Document 5k9K0QXGxkBx1Mz2L6e13BwdR

: rT ~ E~v~ronme~.a| Laboratory SSRRCaaeeomsmsmupupplllltateessnssffyrFFrorroFmoamocmmiAAlnitnthtahayelelyyiEEssn..eePssIIa.. rooDDkfluueSSPProoosoinbilnltutaardndgn,eedd GNGreroomuuonnuddrwwsaatatenerrd WNeesmtoVuirrsgianniad Company Facility in Parkersburg, West Virginia STUDYCOMPLETED:Griber SF'OrUADLYRCEOPOMRPTLCEOTEMDPL: EOTcEtoDb:er 27.1997 Moves 27. 1997 13.1037 FiliAL F~EPORT'COMPLE-I=EO=: November 13, 1997 pvRows. samo Ao Buch r aryiSE te om ororos2sigan onetp Sr5= 77| CCCOOONNNFFFIIIDDEEENNNTTTIIIAAALLL--.SSUUSBUBBJJJEEECCCTTT1TT0OOAAA PROTECTIVE PROTECTIVE OROER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000011 ExhibIi>t 22775599 State of Minnesota v. 3M Co., Court File No. 27-CV-10-28862 _UNC0043306 3M MN00043306 0 Eonar Laborer Tablo of Contents Table ot Contents Sumner ot Rosas: [rp-- 5 . POA Anais in Grunaed ri(597Sopls: POA ArsinyGrsundaiatser(697Samplos): 1" POR Analysies piniCSoOlv.No(St8A7imnSGyampsrleos():s37sSbaymPoursge 352 2 VolatiosbyAED(57 Samples): =5a Volios by AED (897 Samp): ot Fh n 6 (657 Samp) = ro, rp ndAdobe RionGrourer667Sang) 64 G5opiPorsoopfoGtiaisnanodf Cutshteordys,CSiapnpcianngaPoanasr,(6L5a7bSafpapks) "10s a4 CCDIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRL-T- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000022 aM_N0004307 3M MN00043307 Aill.imE be i! io He HH | 0t iiiiikREiE 34 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000033 3M MN00043308 npp n | Ei pEg ine iil HHRhEiMd|m MetE ei6d iket l pi Leoeo I lie Bas LeIHe RE CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2759.0004 3M MN00043309 3 FEVERERRERE BEEEEEE ih ] bBpo Ru HH ar y "ig FERRER| 1h i BbEbbeEERbEEReEES || HF~5o2 Ll i : Rin FEEFEEEER R| PEEPrEEEREH| CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2775599..00000055 3M MN000433t0 a0 Emini aboraory Project Description Description hr cookswoereieicocYaopmEi.LfCo uarytedosNyemou0rs1aEndnCroomnpmoanniyal Three coole~ were received trom r'.t. DuPont de a ou yas seg an nsprojectsomber(Lab ("~Po~. each co,~(~ ~les for a~ io. Esch Samplewooali ginan Ur Furor ichWas ~mto~, E~h ~]~mup W~ a~g~d Dpe ole monn Thapojct rome55 rlowos: R~est Nu~r). ~h =~ ~s a~ 91~n ~a un~e ~m~r W~ was a ~set of~e p~ hUmOr ~e pmj~ num~m Rooos,ssopies 16 es are 1wate irk nd on sf amps, wth R2008, s~mp~es Four groundwaters, one DI water b~nk and one soft sample, w~th SEER ars) andS037 sampl~ dates 5/0/97 (waters) ~ 5/30/97 (soil). Raves, campos n112ato sme,wih sampledoof67577 . R2t48, samples 1-12 Twe~ grout~dwater samples, w~th a sample d~te of 6/26/97 RestoEaipestl1s:1a1rpls, wih ampledaoof 2357 R2382, sample 1-11 Eleven soil samples, with a sampl~ date of 6/23~J7 DSta~momprlprleetssgworoerursepsssotworireeddc1sahte41sI"Ga0,,eiiEnittnhhesoodunarmrk,m, uaurnitilapaaonvbatarhysjzizeeordfda..weyroemsosf FsON,or ~ ~ tasAo~nh3~r4areitp~arstcuoam otmS~vamot~leneasnsdmanCra~ icoons tvoole~s.~,ur~s,. p= su~, ~ ~l~ ~d sorl pH, ~t mol~re ~ ~zmn e tgs 3MA00230134 D`CICSOOTNRNFIFICIDTDEENCNTOTIIUAARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7.TTCTTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000066 3SMH_MNN000000443331t311 aEniroomenal Laboraory PPOOAAAA AAnnaallyysseess iinn GGrroouunnddwwaatteerr aanndd SSooiill ((55//9977 SSaammpplleess)) 74128 D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000077 3W_MN00043312 3M MN000433t2 3M EEnnvviirroonnmmeennttaall lL~ahboorraatt~orryy DDaattaa TTrraansum~iftait~allSSuummmmaarryy [pehies = poasCisr: Reeo"msCivoemtuopmmeeaDineys Companpes euptLLoosnetr: iKimsHeosnn((10512590)) Daoir TewtiMeoedchTOM. Sa Dic 71197 ArGo 8 bam. jcecLkondoordn eorsdigen .se. DuaReever: - = prcany RNM(Sceamt:s:gscepeec Ir.Diba,2o2s18-i5,F1o891 36A32b57 PrTF SHoeat1021u57e k~ on 10/2Iig7 WSraennTeur spym s a ee hel cp cpibe enAT,Ld ER 84125 DCCIOOSNTNFRFIIIDDCETENNTCTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-10AA.PP26RR8OO5TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN COUNTY. HENNEPIN'COUNT~' DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000088 W_1N000K3313 3M MN000433t 3 \ E rren =Advanced Met thpmentTeam t ma e DeeperrstmAPinOAin5psStctdy oWatner E oe me re otahsete sdinrtotycmDaiynCwol t tnASS mset, t ETT TC et onTOAosn ks Gr pTpeE ma]e i Fie E=HE =E EEE | [ole] EEA EE EAE 5 wr ole) [ala] SS arm ee 20nTtSesTrAsTaIzeOnNsSs sve iadom eT. ot sora EINAwRTeIrSessdtc oe O Dh atee raet SatE eiinemT yioeomtea= t osromilr odsd m.= r I -- zoe. '- SCOONNFFDIDEENNTITIAALL - SSUUBBIJEECCTT TO 1A0.4PPRROOTTEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00000099 W_UNGO0A314 3M MN000433t4 P e S ts amL ro eie m E e he iems tn Sma E E e mEE E aRt E EL R n E mpct o0m e ne po r eE m E gerir sorT A ta sone PE S Se oEr rE r R ree r l rs EeToeCominGONenfe pecwoceredlt 3 bd TIT rf=rioened A ro 2=mmcsn E E2Es y R. b=e e EEe fEor rt o= mtvts ame wr . 10 4135 CONFIDENTIAL SUBJECT T0A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED I HENNEPIN CO DCDIOISSNTTFRRIIIDCCETTNCCTOOIAUURLRT-T,S, UNNOBO.J.E22C77--TCCTVVO--1100A--2P288R88O6522TECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNNTTYY 22775599..00001100 33MM_MMNNO00O0403433135t5. t54iEoSnApSAeneiolmFoor csopochmgVdea, 1.VHonn sPkPa10n0isSe ees enSFh. eewsiunmo HECSonrTmtei2r%e 2 fresher d Sae S ot a E rswoeTdenSfe eTgrisaa pact iety ee tsoos sine 40 paraavars tet mien,tt ATOM t EEI EET maEmn er. TANI 42 Samper pC o Te ognos ts yo PfOMencpi0mg npmymceomdpecn Leic ames em, GfmC erorTOo My n pt) I a T Se ec T-- e iinrdnb itvo td 8 rindet ge Germ waGEyCCraOPOm AMJetteno egtpnn)) Br etVien Resor Tp 5 ng3 1a6 3MJ~,00230139 I `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-'10-28862 22775599..00001111 W_MN00043316 3M MN000433t6 EIEErI eE crcrn sre ro - "s S E E pE e S E in E n mnt reecs ea:ts en Ea omen eB E mmse timtstrim--ir-- s ee itsity hrmts tmms FEee] it Ee 0.~59 L~ E E rR e E te, 1,3 oTaRn EE.. fo mmsme. seas . 124128 CfONFrIDEeNTItAL SUBJECT TOA PROTECTIVE OROER ENTERED I HENNEPI COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001122 nem 3M MN000433t7 = m ron -- EE e --EMis~of Fy Soll 2.0 O.Ol 0.10 0_20 [E52] 2~ mm em] eer [Em i414@4 5.00 475017 ~4g_97 74~9 $136166 58"/9b"32. Bus. an mon i = EaE ns CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-'10-28862 22775599..00001133 3M MN000433t 8 YOM SRmaaertpCaorreesndDtasnTbe nnn atep-- t -- ekArr eCoc ROA -rg Co t-- rorrt|in x [E2N] = JF]AR = |arEY, - fPyy" ---- Fo m? ox t1x a - --# eck bterre ebre retdee br rioted oesget mie I--A -- eb eteeAe.oe ATO Et strazmnm 2emein nPOn M mh ehs 4s DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLLT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTV-OO10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001144 3aM_NMoN00000443333t19 a vier Letty ~ i:nvironmer~l. Laboratory POAA POAA Analyses Analyses in in GGrroouunnddwwaatteerr ((66t9977 SSaammpplleess)) 154 ns BCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDGCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7.TTC\TT-OO1AA0.PP8RRO8OT8TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERE~D IN IN HENNEPIN HE~NEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001155 aw_unooosszzo 3M MN00043320 on 33MM EEnnvviirroonnmmeennttaall LLaabboorraattoorrvy DaDattaaTTrraanns~mmitltfiaall SSuummmmaarryy Soo.e ee [Ee fori. ~ or son tenie - iuge, T meyn S =eiernA sso fe-- es, I = -- ~aAA t~ veen IEE Dem = A saa --------------------------w--g CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001166 3M MN00043321 ScEintpepiE eemaesyna eL neteren Finali~ort -L~bRetestN~148 E E 2 T E mE a EERE EEE Ee LT ~tmpk# TET eel F E EEEE E EE T[a] [E EE aiEan-aren Cr REE Es R ECEEEAE ERE PY vase se i w~ v~ 6.0 P,~ Fo 3MA00230]4~ CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..000017 3M MN00043322 sPLw mTRcEnas ta PATROAL These sm~ple~ were checked-ln ~ ]I~2148-! through 12 a~d ~ rEnemr owsae n 31TovestigativeSamples - mma orp S S a E Ep almmteo stTtEL ecE eeR cs se E iacror s e esea t can tce 3A la~tram~lafien TE etteseent "1~ following ~ eon~.eas w~used to +--o_S--E EtfFE SE ES p FoeceehE m-- ynnm rr io s.,enm e eieerbinwrire w~0t,dVo'si~&D CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001188 3M MN00043323 3sJc6oeDnosTsdehsnicnllhtceiidpmensctceoe.TioceFM0DLn4k5cFd TpPceLmdepdmseosohndebooov5 Tsp 4DATA ALYSS DATA ANALYSIS 2 Catrina ~ 4~! Calibrathm Curve - t vege em k es em ne s oeenwefn podd. Bitet ctocta Av~p~k ~ ~om th~ i~i~ ~m~w~epi~d~g~ the 200. Th4e42AeCcC eoCoononcnttriig~inagoC Caeom~lihob tao~ ennSmsemitbtsiomvde omyiimd30 oadnsttinet veHry 0tT repre ne sed be rng RI owtopno --- %D = whos,R5i0 0i2e5pecrc rtroeendfm il tin RL 5 en etoetdfm hecigction tmp Smtr 31CCorleoeuons sfsmcionpets ver my ofdetectedpeak eas othecalibration.curveusingthefollowingforms: a aret on P-I "CT1Pi-$aPocaknkt~aasoefbt~eacea~sttallnr ~toentcnape otena-- ctgh Wetviiaca Weed V~e 6.~ was P,2 I4~.IX~ nresss CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.T0TTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO5T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00001199 an_uNcoosaze 3M MN00043324 =Slopeof decatceavneLign) CTohnercoantcinotntiiotnhoewfaatnercipvlepsebyfcirgocenonfiibe exatcitnw:as coveted oh EGqumatiCoon x gDn=DCiCootnnacsieentsFtsiiaoonrnooffssemric ppeeo'rssoticinvascarnscsa(fptosls)pial) D ffi Diluti~?t F~or LAsaT rne rPu=1mp67077s5ioSn8i149331p398em0rgt2m,et8n.5LanT9to757i;eomilwoosb deicgdEic nsqpnl c 2vR,aCE,o, nLGEyqmu)in. 0,C, 0785 yal nd = 2 hs 0285 fal 20-571 P4eMarMtoasuiSspikeeeSRasemcppolveeesryewreosscklyiectowdienermoeodem ovcepyuosfs:nore Equations r= Ceooon wher,4Pecotrecovery ofscionpsoooconste C=DecoCeceation fame pcwesocnat aMSspl splCGoa=lABv)eercatgeabcckopnrcotva:toconneofmtsrmtmioonnoifmspstiorpoosseoMmSssssspa Got) Assnexheppecetev, eryfortheR2IALMS2s1p,e lied CCLCco.-mo=0om05.0p4034ap~plgaim;tnLt;;s Bthoe~roexe,, %8R==((00.4044-00.040)/00.05030xx0]0o00o-~5,8~00S%03.~ Wet iri Wet,d V~ 6.0 saranoc EPesXactEs C`DICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUALRLT-- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER EENNTTEERREEDD IN IN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002200 33MW_MMNN0000004433232255 PThreoersetemtovseofseni patrons beMS MDsep - la~.sentcd in Table Tabl~ 2 [Pe er RELIST oar [Gr] Rec1ordns ecoo nrm -- caocdoo ondcn rtee neee dmle 50ncionTrceueeunsidisDooneEcStAwS cy ce2iaSngm shRe48o1eefvor Da082orns, o4f01654m%irn,e3pyon.02T4ee02s5 ea,7 rn2peT. 60MHArd oIpNeOnTFRd EAWDNAdTAAANNDARMECDCTOREDSrn. 70Arpimmiceenssect chs ihto They etlbeAMDT 2 LCorm T e C.ems : Taken 1c wa tein --_--_-- pss agi swezores 3MA0023014~ II ] 11 i u, DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLL.T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1AA02PP8RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002211 3aMM_NM0N000004433332256 Wn Emionmortal Laboratory POAA POAA Analyses Ana|yses iinn SSooiill ((66/19977 SSaammpplleess)) 2d ns ill ill I D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6T2tEECCTTIIVVEE'OORRDDEERR ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002222 3W_MN00043327 3M MN00043327 Gourt ReporMMtEioRnERgI"LLLRoLgLaEElGGRVAAiLdLeSISoOgOUrULaLLpTThIIyOOLTNNrSaSil Services Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trai! Services Pages| Page] Page 5 Page 7 . INDEX) 1 THEVIDEOGRAPHER: Worm onth 1 I N D E X (cent_) 2 2 recor. Horabeginstao numberone n he 2 3 owors 3 Gaposon ofCrayCorgan ho mtr 3 EXHIBITS 3 a oron ronson zn| 4 IOS Puen Kern Putnam 4 Duress ey,rc Kian,poivnerstus s 5 No. 42 - PFOA DuPont Meeting Talking Points 228 7 Mohreii s Com7 aEnckom4 Ceomnmtea0 mmoncenent201 223. | 6 Comprany,oo.cos nar 2.046309.: Wo are on 6 No. 43 - Corrigan appointment announcemen! 229 ] aren & 7 tha tor,and day's atofs February27, 7 No. 44- 7-8-03 E-mail Gebhard to Wiler 241 8 No. 45 - 3-27-03 Letter OoGrady 244 eS hemo "+ 2 | 3 08 Theimeissosam. Tho secs 9 No. 46- 9-t0-03 Memorandum Karnowski 247 10 No.7 3304 Emer ns = 5 a aking lace FusiSokn, 1551 10 No. 47- 3-3-04 E-m~il Santoro 252 11 No. 4841Er3o S0am4os Go |10 NohWater Parkway, Sots 100, Wich, 11 No. 48 - 4-13-04 E-r~aii Santoro 256 12 No. 4.PrPrae sks 204 1 Kansas 67205 12 No. 49 - Pioneer Press Article 264 13 No. 80-21705 EmaSega ns 12 Wlcoluoosnsdeiity 13 No. 50 - 2-17-05 E-mail Siegel 273 4 Noonsr.csA1s FA [13 yuom se iwe 14 No. 51 - Ioxic I rsces Article 275 15 No 2 Eneringm Gooa Later Z61 | 13 ngwines wihtSworn 15 No. 52- Environmental Working Group Letter 281 1 eSoIsEEnMConner 2 (15 MR BLOT. Fabietlor 16 No. 53 - 5-13-05 E-mail Corrigan to Olieei 286 17 No. 54 - Sta~l Tribune Editorial 293 ne Emanmens sop [16 Sat.Ardscorcton. ho 18 No. 5,5- 10=28-g5 E-mail Nelson to Reed 300 10 No55"EnmrneGens11s 1505. 02| isSM Comper 19 No. 56 - Environmenta! Working Group 11-18-05 302 =20 No.715508 matRages wr 1[18 ComparMyR.ASHLEY. Cooper Ashley or 20 No. 57- 12-b-0b E-ton!! Rageth 305 21 z 120 MeARbSTRONG: im Aman or 22 2 rearuorpeRoDsuCTsION 21 ones. 23 REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION 22 te. 1-010 homie 2 72 SHERYL CORRIGAN, 24 No, 1 -401(k) information 22 2 ELEY oar ASsOCk ATES LID. | 73 havenbenfr cyswoon aroan 25 KELLEY, YORK & ASSOCIATES, LTD. = CounRepo winOrcs 24. sot he vt. howhol tun,an nothing 126 Court Reporting with a Difference _ Gemremoie 25onetinesifesssiolons| {316) 267-8200 (800) 654-8684 t THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are on the 2 record. Here begins tape number one in the 3 deposition of Cheryl Corrigan in the matter 4 of Gary Paulson, Karen Paulson, William 5 Henry, Bradley Krank, plaintiffs versus 3M 6 Company, case number C2-04-6309. We are on 7 the record, and today's date is February 27, 8 20D8. ]he time is 9:04 a.m. The deposition 9 is taking place at Foulston Sielkin, 1551 10 Nodh Wateffronl Parkway, Suite 100, W~chita, 11 Kansas 67206. 12 Will counsel please identify 13 yourselves and stale who you represent, and 14 the w~tness will be sworn. 15 MR. BILOTT: Rob Bilo~ for 16 plaintiffs. And just a correction, the 17 defendant is 3M Company. 18 MR. ASHLEY; Cooper Ashley for 3M 19 Company. 20 MR. ARMSTRONG: Jim Armstrong for 21 the witness. 22 SHERYL CORRIGAN, 23 having been first duly sworn on her oath to 24 state the truth, the whole truth, and nothing 25 but the truth, tesli~es as follows: Pages| Pages| Page 6 Page 8 ' INDEX(cont) 1 evr: 1 I N D E X (cont.) 1 BY MR. BtLOTT: 2 2 Q Gocdmonig 2 2 Q. Good morning. 5 SGNAOTF WUITRNEESS | 5 A Gaamomi 3 SIGNATURE OF WITNESS 322 3 A. God morning. 3 CERTIFICATE 323 | 4 Q. ly nomRoebBist. Asyouust herd 4 CERTIFICATE 323 4 O. My name is Rob Bile& As you just heard, 5 monsoftho tomoysroresoninhgo 5 5 I'm one of the attorneys representing the s plas nhcos otdescrbwhdic,h 6 6 plaintiffs in the case just described, which 7 7 aor A Poison,tol.versustho 7 7 is Gary A. Pau[son, et al. versus the 3M 8 Company acaso Caran pending insito 8 8 Company, a case currently pending in state 9 5 comtinNimesotn 9 9 coud in Minnesota. 0 10 Woutyousityour name pase 10 10 Would you slate your name. please. n 11 A. ShAmeCringan 11 11 A. SherylAnn Corrigan. 