Document 7O5ndQnrqMVMMv0LM4VOVgwo6
Mnswito
*. T
APR19 1982
-^ur-ucATiQH*woHi r . T. Parker * Nitro Plant - #507
OATt uBjier
April 13, 1982 TCDD ANALYSES
cc.
H. S. Scott - E2ND
T,, M- Bistliney- E2NJ H. M. Galloway
nirtncNC
TO :
A. M. Ford A2SA
ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE
Regarding your inquiry about th TCDD levels reported in the 1969 Nitro TSD Annual Summary, we have no documents that can verify or determine the source of these numbers. The TSD summary reports that TCDD levels averaged 40-50 ppm during 1968. The Nitro research notebooks of Phil Balderson and Marty Wilson contain no analytical data on TCDD levels, during this time period. Balderson stated that if any TCDD analyses were run at Nitro, the results would be recorded either in his notebook or Marty Wilson's notebook. Balderson and Wilson were apparently the only Nitro chemists to run analyses for TCDD. Rick Atkinson, the only other Nitro chemist working with 2,4,5-T during 1968, stated he does not recall having run an analysis for TCDD in 2,4,5-T. These facts suggest that no TCDD deter minations were made at Nitro during 1968.
Nitro measurements of TCDD levels in 2,4,5-T were carried out in both the years before and after 1968. These measurements suggest that the 40 to 50 ppm figures cited in the TSD summary are not realistic (assuming the Nitro analytical method is reasonably accurate) Nitro measure ments never exceeded 28 ppm, and TCDD values typically averaged 12 ppm or less. The attached notebook pages comprise all of the Nitro analytical data I could find on TCDD analyses. I have included some comments on these copies in parenthesis. In particular,*I suspect the numbers reported in Marty Wilson's notebook may be questionable. The numbers are quite low and certain samples run by both St. Louis and Marty do not agree. The St. Louis numbers cited in Marty's notebook were probably generated by Bill Udell (currently with Monsanto Agricultural Division). It should be noted that Phil Balderson employed a slightly different method from Marty Wilson for TCDD analyses, and Balderson's method was based on a method obtained from Dow.
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
02290*
2
Another possible source of TCDD analytical data would be Bill Udell. Apparently, he ran TCDD analyses for Corporate Research around the time period in question. The TSD summary might be based on numbers generated by Udell.. It should be noted that lots of 2,4,5-T produced in 1968 should begin with the., code letters "NK" and this can be used to determine if analytical results correspond to material made in 1968.
Finally, the report in the 1969 TSD summary was probably generated by R. L. Dillon, Jr. and/or J. C. Strum. These engineers were handling process changes, etc. at that time. I questioned Dillon (currently superintendent of MHA operations at Nitro) and he said he did not recall the source of the numbers. Strum is no longer working for Monsanto. It is quite possible the numbers they reported are erroneous.
sa Attachment
R. T. Parker
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT. TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
C22903
1f galJtrj* VC V 6
fi/af/Mte s'*
7
'Tfrapsitesra*'' ifitrftiE'sn?# s&y?/-
'J-sf/n/'jfZ t?/* s*s*Xsiis'*''& 7~
ttsr? ^r^jryyy^Xs* <'*' ?r&ir&&'4pste
^pAxeyuir ^ s e ^ ^ ^ y s y ^ sz> ^fp&sesi&^ts'^
ss= X M f s&'s*Ssf:>('s's?s A?
ig <*?
A M as* /**/& m a <? jsa'"^,
StfJVC7~0*
> S '/Ut&C &a.aaC^ 3 stf.rSZ'/?
3/Z ^y-s' */* Afcsr- ss^/JJ" a#iG0s9*J'*'es& &
AIVf e-e/aw/s/T
tf' 3-6 //ft w/vx/sy**/
_ H/SSSr/*
/?&>y~ S0 (p ?a s 3 ' *? S ''S ~
stJP /> s n /
"* J>ys?A'/fr S '?
. sr/sxiys'ffix '.
