Document 7OB3vjE3a8vRpBm4vqpk2dQ4o
FILE NAME Owens Illinois Library OWL
DATE 1931
DOC OWL009
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Relevant Article & Abstracts from The Journal of
Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL
HYGIENE
EDITORS
DAVID L. EDSALL M. D. S. D. United States EDGAR L. COLLIS M. D. M. R.C. Great Britain
VOLUME XIII JANUARY DECEMBER 1931
PUBLISHED BY
HARVARD SCHOOL OF PUBLIC HEALTH Boston Mass
360 THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIALINDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
in Muscular Activity V. Changes
and Adaptations in Running Jour Biol Chem 1928 78 445 33. ADOLPH E. The Nature of the
Activities of the Human Sweat
Glands Am Jour Physiol 1923
66 445
34. BAIRD M. M. AND HALDANE J. B. .:
Salt and Water Elimination in Man
Jour Physiol 1922 56 259 35. KITTSTEINER C Sekretion Kochsalz-
gehalt und Reaktion des Schweisses Arch f Hyg 1911 73 275. Quoted in 31
36. VIALE .: Absorption et ^'limination
cutan^'ede l'eau et du chlorure so-
dique Arch ital de biol 1915 63 321. Quoted in 31
37. CRAMER .: Ueber die Beziehung der
Kleidung
f
zur
Hautth^/tigkeit
Arch
Hyg 1890 10 231
38. H^ GLERF. AND UEBERRACK K ^ ber
. den Wasser- und Salzstoffwechsel nach Schwitzen Wien Arch f inn Med
1927 13 465
39. SAYERS R. R. AND DAVENPORT S. .: ' Review of Literature on the Physiological Effects of Abnormal Temperatures and Humidities U. S. Pub Health Rep 1927 42 933
40. Queries and Minor Notes Jour Am Med Assn 1931 96 133 and 2055
41. ELLIOTT M. .: Heat Exhaustion on Men Mil Surgeon 1908 22 227. Quoted in 3
This is
sho and one
Notices are
For ntntrry y in par aut
BRASIVE BRASIVE
Clark AIR condit
coal mi and Wa coolomet
'
power mine mine Bedfo
ee RESTOS
bercul
Cumm
workers
sis bo
a
BESTOSI
bestos
Gloyi
ATMOSPHE
PUNZENE (
4
pound
:
pors
i Smyt
HOOD
.
Kirk
of of plu
* HERS
ER
eral
CRON
from | Dude ick
Diova
"egr
{
33 ou
Ward
| fs A min
( ONE =
c power
CHANIDE
Re DENTAL
1 $6 wes 09B8 AWULIOD CANo2DyO Te Ror CE SIG ow e e
MME HAP ee rer eeee
i,
mea Tew
eet Me igh
org
re
rr
(o
1D}
lie th^/tigkeitth^/tigkeit
th^/tigkeit th^/tigkeit
ERRACK stoffwechsel stoffwechsel
arch inn arch. .inn. inn
)
on
the
the
VOLUME XIII INDEX INDEX
SUBJECT HYGIENE, matter matter in VOLUME XIII
HYGIENE
and This subjtehcetresufbojercet itnhdeerxefionrdeexlaoolklfroeradrienagding matw terothred JOURNAtL hJeOfUolRloNwAinLg IINDNUDSTURSIATLRexIcepAtiLon HYGIENE
Notices NMeodtiNotciceessona ere indexed under this on
entry .:
entry
parenthesis
For author
index
see
page
PAGE
;
__
eon normal normal
ies U.
ies. 2 933933 PPub. 2 933
_
otes. 133 2055 2055 , 133 an
SurgSeurogneon 1908
. Surgeon, 1908,, #2
PAGE
hazard
ABRASIVE iABRASIVE ndustry industry hazard hazard
conditionswoworrkikngiwnogrkcaipnacgitcyapacicatpacyity Ain ccoaolndaitniodnsWarner relation relation Bedford
in
.
DUST retent.ion factors involved in
involved involved in retent facti ors io nvolvn ed in
DYSMDYESMENNORORHERA RDYHSMEENORARHEAamamoongng female clerks at Insurance Company Metroplitan Metropolitan
owe
-
_
3
:
3
i
}m
:
co ling coolometer
measuring cooling
power Weeks measuring
261
workers Gardner 135 sputum temperatures mine
reduction reduction temperatures reduction reduction
mine, Bedford
dust Warner primary 77
ASBESTOS primary
berculous berculous infection infection
and
Cummings Cummings Gardner
asbesto- method method staining
sputum sputum asbesto-
bodies bodies sis BESTOSIS BESTOSIS
Gloyne
bestos workers workers method staining staining
Gloyne Gloyne method method staining
eee .
eee
ee
65
85
85
ATMOSPHERE Air
ANZENE see Air.
toxicity ; pounds
toxicity
of Smyth .
87
air determination determination apors determination Smyth
of
Ip
air
+ OD
227 pressure
industry in industry
basophilia
m le
punctate - * of
punctate basophilia basophilia plumbism
Lane
basophilia control
) basophilia control
314
Schwartz dermatitis HpEluRmbSism *
Schwa ) rtz
.---
potency 233 ER carcinogenic
BON MONOXIDE Twort ) min-
Dudding from
MONOXIDE
sealed compartments compartments
and Freder-
ick Dudding Dudley Dudley
DIOVASCULAR impairment impairment
Freder-
...
oo. importance of points
ELECTRIC injuries
importance points
ELECTRIC contact in
and
pulse Kouwenhoven
Langworthy
discharge of and
injuries produced by
im-
generator discharge
Kouwenhoven . Lanagnwdordt eahty h EMPLOYMENT sickness
rates Stevens
FACTORY workers negro cardiovascu- 164
lar impairment in cardiovascunegro physical impairment 157
in
Allen
workers industry industry FATIGUE in
185 ce impairment
subjective side
185
pag
293 FUMHEeSrrseeteyntio.n-o-c f:c fc ac cc tors involved 185
Brown
injuries
injuries
impulse
Langworthy injuries
GENERATOR produced impulse 326 eeenee Kouwenhoven cence
National Institute
Cumming Cumming of treatment preven- preven-
tion with
chloride 347 347
HYPERTENSION 347 HYPERTENSION
sodium
Blood Blood pressure
HYPERTENSION
;
:
night DIOVASCULAR egro factory
dental workers
(
Ward
Pedley
Pedley Montreal 269 and Montreal e Ward
....164
HOMETER for
cooling
HOMETER measuring Weeks measuring power
NSIDE von Bernewitz 115
269 115
DENTAL clinic ..---nceeererct 115
DENTAL
DENTAL
clinic
night
Montreal
primary Dar asbestos effect on
269
<a
tuberculous tuberculous infection Gardner
Gardner Ei: hazard Cummings Cummings industry on
rational industry Clark
rec- 343
~
rational
calculating
calculating
rational obtained _ ords obtained obtained Owens counter
343
tention concentrations Broumstein Broumstein below 10 concentrations concentrations below 50
tention :
Ri.
ver
cubic
Brown
below 50
mtention, concentrations
285
woe porenbie meter (Brown). ...--
sulphur determining
for
dioxide Smith and determining
338
338
silicosis conference INTERNATIONAL
Badham conference conference
i Johannesburg
169
Badham Johannesburg Badham
Warner Warner
ane-
mo mom mete ertBee dfr ord Warner Warner 4
punctate mation Krans Fipcuncktatle ebnaseosptih-i1l4ia0 1
control
r^le (
Lane .. basophilia
control 276
LINSEED dermatitis dermatitis Barnes 49
coal miners 19 19
METHYL CHLORIDE miners ....------0007"" ,
Somers temperatures toxicity White 273 of
Bedford
temperatures 135
135
Bedford Bedford Warner
(Bedford and Warner)...--.sreres
273 135
.
:
362
JOURNAL JOURNAL INDUSTRIAL INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
Miner,
coal,
radio
PAGR
study of PAGE PAGE
coal radiographic radiographic study in-
dustrially healthy
conditions coal
miners
Wales
capacity in relation relation
awtomrkoisnpghercic apacity capacity relation relation
and Warner .. mineral mineral
SKIN diseases
N
NATIONALInstitute Health
U. S.
NATIONAL Institute
Institute Health 1 prevention Public
Institute Institute
Health Cuming Cumming
SPUTUM
Health
Service
1
cardiovascular
SPUTUM
workers
impairment
ae
imipmpaaiirrmmenetnt Allen asbestosisimbpoidniegser impinger impairment
physical impairimmpeanirtment SULPHUR
impairm impairmene t impain rment t 157 157
an OIL mineral carcinogenic mineral carcinogenic carcinogenic potency of 204 TUBERCULOSIS
from mings on compartments monoxide PAINT production carbon carbon production sealed in Dudding 97 333
PHYSICAL Dudley among negro factory workers Allen 3 . 157
dermatitis cyanide international
conference
international
Pacy
Johannesburg Badham conference
diseases butchers dermatitis dermatitis le
cy. anide rash von Berne- 115
linseed treatment CHLORIDE
CHLORIDE SPUTUM asbestosis
SPUTUM
and ddere matir tis matitis
heat
asbestosis asbestosis bodies
treatment Glo- and cramps Glo- 347
method method
ee
15 4
a
in, 85 of
SULPHUR
Smith and for 83
determination Smith and 338
reduction 338
TEMPERATURE Warner reduction 135 of
TUBERCULOSIS primary
asbes- 135
dner Cum- Cum-
TUBERCULOSIS Gar
97
on Gardner 65
mings
a9
National Institute Institute Health
Cumming miners miners reloa-f RADIOACTIVE SUBSTANCES dangers in refining Schlundt McGavock and McGavock and Brown 117
a1
Warner). tioBnedforadtmosapndheric atmospheric atmospheric conditions conditions 252
Warner
Bedford and
252
ve
eeeeesaes
1
\e
. HYGIENE
SUBJECT INDEX
363
ternational
-burg 1930
conference conference
BadhamBadham
butchers
BOOK NOTICES
PAGE
) Criminal Kessler dermatitis dermatitis Liability eed
115
RIDE in treatmBeanrtnes . 49
1 of heat
Glo- cramps bodies te
osis
bodies
in
method
method of
347
.. impinger
loyne .. impinger
hygiene iIoDnE iomfpinger impinger unit for Smith and
Pregl Tt
tee, 338
Gewerbekrankheiten mine air reductionreduction of
Warner)
Accidental Alexander
injuries
.
eeeeee
F. and Staub H The
the Judge and the Pub-
331
Alimentary tract protozoan parasitism
of Lynch . parasitismparasitismparasitism
Allen J. R. and Walker J. H Heat-
ing and Ventilation 331
Appel K. E. see Strecker E. A. Atmospheres mine Payman and Sta-
tham
cece
eee 266
Brezina E Internationale ^ bersicht
^...ber
nach den
Berichten der Gewerbeaufsichtsbe-
h^rden der Kulturl^/nder ^...ber die
PAPAGGE E
Kessler H. H Accidental Injuries The Medico Aspects of Workmen's Compensation and Public Liability Protozoan 331
Lynch K. M Protozoan Parasitism of the Alimentary Tract Pathology
Diagnosis and Treatment
Mental
in industry Elkind 231
Microanalysis quantitative organic
...... 116
Mind human view of and how it works
Strecker and Appel
Mine atmospheres Payman and Sta-
tham
0 persPo ayman n anda Stl a- 266
Gardner rimary, effeecffectt of asbesGardner and Cum-
THe eee
teeeeeeey, 6597
ublic Health Service
stitute of Health of
Jahre 1920 bis 1926
Criminal judge and public Alexander
and Staub Alexander . ceeeees
Currie J. R A Textbook of Hygiene
Disease prevention in community Hil-
liard
00... ce
eee eeeeesenesseues
45
144 82
144
,
Oberteuffer D. see Williams J. F.
Occupation vol )
and health encyclopedia
ce cece ccceceaeevecaeenees 292
Payman W. and Statham I. C. .: Mine Atmospheres 266
coal miners in rela-
ospheric conditiconoditniosns
Warner ) .. re
Nurses .. Hygiene Hygiene 84 232
Elkind H. B Preventive Manage-
ment Mental Hygiene in Indus-
.
eee eee cence ee Talbot
Epilepsy Talbot 84 231 Epilepsy
treatment of
232
Epilepsy Flury F. and Zernik .: Sch^/dliche Gase D^/mpfe D^/mpfe Nebel Rauch- und
Staubarten .. Rauch- Rauch- Rauch- und 292
Food analysis Woodman 231
Gas Sch^/dlicheGase D^/mpfeNebel
Rauch- und Staubarten Flury and ZernikZernik ...
Pregl F Quantitative Organic Micro-
analysis
.. .
eee ccc cee ee ceecuees
116
Protozoan parasitism of alimentary tract Lynch
Quinine in general practice Johannes-
sohn
ccc ce cece ee ccc enceceeees
144
Oberteuffer Schools industrial hygiene for Wil-
liams and
cenen ees
82
Silicosis records of international con-
ference held at Johannesburg 1930 183
Statham I. C. F. see Payman W.
Staub H. see Alexander F.
Stimson P. M A Manual of the Com-
mon Contagious Diseases 84
Strecker E. A. and Appel K. E Dis-
covering Ourselves A View of the
Human Mind and How It Works 144
Epilepsy 232 Talbot F. B Treatment of
Commu- Turner C. E Personal and
nity Health tence
eeenaee
82
Hygiene personal for nurses Egbert
2
Hygiene textbook of Currie 82 Industrial diseases international re-
view of 1920-1926 Brezina 45
Industrial hygiene for schools Williams and Oberteuffer
Injuries accidental Kessler 331 International conference on silicosis
Johannesburg 1930 records .... 183 Johannessohn .: Chinin in der Allge-
meinpraxis bocce eeneees 144
Unemployment case studies of 144
Ventilation heating and Allen and
Walker . Allen and(Allen Allen and 331
Walker J. H. see Allen J. R.
Williams J. F. and Oberteuffer D Industrial Hygiene for Schools 82
Woodman A. .: Food Analysis Typical Methods and the Interpretation of Results 231
Workmen's Compensation for acciden-
tal injuries Kessler
331
Zernik F. see Flury F.
sent considerable difonon artificial media
knowledgment must be ections will be made for
bibliography chusetts General .
with bibliography bibliography
bibliography W York The
COMMON CONTAGIOUS
Philip Moen Stimson ciate in Pediatrics Coredical College Attend-
illard Parker Hospital
Floating Hospital of
Chief of Clinic Depart, Cornell Clinic School Horace Mann Schools ent the School Physi
1928-1930 Fabrikoid
index and illustrations . & Febiger 1931
H.
Feb. 1981
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
VOLUME XIII
MARCH 1931
NUMBER 3
A METHOD OF STAINING THE ASBESTOSIS BODIES FOUND IN
THE SPUTUM OF ASBESTOS WORKERS
S. ROODHOUSE GLOYNE M.D. D.P.H.
Pathologist City of London Hospital for Diseases of the Heart and Lungs Victoria Park London
T HERE is a consensus of opinion
that the asbestosis bodies found
T
in the sputum and lungs of
asbestos workers do not stain with the
ordinary aniline dyes This failure to stain has been one of the difficulties
hour and then recentrifuged and the
deposit mounted as a wet preparation
By this means the asbestosis bodies become a dark brown to black color
according to the length of time they have been exposed to the hematoxylin
in working out their relation to the histology of the disease and in determining their composition By employing the following technic the bodies can be made to take on a definite color which enables them to be
better studied
HEMATOXYLIN
After digestion of the sputum with
equal quantities of concentrated anti-
formin as described by Stewart and
Haddow 1 and centrifugation the
Antiformin is pipetted off and replaced
by a 5 per cent solution of Ehrlich's
hematoxylin Bluing of the hemaxylin immediately takes place owing
to the remains of the alkaline anti-
formin The mixture is well shaken
and allowed to stand for a half to one
*
Received for publication Nov. 22 1930
PRUSSIAN BLUE REACTION
The reaction of the asbestosis body to Prussian blue was first described by
Cooke and Hill 2 and McDonald
3 The foregoing technic is used but the following mixture is substituted for hematoxylin 2 per cent potassium
ferrocyanide part 1 per cent hydrochloric acid parts With this
technic the asbestosis bodies are
colored a brilliant blue A potassium ferricyanide mixture may also be used but the results are variable some asbestosis bodies being stained others
not
AMMONIUM SULPHIDE
The same technic is used but am-
monium sulphide is substituted for
hematoxylin or potassium ferocyanideferrocyanide
The asbestosis bodies are then colored
85
86
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
black This color can be removed
with hydrochloric acid
DISCUSSION
When examined microscopically the hematoxylin specimens give the impression of having hematoxylin deposited on them rather than having actually taken up the stain but after washing overnight the asbestosis bodies still retain sufficient stain to be
colored a dark brown With the ferro-
cyanide ammonium sulphide technic the bodies are homogenously stained
The advantages of this technic are 1 The minute details of the asbestosis body can be better seen than in the unstained preparation e.g. the central core of asbestos fiber generally stands out clearly and can sometimes be seen running across a gap between two segments of the asbestosis body rather like the string between beads on a
necklace The fiber takes on the stain
only very sometimes indeed
not at but the contrast with the
stained body is sufficient to demonstrate quite clearly its existence The outlines of the segments are also very clearly seen and the small subsidiary
bosses on the sides of the asbestosis
body and the cracks in the segments
are better distinguished by this method than in the unstained preparation .-+ 2 These reactions support the view
that iron enters into the composition of
the bodies The Prussian blue reaction
is a known test for iron and am-
monium sulphide is universally employed as a group reagent for iron Hematoxylin also has an affinity for
iron but the reaction in this case is inferior to that given by the other
methods
The amount of iron found in raw
asbestos varies considerably According to Merewether 4 the two main varieties of asbestos used in industry are 1 a larger portion known as
chrysotile a hydrated magnesium
silicate with a low percentage of iron
oxides 0.7 to 4.4 per cent and 2 a smaller portion known as crocidolite
amosite and tremolite which have a
high percentage of iron oxides 3.2 to 44 per cent The latter group is the one used in the factory which produces the cases seen at this Hospital
Cooke and Hill 5 have also suggested that blood may enter into the
composition of the asbestosis body
Oxyhemoglobin contains 0.335 per cent of iron 6
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. STEWART M. J AND HADDOW A. C
Demonstration of the Peculiar Bodies
of Pulmonary Asbestosis Asbestosis
Bodies in Material Obtained by Lung Puncture and in the Sputum Jour Path and Bacteriol 1929 32 172 2. Cooke W. E. AND HILL C. .: Pneumokoniosis Due to Asbestos
Dust Jour
47 232
Roy
Micr Soc 1927
3. McDONALD .: Histology of Pulmonary Asbestosis Brit Med Jour 1927 2 1025
4. MEREWETHER R. A The Occurrence of Pulmonary Fibrosis and Other Pul-
monary Affections in Asbestos Workers
THIS JOUR 1930 12 198 239 5. Cooke W. E. AND HILL C. F Further
Observations on Pulmonary Asbestosis with Special Reference to Asbestos
Dust and the Curious Bodies Found in
the Lungs Jour Roy Micr Soc 1930 50 15 6. STARLING E. H Principles of Human Physiology Fourth edition London J. & A. Churchill 1926
H. March 1931
THE TOXICITY OF
HENRY
Assistant Professor ,,
INTRODUCTION
title of this pap
T gest a very wide rar pounds about the some of which we have (
information but about th
we know little or nothi recently appealed to by a
company to outline a prog
handling of a compound th know was used in industr
the toxicity of which noth
published so far as I know
However though the d
benzene are legion yet
themselves into certain r about certain members of w information In most ca
of a class act on the syster
manner and differences i
differences of degree rat
kind There are except
general rule however sc will be pointed out later
GENERAL CONDI
Benzene C6H6 is the s .. pound of all and the bo
the basis on which all t formed The called
* Read before the Sectio
Hygiene of the American
Association Fort
Worth
1930
Received
Vol 13 No. 3
o
com
Bre
64
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
ord
as facts quite as significant to our ec- employment standards would furnish
onomic and social health as are births and deaths and contagious diseases to
employment information as fundamental as physical sickness and death
our physical public health The official registration of all cases of employment discharge with actual reasons
would involve obvious difficulties
Nevertheless some provision under
which industrial management might
submit to a properly constituted governmental function the undisguised
facts of its experience in maintaining
rates in sociologic studies The facts
thus revealed should go far toward
laying a foundation for practical measures sounder than the impressions and sentiments upon which sociologists
and economists and government offi-
cials have hitherto been obliged to base
their efforts toward the relief of unem-
ployment
STUD LA
T
templa
pneum
Sarana twelve
attenti halatio of ind that tl
gated
and sol action several in conn hard s suited with a Hoffma
perimen
tion to of Dr. 1 tion of Labora
ceedingl plant a perimen 1928 exposed
The stu
* Rece
h
h
OY
STUDIES ON EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMONOKONIOSIS VI INHA-
ne
LATION OF ASBESTOS DUST ITS EFFECT UPON PRIMARY
- TUBERCULOUS INFECTION
g
LEROY U. GARDNER AND DONALD E. CUMMINGS
ne
From the Saranac Laboratory for the Study of Tuberculosis
Pan
The Edward L. Trudeau Foundation Saranac Lake New York
experimental investigation
Tof the reaction to inhaled asbestos dust had long been con-
since so much interest has recently been manifested in the subject of asbestosis a preliminary report is sub-
templated as a part of the study of mitted at this time
pneumonokoniosis carried on at the Saranac Laboratory during the past
ASBESTOS DUST
twelve years During that time little
The dust employed in this study
attention had been paid to the in-
halation of asbestos dust as the cause
when dry is a light fluffy white
stringy substance composed of short
of industrial disease It was hoped fibers and irregular particles Com-
that this substance might be investi- mercially this grade of asbestos is
gated because it is a relatively soft and soluble silicate the study of whose
known as King's floats For a proper understanding of its physical
action might shed some light upon several of the vexing problems arising
characteristics a brief consideration
of its occurrence in nature and its
in connection with the inhalation of method of preparation is necessary
hard silicious dusts It admirably The Thetford asbestos is known as
suited our plans therefore to comply with a suggestion of Dr. Frederick L. Hoffman that we undertake an experimental investigation of the reac-
chrysotile a member of the serpentine group of minerals Pure chrysotile is a silky white fibrous substance but the presence of iron in varying states of
tion to this substance At the request oxidation usually gives it a greenish
of Dr. Hoffman the Asbestos Corpora-
tion of America has furnished the
or greenish color It is composed of tightly packed bundles of
Laboratory with 600 pounds of exceedingly fine asbestos dust from its plant at Thetford Quebec The experiment was started in January 1928 and animals have now been exposed for two years and five months The study is not yet completed but
smooth flexible fibers which are about 0.05 micron in diameter and which vary from 1/8 inch to 6 inches in length In nature these fibers occur in veins which are embedded in hard serpentine rock The thickness of the vein determines the length of the
* Received for publication July 18 1930 fibers which run across it
-
65
tye
yee
oR
To
eee
ee
RaeBe
lt
victors ae Nn
ea ich
ota
Bhesa
aIe
Oye
OE
ee
.
at
en
ere .
66
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
The King's floats grade of asbestos contains only short fibers which occur
in very narrow veins The hard ser-
pentine matrix rich in small veins is crushed dried recrushed screened and pulverized and finally passed over shaking screens from which the fibers
are withdrawn by suction The material is then graded by screening and
the fraction which passes the finest
screen is allowed to settle in a large room Such material King's floats contains not only short fibers but in
The dust has a specific gravity of 2.26 It loses only about 1 per cent
of its weight when heated at 110
yet in a moist atmosphere sufficient
water is absorbed to increase notice-
ably its tendency to clumping or matting
In chemical composition pure chrysotile is chiefly composed of crystalline hydrated silicate of magnesium
3MgO 2H2O It is however
seldom free from impurities which partially replace the magnesium to form more complex silicates Ferrous iron is the most common contaminant
and it may sometimes constitute as
much as 10 per cent of the mineral as it occurs in nature A portion of this iron may be oxidized to the ferric state
The following analysis has been made from samples of the dust used in the study
FIG Asbestos dust X90
addition many small particles of serpentine rock
Microscopic examination reveals the fact that particulate matter is far in
excess of fibrous material The particles vary in size from 10 microns to 0.5 micron in diameter The fibrous
traction is less uniform In length
the fibers vary from 1 mm to 1 micron
or less Many isolated long smooth thin flexible strands are seen while
others consist of short thick bundles with broken ends The fibers are
highly refractile when viewed by polarized light See Fig 1.