2 12. And areyoucurentyemployed? 12 12 Q. And are you currently employed? Io 13 A Yos.lom 13 13 A_ Yes, lam. 140. Andwyohueomplooyerdwiot? 14 14 Q. And who are you employed with? is 15 A Koohinaatios 15 15 A. Koch Industries. 16 0. AdTaliKOCsH? 16 16 Q. And is that K-O-C-H? TA Yeme 17 17 A. Yes, ills. 80. omarlcaiodhere th lo afyour 18 18 (3. ts that Iocaled here o~ the place of your 19 emplolcateodhayeimWhei,nKnstas? 19 19 employment located here in Wichita, Kansas? 2 2 A Thatscomet 20 20 A_ That's correcl_ 2 210. vinasyourbusinessadress? 21 ;i 21 Q. What is your business address? 2 KELLEY,YORK &ASSOCIATELTSD,. [22 A. igetmybusinesscardct 22 KELLEY, YORK & ASSOCIATES, LTD. 22 A. tll get my business card out. 2 2 Q okay. 23 23 Q. Okay. 2 CounRapowitrhaiifneengce (24 A. 4111Eat37hStet Neth,Vii,Kansas 24 Court Reporting with a Difference 24 A. 4111 East 37th Street North, Wichita, Kansas 2 Goro estan 25 oro 25 (316) 267-8200 (800) 654-8684 :25 67220_ 2100 3rd Avenue North, Suite S60BieminghamA,1 35205 2(Pages 5108) 2100 3rd Avenue North, Suite 960*Birm[ngham, AI 35203* 1.800.3880EPO 1-800-888-DEPO 2 (Pages 5 to 8) D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLE-T-N,SSTUNUOBBI.JJEAE2CC7L-TTCTTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002233 SM_UN00043328 3M MN00043328 Mf 3M EnvEirnvoinromnmeenat~alILl~abboorraattoory Se re=ss aa 2 i RaE ST Prmvin. s ~po~r o~ C&m~: --- Pibo-- lad Gamaninry DSE -- r EEs-- aman Lfo r:ineiirastanmit,h, I bo, = e raignSse i immscstrl L D~Paaquale, 22-IIE~03: `Sea/Dtu:e pee ~ent b~. / [hte et rn dt hee eeOU mt. 5 gus COTNFRIDENCToIAtLkTSUNBoJECT TOiA oPROsTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..0000224 Sonneszzs 3M MN00043329 3A aMnEnni vaiareo.ndm mpeentne apl Lhad beTomrustory- AdvancedMethodDevelopmentTeam mfeianst DetermiRneatpioornotfAPuOsXtA nSiSnd0ydWater "Labrequest Raz 21k0 SFoOmNRaYrTiyhesisywlrrsrbctetmyDtitRpEirrhss1.ofhoahsctis. i. C neke ryietTeOAeRtsAcLEnAvre5i8tcmhewedtgbyTeOiLrdlkeic hdbiseyT,sheAst eEcTm in fe iepad besodtenwi, Se TCieoroOm MA a E101 n mi, Rf coi fon 10m (0701 h0eTrPeTswT cepeswecChfmDn cnAG TewmedaCs 28 rE ex AroMETHORS EitdoE crovves c dtby enie g oc pesmtv PrOV MikreBli tDsidtBhet odDkep.dtf.rTaOtM iianmrnd.ihoptmdeLye7vo|TcnoefrdSmnopg Wcnhrheeokidteagcio1nd0Te,Di)iedi Eo iCamco (ry wi (ry a. T LodiVebine6 r sasunoc ' 24 4 nas `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARAL-TL-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY. COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002255 3M_MN00043330 3M MN00043330 Aeedi peecadTVoS. aeedtebbae(Ab,mrpc, em dntfd vaarnek a1r)Aenae | TE OGN araE ein1 rC eendg veys:eFodmtn miaeb,ricse SA TiTOAArsoftspi rst oees gs drt me nTt e E loodre ebboteehevssehco inhhtescmsao emisimt Tt ETL 1Has BISCO pMcehigssoe gniee 1500o3g548Arioedeinesemaid EEooninin oepm.e tTwoena 1pe SB rEEe m we[e=n ms = mph wocnt os vlwi LC deACN dQ ot. 0moSne Amriang te i 3] t togonPi A hB eio sm iA s RFoLioT kri AiRnaO. ) E moay n o.2 Steopeaaonrnetc nt A T sttiveapeeS eTrdmoegtemendncpeed7 miecede un R tm d re 6 rubibntietald. EEecotanmcosFrOheNymetofe Ee03ieBnp hrt h s1Ai ee E m iciti aE3n0 eni ceepad ehFL.CA A inte Wo~'d V~]o~ &.O R,~ZIX~ 2 25 4138 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002266 3_MN00043331 3M MN00043331 a 52 concumonnemat cto Ehbi db TiEe E tee t 42 aR pvoramBANR TA CRacEORDS EE - etveimes was ji Srsriin > a 4138 III CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002277 aM_Noo0saz32 3M MN00043332 RE"DAavppeonodtSize Dats ExDt tetseSadeAsosCBE Spl iomftek praiSnbAy OetMrSsrmrCofencadrm ar ethen5e0 Sp Sohh ey rn ex te be pe. nomen ise xe Sp ntmmentviebelts. mxsunanson Spit (oka re Rep = BdCo, TOMA 50. Be Oren.sm-a1s wt Sr be[ntro eTOMepnrDinrr) nk Co pa. seis tecarnd Spt MdeCocr(TgOdAt D h Ed Crop dt 1795. gh mg =Tm TONN Sot AMT Co TOMdd ke d=Tl medFOMA (04) pe. Coarmpig g-ami ets Comin roewen soma arg 125 wonzonss 3MA0023~155 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002288 3W_MN00043233 3M MN00043333 SE o=e Eells ~.1o 4OOOO 0.05 0~,5" Er FaTOm MSue bdCd ore i aAyN ------ SE or 3MA002301~6 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00002299 3M MN00043334 So at AdenCoeA Remo rose ES 1040 D| |049TB E~'~:~b. ~.~o ,1400 137~ 7~2~0 197790, I| g Conor et poEa aPOMmeAbtre rt: = am note 11,04 r.mo ~p~.i rewon ~23~2_1030~ ssamaun arg ns `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003300 3W_MN00043235 3M MN00043335 _ aEnna aborsioy Yorn ESeenton ih GCS Anayses (607 Samples) VVoollaattii|leess aanndd SSeemmi-i-vvoOlalattliileess iinn Groundwaterby Groundwater by Purge Purge and and Trap Concentration with GCIMS A~nalyses (6fg7 Samples) 50.4126 IIII II I i I III DC`ICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003311 W_MN00043236 3M MN00043336 AANNAALLYYTTIICCAALLSUMMARY pPreee Sotetay:iDnieeet PCoorotmaaprots. seen Snerpt AAnnaaTlJFyoer~titeiriccwaialelbTTmmeeassakttessbRReeadqquiuneedsstbtokeeMtddeS ts 4P g" aiS visouS an s]ot AAnnaallyeyttriiccaall RReessuullttsstr mt ct reMktci EI E AIE RI IIIS AAnnaalbytfliiccaall SSuummmmaarryy Goass cChhro~maotogg~raoph~yMethods Seennagyresb ig8GCM etdecc cle de rc GCmOaoSPnaretTsaemaednI5D pehpih) eel. IEbP=hmehe Pr -- hl B=ure ny Chan dX 03mm,18m ' agus CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8Oo6TT2EECcTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003322 aM_N000437 3M MN00043337 s mECooe,um Bms em E fHa aoremEELE . m mma m BOWren ---- a Er e 3lip ieberrpanaid T ivo nE dSdeerTR ehr eR inhgayeSo ei couA n b onbl ? 32 of 125 CCO(~NNFFIIDDEENNTTIIAALL-- SSUUBBJJEECCTT TTOOAA PPRROOTTEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY. DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003333 33M_MMN0N000004433333388 Court ReporMMtEEiRoRRnRIgI"LLLLLogLLaEElGGVAAidLLeSSogOOrUUaLpLhTTyIiOOTNNraSSil Services Court Reportiong*Lega! Videography*Trail Services Pages Page 11 Page Page 11 1.0. An whatis yourdo ofbith,man? 1 responses becauseyour responses robeng 1 Q. And whal is your date of birt.h, ma'am? 1 responses because your responses are being 2 A Aug3u61s90t0 2 rocoonyrby dvideeoladpe,bntaosotna 2 A. August3rd, 1963. 2 recorded not only by videotape, but also in a 3G. ne yourhome adress? 3 wienvanscrt, Aight? 3 Q. An your home address? 3 written transcript. All right? 4 A 202North BroaWidhav,Kianseasw672,08. 4 A. Yes 4 A. 202 North Broadview, Wichita, Kansas 67208. 4 Yes. 5 @. Andaroyoutakinganymedialcolnans | Q. An,aso, peasemakesure fo keepyour 5 Q. And are you taking any medications of any 5 And, also, please make sure to keep your indy htcoud fectyourmamaryin | 6 vce up ohaxonyouconoda 2awa 6 kind today that could affec! your memoPy in 6 voice up to the extor!! you can today so we 7 anyway 7 canmakosuowoeoo adavideorocrd 7 any way? 7 can make sure we've got a clear video record & A No.lomnot 8 andhathacoutoper can hear you 8 A. No, I am not. 8 and that ~e court reporter can hear you 0 Have youever hayordosibtaokenn | 0 caraAyig,n? 9 Q_ Have you ever had your deposition taken 9 clearly, all right? 0 beter? 10 4 vos 10 before? 10 A_ Yes. 1A You have 10. ft an intin imeyoudon't understand 11 A. Yes, t have. 11 Q. If at any point in time you don't understand 120. Howmany ms? 12 onoofmy queosrwatntcicoaonns 12 Q. How manytimes? 12 one of my questions or want clarification in a A Once [18 anyway, ease ttmaknow, ana 1 go sack 13 A_ Once. 13 any way, please let me know, and rll go back 14. Vinerwestr? 14 andy oestho crlaay sor yeou. 14 Q. When was that? "~ 4 and try to rephrase il or clarify it for you. 16 A 1985007. bolero 16 OlIemgonnglwosssiume heat y.ouve 15 A. 1986 or 7, I bel}eve. 15 Otherwise, rm going to assume that you'~e BA ET eed} Se 16 Q. And with whom, if anyone, were you employed 16 heard it, understood it. and gave me your 7 atthe me? 137 ostresponse,arg? 17 at the time? 17 best response, all right? 16 A. Suof atnesoot. a ves, 18 A. Slate of Minnesota_ 18 A. Yes. 160. Whanyporta sgancy? 19 And taryponytouifeelnhe yeou 19 Q. With ar~y particular agency? 19 Q. And if at any point in time you feel lik.e you 20 A The MinPnollieonCsonotAtgenacy. (20 nea ake reafranyreson.ime A. The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. 20 need to take a break for any reason, let me 210. Andis tckay for purposesoflodaysiwe | 21 know. OthweetrtywI fiaesbreeaks,st. 21 Q. And is it okay for purposes of loday's if we 21 know_ Otherwise, we'll try to take breaks at 22 reer hat agency, ho innesca Poston (22 reasmosntocaa,b38lranee 22 refer to that agency, the Minnesota Pollution 22 reasonable times today, alJ righl? 23 Control Agency,osWPCA? 25 A Verygood 23 Control Agency, as MPCA? 23 A. Very good. 24 A Vos 240. Aroyoureprebycsouensenlttodaay? 24 A. Yes. 24 Q. Are you represented by counse~loday? 25 G._ Otherthon hedopositon you stmentioned [25 A Yes. tom 25 Q. Other than the deposition you just mentioned 25 A_ Yes, faro. Page 10 Pag1e2 Page 10 Page 12 1 bakin1085whoyouweroomploysdwith hel 1 Q. Andwho'sthtconse? 1 back in 1986 while you were employed with thei 1 Q_ And who isthat counsel? 2 PGAnaveyouovrparicpolod manychar| 2 A. J Aarons 2 MPCA, have you ever parl.ieipated in any other 2 A. Jim Armstrong. 3 deposotfainoykninsd? 30 Andh's hestamey sitingto our i. 3 depositions of any kind? 3 Q. And he's the attorney sitting to your right, 3 A No. Ihavenat + area 4 A. No, I have not. 4 correct? 50. Hove youcer proved testimoany | 5 A. Trascoroct. 5 Q. Have you ever provided testimony at 5 A. That's correct. 5 wan @ AtanyptooordiyhpavreYrou 6 trial? 6 O. At any point prior ta today, haveyou 7 A Nothavenot 7 roqucetd ny counsel Fo th Hi Campania 7 A. No, I have not. 7 requested any counsel from the 3M Company in 80. Hove you ver provide testimony in anycour] 8 connect wihyur eoostonode? 8 Q. Have you ever provided testimony in any courl 8 connection with your deposition today? 9 procofaenykoindcothierhnanghe 5 ANothawest 9 proceeding of any kind other than the 9 A. No, I have not. 10 po youjutmao nkoned? 10.0. Haveyoudscssod hs ceposionwihany 10 deposition you just mentioned? t0 Q. Have you discussed this deposition with any A Ne 11 coforSuMprin oro totday? 11 A. No. 12 Q. Sincoits boonawhlosincoyourlst | 12 A. I1scaved apron collfon hnAon. 12 (3. Since it's bean a while since your last 13 dopmoaogs10i0ovoersonmecf.the |13 bere. heNove20m0rbeemre. 13 deposition, I'm going to go over some of the 14 ground ueson how hedsposonprocess |14 lin oe 0 he atec net wo 14 ground rules on how the deposition precess 15 wilworkodaafto.h? 15 Dorewas a equator mobcep by 15 will work today, all fight? 11 counsel for 3M prior to today? 12 A. t received a phone call from John Allison in, 13 I believe, the November 2007 time frame. 14 aleding me to the effecl ~hal I wou~d be -- t 5 tl~ere was a request for me to be deposed by 18 A ves. 16 plait ounce.And ais hoon 16 A. Yes. 16 plaintiff's counsel And that is the only 17 Q. Today mongto be asking you numberof 17. cotact ht ve hd with 3 regrcin this 17 Q. Today I'm going to be asking you a number of 17 conrad that I've had with 3M regarding this 18 questons.manyofwhchmayconcenaves 18 _ proceed 18 questions, many of which may concern events 18 proceeding. 19 oracti tharaccutod along moa0. |19 0. Wakary al onth lesan dung hit 19 or acl~vities that occurred a long time ago. 19 Q. Was anyone else an th~ telephone during that 20 Solaskhat youpease ot gosso 20 cobayonuamndbar.Aconn? 20 So I ask that you please not guess or 20 ca{I between you and Mr_ Allison? 21 specialewhenprovinganswars butlace [21 4. No. 21 spec~Jlate when providing answers, but please 2I A_ No. 22 provemeyourbestrocolociihoen. (22. 0. How long cidtht collet? provide me your best recollection of the 22 Q How long did that cal~ fast? 23 focvan? 23 A Pancpa 51010muon 23 facts, all right? 28 A (Winessnods head) 28. Ainatne you cowedthotca fom 24 A. (Witness no<Js head.) I 23 A. Perhaps 51o 10 minutes. Q. A! the lime y(~J received that call from 250 ndpleasemake suolo verboleallfyour [25 MeAsan.wereyouemplowiyheyodur 25 Q .And please make sure .[o verbalize all of year 25 I 24 Mr. Allison, were you employed with your 3(Poges 01012) 3 (Pages 9 to 12 2100 31d Avenue North, Suite S60Birmingham, A1 35203 2100 3rd Avenue North, Suite 960*Birmingham, AI 35203* "1500.680-DEPO 1-800-888-DEPO D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLE-T-N,SSTUNUOBBI.JJEAE2CC7L-TTCTTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 SM_UN00043339 3M MN00043339 22775599..00003344 AAppppeennddixiAAx:: RReeppoorrttooff LLaabboorraattoorryyAAnnaallyyssiiss ' Eryrs CCDIOOSNNTFRFIIIDDCETENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.T0TTVOO-10AA.PP25RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003355 aM_Noo0s340 31vi MN00043340 [ErT-- Compound im risen SrasmpslesGomcsantatvoinans(e5s) mss frhreocens. EoC acaeere s pr. Cos fAem iMdiroChroere roioye.s. l1BBp 1o00iicI:oooo oo : | ~1[g i0oBi1i m0 oA wr a~8e o ow16e o aw2/e~ mw2e6 fT1600 aD 1559 2300 5 3.7J - e1@ l: zz 2 | i s[SiTll21.7Ja9W w2.-9J -CD: 5[1] 59 49 DLT TT 7,8J 8.0J aab-3FEhe aosw fri Ti40 Conon3.0J 5 SSElherine wa [ 5 i l Po Do T 5 Co aw: 3.3 J ~.SJ ewe | 210 Co ma aemtmaos | 3 P H 5 4o h 1o 1o nI a% a03% 14 14 wa ja Br ieew 5 5 woo loo 5 (E11 I 5 wTfiaTooom om t.~J 1_5 J 140 : oI w om : Ee e e [,[ 55B. i PT0 TD1 pA rrive enosul F[2S1 BE IIDC TeAhworn. ma | si . P * -e-s: TITS PRL - Pr'adk~ Ou~s~km Umlt ct enn. - 34 us CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.T0TTVOO-1A0A.PP25RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003366 am_uNCo043341 3M MN00043341 Hothod 8250RoafuorRt21s40 Mothod ~ Results for R2148 = mt Fes r`auSsospmGaosnscarnuieast(isuolen)s mss T1Dera3asbo0cton0arue. [ss8h iCoCn Da a jOctrbeie oi(i:3D 10IT 1LT .: :3: CB[oeerrn ire $#EE14:4 2I 2T.1:: I : SSipopenrn EHfSliaom w=e Dow rVsipdtteemws oi[lf$:1001PE1 TSoo1 n rT otae e [s1h00bioDnoDrT onon1 LPnieinnteeses s[$13i:0o00n03 13n1o 10 :3 TPcicisoeas te | 3Hs H2 io : n 0D:I iI : oe Tro Den . EgsiEE:oo0fT1 : 1: :: pI Toi ano e g s| 3s 8i| D D oC 1 TF TI D D110 Vatewenes [3 011110 P3ATLoprrcotnstbonr rtd tinhr. Pes 5405 C`DICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUALRLT-- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-10AA-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IN IN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY. DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003377 33MU_UMNN000000K433334422 Method8260Resortatsta Compound. Vlueadmieenrrst CTCoT hteeeoaetnearnes. ee frhooaa res mtvSe ampleraCvr oensc,envtars astmioorgne. e meee: nwH il :Eo E: o[FFi4i .G -D:1- z Woe we wu wewSifilehs ow nom D owe owSI)aas, 5.6 J Soa iaCur $F|1E: : = I: itBu Ep Taorno-G1.i2-Dnmkheitorsouthene osTs8fii1poo.CoonT .. E : N-2- .A2< :3. : SooSHorionevsmaes | i w[$i151oa eG2o .05aCo a04 3Co :: ~7J 2.GJ fe r s GDeres JbSoimoe s1o2-nDNsorenane. rr fy 120cHkroprepane piSEr elrbiee Caer w[ [i2EEGT0 8ED E1 E0 o 18o 1 0n Yv[IEiPoC DDD LIADS . . . :: 51 om . : . . ssib.lono- oo . . z [s[0$]i10:0 wi 1iD1rf1 os11 : ea ctco ooep wi Ic ioInrk. 0 I: we ug ns CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVO-O10AA.