/^ /syzy ,& ** m a sA apaa s->^Asy
. ."... A X 'S W/AXS J - S & / A *arV. Stfs?'*'S'e`/ fs f
. A /srA A s-y r a s * SS/fiA- a a h a A/ZP S s # /
JL /V yiiS/S. j ^ / r t T f0 fB/f?. j?/x xyy-
ra
s f a? /
m/ ssx/ j^a a t a ^ sx #
. /l/'r'f,/ / t& 6 /f.
PA A A -A ys S A /* s?9 if OsP^sf/X/C
A K f& A/v# W /f/3ae^y&r
s& p a> S
. . . //*?r , #t? a / / s/x t a syyAT. s'syA SW P'zv y y y
A/' * ' s#t72~se/efi'sf-Ss'<i>st/ Ax=~ A 's'-
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
_ _____________
C22904
Ho/i ; 7~ht's Js j'h t, &'t~j 4 fiSfro
h
____
H>__ rus* Te. o d &rua ly j e j -- ^
$al<)tr~s~i
j 2e/ct*rsa s) ( 0 3 **
M /s - a s a M a / -asy M a & - as M a s - airy //m y -- aaf? w a v - as?
M a * -a s Y M a * - a JS
M a - as a M a * - a&? M a ? - a/6 M a ? -asF" Astfa? - a * s
. M S T -0/6 . M & * - 3 1/
/ 0 s#/?SS7
Z f s##'*? & / /9>'7? S.^Tyoys^
/*? // y*/*'*? SS yts**#? /? yy?a&? *?/ /y*'*? o?& y/&/?/V7 as yyy&zS
S pyp/n
y/
In y*yu
CONFIDENTIAL
CIIOIFPT TO PROTECTIVE o r d er .
?/Q//
rU 0**9 90b
VV
kI
//6 s A ?
?/?#PC/#~ '9/#^' />/P- 7 # -?9.
ayg/
g # 7 zy -
W O 9-0// ,,M 09-0& / AW/a - asg /Vtf/0 -arg.
W // -asa /M /4 -a a fM /a - a s-/ ///a / -a a 4 < sa / -a /!/
& ?s. 7 # /? .
3 /Z S ;r 3 *3 3 ? y 3
1f1 \!flS: i i1
} t
CONFIDENTIEL cidicy't Tn PBnTFrriVP ORDER.
C22906
f aJef^rjtn aJ
r a # /ss jr sSsMty&zr
'^(0&S*ir' J'sf/77^' s?S St/
/W 6 /&
yr-? 7 .
P/?/e #f/aSS
WVi5" <-2 *s**-
/&>?* ~^y. ]y:
sM'^r-af'S AW9 - /0 0 AW02 - 0 0 / /YJ-0 P - 0 /0 s/j~<02- ~oju> S/JT03 - 0 3 0 /ttfirn - a 9 T0/> g& V 0-^4/fip
& /&>' / /? // 0 '/ //S~
9 / .S'
)
1
l
%
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
C 229 07
-7
kp --r --
/Sxifjysfir
/!/& & ra s P ^ >zs y y jy J '
zrpz&eypjz P a*'p' s/KSssfiio&j&f<y:
fp"-/ s/y
t&fA''S JVPZZ
v//tf ^MPSAtsat+x scyy}
rp~ j'/f/Vjf fr; P'^pzry jtspzz
piA 7&<C> & f&* 'SP- P Z P
z??//y /`/x e p y /? /p
s z jz rs
/r zx/zJ
'/ `/ J z rjz / P Z7/P r<z/>
J&oT z >a//s j 4.r /s 0/t/zy
///psy ypP/ypppyp sw^o?p p z p zzP.
t
.
i
.
'
r**
i
r
I -I
:I
t;
*
/
T
!
i
C O N F ID E N T !^
CIm .PCT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
C22908
MAI
alJttZo* fi}& **y\
r#0 /M S, -/
S0 Afifi/f sfis&fixfi s## sa
*/
*/ fi4 , W A V /S
fists?*
Y H /Jf# r / /
fi0 0 S"* t /
J fifi Afifi/ifi ra fists**/? v fifi**?