%
Total SiO 00. ce. eee 39.32
Fe2O3 Al O. 3 CaOCaO
re
8.84 8.84
0.67
MgO
0... cece 35.56
Alkalies and loss 2.87
Combined water 12.74
Free SiO by rational analysis=
2.6
The material reported as aluminium oxide and ferric oxide was largely the latter Preparations of the dust stained with potassium ferricyanide and dilute hydrochloric acid indicate
that there is ferrous iron in the ma-
jority of the fibers a few exhibit
irregular staining with ferrocyanide Anderson and Clark 1 have shown
that treatment of Thetford chrysotile with hydrochloric acid completely destroys the typical crystalline pattern
Pr Ee ee Ce DEPT Se Ce ea Ot Ce er
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
67
gravity of
1 per cent
at 110
re sufficient ase notice-
umping or
of the material produced in Bragg's ray diffraction technic
Careful and repeated search has failed to disclose any yellow structures resembling asbestosis bodies in the dust previous to its residence in the
sated by frequently changing the position of the cages on the racks
As measured by the operation of the motor the daily period of exposure is eight hours but since the animals remain in this room during the night
ion pure
ed of crys
animal The appearance and method
of development of these structures
will be discussed later
the actual exposure is much longer considerable time being required for all the dust in the atmosphere to settle
magnesium
s however
ties which
gnesium to 5. Ferrous
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
The general plan of the experiment is the same as that previously em-
In warm weather the period is somewhat shortened by opening the win- . dows when the motor is stopped in the evening From the commencement of the experiment on Jan. 20 1928 until
ntaminant
stitute as he mineral
portion of - the ferric
ployed in studies on granite 2 marble 3 carborundum 4 and quartz 5 In the present instance animals are kept in cages along the walls of a room 6 by 8 feet and 8
the present date the dust exposures have been continued for eight hours on six days a week with the exception of a period of three weeks in the month of January 1930 when the motor was
has been dust used
feet high provided with two 3 by 5
foot windows A cloud of dust is
maintained in the atmosphere of this
being repaired
Dust Concentration
room by apparatus located in an
The amount of dust in the atmos-
alcove 6 feet from the nearest animal phere of this room has been checked
%
39.32
This apparatus consists in a horizon tal drum 2 1/2 feet long and 1 1/2
with a Greenburg impinger apparatus Samples taken on Feb.
35.5635.56 feet in diameter placed 8 inches above 14 1928 one month after the experi3 the floor Its top is open and in it ment was started showed the concen- i:
rotates a metal paddle whose shaft trations given in Table 1
.. 12.74
projects through the end of the drum
The rate of suction on the sampling
lysis=
and then through the partition into apparatus was 1 cubic foot per minute
an adjacent room in which is located the sampling times were fifteen min-
luminium
an electric motor By properly selected pulleys and countershafting the
utes and thirty minutes Owing to the fibrous nature of the dust the
rgely the
The dust
speed is so regulated that the desired
dust concentration can be maintained
particles were not filtered before the counts were made but the very large
ricyanide
Ventilation is secured by opening one particles those greater than 100
indicate
the ma-
~
exhibit
vanide
of the windows an inch or more from
the top The animals are kept generally in pairs in 12 by 12 by 12 inch
wire cages set on racks at the sides
microns were simply neglected in
counting Particles over 1.5 microns in diameter magnified ninety times were counted in the usual
re shown
and back of the room While it will manner in a Sedgewick cell
hrysotile mpletely : pattern
be shown that the dust concentration
progressively decreases from the floor to the ceiling this factor is compen-
* Appreciation is expressed to Mr. Morris Dworski for making these dust determina-
tions
.
oe
Yer
yay
gt me
Bega,Mines are vacate
1
oS
aoe
se
it.
Riel
Pi,* t
Bars.
Nean
Nee
Ra clibnceitcerBsranco
eee
ies greinr 0
tae
Rao
BO td
cate
89
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
after being allowed to settle for thirty
minutes The smaller ones varying
from 1.5 microns to 0.5 micron in
diameter were counted in a hemo-
cytometer chamber at a magnification of 410. The usual blank controls on the distilled water used to collect the dust samples were made and the number of accidental particles was subtracted before the results were
tabulated
This concentration was maintained
with little variation until January
1930 when the speed of the paddle was accelerated and the amount of sus-
days before the dust inhalation was
begun forty of them were placed in
the dusting room and twenty
were kept in a normal atmosphere as controls Two years after the experiment was started twelve dusted and twelve normal guinea were in-
fected with tubercle bacilli This
group was then set aside without fur-
ther exposure to the dust All the rats and rabbits and four of the
guinea were used in studying the uncomplicated effects of inhaled asbes-
tos dust Each of the various groups
will be described separately
TABLE DUST COUNTS
COUNT NO
HEIGHT OF
| INTAKE
FROM FLOOR
ft
12
22
2
22
Average
3
4
4
4
Average ..
MILLION PARTICLES PER CUBIC FOOT OF AIR
A
= 100-10... X 95
B
10-1.5
X 95
C
| 10-0.5...
x 410
1.5...or less C-B
Total
A+ C
.
1.130 1.258
1.194
0.450 0.400 0.425
8.033 6.625
7.329
4.960 4.440
4.700
56.666 51.600
54.133
35.000
43.333
39.166
48.633 44.975
46.804
30.040 38.893
34.466
57.796 52.858
55.645
35.450 43.733
39.591
pended dust was increased approximately ten times The majority of the
animals to be discussed in this report however were subjected only to the
smaller dust concentration
In this experiment 128 guinea
eighteen white rats and seven rabbits have thus far been used A portion of the guinea were infected with tubercle bacilli in an attempt to determine the influence of this dust
upon a tuberculous process One group of three guinea
were infected with tubercle bacilli four
PATHOLOGIC LESIONS
Tuberculous Guinea
Up to the present date twenty
months after the commencement of
the dust inhalation fourteen animals
or 26 per cent of the group have died
of epizootic pneumonia and fifteen more succumbed to other conditions such as enteritis and peritonitis As this experiment was designed to demonstrate the maximum effects which could be produced by the in-
haled dustrelatively few of the ani-
J. I.
Oe ad ke a ap Ee RS Ae RRR Le ee ees
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
69
lation was
e placed in three mosphere as the experi-
dusted and
mals have been killed A number
have however been sacrificed at 30 60 90 354 610 782 and 847 days Commencing with the eighth month
of exposure the effects of the dust
have also been followed radiographi-
black particles and few short spicules of doubly refractile material are visible in the alveoli budding off from the respiratory bronchioles A
few multinucleated dust cells are
s were in-
cally in the living animals
ae
tin cilli This
The pulmonary localization of in-
ithout fur-
haled asbestos differs from that of any
2a
. All the four of the
other dust thus far studied Granite quartz carborundum and soft coal
tudying the t
haled asbes-
particles penetrate the terminal air spaces of the lung and large quantities
ious groups
ultimately localize in the subpleural alveoli Asbestos dust presumably
because it is so largely composed of
elongated fibers is carried by the in-
spired air only to the distal respiratory
| Total
A+C
bronchioles and there the major portion of the material comes to rest Mononuclear phagocytes from the
FIG Cross section of lungs of guineapig exposed to asbestos dust inhalation 840 days Normal siz~
adjacent connective tissues enter the
57.796 52.858
lumen of the air passages and engulf the particles The phagocytes with their contained fragments of dust are
55.645
frequently pushed aside into the
35.450 43.733
alveoli which pouch out of the sides of the bronchioles where many of them remain indefinitely More dust
39.591
entering the lung is held up by the
partial obstruction created and fur-
VS
ther reaction is largely proximal to the
Pigs
point of original localization A few particles pass beyond into the proximal
wenty
ncement of
portions of the alveolar ducts but in the majority of cases the deposition of
en animals
, have died and fifteen
conditions
tonitis As
signed to
um _ effects
by the in-
of the ani-
asbestos dust occurs within respiratory
bronchioles of the second and third
orders and in the alveoli given off
directly from those structures Fig
2.
In after
guinea killed thirty days starting the dust inhalation
occasional small mononuclear phago-
cytes containing a number of brown or
FIG Roentgenogram of guinea exposed 880 days to asbestos inhalation
tissues encountered The lymphoid
of
the bronchial tree exhibit a moderate
degree of hyperplasia The lymphatic . trunks coursing through the bronchial
walls are wide open but no dust cells or other material can be found in
H.
Vol 13
ae
Ny
See
eee
SE
8
ONS
AR
3A a :
Nod ee.
enma agre apy ae
ea
_
TO .
a Ee
ane *
i CO
peep Pee Atte ONoy
y -
Sea
et
ne aa as TTDDS
SPLT IEE tad
OL Se
70
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
their lumina The tracheobronchial lymph nodes exhibit no more dust containing cells than those in any
normal animal kept in a laboratory atmosphere
At sixty days the number and size of the dust cells in the terminal respiratory bronchioles is considerably in-
creased The lumina of some of the
lateral alveoli are completely blocked by masses of mononuclear phagocytes and larger giant cells Some of the
latter have six or more nuclei Fre-
quently in Zenker tissues these phagocytes have a diffuse yellowbrown color which is presumably due
to the presence of dissolved iron
in their cytoplasm In tissues fixed in
formalin and stained with acidified
potassium ferrocyanide such cells
exhibit a diffuse blue coloration In
addition there are certain particles in their cytoplasm stained very deep blue which are probably the source from which the iron is dissolved
Doubly refractile intracellular spicules are numerous they are most readily demonstrated in polarized light After sixty days exposure to dust the first evidence of that peculiar structure
which has been called a curious
body is detected We prefer to adopt Stewart and Haddow's 6 designation of asbestosis body and shall use the latter term exclusively
After two months the number of
asbestosis bodies is small and they are atypical in appearance The most common form is a shaped swelling at the end of a smooth pale greenish
fiber Some present small fusiform
swellings along the course of a short fiber They are seen almost without
exception inside of large giant cells After ninety days exposure the
number of these structures has very
markedly increased and they have assumed their typical form The
smaller ones are still contained in
giant cells but many long forms
appear to be free in the stroma of the
lung The amount of cellular reaction has not kept pace with the number and size of the foreign bodies It still con-
sists of collections of mononuclear and
giant phagocytes within the lumen of a localized group of air spaces together with a very slight infiltration of the adjacent septa Hyperplasia has occurred in the lymphoid tissues associated with the bronchi proximal to the foci of maximum dust reaction but no phagocytes have carried dust
particles into the lymph nodules The lymphatic trunks are widely distended but they contain no cells or dust particles The tracheobronchial lymph nodes also show wellmarked hyperplasia but the number
of dust containing cells is still small During the next four months no
animals were killed but nine died of
various accidental causes In them it
is found that increasing quantities of dust are accumulating in the vicinity of the respiratory bronchioles and that
the amount of cellular reaction is some-
what increased Asbestosis bodies
so extremely abundant that as many as eight have been encountered in an oil immersion field They are practically absent in other portions of the lung The other changes in the lymphoid tissues and lymphatic ves-
sels remain much the same There is
as yet no evidence that appreciable amounts of dust are being transported
to the tracheobronchial lymph nodes In three guinea killed on the
357th day the amount of reaction has
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
71
has very
hey have
rm The
developed to such a degree as to be
visible on gross section of the fixed
lar appearance with defined borders
They are arranged radially on the sur-
face and suggest a relationship to the
tained in
ng forms ma of the
ar reaction imber and
t still conuclear and e lumen of
s together
tration of
oo
-
plasia has
id tissues
i proximal
t reaction arried dust 1 nodules are widely in no cells acheobronshow well-
FIG Longitudinal section of bronchus and its peripheral branches Exposure 357 days Approximately X45 Note that dust reaction is localized to region of respiratory bronchioles No reaction in lymphoid tis-
sues
FIG Peribronchiolar dust reaction
in
in
normal
guinea
exposed
840
days
tissue stain Approximately
CXo9n0 nective
he number
till small
nonths no
ine died of
In them it uantities of
the vicinity les and that
tion is some-
is bodies
at as many
ntered in an
y are pracrtions of the ges in the
nphatic ves-
e There is
appreciable transported ymph nodes
tilled on the reaction has
FIG Longitudinal section of bronchus and its peripheral branches Exposure 436 days Approximately X45 Note that dust reaction is localized to region of respiratory
bronchioles
region
tissue Uniformly distributed over
the entire surface of both lungs are fine yellowish ovoid flecks of granu-
FIG Early tuberculous reaction in focus of asbestosis endogenous extension
357 days after infection Approximately
90
finer bronchioles All are of approximately the same size and none exceed
1 mm in diameter Microscopically
those foci are similar in every way to
72
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
the type of reaction already described The walls of the bronchioles proximal to alveolar ducts are thick but this is due solely to an excessive local accumulation of phagocytes There
is no evidence that fibroblasts are
of the air spaces adjacent to the deposits of accumulated dust phagocytes At first only a few cells are involved but after still another 100 days a true fibrosis accompanied by
the formation of very considerable
proliferating The dust cells have amounts of collagen has developed
not migrated to any extent from the The walls become progressively thicker
original foci of localization none are found in the pulmonary lymphoid
and encroach upon the lumen of the
air spaces The epithelium of the
tissues but some have been trans- latter contracts and becomes cuboidal
ported to the tracheobronchial lymph so that the area of reaction resembles
nodes Figs 4-7 In the medullary a gland with a heavy connective tissue
sinuses of the latter location there are stroma The lumina of these gland-
now definite clusters of stained like atelectatic air spaces are more or
BG:
iron containing phagocytes In their less completely filled with compact
ory.
ORrat
cytoplasm many irregular black or masses of dust cells and brown-
brown particles and refractile elon- stained giant phagocytes whose cyto-
gated spicules are recognizable Occa- plasm is gorged with dust particles
sionally a giant cell is seen partially fibers and asbestosis bodies In the
surrounding a very long fiber which thickened septums there are many of
may project beyond the limits of the the latter which are generally extra-
cell One such fiber measured 25 cellular Figs 6 9 and 10.
. microns in length No asbestosis
The amount of dust carried into the
bodies are seen As yet the only tracheobronchial lymph nodes now
evidence of reaction in these nodes becomes more abundant It consists
consists in an active proliferation of
the follicle cells
While asbestosis bodies cannot yet be found in the lymphoid tissues they do occur outside the lung Two of the day animals had developed a chronic fibrous pleurisy and occasionally in the connective tissue there are small clusters of phagocytes containing dust and asbestosis bodies In an isolated field five of them have
been counted
On the 449th day two asbestosis bodies are found within a giant cell in the tracheobronchial lymph nodes
All animals killed or dying on and after the 505th day are characterized by the proliferation of fibroblasts
This reaction is confined to the walls
largely of amorphous or granular black or brown particles with many doubly refractile spicules which fail to stain specifically for iron Occasionally a few giant cells sometimes in small clusters contain asbesto-
sis bodies The stroma of the nodes
about the masses of dust cells now
exhibits a limited amount of fibro-
blastic proliferation The latest stages of the reaction of
asbestos dust thus far produced are manifested in the lungs of five guineapigs of which three were killed on the 782nd day and one on the 840th day All five exhibited a large number of subpleural white nodules at least 1 mm in diameter uniformly distributed over the surface of the lung
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST 333
acent to the
1 dust phago-
few cells are 1 another 100
companied by
considerable
as developed sively thicker
lumen of the clium of the
radiographic e e On section of the organs sharply
The first
examination
demarcated ovoid areas are disclosed to demonstrate definite changes in the
ee
a in every part of the lung One lung was obtained after a dust expo-
so
animal shows fibrous pleurisy over
mes cuboidal
tion resembles
nnective tissue
i these gland-
S are more or
with compact and brown-
s whose cyto-
ust particles
dies In the
FIG Magnified field of Figure 8
FIG Peribronchiolar focus of asbesto- Connective tissue stain Note strands of
are many of
ee
sis guinea exposed 782 days Approx- collagen between gland alveoli Ap-
nerally extra-
imately X70
proximately X140
e 10.
rried into the nodes now
are em > T oere , e x
-
ora
It consists
or granular
s with many s which fail
iron Occasometimes in
asbesto-
of the nodes 1st cells now int of fibro-
e reaction of produced are f five guineakilled on the
e 840th day
e number of lules at least
niformly disof the lung
a)
ay
.
BS Se FF eg
.
a
r
an
Py oaka Ca ay e ide
w of Bok eee
. 5 ad
7
oe .
FIG Magnified field of Figure 8
Note gland
X140
air
spaces
Approximately
portions of the lung without evidence of an underlying pneumonia The tracheobronchial lymph nodes are deeply pigmented in their central
portions
FIG 11.Asbestosis in rabbit exposed
days Approximately X140 Note giant
cells one of which has invaded nodule of lymphoid tissue
sure of two years At this time the
presence of very fine mottling was detected in the lower portions of the lung fields After another five months
ss
Boe
a
ya
fy
Aees
aneS COM Cf
ar
a
a.Seware.
be RD
ne!operas '
ag
i
CRs
ae
'
Weta,
a8
as
oe
ya OI ae
cA a
74
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
had elapsed the changes had become
much more marked As illustrated in
Figure 3 they consist of strands of
epithelium which occasionally dips into the thickened septums to form gland-
like structures In marked contrast
coarse mottling which radiate outward
and downward from the hilum The outlines of the mediastinum and the
pericardium are obscured by similar
shadows Whether the apexes are
also involved cannot be definitely
determined
Pathologic changes in the lungs of
to the previously mentioned areas of fibrosis in the respiratory bronchioles these more peripheral foci include practically no dust cells or asbestosis bodies One lobe of this lung is covered by organized fibrous pleurisy
which also fails to exhibit dust deposits
experimental animals are much more
Examination of the trachea and stem
readily demonstrated radiographically
if the lungs are removed from the
bronchi both by direct and by polarized light has failed to demonstrate
thorax and inflated before exposure appreciable amounts of dust or local
oe
to the ray Roentgenograms have reaction The only evidence of irrita-
ww
been made in this manner of animals tion is the presence of an occasional
with developed asbestosis and the polynuclear leukocyte on the ciliated
=
So shadows produced are characterized
by a pronounced thickening of the linear markings which extend outward
surface and the distention of the
goblet cells with mucus More peripherally the connective tissue coats of
from along the main bronchi to the the bronchi of the second and third
margins of the lung
orders exhibit considerable infiltration
Microscopically the lungs present lesions similar to those already de-
with lymphoid cells and some engorge-
ment of the blood vessels The other
scribed but they are more extensive and fibrosis has become more marked In stains for connective tissue abun-
viscera the spleen liver kidneys pancreas and abdominal lymph nodes have been uniformly free of dust or
dant collagen formation is now apparent
in the walls of the respiratory bronchioles and their alveoli Dust cells and
asbestosis bodies are very abundant
evidence of reaction attributable to it
In the guinea the development of the early two years and five months
response to inhaled asbestos dust may
The extension of the process from the be summarized as follows
,
terminal bronchioles proximally into
The particles and elongated fibers of
respiratory bronchioles of greater di-
ameter is obvious In addition to these characteristic
asbestos dust do not during this period penetrate so deeply into the air passages of the lung as do the other
changes the lung of one animal dusts previously studied The major
exhibits more or less circumscribed portion is held up and phagocytosed in
es foci of fibrosis in the alveolar septums
peripheral to the usual reaction zone
the lumina of respiratory bronchioles and the alveoli given off from their
The lumina of the included air spaces walls Increasingly large masses of
age
are normal in size and apparently phagocytes accumulate in the lumina
een
fully distended Their walls are lined of these air spaces and many of the
PO
with easily visible cuboidal or flattened cells migrate into the framework of
Rag
y dips into rm gland-
1 contrast l areas of
onchioles
i include asbestosis
lung is s pleurisy
ibit dust
and stem
by polar-
nonstrate t or local > of irritaOccasional e ciliated 1 of the
re periph-
coats of and third filtration "engorgeThe other
kidneys ph nodes
f dust or able to it
elopment e months
dust may
d fibers of
ring this
to the air the other
The major cytosed in
ronchioles rom their masses of ne lumina ny of the ework of
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
75
the adjacent lung tissue In this late development Only after 700
location there develops a low grade days do fibroblasts begin to proliferate
chronic inflammatory reaction charac- in the medulla of the nodes
terized by infiltration with monocytes and a few lymphoid cells Approximately 500 days after the commence-
Asbestosis bodies have not been
found in any animal killed before sixty days of dust exposure When
ment of dust inhalation the connective first discovered they are small some-
tissue cells in the walls of the bronchi- what atypical in form and generally
ole and its alveoli begin to proliferate contained within the cytoplasm of
Thereafter the reaction is charac- phagocytes Within the next sixty
terized by increasing amounts of days they rapidly increase in number
fibrous tissue which develops in the size and complexity of structure
immediate vicinity of the dust cells The larger ones appear to be liberated
The thickening stroma encroaches from the cells and ultimately to be
upon the lumen of the air spaces whose free in the air passages or intracellular
epithelium being compressed appears spaces In most cases these struc-
ea presumably = cuboidal as is the case in pulmonary tures
because of their
atelectasis The picture produced size are not transported from the point
somewhat resembles glandular tissue where they first develop in the lung
In addition to this lesion which is Occasionally they have been found in
characteristic of all the animals exam- the tracheobronchial lymph nodes and .
ined one of three of the last guineapigs killed showed a further change consisting in focal areas of fibrosis in
in areas of chronic fibrous pleurisy In these instances they are usually
intracellular
the alveolar septums peripheral in the
Rabbits
pulmonary unit to the point of dust
localization
Five rabbits exposed to asbestos
Changes in other structures of the dust for 40 53 149 253 and 330
lung are not striking There is well- days respectively have thus far been
~_
marked hyperplasia of the lymphoid killed and studied Within the period
tissues in the periphery of the lung of time included the reaction to the
but dust containing phagocytes do not inhaled dust has been characterized by
migrate toward and enter these masses increasingly large focal collections of
as is the case with quartz inhalation mononuclear and giant phagocytes
Dilatation of the large lymphatic These as in the guinea tend to
vessels in the connective tissues of the accumulate in and along the respira-
bronchi and blood vessels has been a
constant finding in all the animals of the series Even thirty days of dust
inhalation would appear sufficient to
produce this effect Its cause has not been discovered thrombi within the lumen of the lymph vessels are lacking
and a central obstructive lesion in the
tracheobronchial lymph node is a
tory bronchioles although in the last two animals killed some collections of
dust cells have been seen in the more
peripheral air spaces In marked contrast to their behavior in the guinea the phagocytes exhibit a tendency to migrate into masses of
lymphoid tissue This occurs early
and has been observed in all but the
76
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
first animal killed It is probably due
to anatomic differences in the two
species In the rabbit abundant deposits of tonsil lymphoid tissue are situated directly beneath the epithelium throughout the course of the bronchial tree in the guinea the lymphoid nodules are not so readily accessible The phagocytes are filled with great quantities of doubly refractile dust spicules but no typical asbestosis bodies have yet been discovered When stained for iron none of the
fibers in the first four animals reacted
In smears of lung tissue from the last animal killed on the 330th day a few elongated fibers exhibited irregular deposits of both ferric and ferrous iron and there were occasional globular swellings along their course But these fibers did not present the usual golden color of an asbestosis body and the alterations in structure
were in no way characteristic
No suggestion of fibrosis or even reaction in the framework of the lung adjacent to the collection of dust cells has been discovered but it is still too early to expect much change In the guinea the first indication of fibrosis was found on the 500th day
Albino Rats
Repeated attempts to study the
reaction to inhaled asbestos in the
white rat have been defeated by the development of epizootic pneumonia often complicated by abscess formation The first series was composed of twelve animals all of which succumbed to this infection One survived for 450 days but in all of them the reaction to chronic pneumonia so obscured the picture that no deductions were possible In December
1929 six new apparently healthy rats were placed in the dust room During a period of 118 days three have been
sacrificed and one has died All of
them have had pulmonary abscesses In only one animal which was killed on the seventieth day could asbestosis bodies be detected and in this case prolonged search of smears of the lung tissue stained for iron has revealed only
two of these structures One was very
small but typical in appearance The
other consisted of a bundle of fibers
frayed at the end and upon one of the fibrils were a few irregular swellings In another rat killed after 118 days
no asbestosis bodies have been found
THE ASBESTOSIS BODY
Since the development of the peculiar structure termed an asbestosis body in the lungs of animals compelled to
inhale asbestos dust may have an
important bearing upon the general problem of pneumonokoniosis it de-
serves detailed consideration
The forms encountered in the lungs of guinea in every way resemble those pictured in the human cases While individual specimens exhibit marked variations there are certain
features which are characteristic of
all the forms observed The fully developed body consists of a brilliant yellow beaded or haustral rod which may be either straight or curved
Its color resembles that of the hemo-
siderin deposits found in areas in which hemorrhage has occurred In length they vary from 1 to 250 microns and in width from micron to 10 microns
The shorter ones are usually straight but the larger forms are curved or even coiled They do not stain with any of the dyes ordinarily used for
E
tly healthy rats room During
hree have been s died All of
nary abscesses ich was killed on could asbestosis nd in this case
nears of the lung has revealed only
5. One was very pearance The bundle of fibers
upon one of the
gular swellings after 118 days
ave been found
SIS BODY
at of the peculiar asbestosis body Is compelled to
may have an
Don the general okoniosis it de-
eration
red in the lungs
y way resemble e human cases
ecimens exhibit
here
certain
characteristic of
ved The fully
sts of a brilliant
or haustral rod raight or curved
at of the hemo-
in areas in which
rred In length 250 microns and
-on to 10 microns
usually straight s are curved or
io not stain with
Hinarily used for
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
77
tissues but Wright's blood stain is absorbed to some extent giving greenish cast Fixing fluids and the
usual histologic stains have no appar-
ent effect upon them IronIron in the
ferric state may be demonstrated by
-
4
FIG Asbestosis bodies in guinea lungs Nos 1 to 10 from smears of lung
tissues Nos 11 and 12 in sections Approximately X560 No. 1 shows a smoothly coated fiber in No. 2 no
fiber is visible No. 7 shows show various forms of this
coating material cracked along fiber Other Other illustrations
structure
ae
trap
RAS
78
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
Pe
ee
treatment with potassium ferrocyanide the process of preparing sections
ee
MO,
8
8 co
in dilute hydrochloric acid McDonald and Stewart Examined under polarized light they are not doubly refrac-
and smears cannot be determined
Fig 12. . The lung of the rabbit apparently
sia:SE tile The shorter forms are usually offers a much less favorable environ-
found within the cytoplasm of a ment for the production of the asbesto-
ine
foreign body giant cell longer ones sis body than that of the human being
et
ats
ae e
ee
FIG Atypical asbestosis bodies from lung of rabbit exposed 330 days
8 and 9 are artificially produced asbestosis bodies X840
Nos
Oe
may be coiled within such cells but or the guinea Nothing faintly
ee more usually they lie free in the lumen resembling one of these structures has
of an alveolus or in the intercellular been found until the dust exposure has
St
spaces of the pulmonary framework been continued for a period of eleven
Whether they actually exist in the free months At that time in hematoxylin
state during life or whether owing to their elasticity they are set free in
and eosin preparations occasional fibers are seen which have a muddy greenish
gpa
ing sections determined
it apparently
able environf the asbesto-
human being
pe oe Semen
days Nos
cae wing faintly
uctures has
xposure has
ay
od of eleven
ematoxylin
sional fibers
ly greenish
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
79
hue but they do not exhibit the regular beading or the characteristic golden color seen in the guineapig Preparations stained for either
ferrous or ferric iron demonstrate a
few very long fibers containing irregular swellings of a deep blue color Whether typical asbestosis bodies will ever develop in this animal remains to be demonstrated Fig 13 Nos 3 and 4.