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003388 aM_N0004I343 3M MN00043343 Method5260Results orRzras 8260 Res~is for R2148 |itess rSuasmsplerCoovnecsaniarvaetrosnsR(iopo)n iss SofDMmeoearosrennme wp[8i1Gl1a0sCC1 .0 TL ooC J[iDorieytneen | lsf TOE io DoCnro $3: 02.2 1 a3 1: mSSiroErabbetre | ii i|= :goed"SI ono co fSBaeeore d LshoEi o o : :: COVornitsreen a[s3li1 0 Noten 25 : o1 : 1D.1 oo: :: M3 EeD copne ee nn s[$[ 5Si410:0 2D 2 1D:0 Dz1:: i pGraieetsyes [$355 i2::101.2 5 D I :: C :: :i iMPemmo ess Foon | 5H(55 i1S40 ile 2CI Co TozI f 1cuco : ote | 315 5 : oe Nte etaom:e e tees | 3I355 hR|4AD 01n | 217 : Toot: 5 f Th renne in --eo orc geet Fn 7415 DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVO-O10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00003399 3SMW_UMNNO000004433334444 a Enver sky VVoollaattiiileess bbyy AAEFDD ((55//99_77 SSaammpplleess))- 58 gras BCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDGCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT- ,SSUUNBOB.JJIE~2CC7.TTC\TT-OO1AA0.PP8RRO8OT8TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004400 aw_unooosssas 3M MN00043345 MEireameni Labora -- Preli(Famgsiocnecomye) A yu cTmE=sims ary Rad [2443 [3453 Bigenunviv| ci Lead: Nome Fhooe. KHamsen| S03 boca Jems:lassi ~l~p L~!~r: Nam~[Phoo~ JDJc~ol~85294 S-- [Fample MaWhs a42s 7,S: oi| SrR etSeR startyster DataReviev~db~ E peS nreE :r se t -e ] IDJ: -- ST E smi ra--nge 3MAOOL~J0167 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004411 3M MN00043346 33MMEEnnvviirroonnmmeenntt~alalLLabaobroartaotorryy--AAddvvianncceedd MMeetthhoodd DDeevveellooppmmeenntt TTeeaarms. BCGuilodninn X0at.r3a50c3 : Khascogamnoo FF`iDinnaaaplleRRsetpepoWroatrtt-eLLan~bbdRRSeeoqqluSeua~me13p~ls0e0ts88 0Novemb1e9r7 DuPent Water and Sell Samples 07 Nowmber 1997 19 STMDRY LO dsepncFeicvofeownegirseamhpcleiscso,pdbieadigohwti,hccimlone,lmmsedfcroolknDiocaandieewncrieerss(pOaCyIcAedEsDaf)moprlBiTohege wanegelep sveeeydadngccnac cthaGmeesn.tcVoeytT,leBw.eSs0senDiBtAe.sSuopdeen2edrehse Compo htweedtditd ev blo owt et. 20 INTRODUCTION 7.0 INI'RODUCTION rtFiF2r00vo.Thessnepseswdercegohbolsseumnpdfoetrhspcrhaecd fofcpeDfumectcivoeirc `GCIAEDo.n(APbOeARa)eFcewsusypiSc voasewedstnvooldl,ePaOyRNvnwosalsiniottddeck.mJzb~vdoui~lngeg CF650o,rmoonfpo(e3so47p5m,clieoost(CCtHCTI)As,ED.Topheensp14l5),sk~omchoau%sneo(st09u9f~o)ei.-vrohet~ ~ cax~o~ (c496). 30 TESTMATERIALS The vewesmeplswerebldg mbpsbe lls: Lbtogess_sutrsmn R02 R200~! 1 DbDuuubPerWWWaees:tkhb.WWWaa~kkesORR1oao~sey,y WWWdlAll KHI~1S4TSO~T. tT[:4468Oppm~ R2008-2 ROS R2008-3 KRuOwLs R200g- 1111I1 " DDDDDDuua~uibPbo~ovmnmstteW WtW~W aaaas~ksahkb~WW .W.W eWaokedeksdd~~~RB~ ~a~aamanW W ecaeyyy*WWWdeenelllall I~143 CLAS F~i43 CLAS ~43 l:4$pm 100m tS0pm [505m ~0~ - B200g-~ I SME byLU et 50 [ Wo 125 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN ~ENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004422 W_MNO0043347 3M MN00043347 Ee rea TTT [yAAll mpsampleseswegeircfzigcmted piety at at~c~aely 14~C 8una3 glesamp~ rpia~oarati~a aad "at0mlr~sios. mmTLoviEY 4.0 ~lg:RIMENT.AL - OVgRVLEW _ Solis s iThet wiaisettosweompp btAe va imft tci h hii yei3Tpo0o SE m TwheL iedoI n oainA gp1e.s8ipteoof (i lft nt ond, ps e EMoonctNognmt (oEDFoh1frdSaepe eedkeah5(TDhCecRmeTards ePerbphe ZnSooncds0tcoToruoMof Qvewbl s,finMofbAecthkmrcevs otptepethdrndelon e b,yfone Scanmof a30 JEER nrs tlmoictikceresh osciio new,eVidmdFOe e rshel smosbcB idy etitd oE n te hn E Eh Vio e st hsve on, 0 pp -- [PVBaaithRTn~ae opm-- T-atems ~m1p5e0-- 10C pP VieadTomekt 13rsts PaPtoGEet [OS -- re l~go2 of'~ yas CGCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDGCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLLT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-T0TTvO-O1AA0.PP3RR0OO8TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004433 au_unooosssas 3M MN00043348 -- S JJLT aruom. a SoabteiLCesTEEE n Eitee Tpe,ypets s wnea 5.0' DATA ANALYSI.~ mm=E =roRmeF= T Ee|i eTresreeraei]sle SEB br E eLpeeemomeRoEte heeeeasr mze m-eeesm BmelORmo SdEcEERs hmeeemn feta momrs Tf iemee R20~-2. DB-6R4 F FI SEs ~3 ~ F cm oEs se R20e~5 DB.~4 P EEEloREreG le os R200g-6 DB-624 F no lX~.s detect1 _ no peaks ~tected no peaks Mins pe re~3 wtis CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004444 3M MN00043349 Court RepMorEMtREioRRnIRgIL'LLLLogLLaEElGGVAAidLLeSoSgOOrUUaLpLhTTyIIOOTNrNaSSil Services. Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services Page 13 Page15 211 A ocYuuerrrssenntteomnppolopyeerr?? Page 13 211 rrereoslapltoeenddttoeodtththheoanntwwhhhaaatttwwwaeersroermemylycyopmptytiioonncsos_n.cAoPAnrannddg,hehee15 2 A. 430. 3 Q. yHYHooeandsd.yyoouu skod asked hatthat anyone anyone romfrom St 3M conioct contact | 4233 responded that that was really my concern, otdhit nhotcoomue.d Apnrodvmiyderensyponkisnedwoafse,ga|lil that he couldn't provide any kind of legal 455.AA. WyNNooouh._?t br. Aso el you dre at 5645 tttiahhsdeeivnncichahetiwrtyeomhmmywyeoo.ounwAndnnaodaftlomthomyemecryeoe.ynsv.peAorAnnsnsaddethitwhoaaant,tsw,waIasws.ill 86 7 7 Q. A pWpWherho.oanAnetetcdcoioandiln?,Mra.s Allison sad t~Ir yo~ during that rer alertedmoo 8677G.Q. tbi0Da.sidiAcoylaotluluyoantashsfekokreffoyonrordauanornyofyrwthnereeccccoocomumnnvmmseeoersnlnad?dtaiotainot.nis ofrrnoomms 15890 A. Mr. Allison, as I said earlier, aleded pthlaftact ncaotuwnsaeslhkantoawnn toehsentiat the fact that it was known to him that me to 1590QAA. MlAI rd.iddAnllnoisoot.ndyfoourhryeotuaerionwednnNceo.unAsremrs.~tong,corect? 1111102Q. cAdpoelappginoostswifiifna'nsgegcmmooreu.o.nrssaenl hyaddisacnusinsli~oenr~st binouty? 10 1[112 OQAQA.. YYAAloenlssdi,,gllIhhdd.edidn.A_ynoy~ eetaiaed Mr Armstrong, CorreCt? hor Gicusswiilahannsy 11t12433 AQ_ A. wNANaonosttdrarowebaaloalyslty.I.thneTTrhhueeepoaconnonlymlyyiddCnisighscpcecousulssessioisonniaotbhndoaotutpthwowasethhtihyawoa?nedd | 11[112343 Q. All dght. Any fudhor discussions with any cjousutndseleors3cMwiorllhvMeirehbaAlnietshoednd?iscussiyonu counsel for 3M other than the discussion you 111! 5456 was aboul the upcoming polenr.ial deposition oundnasdo ehoriwmsoostamhoea,tbnweadcsaiguonsoiesgto and also the time frame, because his 1111645s QA. NjHuN.asotv.deeysocruibheaddwointhyMdr.iAsllcisouns?swiitohannsy 16 7TB17 understanding was that it was going to -- andttwahsveeryr- ehqefomruoteefrasimaNetwovawesmabesr, that the request was for later in November, |f1i11677o Have you had any discussions with any owmpalloyooof 9M -lotmo--wel comoback employee of 3M -- let me - we'li come back 21110899 and it was very -- the lime frame wa~ pwosose.rforkmo raom mtyscihede unworkable for me from my scheduling [|211e098 Ltuorthia((gDt_eenDpttocseoiltioonpnE)ExohhibsitNNoio.. 11twwaaissmmoaarrkkneedd 22221120 QQ.o. fpWWeiarhassapstecthchatresivreoee.iannwnyyhcdciisshccyuusossusiiooennrsanhbobouuottnttghhesqsuuubebssstttaaenndccee. || 27221120 Q.Q= for identificalior~.) MWrosu?ldyou prefer that Would you prefer that I fertoyou refer to you 25 Ms. as Ms_, 72 2232.3 of the case in A10Noprov the to provide the copostion" which you were deposition? being requesled 212224332 @A MIgtarusdoa..or9se.ssnnwt'tsmmaSattoeterrrattonom.me.m. gr entyou 2524 25 0.A. Q. Duringtho No. During lhe collwin coil with ieAton, Mr_ Allison. 66did 2524 25 whatsboonmorkodseExh 1 inyour Okay. Ms. Corrigan, I'm going to band you what's been marked as Exhibit 1 in your Page 14 Page14 PaPaggee 1160 211 AhMHer.oAAdlldisnot naooefferor ccoouurn ~rssel?? 121 mddaoetppoaosnstiidtioonan,i, aamnneddaaycskokyuyooruuetatoolttaaskkooenaglloooiokkeaatt 3423 @AQ_thHDDoeiddeddyipdoounsyortet.oqonue?sutithnaratl3SoMMpprqroovdioudceoceuonusnseslelftfoorr | 2334 1hat and tell me if you documLootnmtoboesrta.tthe document before. rec.~il seeing question. this | 456 5 AA.lthdIWedaiddhe. poasitihotne?rwespsonsse? 455 MwMisst.CaLCneotrormo igteaonre.fdsr dotoroayytyeoooutg uuherdecqecauapaellelessevttivoeoennnr.s?soesei,inngg aa 6787 AAQ..anTTWhcheahrtenwspaosopnthseerlwwraeasssoeplhothaAnatsyswtesob?eeuoccplaauubosseoeobIwwewtanaessironnsoorlhmlooenno.ggeerr|| B677 Q.AA.. wYYAreiestrts,e,nnI.dndooo..Aticnedfyoor uyoruredecpoosigtionins?ioszhael 18990 Q. ttaonSbooemobrpefpdooyriyedorsacoecnewkteiutbshdeb3b.ryMyAmmeityywsoloonwueflndoictrcobMoueuepsnnbsrsedeoetltolev..rifondreme | 15098. Q. A. All right. nTomtgeo?ing notice? And you recognize this ough rw. Hock as that tobe 10 21111 Q_ A So you did ask Mr. Allison f~r 3M to provide cToodunseltledoepyostoioun,tcomoecrt? oounsef to you for the deposition, correct? | 1111102t A. Q. I'm going through it now. I1 looks to be hDaotynootuere,cyaetsh.ewienndefor your that notice, yes. 11116233 QAQ..M.ifDdidiAd_l.ylouoDnhaaavbeoouanynyDyotfouuprrtohueserrtdodnuinsccuSouMssswsoievonnswwoaiikthinng | 11112356 Q. Do you recall the written notice for your dsoaporscifoonracsoonancchaocteogcoufoosdrtocoiurmyeenotsus0 deposition also included a request for you to 11114505 Mr. Allison about the position 3M was taking natrMeoRuAaR?MSTRONG: Iregartod in lhat regard? 1514 15 A search for certain categories of documents hvtesyou moh have inyourpossession" lhat you might have in your possession? 16 71817 MR. ARMSTRONG: BYcMoRursBeL?OTT counsel? In regard to 17t6 17 A. QAQ. AYYAenenssad_. daiidydeyoouu co do mar that? 18. 20019 AQQBY. CMYvaReenss..yBoILuOeTsT:pnyourquestionmorauly? 21118909 QAQ.aAnYAnyenodsd,fddtiIrdihdidyy.eoeua fqinnddauanfnoyyerddpoorcscouudmmutecentnitstossnr"reessppoonnssiviveettoo 20 2212:21 A. Q Can you explain your question more fully? 0AfdoyroyuotuhaatskSMedwoourlcounnotsebloanfdoriing Allon After you asked for counsel and Mr. Allison 22(22101 AaA.. any of the requests 1w6n6atdsyoutns? t did. for production? 22 2232~ told you that 3M would not be offering cosunnseolt, 6? youhavoanydecussion wih counsel, did you have any discussion wi~ him him | 22226233 AQA.,.coHIWmfoophuuaonntsdddoiaaddcwcyoohoppuiyyofoiocnffdaa?orroemccuumseadtiletsttfoeorsrrtthaihaet MoIhihonancndeesotra 25_A_ 2S A. "Tra discussion about why? The discussion hatthat wwoe hhoaddaabboouutt cours was counsel was [2524 25 __Patuon ControlAgency. composed while commissioner Peflulion Conifer Agency. for the Minnesota 4 (Pages 131016) 4 (Pages 13 to 16) 22110000 33rrdd AAvveennuuee NNoorr'tt1hh,-,8SS0uu0ii-tt8ee63936.60D0E"*BPBOiirrmmiinngghhaarmn,, AAlI 3355220033"* 1-800-888-DEPO D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLET--N,SSUTUNBOBI.JJEEA2CC7LT-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004455 3W_N0003350 3M MN00043350 hE t ote Ttreee e pr pe 1 Hs I0R0E0 HLOMMEEFELAabtdihn mrr RD LCN Fe tr hr Loli DR HCHO fdosidsed [----en ae J-- | To----g i] ~ 05, I Fes = B 2 4 Mitr tt -- 13 yas CGIORNTFRIIOCETNCTOIUARLT,SUNBO.JE7C.T0T.01A0 P20R8O8T2ECTIVE OROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004466 Su_Noooss3s1 3M MN00043351 & concrusion aarysofsQpheiuseasmipTi2css50s0esosroofiuDgnhuR2e0s0p6to4nr.d3TswherleivfllsvdeofwldhgevseetyceDIotBc4vm3as1ppowcronesscikn tid becasethywreectfnvl ko dtowes snc. 70 7.0 MMAAINITENNATNCEgOONFFRARAANWWDDCAATETAA Fadcoofptheedtseidin AMDTsive. SnoE?M 8E Milter 110797 beam ry 1BtGE Psuts 9g 125 3MA00230172 `DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004477 3W_MN00043352 3M MN00043352 a Emronmonta Laboratory Vvoollaattiill~ess bbyy AAIEEDD ((61/9977 sSaammpplleess)) yo 135 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004488 3M_MN00043253 3M MN00043353 33MMEEnvnivriroonnmmenenttaall LLaabboorra~taotorryy. Data Transit Summary Data IfooReumsest addEs rBigenenvic petit 19307 brome clon RepCroocmsmptnaoNtieonee Pont CononArbes Commer "ares op LLooseNNeneeePrrooee MKobtnrteimi]ossFUdIE Name [hsyetvri fs fteord: Pharma ca ny cspio t SDEsMdIe4571-43497 hy SEM bfirie c SLetdedrosrdce:pn: Deere: 4 Retsil 184107 con) ont iSvre ic Mp: SusBench Sefbue tmt erec ere OAS oq ns ~,~1~2301T4 DCCIOSONTNRFFIIICDDTEENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00004499 SW_NO0043354 3M MN00043354 33MM EEnnvviirrooanmmeenatta~l! LLaabboor~attoorryy--AAddvvaanncceedd Method Method Development Developmen~ Team Team ContdaicntgsX03a5H4a9mer bpeygun FinaDR"e0ap7osrNteiLmtaeebrmRSeba9dam9ptrl7TeOs 168 07 Nev~mbtr 1997 11.0~ SUMBIARY SUMMARY vSeEssTTyecedetwfraerpirplesiscosfrBic voend,oy moDduaPo,enbtloendJio,Syc2o,a1e9,7,mThdsbssgs DB-624. etsos St~davi~ar~v~ of no le~ ithan R09wetpareddageh Rx~O-9~ va~ g~w~l dm~g e~h ys ~e~lysix = "Coie Tews! rsT[miri bes 10 oota 5035iCpma,ts bas un ET p-- pms pes aCntappmamLsbrdaeitseoasme peau 510 test am= ar Conti oDeh 1142 Cmirebkd Catresmtmbeidd m= To BeBertvcmeoi~ wwafs~cp~ omddpe~ccddGtis~ DcaBny.y oofofd*Dhises- aoum~eppsllee~sicoeaa ~ lbhecDcBh~-ulu2mm1s.~. Hydrogen,was tl3~tmg~n was detected in foer ~=x~h~ ~m t~ DB-5 and i~ eae ~P~ ~z t~ DB-62& Bramley, 2 et I 3M ~ L~u~-y, Lab Req~e~ l~]4g ey Pa~e L ~ 97 4125 pre D`CICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTVO-O10AA-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005500 33M_NMoN000040343335555 20 IvTRODUCTION quepsatRTcIeyMcSre.plmTeehntevtroarievnigsdwl0wlnerewrtoebcesacaeppyesvdiwleafrhoereSesisdcrolmfeDcmooomotpoarnsdsoef. A b.cadspac,,- :sampl~'was ~eed to. ~ut~e ~my v~mil, or semiovotati].," omponeats of" Ceomrpe,caoo3nO(CAUDT).,cTohenma(0l4e96s) wsed mofgern GfHrGB,cc (50), vias into a O2/AED. The s~lcs ~ monitored :for fl'o~ine (F690), ~ chlo~ (C]479), carbon (C496), az~ hyd~og~n 30TESTMATERIALS - Th warspl errecivedin bergs es bdasoll: mTe aaain2 se wbiawa 2T0To0es r2z nRaads Rl Baawwa L2a00r2z . bw 2012 RwRuiaswssr MMMwwc1120e06r8222 mxa0n Tis2 MMMuwss 22100061222 Al mpl everligted ppm4wil lepeansd sts. 40EXPERIM-EOVNERTVAIELW Song Pion oie rplpeetecieTneowrraavhrrssabspeelenlgavwtieveidlhcgoooegixetspbohoyegwwsipg1ehtiepofn3lswg5eeg4ti1.