/* **/i?. / ^ r / ,/ V r^ ^ !' sssss/szefist/
jfi*W0/3? t*rfifi. / W M i W r
S T 0 P s > f/ fi //tA J * S A s v f if if if i
'! ' fi
(j 4 fi -y 2 afia*<s. * s>
\fii. V? /A S 0/ts SlS^- scS/fis>?*?z'fi~-S
Aor rft#
S A3
m
i: U
!
S
-0 0 / 0/0 30 03 V
/ /*/>/
3 sV
/
?
0 V5'
.1
i f*
0S0
i
fia
r
/S ' A fi
1
1 1,
n e /f&hHr S/MMB X / S X SL M
f!
tK # t. f r a
f f * 7fi
B
a 6 F
SURIFfTT TO PROTF^TIUF nonrb
\
j
A /T f/p />/-/St'S, /Z>
jC-SA W X /?C
Utspsy* se
70 XUSA/ 3;`%'S'-/'
j//?j TZ.** . V 7/9/? a>*J <>A4f
i\t
/r^ / > 3/J /f&,-/9s&0S
| 0//#4/ff0/ M i 6
77?/z& s*/a/l/9/3'0
I r e H /a r t/f # '/// . /? /~ y ^ s /e s s '
! Afr/r/P fjr\/&pS. S/fAT/V/TS ^/?
I//a
0/&77?/st/S S~
?
i & / > //f J'/fsSVS^r Z5V/S~ \# * 7 ~
3% JF-5V a tf /tti/ - ?rf C/f/PaMS&AS
A.
li 7 7 ^ 1*
!i aii;
///0A/CS AS
M//& ^ //~
^//ZTt/A/S 77970- 7~00 P&/9/&/'/*&/?
Of0 0 A> s /s z /^ y j'/jr .
nf 1 h
^figrtdt/ #/> h dh
!
fitOAM A?/>9b-0 /aa* -> 30?<i (S> y./&rf>1
CONFIDENTIAL
-- SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
. CS2910
K H i mm
aaifitiBdtti iiflaairfiMHKdMSK^ai^^ *
( g 'terso* aM 7 \
I titiH M jM U i
l
i
PP I
\
i.
tf~ .
7I * ..
I
r f*/ r s /fj
& s', s*?. n // /s/tt'j?
\f*r*Acn sfc rej*
s*//? y
J4> >*/9*J9r/0A< AJA/yS# *AS<ZX S7T
SArt7~
TU
MfTHtry
i
r t f f SXS y y jj T//&Y rA //0 W/7 /
\r r A/s */#<. rx/y y s* /J
is/y#r~7 je*s/y
r y y A/s y*&
w j'/ys97yr s m yyy yty A/^yy/f
; M f# r//y y y . xa Ir y * * So s&ra<*-
1 4$o_ 7w&*y i/s/^r /W( styy/?yf//7 .yya/ry
tya# /T/A /v^r/axy <assya*o /'A/*/**/'
iA/j/r/'C Ae/as.
TSHE r tt,x
P M ceM A E A A A /S S trfA
\AftbA rAA/f ortirA ryszs aa a/SA ama j "beb a Xt/y r#A//. re s V />/> s>s m s ; Apm en/n/ A/ve ,a/f m e r/s sw .
CONFIDENTIAL
| SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
022912
mmmmmrn
7 2 3 7 /Af.
i| ttrscr/yy-'
J& y y y y
\ttFA / y ..AGs?/7 sifSsiP yzif *7"
s ftM H u y s '' y y / r
jv- 2
\y /A /? 4 v y r y s # ?7& c. y ^ - s - j - f v a
>ay a s s yyy?? z ^y &> & &
:, y r/# y a^ T * /* yyyys .a y y j7 z y /y rv y a <?<z &&z7zyi y y # /> # ? / y *4 a w ? s -j * . ? /r. y ^ ?. y ^ /y /y y y y y y y y /^ y y y . y /z v yyyyyyA z * . <? y t> y >y y -s .