In the lung of the white rat they
would also appear to be very uncom-
mon although the widespread incidence of chronic pulmonary infection among the animals thus far exposed in a measure invalidates the results
Thus far only two asbestosis bodies
have been discovered in one animal of
this species If the environment were favorable it would seem probable that
more of these bodies would have been
detected even in the presence of complicating pneumonia
Our observations have led us to believe that the asbestosis body devel-
ops as the result of chemical changes taking place within or about inhaled asbestos fibers The dust previous to contact with the pulmonary tissues shows no such structures A period of time which varies with different species of animals must elapse after the fibers have entered the lung before the asbestosis body makes its appearance
The first forms encountered are differ-
ent from those seen later They consist of iron containing sheath or nodular swellings along the sides or
at the ends of a fiber From such
points further extensions occur until
in some cases the whole filament
acquires a uniform coating which is brittle Fig 12 No. 1 Movement or other stress causes the coating substance
to crack separating it into segments
,
Fig 12 No. 7
Chemical action continues and the
segments tend to elongate in a direction at right angles to that of the original fiber Extension also takes place at the ends of the fiber so that it increases in length Small fragments
may also serve as nuclei for chemical
activity about them spherical or ovoid masses develop The resultant
forms exhibit many variations Per-
haps the most common ones consist of an axial fiber traversed at intervals by
a variable number of thickened cross-
bars Often one end and sometimes
both ends are swollen and spindle shaped In other instances the central fiber cannot be discovered possibly it has been dissolved the body then consists of a row of globules
Sometimes these are of uniform diam-
eter frequently they decrease progressively from one end the other In guinea exposed for more than two years many bizarre branching globoid forms are seen which resemble
clusters of tuberous bulbs
An observation which merits com-
ment is the scarcity of asbestosis
bodies in the tracheobronchial lymph
nodes Presumably because of their
size the majority of the inhaled
asbestos fibers are not transported to
distance any
by phagocytes Never-
theless after exposure to the dust
has been continued for somewhat over
a year appreciable numbers of doubly
refractile staining fibers can
be found in the lymph nodes of the mediastinum They are embedded in the cytoplasm of phagocytes which have migrated from the lung After two years large masses of such dust cells have accumulated and yet asbes-
60
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
tissue tosis bodies are not found in
any
number in the tracheobronchial lymph
bonate among other constituents Samples of the peritoneal fluid were
nodes Those which do occur are withdrawn with
located in clumps of giant cells It is
capillary pipettes
believed that the formation of the few twenty and sixty days after
asbestosis bodies found took place in
the injections In each series the fluid
exhibited large numbers of dust con-
the lung and that they were then taining monocytes and in both the
transported to the lymph nodes in
emboli of
asbestos groups large giant cells were
phagocytes
Why do asbestosis bodies
numerous No sign of an asbestosis
occur so
rarely in the material which
body could be discovered Dissolved
has been
transported to the lymph nodes
iron was detected in the cells from the granite series but none could be
Were the fibers during their period of in those from
found
residence in the lung deprived by
either of the asbestos
-
groups
solution of iron or some other sub-
On the
stance necessary to their production
seventieth day and again on
the 110th
or are the transported fibers
day one animal from each
different from those
essentially group was killed The amount of
remaining in the reaction was surprisingly insignificant
lung or again is the environment
furnished in the
Careful search revealed minute foci of
lung especially favor- pigmentation in the
able for the production of asbestosis
omentum of each
bodies
animal At seventy days no sugges-
To answer the last
tion of an asbestosis body was dis-
possibility injec-
tions of asbestos dust have
covered but at 110 days a few very
te
been made small but typical bodies were found in
ge
into other portions of the body In a smear stained for iron
the
the peritoneal cavity of the guinea nodule from
of an omental
attempts to produce asbestosis bodies
one animal injected with
have met with but slight success In the King's floats dust The asbestos
one series each
fiber and the iron containing granite
guinea was injected with c.c. of a heavy suspension of the
_
animals did not show them These
King's floats dust which was
findings were confirmed subsequently
so pre-
pared by sedimentation 7 that only
by histologic examination of the
While the
particles varying from 2 to 4 microns
remaining animals of this
were present This material it will be recalled contains not only asbestos
experiment are still under observation
it hardly seems probable that asbes-
fiber but a considerable amount of tosis bodies will develop in any num-
iron and other material Another ber Aside from its failure to favor the
series received a like amount of pure formation of these structures it is
asbestos fiber cut and ground into the finest possible state This fiber was obtained from a vein of Thetford ore As a control a third series was
injected with a suspension of granite
from Lorain County Ohio This rock
contains free silica and ferrous car-
surprising that the peritoneal cavity exhibits so little reaction to the injection of very considerable quantities of
this foreign material When more
insoluble dusts such as coal quartz and carborundum are injected very
appreciable deposits are found in the
constituents cal fluid were
lary pipettes our days after
series the fluid of dust con-
1 in both the antcells were
an asbestosis d Dissolved cells from the could be found
*
the asbestos
and again on
nal from each
2
amount of
insignificant
minute foci of ntum of each
ys no sugges-
dy was dis-
s a few very were found in of an omental
injected with
The asbestos
ining granite _
hem These
subsequently
L of the tissue imals of this
-
observation
c that asbesin any numre to favor the
ctures it is Loneal cavity to the injecquantities of
When more
coal quartz jected very
found in the
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
81
omentum and beneath the parietal
peritoneum In the subcutaneous tissues at-
tempts to form asbestosis bodies have been somewhat more successful In
logic salt solution The iron free portion formed a smooth turbid opalescent suspension while the untreated portion produced a green floccu-
lent one Two c.c. of each of these
- an uncompleted experiment designed
to determine whether certain dusts
~
might cause a dissemination of infec-
-
tion with tubercle bacilli of attenuated
'
virulence daily repeated injections of
asbestos dust suspensions were made
into the subcutaneous tissue of the
suspensions were injected into the subcutaneous tissues of the groins of
each of six guinea the untreated suspension on the right side and the
iron free material on the left When
'
examined thirty days later all the animals had palpable nodules at the
groin of guinea previously injected
with tubercle bacilli in the same area
site of injection of the untreated material and none on the opposite
In all thirty injections totaling 3 mg of very fine dust King's floats
were made Most of the material has
side At this time one of the guineapigs was killed On the right side there was a nodule 10 mm in diam-
not yet been examined but in one eter filled with greenish necrotic
animal dying in 102 days and in three material while on the side there
more
killed
264
days
after
the
"
dust
was only a faint suggestion of pigmen-
injections were completed the subcutaneous tissues exhibited large masses of foreign body giant cells containing many typical asbestosis bodies
With a view to determining whether
tation in a very slightly enlarged
superficial inguinal lymph node
Smears made from the material on
each side failed to demonstrate goldenyellow bodies When stained for iron
the iron of the asbestosis body is
derived from the dust or from the
with potassium ferrocyanide numer-
ous uniformly blue fibers were seen in
animal body the following experiment the abscess produced by the untreated
has been performed A mixture was material but only a few short un-
prepared which contained equal parts stained fibers could be discovered in
of very finely divided pure asbestos
fiber and fine whole asbestos dust
_ King's floats the latter composed of particles between 2 and 4 microns in
diameter Both of these elements
were included because the pure fiber from asbestos veins contains so little
iron The mixture was divided into twoparts and from one of them the
iron was completely removed by digestion with hydrochloric acid and subsequent washing Both fractions were sterilized by heating at 100 for
the smears from the opposite side There was no suggestion of an asbestobody As in the case of the peritoneal cavity the impression is gained that a part of the dust may have been dissolved in the body fluids The
effects produced at sixty days were
identical The absence of asbestosis
bodies on the right side is attributable
to the lack of sufficient time for their
development the disappearance of the injected material on the opposite side
one hour and suspended in physio- is most surprising
To be concluded
IENE
hrbuch der Intoxika-
1 edition Stuttgart , 1906 vol 2 p 789 termination of Aniline ir THIS JOUR 1920-
Book of Organic w York John Wiley -
: Das Toluylendiamin | sung auf den Thierf exper Path u
1 14 231 : Die Wirkung des auf den Thierk^rper
Weitere Beitr^/ge zur erus Ibid 1883 16
STUDIES ON EXPERIMENTAL PNEUMONOKONIOSIS VI INHALATION OF ASBESTOS DUST ITS EFFECT UPON PRIMARY TUBERCULOUS INFECTION Concluded
LEROY U. GARDNER AND DONALD E. CUMMINGS From the Saranac Laboratory for the Study of Tuberculosis The Edward L. Trudeau Foundation Saranac Lake New York
PRIMARY TUBERCULOUS INFECTION IN never seen The course of the infec-
_
PULMONARY ASBESTOSIS
tion in such guinea is generally
To determine whether inhaled asbes-
tos dust affects the course of tubercu-
lous infection the same procedures
have been employed which were used
in the previously reported experiments
on other dusts i.e. granite 2
marble 3 carborundum 4 and
quartz 5 For this purpose animals
them exposed to asbestos
infected by causing
have been them to inhale
small numbers of tubercle bacilli of the
attenuated strain R
By this means
in undusted guinea a limited
infection of the respiratory tract is
produced with lesions comparable
with those of the primary complex
in man They consist of a variable
number of small discrete subpleu-
ral tubercles in the lung together
with a more extensive involvement of
the tracheobronchial lymph nodes The pulmonary tubercles caseate and
then the bacilli die The caseous
matter is absorbed and after a period of from eighteen months to two years complete resolution of the entire
nonprogressive Figs 18 19 and 20 During the period from 1920 to 1928
. there were three instances of generalized tuberculosis among 251 guineapigs infected with this organism as controls to different dust experiments
In one of these three there was some
question as to the identity of the
|
animal In the last three years however eleven instances of disseminated disease have been discovered among
148 controls similarly infected The occurrence has been sporadic and only one animal in a group of twentyfive or fifty such controls exhibited evidence of spreading disease The cause of this apparent accentuation
in virulence has not been ascertained
It is hard to believe that after main-
taining a constantly low degree of virulence for a period of thirty years the R strain has rather suddenly been altered As far as is known the gly-
cerin broth on which it has been culti-
vated has been prepared in the same manner as heretofore The dosage
used for inhalation infection has been
lesion takes place 8 Macroscopic maintained at a constant level The
disease of the spleen and liver is almost only discoverable factor which has not
97
aene
e
aLg, 98 THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
been controlled is the guinea used for the experiments They have regu-
introduction of epizootic pneumonia into the animal house It had not been considered necessary to perform
routine _ intracutaneous tuberculin
REACTI
low virulent artificial 1
been fection may have
d
accidental infection with
FIG Primary subpleural tubercle
partially healed by fibrosis Below it and
to the left is a nodule of
lymphoid left tissue
Slightly
hyperplastic
removed
foci of dust reaction No
are
spread because
lished Exposed to both dust and infection
357 days Approximately X20
FIG Healed fibrous tuberculosis in - an area of asbestosis Simultaneous
ismuraetetloyduXs4t5and infection 838 days Apperxopxo--
FIG
Inactive
Inactive
sub sub
in undusted control anim
has commenced 654 days
Approximately X110
FIG Another tubercle
primary
subpleural
from which has
the
same
lung
as
Figure
14
reaction
spread locally into an area of dust Approximately 20
larly been purchased from one farmer On their receipt they are quarantined
for a period of three weeks to avoid the
Approximately FIG Section of
bestosis from
uncomplicated as-
ing
more
same lung as Figure 16 showfibrosis than
tissue stain
usual Connective
90
tests as no case of accidental tubercu-
losis had ever been recognized among this stock It is possible that these
recent cases of apparent spread of the
J. H.
March 1931
FIG
Inactive
Inactive
sub
sub
in undusted control anin
has commenced 654 day
Approximately X110
lent strain Generaliz
t however has always n
ance only after ma
:
Vol 13
ry 3
No. 3
IENE
izootic pneumonia
house It had not
ecessartyo perform
aneous tuberculin
f
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
99
low virulent artificial tuberculous in-
fection may have been due to previous
accidental infection with a more viru-
residence in the animal house Subinoculation tests are now in progress in an attempt to determine the type of
fibrous tuberculosis in
Simultaneous expo-
tion
~
da 83y 8 das ys Approx-
FIG Inactive subpleural tubercle in undusted control animal retrogression has commenced 654 days after infection
Approximately 110
FIG Healed subpleural tubercle
654 days after infection Approximately 110
of uncomplicated asing as Figure 16 showan usual Connective ximately X90
f accidental tubercu-
n recognized among possible that these parent spread of the
J. H.
March 1931
FIG Inactive subpleural tubercle
in
in undusted control animal retrogression has commenced 654 days after infection Approximately 110
FIG Partially healed tubercle in wall of large bronchus Location atypical 357 days Approximately 130
tubercle bacillus responsible for this
lent strain Generalized tuberculosis disturbing manifestation
~~ however has always made its appear-
But in spite of these occasional in-
ance only after many months of stances of disseminated tuberculosis in
Vol 13 No.
100 THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
the control animals this method of
testing the effect of inhaled dusts upon
tuberculous infection is of value The
great majority of the controls not
exposed to dust inhalation exhibit
nonprogressive pulmonary tubercles which ultimately heal by resolution On the other hand almost every
animal similarly infected and exposed
to the inhalation of quartz dust dies
of generalized tuberculosis unless
premature death from epizootic pneu-
monia or other causes supervenes
In the asbestos dust experiment two groups of guinea were infected
with the attenuated R strain of tubercle bacilli.2 One lot of sixty-
three normal animals were subjected to
inhalation infection and four days
later forty of them were placed in the
dusting room where they have been
A second group of twelve guinea-
pigs which had been exposed to asbestos dust for a period of two years under
the conditions described above were
infected by the inhalation of an
approximately equivalent dose of R.
tubercle bacilli At the same time twelve normal animals were infected
as controls Both the previously
dusted animals and the controls were then set aside in the general animal
room to be allowed to live as long as they would This second test was designed to demonstrate whether the
alterations in pulmonary anatomy
and physiology produced by the in-
haled dust would affect a tuberculous infection
Infection Coincident with Dust
Inhalation
curred kept under the conditions already
Of the forty guinea originally
described until death occurred
remaining twenty of this
The
infected and placed in the dusting
group were set aside in a normal atmosphere
chamber thirty are now dead
Seven were killed and the
as controls to the infection From have died of
remainder
this experiment it was hoped that the of
various causes four
effect of inhaled asbestos dust
generalized tuberculosis seventeen
tuberculous infection
upon a with more or less extensive epizootic
mined
might be deter-
In the animals thus exposed
pneumonia and the rest from various accidental causes Nine
asbestos particles would continue to and
are still alive
enter the lungs during the period of
apparently well at the time of this
tubercle formation
If solution or
report two years and three months after infection Some evidence of
other chemical reaction should occur spread of the tuberculous
these changes might conceivably affect been observed in
process has
the activities of the tubercle bacilli
it has been
ten animals in six
The method of
confined to the lungs
infection has been
described elsewhere 2 The dosage em-
while in the other four it involved the
ployed for the present infection consisted of six puffs from
abdominal viscera as well
Pulmo-
a DeVilbiss vaporizer containing a suspension of R tubercle
nary cavity developed in four animals
bacilli The water clear suspension was In most of the cases an extension extension of the
tphrrepoaurgehdpabpyercesnotrtihfautgatthieorne waenrde ffirlotmrattieonn tuberculous infection had at
to twenty isolated bacilli in each oil im-
mersion
some time previous to death and
broth field No clumps were present
The bacilli were grown on glycerin
subsequent healing resulted in fibrosis
of all the
the first group for eight days the second for
secondary lesions In all
twenty days
the tuberculous animals even those
H. March 1931
REACTI
y <7"
:
dying
lesions with generalize tend to be fibro
exudat initvypee
Of the twenty
trols twenty are dead
595 days of generalized
culosis with extensive :
spleen liver and abd
nodes The remaining cumbed for other rea died of pneumonia and t various accidental cal 244th day the tubercu the lungs had healed to that all evidence of disappeared With the noted the other anin after this time showe
foci of scar tissue at 1 former tubercles In t
were healed fibrous tub
scopic dimension in the
The distribution of
tuberculous foci in th
asbestosis group is some
not only are the us tubercles formed but ir
few foci are found in th
lung apparently origi phoid tissues at bifu bronchial tree Fig 2
monary lesions are asso
customary lymphatic m tracheobronchial lymph development of exten that location Many
nary tubercles are inde of dust reaction and a this occurs the nor resolution is free to
foci resolve completely
disappear Others:
extend into areas of du
about respiratory bron such contact is establis
Vol 13 No.