+oT0ih03il1psywmas0snd0ooa,cf,eonsfnodcnd hd eobseabrliSyecntnleyootsryecova(ulbeBrusfalFieo)wconesonepdamncvppesnopbcoodedcurehddlabooessenbggesotatewedoe0fDdCtsEdi)l.fSTeoosnshsiadodeefrgscarve.s oiDnal.Tioh,THownyakosBpFwewwtedssvpreeipaatno.i1n0s,cPoOMnFeDSs;cdvtbihee,(oy-h0oeCnD)wa,tsv1pdlrophorfeoicn emma,Lbee E16 erat us 45 sure D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005511 3IM_NMDN000040343335586 2M54E1,QFStevLc,erl5i01s,1t2ko,o1fM051Q.cAbacsnisew(ehrendbDcoB.aninldyous.pdikfesa(t1e0ci0t.icnagcch)oinm1p0rm a an{d mtbeesDcsBeoabb3ri4tkbomnrechohgtoccsnprhagts.eeccoocvmeoptow,sbdiosftscpkcelrawemelssawyeEsipelcydo1)edysiellpdBedeea viBiehn.sgbWWhhhenBfaFsSoaeFardDcw.arDsCmt.oowTrehreeedf,cdoherredd,ate rfwdorisBvaos edrwoea,scgcvhecsnw,debryberdso,icad2pd,em verebcd BEB.Th loiscv asbc000-DCD. Insane odOpecConditions HS eapcsVTSiubia TLeoec:mppg eewrssepe8P5ricaCka1d019C3550 VePialrrP ottLeei)r osi,en1,e esoonnse st 119ss, ceocnss Ptikeoet1G -5secon1 dcsondto 2 0esd Fuck obencave GOvCsoetnCoPhrr:eoDpmeOsntS:op1GpieWHSe@w4ice,1)P0cm3ia0nmx802905SmixxsS2i9n, 2633586 OvC enTro Do0p2:4|m mAinW@S4i: ,t1e0)s300m2403mrmin1.m, ilR122 InnPt.25,mit. ciBisonDeco:Henle Packed921A. "Flo rendbot Lsag 23 Pusan 4 of 125 DI`CSOCTNROFIINDCETFNCITOIDUARLET--N,SSUTUNBOBI.JJEAE2CC7LT-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005522 33MW_-MMNN0000004433338577 50DATAANALYSIS SAaLESIS: CoRona:DtBS es RRai s RRa56 RRaass RR1s0 A a-- Sweteyaew So tn 1pmapme oonnee anAptirriiiarczgee poeetachheeahtrernn i--c--t T CTorme:aDtBA -- ew ee -- RRaass2 Riss rrstppia hrem. 7mp ew<ohhore wedre pRRaaarnese] 0tkoenr2y38rrmmrA0e3 f 2Tsspcoh<rbp hprpseee. Rfaraeessd h ri chs m [Srp saannsa (vrieensp i armaseLR IE Pots Page4 of S So 4 ns `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005533 3W_MN00043258 3M MN00043358 Tcoov)mm:p25 ci Fe R Te E i ras Comm vende Japan sees raeWEAd OpTmimseesbcimWrelpnc <amhmra wesieed a EwE e Sma E An UE Kost Somme pac Sm see RIS Kis r[e2nt omic bead ied lima it red oid smed ws Cotemmamnres smd pein died Rut mics sche eden sebend RL ehcmel s d weiaed L RE a L Mac esr Re 8 ase 514 125 CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-1A0A.PP26RR8OO5TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY. COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005544 M_1N000K3358 3M MN00043359 O CTolema:ems4 Coe w RUBE pest id RS ombud Res decent sant RSS oot smd RULE mTmadrpdeacior dIpeoh BT mes mie RES pecs ded RLS mkcionst tid RU lcd dint RMN ics det RUD dee band EET------ Om eden le i lige eed Gog nsdn 0Si 7pTmi ti.pm, sed Sommer some m mapE as dct publ set pect sedd obit edd sebid nd ee Alsvee cone,emi hedyof i = gl. MormonLi,Lo Reh recs S248 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005555 3W_MN00043260 3M MN00043360 Court ReporMMtEEiRoRRnRgII"LLLLLegLLaEElGGVAAiLdLeSSogOOrUUaLpLhTTyIIOOTNrNaSSil Services. Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services Page17 Page 17 Page 19 211 .(3y. oAAunnrddcpopu#norsretolntohaenbdboreeggdiinnutsinnianggcoooofpftythhotefotddhoehappteosseit1ti1eonn,, || 211 lI ahhtaaerdd.wwitithh th agency, the agency, histhis ppaardiicc~udlarr Page 19 a2 3 3 4 5 your counsel handed us a copy of that. I'll go hesncamarkdhat. go ahead and mark that_ fori(dontDtcaatonEp)xoh sNo.i2wias moarkned (Deposition Exhibit No. 2 was marked | 2334 .Q.wTeleThrthteooera.ttnhhyaanonkfkytyooouusnsnofottreossmttahhnaatyyyoeoumupjjluuossyttemmeesennottifionneSeMcd,, 45 A. Mo.were aLnyoofbtthoessempefrcoeim.anTyheemywployeeeasrrokf y3oMo?u 7665 QQ._bfooMMorans.id.CemConaortririfrkigicgeaaadtnnio,a,snII.'E)mmAggnoobiiUnngNgtotoo.hh2aa,nndodnyydooauuswwkhyhaoatut'sslo || 657 A.nsenoNrotvoteei.scseLttwhehaatitimwweet&rhbreeeegagsigipvvoeeencnniyf1ict,so_cmmTooehnaeasygpwpaearerttrteuooftfhtmmanyonylkncyyou 8987 thblloaeotekionsamthotaherakktdeadnoaadsc1etEelluxl mhmimiobeifteiayfNyyoonoou_tuuc2tjac,nsaoeiintndrdiindeeelanaenstdrktliiftyyyeodu to || 89 sea,ice with the agency, congratulatory anstolaec,iefdowimhv.arius roupsthal I nad as I left, from various groups that 1 had notes 111900 A that is the document tYoteasty.oufound? to that you found? that you just referred 110. interacted with_ Q.wYoorusmteniiohnethde Q. You mentioned thhaaPtCyyAoouuwrrhffiieleensswywioiuthhatthh,ee HMPPCCAA 11!12132.0AO.a.. sYIIsbetsieh,sinsilglttshrh.eeooennllyysddoocpcuulmmooeenentnsl tohhsaratetyqyiuooeuusvdtidseeennotrtifieedd || 111223 A. were left cCoomroectt?. correct? with the MPCA when you left, 11114435 A as being responsive to these pvers oduofdcoctumienotsn? production of documents? requests for 11560A.. WYheastL youdotoforldoocumoenkts 111114534.AQ.p. uVCW tioihhrnyyrewywcoata.ussrpEEexrxhsiobinilaNNltoof._o22w,,whwhehynywywaoasuslaaecfctooppyyooff atbst | 1156 A. pumty ptorsiancnlo. put in your personal file when you left? 11118677 AO..rerelW qqouuhoeeaksstetld.deeidddthryhaooeruureged?h?omtyoptoeokrfosr doofclnuemsaoelnntds 16 1178 A. AaQ. BIwWphuayt?eit in |mcaynpiceairspoanteuadl firleas.t ithehe 2I11098g 2210 A. I looked through my personal files and 18 Prous aydocioriccmondercofies. [10 through any electronic correspondence files. 19 hlooookxeedntroofumgyhspehaornceh.messages. Andhats | 2210 ~ looked through phone messages. And I.hat's 20 A. t3ecause I anticipated that with conection th00 Pa CA sul et connection lhat i had to the MPCA, as well as prnoovriowuosucldboonanenedeo13ch,avtheaiitpsooittenhnmtsely. previous connections to 3M, that potentially 22221232 Q. Q. WtmhWieeintehtxrhtreetnsoytpooesufcrmtetpoyceshieeavaredrcdcccthoo.itppsyyrtpepoqapoupeeersrntfflifieccarss,,yraaottuttdhhee ([22221232 there would be a need to have this with Asndpaaico,ilaoasmyelo.ucanrecpartains And it also, as you can read, pedains me. 22223456 tcttooiomplyleooootpkhkafapFeotroryr odduloecrosuembceuecivnlelsudc,dtdlhdimdistyyroeoeeiuunqdauhhnenaasyvvteetwfaoaarnnsyyyyotahu,aorrdd_||22225344.Q. tsYYpeoo.ueucimtmiccealnlyitoioottosn:emdn1oesyy.toohunuttaackloisonooosscceetaa?nrrcchheeddettrhrooduugghh 25 copy paper files Ihat related in any Page way to 18 25 electronic files; is that correct? Page20 2t1 wyyouoroprikour -iittosoriyynLooKuuoprrgccehmorlnpmdloueyosimtnieretnrst?prriio--rrttoo Page 18 2 11AA. YYAees. xdhavde poorsoynslcoompuuter?Page 20 working for, is it, Koch Industries? 3 A. Koch nutes msory, te question 3 A. Koch Industries. ~'m sorry, the questiot3 45 @. Dgimtyaounhavo any fies rong 0anyof 4 again was? 4323 Q. AQ.A. WIlAaddnaosd.ydoouyropuerhsaovneala personal oomputer? computereverused for , 45 sending mas lang oyour work whe Q. Was your personal computer ever used for 85 6 7 7 Q_ Did you have any files relalir~j to any of ynocuursprioerse? mplboeloywormkineg onrKetch your prior employment before we[king for Koch | 65 [76 A InTdhuesetriesm? plhtoInyadpmiorelownokitng | &7 sending e-mails relating to your work while ato MPCA? at the MPCA? Aomcoolnetfionmkomfyapneorcscoanseiconohmpeurte,1 40d0sheendd a A. I oan~t think of an occasion where I ~id send 8 A. ]he employment that I had prior to working 9 forkoch kateswasas hoCommissioner 9 for Koch Iodu.'4ries was as the Commissioner 1TT0 aogfetnhceyM,PlCaAitAhnodmfoorsmoy sosv,cclseshshrheaesy lO of the MPCA. And those files, as [ left the 8 e~maiis from my personal computer, as t had a | 9 BacwhikwBas ootbemWPCyA. 9 BlackBerry while ] was at the MPCA. | 1110 AQ.. AYne.dwasyourBlackBerry sued by the NPCAT 10 Q. And was your BlackBerry issued by lhe MPCA? 11111222 1143 agency, I left them for my successo[ as they boio nheStgoole Mesdo. Pirlo belonged to the State of Minnesota. Prior to hcatplancoik,eadnfdorocMhina u|mcbheraonfgeerdsent that I worked for 3M in a number of different || 11 A. 113.2. 12 O. rAYAnendsde.ddiidctthhoeeuemmgeheistshaasgtveBssattcehhaatkteyydorgouu.eseoefnn~sfooorm 413 tBh ackoBe roevedrtryoug,h. recaived through that BlackBerry, or from 11114556 capacities, and each time I changed roles wpianr,ricflotshweihotshofosruhcocseessorhfoosre with 3M, I left the files for those 11116545. A. that BlackSeay, get routed through MYePsO,AhSecyomdpeu.ter system MPCA's computer system? the 111786 rodrpoloaleenrlssoic..tuShSloaoortvrthehoooleenssyannwfesiltwwehesertrhitnteooymsyoyuoucpurcoresqqssuueseesosssrttifioooonnrn'.tshis|oIse 11890. Wdohenroel hdavdeyaonuyifildeshJendmoycupomsesnetssnioant.smarked 16 A. 1167. 17 Q. DmYDaoeolys,lyootmuhueersreyescdcaaiadgtll.eeesvveerlrsaseeinnnddiitnnoggyooorur rreewccoee~rnvskinn.agqaaMnnPyyCA (1198. vous e-mail yourhomecompen? messages relating to your work at MPCA 221109 Q. A. Where did you iwnemmypnezrsrona at Exhibit 2? [iud he. lhe document that's marked 222t0019AQA.. D1thlgodroooyunnogt'thrryeesomtmiuleerpmmhabboseemarrr.escsonmaptuhleorm'~ecomputer hat 22221223 A. Q. lAIAnnnmdobybyypmeyyroosuuoorrnpipaenlertyrfsisoloeoun.inapalletforeiles,,ownwnhhaaftstlikai?ndooff 22221225 waamsainnypocurAprossession whi youweroworkng Q. Do you still possess lhat home computer that ~as in your possession while you were working 22225483 A. A. cMinMyfoyorpmpeearnrtssiooonagnaaisl rflininleeosystacoe~ousonoruntpntaeaitriinnhseeeoddnaaahtplhapfatinolneikk?nyotyomoueurnnnteorytsaes,t,__| (22224345. 0AA... WaNNthotoh,e,elnddMoodPnniooCyttA_o.?upuchase th currentcomputer 25 congratulatory r~otes on the appointment that 25 Q. When did you purchase the current computer 2100.3rd 2100 3rd Avenue Avenue NNoorr1tt-hh,8,0SS0uu-i8itt8ee899.66D0E0P"*BOB.iirrmmiinngghhaamm,, AAlI 1355220033* 1-800-888-DEPO 5(Pages 171020) 5 {Pages 17 to 20) D`coICNSTFORIDINCEFTNCITOIDAULRET--N,SSUTUNBOBI.JJEEA2CC7LT-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005566 33MW_NMON000040433336611 [EN Sm-elt ted ef pe cs 09 Ee 2 Lo YE a concuons e E iA mineE baesdFeESdS e SLA LL E ahas sor" ieicxnps-------------------- 7.0 btAIIVIrENLAIqCE O RAW DATA 8,0 J -- oBen -- . 1'6~0 DB-624.. " a a Soma e J 5 qns CSONFEIDENETIANL ESUBJEGT Ti0A PROTECTIVE OROER ENTERED I HEINER COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005577 auvonnee: 3M MN00043362 AAppppeendnidxiAAx:: CCF~erohoeuratoo~oof~mssaemaple~t6((Mo4P/3-g3226or7f2)) Dogs DB-624 590ooff" 13130B6BTT::rFE8221IRRII33RA.. 0D @ = a 0 5 ) Tire tain}I Feuer 1aeaT TRIAD Time F G9~ 13~T:FI821RI3~.D pS = | v z Tine tain.) IM rem er,12Ren at 3 aetrs 1 4us 3M~D0230|~2 `CDICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER EENNTTEERREEDD IN IN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005588 3W_MN00043263 3M MN00043363 4 Emimomenal Laborory TToottaall FFlluuoorriiddee iinn SSooiill ((66t/9977 SSaammpplleess)) 55 4 12s pr 3MAOOZ3OI &3 D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00005599 3W_MNO043364 3M MN00043364 33E MM En nvirv onmei ntalr LLaalb~.ooo r,raattoon rryy m ,. ental PDiDanattaaiTTrarnasamsmiFteita~tta~all (SScuummrmomanar)ryy frase Tbkemear: Moady Br fomeerCliot RogieDupontWinVgrisPnst [rjcLes: NaePicsKesHosen! (612)78.4015 Pro~-t Le~: Name t Fhonv Kfis Hav~ea / (612) 778-~01~ Teme To For AnaI-j~e(s) or Test Method ~. Total Fine,de ihsDoas:s5i2l907 rong 10017 S~~pl Mabi~ ~il ays DoeTowra ox DaiHow Do Reviewebyd:Kis oem frie:oA csi spisv ktYoowmn: ghlon frost hbSaBscch fro es KpeFeenRais DRSe 10757 nt!}y: I De~e Fina TER) _Sab} TD oR 10757 DRFI ! 11-07-97 rStaepncifmod encom eg GAT LE sd stg 125 D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDTEENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVO-O10AA.PP28RR8OO5T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY. COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006600 33MU_UMNN000000K433338655 f3f3oMoM t rEeEneuvivnir irre.oSoemmpemnetrnar tallvLLaabiboroa~ttoorryy--AAddvy~a.an.nceeedd MMeetthhoodd.DDevevedloolp~mmeennttTTe~atmm en DDetetTmtEaiuteao~riraFoFtailoomnoafy+fRtTTliReRooqetaenauppleolFastrltottloRtrr2if3iil8+e2iollSSnooill 1osuARY FE oierveLm ailRspei i[seeosNrtfsoo oKIDfSeom ,ntatl,ypsWs ieassoif|nwt rlnfgWil or1ek1.s,PTlhtvses cswipetredsltoobttesed tmd~ Lab Retlue~ Na R.2382. sampl~ l tlmmgh II. TmhesloesiegresdyrnasinDg 230O0CopEeA90TEbxpanlds eonAsserBseic e Toe lowing bl coats asmry fhrl.TheTolFievweo. The following table contains a summary oftlm t~-ults. The Total Fhun~e values arc the reasof ie pliclsof heae ple, ive nelto wilh he a'~tge ~fflm~ re~cates ofthe same samI~k~ and m~ ~iven ~the raffle along with the idei de ee n rept. TolDeseo shcoacutntioonf sta~lacd de~x~oa effthe tlxe~ replicate~ Total fluoridois defiuedas tl~com~eutmtionof [SSmoufemmSsaaamrpylleismfiTarnblgeo: mcDoupconctoWnatsohoif hnesgRat2p3o.5n2 F- nmmsmed follov~g omplta'e o3mbusfion oftl~ sample.. 20TESTIATIRIALS RTEehqsaKmIpv2l,Leiiwpoelreecseraaoo5.uePDgo1shg1roeSa,a6Wm6lph9li7es.sgTeihsoeensWfporilkessnhwedtre4dogrgitfvloemrtyLhsse.. ADsasltHoDantaen 10.457 Pasar 574 15 pr D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006611 3W_MN00043265 3M MN00043366 AISTRUMENTATION A De`bOPrEaRADTIXN0G00COONrDgIaTIHOaNlSseAalyrmodiidfrfee esis CCryommdHthaemunprow iSDoc95e0niC: DCp ioklettioo nne B-i0r d0s3oDo dmsLo-fu4101 Ts oSoAdsBMIE0Q B. fiornEeADHOExpands lo Asslyae wil ronS609DNCaisation Farid 48KXPERIMENTAL, OVERVIEW: Toll oer Deerminatin 41 SundAPasrOiiAn)sdocckrewtsionpe(p1a5s7d4f2o0mtAerEosonwPingeconmencioen:25,50 :e55a0c,5o00,r1e000pmpamlFlOyAwAifhnMoeeDOoHb. ForcDaXchAiOrl g0a.2La, oifwdiel xsntcyoi.o.TrShtoeaBddOsXdo-sfLwiaenedpeeceoprtemsewpseordscogyoodlwdism e3imdplfaoof.s 11TTheSdA. hbre0gv.hsTochcocalollciilonfeiutnksdo.epOFarccetsdecnesadkkheipacgotp f iecoor nbeasiyibdolne Tirhencom5n6ce0s7in0oo ntofvfi iuteiOs fnimtheeEo cAolVicQcn iPiencvg.aaTlwoasOd0eaeAeErAszDDebvyavsith SietepssscdoinbcyomdiCsiioeomsnimnoegfsS0e1e,c0e5s,n1F9i,eh1d3o,5b(0aApl0rc5F7o. )Stedwhietnewserned1. anno. 42BlaCnrtesntaosyDofotaesrpDeYsNndOsHdilsde,AnnyL onf MhEaQweasy {Tooe uBocrdsevoa .eamyescowae roofnEnyABuSi.decnmination DAansi sB1oiDwottaen 16157 Daniel ~ / I0-t-9"/ Pgeztr P~oZof7 s3gns 3MA002301$6 II I I I II DI`CSCOTONNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006622 33fLW4 _-MMNN000040433336677 43samFporlsespesatin, 0.2 rssep of llwasecednplics SonotlhedDcoombpu pDrXog2a0m0w0aatwheedsfmoresvuanyple1xthmestanid.alTsh.eTheEOXcionlcobteaOtroinnofARBaD.idomtedws determinedby ecernest 59 DATA ANALYSIS: Tot Foeride deermiaston 51SanNduardtiyadcrv wasdevo wi-n hePO svdadsoos ee copncpen)tr.a ThoefBBiudideecfnohoonsotfodPoOndAsRw5s6d6e.k1e0m%i,nedbyhe lily BecoceofsPOtAAbty6o6.1n0%. CCCoonncceeonnr~aaitnioonnoocofffF.-e=== QS(S5rtphagnedeaaxd~PlOceiAooAm)meo*~QamUt8~n6a)1i)*o(0nO..6)676*)D Conocf sin25t50 uPOAiA=1o6Snp Co~eatr~6on ofF- =~ (25plum POAA) Co~r~s~n.~ti0n ofF- in 25ppm POAA = 16.51~m Thceasrescgersaion.vTahcewteriecplootfietdeaondriaosndiyca0e0c06l7 e0105i1n.g AAgIc~ensaetarcc2o,5.rone~l0la0fi0opn econoeA1f"TufOfiee.~t of 09943 c~f0..9962 asebadfc was o~ fro- smc the ~ range of 25 - 1000 ppm APO. 2 ink 5..2 Bhmlet Nofrhranalysiswes doeontheBris. No fiw,lu:r m~aly~s was done on rite bla~LkS. 53SSeam"mpTplhleeTs o Florida in tesamples reposted vega of phic ~ CplTeoits~!lFfflm ucsi~edns~eicnhgGttethseeoV~pmsppn lderse.girsexsespioornt~ stonto crcfo l a~ ~t~ ~emge c,ftdp]ieme rxtr~on ~c~-y (s=~ af4~od~). CCruealtetdFF-((aag)) -=((MeetteerRReednidinoggofIRtISrEe2g1)./1 S+l4o1e06) 00067) CCalhecdFFb-.o(fuK3=8e2.1d-01.30=4D7+e0n.1g081) (0.0067) Caleta Caleta (P--C((aKgoee))Vlo==bu(l1o3eC)6eu09bB1ces)mp*-iGled(Wo)geLi0gn)h)0* 3m) Calas F-(age)= 2010m0/Ka Aeaollyclaslyacikosvsrdtycaoltlhie yn cehenckcsoomdmaasw9eprecseyeodp. ADnuatcytHroveen 10.197 Peres , Dank] Ho,m~m / 10-1-97 P~3~7 51 gn `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARL-LT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO5T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY. COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006633 3M_MNO0043368. 3M MN00043368 <o concuusions 1~ 0T~6pitr3[i~i0c~c0ns~ 3ewra0ancadt tlyaassis~norefl~&le~ pcpyprrloldeyys.isTTreooeu~cSsrooidRyeEcTLtoik0(oRnaOvDhie1e9 2i1tg 10 ThierhcttteilrBeorndieeeyrefondfnR825mdR232.2 hebt ves DaAonvseanre 10.197 Dmdei Hewmaa / 10-1@7 Basar to gis DCCIOSOTNNRFFIIICDDTEENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006644 IW_UNO0043269 3M MN00043369 a gz IHRE i ERRERERTRERsisE : NI NG iafEy N\ 2 i g 3; 2 3 A L ' LL NNL d LLIN gis L SEE P CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006655 -- 3M MN00043370 -- im---------- ETH ER Ble l H E 5 e |e = BC =Ls E I I I E fe|l EB mr Ei lsl[amm lo8xL(ea l le!