' y & y -y& e s '-y y y y y y y y y s '.
i M f S y ? / < //{ * 2 S & J y < z / /
iy y y y y y /y y y rs y & f s'~yy> y y y y u T jy M S y y ry y y y y y y y y y y y y y y .
j w /7##M iv y y f & >##/>? e y y ^ y x & e
is M > -y y A tF /y y y & & & # ^
: M 9fi?A,J7Z ' y p ja w yz> /^ / // /r & e f .
. W /r# y A ti/ 9& y / y y y yy<sz~<y~ 5s ff/fs y y r. y /y y y y y y y y y y y yiyyyyyz-
! o '" rs* .
stm s
5 TP. 7 # /ff$ . S7 Wr, 6o 07ro , *
*un
&& /9f
//K
/s*f .... y/L
o/.yy*~
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
2 -2 /-r 9
C32'
3 /r li szezr/v <p a'-/3j# '-- /*.... T&j? -- az&x&itwtf
Il > y
4 m a&p/> jpj*i ___ &0 /99-- / t . __
L S r ^ c ^ i _________
__ _____________
------------------ .
__ .y/ JK&~-
sjutsa tv a s a */
j._____ j0.0 /3
..
.*? -j3.d
_ . . ....:._
S7) .S S / '&PA'S .<ZA/77frV**ri37
T.a .e > 3 r ._ M ,
; _____ 1.37 . . . ___________
\_____. J &
__________________
...0,f & ,/*H14 d-,j_T _$$.*(
J QuO iU V ____m
TOO
I; 8
BeiJtrS\st
JMMYSS3
3
I+SATMCT/oA ._J>0// .2/ S/MXWf, /O r#J/n
i T ._____w/r//- -- . a a . j* / . 2 t f /3 . -/*>/?
h o /*.
L JASL__ J'f/W/'z ____ /J T/tM Cfvrfi/JF04&
I//o.-- riter___c#ajej*a/ejw . n//r/A/?A>swA/. us
.* r / . . / 4 / A a J tf '4~7?r/7 j t'0 s > f2
;.jW / ? / V / SS
/eaxf ys /w/<-^2f.
_ s 4/ti?//=/<6s? 2 X 0 x*'r~
<aa
iTTMte? 14//TM)*?A)u/*S /V774/t W44//>y2.
- T//2 . -/y /.*/A ST AXXX*AaX-?
.T> /ey/i/ss 'fri'O " & s ss&e A^sy/UT y/=- r/ys/f 4>&e AAA^? W sta
..AXA ?A AS~ ats~/ *st/ <6 (j*
:*9st AAy7Sr. / y/ X3-). A/ syy=AT
/A,, f i /A/ >A& -ja1 ASATSel SM4>*/s<Si
.:j/ja/ A ___4 4 / . (6y>is .. AsyXAxoefiy? > ? ^ -
:,,.$4S4 / / / t a o /y o A sA /yA 7~~
i //0>-fi3Y. ,.- .Z/>/>/n
,is-.~/t, sea/ z & '& ' / fj r\
Ato? -aa$-
.. A /0 7 r e s /
A3jty?/n
i.S />A'y\
..s ie 8"~ CO3 ,.A o f a y
#'yy>sr)
L1 ff>*\
- ai?6
iJ/4t SAO-
l '
lU^CLr
__jtff/st__
C2281
al*rs**'
I
'jyiej^-O&o _ _____. __3.*7^ ?. JSSsrt__
Jl aU o P - J 2 * .... ........ ........ 2* 5' . _y ^ c r * ----- -- . ^ i S/o Bt*>
,t/L O #-= J2P y..^
/VJJlS-L2>__ nua3-=*ci2-- jifio -.e// ..
___ _____ ________________ _____
________ LC>.-/>fso.________ .
...
...:____ o,? ^
mar.jz/9...
*
JV0J'..-*IS
t
~>/f
aya.
. .# 0 6 -
?&&
___yvt)6 r-a/fi-
__ L^54 r>>5.
_
l i.vx
o?_^zep_oo_.yy__
_________ 1jV^J.-.aSSL
....... i.*.. _3.<L
____ f.S ____
jL 'y ^ .-'i^ d y .7 . . ^ . _ __ _
g/<
3 - ............
,,A/ . /X
.
.._
. . ..