YGIENE
oup of twelve guineai been exposed to asbesriod of two years under described above were
he inhalation of an
equivalent dose of R
At the same time
animals were infected
Both the previously
and the controls were in the general animal
wed to live as long as
his second test was
onstrate whether the
pulmonary anatomy
produced by the in1 affect a tuberculous
ncident with Dust
|
a , alation
uinea originally
eRe
dusting ced in the
one are now dead
pere
. and the remainder
5
StYetU pear I
ahd arious causes four
4
erculosis seventeen
3
- extensive epizootic
os
e rest from various
2
Nine are still alive
Il at the time of this
and three months
Some evidence of
rculous process has
ten animals in six ned to the lungs our it involved the
as well Pulmo-
ed in four animals
an extension of the
on had occurred at
is to death and
resulted in fibrosis
y lesions In all
mals even those
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST 101
are dying with generalized disease the much more marked than that
lesions tend to be fibrous rather than by either irritant alone
produced
exudative in type
is the result
Of the twenty infection con-
Extensive chronic inflammation and
granulation tissue develop but the
trols twenty
dead One died after dust cells do not
595 days of generalized chronic tuber-
culosis with extensive disease in the
migrate into the interior of the tubercle as in the case
of
spleen liver and abdominal
inhaled quartz Nevertheless the
nodes The
lymph subsequent course of the tuberculous
remaining nineteen suc- process is altered In some instances
cumbed for other reasons Twelve there is merely an interference with
died of pneumonia and the others from usual process of
the
various accidental causes By the
resolution so that
excessive fibrosis and calcification of
244th day the tuberculous lesions in the necrotic central
the lungs had healed to such
areas result In
an extent that all evidence of caseation had
other cases some product is produced
possibly soluble silica which causes
disappeared With the one exception renewed multiplication of the bacilli
noted the other animals autopsied
after this time
and a spread of the tuberculous
showed only minute process
foci of scar tissue at the site of the
The extension takes
former tubercles In two
place locally
were healed fibrous
cases there about the primary foci of infection
tubercles of micro- Fig 15 and there is also
scopic dimension in the spleen
of tubercle bacilli to the metastasis
The distribution of the
peribronchio-
primary
tuberculous foci in the lungs of the
lar foci of dust reaction Fig 7 New tubercles develop in the latter location
asbestosis group is somewhat atypical which are temporarily progressive and
not only are the usual subpleural which may even break down to form
tubercles formed but in addition not
few foci
small cavities Usually however the
are found in the depths of the lung apparently originating in lym-
process tends to come to a standstill
and ultimate
phoid tissues at bifurcation of the
healing with fibrosis and considerable anatomic deformity is the
bronchial tree Fig 21 These pul- result Fig 16 The spreading dis-
monary lesions are associated with the ease is usually confined to limited
customary lymphatic metastasis to the areas in the lung and death has with
tracheobronchial lymphlymph nodes and the but one
development of extensive disease in
exception occurred from other
that location Many of the pulmo-
causes Such endogenous reinfec-
tions have first been encountered 203
nary tubercles are independent of foci of dust reaction and apparently when
days after the beginning of the experi-
ment The last animal of this
this occurs the normal process of
group
studied died on the 838th day of
resolution is free to proceed Such endemic pneumonia which was
foci resolve completely and ultimately localized to
strictly
disappear Others are
one cephalic lobe The
extend into
contiguous to or lungs show no trace of subpleural
about
areas of dust accumulated primary foci of infection but in the
_
respiratory bronchioles When deeper portions along the course of the
such contact is established a reaction large bronchi are healed fibrous tuber-
Vol 13
No. 3
102 THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
cles with plaques of bone and marrow
elements in their centers These have been interpreted as the remains of
primary tubercles produced by bacilli which did not reach the periphery at
the time of infection because of the
obstructing dust in the bronchioles
Elsewhere about respiratory bronchi-
oles are very massive circumscribed
foci of fibrosis containing the compressed remains of gland air
spaces Whether all of them were
once the site of specific tubercle cannot
be definitely determined However
the occasional occurrence of concentric masses of scar tissue enclosing a few giant cells suggests in some instances
the presence of tubercles In other
organs the tracheobronchial lymph
nodes and abdominal viscera there
are also many caseous fibrous tubercles
spread in the preestablished scar tis-
sue and undergo extensive caseation Early metastasis to the tracheobronchial lymph nodes occurs and the most
extensive foci of reaction are found in
this location In fact in one guineapig dying of an acute pleurisy on
the twenty day no pulmonary
tubercles can be discovered whereas the lymph nodes are heavily infiltrated
with masses of epithelioid cells All
the animals dying on and after the thirty day show very extensive
tuberculosis of the spleen and hepatic lymph
The infectious process exerts a
very noticeable effect upon the reaction to
ani- the dust In all but one of the
mals the amount of fibrous tissue about
the respiratory bronchioles is much
more marked than in tuberculous
Infection Superimposed upon an
Established Asbestosis
animals exposed for the same period In two of them which are uncompli-
cated by the presence of epizootic pneu-
Of the small group of twelve guineapigs infected after two years exposure
to asbestos dust six died and three were killed during the following fortyeight days Three of those dying presented an acute tuberculous pneumonia involving only one lobe of the
lung and two an acute hemorrhagic
pleural effusion
Pulmonary tubercles were first found in the fourth animal dying on the
thirty day all of the remaining five showed some evidence of pulmo-
nary infection The majority of the
tubercles occurred not in the usual
subpleural zone of the lung but in the areas where dust reaction had already
been established In some instances there are also characteristic subpleural lesions The peribronchiolar tubercles
monia the alveolar septums in wide
areas peripheral to the foci of localized
dust are extremely thick and fibreus
It is of interest to note the effect of the infectious process upon the asbes-
tosis body The development of caseation in an area of reaction containing these structures ultimately destroys
them They lose their characteristic
yellow color fail to give a Prussian blue reaction and are apparently so completely disintegrated that not even a supporting fiber remains Polarized light fails to reveal refractile
elements In the walls of small tuber-
culous cavities developing in foci of
dust reaction the various steps in the destruction of the asbestosis body can
be studied The cause of their dis-
appearance has not been determined but it is possible that the change in
} }
ished scar tisive caseation
tracheobron-
and the most are found in
n one guinea-
pleurisy on O pulmonary
red whereas ly infiltrated
d cells All id after the y extensive
and hepatic
certs a very reaction to of the ani-
.ssue about
* is much
berculous
e period uncomplitic pneus in wide
localized { fibreus
:
effect of e asbest of case-
ntaining destroys
cteristic give a
appared that mains
fractile
tuberfoci of in the
ly can
ir dismined ige in
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
103
hydrogen ion concentration incident
to caseation may favor solution of the
foreign bodies
trate into the ultimate divisions of the
primary units of the lung the major
part of them come to rest in the
DISCUSSION
respiratory bronchioles It will be
The physical and chemical
recalled that these structures are
properties
of asbestos are so unlike those of
any
lined not by ciliated but by smooth cuboidal epithelium and that at
other dust previously studied that
when inhaled particles of this sub-
inter-
vals along their walls are the
of
openings
stance provoke an
a variable number of alveoli As
reaction in the
unusual type of result the bronchial tube at this
lung
point
is no longer smooth walled but is very
Localization of Dust
irregular in contour This roughness
The fact that a fiber
is probably at least one of the factors
as long as 100
and even 200 microns can be inhaled
responsible for the arrest of the elongated spicules and fibers
and ultimately reach the finer branches in the
which catch
of the bronchial tree is
openings of the lateral alveoli
surprising and
controverts the accepted ideas of the
In marked contrast with this is the behavior of
effectiveness of the upper respiratory
a particulate dust like
quartz the major portion of
protective mechanism Whether such
which
structures enter the lung in full exten- passes through the lumen of a respira-
sion or whether they are partially
tory bronchiole and enters the alveolar
duct and its further ramifications
coiled has not yet been determined
Coiled fibers do
Having come to rest the asbestos
not occur in the dust particles are
itself In any case it is difficult to
ingested by free alveolar
imagine a structure of such
phagocytes As so much of the mate-
making its
dimension rial consists of elongated fibers giant
way against the normal cells are
current of ciliary action
-
It is
very prone to develop With-
gener-
ally assumed that prolonged inhalation
in the cytoplasm of these cells the
chemical changes responsible for
of dust provokes a chronic bronchitis
but in the case of asbestos dust no
the
development of that unique structure
the
morphologic evidence of such
asbestosis body occur The proc-
a change has been observed within a period of
ess requires a period of
two
months
before
approximately
the
characteristic
two and half years It is quite alterations are
possible that the physiologic activities
produced
of the altered
ciliated epithelium may be without demonstrable ana-
tomic changes In support of such a
view is the fact that very long fibers have not been discovered in the deeper portions of the lung until the dust
inhalation has been in progress for
several months
Chemical Reaction and Asbestosis
Body
:
That the changes in the inhaled
material are truly chemical in
is indicated by the appearance nofadits-ur ~
solved iron in the cytoplasm of certain
phagocytes at a time previous to the
Unlike other dusts asbestos fibers
AA
a4
17
appearance of the asbestosis body
The presence of the iron imparts a
104
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
and it reacts specifically with potassium ferrocyanide and dilute hydro-
chloric acid
As previously noted study of the
structure of the asbestos fibers indi-
cates that iron occurs in intimate com-
bination with silica and even in the best grade of chrysotile it actually replaces some of the magnesium Chemical changes involving one con-
stituent of the asbestos molecule must
affect its other components The presence of iron uniformly distributed
throughout the cytoplasm of a phagocyte may indicate either hydrolysis of the ingested dust or solution of at least part of the original constituents and a subsequent release of silica This
silica may exist in any of several
physical states as soluble colloidal or insoluble silica or as soluble silicate By study of the chemical structure and
the method of formation of the asbes-
tosis body it should be possible to discover the actual mechanism by
which structural alteration of an in-
haled silicate occurs
The asbestosis body has been subjected to various chemical tests by several investigators Cooke 9 and McDonald 10 first described this unusual foreign body and stated that it did not stain with aniline dyes but gave a marked iron reaction They also noted that it was not doubly refractile McDonald 10 and Simson 11 also presented a theory for the formation of the golden bodies from asbestos Stewart 12 claimed
the presence of asbestosis bodies in
histologic sections of lung as diagnostic of pulmonary asbestosis Cooke 13
later called attention to the relation
between the iron content of asbestos dust and the iron reaction of asbes-
tosis bodies He noted that they were not digested by trypsin and that they contained less iron than chrysotile He also noted that they failed to cast a characteristic pattern when treated by the ray diffraction method of Bragg though a central fiber could be demonstrated with a dissecting microscope He therefore concluded that they were fibers of vegetable origin covered with
colloidal aggregates of adsorbed blood proteins Stewart 14 replied to
Cooke's suggestions and stated that all the reported cases of asbestosis had exhibited these curious structures Stewart 15 later noted that antiformin did not destroy them Gloyne 16 stated that the asbestosis body withstood calcination but lost its yellow sheath after treatment with concentrated sulphuric acid leaving a thin central fiber He reported the body as refractile on dark ground
illumination
We have been able to confirm many
of these findings and we have also attempted to prove conclusively whether or not the asbestosis body contains organic matter Since it resists calcination without change in configuration or color and since it is not digested with either pepsin and hydrochloric acid or trypsin it is not to be regarded as protein in nature More-
over asbestos fibers fail to adsorb
proteins when placed in blood or pep-
tone broth media for several months
This curious structure is not soluble in
any of the usual organic solventsand
fails to show charring with sulphuric
It will be recalled that the asbestosis
bodies and even their supporting fibers
ultimately disappear in an area of tuber-
entirely solution culous necrosis The explanation is not
entirely clear but
may be due to a
high degree of alkalinity created in the
degenerated cells
at they were and that they
1 chrysotile
ailed to cast a
en treated by iod of Bragg
ild be demon-
; microscope at they were
covered with sorbed blood
replied to
. stated that sbestosis had
structures 1 that anti-
em Gloyne estosis body
ut lost its r treatment
ic acid leavHe reported dark ground
nfirm many have also at-
ely whether ly contains
resists cal-
in configu-
e it is not
: and hydro-
is not to be ure More-
to adsorb ood or pepral months t soluble in olventsand
h sulphuric
he asbestosis orting fibers sea of tuberation is not
be due to a cated in the
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
105
acid Consequently it is considered to be an inorganic structure Inasmuch as a central fiber can be readily demonstrated in nearly all instances the body is undoubtedly derived from
asbestos
partial solution of the inhaled dust is responsible for the development of the asbestosis body the following observations may be cited When studied by Bragg's ray technic asbestos fibers exhibit a characteristic crystal-
The marked iron reaction of the line pattern which is lost upon treat-
asbestosis body is not to be confused
with that obtained on the dust pre-
ment with acid Cooke 13 using the same method showed that asbestosis
vious to contact with the animal body
In its original state the iron in the fibers is almost wholly in the ferrous
state while in the asbestosis body only ferric iron can be detected This structure is therefore regarded as an oxidation product of the original
dust
In an attempt to prove whether the iron of the asbestosis body was already present in the fiber or whether it was derived from animal tissues the experiment was made in which asbestos
bodies exhibit no crystalline structure Ray and Ganguly 17 state that precipitates formed from solutions of
ferric chloride and sodium silicates which are identical in color with the
asbestosis body also yield no crystalline pattern by ray As further evidence of physical alteration is the fact that the asbestos fiber is highly refractile in polarized light whereas the asbestosis body has completely lost
this property We have attempted to reproduce the
fibers freed from iron by leaching with hydrochloric acid were injected into
It has been assumed that the demonstration of iron in the outer coating of the
asbestosis body is evidence of hydrolysis of
the subcutaneous tissues of guineapigs as noted above It was unsuc-
the original asbestos fiber on which the
body formed But actually this finding does not constitute definite proof unless an
cessful because the acid treatment rendered the asbestos soluble in the
endogenous source from blood pigment can be excluded We have thus far failed to
eliminate this source of iron However
body fluids and no significant reaction occurred One month after the injection practically no trace of the fibers could be discovered and only a very
the demonstration of magnesium in the
asbestosis body would furnish equally convincing proof of hydrolysis and the objection that it was derived from the tissues could hardly be raised for the amount of this substance in the body is
slight fibrosis marked the site
Treatment of asbestos fibers for the
extremely small An attempt has therefore been made to develop a microchemical test for magnesium It has been found that
determination of free silica disclosed
the ease with which the chrysotile
both asbestos fibers and asbestosis bodies
are definitely stained a light green
color when treated on microslides with a
molecule could be opened If enzymatic action or hydrolysis of the fiber
dilute hydrochloric acid solution of pararesorcinol followed by a
bath of sodium hydroxide
is assumed to take place in the presence of body fluids it is quite possible that
proof e: the ferrous or ferric silicate existing in
the fiber is oxidized and hydrolyzed
ene directly to produce the asbestosis
The presence of magnesium in the outer layers of the asbestosis body is convincing
of hydrolysis of the inhaled dust This color reaction is given only by magne-
sium cobalt and nickel substances which
do not occur in sufficient concentration in the tissues to cause reaction Therefore endogenous sources for the coating material
body
of the asbestosis body are assumed to have
As evidence that hydrolysis or been eliminated
106
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
asbestosis body from asbestos fibers by immersing them for prolonged periods
until finally the membrane becomes impermeable
in buffer solutions of various hydrogen
ion concentrations both above and below neutrality The solutions have
been adjusted with agar and silica gel
to a viscosity near that of the cell
Oxidizing agents have been added and
the reaction has been allowed to proceed in the incubator for six months
No yellow structures were
obtained
We have however been able to reproduce the structure of the asbestosis body quite closely by other
means Iron free asbestos fibers are
impregnated with an iron salt by
Microscopic structures of fibrous
character suggesting asbestosis bodies
have been produced both with dilute solutions of an iron salt and a soluble silicate and with iron and silica sols 19
These observations lead us to conclude that the asbestosis body is a derivative of the crystalline asbestos fiber which has been oxidized and
hydrolyzed to a yellow amorphous structure As such it can be regarded as the first direct evidence of
altered chemical composition in an inhaled silicate dust
heating to dryness in a dilute ferric chloride solution and ignited The fibers are then placed in a solution of
sodium silicate The iron salt adher-
ing to the fibers reacts rapidly with the silicate producing a curiously shaped
yellow structure which very
closely resembles the asbestosis body Fig 13 Nos 1 and 2
A similar reaction is involved in the
production of the familiar phenomenon the silicate garden 18 If a crystal of ferric chloride is added to a
solution of sodium silicate goldenyellow filaments often several inches
In the animal body the evidence thus far accumulated would indicate that the lung of the guinea and of man furnishes the most favorable en-
vironment for the development of the asbestosis body Asbestos fibers trans-
ported from the lung to the tracheo-
bronchial lymph nodes not ordinarily
appear to produce these structures
Possibly prolonged residence in the lung
has deprived them of their capacity for further reaction or possibly some necessary factor is lacking in the lymph nodes It is believed that the
few asbestosis bodies found in the
in length rapidly develop which exhibit irregular swellings and buds Ferric silicate is probably formed
nodes were transported after attaining
full development in the pulmonary
air spaces Injection of asbestos dust
This product is partially hydrolyzed
producing a thin wrinkled skin of silicic
into the peritoneal cavity of guineapigs has failed to produce characteristic
acid streaked with ferric hydroxide This skin acting as a semipermeable
membrane permits diffusion to take
place and a high osmotic pressure
develops with a consequent rupture
of the membrane Further hydrolysis
occurs and the reaction repeats itself
structures in any quantity In the
subcutaneous tissues they do develop
but the period of incubation is nearly twice as long as that required in the
lung Practically no asbestosis bodies
have formed in the lungs of rabbits and
albino rats The necessary environ-
mental factors which are lacking in
ane becomes
; of fibrous
estosis bodies
h with dilute and a soluble and silica sols
id us to con-
is body is a
lline asbestos oxidized and
yellow amorch it can be
et evidence of sition in an
the evidence ould indicate
pig and of
favorable en-
pment of the
s fibers transthe tracheo-
not ordinarily
se structures
ice in the lung r capacity for ossibly some king in the
eved that the ound in the
fter attaining e pulmonary
asbestos dust
y of guinea-
characteristic
tity In the y do develop tion is nearly quired in the
estosis bodies of rabbits and sary environ-
re lacking in
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST 107
any of these situations are entirely
not sufficient for the production of
asbestosis bodies
unknown
Attempts to determine whether the
Pulmonary Fibrosis
asbestosis body will develop in the
inhalation
animal when any of the theoretically
That the continued of asbestos dust is responsible for the
necessary elements are lacking have
The
development of pulmonary fibrosis is
thus far met with little success that now unquestioned From many parts
experiments in vitro indicate
of the world come radiographic reports
crystalline ferric or ferrous silicate in
viscosity and a
of fine fibrosis in the lungs of persons the inhala-
a medium of proper
essential exposed by occupation to
fiber for support are probably
tion of this substance The findings
to the production of these structures from at least ten postmortem examina-
In our attempt to determine whether
have furnished reliable evidence
iron derived from the tissues could be
tions
that the shadows seie n tn he roentgeno-
fibrous substituted for the iron inherent in
are produced by areas of
the chrysotile molecule we have been
gram tissue
20
In guinea experi-
__ defeated by the fact that the manipula- ments reported in this paper it has
tion necessary to remove the iron from that
been shown that the fibrosis begins in
the fiber apparently renders soluibnlthee body fluids
those portions of the lung where the is localized and that this reaction
structure The injection and the inhalation of
dust
detected in ray pictures after
dark Barre granite dust which con-
can
about two years exposure to the con-
tains both free silica and iron have
of dust used Fig 3
never resulted in the formation of
centration
The earliest evidence of proliferation
structures in any way suggesting of fibroblasts has been encountered
asbestosis bodies
The solution of micro-
approximately 500 days after the
iron can be demonstrated by
is commencement of the dust exposure
chemical tests and it generally
in the immediate
assumed that the silica is also ulti- It first appears
accumulations
mately dissolved Intraperitoneal in-
vicinity of the largest of dust cells which occur in the
jections of granite from Lorain County respiratory bronchiole and its adjacent
Ohio have been made because ma- alveoli As
amounts of
increasing terial contains iron in the unusual form dust accumulate in the walls of these
is
of ferrous carbonate No suggestion
of an asbestosis body has been dis-
light
covered In the light of subsequent
otherwise structures structures
thethe amount ofof fibrfoisbisrosis
sltriucktuerewsise increased In the otherwise
normal
pig guinea
guinea
migration
migration
of
dust
studies
studies it is
now
recognized
recognized
that
the
peritoneum is not a proper location for
a test and subcutaneous
such inocula- tions have
been made with this
already substance but it is too early to report
on them
Thus far it would appear that the mere presence of iron and free silica is
cells to intrapulmonary lymphoidlymphoid tissue has not been encountered and in
consequence the nodular foci of fibro-
sis which are so characteristic of the reaction to quartz dust fail to develop
The occurrence in one of the last
animals killed of a more diffuse fibrosis peripheral to the point of
salting
Og
108
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
At maximum dust deposition suggests more
that collapse induration incident
slowly than asbestos in the
occlusion of
to
respiratory bronchioles
guinea
After 910 days the maxi-
may play an important later mum period of experimental exposure
stages of the disease process
to granite the lungs show large
Asbestos dust a silicate of
magne-
sium is relatively soluble in fluids
masses in
of
dust
filled
phagocytes
lying
the lumen of the alveoli along the
parable with those of the
com- alveolar ducts and atria In the
tissues The
asbestosis body develops only after
adjacent septums there is a slight
solution has occurred in the
thickening due to the presence of
environment
proper
The development of
lymphoid and monocytic cells but
these structures in the lungs of guinea- fibrosis is entirely lacking The sig-
pigs and of human beings is the first nificant feature is the absence of dust
direct evidence of solubility of
particles in the connective tissues of the
an
inhaled dust known to produce pul-
lung In the tracheobronchial lymph
nodes on the other hand dust accumu-
monary fibrosis It still remains be
a demonstrated whether
lates in such quantities that
stance is the
dissolved sub- develops within one
fibrosis
factor responsible for the two
year and after
multiplication of fibroblasts in pneu-
years exposure the lymphoid tissues are largely destroyed by a
monokoniosis In this connection the
_ evidence from asbestos
series of true silicotic nodules
It has
inhalation in the rabbit should prove most valuable
been postulated that fibrosis has not
developed in the lung of the
_ If after a proper period of
animal
exposure typical asbestosis bodies should still
exposed to granite because the dust particles do not
be lacking and if fibrosis should like- intimate
come into sufficiently
wise fail to develop it would be logical
to conclude that fibroblasts
contact with the fibroblasts of the alveolar walls In the lymph
were not
stimulated because no solution of the
nodes on the other hand fibrosis begins early and
dust had occurred Thus far the nodules
typical because silicotic
reaction of the rabbit has only been
are produced because heavy
studied during an exposure period of concentrations of dust are brought into
330 days The only sign of asbestosis close proximity with connective tissue
body formation is an irregular swelling
elements
The conditions of the
of certain fibers which give micro- with
experiments
chemical tests for iron evidence of
granite and asbestos dusts would
theoretically fibrosis is entirely lacking The 500-
favor a greater reaction in
day period of exposure when true
the former case The concentration of granite dust was over
fibrosis appeared in the
eight times as
is anxiously awaited
guinea great as that of asbestos 287,700,000
particles less than 1.5 microns in
Comparison between Reactions to
diameter perper cubic foot of air for
;
Asbestos and to Other Dusts
Granite dust which is known to
pro-
voke the formation of extensive fibrosis in human beings appears to act
granite and only 34,466,000 particles
of the same size for asbestos However the greater solubility of mag-
nesium silicate together with its peculiar localization probably is the
estos in the
ays the maxi-
ntal exposure
show large
gocytes lying coli along the
ria In the
is a slight
presence of
C cells but g The sigsence of dust issues of the chial lymph
ust accumu-
hat fibrosis
. and after
lymphoid yed by a
es It has is has not he animal ' the dust
ufficiently
Sibroblasts he lymph
silicotic
se heavy
ught into
ive tissue
criments
ts would action in ration of imes as
700,000
rons in air for
articles.
Howf magth its is the
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
109
factor responsible for the production of the more rapid and extensive pulmonary fibrosis by asbestos dust
Quartz which is generally accepted
as the most active of all the nontoxic
dusts which are inhaled in industry is much less easily dissolved than asbes-
tos and yet it will produce extensive fibrosis in the lungs of experimental
animals more rapidly In guinea pulmonary fibrosis and even necrosis has been observed after one year's
exposure to quartz dust in rabbits typical silicotic nodules are formed in
eighteen months The difference in
the rate of reaction to quartz and asbestos has been ascribed to several
causes With equivalent concentra-
tions of dust in two given atmospheres
more quartz than asbestos particles
will be inhaled and reach the paren-
chyma of the lung This is presumably due to the relative differences in
the shape and the surface characteris-
tics of the particles After phagocytosis quartz particles seem to possess the ability to stimulate a rapid migration of the dust cells so that they concentrate large masses of dust about nodules of intrapulmonary lymphoid tissue Here again but by a different
mechanism the foreign bodies are
carborundum does excite fibrosis and structures suggesting silicotic nodules
have been discovered As in the case
of granite proliferatioofn fibroblasts
occurs at the point where they are
in intimate contact with sufficient
numbers of dust laden phagocytes
Whether solution of carborundum by the body fluids is possible has never been determined
From these observations on the reaction to various types of dust an hypothesis has been developed that fibroblasts proliferate in response to
sufficient concentrations of a soluble
substance liberated by the action of the phagocytes on the included dust particles The soluble substance
probably diffuses through the membrane of the intact phagocytes but it is only stimulating to fibroblasts in the immediate vicinity The undefined soluble substance possibly silica in some form is rapidly neutralized after leaving the cells in which it is
produced and it exerts no effect upon
more remote connective tissue ele-
ments The process of neutralization
may be chemical in nature or it may be
a result of absorption by some other type of cell which is itself unaffected
collected in circumscribed areas Sub-
Theoretical Consideration of
sequently perhaps as the result of
Pneumonokoniosis
solution of the quartz a local pro-
liferation of fibroblasts takes place
Carborundum dust has produced no
In a previous paper dealing largely with the reactions to granite and carborundum dusts 21 it was sug-
pulmonary fibrosis after exposure as gested that the primary lesion of pneu-
Fe long as three or four years In the
lung it is treated much like granite
monokoniosis consists in the develop-
ment of an obstructive fibrosis in
dust collected in phagocytes which the tracheobronchial lymph nodes
remain within the air spaces so that attended by stasis in the afferent
M
M the dust cells establish no contact with
the underlying connective tissue In the tracheobronchial lymph nodes
lymphatics in the lung and ultimately followed by a perilymphatic fibrosis When only these two types of dust had
110
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE -
A been studied such an hypothesis to the
looked tempting for the only trace of
asbestos dust cells but for causes
fibrosis in the lung in these cases was
inherent in themselves they do not
migrate to these vessels
situated about the large lymph trunks
.