| EBEeEm [T TETE ETR E|&EE[T EEEE EE. - ne CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006666 31~I MN00043371 `Court ReporMMtEEiRoRRnRgII"LLLLLogLLaEElGGVAAiLdLeSSogOOrUUaLLpTThIyIOOTNNraSSil Services Court Report|ong*Legal Videography*Trail Service~ Page21 121 yqyououeurs'rtoeouuns.siinngg now? now? VielWell, letme let me ectaothePage restate the |21 21'~ 2334 hqaueeHsHtoinoowonw.wmm?aannyyccomopumterps ddoouyyootuuppeeerrssroonnaaslllyy | 4233 4555 .AA. hTTAawlwvroeoi_gnhotw?Whenddyou ourchasethose | 5645 6778 O. A WccoAoemmlhlprpiuaguthvteetre.rss?W ? lhaepniodpcidoymopuutpeurrchhaatsewothose purchased 677 10899. A.itninhW leafOeattcoehta22ov00be00e77a.,1ilaI precetocapafllalc,mo|~emeb,epbluiulettevre|ectthiotwauwvtkaawdssboeieinnpwurrocnhga,sed| 19890 10 12111 gaIghoiveveOooocrrlotoabrgkeuerlaaotitrmmmcoeoonmnfiraptahhumotoneontk,rhtbhahuatattootIonwcneooe.u.lpduAArbnnceddhwwwarseeoendgi,n || 1111102t 111t3234.AhAuAaugnvgueduscsattioroefyfg22ou00ul0a0h6r6awcwvohehmeeapnnnuwywtpeoeermrtmhosaoovtvnewesddettcpooouWWmricpcihcuhahitsitteeaard., icn| 12 1134'~3 11114655 Q_ And did you have any AtoVAeusgwueotdodf20067 to August of 2006? personal computer prior t1114556 11116787 A. .AQ. AVYAnienedsdg,wowwthiehiaddt iaodhf.aitplpehneodttopo hthpaatteccoomnmppueutteedr? t10[6177 21110899 QAQ..coWW Wmpehuagthtoedtrirdsiadfyooorufotitndo.yottidoonsfsoeeradamacrcthhiyoyynohouaurotrccmouimrugerenhntttbo (11[210989. 20 22121 computers for any information that might be rEmeonstopheorecunestsforiinfovmatoenia responsive to the request for information in | 2222110 2'2 226323 AAwoIEHI uxloohooibkkielehd1dav7r1e[o,qiruonagpghb a1hheeetleeleucactrtnrtooynnoiaiccmflariles.s thh| aattwwee | 2222233 2254 lwocokuelddhtahvreo,uginhdpoodcicuulamreannbyutet-smmy,a.il. I 2524 25 25 looked through documents, but my Page 22 2t1 cmcoomtoomrusnmicatemionndsuswwhii|pbtnoMMaPsPiCeCdAA,ceraaenliaodtviavoenoytoipiepnPnerrgsasoogsnneaa~l22|| 2t1 342 3 matters are friendship based, and anything arsoeo,toenddsroomofsookoswmaolkshnaavtebiowoondcdorsatveed else, and so those e-mails that I would have || 3423 55 45 iYrimenocmmeuoeivcdseitadoltefyrmlo,yem.ntfoiloknsewdopuhlodnhoamveesbseaeg~esdewlhetaend! | 5845 86 7 7 You also mentioned phone messages when asrokveodweydo.uwchoartek?indof omatonyouhad asked you what kied of information you had I | 7867" 19890 AAQ. AreUUgvrhaine-ihuwnun,eh.jd.u, sctomrraekcst?sureyouvebalzeyouw [1890 11tl2 Q. A Again, just make sure rYeessp,oynseoTmsso.ry response. you verbalize your 1111120t 11112343 AQQ...pWh"WYooenerser,eeoyyreyoosus.uorrrmemoefeopsrlmorairnrcyge_oitoosmmee?essssaaggeessoonnyyoouurr hhoommee [1111233 111154560A.Ay. ApMhnoydnhhedoooommyroesopouphmhosoeannvpeel,a,yctyeehesos.e.slseem?essages? 1165 111177680AA.Q=. ANNAronotodtottpyhdipoocircaysalomlyulye..ssasvaego~,shsosaevmeedsosnaygoeus?r homepron] 11118T76. 21118909 Q. A0A. NNSAooroettwaathhsseaarteccdoomdmmeymmsosoouanngdpeopasroacscrtateievceve._dewonyoyouuprhhoonmee phone'?. (11128990 2222211o. Q. A mm1Seesossswacaghgeaeshts'd?~oiudaryopuhcodnoektmo oreosvsieedwsy.our phone 22221012 22222334 QAQ._.roIOOsckkiahanyey.gc_kiAeAnndnaddonuythrowerporoheyowlwnooeasssmrnnyeotstisihaningtggeoesoiq.nnutnethhseegtrreedein (22222334 2524 25 tha roquestfor produfcn Etxiiotn1 relating in any way to anything requested the request for produclion in Exhibit 1, in 2524 25 PaPaggee2233 A ccCoorornemecet?t? QAQ.f.. 1oCrI4'doakrlrikeeect.tm orereffeearo rynyodouuptm oaoPProagcge oea77oPofon fEaExgxrhhoi, bpiht|15 wfwahobheredraoreecmuthohmemeerrneeetnstis,,aaacnoerdemcqmpuuuaeernstsiitctcfufaoorarl.,rolqyunuosPotaateenr,a,gaasrnnalyyapshaahnn5oddr eElaESlSltldInonincgyuyoomnuuearrpnnptysoo,swcsooseymsssmoioaunern,ciyccusuacsstoiistooomnddpsiyyoeaoonnrcdsconosalnnatt,tsreoohdnlror telsting in any way to a~qy compensation or oeearred.aAnncd hbeonnborreorcso,mwohde,tseroercoloor other financial benefit received, accrued or reiereacncractehweievehded.de,,Accdnooosdsssteeahtepponuvnrepeonaefsrse,e,brbspyy, Gowdehorpeotpehneefunrnoottnfrafrosneolommtn33tMM since lhe cessation of deponenl'~ formal eDomysepeohalullatonoshpywim3,econocutnts employment relationship with 3M, close quote AAQ.. UADUronhhdy-ohouuhnh,s,keyyeees,tyh,ao1ttu'?d6m _o0.. onard r ha eyou Q. And I think hcoodnweca?kod had workcd onopotfo you mentione{d at one point for 20 3M Company, earlier that you the 3M Company, AAQ... TcA~ohnrrhardaettc'sdst?cdcooyrroruee,cdtG. rog hat elemenactu, Q. And did you, dudng that employment, A anYeyss.lol4 othockComipanny? any stock in lhe 3M Company? acquire AAQQO... AYYAnoensdsd..dldIcodooyid.yo_ouussttilll ooawnn stocki the stock in the 3 Company? 3M Company? AQ. Y.es,_idaD. oanyycoocumeuntsnraangvoee Q. Do you have any documents Page relating to the 2 vtvahaoklutoseoiooffctkha?at lockorany stock or any dividends dividends fromPage from 24 AAQ.. LthoIIdaodatko.sitnogck?atPara5, 6gd yrouahavepsohme Q. Looking at Paragraph 5, did you have some tboolPoafrthaatgtrhaop6soh7docuwmereenonl rtelasted belief that those documents were not related AA.. cLtoaeLretPtimamnreaeyggrgalviovptoemhyya5oob?uuommypyWolihnkinikanibngoguototnnitihsis,, aanndd tcweods"aTTeinhhptaeyassrtletaoot cecmkkseothuhbaraect eoIospo.wewOnnnnaforoboowmmua3t3stMhMiacscg.oaimmeehfefrrtoomm rewtrweccoeeisihvveeewpddaarffsealrotmoermaammsmnioyeuydrpcp.reaesren.InvtOtossnn22oe00vwesmsaoosmmaeaeygyeifeatdaarthrtssaaeolagdg[ oos a when I onOhra.t on that tocksince | was married. stock since I recoNeidt. I've never received it. made a trade A.mTyTOhhkee0aoy1ov.t0hee)rrasscoocuuorurccneet,oowffr33iMcshsitsoclkkrieissscicodonentstaawiininteeiddniinn my 401(k) account, whioh stif! resides within tnhevee3rWmbaedneofatsroardgaeoninzahtailon,n.oArghaainv,ev| e the 3M benefits organization. Again, I've nim nmegavhnetipraaumnlaadtdenead aptthhtoaapraltldstetooocuocgkkno..irt|h|ztahoattiet,tlsenemtoomoropdhttoeaedwdd vnelsalIsotlad night, and I apologize for this, to download solSotnogmsainntcerohmamdyb4oe0n1to)hbauttatccaosunb,ee| n a statement from my 401 (k)~ but it has been ffs|oocorragnglooonttmgrmyo~ypcinpeoaeesasI8whpaosdrda,baeasnensdnd wttoollwooxthcccokakoeetopddatmrcmciyraoyaumdacndccatc,oo.uI,unntt.. whI ciacnh't reecyepirveomaipsaesdswoodrodweixtcienpttvwioabumsaiiln, ess which they promised to do within two business 221001331rdd0AAvvee0nnuuse NNoorr"tt1hh-,,8SS0u0ui-itt8es6899.66D00E*"PlBBOi.irrrmniinngghhaamm,, AAlI 3355220033"* 1-800-888-DEPO 66((PPaaggeess 22111to02244) D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLET--N,SSUTUNBOBI.JJEEA2CC7LT-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006677 33MW_UMNN0000004433337722 iio foe) BET rE Lr =_iEhEEEs EE EL E BE E i.|E E [EEE E E EEE EE RE E | E )| E BE EE Be 2| [=|BEET| I Bie| =|& |gls=f|cr| SE evar Ed 3 4 125 CO~IFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006688 3M MN00043373 Enon Labora TToot~aall,, OOrrggaanniicc aanndd AAdd(ssoo3rr7bbaaSbballmeepFlRleuusoo)rriidd~e iinn GGrroouunnddwwaatteerr (6i97 Samples) ui fas DCCIOSOTNNRFFIIICDDTEENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00006699 SW_UNO0043374 3M MN00043374 3E 3MM n~v nti alr LLaabboo orraatton oryr_y mental DaPtlianTyrasmFititla Socrmeemary RauLibRe [pe Fe I3~ F,~ceived: fr SR M r Conc Labsi8y func Clit: Sponsor or Cl~t: RReCproeeu~mpatapntiwy:NNNraameesDD3uMacs~ BBa~cscoonn/iRRoobbvottHHooemweellll Com]~ay Nm~ CompanyAPdadcse Comlnmy A~ 399I33MS55ABBTuTtstshh7AAv5ve~,0,SStT0. PPaoult~MbNin. Phone 773A736177&T540 ~orepejeL~LteoLsenae:dr:: NN~eammeae/PBPobrosueee KK6i1~s2is:HH78ai.n4s0n~18 Fale YENi)cT:eDtuMpeetshoWdatFoal s hie, rte ot,AdresOras Fhe wuissDoe 1597272557 Airy rashNeyBerge sDL.esbtoesr soardes.r: DPaaRtheeidby: Pat ~ o1 ws r~D. ~{or Di. Xi Hen I YQont DAIN|( U:cs(S KMArrigcshHb irvy aeDn:s)es:RS~sRiis v ciechhAYeop: n: nnaghom esCor RecessPara) Sent at Se~l~ JSD JGS /11/07/97 SJoass nnwuors JGS ll 1/07~)7" SoSs nbvm JGS/l 1/07/~7 AB frm edepeA sy ns D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007700 W_MN00043375 3M MN00043375 CB =So)EKiAtintiht r a ed Dev nTn 3M Environmental Labo~tory - Advanced Mtthod Development Team LN. -- E rn T -- L S-- ETTnETaRoYEdE TEtMo to inE t SmEasen S E oToroe mm iWfpnrEe EREE mREmD SupEee oR EBrOomEm oo#8: oogn OBE #0 o 0 ou EBEoooEmm # ow 0fz0: o 2aS .0nINhmTfRoOEDntUcCYnE~vOnN EtA 4M rE ch e i Fresess wT eI pte E itE e A ehnets wgFnsa fret CONFIDENTIAL- SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY. CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNT~r DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007711 IM_MNCO0K3ITS 3M MN00043376 Remseedt.2148,sncpls 1thoough 12. Sempleweektseigsedwe feywre samnodneidosn(a3p9d7ea:r3i0u6cr)ucrcfvoceriwoaossilpc cD(FupOAc,Aef)Spoulensadnesrrop(n5c5iD77o3o8rp3etfsorcsboyccistmwboldneef(orPmOpAc2). 4n0iEaeXiPsETtRohcIkOMstEraNncdToAcLit O0wV%sETcRIVlSIAiERWn50du%lVyw0i.h wrdispropelfnCouto 1FordetonAnti 4.! Fluoride Ioa Analy~i~ - mucseioedcTemhtiOebsndsehiedrlsunplyeyegmrw.einsoFgsfoCersm odemthoeee gsdsosanms netdpolsfTwrBoaivsdeddn ehaierodoisw2nirhhoot esfsn0e0E3clAolS l1w5ifpbyonft sTlISeADdLpdiacayeI vonehyeOorkcheyteenAcnsitimmegd oscrtproodpoer.nws 424.2 AdoOrrgaaiacPobrle(AeOF) Adsorbabh~ Organic Fluorine AcfmihdehdeGneTiricnomsmaebmunsswtlepincsglewbmayteCprtsraseansnyFthshoeemracetmrosoedsnd, eDoIfnpN ilmesotAohoCuoFsdg,h38c4+0c3pca1bi2ecndc(rvoaieonrena0s EMBeL0ow)0di)tsg,ho1ws0Tag0hsh0efotoclalerlbooocfnswa.bctoTanbaiaenrcaPsooOAowseAasrsaepwblcicneg(des+iconaDve5iebosgowmddtaireonfeAsDDpIoweNetOeaonArcdedDeetrroAp11eD0gn (VOenMcprmnideQH.wuTiheedrOetAodmycsle,yiccnoaglotlcneiodgroohmen.of3EfA7gO5aKsD0spierns3Sw0ictnhiLh:ofi1epTIiSAcD 43To PlarineAnalysis itTohf{msritsrodeldssmmllee,rceleis8oce.oofrwstla2Dtdsbitiybyncocmoblinlgec12 AAlnntaFaOsA2A2si2onfdOf ncsaEivASeHwUDmeiscgr1eCnaTrIsSeAebDyAboGiHmn.v05k1007A7LFstmnodt, OricachEsAiDo te. The watersoppiesrwrt sslynd llores r- INSTRUMENTATION OIDuuNokbShrTnmRmiU~nMADDdXEXe2N2r1~Tp0Oi0AoOO TnpIbrO~iiNie~lHeHalAailiddDeeAnSsty mid fo fries. Me sy, m Ro 2148 w gas pr D`CICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IN IN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007722 3WM_MNM0N00004043333T777 neTRBENTATION DxINFnS0TERAiUlSMEEeeNTxvAeTpIiONl100n,myoeeitihGxionSsINcCionmbine D Neeen 20 Rte hhcon(KFst) ormATINGcorprmons CO m OPoRA iTnaIv ~etCen OmfNpoaDnIaTg i nIi0O3Ni45Snn0s o9itts CTleSySosl, 1 SADMNSQwe Reams So DAe TTAAiNAS LSYoSnRg0fpeprhDfefCRsECAoRriipo MoStI 010AE2 Ths ionMes, 4202, wocle chcin iomysic Thy t'~em Meter, serial # 4202, 'was al~?za'ated car& morning prior to an,/ss~p~es oinmgCronmCialgtBooneoksSbad,CAntsmpeent ofocn ltisSatDs5rc being ran~ Calib~fon was based on dlmct measu~mcat of'calt~m-ation ataadatds made fiom rToineEsson Coming ~ocid ~tock TFPooenri--ni--aat-ie! standard. An aceq~tabl orrelation a Esarm oflScicnt is ~ 0.9950. 1523 opr 17_ lg-21Aagtt~|997 IS ~agu,st 1997 ACF ye POA rvs POAA~ard.-m-~ Fhmri~o io~ a~,~y~i~ " S439 _~'0.9993 _>0.9998 ' D3o9emf1zalo2~os,50f5*s,.~0a,5ToA2I02u0Sg0,,u5A05s0260Bt,c,s!M0~~ Iri,7oeM.df10oi~0QApdOC~ FevrAr,e~iaFPoaHlO~naodA/lw~aNPeaOs~ AAsaAmtsdyetasntddie,a~ dnFhTlbOhy~RtmcAo-wOofb~pm6o~mp.s.e15sn~.,w0e~ 1>i s0U~ls) .qc~ g~dbut~~ks 5VS3shioreconeressic,tealcoitnoe3aeecoonwannEvofepdoinb .he nts M1FYO0oM~0fAOmft-A~cDlsxoiohr0.o0tIaoa5m~coP~ cv2eusl0Ro0:n=0cgsc~tO.aro~ hmle.eHt4rT5phd,t1CA1iyio,.ns(oT2OaeF5svv4a6e1tgh,pcios5hdolo3beiycpo5t eitnn,3sg aSL2aeafcss1OlnCeTtoprIsiBocotmIna,nMeeoErbieQroavnnh.tehePoodalwse,eyBrnBilioehwiBcncfcOuo anebpeetrnUdiie oeyt M i} hrb y1 rp 14 3M Ea'c~i:a~e,ntsl Lab,onion, hb Rcq~g R214s as I I I lillllll II il CDCIOOSNTNFRIIDFCETINCTDOIAUERL-TN-,STSUNUIOBB.JJAEE2CC7LT-TCTTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007733 SW_UNO0043378 3M MN00043378 -- Pts SAMPLE A~ALYS/S: ERE gw m eTe Eme RMELooEn oz ow BgSShOn EB@ i ooc bsn ot% ne ae t AfroR ertic N AOF~ta~dard Cexve we msammmia pTFm opyrEoE gaECsRn am om EMMEEEESLSE,EE veOOEE erOOeHBasm OOHE 30amWgEoLt,Cmmap saree ppHHmhaoEEggnEemsm oBoom mam onB2x OH23i2 m E aEmEm E eEs 2oE BE z3=0B iiF&i E atE ieEann o2n, #= gas CSONRFIRDENCTIoALlSNUDR2OcuTOAsPeROnTECTIVE OROER ENTERED I HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007744 wwnomcers 3M MN00043379 TAoteriF cSone d asreaMtEs Reesepm aT Gy Tm oman san [B m RrEeNeErr Em -- awwoedmm oon3 TP iis sen ~,~I~e ~) 2S a ~[d~" * I~mtl~ Olr To,m] }zF../mL. P.~a~IIus ~ample (mL) 1~ ~ample " mwhwwaaahodl omooGmhaeeemsl iowwboaimRmmno o8 8B 8 B fE8IF Wa BEodmo8 @ me mah tem a WaarmmeninoaE 8 i 2: caconcuson E~o.oiCeOtNi ChrLteUlSeIOhNcoroorceynessorseeicoemaet10t0ayl1bS0fkewaSpeetr,rei3,op5cEe4ao5 vt. So oh tee n leh on et poe ee:s 0 aonTrENpCEOFAeBAeTA84 OTsl Be~d col~i~ of~he d~a ~m fik~in ~ AMDT an~hivv. FC -- 0 4 ns DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27.0V-10.25882 C`COONNFFIIDDEENNTTIIAALL-- SSUUBBJJEECCTT TTOOAA PPRROOTTEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007755 ass 33MM_uMNNo0o0o043380 sf -- Sgreanzgalf : i & ii 5 i F |; B : : 3 of : ngs sworn roll CGCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLLT-,SSUUNOBB.JJEE2CC7T-T0TTvOO-1AA0.PP3RR0OO8TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007766 auunconsazen 3M MN00043381 LB h Jlei ink Hh i LSLiL i RRii kiig Dd el illil wi 1 i i 1eb : iti fi CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2759.0077 3M MN00043382 `CourtReporMMtEiERoRRnRgII"LLLLLegLLaEElGGVAAiLLdeSSoOOgUrUaLLpTThIIyOOTNNraSSil Servicos Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*l"rail Services PaPaggee2255 PPaaggee 2277 211 dtydoasyms..ha1I taam4m0h1ha0ap)pp,pyyifttyoooppurrwooovvuiiddleodaaknneyys.tstaatteemmeenntt | 211 Q. rMHaaevveeypyoouurbbeoeeeonnfsrtinhteeeeMrvnnaiesweteadwlbabyaeyaiAantdnoyyvrnocy. 2334 aAQ..lfriOOonmykna.tyoh.wata4y0m1e(ka),niiftyoonuowtobueldreliskep.onsvoand | 2334 representative of the Minnesota Attorney GPeFonCrSoMsr? lon'ansythOingfrliticngefo General's Offioe on anything relating to 4 5 56 A. I in no way meant to not be responsive and ediexmmop. laconunsceldstmoomimngymy explained to my counsel this morning my | 645 QAA.. PNNOFokoC.a,y'Ist.hhooaArvvn3eeMnn?yootot_umenttatioorpunrpoesesdof 6 7 87 QQ.i. tdOsOilkerkemeaycy.me.iaWvW .eede.wwoouulld(frreeqquueesstt aaccooppyyooffththaatt wwhheenn || e677 Q. Okay. And you mentioned thal for purposes MyeouArnedrseon,pcotmooeccatsyrouire rteprieseontednby your deposilion today you're represented by of 1s980 diitf'sferreS SeconetiIvoteo htdine.kgyoyt orouiumsmeoh nfetsnittioooi cnnkee.dd htn heerree'sskttwwoo | 19980 Mr_ Anderson, correcl? BYNRBLMORT:ARMSTRONG: MR. ARMSTRONG: Armstrong. Armstrong. 11111102 AQA._ dTTOifhhfneaaerttew'ssnorturiilcggadhhtttbe. geosroiemseosftsotocckk.youreceiver from | 10 BY 112Q. 11 Q. MfI'mRms. soMBorIryLrRy.O. TAAATr:RrmmHsstSlorTonRnggO,.cNcoGon:[erecetHl??appaelnhso 1t113234 AQy. yoCOouounrmrepepadwartroeeunntldtss abou20years ago, comoct? be some stock you received from about 20 years ago, correct? | 11113423 A ttiiTmmhee.atsMcoRm. eAtRMSTRONG: Happens all the 11114565 QAQ._..thACAononcdrdrdedcoout.yyoovuuralhhuaaevvooeefaanhnnauutnntdtdser?estransditngaaansdttooiwwhnhagatt1111115456 AQQ..p. rTAAonhnpdadat disidfycoyoooryurueohcuhatra.vvdeeoapanonsyykmimeoeente?itinnggss with with him him fo Io 16 81717 A. A. the current value of that it is? aNnd5o000b0.havsvairiodo,buut tssbotwloony20 It obviously has varied, but it's between 20 | 1167 11176 prepare for your deposilion? A@.. HYoowrImdadn.ymeetings? A. Yes, t did. 12110890.O. AahAnandnvdde$is3thc0eeu,40r4r000e01n1.