Document 6bd4jzDx0wRKV3d9X3EMv3JVo
6106 EAST 32ND PLACE TULSA. OKLAHOMA 74135 (918) 665-1170 / TWX 910-845-2396
July 16, 1979
Mr. John Myers
Union Carbide Corporation
4625 Royal Avenue
*
Niagara Falls, New York 14302*
.. '
Dear John:
We understand that you are meeting with the Department of Transportation in Washington on July 19th. There will be a discussion of the pending regula tions covering the transportation of asbestos- This letter is in answer to your request for a review of asbestos applications in the drilling industry, with emphasis on material handling and transportation.
First we would like to establish that asbestos performs a valuable function
in drilling fluids. By providing desired levels of mechanical viscosity, cut
tings can be more adequately removed from the bore hole, with attendant im
provements in penetration rate and bit life. For proof of the efficacy of
asbestos in drilling fluids, one need look no further than the fact that users
have continued to buy the material since July of 1972, despite the powerful
negative incentive of stringent OSHA regulations.
.
Even the most desirable product will be rejected, however, if it is not con
sistently available at the right time, in the right place, and in the right
quantity. This is especially true in the drilling industry. With rig time
now costing in the tens of thousands of dollars per day, the logistics of
availability override virtually all other considerations. The problem of
product availability is exacerbated by the fact that, with rare exceptions,
rig locations are remote from all routine warehousing facilities and trans
portation.
'
The use of asbestos in drilling fluids differs substantially from its uses in most other industrial applications. There, shipments frequently involve carload or truckload lots from a source mill to the end user's plant. (Even in smaller lots, delivery of less than a pallet load would be rare.) On arrival at the point of use, the product becomes part of a fairly continuous and predictable flow of raw material through the manufacturing facility. Implicit in every order for materials is the expectation of their complete consumption in making finished goods.
In the drilling industry the delivery of material to the "plant" (drilling rig) is much more complex. A carload originating at the source mill will
UCC 009260