Masses of dust filled phagocytes lay Tuberculous Infection and
for many months in the air spaces and
Asbestosis
Where inhalation infection is insti-
apparently provoked not the slightest reaction of the connective tissues
tuted simultaneously with commence-
ment of dust
But subsequent experimental investi- of
exposures the majority
gation has modified this concept it is
inhaled tubercle bacilli localize in
small peripheral lymphoid masses in
now believed that fibrosis develops
wherever sufficient amounts of dust of
zone immediately beneath the pleura
This is
the proper type come into intimate
characteristic of such infection
contact with fibroblasts The pri-
with the organism used in the experiment A certain number
mary obstructive lesion in the tracheo- rest
come to
bronchial lymph nodes occurs with
atypically in the deeper lymphoid
tissues along the intermediate bronchi
quartz inhalations but not with asbes-
tos Undoubtedly such a lesion has
possibly because they are mechanically
arrested by inhaled dust
tens the development of reaction in The
particles
the lung for it reduces elimination and
majority of the tubercles formed
concentrates the dust but it is not
undergo spontaneous resolution which
is the outcome of the infection in
essential to the production of pulmo- most normal control
nary fibrosis
animals
cer-
One further point in connection with
tain number of tubercles by accident localize in
the state of the lymphatics deserves
proximity to foci of localized
dust If
comment In
the contact is sufficiently
experimental asbestosis both in the
intimate these tubercles spread locally
guinea and in the and more remotely into foci of dust
rabbit the lymph vessels are widely reaction about
dilated after as short an
respiratory bronchioles
from
exposure as A new crop of tubercles develop in
thirty to sixty days Inhaled this location and these
asbestos dust is not transported to the
may progress
and even form small cavities but the
ctornascihdeeorbarbolnechial lymph nodes in any ultimate outcome is usually healing
quantity and no obstructive lesion has been produced at this
with more or less extensive fibrosis
and calcification The
time Therefore in this case the dila-
tuberculous
tation of these vessels
process is practically never generalized
other
must have some throughout the lung but is generally
cause possibly it is merely a confined to small nodular foci Blood
physiologic response to intrapulmo- stream metastasis is usual and
nary irritation Asbestos filled phago- scopic disease in the
macro-
cytes do not enter these channels be- times in the liver
spleen and some-
cause they are apparently relatively rence almost
is common an occur-
inactive but epithelioid cells contain-
controls
never found in infection
In the thirty animals of
ing tubercle bacilli may leave the lung
in
this group dead at the time of this
great numbers Apparently the report a spread of the
lymphatic channel of escape is open
tuberculous infection occurred in 32.2 cent In
GIENE
ust cells but for causes
mselves they do not
* vessels
ection and Asbestosis
tion infection is insti-
usly with commencexposures the majority
cle bacilli localize in
lymphoid masses in a y beneath the pleura
istic of such infection
m used in the experi-
in number come to
1 the deeper lymphoid
intermediate bronchi they are mechanically
aled dust particles the tubercles formed
cous resolution which of the infection in trol animals A cer-
ubercles by accident ty to foci of localized Intact is sufficiently percles spread locally ly into foci of dust piratory bronchioles ubercles develop in
. these may progress
all cavities but the
is usually healing
s extensive fibrosis The tuberculous
ily never generalized ng but is generally
nodular foci Blood is usual and macro-
e spleen and some-
s common an occurr found in infection
mirty animals of at the time of this of the tuberculous
in 32.2 per cent In
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
111
40 per cent of them the tuberculosis
had subsequently more or less completely healed by fibrosis It seems probable that in the remaining mem-
bers of the group a similar result would
have been attained had they not died
prematurely from accidental causes
Where inhalation infection was
superimposed upon a established asbestosis of approximately two years standing the primary localization of the tubercles was atypical Many of
the tubercle bacilli were mechanically
held up by the reaction to the dust in the respiratory bronchioles It would
appear that many perhaps the majority of these organisms were phago-
cytosed and carried directly into the distended lymphatic trunks The
earliest manifestation of tubercle formation occurred not in the lung but
in the tracheobronchial lymph nodes
a condition which has never before been observed in experimental inhalation infection Some organisms local-
ized in the foci of dust reaction and
then produced tubercles a certain number of bacilli passed to the periphery where typical subpleural lesions developed The major portion of the guinea comprising this group died or were killed during a period of forty-
eight days after infection Within
this time not much extension of the
intrapulmonary infection had occurred The tracheobronchial lymph nodes were heavily involved in all animals dead after the thirty day It is too early to state what will be the
ultimate outcome of infection super-
imposed upon a preestablished asbes-
tosis
From these experiments it would
appear that inhaled asbestos dust is
capable of exerting some stimulating
effect upon tubercle bacilli of attenuated virulence To exert this effect the dust and the tubercle bacilli must
be brought into rather intimate association This occasionally occurred
when the infection and the onset of the
dust inhalation were simultaneous it was much more common where infec-
tion was superimposed upon an already
established asbestosis The dust per-
haps by the action of its dissolved prod-
ucts or by alteration in tissue reaction initiates a renewed proliferation of the tubercle bacilli and the infec-
tion spreads But this stimulating effect is only temporary and ultimately the foci of new disease tend to heal by fibrosis In this respect
inhaled asbestos dust differs from
quartz which incites continued and progressive multiplication of the bacteria and consequent spread of disease
As has been observed with the other
types of dust granite and carborundum the presence of asbestos in the lung of an animal infected with tubercle bacilli promotes more extensive fibrosis than is produced when either the organism or the dust is acting alone Where the two irritants
are concentrated in the same area
each provokes the formation of granulation tissue which ultimately organ-
izes to form fibrosis But even in areas of dust reaction remote from the
site of tubercle the fibrosis is excessive an effect for which explanation is lack-
ing Figs 15 and 16.
SUMMARY
Guinea have been exposed for eight hours daily for periods as long as
two and third years to an atmos-
phere containing approximately thirtyfive million particles per cubic foot of
asbestos the
en
dust Canadian chrysotile 1.5 microns and less in
due to the contraction of the included
Rabbits and albino
diameter alveoli and consequent compression
rats have likewise
been exposed for shorter
of the epithelial lining cells
In the
days
periods 330 rabbit sufficient time has not yet
- The experiments demonstrate that elapsed for fibrosis to be expected
tn
fibrous structures at
In the lungs of guinea asbes-
iyRy
200 microns
least as long as tosis bodies apparently identical with
Ate
can pass the protective mechanism of the
those described in the human being
On tract and enter theulppuenrg reAsnpaitraotmoircy have developed after an exposure of
R R evidence of injury to this mechanism
approximately seventy days In the
rabbit these structures have not been
I is wanting
Re
Inhaled asbestos dust does
discovered after exposures as long as
not 330 days In the albino rat they are
RA
penetrate to the terminal alveoli of
AT the lung as is the case with
very Only two small typical
late substance such
a particu- forms have been discovered in one
as quartz The
major portion is held up in the respira-
animal exposed for seventy days The prevalence of chronic infections of the
tory bronchioles There phagocytosis lung in all members of this
takes place and there the material possibly responsible
series is
remains localized at least for a period
Asbestosis bodies
of two and third
apparently fail to
years
cytes containing asbestos
Phago-
form in the tracheobronchial lymph
particles migrate into the lateral alveoli given
nodes of guinea They may be transported in small numbers to
off from the walls of the bronchioles
and considerable numbers
these tissues and to areas of chronic pleurisy
ultimately They have not been discovered in the
penetrate the adjacent connective tissues In the guinea transpor-
peritoneal cavity 100 days after injec-
tion of dust In the
tation of dust particles to intrapulmo- sue of the
subcutaneous tis-
nary and mediastinal lymphoid tissues
is so slow that
groin typical forms were found 102 days after the injection of
changes in these struc- 3 mg of dust
tures play little part in the early
Asbestosis bodies
development of asbestosis In the
are not present in
rabbit dust cells begin to
asbestos dust previous to contact with
the lymphoid tissues of
appear in animal tissues They are produced by
sixty days after the the lung within oxidation and hydrolysis of the chryso-
commencement of
the inhalation thereafter they con-
tile molecule The formation of these
structures is the first direct evidence
tinue to migrate in increasing numbers that the body is capable of
In the guinea fibrosis in the
effecting
walls of the respiratory bronchioles and changes in inhaled silicate particles
their lateral alveoli is first
The chemical processes involved have
manifested after 500 days exposure Thereafter
been discussed in extenso Attempts
at artificial production of asbestosis
this type of reaction
progressively bodies in vitro have been
increases in intensity and extent
partially suc-
The resulting atelectasis is responsible
cessful solutions of ferric chloride and sodium silicate have been made to com-
for a gland appearance which is bine in the presence of a fiber to pro-
YGIENE
raction of the included onsequent compression
al lining cells In the
at time has not yet sis to be expected
of guinea asbesarently identical with in the human being
after an exposure of
eventy days In the
ictures have not been
exposures as long as he albino rat they are y two small typical n discovered in one or seventy days The
onic infections of the bers of this series is ble
ies apparently fail to cheobronchial lymph pigs They may be
all numbers to these
s of chronic pleurisy
en discovered in the 100 days after injecthe subcutaneous tis-
typical forms were fter the injection of
es are not present in ious to contact with
hey are produced by rolysis of the chrysoe formation of these irst direct evidence capable of effecting 1 silicate particles
esses involved have
extenso Attempts
ction of asbestosis
been partially suc-
ferric chloride and been made to come of a fiber to pro-
REACTION TO INHALED ASBESTOS DUST
113
duce more or less typical forms The asbestosis body is therefore analogous to the known silicate garden Attempts to produce asbestosis bodies in vivo by the injection of dusts containing iron salts and silicates have thus far failed The failure to produce them in tissues other than the lung and subcutaneous tissues of guinea and man has not been explained
Comparison between the localization
and the reaction to asbestos and other
types of inhaled dusts has been shown The points at which inhaled dust is
localized in the lung or lymph nodes vary with the type of dust Granite remains within the pulmonary air spaces and produces no local reaction
fibroblasts for several years In the
tracheobronchial lymph nodes characteristic silicotic nodules develop within
two years Carborundum likewise has
failed to affect the stroma of the lung
even in four years but fibrosis the
lymph nodes has been observed Quartz is rapidly concentrated by migrating phagocytes in the pulmonary and mediastinal lymphoid tissues In these places it provokes an early and rapid multiplication of fibroblasts Asbestos as it is inhaled is concentrated in respiratory bronchioles and their lateral alveoli Phagocytes carry it into the walls where fibroblasts
are stimulated
Lymph stasis plays little part in early asbestosis the structure of this
dust tends to localize it within the
lung from the start Lymph vessels
are dilated in the absence of detectable
obstruction The dilatation may be a
direct result of pulmonary irritation Primary tuberculous infection is in-
fluenced only to a limited degree by
inhaled asbestos This conclusion has
been reached after inhalation infection
with attenuated tubercle bacilli strain
R
In normal guinea such in-
fection produces tubercles in the lung
and tracheobronchial lymph nodes
comparable to the primary complex
in man The lesions caseate and the
pulmonary foci heal by resolution Spread of the infection with macroscopic disease in other viscera is very rare In the asbestos experiment one group of guinea was infected at the outset of dust inhalation a second
group two years after the commencement of dust exposure In the first
series 32.2 per cent of the animals showed some evidence of spreading tuberculosis New disease began as a local extension from primary tubercles
and metastasis to areas where dust
reaction had occurred was common
Rarely small cavities developed in the secondary foci The tendency to healing by fibrosis was marked at autopsy
40 per cent of the cases showed healed
, fibrous tuberculosis macroscopic disease in the spleen and sometimes in the
liver was common The contrast with
animals similarly infected but exposed
to quartz dust is marked In them every exposure longer than five months
resulted in generalized chronic tuberculosis of the lungs and other viscera
For the second asbestosis group
infected the localization of tubercles was atypical Many bacilli were trapped in foci of dust reaction Some produced local tubercles others immediately entered the dilated lymph vessels and were transported to the tracheobronchial lymph nodes Tu-
berculosis in these nodes sometimes
occurred without involvement of the
lung Early disease in the spleen and hepatic lymph nodes was the rule
114
THE JOURNAL INDUSTRIAL
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
The ultimate outcome infection
The
infection dust
ultimate outcome outcome of infection observed
group not been observed asbestos
independently and tubercle bacilli the lung lung
produced fibrosis than did
lung
either either
acting independently
BIBLIOGRAPHY
aOtea Commonly McDONALD Relatively 1, ANDERSON V. ,
AND AND CLARK L L.: ANDERSONH. V. Rays the Classi-
Classi-
Cooke W. .: Pulmonary
Med
Pulmonary Asbestosis
Application Application Fibrous Silicate Minerals
Jour Histology of Pulmon- Pulmon-
Commonly
Termed Asbestos In- McDONALD
Histology 1025 Pulmon- Pulmon-
2.
Commonly Termed Chem1929 21 924 924
Asbestosis Asbestosis Pulmonary Asbestosis Asbestosis
+
GARDNER Engin Engin Studies the Rela- RelaGARDNER GARDNER
SIMSON SIMSON .: Pulmonary Pulmonary1928 885
Mineral Dusts Tuberculosis Tuberculosis
tion of Relatively EarlyLesions Lesions in
South Africa The
STEWART STEWART Pulmonary Pulmonary
Immediate Immediate Di- 885,
Experimental PneumokoniosisPneumokoniosis
agnosis
PulmonaryAsbestosis Asbestosis Di-
Experimental by Granite
Pro-
Pulmonary 1928 509 at
Inhalationand and their
Influence on Pulmonary
Necropsy Pulmonary Pulmonary Asbestosis Asbestosis
Influence Rev.
Pulmonary Tuberculosis
Tuberc 1920-1921 734 734
Coo--"E Coo--"E585 Pulmonary Pulmonary
ary Asbestosis, STEWART M. .:
3. GARDNER L. U. AND
,
Idem II The
DWORSKI .: STEWART Ibid 675 J.: Pulmonary Asbestosis.
sions Produced by the InhaElaartliyonLeo-f
STEWART M. .:
15. ing Sputum for Asbestosis Asbestosis Bodies
Marble Dust andand their Influence 1922
Bodies
Pulmonary TuberculosisTuberculosis Ibid 1922
Ibid 1929 581 for Presence the
1923 6 782
GLOYNE R The The
4. GARDNER L. Idem III The Experimental
tively Early Lesions in Experimental
Pneumokoniosis Produced their In-
borundum Inhalation and Tuberculosis Tuberculosis
fluence on Pulmonary Tuberculosis
Ibid 1923 , 344
8. GARDNER , U PneumonokoniosisPneumonokoniosis Pneumonokoniosis The
mental Pneumonokoniosis Primary Tu-
Reactivation Reactivation Lung Inhalation Inhalation
bercles bercles in Granite Granite and Carborun-
of Quartz Granite 1929 833
dum Dusts J. and Haddow Haddow
6. STEWART Demonstration Demonstration of Peculiar Peculiar Bodies
Demonstration Asbestosis Asbestosis Asbestosis Asbestosis
of Pulmonary Material (Obtained
Bodies Puncture Puncture the Sputum
Jour Path and Bacteriol Bacteriol 1929
Jour 172 and
7. CUMMINGS
Studies Experi-
P. 16. Asbestos Fibre Fibre the Lesions of the
Asbestos Workers Tubercle Tubercle 1929 of
404 Workers,
RAY R.
The The
Conditions Conditions 17. Optimum Optimum
Conditions Alkali Forma- Sili-
tion from Alkali Jour Phys
cate Solutions Solutions Part I. Phys Phys
Chem 1930 Silicates Silicates in In-
VAIL New Soluble York
18. dustry dustry New York 79 in In-
Catalog Co. EVANS W. 9n
MOORE Growth Growth Resembling Resembling Resembling
19. Forms Organisms and Products Products
n
Slowly Organisms Organisms from Metastable Solutions
Deposited Inorganic Colloids Proc Roy
Inorganic Series 1915-1917 1915-1917
Soc London Series Proc.
MEREWETHER
MEREWETHER
E.
A.
PRICE
PRICE PRICE
MEREWETHER
7. mental mental Pneumonokoniosis Pneumonokoniosis Pneumonokoniosis Pneumonokoniosis IV
Separation Particulate Particulate Matter
Smaller than Screen Graded Fractions Fractions THIS JOUR 1929 Resolution
GARDNER L. Healing by Resolution Resolution 8. in Experimental Experimental Experimental Pulmonary Pulmonary
in culosis Rev. 19221923 6 163 Tubere., 1929-
1923, 6, 163,
Dust Infection 20.
Lungs and
pression pression in the Asbestoands DInduustrsy tIndSuustpr-y
Part I. London London M. Stationery Stationery
Office 1930 the Asbestos
Gardner Gardner L. Tuberculous Tuberculous
Infection and Tuberculosis
21, Experimental Experimental Experimental Pneumonokoniosis Pneumonokoniosis Tubercle Tubercle 1924-1925 336 by Tubercle Pneumonokoniosis, Tubercle, 1924-1925, 6, 336, 443,
YGIENE
cle bacilli in the lung
ibrosis than did either
ependently
: Pulmonary Asbestosis
our 1927 2 1024
: Histology of Pulmonis Ibid p 1025 : Pulmonary Asbestosis ica Ibid 1928 1 885
.: The Immediate Diulmonary Asbestosis at id 1928 2 509
Pulmonary Asbestosis
Pulmonary Asbestosis
: A Method of Examin-
for Asbestosis Bodies
. The Presence of the
e in the Lesions of kers Tubercle 1929
Ganguly P. B The
litions for the FormaGel from Alkali Sili-
Part I. Jour Phys
, 352 uble Silicates in In-
York The Chemical c 1928 p 79
Qn EVANS W. .:
h Resembling Living
their Products Slowly
Metastable Solutions
olloids Proc Roy ries B. 1915-1917 89
R. A. AND PRICE
on Effects of Asbestos
ings and Dust Sup-
Asbestos Industry
4 H. M. Stationery
uberculous Infection
as Modified by Pneumonokoniosis
925 6 336 443
THE CALLED CYANIDE RASH
The Editor Journal of Industrial Hygiene
Sir
Braddock and Tingle's article on Called Cyanide Rash in Gold Mine Mill Workers in the JOURNAL for September 1930 interests me because I can add sixteen years personal experience and observations from New Zealand and the state of Western Australia to the other countries listed As a cyanide salt we first used potassium cyanide but this was superseded as in all countries by sodium cyanide The solutions were a stock liquor of up to 20 per cent from which the working solutions of 0.1 to 0.2 per cent were made Ordinarily these working solutions were cold but when in some plants the roasted ore was mixed
therewith the solutions became hot and remained warm to the end of the process
An odor of cyanide pervades every gold or silver ore treatment plant and renders smoking unpleasant As Braddock and Tingle conclude the rash
appears to be a dermatitis is it is a superficial aliment the blood is not a
factor I had the rash more or less severely on the arms and face especially at the hair roots others had it there and on the legs Drinkers and nondrinkers and smokers and nonsmokers alike were affected but not everyone employed around cyanide As far as my observation went as one handling cyanide salts and solutions also as a foreman and metallurgist there was no lack of personal cleanliness among the men as suggested Some men became immune to the rash after being affected for a time others had to change their jobs The wearing of rubber gloves helps but they induce sweating which often starts a rash As rule we used potassium permanganate solution but zinc oxide ointment also alleviated the trouble which as Braddock and Tingle conclude is probably due to irritation by the strong caustic excited by lime used in the process We never considered it as cyanide poisoning but simply a skin
outbreak M. W. VON BERNEWITZ
Pittsburgh Pa December 19 1930
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
already 1931 4 THE some other
some other
source 9.
young young person under
other source of 9.
approved approved in writing the local 18 years
young
age of age of
shall be allowed allowed work to
"
approved district which the Provided
bath shall
that Regulation
work
situated situated situated which shall
on
suit- not
apply any young
Regulation shall shall
young person already
ssel where water
employed August August
Except where
is de- so
The occupier
that the
where water which official
conveniently Placard an upward
Cautionary
shallshall that the that the
affixed affixed to the
rkers rkers conveniently
effects
or drinking drinking
tchehrome chrome the position position as to affixed
one suitable suitable supply supply be
works such such persons employed employed as to
drinking at each point supply drinking
drinking water supply be employed
drinking Drinking Water
racticable steps shall taken taken rve the water and vessels from ination
employed person made and for record record bya
responsible inspections kept in the
such inspections Register to be
record
Health Register
kept in the
e occupier shall make such arents for first aid treatment of to persons employed as will
Parr II
with the requirements laid
shall t factories in Section 29 Act ,
rkmen's Compensation that
1d in addition shall see that
ttaid box is provided and im-
supply of ointment and im-
le waterproof employed
12. very person Surgeon
in ined urteen days or at such other
urteen days specified
writing in 28 specified Chief may Inspector Factories Factories Factories Chief
which notice ocfoncerned concerned andsshuachlexlami-
.
Duties person employed
shall or without the
concurrence in mis-
occupier occupier responsible responsible
person appliance the
charge interfere
pursuance Regu- in
provided pursuance pursuance
lations in
these Regu-
person employed employed
wear protective and
under Regulation
shall deposit
clothing when being the protective clothing provided provided
worn Regulation
under
shall place when not
Regulation Regulation Every person employed
shall
13a himself himself
t ealth
ealth persons
all
employed shall
form approved the Chief
Factories suspension suspension suspension
of person
yed without written or
ved Surgeon entered Register
the Health Register or atthe Health Register,
suance Regulation Regulation Regulation
suance
shall
after suspension person after suspension shall shall
work in process involving
with with liquid from
without
written written
bath without
sanction sanction the Health
entered entered attached attached the Health
Register Register from the
entered in
Surgeon,
Register, or attached to the H.
SUBJECT INDEX TO VOLUME XIII
index to all the reading matter in the ABSTRACTS OF THE Literature OF ITNhDiUsSTisRIaAsLubHjYeGcIt ENE and one should therefore look for the subject word The name
of the author follows the subject entry in parenthesis
For author index see page 288
PAGE
PAGE
ABSENTEEISM in coal mines Vernon Bedford and Warner 255
ACCIDENTS see also under Safety specific occupations and specific parts
of body
ACCIDENTS and diseases international
congress of see International Con-
AIR conditions see also under Heat Humidity and Temperature
infiltration through wood windows Larson Nelson and Kubasta
pollution pollution Simpson et al
pollution amelioration amelioration of Green fourteenth report 1927-
engineer's
267 37
248
gress
clinic Shellowes 22 save electric fatal Pietrusky 22
refrigerating machines Wen-
191
pollution from engineer's standpoint Meller eradication
pollution smoke eradication to save health value of sunshine Tonney
IndufsitrialnrdouImnsdtusrtiriaallprevepenrttiaoinning Rossi 156 248 problems neuroses
law
to
154
Barreto
Martineck 156
study
and DeYoung York
pollution soot particles in New York City air Free probl W e om ls -
pollution special problems Wol-
proneness psychologic 98
man Blanke
Boston Farmer
cee
cie eee ene
eee
Elevated Rail-
removal of allergens from Blanke 248
238 reduction by Boston
35
for fine powders Roller
way Slocombe .
separator ACCUMULATORS see Batteries
velocities influence of on skin tem-
of men at rest and at work
ACID see under names of specific acids
perature
Palmer Palmer.... ACROLEIN use of for detecting leakage
Liese functional Palmer
194
of methyl chloride from multiple
ALBUMINURIA
removal from air Blanke 248
Schrenk refrigeration system
ALLERGENS
ALUMINIUM baking powders effects of
Patty and Yant 6
habitual of on utilization of
use use of for detecting leakage of methyl
food Kraft reer 102
refrigerators chloride from
Yant 5 AMINO ACIDS treatment of tar tumors
Schrenk Patty and Sayers .....
of
with Vl^sde Coulon and Nicod 206
ADHESIVE PLASTER bandage healing 128 AMINO COMPOUNDS aromatic indus-
wounds under Dabasi
trial illnesses produced by
AGRICULTURE child labor in in Colo-
231
rado Mautner Abbott Bell and
Mayer gets
aromatic poisoning
in fly paper
by Abbotteeee eens Bispham GGGG
factor^ Rosenthal Deussen 231
children in McGill
.
GGGG
aromatic production of bladder tu-
AIR analyses in Illinois mines Miller
238
by Sch^/r mors
explosibil- explosibil- 110
explosibil- analyzer for fine powders Roller GGGG AMMONIA and air mixtures
and mine gases MacEachern
comparative temperatures with vary-
231
ity of Banik ANILINE poisoning Bonzanigo 196
ing air movements underground
104
tumors of bladder results of opera-
our homes Ranson home Bu s l-
3
tions for Simon
conditioning cooling our homes Bul-
ANTHRACOSIS Cummins and Sladden 48
Schulte lard
0... cece application eee nee
eens
of
and tuberculosis (
. ...
17
conditioning problems application
122
in coal miners Cummins .. spu-
heat and moisture losses during Miller
origin of pigment in anthracotic spu-
work Houghten Teague
266
tum Paviot Chevallier and Badi-
Car- and Yant
occupational disease recent
Car-
nand occupational tess 169
conditioning and progress
217 ANTHRAX as occupational disease
~~.
rier Vernon
Cheney conditions in pithead baths Vernon
93
Smyth and
Uhlenhuth neeeeeee
campaign against Uhlenhuth Uhlenhuth 30
charged with
Bedford and Warner
conditions thermal exchanges be-
disinfection of skins
tween bodies of men working and
fatBarl octaszeuCa hretien J aunli denJulien Julien 30
atmospheric environment Houghten Teague Miller and Yant 214
94
in industry Schmidt ..