(tk)u) aenccccdoouuennttr,iisss htthaaatast -f~noddwdoohyiyaootnuuthge (| 12110989. QAA._ How many meetings? OWnheenwesthat? One. 20 22121 have a current understanding as to what the cuorwrentvalue, approxofihmotaactcoeun,t| current value, approximate, of that account 122212102.AA.. MMW Hoonhneddonaaywyoaefws0f ntthhsiaslhtw?waeteemeokek,e,FtFineenbbgrlrugsaurtya2?26r51yth.. 22220423 AA..siisMMx?yym---o- Inrreesccaaalgllloss.eeeeiw inngg aassa ttialteaemotevs nertf,frmoo1mme.aanbbootuutt | 22223:32.4.AAQ...WAAeHpporpweprolroxyinomoguaxsdtheiidolymwlwhntawaottoamhnehoyeoudlerustryios.n.gclaust?moef annytkisnd 2245 rsoixcamcoonnthescatgyo..aIit mweaosvaelritt$le1o0v0er0,.if0I 1 2254 Q. cuW ringerethyaotu mtng? shown any documents of any kind 25 Poge26 recall correctty, a little over $100,000, of 25 during thal mee|ing? Page28| 1 whichaperceIMnsttocakangdtheePrasegse: |26 1 A. Iwasnol. Page 28 522 1 whicl~ a percentage is 3M stock and the rest ifsoolmhor invoansd mtutumolondnsatndsso is other investments and mutual funds and so | 232 1 Q.A. Q. OtIDhdwoidatysymooenuuotbtbn.irgnin?ggaannyy ddoocumcenutswmwiitthhoyyoonuuddtuuridsnngg 4453 G.AQ. foDlDrodtohoyy.nooouutkknnoowwwwhhaattppoerrcceennitaaggeo?? 453 4 AAQ.. that meeting? aWasdaanyone I did not. else presentcingthemeting? 5676 QAQ._.vaID Dldouoynoooofutt.hhaoy v3eMaapnno oaaprpptrporu ioxioxisimn?mahatteedidaoeaaoofvfwwhhaao tttthhee | 7656 AQAQ.... NWNWoao.a.ssaannyyboondeyeplsae prrestenit bdpuyrianhgottnheie,moneeegrting? 97 8 8 A. A. g vLLaoelusssseta othhifmaathnnue4n40n 30eMpwprepcorooc, fnrettinho,tan,t|I.iwsw?oouullddtthhiinnkk.. Bul, But, 8 897 Q. A Was anybo(Jy padicipating tNhoo.ntotwoolyou? than the Iwo of you? by phone, other 1119100 QQ..itaOrOgloafakioanyry,.s.ItO'mOonnuPnnPaysagdugroce1o0o10foctfohfaEutEx.hxiyhmbiobiutietm11,g,nPhPatarthraaaggsvrraaepphh2200,|, |1110910. A@.. Okay. Whoispayingfor yourcounseifmse Q. tOockaayy?. Who is paying for your counsel's time 11111223 roiirtleorlatenitfiennvgrgstettooo silaitgnigtayoatrdtioiioonncngqouuormiarrgegionoetvtsvseeiryrlnonaommuienemnngntitogasahlr!t have 1121312. A Tam teeny? A@.. Dl oaymou anticipatemakinganyrequest hat any 11115434 investigations or inquiries relating or AreYfoesr.ilndgo. any PFC.D0yousoothat? referring to any PFC. Do yo~ see that? 1t114435 Q. Da you anticipate ranking any request that cphayefronriytoyurreciombuurnsseyieomluesf?o whateveryou other entity reimburse you for whatever you any 11117656 AQQ...AhnYAadcntsdic,saiIsdtieotc.cioonmna~emetyclwtthhaaayt[lyyooouunhhyaavivenevnensootiddgoaotcciuuomnmsee.nnttss || 11116567. 0AA... ApIahfhyaarvfvoeerrnyntooeuttrthhcoocouuuggnhhhaesttetrtlrh'esvrocotuuiumegigsehht?fftanohta.yt.gour 11119878 that relate in any way io any investigalions hyaonMPgCAowavtineg rloPangFeCnmsci?eessninctoyoaulll by af~y governmental agencies since you left | 11118789 Q.dddeAepplotieossriiitrsieoocnneiciinvwnitnithhguihisstachcnaseayssreoee,nsq.doudiaeiiddtstyyyfooooouuurrhyhcnaoauvuvtereaesanntnyy 222110o9 QAA.. tAhTTlehhreaMitthiPisstCc.cAoomHrrereaeclvcatte.t.iynogu,oo PFC's? verboon in t e rviewbeyd | 122210~) A. oda1imsicdpmu.losys|einporaonabstbolewouduittthmtolhhyaeerd~sydyeoepunpoeeospsaiittteiyrooonrnua??rndcdursreidnothirm 22221225 Qa. DanAnyyllrrreiegpohrte.ppsHeonarftavaJetuaivsyetorsouiofcfeeettvtrhheeoenUlrnaUbmiietnnteigtenebdadeaiSnSanttet~grnetvoieisenswgtedfoby i } 222[2123 A.Ah tnhI addtidI.awlIusa nuolocdloibfnbieetedaiil cnnmtvveyoodllsvov[eeu~ddprl eiginnrevnaisdeoderrpeaoapo lsncoidsotiiuttioononlsnd.e. hlimand 22224435 Depadment of Justice AdoNow.lhaMvoenroPtECs? do with 3M or PFC's? relating to anything to 222445_Q. gAgaAanvnvdedeIi6haimdlmsyothohceueoshnsataaamvmcetoeeamdmnayosedussrasiggaeegs.nee.craul cswoiustnhsitehloeannmd. 25 A. No, lhavenot. 25 Q. And did you have any discussion with them, I 23 2211000033rrdd AAvveennue NNoorr1tth.h,6, 0SS0uu.iit6tee8099.66000E"*PBB0iirrmmiinngghhaamm,, AAlI 3355220033"* 1-800-888-DEPO 77((PPaaggeess 22551t0o2288)) D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLE-T-N,SSTUUNBOBI.JJEAE2CC7LT-TCTTVO-1OA0A-PP28RR8OO5T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00007788 3M_MN00043383 3M MN00043383 lin T CT e AR mem|e LL pee |] [ii gi [TTTTTTTTT besa 11] 4 ; LTT CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2759.0079 3M MN00043384 [ ibutly [Fer i Ty ! (fe 7 4 LE ds buts | TULL TT ge in Ii o Iii | [lL Ii 4 HTL wan CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 | - 27257599..000080 3M MN00043385 mmeeaassuurreedd eelleeccttrrooddee, rreessppoonnccee ((ppppmm F?-) ag,s >:5.0y0 5F4 oEK i3 =2 3 i.=5] =3. - 3 Vola - s25:o8 |Z aE ggrL | || <23 B? : EI g a$ :g g 2 85g \\ 25 N g3 B\. wg ns -- 3MA00Z30203 CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008811 a_N00043385 3M MN00043386 I Him Te e fi l|| ifgSaaesieeadEdELpSaeca3 aees ||3|3 4d |&PELE 3 qe 30 femsabed eds | feared rasereedl hudieg | (iss ; pss RE Bees EEITRR INS Bs IB f sf i Bl 3" ; wt CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008822 3M MN00043387 iB SET TRE TT | 2): FHHEEaEgRlGcRpIEAEEEEENzEe DHSult iLEEHl fBhld i3) iHl iEl] 2id 2 ecees |eodzegees oes | : i ey ig cpeoclresoleolazssleailessdiieeiclongEEL i2% a bloassleree l[oonsslesasahneinnsnl i| iinegl lo833o3 |233(233le8 besieesl [ssauacess il : 2 | 3 H i. wens ss CONFOENTAL SUBJECT TT0oAaPTReOTECTIE ORDER ENTEREDIN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008833 ---- 3M MN00043388 iB RETIRE TIA IA TOON | 33 ESE8[s HE3E5RlaEf REC3E&I5 HNEIE& EYHICH Hz |: 2EES) ls :3 2A NyBe Ligi: eeclege [2ogfeaslene fon | : i eens IIRLIIR|ITEH [23283 (033033; Ese Eyl [exanatEas EE | 3 i HE i [| id J !z | d 3 i. yn svn CSONRFITDENTCIAeL. SUNBeJE3CcT uT0A PeRsOrTECTIVE GROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008844 Swaossss 3M MN00043389 an Ena atoriy ~ E~v;~onmental Laboratory Properes and Nutnt Concentration Analyses haSoil Properties oT Campion, and Nutrient Concenlration (6J97 Samples) Analyses ngs lilll Ill II I CSIORNTFRIIOCETNCTOIUARLT,SUNBoJ.EC7TCT100A2P0R8O3T2ECTIVE OROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008855 S_No0043390 3M MN00043390 JE ------------ `SSAooniillalPPyrrosopepeserrtotiifeeSssaaamnnpddleNNsuuttRrrieieecnnettivCCeoodnncFceernlnortmraatttihiooenn EE.. Analyses II.. DDuuPPoonntt of ddee Samples NNeemmoouurrss RaaenncddeCCivooemmdppFaarnnoymy FFtahacecililiittyy " iinn PPaarrkkeerPssbbuurrgg,, W Weesstt VViirrggiinniiaa. To CoNPLETED: A27, 187 STUDY COMPLL:~ED: Au~jo~t 27, 1997 pp FINAL REPORT COMPLETED: October 31,1997 oer se a Emenr Awl.fel, , st ER 935 ~ Avenue ` 0 416 CONFIDENTIAL SUBJECT TOA PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DDIISSTTRRIICCTT CCOOUURRTT,, NNOO.. 2277--CCVV--1100--2288886522 22775599..00008866 Sonneszst 3M MN00043391 - a Stn Entra ~ Ecotoxk~olo~y a~d Environmental Fa~e L,~bor'a~ory 1 maton 1.0 Introduclion ER rnpi s E tee n nAefs ee s co El~ve~ soil samples were r~c~ived from E.L DuPont de ey for pmpar~oB and ~raiyses by the Ecotoxicology and Environmental Fate Testing Group of the 3M Envkonmer~ I_~I~rato~y. These sa~pbs w~re EE SL SEESe ~gn~l a Lab Request number (LR No.) of R23~2~ The sampl~ date w~s FB= E2 B E2 =B pueEirhNE o-- BERLROIoL n IBEeEEEioEEE 6/23/97. S~mples were numbsred R'2382-t through B23~-11 fS ine teu r S 22.00 Rmeesulstst GS ottI a | EEE EEEEr EEE EEe e t Esr E e e t re ee e ee e e e EEEEEm EEe r re r e E e R he z ss 81.4 125 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008877 3M MN00043392 8 EotanndEniviocusFolagaboryory 30 Initial Observations 3.0 Initial Observations a1 sample F221 3,1 Sample R2382-1 o5a con ctlc. Oos to o pres. H~lf of the two foot column not filled. Only o~e foot of st~il present. 32 Samples M2022 through 20211 3.2 Samples R23~t2.2 through R2382-1-1 131 0v ninar peso rae. . }tad an unusual odor, poss~bly hydrocarbons. 33 Samples 22021 through nae 3.3 Samples R2382-1 b'trough R2382-6 NpodtioBcova. Appear to be 54 Samples nas and maze 3.4 Samples R23~2-7 and R2382-8 Hover ra, reShor. App~x to be ctay/silVsan~l, ~,re si!llsaKI. 55 sample naz 3,5 S~rop!e R2382-9 rabies Appea~s to t~ s~nd/sIlt. 38 sump naan 3.6 Sarople R2382-10 eer i win ootowing tea cote. Appears to be sand~s~ w~h lree-flowing water in column. a7 sample R221 3.7 Sarople R2382-11 Spocooe ran .~op~ars to be co~se sand. 40Sub sampling 4.0 Sol) sampling Non-ootoo frum a1y0oofnsochHcooni brfougheacsarercvassmsoavnecde.. A one-foot cor~ from the. top of each column tbrou0h the cenler was removed. Erss er FC dan. The s~np~e was thoroughly mixed thor~ si~ fo~ [no~ga~k: and orga~Jtc 1"ha rern~r~ng ~rd,~"t cores were refdgera~ed at 4'~ In the d~rk_ 50 Sample Proparation 5.0 Sample Preparation otteehsiewttok rcaindG0erspdptBdisscoraps Ao Fnsa Aliquots at well-mixed so~l pxoper~este~tlng, pried pe srsPn wet soil (as.mce~ad) were I~'ep~ed ~.s r~tdent _analyses, CEC, and ~ fluorkJe anaf~..ss. After 51 Arored son - 200 mm 5.1 Air-Dried Soil - 2.00ram, Eis aar heeisa aiaynroomtea8ppsst andcpoendedwBaAel. Soil Saml~S ~ero ~'<lded at ambient morn tempera~umto con.~a~t.w..eight-, ,~oil ~ crushed, as r~c~s..~aly with a mor~ and pestle, and passel mr~ug, a- pSnb ciesSo Gov. pr Bs ye w 54s 0ot 1 P_00 mm st~nless steel ~'mw. Soil prepared Ibis way was used forpH s 2.4 15 CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLLT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008888 a_No0043393 3M MN00043393 `GourtRoporMMtEiERoRRnRIgILLLLLegLLaEElGGVAAiLLdsSSoOgOrUUaLLpTThIyIOOTNNrSSal Services Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services Page2a] Page 29 PPaaggee 3311 211 seetitnheeurrooffttbhhetehmma,ts, msaibbgoolhuuttt aacnanoyymoooffnuttphhueepcpnootlgeononttitahlle || 21 hoinavaoplrvdeodceiisnnsthohfsisppgrraopcieonegdcinagnesantnedodhmtdheta.itII awnassgiin 4233 A substance that cTapaosatmion? deposition? might come up during the 3423 0.Q. tDahDeooypyornoouucehhsaaysvvoteefhoaeoonningmnuaongddsnienorgotstasaronnAdtasiotnlogrtwmomaoasesyyttin.Goowowdhnheehenattrhgesr 455 AQAQ...MIDDydididstiunhpoeetyr.advasisskko,treaeistithhkheeerrdooewffhtehrteyehmme??r wasrolaed | 545 anyone w4th the Minnesota Attorney General's Ocounfsel?fcMPsCARoascronttacthedyeour Office or the MPCA has conlactec~ your 8677 A_rommMlyyyteeosmdutppmoleormyvmpyisoeonrltamffsookrorpeM3dMolywrohreowmawthhsheyeceterothmhimtemewirnrasowitsswiatnroeasnlsaettre.d to || 7867 hcoaunsleolMM?mRRa_toAAnRRfMMoSSmTTRRsOOoNmNGeG:b:oWW ceyetall,iifefsrshhheaahhnaamsso, 199800." related to my employment as commissioner. ADniddtrheyeasskapnytohomate|nrwaqdsueusentcocdnasr?. And I responded that I was unclear. 1[10890 tMf~h'1i1akltettionhhfooerrrmraananastsbiwowomeneru,rft.roBahmBuaurtstiotitsfmshhoeeembrrieoootdnnhylyioon(gh1en5r tkhan me, 1111102A.QA..TDhTDiheiddeyyytdhodeuiddypranlosovkt.iadneyaontyhoerxqpueisationnsat?oiomn abouf 11T110T2 information aboul that is something hier, hnehnaaatostr0cnitevend,1 her. [her} Ihat's privileged, and rll ! told 11112343 Q. Did you provide any explanation to them Awdhodtwnasgoingonwih isdeposition? what was going on with this deposition? | abou! 11112334.AA.. ADinAnosntdydruohcthtuoehheuqaruveneosottsiotnosnuwawnatnassswacoaeggreaaniinr?? saasnowdheithenrogr 11114655 AQ..bAoIAldoRoindermnr yoyaootd.uuowweoerrroeyonnuoorftiffeioepddohsthiaaittoanarroneqquuoeesstctahhgaaodd, [11[114565 Q. Do you have an understanding as to whether nGoetnoanryaosnOefafictoheoMriPnCnAnaasAstoontmctes,y not anyone al the Minnesota Attorney or 16 1717 A been made for your deposition in this case, cildydonuoctontoct anyoneof theMPCA? did you contact anyone at the MPCA? 16 1171;" General's Office or MPCA conMtRyaoAucRcMotSuTnesReOdrN?G contacted your counsel'* has, in :And fact, goin,it 21110899 AQQ._.AtDIDodiiriddmynyeooeyuutG.ceconononrataaccrttsaaOnnfyyiooncneee?aatt tlhheeMMiimnensecsloata 1[2110989 MR_ ARMSTRONG: And again, limit yooeurranswefrrotonamney.thing iat youloomed your answer to anylhing that you learned 20 Attorney Gerteral's Office? 2212.AlWdh.o dityoucotact? 21 A. I did, 2222O112.A other than from me. Dsoyooruknow hetero I do not. otayoocyat he 22 Q. 2234.A 23 A. ABBWnoohdbbowRRdooisdahccyhho.unaicsopnottsatcit?son? 22226233 Q.inMeaDinsnopenryseoosovuotitakadneAAodltwtaoonwrmynhoereyyt|hoGGeemernanoeterrorananlol'sst aOOynffoyffibuccoeardoocyrroaMuMtnPPtshCeCelAA? 2254 AQ. AAsnsidswtahnattAitsohmisepyoGseitnioenr?a. 224 has 1. ARMSTRONG: Same nstucton. provided any information to your counsel? 25 A. Assistant Attorney General. Page 20 25 MR. ARMSTRONG: Same Page instruction. 32 211 0.AQ. WCWeiothimtnhoe-iinn Minesot,correct? Minnesota, correct? Page 30 211 AAa. ItYddooourdneoottn. tkoow? Page 32 2343G.AAQ.. TWCoWhlohyeryrteadchiitdi. myykoounucocowonntthatacttaihncirmatd??--that Iwouigbo. | 3423 AQ. A. otI1Yhodoeonrunthd'thoahanna~vmvtoekya~acnonwyoy?iiunfonfrmoatiomnffaroommdaanonyyoonnnee. 64 5 5 A. dsdTteoopmoaleesyte.hdpi,maAnokdntolthhwsaatttbhtteahhtee|yayI sddhsoahhdntoo.tuu--blddtaihacicaoeottnvmInteawaccohtotudammlddyybe || 4 65. 5 Q. oDDthooeyryoWothuuRanhh.aamvAveeyRicMinnofSfuooTrnrmmRsaeOatlit.NiooGnnf:frrooWmm yyoouafurrmccgooouluninsnsegell?? &677 araaatnonloaamttteaoonyrm_dnyeg.Ayv.toAtAhmnnayddt clIiIomssueeanisdf edttlhohnaaBto'ttbwIb'weosoluiuedvldeomrmaImhakaakteedon. || 7867 lpoIroiininsesitgrueuMcdctR,t hbh.eeoArrcrRnaoMoutteS~ooT.otRnahOneesaNwnGres:rwteW hhlrae.ttl.lo,tTTIa'hmhatatgrwssooiunlgd 18890 AQQ.. GWsouWhrcehyayaudndsididdegyyhiooveuuehcmcaoodnyntbctaaeocceuttnnMMsrhe.r.RleRo8aoosasbaci'cshsht?i?nanfotrAmGa,tion. [19890 privileged, because the answer to that would igmoipnlgyotnoloewlahyeroarnhsoowtheheerrl,,and so mot imply one way or the other, and so i'm not 11111120 A.oaatgBtletoeonrcmcnaeeyuyycsguegereihnnneeegrhrmaaaylld, wwbehehneoounhheatahddearsraeecspopsrmreimsseitaessnnsettienAodntGeooe,ruud.rr || 11111102 going to let her answer that. hor not MoaRnsBwILeOrT?T. Youre MR_ BILOTT: You're nsructing instructing 11114235.A. agency during my tenure as commissioner. IAbolldod iveMtrh.eRyoaarechcwoolrakguwoish.Alon Willams?| And did Mr. Roach work with Alan Williams? 12 11513 her noHt HMtoRRRa.nAABsRIRwMLMeOSrTS?TTTR:ROOANlNGrGi:g: hftI aamm.. 14 A. 11650. 15 Q. d]W Wbheoelienh yvypeooutuwhnae oenoysottbaifeesrieein ddncgWioMrrller.e.qaoRRugeousaoetncseh.dsh.thaatdct hyyooheuurr [11[114565 BQBY.YMDMoRRy. oBBIuILMLkOORnTT.ToI.B-w:IwLhOeTtTh:erAollfringohtta. ny instuctns. 11116778 A deposition was being Hreospdodndnionanyway? respond in any way? requested, did he 11116778 Q. Do yott know whether or not any instructions wGoenrorapfrsovOifdfedcboorthheMe iMPnCnA e10 Aastnoyrontnea.y were provided by the Minnesota Attorney 12119089 A_ QA.Q. DHNDodei.ddhMhideynaoposhtk.oa.annneycyaaqqluueetssostiomtknsws??as a vicemal, | 1(119289.0 A. General's O~ce or the MPCA to anyone re1ldaotinnogltoknyoowur.depositoidoy?n relating to your deposition today? 