun T By BuN T esow Ser No. 1953
1231
0}
S. J. A[IVoN) payord Res Suny 244 Spec
B 7
ay)
7
sy,
sev
Ava eB
Har ison
Le
King
NAGELSCHMIDT SUOMBAT SUT-[ZO0d and DUSTHarison V. UaAId Med Ghezi Med King Spec Joys CEpelin 48 Ghezi
Lavoro
Jo
Wey} Jo jye
C. Harrison
Roentgenol Lavoro oures PATTON
1942
380 BY}
oJOM
3snp
Postgraduate
Ssof folowing
Medical School Schol London
1957 uoNIvaY Amer acount HOBBS Jr. Amer Roentgenol
THE descripton Roentgenol acount atempts and phot- Dtsch
snp THE
show show description description
AUFDERMAU folwing atempts Dtsch aATSqO reacts Wschr AUFDERMAUR M.
Wschr
Hlth &
ayy ayL
account
folowing how how
animal circumstances circumstances
circumstances
dusts
experiment diferent under under
195 simplified experiment 182 O} jo
circumstances circumstances
animal
BOVET 1952 industr consider before of before experiment Arch
Med Hlth STU sn
consider consider
reactions
human human
complicated
367
Publ Transval during worke's complicated Transval Inst
conditions the reactions
conditions
during worker's worker's
more
& complicated
SUIMOTIe uonerde we quartz obtain conditions The dutshtsat have most quartz and
SilcosiPneumoknios Pneumoknis Pneumoknis Dust experiments has given Silicosis
Pneumokniosi and
London Jo ous
of
our experiments experiments experiments the dust been been
single intratracheal intratracheal
industr BAH SAH and
1951 Arch Hyg
this
VORWALD C. Hyg J. J. E. ) HARRISON
(
49
J. MITCHISON
Amer A. aisnpul aisnpul particle MITCHISON exper 553 KING BP MITCHISON D. 9 ...
Brit Path S ON
Pub
"PAW *
f
"LTL SGI
"Yay alveoli alveoli
pdaOMoaDT AISNpUl (6b61) (COp6T) "YOSIT uo]
'D tas
ISUT 204d UAL POL
alveoli
(Pp
siomyunag 30 pay ELp fo
thes MOLVA *(7p6]) (ZS61) AVS(IE61) PAW days DM Uisuy "PAW Yosy day OL "601
NOLSATdH AISNPUL aad 6T9Y savsiq s}ori7s' (LS61) (S61) Idns adxe 19nd ST
SNVHOAC EISHOMC migrate WV 9
AL (W
W
D pue
TI
*f 60L
'O respiratory
d
respiratory
"LE
uo "pf SLE
SAyoquamn uopu0 migrate unod sasuq Spy SunTSZOI and CAME 'V
anvANudiny ajovaqny SANIAY] SasOH{ (SE61D) *(9S61) situ (AL CYtod "IEZI oads fu0pUIA, 2 pur say
joiasnpuy IZ HD s2WJO (861) GN reticulin H9Dg EV "SV YID sf
A ep
NVUHOD NYauNG within "UISU] TSpaw 0rd pate g
Pure pue
pue
Y
HOND -yrndaquny (pe-<E61) sugo0y day Yl0d VW
d
a *p
Op
pue gT1
S
'V ON
OT
PUR fine
f sf A@
within within the
'O "egg
AIQUOIES NVHOULS INVH1IEG xosy NOxIq SINUS (0S61D) (ey61) (LP61) sau With IE Pat OD
'NWHOVULS The uaAog (p61) "Yo4P WU HAT SSF I
SNIVdD dust NVIdVD NOLVd OI(L761) (S61 (SE61) pue D "HM is IA'H SV VpSl A
'
swan (es6) 9
uowsatdngy NITHO*SV4290M SNITHOAW uOpuoT (TP61) COA per rat Paw d'd EIPI pan CH f
pue 'f
With fibrogenic
into OD pur Ul pue f Pf The Wdiutsht
SY
'f
MA f "OD "AA "AA AA
'V "WY 50 mg fA
"ALOS
dJA
'p9
Lb LL
C
clusters
AIVNOQ Weasl LAIWHOSTVN WANLOY SUadTHOS NVHOULS ZaNOZVA SAIWMAO SOIVMOA into clusters SINVITOIA NVIAL STIVTAL SINWAdSOUNOd NOSHIS'NOSNIS NOSI NHOW clusters 9 TOW PW