271
SUBJECT INDEX
273
PAGE
BLOOD
high daily and
monthprleyssruhryethm in Brown 101
pressure high occupational impor-
tance Dumas 257
pressure in lead poisoning Petroff 25
pressure low after burns Blalock 245
pressure reduction in after trauma
to extremity Blalock 245
stream composition of fluid that es-
capes from after traumas Beard
and Blalock . 245
transfusion gas poisoning and Sen-
nelnesls
vessels cancer cells in in tar cancer
Babes boil tubular te ubularbr oilerss boilers 167
BOILER work in hot tubular boilers Van Themsche and Wautriche 216
BOILS see Furunculosis
BONE roentgen sign of plumbism VogVogtt) ... shadows produced by lead in growing
skeleton Park Hackson and
Kajdi for formam lin Haa ckson l Hacksoni ean nd 201
BOOKBINDER formalin eczema in
Lutz .
cece ceca
ese
eee 209
BOTTLE making physiologic and hy-
gienic experiments in drjawzew Lessen
Dobrin Sirota
Kuand
Tutkievitsch 0.005% 186
BRAIN effect of carbon monoxide on
barrier apparatus of Gr^...nstein
and Popowa 161
lesions from carbon monoxide Se-
merak and Bacon 162
BRICK cork workers cancer in
Sch^...rch0.0.0 Hud. leson a0 nd. John-. John-. John- 236
son son
BURNS asphalt epithelioma following
( Gunsett . escapes escapes from 125
composition of fluid that escapes from
blood stream after Beard and Bla-
lock ... ccc cece cece eter ee eees 245
low blood pressure after Blalock 245
wax paraffin treatment of Cook 100
prevention of pain and treatment of
NovPa fab Pfabk treatment treatment 128
silver foil treatment of Pfab 100
Underhill superficial changes in capillary permeability induced by Kapsinow and Fisk 181
superficial composition of edema fluid resulting from Underhill and
Fisk
0...
cc
cece
cece eee
eee ees
181
superficial composition of tissues
under influence of Underhill Fisk
and Kapsinfo luid fw or- 181
superficial extent of edema fluid for-
mation induced by Underhill
Fisk Kapsinow 181
superficial nature and effects of Un-
derhill Kapsinow and Fisk 181
superficial relation of blood chlorides
to chlorides of edema fluid pro-
duced by Underhill Fisk and
Kapsinow
ccc. c cece eee neces
181
tannic acid treatment of Prioleau 100
PAGE
BURNS types pathology and management Pack and Davis -
whirlpool baths and posterior splint-
, ing to overcome contractures in
Hilbert . contracues contractures contractures contractures contractures 129
CABINET makers dermatitis venenata
in due to Brazilian walnut wood
Schwartz . relieverelieve 244
CALCIUM CHLORIDE use of to relieve
peristaltic pain Bauer Salter and
Aub
coat: 202
CANCERCANCER c chihmnieymsn wee epsydisadppieasr-appear-
ance of Richter 111
following injury by burning asphalt
Gunsett 0.0... cece cee eee 125
in cork brick workers Sch^...rch236
industrial Teutschlaender of 192
industrial incidence and cause of
Bristol
0... cece
ee
eee
ee eens
227
occupation and Jacobs 111
occupational Blum and Bralez
America Pedley occupational in
occupational neoplastic disease
_
... 192 Haa-
oc ur ence gensen
0. eevee various various 227
occupational occurrence in various
countries Koinuma 191
occupational of bladder and prostate
Kennaway Henry
and Kenna-
way . .111 193
occupational of hand Epstein 157
of lungs Joachimsthal miners Pir-
chan and Sikl Sikl 3
of lungs Joachimsthal miners Sikl 194
of lungs industrial Doubrow 228
producing factor in coal tar pitch
Shiba Kennat way KennawayKena naway..
producing substances Kennaway 136
producing substances fluorescent
Kennaway spectra of
and Hieger 136
producing tars and oils spectra of
Hieger dioxide 136
skin due to carbon dioxide snow
Manse Streef n Streef Stres ef 89 233
tar Bonne Lodder and Streef 89 204
tar Calvanic Streefo eees 135 tar Fabris 0.0. Mel anby M6 elanbyMell. anby.0 .2: 05 167
tar Watson and Mellanby 205 205
tar cancer cells in blood vessels in Babestissue tissue eens 167
tar changes in elastic tissue in Sed-
ginids tissue ree nee es 136 tar in Baden Brenner Choldin eres 134
tar predisposition to Choldin 135
tar susceptibility and resistance to
acids Maisin 204
tar treatment of with amino acids
Vl^sde Coulon and Nicod 206
tarred streets as cause of Lehmann 167
CANNING pineapple in Hawaii employment of women in Manning 54
CARBON BISULPHIDE see Carbon Disul-
phide
in
CARBON DIOXIDE and oxygen in air
simplified Haldane apparatus for determination of Marschak 47
outbursts in mines 84
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
DIOXIDE CARBON
PAGE
physiologic effects
high
CHILDREN
child
labor
and
figures
PAGE
56
physiologic effects prevention of Brown
poisoning in mine disasterdisaster at Neurode
snow skin cancercancer due to Mansens
CARBON DISULPHIDEDISULPHIDE poisoning Holm-
infections )
child labor health hazards
child labor in agriculture and farm
life in Colorado Mautner Abbott
Bell and Bispham
child
workers
on
city
streets
0...
McGill
employment of in New Jersey Mc-
GillGill and Skinner
in agriculture McGill
work
COMPANIES
Eastman Kodak Company n
work of Comstock
Endicott Johnson Company "
service of Carpenter
Four Wheel Drive Auto Co
skin
in operati
Fredenberg . sent e
Milwaukee MONOXIDE asphyxia neuro-
resulting from Chornyak and SayersSayers ... 257
Guillain Thurel and Desoille 162
brain lesions from Semerak
detection of in air with ampoules of
plating palladium salt solution solution Berger and
Yant
school leaver and factory work
CHIMNEY SWEEP cancer disappearance
of disappearance 111
CHROMIC ACID dermatitis Werther 96 96
mist acute effects of Schwarz and
Sieke
CHROMIUM
plating
plating establishments
health conditions in F^rster
..
plating health hazards in Blair 163
health of worker in Trum-
per occupational
plating occupational risks in
Railwa
Electric Railwa Light Company accident c
Shellow Carolina Pacolet Mills South Carolina
program of FullerMilan Pirelli rubber factories Milan
of tuberculosis ....
Workmen's
COMPENSATION see Workmen's
pensation
COMPRESSED AIR tools see Pne
tools moisture
CONDENSATION of moisture con
Roels determination of in air Zapadinskii Leonov
regulations Great Britain
plating effect on barrier apparatus of brain
poisoning with manifestations of sen-
i
161
effect on nervous systemsystem Swetnik
sitization case report Smith ..
gas mask Stampe and Bangert
dermatitis Nightin-
CHRYSANTHEMUM in exhumed cadaver
examinatexi aminatio ons n Nighs tin-
poisoning fatal from gas heating of
CLEcRleKricpahlysiwcoarlkeerxsamiMnuathilobnesrogf mMacl-e
Cord and Allen
85
poisoning in battleship blisters 233
pulse rate readings on clerks Brit-
poisoning in hat industry
ten and Wallace Strauss
poisoning in industry (
CLIMATE and work Strauss
review SayersSayers and Daven-
of working hours to Ishi-
poisoning relation port
hara
treatment of by light
9. CLINIC acM cidi entl ofw Mila wau ukek e Ele ecte ric
poisoningKoza
Railway and Light Company Shel-
mice
Shel- response of mice and
low international
canaries to
Yant Patty Schrenk and Ber-
factory international Rollier
COAL dust explosions see Explosions
danger CARBON TETRACHLORIDETETRACHLORIDE
to
dust in treatment of pulmonary tu-
berculosis Glaser
fat in poisoning with macroscopicmacroscopic pul-
mine see Mine coal miner see Miner coal
monary artery MacMahon and
mining see Mining coal
( CARBUNCLES in miners
tee
Fisher
235
pulverized hazards protection of
Spitzm^...ller CARDIOVASCULAR lesions in machine
workmen Wietfeldt COAL TAR see Tar
Muhlberg Allen and
COLDS common effect of ultraviolet
system functional
light on Doull Hardy Clark and
poisoning LyublinaLyublinla ead 261
Herman
Doull 173
CELLULOSE lacquer see under Lacquer
common
of (
etiology varnish see under Varnish
Bourn and McComb 195
Vogt CONTRACTURES
CONTRACTURES of hand Koch
COPPER content of human Kleinmann and Klinke
determination of in biologic m
t Inouye and Flinn liver
in food cirrhosis of liver due
drianoff
Conk brickworkers brickworkers canc
Sch^...rch
0...
mills sickness
COTTON spinning mills sickness -
operatives in Hill
CYANIDE poisoning new trea
Schmidt .
DEHYDRATION by pilocarpine
varied dietary conditions (
hill and Fisk U
produced by various means U
hill and Fisk .
DEPARTMENT STORES health and
turnover in Ho Pidg
limited price women in Pidg
DERMATOSIS see Skin diseases DIATHERMY surgical in treatme
wounds
...
DIET Nutrition see also pilocarpine
DIET dehydration by pilocarpine U
varied dietary conditions U
Fisk hill and
poisoning poisoning
DINITROBENZENE poisoning Bo
igo
CEMENT dust and tuberculosistuberculosis J^tten
and Kortmann
139
.
order
CHAUFFEUR minimum visual visual acuity of
common etiology of Shibley Mills
and Dochez labor in Mills Mills
COLORADO child labor in agriculture and farm life in Mautner Abbott Bell and Bispham
COMFORT effect of variations in relative humidity on Miura
skin
Bonzanigo
DIOXAN vapors acute respon guinea to Yant Sch
Waite and Patty internat
DISEASE and accidents internat congress of see International
gress
working
with
and use of corrective glasses Kan-
rs
temperature' in relation to
Ward .
COMPANIES
Boston
Elevated
Railway
Railway
accident
reduction work of Slocombe
caused by working with pneu
tools Seyring in
industrial diseases scheduled in
industrial many
Teleky Collis
prevention of Collis
occupational medicolegal as
Kummel
SUBJECT INDEX
275
PAGE
COMPANIES
Comstock Eastman Kodak Company nutrition
work of
. eeeeeeeeeee
Endicott Johnson Company medical
service of Carpenter Four Wheel Drive Auto Company
skin infections in operatives of
Fredenberg
Milwaukee Electric Railway and
Light Company accident clinic of
Shellow health Pacolet Mills South Carolina health
program of Pirelli rubber
..
fafcatcotroireises
Milan
Milan
teens
study
of tuberculosis in Com-
COMPENSATION see Workmen's Com-
COMPRESSED pensation Pneumatic AIR tools see Pneumatic tools
CONDENSATION of moisture control of
Vogt
.
e
ccc c eee
eee ete ee scene
CONTRACTURES of hand Koch
COPPER content of human organs
Kleinmann and Klinke determination of in biologic material
Inouye and Flinn
in food cirrhosis of liver due to An-
drianoff oo...
cece
Cork brickworkers brickworkers
eee
eee
cancer
eee
in
Sch^...rchsickness ves,
COTTON spinning mills sickness among
operatives in Hill CYANIDE poisoning new treatment
Schmidt ..........00se005 se eees
175
105
20 212 164
DEHYDRATION by pilocarpine under varied dietary conditions Under-
hill and Fisk cee a cence
produced by various means Under-
hill and Fisk labor labor
DEPARTMENT STORES health and labor
Ho turnover in
limited
limited price women in Pidgeon DERMATOSIS see Skin diseases DIATHERMY surgical in treatment of
Spitzm^...ller wounds
DIET see also
Nutrition
. e eee e eee pilocarpine
DIET dehydration by pilocarpine under
varied dietary conditions Under-
hill and Fisk
DINIigoiTgoROBENZENE poisoning Bonzan-
DINITROCHLOROBENZENE poisoning
Bonzani poisoning g poisoningo of
DIOXAN vapors acute response of
guinea to Yant Schrenk
Waite and Patty DISEASE and accidents international
congress of see International Con-
.
gress
caused by working with pneumatic
tools Seyring in nees
industrial diseases scheduled in Ger-
many TelekyCollis industrial prevention of Collis occupational medicolegal aspects
Kummel ccc e ee eee cece .
181 181 106
51 90
181
196 10
21 154 189 155
PAGE
DISEASE trauma compensation medi-
industrial colegal relations
unsuspected in industrial
workers
workers
155
Squsi kins chae rged charged wr ith 224
DISINFECTION of skins charged with
anthrax Brotzu
DIVERS DISEASE prophylaxis Blattner and Zangger 130
Dock laborers skin injury in due to salt Somogyi 209
DRINKER RESPIRATOR analysis of case
reports Drinker Shaughnessy Shaughnessy and Murphay rrest 149
treatment of respiratory arrest in Murphy Drinker and Drinker 149
DRINKING facilities in places of employment Correll 150 268
Duco retrobulbar neuritis due to
Goldmann . events eeeeeeneees
DUST abatement Engle .
34 248
absorption of solid air dispersed material by respiratory system
Weber . disease res. piratory Russell Russell system system
and pulmonary disease Russell cement and tuberculosis J^ttenand
KortmanPetrn off Petroff
chamber Wigdortschik and Petroff 138 clay slate and tuberculosis J^tten
and Kortmann -
-clinical symptoms of dusted lungs von D^hren
coal in treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis Glaser - ...
" control Gum Pescz hPesch ..
determination of in rooms Pesch - ...
dusted lungs and roms tuberculosis B^ under Explosioh ns Explosions Explm osionseeee
explosions see under Explosions
fluCeookepnCookee umonokoniosis due to
industrial control of by legislation Sch^...rmann=
influence on health of man animals
and plants Natho inhalation changes in red blood pic-
ture following Scharlau 28
inhalation
inhalation experiments Haynes 28
pathologic anatomy of dusted lungs Schritubd erculosis td uberculosistuberculosis e tuberculosis
pneumonokoniosis and tuberculosis
in dusted lungs J^tten
producing materials dustless filling and packing ....
relation to infection Kettle
rock pulmonary changes in miners due to Policard and Martin
stone disease legal establishment of
Reichmann . .
stone maladies in Ruhr miners Hustenten .
tobacco and tuberculosis J^ttenand
KortmaAbn rest J^n tten
toxic effects of Abrest
zinc action on health and accumulation in organs Nuck Remy and
Holtzman Remy an nd
48
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
tained in a second wash bottle By passing a known quantity of air through these two solutions sulphur dioxide and hydrogen sulphide at
concentrations respectively of 0.017
to 0.6 mg and 0.092 to 0.6 mg per
liter can be evaluated with satisfactory accuracy by determining the sulphuric
acid formed D.
INJURIES FROM URSOL IN THE FUR
INDUSTRY R. L. Mayer and M. F^rster Abstr as follows from
Zentralbl f Gewerbehyg June 1929
N. S. vol 6 pp 171-178 171-178 in Bull Hyg July 1980 vol 5 p 571
Ursol is the commercial name given to metaphenylenediamine and is regarded as a frequent cause of dermatitis The authors emphasize the importance of functional tests applied to the skin in addition to mere reliance on
the family and occupational history If such testing is applied the number
of cases alleged to be due to ursol
falls considerably The diagnosis ur-
sol poisoning from the history is no more to be relied on than a diagnosis of lead poisoning from the presence of
punctate basophilia
Altogether 181 persons employed in the fur trade were examined of whom
111 in the course of their work had
suffered from dermatitis or asthma Of these 111 45 per cent showed
asthma existence of eczema and 38.7 of
a combination of the two was found in 16.2 per cent On testing their skins with a small piece of 2 per cent para-
phenylenediamine vaseline 44.1
th cent showed hypersensitization
ursol Forty per cent of those
with eczema gave positive reactions
30.2 of the asthmatics and 72.2 per
cent of those who showed presence of both conditions
The authors regard 44.1 per cent as
directly due to ursol and 55.8 per cent
doubtfully so The general question
of sensitization of the skin is then
discussed in particular relation to
ursol M. L.
DUST HAZARDS AND THEIR EFFECTS
MINER'S LUNG AN INVESTI- excellent illustrations
GATION INTO THE ANTHRACOTIC LUNGS
are given of the
OF MINERS IN SOUTH WALES macroscopic and microscopic condi-
S. L. Cummins and A. F.
tions seen The paper opens with a
Sladden Jour Path and Bacteriol 1980 vol 33
useful historical r^'sum^o'f earlier references to anthracosis and
pp 1095-1132
other forms
of dust diseases The authors hold
This study of the black lung of coal miners is unusually thorough It is
that the blackness of coal miners lungs
is due
based on
to coal any iron present is quite
an examination of lungs from thirty
in subsidiary amounts
Frequently
cases many of whom died fibrosis is present caused by dusts
accidentally In addition to the pathologic examination analysis of thirty-
other than coal and particularly , by
silica from
four of the lungs was carried
intervening rocks Such
Details of these
out fibrosis blocks the lymph flow of the
and form the
analyses are given
4
lungs and coal dust collects in abun- 4
such
most extensive series of dance in such lungs Normally coal 4
analyses yet published Eleven dust is fairly rapidly removed from
ABSTRACT
healthy lungs but it may so collect in
of fibrotic lung as to form a
of
nodule coal At times local
takes
necrosis place with cavitation quite apart from
any tuberculous infection Discharge
from such cavities accounts for the
black sputum of miners Wherever
the coal particles were found most
concentrated analysis showed the con-
tent of silica to be particularly high
that The conclusion is reached
anthra-
cosis is not a simple condition but
exists only as a
subdivision fibrosis usually due to silicosis ably the lungs of miners
of lung
Probinterfered
with by different dusts account for
the high death rates from
dis-
pulmonary eases particularly bronchitis among
coal miners on certain fields even
though their death rate from tubercu-
losis is usually low Nevertheless a
be condition of anthracosis may
pro-
nounced without interfering with the
general health L. C.
disea
coun
Brita
ence
carri
dust
been is c and
poss tain due fine
caus
whi fata fecti fibro radi
ASBES- ASBESTOS AND PULMONARY
TOSIS V. Dhers M^'d du travail
July 1930 vol 2 pp 147-172 Sept.
. 187-209
1980 long article the author
use- fully summarizes
relating
information to the occurrence of occupational as-
bestosis A history of the use of this
mineral and its properties is
to-
given gether with its chemical
composition Then a description follows of the
indus- trial uses to which it is put during
which dust may be generated par-
ticularly during weaving operations
The lungs of workers become affected
in direct proportion to the length of
time they have been exposed to it
until after twenty years of work 80 per
cent are affected Statistics and in-
formation as to the occurrence of lung
sun
POP
B. 198
A the We at asb thi
sev
s no
e of d in
1om
ABSTRACTS
49
healthy lungs but it may so collect in fibrotic lung as to form a nodule of
coal At times local necrosis takes
place with cavitation quite apart from any tuberculous infection Discharge from such cavities accounts for the black sputum of miners Wherever the coal particles were found most
concentrated analysis showed the content of silica to be particularly high The conclusion is reached that anthracosis is not a simple condition but exists only as a subdivision of lung
fibrosis usually due to silicosis Prob-
ably the lungs of miners interfered with by different dusts account for the high death rates from pulmonary diseases particularly bronchitis among coal miners on certain fields even though their death rate from tuberculosis is usually low Nevertheless a
condition of anthracosis may be pro-
nounced without interfering with the
general health L. C.
ASBESTOS AND PULMONARY ASBES-
TOSIS V. Dhers M^'d du travail
July 1930 vol 2 pp 147-172 Sept. 1930 pp 187 209
In this long article the author usefully summarizes information relating
to the occurrence of occupational as-
bestosis A history of the use of this
mineral and its properties is given to-
diseases among asbestos workers in all
countries but particularly in Great Britain are brought together Refer-
ence is made to experimental work carried out by exposing animals to the
dust the results of which have not all been published The lung condition
is characterized by dyspnea cough
and the presence of asbestosis bodies
possibly in the sputum but more cer-
tainly in the lungs These bodies are due to organic material deposited upon
fine spicules of dust The fibrosis caused is general throughout the lungs
which are so damaged as to lead to a fatal issue without any secondary infection necessarily occurring Such fibrosed lungs may be detected by
radiography but the shadows thrown
are not so coarse as those of silicosis
Diagnosis must depend largely on a knowledge of the occupation of the worker Prognosis generally is un-
favorable since treatment is unsatis-
factory The only thing to do is to abolish the dangers by suppressing the
hazard Efforts made to this end are
summarized The article is accom-
panied bya full bibliography contain-
ing fifty references It ought to be a useful contribution to which anyone
interested in asbestosis will turn.-
E. L. C.
gether with its chemical composition
Then a description follows of the indus-
trial uses to which it is put during which dust may be generated par-
ticularly during weaving operations
The lungs of workers become affected
in direct proportion to the length of time they have been exposed to it until after twenty years of work 80 per
cent are affected Statistics and in-
formation as to the occurrence of lung
PULMONARY ASBESTOSIS A RE-
PORT OF A CASE AND A REVIEW W.
B. Soper Am Rev. Tuberc Dec.
1930 vol 22 pp 571 584
A man of 30 years was admitted to
the William Wirt Winchester Hospital
West Haven Conn on May 26 1929
at which time he had been exposed to
asbestos dust over a period of about
thirteen years No indications of the
severity of the exposures i.e dust
50
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
concentrations are given He was admitted to the hospital four months after he had stopped working
At that time his weight was 142 pounds or 8 pounds below his best
weight
Physical examination
showed 5 cm chest expansion con-
siderable dyspnea particularly on ex-
ertion sputum occasionally blood streaked but negative for tuberculosis occasional r^lesburning pain over the whole chest nervousness irritability and constipation of three months
standing Several nontender asbes-
tos corns were seen on the hands
Blood picture and urine showed noth-
ing unusual ray picture was dis-
tinctive of the cobweb appearance
noted previously by Wood see Tubercle 1929 vol 10 p 353
The patient was discharged on July 2 1929 and reexamined on April 9 1930. During the nine months
interval he had rested at home
Dyspnea had increased the burning pain in the chest had been superseded by dull drawing pain above the left breast and weight had increased from 142 to 162 pounds Respirations were 25 and even ordinary speech produced shortness of breath the complexion was leaden with noticeable cyanosis of the ears hands and skin on pressure chest expansion was 1.5 cm as compared with 5 cm nine months previously R^les were considerably more definite and more widespread
than nine months earlier
Among the author's conclusions are
the following The most common single symptom
is dyspnoea This and the other
symptoms are essentially those of a
progressive generalized lung fibrosis The physical signs of uncompli-
cated pulmonary asbestosis are sub-
stantially those of generalized fibrosis of both lungs and basal pleurisy
ray examination is of great value in establishing the diagnosis
Asbestos contains but a very small
amount of free silica but probably conduces to a more hasty evolution
of any accompanying tuberculosis as
in the better understood forms of
silicosis
An immediate diagnosis at autopsy is said to be made possible by simply
squeezing out upon a slide a drop of
lung juice from the fibrosed tissue and
covering with a cover The asbestosis bodies in large number are <
~
readily visible under the microscope
-P D.
PNEUMONOCONIOSIS DUE TO FLUE
DUST W. E. Cooke Brit Med
Jour Nov. 15 1980 vol pp 816-817
Detailed analyses are given of boiler scale and flue dust and also of dust
particles found in the lungs of a man
who had been a boiler cleaner for 113
months He died from tuberculosis while rays suggested advanced
pneumonokoniosis The lungs were fibrosed throughout and dust and dust
cells were found in excessive amount
Although the silicious matter in the
pulmonary dust was proportionately less than in the flue dust the occupa-
tional exposure is held to have cer-
tainly originated the pathologic condition The process of flue cleaning is not favored during twelve years twenty men have been employed and have given up the work Excepting two of these one of whom worked only one day and the other one week the average period of employment was fifteen months while the nearest approaching the period of the deceased
man was thirty months - C.
2m
ABSTRAC
A STATISTICAL STUDY OF PUL-
MONARY CHANGES FOUND AMONG MIN-
ERS WORKING IN ROCK DUST A.
Policard and E. Martin Bull Acad
de m^'d1980 vol 104 pp 333-343 A clinical and radiographic examina-
tion was made of 175 men using rock drills in mines in the basin of the Loire some being rayed on several occa-
sions As many men came for exami-
nation on account of illness the percentage of lung trouble found cannot be held to be representative Nevertheless when divided according to length of work nearly 50 per cent were normal with less than one year of work as compared with 25 per cent with ten
years or over of work No informa-
tion as to age is given which might quite invalidate the findings Two certain points emerge one is that even
ten years of exposure to mine dust does
not necessarily cause pulmonary fibrosis and the other than an unusual
number of cases of open tuberculosis
were discovered No ray picture diagnostic of silicosis was found but progressive changes in the appearances were of value in detecting the silicotic condition The authors hold pulmonary silicosis to be a particular instance of tuberculosis developing under special conditions L. C.
SOME ASPECTS OF SILICOSIS P.
Heffernan Tubercle 1980 vol 11 pp 481 489
;
tha tha lun fibr whi
age
logi
silic
cast
int be
pla
dito soa
nor
pro ciat
dry
sup fail
sigi
and The
and cert
exit of t othe risk
inh
tem
phy
less tub
WOMEN AND CHILDREN
1 WOMEN IN CENT STORES AND LIMITED CHAIN DEPART-
MENT STORES M. E. Pidgeon U.S.