22221120 A. Q. bDbeNeitlodiee.vyveMeo..yurpehcoenievecaanllytovohiicmawaasnayrveoticuemcmaalill, I 20 A. (2221. 21 Q. DcIDodoooyyonnoouuttkkkynnnoaooouwwwrcw.cwhotheuetntehsheeerdlra?annyyoonnee at at SMhas 3M has 22 22023 Q. A Dfd you f1o60mn.ot from Mr. RRrBoeoucaaleccilhhve??ddanntyevropicoec-t-oannoyareettuhron call (2222236 Acgoanitna,cteMNIdRRn_ynoAAuRRhroMMcooSSnuTTlnRyRsOweOlNa?NGyGs::hSSoacammooeudinnskstrnrueocwitoionn.. 2524 25 colwasjustolet himknow that I woudbe __|25 A. f did not. But 1 didn't expect one as the 24 call was just to let him know that I would be 25 that unlosssomeon a1 3M 1khr,is based. Again, I think the only way she could know that, unless someone at 3M told her, is based 22110000 33rrdd AAvveennuuee NNoorr"tt1hh-,,8SS0u0ui-itt8ee8899.66D00E"*PBBO.iirrmmiinngghhaamm,, AAlI 3355220033"* 1-800-888-0EP0 88 ((PPaaggeess 22991to03322)) D`CCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00008899 3W_N00043304 3M MN00043394 ET ---- ~ FcotoxJco~gy ~nd tCnvironmerdal Fate Laboratory 52 Abies Soi - 0500 mm 5~2 Air.O~ied Soil - 0.500 mm cot of ar ie .60mi swe shedihroaandpeso - A~luots of air-dried 2,00 mm sot; were cn~shed ~lh a medlar an~ pestle until eres carp acs Bh SSE aac otSve the entbB sample passed throug~ a 0.500 rnr~ stainless steel sieve. rar oyws BE was ors prepared this way was t~Sed for (~EC and nutder~ ana,~sP~_ Fi5k3epyotvoentedhritee5da0yS5omns-eoreedgss5mgmrFoarrpuaBOy--ogeednehcaarac3aoraseo. r. Topo ty 4ADTLosi 60 Analytical Methodology 6.0 Analytical Methodology a1 sol water content Soil Wat~,r Content rina ipaFwwsovednw 0cotnanenogHr .rTswaotsy 0e v0 Shima pan. Too pans andSo wetnSat 105 1 onstant Numinum pans were nverPdde~ tO ~uots of waltzed ~ soil (as-~) worn ~h~ ~ t~ a~minum ~. The ~ns TER elato we Sete how eon we~hL T~ s~l ~ter ~nle~t ~s determ~n~ by the ~1~ ~ation: 82 spn MWWee eokni.olWDeySgo aotDvSct x mw 6.2 Soil pH Wei~h~|ol Wet ~ - Wei_o~t o~ Dnt Soil Wetgl~ of Dry ~1 X 100 6nTo 6e22iv12tagtnrpS pg iiettcAoirifGnna2e w6cra0oaotreemrtso A ceaHvcoeynaasaSsN rEhSh1ab0a1SMS riesscOopOsovw noecr, owee vrrepodcod ~.~2 p~ In o.om ~ Aer pnworws and, 0.10 mL.of LO Gaiwsada After pH in waterw~s Oetermlned, 0.~O mL of 1,0 M C~CP2 was aOded to ach. To tswar hk fo ms hn wedssSa each tube, The lub~s warn shaken for 30~minutes lJum allowed to st~md te Emri S80 4 i i for 30-~inutes. A Cole-Pammr Model 5992-60 ~ ~ectrode was used to measure the 63 Caton Exchange Copaity (CEC) by Sodium Saturation 6.3 Catiam Exchange Capacity (C.EC) by Sodium Saturation 834 adsorption sip 6.3_1 Adsel'ptlon Step Frame 500 Sov sd 122m of10 18.2HaOAG F'rve grams Of 0.500 ram-sieved soil and ~32 mL of t.0N pH 8.2 NaOAC pce a250mL cometpOYGBrs A ne Tha were placed imo 250 rr~ conical polyptopylene cent~uge tubes. The . e415 anemia CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLLT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009800 a_No0043395 3M MN00043395 aExton ona EnvonmoFnis Labor tube wer thoncopped sdshakeroverigt 300.400rp. Alar were lhen ~pped and shaken over~ight at 300-400 rpm. Afler Shabir in owe ors cougar 10 nt S00pm. The shaking, the tdbeS were centriluged lor 10 minutes a~ 300O ~pm. The omitwas anSosunadantSarah supematant was then i:lecantecf and discarded. 822 wang stop . 6.3.2 Washing Step Lo pana asthanddd 5ech 5. Tubeswort capped F'~ly rn~ of 2-propanof was then a~fed t~ :each soil. Tubes were capped Bt Ey ~ sha~en for 30-minutes. After shaklng,~they were cenidfuged as in ETavy purasecuced Th: 567was enoptewdh ~.3_1 and the supernatant (~scarded. This step was then repeated with araihar SOL ha of propane a~olher 50 mL aliquot of 2-pmpanol. 533 Desorption sep 5.3.3 Desorption Slap Gos oncend oO, 57.0 AOA:wscod1 chsnp One hundre~ mL ol 1.0 N, ~H 7.0 Nt!4OAc was ~ted to each sample. ThoRhus wor topper nd hak ovr gH.ATSShan.ny The I~bes were stoppered and shaken over-nigN. After shaking, they recrol fTomig nges eSH dTo Tho ape wy were centrifuged for 10-minutes at 3000 rprn. The supematards were decanted for sodium analyses~ The supematanls ware then ~ubm~ed to aan yi nn 1 4EpamanaLosi tor the Inorganic Anal/sis Group of ~e :~d Environmental Laboratory for Sar oFOM8c 3,Mero So. analysis ot s0e~Jm by IGP [,SW-846, Method 6010). 6.4 Coleution of Catlon Exchange Copacty 6.3.4 Calcu~ation of Cation .Exchange Capacity xatc in.mo 22 O.1 x ~.conc. ofNa_ _m~/LV'23 Cco"dortsbnStaaowwnaisndgtei2e 1oofom05oe0loehmitocrXe1Gn0EsstvCwolotr=esomvfneelan,osvn10aa0ugo13svs0eel over,diCed weight ofsait, g" x 100 = meq/100 g so~f 64 Teli N(iatsaonnitosAores,iyio.esIAVILc)ftora wor tn ioSy nean, dulsey. Tho tgmer otssa Va6.i41.nt oaNouifl~tSlootetA.iNrr]tos~ggeee,nn2ndction,22. 6S4a2s,sutmroedsoe. Melt~xIs of So]~ Analy~s, 6.4.2 S~dfate 2nd Edition, 33=8. 6E43wesumre. SW-84~, Mothnd 9088. 6.4,3 .Sulltte EPA !~thod 377.1. s #4135 swear: `DCIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLE-T-N,SSTUUNBOBI.JJEAE2CC7LT.TCTTVOO-1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009911 aW_uNC00433296 3M MN00043396 0 Ecotoeokgy and EnvironmenlFao Labora and Environmen~I Fate CCooppiieess ooff RRaaww DDaattaa aanndd CCoonnttrraacctt LLaabboorraattoorryy RReeppoorrttss . 8544"4 as pr 3MA00230213 D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009922 3W_MN00043397 3M MN00043397 esm ore-- F..N~IRO NM~I,,TrAL wSEn AaZzSRBrz. Rm Lf A ee a le A ras Eh _-- = _ og ne COTNFIRDENTCIAoLtkTSUNBoJEiCT ToOA PsROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009933 oumonneszss 3M MN00043398 sb cn SOIL WATER PERCENTAGE OF WATER IN ~I-IE,~AMPLE OHI A DFff-MAS:E: BA~;~ westR HHge ern + n-; G~lner. Walter~ 19~_ Wate~Cor~e~l. p. 4~-544. In ~ ~lu~ [EEL}. Mel]'K~ of~ ,~ly~, FRET TR % pF mre eSoiae Rt --20 s--H[ s Sr an - mea| s e e r s ec -s . s ree .- . --t e -- - . --- . - r = t ee ee ee-- MTR par---- ins Ill[If I II III f III CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009944 3M MN00043399 -- e ni--m aE ETT ei I E PBA T I E memes "ZOO mm ~r~lr~~us~L ia ns_--gene{e om | e nef n|i E e eI e r. S er . d r i o s . e .,h s ESo.l -- R e s-- sEee E AT] s C e = Ee- ke r e C - = e e e --- --e] Ieveem-- eer --r -------- Y------ -- ---- ------ ee eb] ee ii e m-------- 98 4 125 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009955 3M MN00043400 HIRT - os. -- b E iF re rte eE s r fEHE e m b p b e : r m p Ee H m He B i-- EB 3= '17 --rbldhaoretl= ] s er a b :e f ---- H e m ee B -- :-- -- B o -- -- e F r S -- -- E e He E+ -- e E A r e reee -- -- e -- 3~4iI, ---- -- EEe -- e-- ee H Ab -- B -- e --e--} e -- -- r E e ee e -- ee e ErEe E ae CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DDIISSTTRRIICCTT CCOOUURRTT,, NNOO.. 2277--CCVV--1100--2288886622 22775599..00009966 3M -MN00043401 ROWENTA LABORATORY sor. warencowran (Gob, Wit 1P9a0.5WPtctCoavnedtM.a4r9i05e4.aAlocA0goo(r4)y,WeenbsoS.63 rydiEnr. 6WtCored + HWA ee=l6M W1MAS DSH 3 100 weJg~ of D~ For CEC. Calculation CC a razeg se algeyna a A g do E e nly Toagu 1a agald| [hb | ts ute erelaodsslave 4 7S--7-- -- 2d ---- -------- ---- -- r -- ee-- -- ---- r -- ------] f Fr F -- E0 S ---- ---- ---- ---- -- -- -- Ee Ee r FV rr1 rr Re -- : 0d 135 `DCICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009977 3W_MNO043402 3M MN00043402 * ; ooTvoeirms CATION EXCz~IAI~;E CAPACil'~ (C~C) I~Y S,OO|UM ,.~ATU RATIO~q rcerrt oent E rN T E oeom E pE ee e E st E c E 4e re. tet reap Cs r b. C --eehe Eh ~ ood n s1 0 t g E eeE 1 200 2 220, =a =f-- r -- -- Hi -- r --r ------rr r r r r = fe] -- He-- tt wane 3M~0[TJ~0Z19 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00009988 3M MN00043403 D>] LABORATORIES, Inc. Xai SRTEBrcIaERo,emis--ec--momen sn gE UYeomruiEs,t,, BWSi :wews u sUpZg ar sotrs p res aS0m5 wS0a5 wSOoSwH WSaOo wSaOnN wSa0s0h io 5 ~[,at,No................ as"~,*,-~? eWe-~s anw-..~9 Me vos W-551- KeW-$52 . sna S rot . ---- Wma Wms aa WE WWE<0.1 ms me ea43.4 ma aa .<2 70.4 '<2 E i iY y toni EERET EY CONFIDENTIAL SUBJECT TOA PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED I HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER EN:I-ERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DDISISTTRRIICCTT CCOOUURRTT,, NNOO.. 2277--CCVV--1100--2288886522 22775599..00009999 S_onnesase 3M MN00043404 - `Court ReporMMtEEiRRoRRnIgILLLLLegLLaEElGGVAAiLLdeSSoOOgrUUaLLpTThIIyOOTNNraSSil Services. Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Traif Services Pages Page 35 1 upon acommunboitwceonamytliePnaotgaenn3d3| 1G. Andhaveyou mained so eansad siPnacgee93457 2231 upon a communication between my client and mec.uAdtstohiyatocudonntceoend,lolmityouransuerto | me. And so you need to limit your answer te 2231 .QAA... AYYAneensysd.,oIhtI hahhevaapevwery,.oou fremeasinsediasonosnlieceasnolsred since "94? 4543 AA. TaohTuehtseurirdeees'osttbfhboaehoiieonctnoncnndootoemcxceoteonn.nttt.aacctt hatthat Imawareof I'm awareof | 3445 Q. A Any other professional licenses cNoo. ricoaftnyokninsd? cerlificatiens of any kind? or ,5 766 Q. Q. wohuLLeetsttihdmeeereosaftswkthkhaaittmtIlchoeiisnnwetwefaxayoty.::maWWtiitihwhoaoosuuntt petorlottviinisgdgedmm,aedo. || 5 A. 67 G. 6 Q. CiNsCootan.rnyyyobouussouummamgrairwiizzntehffyooonrurmrmeriysyotoufunrrlemgpmpleloo.yymmeenntt 8 7 8 ywyoohuuektkhnneoorHwwR--t.thwheeAhRaaatMnnissSnwwfToeeRrrrmOttoaoNthiGtoh:naatTwqqoauusewesshpttriiaoootvnni?q?dueeds, tdoon?| 788 history beginning with your first full-time A.joMbyfatsetrcuo-liemgeo?job afrcolegewoswih job after college? 1119001B.BYYNMTRR. hBBILLMuOOsRaTtT.a.TsA:ktReMd.STWROhNGe: oTrotnwothhtahteeqrueehsratiosn'?.| 1110910 A. My first full-time job after college was with Q.thAenMdiwnhnoesnodtiadPyloluusiaontCwointhrWoPlACgAe?ncy. the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, 11 31212 Qb. ecboTeeuehnnnasietnilnI.ljfuooDsrmmtoaaaytsloikooeunndkp.pnorW ovoviwhiddteeehtddheeabbrnyyosW3rwMlneoortto?ythoyeoururer has | 11111223 AQQA.... AA11n93rdi86d68ww0oh1hrea11np99o88ds77idi.tyonou0sdtayr[owusithtaMtPaCtAM?PCAat 13 15a14 ncooquunesseilMM.oRRnD..oAAyf RRoMMuSSkTTnyRoRoe wOuONaNthnGGes::wat enTTrshhwahaeatf'strs?.aayyoessoorr 11114345 Q. A tthAIhawnotadttsitmwmaehop?a?ot uptoosintiocnondtidolyosupesctiaarltsa.t MPCA at 1811657A.A. CnYYoaoenqrsu.yeosutiobnrieIs'll leut ymoumanaswreorr itmheaztyoeur 111(165760AQ... I was a pollution control specialist. HMPoCwAlTongdi you emai notpion wih Howlong did you remai~ in that p~sition with 11117889 Q. Can you briefly summarize for me your cddeugsroeleisonyaolubhaacvkegroobutnadnaedf?r gh school, educational background after high school, 11[117898 AA.. Ma1yI orPrueoCrccA,aa?lllsaaobbmooouuwttbaayyreeeaararraaonnuddndaa hthahalalllf,, ppeerrhhaappss,r oorr 22211009 AA. idffeagntrateeenatsdoeyfdtotTtutehhuecheohaUUnvrntaeinlviovoeooebgrrytssadtiiytanynedoodff?rMMeiicnnennieevssoeoatdtaa 22211090.AQ. a year, somewhere around that. CSoomuentite 19or1896767 So untillate 1987 or 19887 22221225. BIBnVasictihetouentleodrocidofyfTSoSechucciihoeebnnntooccafeeoidgndekyteghgarernetedreecierienngcgorgeeeeioveoe?llfodogyay.. 121 A. 2232. 22 Q. AoCAnmnoddrprwewlchhta.oattyhhampetpahenontepitdmwawepiti?thh reroessppnoeccttet0oyyodouurr 222243450.AAQ_. s1W 1v99h8c80e6h.n,a1Ibdvbieodelilyeovyoeu ue,_oobbttaaiinnethdaatnydecgtreeved?ucations [22223456 A. A. employment at that time? psositton atyheaegendcy. but I stayed at the agency, but I had a had a ddiifffeerreennTtt o 25 (3. And have you obtained any other Page 34 educational 25 position. Page 36 2!1 Adde`eggrreeNeehsslbboedeyeyogotnrneddeyy.aooouur.r8BS7? Page 34 211 Q.QA. AIAnwnddaswwahhaPattappotososiittniooCnnon4dtidryoyolouSu pggetet acattitthhaaatltpPapsoaoni.gidnnett??36 2 A. 430A. 3 (3. Nola full degree, no. Diiseyou work low amyfrther Did you work toward any I'urther degrees? degrees? | 4323 A. t was a Pollution Control Specialist It, owrgkaenzdationnl. r group wii the I worked in a dirterent group within the and 5545 G.AA. AIMW Wdhahiasdat.ttaodraidoyyooofuuSwoeocrrokknttdooowwraayrSrddcsso??nceEducodon, | 455 Q. Q. organization, Opkosatyi.onA?ndhow Okay. And how long ~ong 94did you you remain remain in in that that 6 A. 78 0. 7 Q. A Master's Hdaogwemna?ny How many ~howlongddyou pursue tat of Secondary Science Education. -- how long did you pursue that | 6 787 AA. position? Ahbatouta year About a year andahata and a half, a year, year anda year, year and a 1990AA., AdAAenygyyereeroaet.r?h.e -- ave youworkedtowardanyother 1089. Q. Q. heAAanlnmfd.dhptohenlnwowhahaytattlmhahaateppppponeennnttee"dd wihwith respect respecl 0your to your 11111102 Q. Any other-- have you A edNuoc.attihoanvaolrdaetg.rees? educational de~jrees? worked toward any other 11111102 AA. C eTTmhhpeelnnooyItmtaooesoonu kkatwaaaantntteehn ewwarptrrpoaolos lneeinosatf?.t tthheeMMetertrooppoollittaann 1t113263 Q.A. Q_ DcNDoaooy, yonI ohuufahvhaecavvnooeooftna.otnynyopprkornoifnfeessdss?siioonnaall censosor licenses er | 11113423. AQQ._ Council as a water pranner. Cnordotchttwas in approwima1t0e0l0y7 And that was in approximately 1990? 14 11651,5 AQA. certifications of any VWohsor.eahotse? Yes, I do. kind? 11114565 A. AQ.Q. ACHgHaoooirwwrnel,lcooitnn.sggq0dudidtyeyosouuormreeemmtaaiminneiainntgthoha.attNppoyosstiitioonn?? 11116778 AA.StImW'lmaehaaoptlparWroirefsetcshosooinsoseni?fanlggeeeoloologsgiissttsilicceeinnsseeoddinintnhthee 11[118677. A. rhraAelcglo.alowilne,octiito'ycsneaqiraussioot,feorsrsaoaobmlbmoeouewuthttcieamryyeeeeaaatagrr,,ooyy.uoeonuMadrryatahnnnedrd.oa 211t9809. Q. Q. WWSiWhtsachetoeennnsoifndiW iiddnyisyocotouunhfsrtirisnrst.tobgbeaecrcaoo?mmee censed licensed in 21110989 Q. Q. half, two years, somewhere around there. oAnmdpwlhoatyhmaaetptpnheotntedpwoiint? respect 0 your And what happened with respect to your 2222O112 AA. Wisconsin in that regard? owiaen.t mink bock. I want -- Im thinking back. 119999440o0r 9'955,,1I [22221201 AA.. TCeTmhhepelnonoyIimttonoueooSnkketaaaatntntnteeeh,wwatWrapoolsolehinwiwtin?ilgthhtothhnee ---wwiithhKKiinngg 22220253 Q. Q. gbAAeenonlieddovdgedioo.syyrooou remainbcensed remain licensed as as professional a professional | 22223263. QQA.. CAIAonwnuaddnswtwayshhinaltuSddeiddaryttyloweoauf,utdWdeoaoarspIoh-oarcirnnKKginitenneoggn.C.Coouunnttyy?? 2245 A Yos1oo, geologist? 2245_@A.._AInwaansaatwsuarsfacbeegwiantneirnpglaanpnperr.oxmatey 19827 25 A. Yes, I do. 25 (3. And that was beginning approximately 19927 22110000 33rrdd AAvveennuuee NNoorrt1th.h,6,0SS0uu.i6itt8ee5.99D66E00*PBBOi|.rrmmiinngghhaamm,, AAII 3355220053"* 1-800-888-DEPO (9P(Paaggeess 33331to03306)) D`CCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 300043405 3M MN00043405 22775599..00110000 Bony asomsromes, me P_o. 8~x z~9. t~26 No FROJ~T ST~EE~ r~EW UL~ M~ ~0Y~-~4~ AREATSQEUAEL SOPePOrRTIeNTY7SAPsLeOaTnER 00 W,4~NE (507} 3r-~1-1~17 WAT$/8~0f 78:Z-3557 F,a~X ~507) 35~2~9 fM--ro--rm--eaPO [rr DF Due Oh fy Pa~2 et4 hapa Sammi Talia... SL SE WE SSH WS Ss WE WSK S00 Was SeID. or. REY BS BE RN TN J. Naaoga(xi. <o1 om <u <o1 <a 1~i~Hi1~o~m (m~l~I~ .. ~:O.l 0.II ir 18 Ww @3 Kz S~e(m~-. .......... 