Document 6w5Om7ab9zja6mVqJ8VLY4eGR

Davia LOMA David - LCM A. Siders To: Join. MuhCaoours sUeSnMCUonoSr Sanders Sune: RPeamronWs.eLrotganlUS Comore USGI Comore 0099//0099//22000000 0022.:2277 PPMM To: John R. Mulhausen/US-Corporalel3M/US@3M-Corporate Geary OlsenUS-Corporate/3M/US@3M.Corporate Perp/W. Logan/US-Corporatei3MIUS@3M-Corporate Geary OlsenIUS-Corporate/3MIUS@3M-Corporate cccc:: JJeeffffrreeyyHH.. MMaannddeell/UUSS--CCoorrppoorraatteel3/M3M/UUSS@ @33MM-C-Coroprporoarattee Subject: Re: manuscript Sony, you shoud ave boon coi anas wsell, Wo wil aed your updated isto scenic papers, Sorry, you should have been copied on this as well. We will need your updated list of scientitic papers, and tera; | nik you had Some ont pes wih Occ Med. Thnk, Gave and timetable; I think you had some joint projects with Oct Med. Thanks, dave wardsDavid LOMA.Sands Copa AUS n030920000823AM Forwarded by David - LCM A, SandersfUS-Corporatel3MIUS on 09/09/2000 08:28 AM )Dovis- LOMA Sancers David - LCM A. Sanders OB0R2000 04555 09f08/2000 04:56 PM Ee aes 31~1 Corporate Life Cycle Manaerne~t Wenge 3M Center. I~ldg. 220-9E-11 adem ay Tel: 651-733-5226 ER Fax: 651-575-1989 GTSo BCiDLMKTTraihlialcaaoehW thrmaetRsyeas.lBsh]R.aAZEee coD.eSDboaaPnERnIscTteoUpsoC-SeranEodCuuTomsaUUrm SerCpSCSLooSioCgrrAMpeaopLU-oe oMmerSrMMnGaoUCaGlUaUrSIelMr oSMeSa-@MMVCUUIp@ISoISSNrUM@l rMo@C-MGpCCSoI--oarayCCrmMrroS pEaopmsorCrorropprarCeoeottporerosrartptaeoterea SSuubbjejectc:t: Charles Reich/US-Corporate/3MfUS@3M-Corporate Michael A. SantoroiUS-Corporatel3M/US@3M-Corporate Bill WeppneriUS-Corporate/3MtUS@3M-Corporate Kalherine E. ReedlUS-Corporatel3MIUS@3M-Corporate Thomas J. DiPasquale/LA-Legal/3M/US@3M-Corporate Michael I. DoughertylUS-Corporate/3MIUS@3M-Corporate Larry R. Zobel/US-Corporatei3M/US@3M-Corporate Dale L. BaceniET-ET&S/3MIUS@3M-Cerporate JJeeffffrreeyy HH.. MMaannddeell//UUSS--CCoorrppoorraatteef3/M3M/U/USS@@33MM--CCoorrppoorraattee JJoohhnn LL.. BBuutteeanbhooffff/UUSS--CCoorrppoorraattee/3/MSM/U/USS@@33MM-C-Coreprpoorraattee RRee:: mmaannusucsrcirpiptl [FJI Chuck, cuss hi ri th ith Lary Zobel is afsmoon, anc | iwok see tha tchnice Chuck, I discussed this briefly with with Larry Zobel this afternoon, and I think we agree that technical Soper 0osCIDnG OUTS aca maa urvlance esl, oon wih re Clams stu, wi Jo us papers describing our most recent medical surveillance results, along with the Claims study, will give us 0 fomawthwoound nas 0 suppor 1h safety of a gh xpos population segment 1 PFS the information we would need to support the safety of a highly exposed populalion segment to PFOS. By copy of is te am asking each department Lo eis hs metals or development ond By copy of this note I am asking each department to revise their timetables for development and Sham of cane papers, and 10 Sub toh by SEpL22. In evaofnth st Core eam submission of scientific papers, and to submit to me by Sept 22, in advance of the next Core team nosis Ths will ganda Rom or 0 een Sot 2.35 0 Spee meeting This will be an agenda item for the meeting Sept 26, as you suggest. Bacon Sano... Anayical & Environmental * BaconJ Santoro...... Analytical & Environmental *Bueno... Toxicology * Butenhoff......Toxicology "MandeL....Occ Mec *Mandel......Oct Med Dal 0d me Up tht Goi ha 0 eschedul is tM... 5 now Scheduled or Sap 2425 Dale told me this pm that Geisy had to reschedule his visit to 3M....it is now scheduled for Sept 28t29. Gale. wiyou con? Dale....will you confirm? Thanks Dove Thanks, Dave Chars Roch Charles Reich 7 Ccatnaatzeos0r0epnazA Charles Reich 09f08/2000 08:32 AM Exhibit 1740 SMMuaabddjeeecAAtvvataoliilPaarbbltleeecbbhyyv33oMMOrffodorerrIInnIssnppePeccattliioomnneaarvnn.dd3CChooppNyyoii.nngg63aass.0CC4oon8nf3ifi0dde3enntitiaall Infomatn: Information: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 1774400..00000011 aMAootssas 3MA00198538 susp Homans 3M Speci~l|y Material 220 13W38 i mons Tel: (6511 733-0439 Fox eh an Fax: (651) 575-8001 