Dej
~
76
-
119 119
ABSTRACTS
51
A STATISTICAL STUDY OF PUL-
MONARY CHANGES FOUND AMONG MIN-
ERS WORKING IN ROCK DUST A. Policard and E. Martin Bull Acad
de m^'d1980 vol 104 pp 333-343
A clinical and radiographic examina-
A discussion is presented rather than new facts The idea is advanced
that silica may react by toughening lung tissue generally while nodular
fibrosis occurs at the site of lesions of
tion was made of 175 men using rock which tuberculosis is the most common
drills in mines in the basin of the Loire agent Such nodules may be radio-
some being rayed on several occa-
sions As many men came for exami-
nation on account of illness the percentage of lung trouble found cannot
be held to be representative Never-
theless when divided according to length of work nearly 50 per cent were
normal with less than one year of work
as compared with 25 per cent with ten
years or over of work No informa-
tion as to age is given which might quite invalidate the findings Two certain points emerge one is that even
ten years of exposure to mine dust does
not necessarily cause pulmonary fibrosis and the other than an unusual
number of cases of open tuberculosis were discovered No ray picture diagnostic of silicosis was found but progressive changes in the appearances
were of value in detecting the silicotic condition The authors hold pul-
monary silicosis to be a particular
instance of tuberculosis developing
under special conditions L. C.
SOME ASPECTS OF SILICOSIS P.
Heffernan Tubercle 1980 vol 11
pp 481-489
logic indicators of more extensive
silicotic changes taking place but not
casting visible shadows Silica enters
into certain forms of life and so may
be expected to interact with protoplasm The reaction may be expe-
dited by such a medium as alkaline
soap with acute silicosis as a result normally the reaction is a chronic
process Its development is associated with increasing dyspnea and dry pleurisy Should tuberculosis not
supervene cardiac hypertrophy and
failure ends the scene Physical signs alone are not diagnostic nor is a
skiagram a history of exposure to risk
and symptoms must also be present
The fibrotic changes are progressive
and cannot be inhibited Coal and
certain other dusts may facilitate the exit of silica but silica has some power
of bringing about the retention of dusts
otherwise excreted Prevention of the
risk must be effected it lies in keeping inhaled air free from a suspensoid sys-
tem of silica which behaves
physically as a gas The risk may be lessened by minimizing exposure to
tuberculous infection L. C.
WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN INDUSTRY
|
WOMEN IN CENT STORES
AND LIMITED CHAIN DEPART-
STORES M. E. Pidgeon U.S.
Dept. Labor Women's Bur Bull No.
76 1980 pp 56
!
This bulletin covers personal infor-
29
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
to form ient conglomeration larger OF OFSILICOSIS
ected shadows and a gradual Am
IN MAN R. G. Mills
om
Jour Hyg Jan. 1931 vol 13
escing phenomena which are asso-
d with
pp 224-234
srt stonecutters wet sand-
The spicules of the
e grinders and sand blasters sponge Spongilla
water
d
act:
circumscribed shadows
fragilis are com- RE
appear
Sen clearly in the lungs of stone
posed of opal a form of hydrated
silica which is similar to
rs Weak diffuse and cloudy chemical
quartz in its
ows are characteristic of the coal when
reactions These spicules
an lung silicotic shadows
introduced into the tissues of
for the most
are howalso
animals are slowly but definitely dis-
part
ray picture of the
evident solved proving conclusively that silica
seamen
schamotte workers shows less nodule forma-
is soluble in the tissue fluids of animals
rer ene
and a somewhat
and presumably of man This con- SS
greater expanse firms the
nnected shadows
assumption held by many
the second part of the
students of silicosis that particles of
ae
HE
ERB ted the results of the paper are silicious material are gradually con-
enty sand
examination verted into the colloidal statestate and
*
blasters twenty of such exert
as
a
3.9
1 had indications of silicosis in the
a fibroplastic influence on
SN
ent stages
lungs of miners and other exposed
MA
industrial workers Definite fibrosis
E EFFECT OF PROLONGED EXPOS-
of the lung of a dog into which the
spicules had been introduced
OF THE SILICEOUS SPICULES of ^ that there is
suggests
ER SPONGE Spongilla Fragilis To
ACTION OF ANIMAL TISSUES A
concomitant injury
attributable to the disappearance by
RIBUTION TO
solution of the silicious elements of the |
THE PATHOGENESIS spicules Author's Summary
UPATIONAL AFFECTIONS OF
CUPATIONAL ECZEMA M. Opim Arch Dermat and Syph 1931 vol 23 p 346 e dermatitides may be divided
the following groups 1 In dertis sensu strictiori the skin is able al with the irritant almost every-
skin reacts to certain strong irri; e g croton oil even if with t variation the course is
acute ng soon follows the removal of the n 2 In toxicoderma there is a
enital or acquired idiosyncrasy
slightest irritant evokes it The ation period is short The effect rked and the course acute 3 In
THE SKIN AND SPECIAL SENSES
eczema the entire skin is sensitized For this reason the intensity of the irritant may be slight The development
of dermatitis is gradual The course
is prolonged and healing delayed Occupational eczema is among the
most frequent of eczemas the most frequent of skin diseases and the most frequent of all diseases The predis-
posing factors important immer-
sion of the hands in water soap alkali .
or acid and the influence of heat cold and mechanical action Occupational eczema is allergic but the predisposing
factors mentioned play an important
part Dermatitis artificialis acuta
OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
ABSTRACTS
- 125
larger dual
3880-
*
OF SILICOSIS IN MAN
Am Jour Hyg Jan.
pp 224 234
R. G. Mills 1931 vol 18
and-
The spicules of the
ters
water
sponge Spongilla fragilis are com-
pear posed of opal a form of hydrated
tone silica which is similar to quartz in its
udy chemical reactions These
coal when introduced into the tisspsiucesuleosf
how animals are slowly but definitely dis-
lent otte
solved proving conclusively that silica
is soluble in the tissue fluids of
ma- and
animals
presumably of man This con-
a
inse
are
tion of in
Os FA /
'
firms the assumption held by many students of silicosis that particles of silicious material are gradually con-
verted into the colloidal state and as
such exert a fibroplastic influence on the lungs of miners and other exposed industrial workers Definite fibrosis of the lung of a dog into which the
spicules had been introduced suggests
that there is a concomitant injury
attributable to the disappearance by
a
nr^'
F. *a
A solution of the silicious elements of the
SIS spicules Author's Summary
sembles occupational eczema The patch test has only a limited value Attempts at desensitization have produced only slight results
as follows from Bull Assn fran^pour
l'^'tudedu cancer 1980 vol 19 p 459 in Am Jour Cancer Jan. 1981 vol
15 p 357
DERMATITIS DUE TO SENSITIZATION
TO CONTACT SUBSTANCES DERMATI-
TIS VENENATA OCCUPATIONAL DER-
MATITIS B. Kesten and
Arch Dermat and Syph vol 23 pp 221 237
E. Laszlo
Feb. 1931
In eighteen of a series of twenty patients suffering from dermatitis
venenata or occupational dermatitis the etiology was determined or corro-
borated by patch tests In the remain-
ing three there was an exacerbation
of the dermatitis when the substances
were applied to the sensitized skin
In all of the cases there was freedom from dermatitis when the specific substance was avoided
The sensitizing substances were
paraphenylenediamine sodium bi-
chromate novocaine novol potassium mercuric iodide primrose poison ivy
A workman aged 50 years was burned on the back of his hand by a small piece of burning asphalt The wound did not heal and three months later there was a nodule at the site of the injury 1 cm in diameter The
mass was excised and found to be
squamous epithelioma with large keratotic pearls a few mitoses and a
moderate inflammation of the stroma Pain in the wound rendered it neces-
sary to remove the sutures and some small nodules on the border of the scar
were submitted to microscopic exam-
ination and found to contain some
remnants of the growth After this
second operation the lesion was
treated with radium and healing
occurred The case is too recent to
know whether further metastases will
take place
Four similar cases from the litera-
OF THE SKIN AND SPECIAL SENSES
ph
.
ed erole
ryriith
te he
is y he ect In
eczema the entire skin is sensitized For this reason the intensity of the irritant may be slight The development
of dermatitis is gradual The course
is prolonged and healing delayed
Occupational eczema is among the most frequent of eczemas the most
frequent of skin diseases and the most
frequent of all diseases The predis-
posing factors important immersion of the hands in water soap alkali
or acid and the influence of heat cold and mechanical action Occupational
eczema is allergic but the predisposing
factors mentioned play an important part Dermatitis artificialis acuta
pyrethrum mascara face powder and
face cream In the dilutions used
none of these substances was found
irritating to the normal skin
Passive transfer of sensitization was
unsuccessful
A case of local sensitization and
desensitization to potassium mercuric
iodidies reported
In most instances dermatitis venenata and occupational dermatitis result from local cellular sensitization to specific proteins acquired by pre= vious contact of the substances with
the skin Authors Authors Summary
A CASE OF EPITHELIOMA DEVEL-
OPING RAPIDLY AFTER AN INJURY BY
BURNING ASPHALT A. Gunsett Abstr
ture are referred to In three burns were followed by rapid development of cancer in the fourth however the tumor in this case on the lip did not appear for two years after the burn and hence cannot be absolutely correlated with the injury Two similar
instances of the development of an
epithelioma following burning of the skin with sulphuric acid are also on
record
WARTS FROM MINERAL SUBSTANCES
A. P. Dewirtz Abstr from Roussky
Vestnick Derm March 1980 pp 243
et 247 in Ann de dermat
30 1930
syph Dec.
This writer when examining work-
ers among asbestos found a kind of
126 THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIALINDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
dermatosis It is chiefly confined to author says that this is the first
}
the palmar surfaces of the hands and sion on which these asbestos woacrctas- i
fingers in young people who go about have been brought to the notice of the
without shoes it occurs also on the soles of the feet The right hand is
dermatologist He suggests that sur-
gical removal is the
only advisable
usually more extensively involved course to pursue P. W.
than the left The individual lesions
consist of apparently noninflammatory round or polygonal topped warts They vary in size from a millet seed to pea Sharp needles of asbestos enter the skin and thus produce these papillomas The thin skin of
youth and the flexures of the joints are particularly vulnerable and on these parts the warts are chiefly found They are most objectionable because of the pain and discomfort they cause when walking and because of the trouble and inconvenience they give to those who handle tools These little
ERUPTION CAUSED BY RESINS OF
TREES Longin Abstr as follows
from Bull Soc fran^ de dermat et
syph July 1930 vol 37 p 741 in Arch Dermat and Syph Feb. 1981 vol 23 p 333
constituents Three cases of eczematiform erup-
tions produced by volatile
re escaping from freshly hewn wood
reported In one case there was an
exacerbation when an intradermal
injection of an extract of the suspected wood was administered
tumors are well known to the opera-
tives and are called verrues d'amiante
or asbestos warts The irritation they produce leads the employees to re-
move the fine spicules of mineral which
stick into the skin either with pin or a needle or with the nails This
gives only partial relief as the little
tumors continue to grow or recur on
the same place
The histologic picture was examined
and described by Dewirtz The horny and malpighian strata are largely increased In the dermis are a large
number of round and polymorphic cells situated especially in the papil-
lary layer In these warty growths Dewirtz has found the crystals of asbestos These he accuses of being the cause of the thickening of the rete
mucosum and the basal layers and of
the formation of giant cells The
whole condition turns out to be a very slow chronic local inflammation The
OCULAR HYGIENE IN INDUSTRY V. de Uzeda Abstr as follows from Folha
med 1980 vol 11 pp 290-292 in Bull Hyg Jan. 1931 vol 6 pp 20 21
This is a brief sketch of the condi-
tions of interest to the ophthalmologist
as they are met with in industry
Reference is made to the risks of work-
ing in defective light in excessive artificial light and the aggravation which
may arise in morbid conditions already existing e.g. myopia Secondly there
is a discussion on the irritant effects
of certain gases especially in chemical factories of dust or larger particles in those working with metal or
stone intoxications as from mercury
phosphorus nitrobenzene arsenic etc
the effect of heat as cataract in those
attending to furnaces in glassworkers and others and finally trauma from
fragments of wood metal glass or
stone causing various degrees of
damage from slight conjunctivitis to
ABSTR
actual penetration of the anterior chamber and its complications and
sequelae H. S.
THE FIELDS OF VISION IN MINERS
NYSTAGMUS C. F. Haycraft Abstr
528 as follows from Brit JourJour Ophth Oct.
1930 vol 14 p
Arch Ophth
1931 vol 5 p
.
From study the
of the fields of vision
in a series of forty
of
cases miners nystagmus of which thirty-
five were old and eight were new cases
that is certified as suffering from the
months disease within the previous six
the author arrives at the following
conclusions
INDUSTRIA
SHOULD LAYMEN GIVE INJECTIONS
OF LOBELIN AND CARDIAZOL L.
Teleky Med Welt 1929 no 2
consider A large number of doctors
injections of lobelin of extraordinary value in restoring life in cases of appar-
suggests ent death and Teleky here
that as doctors are bound to take time
arriving on the scene of the emergency
teaching laymen should be trained to give injec-
tions as part of first aid
It
is generally objected that it would
be dangerous for laymen to give injec-
tions but in giving first aid in
industry they often undertake methods which may involve greater risks Thus the
of Silvester and other methods
'
arti-
ficial respiration broken ribs and
while injury to the liver have occurred
the tongue may be injured by drawing
of it forward and fixing it In cases trismus opening the jaws may cause
wounds the teeth of
lips and broken
The use of the pulmotor which i
recommended in factories requires
4
ABSTRACTS
127
actual penetration of the anterior chamber and its complications and sequelae H. S.
THE FIELDS OF VISION IN MINERS
NYSTAGMUS C. F. Haycraft Abstr
as follows from Brit Jour Ophth Oct.
1930 vol 14 p 523 in Arch Ophth Jan. 1931 vol 5 p 146
From the study of the fields of vision in a series of forty cases of miners nystagmus of which thirtyfive were old and eight were new cases that is certified as suffering from the disease within the previous six months the author arrives at the following
conclusions
In a large percentage of cases of
miners nystagmus there is a definite alteration in the fields of vision The
most common change is a concentric contraction for white A large num-
ber of patients show contraction for
red and blue and interlacing of these colors is frequent The amount of contraction of the fields is usually but not invariably a measure of the severity of the disease In the absence of physical signs the change in the fields described combined with typical subjective symptoms can be relied on in diagnosing miners nystagmus or in determining that recovery is still insufficient to permit work underground
INDUSTRIAL SURGERY
SHOULD LAYMEN GIVE INJECTIONS
OF LOBELIN AND CARDIAZOL L.
Teleky Med Welt 1929 no 2 A large number of doctors consider
injections of lobelin of extraordinary value in restoring life in cases of apparent death and Teleky here suggests
that as doctors are bound to take time
arriving on the scene of the emergency laymen should be trained to give injections as part of first aid teaching It is generally objected that it would be dangerous for laymen to give injections but in giving first aid in industry they often undertake methods which
may involve greater risks Thus in the _ Silvester and other methods of arti-
ficial respiration broken ribs and injury to the liver have occurred while the tongue may be injured by drawing it forward and fixing it In cases of trismus opening the jaws may cause wounds of the lips and broken teeth The use of the pulmotor which is recommended in factories requires
training and skilful manipulation The bandaging of a broken limb may be the cause of great injury Compared with these risks those from giving injections are small
Thirty years ago it was quite common in clinics to give injections without any aseptic or antiseptic precautions and at the present day many morphinists give injections through their clothing without any serious results Lobelin is kept in ampoules in emergency aid boxes and it would not be difficult to teach the giving of injections as part of a first aid course It has been found in cases of gas poisoning in D^...sseldorfthat firemen trained
in first aid arrive on the scene a half to
a quarter of an hour before the doctor and as every minute is so important it would be a great advantage if these
men were able to give injections of
lobelin and even of camphor or cardiazol if necessary J. C.
142
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
Sommerfeilnddustry PhfRemeE frequently those who are employed in the mills
where the dust is
The fact that mild degrees of
prepared Since our practical experience goes back
injury Schott
K^/stleare found
lung and
only a short time as is true also of
among workers ex-
Schultze's work there is
posed for a number of years and that
positive to be said
nothing other health derangements occur
concerning the ac-
tion of this kind of dust on the lungs
result of severe exposure in together with the results
as a
e
of men engaged in this type of work
of our ex-
Dust with a high quartz content or
periments show that cement dust is not entirely harmless Care
clay slate dust mixed with a high con-
tent of silica
taken therefore to avoid
must be Ge
should however be ment of
the develop-
eliminated as far as possible Further
too large a quantity of dust in RE
research is necessary in order to show manufacturing and to insure efficient
Aa Oe
how pure clay slate dust behaves
removal of the dust by suction At first glance our
experimental
ste.
experimentally and especially to de-
termine the degree of
results with tobacco dust
hazard with be at
appear
to
varying silica content '
variance with previous experi- ie
Our next study will be devoted
Nima mental results as well as with the ee
the dust problems
to statistics on the incidence of
Clo
dusting If
involved in rock losis in tobacco trades
tubercu-
clay slate dust should culosis
That tuber-
actually prove to be injurious to the
occurs
among
lungs there are available several other
kinds of dust which are less
denied tobacco workers cannot be
but the opinion at the present time is
and which
harmful that this is not due
satisfy the requirements of
entirely to em-
mining authorities We may
ployment in dusty work but is brought
aA
for example limestone
mention on by other causes of a social and
dust which economic
contains only about 3
nature We cannot con-
per cent of
silica and has a high lime content
vince ourselves however that tobacco
dust is entirely harmless We
there-
Moreover official tests have shown
that it meets all the requirements
fore stress the importance of improving
the industry Our animal
of hygienic conditions especially of
ments with it have been
experi- women workers of furthering voca-
satisfactory
completely
An exhaustive
tional selection of prohibiting em-
concerning this subject will
report ployment of young persons and par-
our next publication
appear in ticularly of installing efficient dust
The relatively slight injury caused
by cement dust in our experiments is
in complete agreement with previous
practical experiences and statistical
studies Only a few authors have
ascribed a tuberculosis
tion to this
promoting ac-
dust and their views are
longer significant since statistical stud-
ies have nowhere established a high
tuberculosis mortality with certainty
removal systems and of eliminating
the possibility of infection
observations on tobacco dust inThhaelsa-e
tion clearly show that other factors
are responsible for the dust injuries and particularly for the tuberculosis
They demonstrate the correctness of
K. B. Lehmann the Nestor of industrial hygiene in his assertion that
poor nutrition bad living conditions
weak constitution and susceptibility
OF INDUSTRIALINDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
lung mills
ince
The fact that mild degrees of
Sommerfeld injury Schott
back K^/stleare found
and
workers among
ex-
> of posed for a number of
ning other health
years and that
derangements occur as
ac- result of severe
a
exposure in industry
together ngs
with the results of
ork
our
ex- periments show that cement dust is
or not entirely harmless Care
on- taken therefore to avoid
must be
be ment of too
the develop-
her
large a quantity of dust in
manufacturing and to insure efficient
OW removal of the dust by suction
ves
At first glance our
le- results with tobacco experimental
dust appear
to
th be at variance with previous
smteanttisatlics experi- in results as well as with the
to
ek losis
on the incidence of tubercu-
tobacco
id culosis occurs trades That tuber-
e tobacco
frequently among
workers cannot be denied
r but the opinion at the
is 1 that this is
present time
of
not due entirely to em-
ployment in dusty work but is
other on by
brought
causes of a social and
11
f economic nature We cannot con-
vince
dust
ourselves
however
that tobacco
l is entirely harmless We there-
fore stress the importance of improving
hygienic conditions especially of
ployment women workers of furthering voca-
tional selection of prohibiting em-
of young persons and par-
ticularly of installing efficient dust
removal systems and of
the
eliminating
possibility of infection These
responsible observations on tobacco dust inhala-
tion clearly show that other factors
are
for the dust injuries
and particularly for the
tuberculosis
They demonstrate trial
the correctness of
Lehmann the Nestor of indushygiene in his assertion that
poor nutrition bad living conditions weak constitution and susceptibility
ABSTRACTS
a
143
to infection play a more important
ASBESTOSIS BODIES IN SPUTUM AND
r^le in the production of tuberculosis
than do moderate dust concentrations
We hope that we have shown by these observations that it is possible by means of animal experimentation es-
LUNG K. M. Lynch and W. A.
Smith Abstr as follows from Jour
Am Med Assn Aug. 30 1980 vol 95
pp 659-661 in Arch Path Feb. 1981 vol 11 pp 291 292
pecially with tuberculosis immune animals to evaluate the danger of
In microscopic sections of lung from the body of a worker in an asbestos
different occupational dusts by ex- factory who died from a gunshot
tensive parallel studies and to reach wound numerous asbestosis bodies .
conclusions which are in agreement with statistical and practical results
were found in the alveoli the walls of the alveoli the deeper pleural tissues
Ickert confirms our opinion by a comparison of the findings of J^ttenand
Arnoldi with recent and old statistics The statistics show a scale of dust risk
which Ickert states agrees exactly with the experimental findings of J^tten
and Arnoldi
Further studies on the relation of
the bronchi and the interlobular framework in thrombi in the veins and in the peribronchial lymph glands
Associated with them were black gran-
ular pigment in the lymph glands a yellow granular substance a reaction of mononuclear and polymorphonuclear giant cell phagocytes and
in the framework structures a cellular
occupational dust and pulmonary tu- increase in fibrous tissue The asbes-
berculosis will be of value especially if they are extended over a long period
tosis bodies were seen in the sputum of three people who had been workers
of time and include observations on in an asbestos factory one as long be-
chronic dust inhalation The correct fore as six years In the sputum
evaluation of such animal studies can these bodies had a central filament
result only from extensive series of of a transparent slightly greenish-
comparable experiments with various kinds of dust furthermore statistical and other research findings as well as the social and economic conditions of the various groups of workers must be taken into consideration If stud-
ies are carried on this way it is our
opinion that it will be possible eventually to reach a definite decision in regard to the industrial dust problem
tinged needle crystal On this were deposited nodules blebs and
...
segments of a homogeneous refractive
substance These bodies were from
12 to 140 microns long and from 1 to 12 microns thick They did not take the ordinary dyes for tissue and sputum They could be stained by the
Prussian blue reaction for iron It
is suggested that the iron content of the deposit was of tissue origin prob-
ably from the blood
/
|
206
THE
JOURNAL OF IND HYGIENE HYGIENE
THE THE JOURNAL JOURNAL OF the
and, removal of On the
other
Th0e.03 0.075
absorption tar skthienother The dose was 0.03 0.075 gm daily daily tul tul
removal removal from
by cases
tumor dis- Su dis.
preliminary treatment
petroleum petroleum appeared
produced produced treatment effect the
an
thirty seven
entirely entirely regression
fit
was continued
nine fir fir
being decreased decreased the i
grow and in im in
TREAFTMUENTRTTREHAETMRENINVTESTIGATIONS INVESTIGATIONS INVESTIGATIONS THE two
TUMORS WITH CERTAIN CERTAIN AMINO ACIDS
MICE regression
A. Coulon and
F. regression
controls not
of fil
single discovered case case
regressimade on been discovered propor-
ptewtee as follows from Compt Compt rend
A
.
we
even more
seven with twenty twenty
treated carcinoma
subcutaneously seven biopsy were
equimolecular
given equimolecular equimolecular
mixture
tially
proline mouth mouth
tumors
con- Par-
in six grow
tinued
and remained remained
or by both
grow grow, and
con
routes stationary
One
remained
i
Beihefte z Zentralbl
Gewerbehyg
no
Reviewed Reviewed follows in B1u9 l1l930 pp Nov. .
whether recover recover or
as waste
hasbe work to
ampri ly amply illustrated ilustrated illpusrtroatdeduct . The photo- photo- got
graphs
both
and diagrams
which work
well and
diagrams reproduced.- reproduced.- reproduced.-
clearly hygienic
with with
importance subject
and and aes ngineering side technical technical be
direct
such is medical officer officer of
service service to lays
health health
stress on
the the
aspect the problem first
dual aspect of
presents the
catching up
importance as
dust dust
formed and render-
ing ing dust innocuous innocuous innocuous and secondly secondly
method dealing
method method Naturally treatment traeatmenft ttreeatmernt wards afterwards
Naturally according
will nature
end industry
according the dust its
industry
nature
H. S. and clearly reproduced.- of which
-
HLS,
reproduced,
CONIOSES
Med
581-540 581-540
This
March 1981 Epidemiology Epidemiology and
18-22 Abstract
pp
Medi- Medi-
author author of
work done with
summary summary of dust diseases Lectures
since author's author's Milroy
1915. Studies Studies
silico- of
sis may
have shown that impair-
ing
advanced without
health but may superimposed superimposed
of the the dust qu
fatally health; but itGenerally superimposed superimposed
may J. H.