3 ? . 5
. . s r . __________ ;_________
...f-Qj
~ _________ j
......... - . S * ..........
__________ WK^=>-~<?J-3.________ &. rz___ __________________ _______
_____________~ ~ T
J .. .. ...W t'< ? y --0 3 .
____________
___________________________________________
__________ M
-03.0 ______ ___________________________ ________
j ____ (>y.__________
'fyLz/L.z4<l,_____ /,S'.______
"ettoiOT m : P M l T E C n ^ * ^ t K - ^ - ' :''* ' T ^ O C M i ' -
-, * BU t
i i
- A / A 0 5 2 . 3 ............ A y p s r
' A H . a 7 - a / &
S ^ jo p / p i
\\
\ \ f V U > 7 - & ! ? ___ /ZA X 9 Q .0 P / 3^
... . ^ j j L O . - 0 1 - l t
\J\L V * LC/
C / J o & - >/5 ^ ^ / r.i
.................... : L & 7 -- T~1
i." ?
TT*7 A/'^T
fj f f m
L *f jp f* w /*5
..
____ H . o t - - V"3- I ../L 0 6 -. / 3 #
/^ yy* r* . *(/*/****
. N l o ? - 0 0 e!
V/*"" /. >^"
. ... .
J iL O i- O H
-N L O S - 0 3Z
/
-- . . Jj/L O t-. 0 1 1
_______ r, ..> .? s r - 3 * .
___________ i i A M i - 4 3 ' . .
_______
lf\o s -0 1i
/- 3/yT*^ .. . . A /yjy KVi
/ ^
c p f '*
____________ ,, it't tf - 0 .1 9 . _ . . . .
_.. _____ J i l o l - . e n
'H fj'* *
..... . ^ L O 'Y -O ^ C f
_________ ,, V L 0 Z - O / Z .
*
- /
***
__ \_rVL(f- C92> "AU-0& -
____!^ .J?6. .-7 J V
'tite, _-_aSi
ia.icJS',%' J/-SZ. g/s
3.9% a s - T
t.
teas -asV ____
!A t e a * --
i
j^LzStelJ..
J?0 <sS-
/}3l? uxt)
X f / '.'V. ___ .fj/rsT? ____a s flam
M L j> J r-a 5 _________
!YL0J rL&>> .
yrter..-.fix..
/a/ / " * & w /y * ?
S/?*7 f.Sjyrsrj
H/07^uS>/>.....
/ i t ? ____ ____]fa -j Q>6/ f
^Wl
.....jto> - 0 3 .... ..MM-#/"/. ....
/ ./ /y v s y
. ._ &tyy?sv .fo/yrri
A. f / '/ 1'' 9?
3./
_____ .................
fie.
r/? ats-y
/MU/ --
____
::ezoiss7?/r'. >i-lJ/77yi/ 7~ 07/'^X .
&>>l j y*/<r a.&0*~ y s =y& /77~ ypjsy& zszs.
1
.. Q&/3*c ~ .
/ / / y z y u s c / 'P J /z& 'P p ^ 'T & e
.. 3-, S - / o J //&.///?/ /PSSZPs&eyrjSZe
.. A ?
7 2 V 3 7= &//11- j y/yyy't?<&-vz/
../* a /7 /j9 ///ji//y r ) y y y y y ^ /y y y y y x
\Q <A * /
fy - # /* a s* & &
S2> *0?2r>S' ^ 2 _
y y v fJ r y y y .
< r ^ / *y=
.y/?y> s / i / z y /e :/? y y & x /> //
-M7-
>/=-
^
, h.s /////jfs)
<2s C tf# y 7 ~ z> y i/y & sy
i
p F
- -4 -
`CONFIDENTIAL
t j. SUBJECT TQ PROTECTIVE ORDER.
C2291
_JUStfEZ5/?S?7*S<r___ jfS__ s?S
727S3__ ............................................. _ _
/VZgrg-....SsT.
y-._
I
___________i*^?r___ ? A ____
_____
I'
I
y
y
.__s& g J M '
______ :_ljAj& v& 's?}'__ /
JS'S 'Z'* .