To: SGuEbject: TDRMLiKMohoacli:alolhcomrWhmahaeaeyRsasnpr.i.uspBi|)sAZnnoco&eDorcDSbriooalipRltUmnoPeUSoEs1SerTCsCoudoEorqUsUTprSuopACSgroaCoSarCipaAoeotohMerAmmUaA-oSatoULrIoSeMaroSngAMnoaLuUrSsysS Subject: DDaavvidi--d[CLCMM AA. SSaannddeerrsst/UUSS--CCoorrppoorraatteel3/M3MIU/USS@@33MM--CCoorrppoorraattee Michael A. SantorotUS-Corporatef3M/US Bill WeppneriUS-Corporate/3M/US Katherine E. ReedtUS-Corporate/3MtUS Thomas J. DiPasquale/LA-Legall3MIUS Michael I. DoughertyfUS-Corporate/3MIUS Larry R. Zobel/US Corporate/3M/US Dale L. Bacon/ET-ET&SI3M/US Re: manuscript ~1 Having ust road trough is pap, my reaction is a olows: The acs ars what thy are and Fm sure Having just read through this paper, my reaction is as follows: The facts are what they are and I'm sure ho cinco behind he (act dou. |{hk coofmna anuoge tends 0bo pg0ee of possi the science behind the facts is sound. I think some of the language tends to be suggestive of possible `hhaazzaarrddss aasssoscoiatcediwwaititthhtethhdeeffiinnddiinnggss,,wwhhiicchh ssppeeaakkss ttoo mmyy nneexxtt ppooiinntt.. TThhiiss ppaappeerr ppuubblliisshheedd wwiitthhoouutt aannyy ScCompaying paper of recat paper on he ealh and sail acors Known 0 ns Chemisty coud accompanying paper or predicate paper on the Health and safety factors known for this chemistry could Seacohin fecof sipecolalnon at Could eapethn issue wilh th eda an move 626k 0. set off a chain reaction of speculation that could reopen the issue with the media and move it back to a Heath ty SomGtingup1-hweohawve avoid. Therefore sce tome hat woshould Keep health stew,; something up-to-now we have avoided. Therefore, it seems to me that we should keep "our ckntic pUDICaLONS he right oder aswe had lady sree. Nowe | ciety unrstand hat "our" scientific publications in the right order as we had already agreed. Now, I clearly understand that someon ise may upsage ou lan. which speaks the needfo urgency to moveuy or publications. | someone else may upslage our plan, which speaks to the need for urgency to move up our publications. I Ue10 568 ur TAI Updaiod an DOV 10 Te xt Cot eam moctng on Sepramber 26. | would like to see our timetable updated and brought to the nexl core team meeting on September 26. I prosume Or Geis' wak Gone under contract 0-31 and thereloras wosronkly publshabi and presume Dr. Geisy's work is done under contract to 3M and therefore the work is only publishable if and nen we ogee. understand Dr Geis gency 0 be fst 10 pubis | ed in his wrk many years when we agree. I understand Dr. Geisy's urgency Io be first to publish ( I lived in his world many years 350%, but 4 com dita ur Umino, hawevar, we iso cant ly daly around hor Iwill a ago), but this can't dictate our timelines, however, we also can't dilly dally around either. II will take a rai deal of sensi and people Skt a ying Dr Gas around outhingon is and ote sure great deal of sensitivity and people skills to bring Dr. Geisy around to our thinking on this and to be sure Re oot misarre oorposton a ning 0 ds th wit. We us: anth wine nie bun. he doesn't misinterpret our position as trying to hide the winnie. We just want the winnie in the bun, compwilthmeusttaerd and ketchup. | assumethis wilbeHike Sanioros oboaccomptlhiisasskh. It complete with mustard and ketchup. I assume this will be Mike Santoro's job to accomplish this task. It Wil he lke fhe has clear cureofout publshing Uneine. will help Mike if he has a clear picture of our publishing timeline. These aro my thoughts onthe subject. |woud ke to have yours ASAP. We don necessarily have 1 These are my thoughts on the subject. I would like to have yours ASAP. We don't necessarily have to ver Goi Genki answerwhen ho1 hr on September 16, butwe shod bo prepared do so give Dr. Geisy a definitive answer when he is here on September 18, but we should be prepared to do so Sor fri Vl. Wo kd elco8 Comnc e o i ae our Stor2 cos eam shortly after his visit. We could likely come to a concensus on