Generally superimposed
JH,
OFOF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
e other kin by
The dosedose was 0.03
cases roleum
. daily
appeared twenty 0.075 ct the
sed
other
remained esults
appeared tumor there
the
tumor ; tumor
thirty
animals tionary
contained
entirely in partial regression
continued to grow
it
This last group
dis-
seven
in nine
in
sta-
THE
ICE
l^s
str
was to
exert begun discoveArmeodngdiscovered two
treatment begun
after treatment
and before it had had
exert its full effect
had time
Among controls not a single
regression had been
forty-
case of
.
two in glutamic d tion of
made up
the
ur acid to ontewo omfolecules of d propor-
acid even
cystinecystine promised
to got recover rid sufficient
commercial commercial
commercial
of or whether it has
as a
got
The work
both by photo-
, all of which
clearly reproduced.-
This
Abstract by author
)
|
ork
presents a
article summary | ce the with regard to dust
health aaduvatncehdor's itsLeedlicfsteauserses Generaly Studies
Milroy
may be
have shown that silico- Lectures
advanced without without impair-
silico-
but it
impair-
lly
may
superimposed Generally
|
H.
t
ABSTRACTS
207
tuberculosis hastens the termination Such infection may precipitate latent fibrosis Other dusts may set up
fine generalized fibrosis seriously impairing the pulmonary functions but not predisposing to tuberculosis Asbestos is particularly injurious other silicates such as basalt are
harmful Pure coal dust seems to be quite neutral but raw coal often contains sufficient minerals to originate fibrosis while fibrosis may so retain coal particles in the lungs as to block
the lymph passages and impair function Radiography displays the presence of fibrosis but gives no clue to the causative factor When silicosis
is present the shadows tend to be nodular superimposed upon pro-
nounced arborization Reference is
made to recent mortality records
associated with different dust hazards
Clinical and pathologic studies are summarized which are concerned with dusts of iron ore cement coal asbes-
tos and marble
THE PRESENCE OF ASBESTOSIS
BODIES IN THE FAECES IN A CASE
OF PULMONARY ASBESTOSIS S. R.
Gloyne Tubercle April 1931 vol 12
pp 158 159
This short note describes how asbes-
tos bodies in cases of pulmonary asbestosis may be found by emulsifying the feces in four to five times
their volume of 5 per cent formalin
in saline and then centrifuging the
product which will be found to con-
tain a scanty number The bodies
which have probably been swallowed
in sputum show less than usual of
the typical yellow coloring mat-
ter as though the pigment were
partially destroyed by
,
juic-eEs L. C.
intestinal
SILICOSIS AND MINing J.
S. Haldane Tr Inst Min Eng
1931 vol 80 p 415
In earlier papers the author concluded a that no danger to health would arise from stone dusting pro-
vided suitable shale or other material
was employed and b that the unusually high bronchitis mortality rate among colliers in the higher age groups is due mainly to the strain on the lungs caused by muscular exertion In the present paper Dr. Haldane reviews his conclusions in the light of
the full data containeidn the Regis-
General's Decennial Supplement
for 1921 to 1923
The phthisis death rates for the various groups of underground workers are distinctly lower than those for all occupied and retired civilian males Even in that group engaged in making and repairing roads which includes the work of ripping stone roofs and driving
roads in stone the death rate from
phthisis at all ages above 25 is lower than for the standard population It is mentioned however that in exceptional cases great risk may occur among men driving roads in highly silicious rock particularly when
machine drills are used The Mines
Act of 1911 required certain precau-
tions in the use of these drills but
the clause was practically ignored
As a result cases of silicosis have been
discovered in the Somerset and South
Wales coal fields The thesis is advanced that the
inhalation of coal dust and shale dust as among coal miners coal boat loaders or cement workers stimulates
The Effects of Dus Inhalation Tr Inst Min Eng 1917-1918 vol 55 p 264
The Health of Old Colliers Ibid 19151916 vol 51 p 469
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
DUST HAZARDS AND THEIR EFFECTS
CONGRESS OF INDUSTRIAL MEDICINE Foreign Letter ItalyItaly Jour Am Med Assn Feb. 14 1981 vol 96 pp 542-544
This letter contains an account of the
Ninth Congress of Industrial Medicine
held Rome The subject before the Congress- Problem of the Re-
bodies were intracellular and their
study suggested that they were formed by the deposition on asbestos fibers of
iron containing substance elaborated
by the cell The shortest exposure to be followed by the appearance of the bodies was five months L. C.
spiratory Pathology of -was FURTHER
divided into several parts Caccuri
OBSERVATIONS ON PUL-
of Naples discussed the
MONARY ASBESTOSIS WITH SPECIAL
etiology and REFERENCE TO ASBESTOS Dust
pathogenesis of respiratory diseases due to dust Coppa of Naples the
and
THE CURIOUS BODIES FOUND IN THE LUNGS W. E.
pathologic anatomy and the clinical
Cooke and C. F. Hill
Abstr as follows from Jour Roy Micr Micr
aspects of respiratory dust diseases
Pastena also of
Soc 1930 vol 50 p 15 in Physiol
research in
Naples radiologic Abstr Feb. 1981 vol 15 p 626
pneumonokoniosis Ab-
In a case of
stracts of these papers are included in
suspected pulmonary
the letter
Communications were also
asbestosis sections of the lung or
macerations of the tissue revealed a
presented concerning the respiratory large amount of fine
>
diseases of coal heavers and of workers dust but the fine granular black
-
t
in hemp.-K. R. D.
spicules of fiber
x
which make up the bulk of asbestos
ee3.
ASBESTOSIS BODIES
dust were not found There were
4 i
IN THE SPUTUM A STUDY OF SPECIMENS
present however large fragments 5
i fs
WORKERS IN
FROM FIFTY to 360 microns closely resembling in
ute
AN ASBESTOS MILL F. W. Simson and
size shape and color various constit-
le
Jour Path and
A. S. Strachan uents of asbestos dust These large
ee vol 34 pp 1 4Bacteriol Jan. 1931 fragments are found in the lung em-
ee
Es
The result is reported of
bedded in fibrotic or necrotic areas of
aa ee
examining
sputum from fifty workers who
which they are the cause In addi-
were tion curious bodies were present which
AS
intensively exposed to asbestos dust in
a mill in South
are believed to be diagnostic of pul-
bodies were
Africa Asbestosis monary asbestosis These bodies were
easily demonstrated by direct thick films They were found
eventually shown to consist of a cen-
tral
of
best by examining specimens taken
core
asbestos fiber enclosed in
early in the morning in the
adsorbed d^'brisK. D.
evening
the mouth and nasal pharynx were too
ANTHRACOSIS loaded with dust for the bodies to be
SILICOSIS AND TU-
easily detected The sputum was
BERCULOSIS IN MINERS
Cummins Lancet Jan. 31
S. L.
1981
always mucoid in character often vol 1 pp 235-238
,
resembling egg albumin No tubercle bacilli were found The asbestosis
The claim is made that anthracosis
is a dual
condition in which coal dust
F INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
SAND SAND THEIR EFFECTS
-DI- bodies were
m
intracellular
study suggested
and
their
that they were formed
by op the deposition on asbestos fibers of
he iron containing substance elaborated
.ne
.e-
ri ASBESTOSIS e MOFNUARRTYHER OBSERVATIONS ON PUL-
REFERENCE
WITH SPECIAL
TO ASBESTOS DUST AND
THE CURIOUS BODIES FOUND IN
LUNGS
THE
W. E. Cooke and C. F.
Abstr as follows from Jour
Hill
} Micr Soc 1930 vol 50 p 15 iRnoPyhysiol
, Feb. 1931, vol 15 p 626
AbstrIn a case of suspected pulmonary
the asbestosis sections of
lung or
macerations of the tissue revealed a
large amount of fine granular black
dust but the fine spicules of fiber
which make up the bulk of
dust were not found
asbestos There were
present however large fragments 5
to 360 microns closely resembling in
size shape and color various constit-
uents of asbestos dust
fragments are found in
These large
in
bedded
in
fibrotic
necrotic
or
the lunglung em-
necrotic areas of
which they are the cause In addi-
tion curious bodies were
are believed to be
present which
diagnostic of pul-
monary asbestosis These bodies were
eventually shown to consist of
ral core of asbestos fiber
a cen-
enclosed in
adsorbed d^'brisK. D.
ANTHRACOSISANTHRACOSIS SILICOSIS AND TUERCULOSIS IN MINERS S. L.
oulm1mipnps 23L5a-n2c3e8t Jan. 31 1931
The claim is made that
a dual
anthracosis
condition in which coal dust
i
ABSTRACTS
123
is retained in the lungs owing to a
state of fibrosis with lymph blockage The pathologic condition arising from dust inhaled together with the coal and
which in all probability is closely associated with the life of exposure not only to coal dust but to stone dust as
well.-E. L. C.
also chemical analyses are similar so
far as the content of silica to those
found in cases of pure silicosis In
certain cases of hard heading work
where rocks rather than coal are
mainly tackled by the miners silicosis develops which is indistinguishable
from that seen in other cases of silica
risk But when coal has been the chief
dust inhaled no tendency to succumb from tuberculosis is found and the suggestion has been offered that coal
dust exerts a protective influence
against tuberculosis This idea is however not definitely accepted at least the suggestions to explain why
the coal miner has a low mortality from tuberculosis although his lungs show definite fibrosis are not accepted
Professor Cummins now puts forward the possibility that carbon particles in the lungs adsorb the active principle of tuberculin He points out that such adsorption occurs in vitro since be has found that finely powdered dust of anthracite coal is capable of ad-
OBSERVATIONS ON THE DIFFEREN-
TIAL DIAGNOSIS OF SILICOSIS BY
MEANS OF THE ROENTGENOGRAM AND
AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE RISKS
OF SAND BLASTERS Lochtkemper Abstr from Arch f Gewerbepath u
..
Gewerbehyg 1980 vol 1 pp 271-302 in Ber ^...d ges Physiol u exper Pharmakol Oct. 8 1980 vol 56 p 182
The author distinguishes roentgeno-
logically the various forms of silicosis
pneumonokoniosis caused by quartz dust The first stage is characterized
by enlarged hilum glands and by increased vascular markings the second
stage by numerous infiltrated and iso-
lated nodules and increased induration ;
the third stage by the called snow-
storm effect which is partly an iso-
lated and partly a confluent mottling
The rate of dust inhalation and the
concentration of the quartz content are
important in the resulting roentgen
picture Among workers in industries
whose dust contains free silicic acid-
sorbing a large proportion of the active principle from old tuberculin
diluted with normal saline solution Whether or not carbon dust particles
bathed in the tissue juices retain this adsorbing power requires further investigation Some clinical facts appear to favor the theory Certainly nega-
tive sputums are more common in
clinically tuberculous coal miners than in other clinically tuberculous adult males Although any excessive liabil-
ity to tuberculosis is absent in the case of coal miners a high mortality from bronchitis among old colliers is present
sandstone grinders stonecutters sand blasters porcelain workers and stone
hewers are found in the ray
picture of the lung near the enlarged hilum small sharply defined shadows from pinhead to pea in size some of which are isolated and others joined by
fine streaks The thickness of the
nodules is greater in sandstone grinders and stonecutters than in porcelain workers and stone hewers and in occupations in which a mixture of quartz and clay dust is inhaled In the further development there is a gradual
increase in the small shadows with an
240
240 the THE dust particles
THE JOURNAL OF
INDUSTRIALHYGIENE HYGIENEHYGIENE
Particles and on the 38 particles
Calcium many
is 10 pp 601-634 601-634 Bull Hyg
1981 6pp 467 468467 468 467 468contai, ning
a long article article containing
points importance importance importance
Hyg,
con- interested
in hyperemia alveoli The
PNEUMONOKONIOSIS AND TUBERCU-
PNEUMONOKONIOSIS PNEUMONOKONIOSIS Willis
LOSIS
Medicine
Dec.
Abstr follows
1980
follows
418-506 in Am
vol pp ,
Jour Pub Health
418-506 1981 1981 vol 21 p 565
study study the original original
interested subject subject
chief by those
The . chief
The whole like Caesar's description
divided divided into three detail
of
presents considerable considerable
the The
conditions whichiwnordkeursstpneru-y is the
on but except
pneu- is
those engaged
drills but process later not pneu-
the grinding masks Illustrations
use
district the and Illustrations of of use
district processes machinery
differ- of
machinery are well differ.
This This is review of the whole
of
pneumonokoniosis and
tuberculosis
tuberculosis
ship between tuberculosis prophylaxis and
monokoniosis and and prophylaxis and
treatment
thirkidlogram per chemical investigations
part details pulmo- pro-
tissue
investigations the presence the
shows presence tin no
silica iron aluminium aluminium estimation
lead Quantitative
gave of
10.9
kilogram the (no
kilogram the
summary need It It quite justice to
per thousand ferric oxide
abstract abstract itself justice an
the paper
since since in itself
interpretation interpretation
kilogram kilogram expressed
2.5 gm per
as the un-
complete summary
kilogram tissue expressed
and important important
important
contributions interested this field
kilogram
was 0.45 gm iron .
ferric oxide 0.34 as iron the
who interested interested in kilogram symptoms symptoms
Anyone Anyone dust effects reference work resulting disablement disablement produced produced fibrosis of
problem problem invaluable invaluable invaluable reference reference
resulting
disablement from fibrosis cardiac cardiac
this The paper with bibliog-
and consequent cardiac cardiac
he raphy references references
bibliog-
a bibliog-
mischief
author author rightly demands
detailed prophy- prophy-
raphy raphy raphy references,
lactic
demands force
measures measures should put industry industry
MINERS reduce the sickness proportion
wr
follows follows from Orosco 1981 which employs large large
proportion
wiies
follows from
Semana Semana 1981 as reduce the sickness proportion proportion proportion to mR
Semana m^'d., 1981, vol.
in an industry
which employs a large Proportion of Om
ti
&
OF
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
e
air
nian
ium
con-
sto-
467 468Bull June J3une8 no 10 pp 601-634 1931 vol 6 pp
in
in Bull
. Hyg
is a long article containing
importance and
con-
interested in the
nd subject The chiefchief
features only to coli
can be referred
coli here whole whole like Caesar's description here
Gaul ic
is divided into three
of
imnatic presents partspTnehtuhe-e conditionmsaticconditions detail grinding a
in considerable
.11
conditions
under which the industry the
ils
The workers use
but dril s drills
n
the
grinding
except those engaged
process later do not
protecting the any Il ustrations use ent processes
masks Illustrations
district the mines and the differ-
reproduced and machinery are well
ing conditions , showing the actual work-
conditions of the
second part gives
employees clinical
histories
The
typical cases and clinical histories of
QuantitaQutaintviteative
of tin per
2.7
and
estimation
tin
no
estimation gave
kilogram of the
kilogram of the
| ch
an industry
employs a large proportion of
{
ABSTRACTS
241
.
the workingmen of the country
A CASE OF PULMONARY ASBESTOSIS
H. H. S.
. H. E. Seiler and M. D. Gilmour Brit
Med Jour June 27 1931 vol 1 pp
Y PULMONARY ASBESTOSIS II IN- 1112 1114
CLUDING THE REPORT OF A Pure Case
The pathologic findings are reported
K. M. Lynch and W. A. Smith Am
Rev. Tuberc June 1931 vol 23 pp
643-660
of a fatal case of asbestosis uncomplicated by pulmonary tuberculosis
The man died aged 42 after twenty-
In survey of all available literature three and fourth years of occupa-
on the subject up to the present time tional exposure to asbestos dust in a _
we have collected 172 cases of pulmonary asbestosis There are references
to this subject in one or two abstracts notably those of Bridge and of Sir Thomas Oliver but specific cases are not enumerated In four cases belonging to Wood's series the diagnosis was doubtful and in the majority of others the diagnosis was based entirely on clinical and roentgen findings There were twenty in which the diagnosis was confirmed by the finding of the asbestosis bodies in the sputum in the lung juice by puncture or by nec-
textile mill Death was due to cardiac
failure secondary to back pressure from
massive generalized fibrosis Before
death cyanosis was pronounced and
diffuse fine mottling of a silicotic type
was detected on ray The macro-
scopic appearances were typical of dense pulmonary fibrosis with other
organs secondarily affected heart nutmeg liver and indurated
spleen and kidneys The fibrosis was
generalized with no nodules or whorls
as in silicosis no polymorphonuclear
cells were to
seen in the bronchi or
ropsy Necropsy has been made on elsewhere Asbestosis bodies were
eighteen cases In three of these the
disease was complicated by pulmonary tuberculosis three by lobar pneumonia three by bronchopneumonia
and one was a traumatic death In
abundantly present and also a great deal of yellow pigment in the form of granules and globular masses No
tuberculous lesions were found.E. L. C.
four the authors failed to give a com-
plete report stating only that the THE FORMATION OF THE ASBESTOSIS
necropsy confirmed the diagnosis Including the very first case recorded that of Murray in the Charing Cross
BODY IN
Tubercle 399-401
THE LUNG S. R. Gloyne June 1931 vol 12 pp
Gazette of 1900 which apparently
received little attention until resur-
Pictorial presentation is given in this short note of the formation of
rected by Cooke there are now four records of necropsy on uncomplicated pulmonary asbestosis Except those
asbestosis bodies They appear to be formed by the deposition of some organic material around an asbestos
reported by ourselves and those by Pancoast and Pendergrass and four others by Simson from South Africa these cases have all developed in the
British Isles Authors Summary
fiber this material then fissures or cracks giving rise to the appearance of segments finally fragmentation from the asbestosis body may separate portions There is evidence that iron
242
THE JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
is a component of the material de-
posited on the inhaled fiber During
the reaction which takes place solution
of a fraction of asbestos occurs but
evidence is lacking as to how the long . asbestos particles which are far longer than the diameter of a dust cell are introduced into the pulmonary tissues
;
-E C.
SILICOSIS T. H. Belt Canadian Med Assn Jour Dec. 1930 vol 23
pp 802-804 This is a general discussion of silico-
sis and of the various theories as to the method of action of silica dust in the
lungs C. S.
DIAGNOSIS OF PULMONARY SILICO-
PNEUMONOCONIOSIS THE DE-
LAYED DEVELOPMENT OF SYMPTOMS
J. A. Britton and J. R. Head Jour
Am Med Assn June 6 1981 vol 96
pp 1938 1939
Most clinical and statistical studies
of silicosis have been made on groups
of men still employed in dusty trades
From such statistics one cannot say what is the late effect of short exposures In this paper we have reported four cases of silicosis or silicosis and
tuberculosis which developed many years after relatively short exposures These instances suggest the necessity of revising the conception of the length
of exposure necessary to produce the
disease and make it seem probable that
after relatively short exposures suffi-
cient dust must be deposited in the
SIS C. Garin Abstr as follows from Presse m^'dApril 18 1931 vol 39 p
568 in Jour Am Med Assn July 11 1981 vol 97 pp 143 144
Garin states that most of the authors
cited by him reported cases licosis in which tuberculosis was present None of them attempted to bring out
the differences between the two condi-
tions He stresses mostly the roent-
gen side of the question In his roent-
gen studies he found that about 85 per cent of the cases are those of a
granular silicosis He believes that
the granular aspect of chest roentgeno-
grams is not positively that of pure
silicosis and it should not serve as an
exclusive base for diagnosis of silicosis
The diagnosis between simple silicosis
with a granular picture and pulmonary
tuberculosis is however easy the
lungs to set up a progressive fibrosis which only after many years becomes
patients with silicosis have no fever and the condition is progressive On
sufficiently extensive to produce symptoms They tend to indicate that
the other hand diagnosis becomes almost impossible in cases of silico-
men in the work develop symptoms
only after many years of exposure
not because that length of exposure
is necessary but because it takes a
long time for the disease to develop
-Authors Conclusions
tuberculosis in which the tubercle
bacillus interferes with the develop-
ment of a pure silicosis In such cases
it is impossible to pronounce the pa-
tients sick with silicosis or with pure
tuberculosis One can only make a diagnosis of silicotuberculosis
F INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE
de-
ing
ion but ong ger
are Cs
| F
Canadian SILICOSIS. T.T. H.H. Belt.
Canadian
Med Assn Jour Dec. 1980 vol 23
pp 802 804
This is a general discussion of silico-
sis and of the various theories as to the method of action of silica dust in the
lungs C. S.
DE-
DIAGNOSIS OF PULMONARY SILICO-
SIS C. Garin Abstr as follows from Presse m^'dApril 18 1931 vol 39 p
568 in Jour Am Med Assn July 11 1981 vol 97 pp 143 144
Garin states that most of the authors
cited
cited licosis by him reported cases
in which tuberculosis was present
None of them attempted to bring out
the differences between the two condi-
tions He stresses mostly the roent-
0-
gen side of the question In his roent-
gen studies he found that about 85 per
d cent of the cases are those of a granular silicosis He believes that
the granular aspect of chest roentgeno-
grams is not positively that of pure
silicosis and it should not serve as an
1 exclusive base for diagnosis of silicosis
The diagnosis between simple silicosis with a granular picture and pulmonary tuberculosis is however easy the
patients with silicosis have no fever
and the condition is progressive On
the other hand diagnosis becomes almost impossible in cases of silico-
tuberculosis in which the tubercle
bacillus interferes with the develop-
of a pure silicosis In such cases
imtentis impossible to pronounce the pa-
tients sick with silicosis or with pure
tuberculosis One can only make a
diagnosis of silicotuberculosis
ABSTRACTS
243
OCCUPATIONAL INFECTIOUS DISEASES OCCURRENCE
,
TREATMENT AND PREVENTION
CASE OF ANTHRAX IN MAN
C.
*
ciation with pneumonia
He describes
j
Rasch Abstr as follows from Ugesk f the postmortem appearances of two
i
i Laeger March 19 1931 vol 93 p 307 miners who had died of this In addi-
i
in Jour Am Med Assn June 18 tion to the ordinary signs of pneumo-
1931 vol 96 p 2080
nia he found throughout the lungs
Rasch reports the case of a man on extensive deposits of foreign material
whose hands two lesions developed rich in manganese which had led to
after he had handled a cow with an- fibrosis of the lungs
thrax A scraping made under the
He considered that his findings
crust on the larger plaque when together with the clinical experience of
stained with methylthionine chloride the medical men in the district of Gies-
revealed numerous typical anthrax sen where the manganese ores are
bacilli This result is almost always mined explained the prevalence of the
obtainable he says if examination of pneumonic symptoms but the classical
untreated primary anthrax is made symptoms of chronic manganese poi-
during the first three days Treat- soning are unknown in the district in
ment with 0.75 gm of neoarsphen- question M. L.
amine three times daily at intervals of
from three to five days together with
VIOLET RADIATION AND RE-
hot local applications was followed by SISTANCE TO INFECTION INTRANASAL
rapid recovery K. D.
INFECTION WITH THE PNEUMOCOCCUS
AND WITH BACTERIUM LEPISEPTICUM
PNEUMONIA IN BROWN IRON ORE
MINERS Schopper Abstr as follows from Arch f Hyg Sept. 1980 vol 104 pp 175-188 in Bull Hyg April 1931 vol 6 p 322
In this paper Schopper after referring to the recognized peculiar symptoms of chronic manganese poisoning has followed up the other
aspect of its action namely the asso-
IN THE RABBIT M. Hardy and J. Chapman Am Jour Hyg Jan. 1931 vol 13 pp 255 280
Exposure of rabbits to direct sun and
to artificial radiation from a mercury
arc had little or no effect on mortality rate and on resistance to pneumococcus and Bacterium lepisepticum infection and little effect on blood counts and antibody formation P. Y.
OCCUPATIONAL AFFECTIONS OF THE SKIN AND SPECIAL SENSES
DERMATITIS
FROM
CELLULOSE
VARNISHES J. Rousset M^'ddu
travail May 1981 vol 3 pp 76 82
The occurrence of outbreaks of skin
1 troubles in a furniture factory led to investigation of the composition of the varnishes used The composition of
the fluids used for filling and for clean-
ing the wood and for diluting the varnishes is given These fluids con-
tain a number of volatile grease sol-
vents Experiments by applying them to the skin failed to reproduce the condition which occurs in the workers but wood vinegar and benzene two of the constituents did cause some ery-
Vol 13