Document 6b8xE6g9oN4zYrRy9y1dyB9qR
Hooker's Wilkenfeld (standing) discusses environmental research with operating personnel.
A day on the ecology front
In typical workday, a chemical company's pollution control expert gathers technical data that he relays to colleagues
What's a typical week in the field for a chemical company's director of envi ronmental health? Take Hooker Chem ical's Jerome Wilkenfeld, who flew into Buffalo, N.Y.,. to visit the company's Niagara Falls plant after conferring ear lier in the week with Dow Chemical pollution control specialists in Midland, Mich., and advising on plant operations at Hooker's Detroit plant.
That's a thumbnail sketch of the kind of activities chemical companies' pollu tion control executives are involved in day to day (CW, June 29, '68, p. 48).
"My function," says Wilkenfeld, "is
to offer technical services in the pollu tion control field--such as legal, ana lytical and design information--to those with operating responsibility. To go fur ther than that is a mistake. After all, the plant manager is already responsible for costs, safety and efficiency, and he should be accountable for pollution control also."
Wilkenfeld, to gain information he passes on to his colleagues, belongs to a multitude of government and industry organizations and reads voraciously on the subject of pollution. He is helping to develop a new compu`"'- ^meram for
pollution control, spends a lot of time "bugging" plant managers and some times goes directly to Hooker's chair man of the board.
Round of Activities: On his latest trip to Niagara Falls (where the company has its largest plant complex), Wilken feld inspected two major pollution con trol projects, was briefed on pollution control research projects at the com pany's nearby Grand Island technical services center, and had a breakfast meeting with the manager of. the Hooker plant at Taft, La., and the pol lution control specialist from Hooker's plant at Columbia, Tenn.
The two big new pollution control projects at Niagara Falls: an $800,000 diversion sewer (90% complete) that will extend 400 ft. out into the Niagara River, carrying some 20 million gal./day of cooling water that had gone to the city's overburdened waste-treat ment plant; and a 3,200-ft.-deep dis-
40 CHEMICAL WEEK March 11, 1970
DSW 552106
.___ With Bird, Wilkenfeld plans " pollution control by computer.
STLCOPCB4090523
'-
' X/v
ENGINEERING
Lead's loss
could be
coal's gain
Aromatics in syncrude from
cuai MgiIWveA Sitt Mpti>oAiViMuMumm venue
If the lead comes out of gasoline (p. 13). synthetic liquid fuels from coal-- which are rich in naphthenic and aro matic hydrocarbons--may be in big de mand as high-octane blending stocks. Conservative pricing would peg the value of such materials at $4/bbl., but this is bound to rise with a shift in em phasis to nonleaded gasolines.
Another important factor working in favor of coal: a projected paucity of new domestic natural gas supplies. Thus, producer gas (35-45% com bustibles, consisting mostly of carbon monoxide, hydrogen and methane) could be generated from coal char to augment dwindling reserves of natural gas.
Commercial COED: Cheered by these two "plus" factors, R. Tracy Eddinger, director of FMC's Project COED (Char Oil Energy Development) at Princeton, N.J., updated the process economics of a commercial-scale COED plant at last month's Denver meeting of the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical Engineers (CIV, Feb. 25, p. 20).
Flowsheets have been developed for processing 3.5 million tons/year of Utah A-seam coal (10,600 tons/day, 330 operating days/year). Assumption: a portion of the COED product gas will be used for process heat.
Coal would be crushed and dried, then pyrolized in several stages. The product charge is sent to an electrical power plant. The raw oil and gases are separated. Next, the gases are reformed with steam to produce hydrogen, and a portion of the hydrogen is used to hy drotreat the oil. Liquid product is a syn thetic crude oil suitable for con ventional petroleum refining. Excess hydrogen can be sent to an ammonia plant or to an oil refinery.
Three Options: Eddinger offers three options in the economic analysis (table).
Economics of synthetic fuels from coal
Case
Product gas Process fuel
1
Hydrogen Gas
II
Fuel Gas Gas
III
Hydrogen Char
Investment (million $> Fixed capital Working capital, at 7%
Total
36.17 2.53 38.70
32.70 2.29 34.99
44.65 3.13 47.78
Manufacturing COStS (million $/year) Coal, @ $3/ton Oxygen, @ $6/ton Utilities Taxes, insurance, depreciation, maintenance Labor, supplies, overhead
Total
10.50 1.73 1.70 4.34
1.20
19.47
10.50 1.73 1.39 3.93 1.20
18.75
10.50 1.73 2.36 5.36 1.44
21.39
Product values and profits (mimon $,yean
Char, @ $2.75/ton
4.78
Oil, @ $4/bbl.
18.80
Hydrogen, @ 25c/1,000 cu. ft.
3.90
Fuel gas, @ 11,8c/million Btu.-
--
Total 27.48
4.78 18.80
--
0.87 24.45
3.33 18.80 11.70
_
33.83
Advertising, sales, research expense
1.38 1.22 1.69
Net sales value Gross profit Net profit, at 50% tax rate
26.10 6.63 3.31
23.23 4.48 2.24
32.14 10.75 5.38
Return on investment (percent)
Before taxes
17.1 12.8 22.5
Discounted-cash-flow method
13 10 16
Basis: Commercial plant processing 3.5 million tons/year of Utah A-seam coal, operating 330 days/year. Source: Project COED. FMC Corp.