this matter at our September 26 core team meaing meeting croicn creich Onid-LOMA. Sanders David - LCM A. Sanders } Doug Low A Sanders David - LCM A_ Sanders 030620000458 09/06/2000 04:58 PM CareUers ochre 3M Corporate Life Cycle Management 3M Center. Bldg 220-9E-11 Te Tel: 651-733-5226 pea) Fax: 651 575 1989 TToo:: CChhaarrlleess RReeiicchht/UUSS--CCoorrppoorraatteel3/M3MIU/USS@@33MM--CCoorprpoorraattee MMiicchhaaecl AAl.. SSaannttoorrao//UUSS--CCoorrppoorraattee//33MM//UUSS@ @33MM-C-Coroproproarattee BBiillll WWeeppppnenre/riUUSS--CCoorrppoorraattee//33MM//UUSS@@3M3-MC-oCroproproartaete: Thomas. DiPasqu A-Leoal MUS Corporate Thomas J. DiPasquale/LA-Legalf3M/US@3M-Corporate KatharinaRoodUS-Coparte BMIUS@IM Corporate Katherine E. ReedlUS-Corporate/3MtUS@3M-Corporate LaryR. Zabol. CorporateMIUS@Cor3praMte Larry R. Zobel/USa3orporate/3M/US@3M-Corporate MSMuaabddjeeecAAtvvaiaoiialPabrbollteeebcbtyyiv33eMMOfrfooder rIInnIssnppePeccattiiomonneaavrnn.ddSCCMo,oppNyyoii.nngg62aa.ss0CC4o.on6nf3ifid0de0enntitiaall formation Information: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 11774400..00000022 MAcotessss 3MA00198539  Dall BacwEMUTS@EIMT-CoApoSne cc: Dale [. Bacon/ET-ET&SI3MIUS@3M-Corporate Sitcoms Subject: manuscripl Dal Bacon as confmedwith Joh ley hat he il come 3 an Sept 11910 view oa nd Dale Bacon has confin-ned with John Giesy that be will come to 3M on Sept 18-19 to review data and esata Sis poate OA stor. wl stm A es 2 resulls of his biosphere monitioring studies. Dale will set lhe meeting details asap. Rrachud 301k ana hf 5 wok 1 bt for UBC, Attached is a draft manuscript that Dr Giesy would like to submit for publication. Foryou tonom For your review CT Fonda byDoi LOMA.Sas Copco HS on090820000451 PM Forwarded by David - LCM A. SanderslUS-CorporatelgMIUS on 09/06/2000 04:51 PM 7 Sbaesltseonmozen Dale L Bacon 09/06/2000 04:02 PM wy ET&SS Env. Labs 2-3E-09 Tel: 778-4736 Fax: 778-5176 To Dad-GHEM A SandersUS-MUCSoQnIMp-aCoapotrssta To: =cc: joramp-- Subject: David - CHEM A. Sanders/US-Corporatel3M/US@3M-Corporate manuscript ee Fond byDl,BoconETETS HLS on000200005 PMwere Forwarded by Dale L. Bacon/ET-ET&Sf3MtUS on 0910612000 03:55 PM gy romano .................. JGiesy@aol.orn on 0812412000 04:16:06 PM To Dill BawETETASIUS@IM-Copone To: maa co: Sino. mover Subject: Dale L. BaconiET-ET&S13MIUS@3M-Corporate kuruntha@ pilot.msu.edu manuscript ---Dale: Attached is a draft manuscript I have prepared fo submision to Science. I ELL TR Re There is an error in Fig one that I will fix before submission. a ---- KeiLh 5olomon and Dezik Muir have au~[~itted a paper on sources to Nature. IL Sieh selon, sf urs debare pum pagesonsmo to Ben, Jt was rejected but they are now sending it to Science. I think it is important to publish our work before theirs. Otherwise, it looks ike we (ie 3M) was ee Sn oid sibiemees arian pressured into the investigations they have done and subsequent release of the data. Thus, I would like to get the papers sL~mitted as soon as ar DS SN RE Ra possible. Please have a look at Jt and get a r~view from the appropriate ERO ERA RE persons w~thin 3M. Please send me your edits and conm~enEs Lo be incorporated PERRO, before we su~[dt tile paper. soe you ox yo sont gprs. wd avssaose thank you for your continued support and assistance. Sincerely, J ---- your colleague and friend ote JPGiesy WSaedceAtvsaPbrloebcyi3e OrordoInnspbeactmaenravnd Coopying62a.0C4.o6n3t08ent nformtn Made Available by 3M for Inspection and Copying as Confidential Information: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 11774400..00000033 awsootssio 3MA00198540 103.It~] compro _ sciencepaper.doc M`MSaaudbdjeeecAAtvvataoiillPaarbbollteeecbbtyyiv33eMMOrffodorer rIInnIssnppePeccattliiomonenraavnn.dd3CCMoo,ppNyyoii.nnggC2aa-ss0CC4oo-n6nf3ifid0de0ennttiiaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn:: Subject to Protective Order In Palmer v. 3M, No. C2-04-6309 11774400..00000044 3MAD0198541 3MA00198541