^
SSZ-Z7 <*
/ . .. ^f*sg _/#&&*
^ y ^ s c>S' ' saS
________ ,, 1 _^5*2^5*i?" _*5<*<5
\l'jvs?--X's/'f r ".___ s>
7x/=~
%#///&*.* -
^SyffiY
______ - ij /4t . . T Y F .. A y fffff . T O . _ytV4 / . . sF ffJF
-------------------U -OE Y S 'L T "-. ,_TM _ J F > . & X 7 7 /t r > f V s f f I
iiw j & t t e o ..w / r t f j? / t/r ` a/s j / / s, j t # - * s /w & ri T.__U.TJ*L/?.Sea/Z/VS"__ 0//it/,J/fs9-7''> S/*/
... ..
---
fio
M._____S fitto ____s e e s ___________ 3& J& -/V ? & . j h / cM tI nt* `
_J
f f f / / t.S
f* aereo.
_ i g T -- ^ S tS . <sfi*77M4 . O . S f f / s p f t y X ySiet/e# r e
w/T - i :X7~ . ___j f f
& Stf& ffl'^-tu/en.
**/ fietO /fsg .jJ tr
t i f f /* 1 f t .
1*5. 3^L&ec* ; Steel 6&t) t f f i - / S J & yVX
4*0-
(j fjf& i w * rz> s9*?
**-5'fl^J3E?iS"f^?T.
--- V7____ ^ /s r ..^pTjEZSsy^"
-$? 5 U -- I& # r * f/^ B
AfanB 0T7W & Bm
: iy
_J& 7 7B L ............. _ ^ 3
/A W 77SJ - -
X^ 2 0 ------
rz~ x'/sr./s
j * .V :
TE
JE
n
Q Mtrit a flt 70 ~ /T \
.Jf/O ^ O ___ .. _ T T / Z -'T'/VTA' f S Z & fi& S yfTTTZC .
..J/ f/r ty tt
^ r^ t^ A p Z T .
'.."Z & s / - -J& y. s f -
___
,,^iv^r
&rssizr ._
. . . i:
S s& s* /^ /s& y ~ . y& 2& y ._
k S 7& s07 -jr& .-7H 52 7 7 9 ^ 7SZ? -T/TZfs^
\./M A ...
y ? ^ z s? S ~
_
v'ZVJ& y*? S & ^ s& r >> s t? / / y e / s u t^ _
____________^ ?
y2y0ZZ7.. s # S __
_ _____ ' i y ^ f - yr^ y0 y& & & g > f X T ^ & & Z rl7
\y W ? 2 9 ^
y*& ?Z iZ ? ^ 7 . _
...........
^ j f f y E Z ^ f . y ^ y f ^ P & frSyf?. Z2>
________ T v/~ . -72?SZyZS . ^ Z P JrZ ? *?-
_
.................. yfo'TT Z& rX ' . /& e .
7 M 7 /0 /Jr7Z 'A :r
. . . ________ I/ # 7 J 9 ^ _ ...J & frte/= & X & T 7 .J & T ^ . 7Zs>
_ ....... _/?.
/V/t/yz/cTtS. , ^ 7
.......................U A X & -- JP y oe tc/-SS= -3>'
7 - __
_______:... j. 7 7 /^ . --. J W 2 y* H T ..^ y P ify i^ S f .. 7 & ts x /___
_____ _ _ . ,, n /yP ^ S ^ 1. Zfyy<^~ s ts s z* * 9 5" s S
___
. _______
. y . J TT. -J t//7 y y s r s # / < rs* r ^ S ^ y _
................. ^ 7 2 2 '.. .7 r ' 2 7 7 r . 7 f ..7 2 StA fii& T0
_
.. y & __7 ? /? yyy r3 ' '^ _f/n/>j.G.. . O /ssae. u s a ______
. _ W--..:Le .:\t*/- -fjr .j?77/x/t&r) . y ...___
'M l # * Z ? . - _72? A .. A AA . ... tffA . ,,
06U/A / 7 0 _____ / TVJ . . . 9*- . s f /A S .........................._
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT. TO PROTECTIVE ORDER;
C1
S. rsnj0
f.
y - .JH/2 /a/ sa9f/i5f 3*su)
..S . flW .YEXTKH SJjOB /**" W
.. & 79fi__>*V .yftEWC^/. , _.