Case I assumes that the process gas is upgraded to hydrogen and that part of the process gas is used as process fuel. For Case II, only sufficient hydrogen is made to hydrotreat the oil. A portion of the process gas, as in Case I, is sold as a fuel gas at coal value. Eddinger sets this at 11.8C7million Btu.
In the third case, all the process gas is upgraded to hydrogen. A portion of the product char is gasified to producer gas and used as process fuel.
Product Values: Product char is cred ited at 90% of coal cost, based on gross heating value ($2.75/ton instead of $3/ton).
Hydrotreating studies have been car ried out on COED oil by ARCO Chem ical Co. as part of its Project Seacoke. On the basis of this work, and consid ering the unique character of the oil as far as aromatic content is concerned, Eddinger estimates that it has a value of
at least S4/bbl. The syncrude oil has no
sulfur in it and lacks a residuum frac
tion.
Therefore, Eddinger reasons, as lead
is phased out of gasoline, syncrude val
ues could rise from $4/bbl. to perhaps
almost $5/bbl. Endorsements of this op
timism are hard to come by..Rex Elling
ton of Atlantic Richfield's fuel labora
tories in Dallas, Tex., sees the octane
content of syncrude oil as a potentially
important property.
For the record, Atlantic Richfield's
position is that while the company is-
continuing its research in this area, liq
uid fuels from coal are not looked upon
as a near-term answer to the octane
question.
Industry observers suggest that any
other comment from oil companies at
this time might prejudice the posture
they've taken in Washington on the
subject of unleaded gasoline.
END
March 11, 1970 CHEMICAL WEEK 39
DSW 552107
STLCOPCB4090524
DSW 552108
STEPPED-EIViD PASTED VALVE
Available in 10 daysGuaranteed delivery from
LITTLE ROCK AND DES MOINES!
Why be back-ordered on steppedto 8
weeks! Our own fleet of trucks will deliver to your docks in 10 days (after print approval). Guaranteed, delivery by Great Plains Bag Com pany, manufacturers of:
Sewn Open Mouth Sewn Valve--------
Pasted OpeH Mouth Pasted Valve Pinch Bottom Polyethylene - heavy duty
plain and printed
CALL COLLECT:
Des Moines, Iowa (515) 283-2041 Little Rock, Arkansas (501) 982-1573
GREAT PLAINS BAG COMPANY
Home office - 2201 Bell Avenue Des Moines, Iowa 50315
SODIUM SULPHATE
(Anhydrous)
SALT CAKE
pmoR\
1 Chemical Corporation
420 Lexington Avenue Phone: 212-532-9811 New York, N. Y. 10017
42 CHEMICAL WEEK March 11, 1970
SAME-DAY SHIPMENT
OF ISOOCTVL AND ISODECYL ALCOHOLS
We can ship them the day you order them, even if it's today. Any day of the year. Your own phone is the Houdry Hotline for fast service: just pick it up, order, and we'll have a bulk shipment on its way to you in hours from our plant in Delaware City, Del.
Chemical Sales Department, Houdry, Division of Air Products and Chemicals, Inc., 1339 Chest nut Street, Philadelphia, Pa.19107.
FOR SAMPLES. QUOTATIONS, OR SHIPMENT. CALL:
HOUDRY HOTLINE
(215) 568-6000
FOR EMERGENCIES AFTER NORMAL BUSINESS HOURS, (215) 236-8004.
ENVIRONMENT
posal well, for certain type acid wastes.
With Nickerson Hinckley, works
manager, and Fred Olotka, technical
supervisor for the environmental pro
grams for Hooker's industrial chemicals
division, Wilkenfeld examined core
samples that have been taken on the
well site. But now it appears some of
that acid waste stream might be salable.
Ernest Gedeon, assistant commis
sioner of environmental health for the
Niagara County health department,
joined Wilkenfeld and Olotka on an in
spection of the two pumping stations
and control apparatus for the company
diversion project.
When the state power authority di
verted the river's flow to build an in
take, three local industries, including
Hooker, installed effluent outfalls into
the river. The idea was that the city
would upgrade its waste-treatment
plant, and the plant's cooling waters
(which don't have to be treated) could
be diverted directly into the river.
Research Round: At the company's
technical services center, Wilkenfeld
was briefed on developments in effluent
control research by D. Bruce Merrifield,
Hooker's director of research.
Together they viewed the work being
supervised by chemist Sung Ki Lee.
Wilkenfeld describes the project as
"very promising," involving "a method
of oxidizing materials in solution."
With M.O. Bird, manager of techni
cal information systems, Wilkenfeld
talked of his project for computerizing
the quantities of information needed for
efficient management of the company's
pollution control efforts.
Back Home: On the wall of his New
York office is a picture of Wilkenfeld
shaking hands with former President
Johnson. The occasion: signing of the
'67 Clean Air Act. Wilkenfeld--as chair
man of the Air Quality Committee of
the Manufacturing Chemists' Assn.-
had testified three times at hearings.
Wilkenfeld has also been chairman of
MCA's Water Resources Committee,
member of the New York State Air Pol
lution Control Board, and a member of .
the advisory committee of the Con
servation Foundation.
For Jerome Wilkenfeld each day is
different. But like all chemical industry
pollution control specialists, every day
is aimed at the same goal: under
standing among industry, government
and the public, and achievements to
meet a real need.
END
DSW 552109
STLCOPCB4090526