______ y __MCS-L&ifyaie
cwe/rf .
. _____________________________________________________________________
____ S__JT exr/* fi~> r^sr_____________ I
__:. \./.v & r .sre&LSKT*..
xxr
/V/C___
M c. e,i -o^ u ps.
*f>!-____
1
Ti.
CONFIDENTIAL
'SUBJECTTO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
022922
- 6 1 f o p w-'-'i
r
Cafi/
\
/79arjy yS/j%s%
Moilq J<
/
^ ftmjt
^S&*u0+jCba~
^fr,, _<
iJ
^ut
C^uCA* ^ f i f l
(U-aafuA. ***
^
7&fc }< *
J&0
/ S/
yy.
//r
/fa j.y
If?
aim^
iff
tS 7
4.5"
^'`-t ft* \st*dir >*>!LtA
A / A yLi//i&J
>4C&U.
'i ^
! A t/-* ' ^/-cy J
y r /# su&U~- J?yC<_ 'ye&vKjL- $AiL*Ty*c-c/st*/
|i sty -?/ y
>J cpZy 2^
4 h $ L $ /scA--~
to
^
/U ,^J *-*-*iz~i & & [
W l 7^^-InF.NTIAf,
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
C229,, ^ ^ r 0 C229-3 . - ^ M l l-_
^ ________
f jjife_-r.'fhti .**/.' ,/V/i .>i*il*.f ? <
.*. `"i-."1' *'.\-V:. .v - - L*.- : " *"" J --*1 `
* . .i
? e:^^
^ 'Tvi/mv ^//Cr .'r* 6 ^
`<
-- e.i
/ /-%t 7 & <j
- o^ - y ?s-a"c~
<5~Z>
aSc j z :
7*~
/7 ~ sr< ? L tf- / X
i**'.
JMr+.
/v< 7^>/>
2*
C m c /s
im: * .*5'-V
> rv"i *-
y a ^
h
'Whs
ira/ * -f*
X
f-. `-T*
C22934 f e t g f l
CONFIDENTIAL *i/r A n n c D
f
f-/? - Z f '6 f
~ fP P
6**/
r flOorf"/ *A'/$n /Vtf Ao*r
^f.
eQ xp. r f
K * J ^
*&
u - n e
('J o^"
*
J
s ^ - .d / jn* C#*4j
^ ^ *>
y
cv > ^ 2 ^ * ^ y A x
!& 2 /
W*
b^
b f*
1^0
*prf~ 0m^pf M
TM7^7/^" P p rn
fp\
- -S' y/0/^
' ./S7*r
= / '/ > '
VLL-fr-
&;//>$
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
022925 -
J ch*a U-~/ v ^ 4 .
2^ `-x?*?~ &4d)??
3-*/-M
*
T^/
4r/ #3 &/ Hi
't' A D
a -Y p/,'Vj a ^ /V ^
/ * - V //^ ^
/ / ff/>7
CONFIDENTIAL
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
G2292
hfy
!ay2j?*
s
jr/'i" /
!-7
CONFIDENTIAL SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER. "
G2 2 9 2 7
/^ .- -
/ ^ry
7/ /
y O'*
-r *-aa--
& f * S ft. 7jOJ> ? 77?^ $JAL**.
/?J? i,
-
(D ^*4'
yA2z^*^L ^
XS&/ / d ^2`&&`LdJL A^f A
/2AjlM j
^ (tJUL l^r^A flHdfj' cf v ^ ^ l ^ d L
/wx--
< JSS
\JL"fit.
*/tf
J*f
t/fy
i ns
\j/0
7
-rJ)0 o iffiL a .C tfv J.2.
0. $
0. s
6-&
-Jv*
A
V
f CONFIDENTIAL'
!: SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER.
. P H H | I .
'*
1 --
*7
022928
,\ - :*I*
VJ..
**'/
3>.3v*-