217 eo) 2 a a a a ~ (u~L) ............. <2 <2 <2 <2 <2 AA ysmtR:s Vite a wU TogLonbs. prem res ee pry III lib illll III CBCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDGCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT- ,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7.TTC\TT-OO1AA0.PP8RRO8OT8TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110011 aw_unooossaos 3M MN00043406 Eg LABORATORIES, Inc. ES a meta AAn~a.llyys~iissooff33M M SSaammpplleess rseae Naoaviotnepued Meee x sa bJ es S-- we _-- -- - - -- ---- e-- Im-- smermresmm---------- CONFIDENTIAL SI UJET Ts 0A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED I HERNES COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110022 El pr3M MN00043407 Tr CCT RELATE CEN ROAR BY FHVETER ,dpsi etoi Tees FI{O.rE(~T L~P,I>; Rl) Hr.~ELL he it ' . ares =. amenw A & p7 p8g%E0m, Rr O~l~J3/~.g97 wane CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110033 3M MN00043408 ow Eccorcobgy and Envronmontl eto Labor CCooppiieess ooff SSoolill MMeetlhhooddss 9% 4135 D`CICOSOTNNRFFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIUARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2277559..00110044 3W_MN00043409 3M MN00043409 aw EnvmONENTAL LASORATORY 3M EI~qRO~IMENTAL LABORATORY PRCLMNARY PREPATATION OF 0K SAMOPRLALBOREATOSRY AIALYS pRELIMiNArY pR~PARAT|OH OF SOIL SAMPLES FOR LABORATORY -- CsR erattI Im e T R e Eye t th rds . + reer oe<bmn CEEE mrntE 2 iS a SlTCie Re SAE b-g + SeEmrmtsps1m0 gtmonpeTmeneEnmE1C0ome cfohipmAn 0 dps a| sme rE te TE n ItEa eEeToA n cn tsi m R ho n E werenepnmces ga hi Sm e ee--" ed te i in ad Aiad 7 4135 DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIUAARLLT-,SSUUNOBB.JJEE2CC7.TT0TTV-O1O0AA.PP25RR8OO8T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110055 ane 3M MN000434t0 3 ENVIRONMENTAL LABORATORY 3M EI~VI~ONMENTAL LABORATORY. SOIL WATER CONTENT SOIL WATER CONTENT PERCENTAGE OF WATER IBATSHIES SANPLE ON A PERCENTAGE OF WATER 114 -file SAMPLE ON A DRYAMASS DRY-MASS BANGLE OF THE SON. WATER CONTENT METHOD. earne t PoRenINCthIpPLEcOF tv"[]c~FbS..epee SOvILoeeWATvmoEoARpmhCeOtKtrsaEdHtiT MEc'ri HsOTD e2t i AERA SS SR amen eRrIas IrsemIcr aSeR. ee,, er oat Te e oi by as ava Ano soiSTVIY nr stn urs RAHGG AHD et renrenewces Lste mi we 15 + Sart teOre x bv lonsoltaBceoo l snacison a0 ACCUAGY PRECISION AN~ ACCURACY RSS mI eet Syedwsite aq 1S i JL C`DICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7.TTCTTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO5TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY. COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110066 3MM_MIMNNOO000S03443141tl EausMENT AND REAGENTS has. Omiea inspmeicptgciirnesd.kkds he rcg vnn s 1 1 Danecingse 5 Meena - 1 WATER CONTENT PROCEDURE ofnrt rive0m 4 pep er WATER COHT~NT pROCEDURE ed i4 1)~ ~ 2 5 PW raemddtem einnd 1ga 1 caese rd 0e crti n hi 4. PA 0 CT lot e atmn tnmspos i. ihlnaycn. Cort AY teiBtHreAsA AE) 1 nerenences Cr10, WeCot 5b: Ar ania RF.FEFiEI~GESsa iot.Sk,Po 2 ara D`CICOSONTNFRFIIIDCDETENNCTTOIIAUARLLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2277559..00110077 _MNO043412 3M MN000434t2 240 ENVIROWNENTAL LABORATORY ENVIRONMENTAL LABORATORY SOIL pH METHOD SOIL pH ME-fltOD HE Em PRINGLE oF TE sot. METHOD PRINCIPLE OF Tile SOIL pH METHOD EE Fr ECR eSSass Stet et A ET ae b pe b eaey EE = et teadvesdanohsmtnd RANGE ANO ~EF.SITIYrI~ i i rcnrennces INTERFERENCES | B TeECmE u RnarEsi. ER oy ce tTtaecahdattahoa reese be Soo ss T petaheye hen dfpeee tee cabeSCson S SEESeR eETeEtS R eaT r EsSE EL Tt smscison ano AccumAcy Ere ah oo 125 l II m I lllmll m CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-Tl,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVO-O1A0A.PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110088 aM_MN0O043413 3M MN000434t3 3D piecotS r mners e ao moghnos er EQUIPMENT AHD_ ]~F_AGENTS . J>R l rconei tpma--eto vpa--n--i ] o Jse m . I gum -- he 0--prroecetreat 3 wmntsr edttr ht tteeerre k.t I-- > mS eEmES eE ,pt E E pe E mi ees JP ian E 13m E o 1 mR I a E EOS Hette 1) re st oea Bc t em sEsEofoRE isRsTuHlfS SJ R --EA SASS hh fS on ert E to Sh : or 4 as 3MA00230229 CONFIGENTIAL SUBJECT 10 A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28852 CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00110099 33MM_MMNN00O0004433441t44 CATION EXCH4ANGSEENVCIAERPOANCIMATEYNT(ASCLECL)ABBeYORoSAOTnBORUYN SATURATION [-- Tp Ee R aA te ontt hognoyn SkE g oSw t8 B e ER yES E en RC R E, crepmg J--in e R~NGIE At;O SENSR'IV]TY J-- eBE Tre ri SEeg Ce CE a t E sh aa noyS E EEES RE E E R E RSE eE Smion aC EE R meson an scent T om AR E pf~ECI~ION AND ACCURACY . on gas" zn CCCOOONNFMFIIBDDEEENNNTTITIAALIL.-LSSUUSUBBBIECJJT EECCTT 1T0O0 A A PPRORTECOTVTE ECTIVOEORDER PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN HENNEFIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111100 -- 3M MN000434t5 `Court ReporMMtEEiRoRRnRgII*LLLLLegLLaEElGGVAAiLLdeSSoOOgrUUaLLpTThIIyOOTNNraSSil Services Court Reportiong*Lega! Videography"Trail Services Page 37 Page 37 PPaaggee 3399 211 GA.A. A!19n995d22,h,o11w99l693o3,n, sgsodmoideywmohueerreoamawoarouiuhnnndndetthharertrepe.o. stion? | 21.whEEicnhvinrodnimvveniithhseIearamitltsohhaoonarnny"dd.nssaaffeemltyymmeaannanaggeesrtfoorr 2 Q. 43 GA 3 A. AAAAnyynededaawhrhroaaawnntdldohanangahtdaai.ldf. ypowuirephmreasienpeincntthiaotydpoousrition?| 43 AQ. DwIInhondidcyuuhssottduiriiovarlilesMcMioaiilnnnl?eewrrahaIa~l'mtPPrsryoooedradruryuc.ctwst.a.sthatyou 6455 Q A oemTAmp1nopld0lookwyyammhneaeontntwht aatrptoaptahetwantieppdhoowNinnoitt?dh?hroerspneEctntvoiycorumorntal| 65 A. Do you recall what year it was a2c0or0qh20a10ut2newiporsiteon? acquired that new position9 that you 8677 A a I took a new role ToNcohhmeoorgni?es. Technologies. with Northern Environmental 8677.A 2001 or 2002. Anydehrowlongdid And how |ong did you you remain remain in in hatthat posion?| position? 199800QAA... WUUhNhneo-rnrhthuueehwnr.na?sthat? 15890 0. enAAApnnlyddeotaythhrm.oenennwwhhatathtehhnaa?ppppeenneedd wihwith respecttoyour respect to your 11111102.AQA..NANW onewhdwetBrBerargiwtghahiesloosntnhi,,anMMtsi?innpnnopesscrototaa.x. mat19e9l4y7 t0 112I1 AA. TtehThronhopeinlne!yIwmwmaeasmsaanpthPppepaoniole?ninilteeeddsnaaCssotntchhtereoCCltoAogmmemmanicissys.sioinneraoorff 11112334.0AQA._. YYAAeennssdd.hthoawt lwoansgin6dapyporuoxriemmaaitenlyin 19a9t47posi?| 111123430QA... the Minnesbta PoIlulion Control Agency. TAhnedehopwllsoynegarsid. youremain i hatposton? And how long did you remain in thal position? I4 Q. 1156.A 15 A. AAAAbnbnodo~uutthtaeoaywnyoweuloarhnr,,gtyydeaPidaarrpayaponneuddnreeadbmahwlaaililnf.h. in that post|ion? respectto your 11115645 AQQA.... UCTUnohinrrtrkeiloec11tp999l9u86s. im sory, 20067 yea~s. -- !'m sorry, 2006? 11117678 Q. A eeTAmhmnpedlnopt!yhtmeloneoknowtahayatantittmehahwaatertppoppnlooeienntwnet?tdhwi3th respect to your Company. [| 11116787 @.A. Q. 2ACA0n0ondr6dr7eadcidt.iyoualeayveMoMPPCuCAA Itinn..wweaassaitt, JJvuunneeeooff 21110899 AAQ..AATAsnhnadednwrwhIhatoateot krooaofemnwweawas--estrohothcaleitadu?tw?olityha,3wMtaCsoamopsaoninyo.r | 21110998. A0A.. W2CC0hoo0no,6e-r?cnetc6.t.d you tartworkingfor Koch? 22221120 /L ereAnngsgioianneeremeermrwweaiidtohhiafdt3icioMonantht-h-aaattmaticssntppiuaeeatccfeloiydai,sliziiztnteeweddsa.isinna senior 22221102Q.AAQ_.. ASSWneehdpetpe6nmdtdbiydeeoryuomoo-fufb22ws0e0et0a0r6rr6et..ywoourkienmgpflooryKeodcbhy?anyone 22223623 QAQ.". rAe1Anr0nnadedhytiheaaatetitowwr1ra0aoc0sri6icnnooanwptpoappumrlorinxdoaimhsteaaidvteomsblayitoe1to1s9n=9o.99l66y?7 [122220323 Q. And did you -- were you employed by anyone A bNeot,weIewnasJnuanro andSeploomfb20e06r7 between June and September of 20069 2245_QA.. f1i9ndhyoewsl, o1n9g96iidt woyouulrdehmaavienbien ethna.tposito|n2?4 2A5_Q._. VNioe, lnwyaosunsotta.rtedworkingfor Koch,whatvas 25 Q. And how long did you remain in Page 38 that position? 25 Q. When you starled working for Pagodo Koch, what was 21TAA. IvInnottaihnadtppaarrrtoitcaueyleararrppso,osbsiittiaoonnowtwe.o ----bbeo~w.weeennPage 38 2I1 A.tDthhieerpapcoosoritioofnysEyoouuntwweserreierhihoriroeedndHnionnmtatoo?e? snndtPSaaafgeelt4y0 42 3 3 Q. Q. two and three years, t believe. oAnncphlenoynomthehtansptpooianncttd? wih And then what happened with espocttoyour respect to your | 4323 A. Q. ICCDsoomimtrpehplcalattioantrnchcoaeepf..Envoironsymoeuntatael oHseialnltihn?and Safety 5645 AA_meoTTmhnhpeeglnnoeyIHrmtooeooofnkktEaaanntvntothewoawtnrmpiooeeleinnwwtti?iatthOhpiinenr3aMtCoCoromsm.ppaannyyaa5s a| 455 AQQA... . Is that the HNoowlong No. position you 6dyouhald are still heposi in? ton cf 7567 .AQ. manager of Environmenlal Operations. Muannhaognerof EndeonvmenalOperations? Managerof Environmental Operations? 876 7 Q. How tong did you hold~ the l~osition of DCiotmcptloonocfoE? nronHemalesanndStafelty Director of Environmental Health and Safety | 19890 A. aUnshw-heurhRMo. uARt.RiAMoRwSMTSR]-ORONNGG:: Youhaveto You have to 18990.AA. CAUUonnntmditilplDwlDihaeeanctcecehm?aebpepmreoonbffe22de00w00ir6t6.h. respect toyour 10 1112 AQA._ answer out loud. eThsankyou. And Yes. atinusppraocmsaly | 11141102 Q= And what happened with respect to A.em1p6l0oKym8neontw hoeln?as theDict cf employment then? yot=r 12 Q. 5"A 13 Thank you. And tYoemsmor wee? 1998 or 1999? that was in approximately 11112334 A. QI CCIoetmmotphoplak~atiatnahcnneoeere.w.leroyleouarsethien Director new? of 111145850AAQ... DYdDooeoysny.oto.uuhrroeencceaastiltwwyh.haatRt yeeaiarr??mhagvebheetna 11114556AA.Q.. TYhOIskhaatathyta'.sstcGctohooiermrneergcoctlbt_eaycokuu'repinotnhowf?stpositon 16 71817 A. Q. Idon't, honestly. It might have been a Aenbahtowiloanhgatdndprayoturomainin st poston? fittle bit later than that_ | 11118767. Q. Okay. Going back up to the first posilion pyolioonuormtoleswhnipchetwacsiwbieigohianhinlengeoPCdAas. you mentioeed, which was with the MPCA as a 21110089 Q_ QA.A_ AFFAnonoddrrathyahooeywmaerwl.ohnagt daidpypoeu nredmwaiinhrinetshpaetcpotosiytioounr? [11128990 A. pollution control O1r9s8o,maibgehr?e 1986, all right? specialist beginning heroabouts in 20 2212! Q_ And then what happened with respect to ,your AsmTphoeynmlomnovvedra?rowresnciwaste employment lhen? !222(~102 Q.A. Q. Or somewhere thereaboets. Ooknay.What MPGAlocaton Okay, What MPCA location 8ddid youwork you work out out 22223236" A. eohTnehvnieirnnodvnoImsmrteoinvooteaMdlnihtonemaealtohoneaPawnrnnodddrstouslceaotlfsaetntDhydimmoIsowanonoaonagsgetterhrfehfoorr 22(222334. AAQ... WoTTf?hhh.eeoSSL.ti.PdPayauoulul rofefifpiccosretiitnnoM,Miwninnhneoeswsoatoatsa..yourdrect 224 winnow the Industrial Mineral Product~ Division 2245 Q. sWuhopdei~ryaotvutihreatpsotoirtmtreo?, who was your direct 25 within 3M. supervisor at that time? 22110000.33r1d AAvveennuuee NNoorrt1th-h,6,0SS0uu-ii6tt3ee899.66D00E"P*BBOi.irrmmiinngghhaamm,, AAlI 3355220033"* 1-800-8BS-DEPO 10 10 ((PaPgeas33g77tteoo44s00) D`CIOCSNTOFRIINDCEFTNCITOIDAURLET--N,SSUTUNBOBI.JJEEA2CC7LT-TCTTVOO-1A0A-PP28RR3OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 33MW_MN0N00000433441166 2277559..00111111 bom cun n sce EQU|PMENT AND R~AGEHTS o -- roe--m--m-- BA EASEe E teATrtent A e E E m r C pT I R e e TA eEr eEmECeg Bemoe croccp zosunnsmeAT.EN : bsg pe earstree mmo B B e eDSt B E RSENSIAR ET p ER e R b TrReE ed) E an te hp samtte 0 .2 re CSONFeIDENCToIArLoSUBJ3E7CTovTi0AoPRsOTECTIVE OROER ENTERED I HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111122 suunonnesa7 3M MN000434t7 caLcuLaTIon "J oma AE "8mrvispydo. SUT Bscm cy 1 1 Ct BEM Lt AER Se ALA Eafe H L30T 0, arE c.198,RwCeecs.dSkClt TobdmeershofCCatodCPorgsHh 3 101 135 CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARL-LT-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T-TCTTVOO-A10A-PP28RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111133 33MU_MMNN0000004433441t88 an Emon Labora CooppiiJeoss ooff CChhaaiinnaoofbf CCuRusostqtoouddeysy,t, sSShhiippppiinngg Papers, Papers, Lab Requests tos 1s DC`ICSOOTNRNFIFICIDTDEENCNOTTIUIARALTL--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-10AA.PP26RR8OO6TT2EECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775509..00111144 aW_uNoo0s241s 3M MN000434t9 pL Cprinmse esea nnp, ions C wm et nete pinor ar |11 comeatoneof wacersemen S- on,i! P=-E i! VV SPw oE h|. . -Ttncby ity ma so et a No. 38-97: } re i148s 1i, ny 1 !!h.. :' ~m ac eaya vermis oa ie tt com re : BiH [UR i~LL| ee prsaen 1!Deoisrm csromoie ie owe lLteeom - ok 4155 san GCSOTNRFIICDTENCToIUARLTSoUNBGJE2C7T-T100A 2P8RO8T2ECTIVE OROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111155 auunommezizo 3M MN00043420 Ea! ee | Glee NEL [CNS [- ofl N Se ee rm a iISR ! N7OP mE mi cme le ol LE i H W p P] ii ET >] i i B Tn ERE H EE 8 Ki BI RR of] A HE R es r hs]Hh a esoon|[F] ib Ea EE B He srr_ e Ff was i | ea 1] s i| | ll] R Hii Big id ib 1 | ph LA i #il | BPIrAFDBHERE 080 S Sih sma 1 Tosforet. COSNIFRTIROIECNTTCIOAULRT,SUNoB.7JECTCT100A2P0R8O3T2ECTIVE OROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111166 Su_Nooossaz1 3M MN00043421 we SIERR . Shtp co dP a 3 mEov--tr--oc--mental TecA hanlogy & |pIenance ob to. 30-aTIRONR -=o w irv e ms Dams ec i-s ! roa. ti o , wee - rh comaeaesot sepia a oh eo " - w "ooohnn|| ,:woo|: =; =PE n| Sony |"Po.nosoo -tbtoiVyisat oh 5 et on Ll --- npr wam v s en tVsra ein -= eneier ren 08 Ear cn ---- - @i i weston! irae l&e- on le Ly os oa of as CCOINTFRIIDCENCTOIUARLTSUNBoJE3C7TT.01A0.P5R8O6T08ECTIVE OROER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111177 a ncoosszz 3M MN00043422 m " ecue tee ctnsie QaPncoe mnerstmennen -- iHE -- : Sem or coor" Db EcaeneBdeTrriet2oF TsweeTrlen oL n 5 [L 317 Ue cre om viens any 3m : sone 13-015 : pe B SRT Ce Ne y 3 cu cer ------------------ CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111188 S-- 3M MN00043423 fa ae Ba : |ai5Hi2l LLL ete et A PHELH LES TIEtRe = = piebd FEpeE||LTH 3NEMAH 572% ee I(ENRERS EEhepak LIB 3) | idl ii ! 3 AEE RR HhAHo ! WEAK CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00111199 |111 II II 3M MN00043424 om ETEEE . - nu noe Ship to 4a I Bavicommental Tachnology & a Service Laboratory, 32-36-08 ios o62e/m , Ising we. aw9mmvson on 933 tr ! ron P DSS IV.O.S. wn ; ~ to cana] reste Code/ Daseripeion ~ Joe wr a 1) Coolacs contatotng water samples water 6 166 )! 40 each On wo " 'h 5 oa - hi ww N\h ,\h1\ -oo - - ohy1 1 on hh oa -eta ty aod Ltn, Orr: le, Bis 42 bode m"ni Fa ca tn -- CP ottp e osp 1 " pFastvs iter -on pnraisr rie on. Co 1 nmacrrise tp on ore, i. 4 - ! ion eon J ia + AToRTEATIGN 40 tnow e Le ont I~, bL y Lt im wo sas | CDCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-Tl,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.T0TTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00112200 au_uNooos3ezs 3M MN00043425 i COOTER | ERR | [TNINE HEHE8 | iein IB E P EEE a E i i EEREEE HY & i } HHH =F i i I | er i H I brge 1 I errr g i B eF se E e sBti W L H T i Teee Ti CER HE Ef | CEN sears u fl | | CE | sane| ! HTH] IH I] HHH i NLC dE Ep ii a i& 3 ; 3i LT {Ll. CTONFRIDENCToItAkLTSUNBoJEiCT ToOA PsROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00112211 Sonnesezs 3M MN00043426 `Court ReporMMtEEiRoRRnRgII"LLLLLegLLaEElVGGiAAdLLeo$SgOOrUUaLLpThTIyIOOTNNraSSil Services Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services Page 41 Page 4t PPaaggee 4433 21A. DKKuaattnhyygSStwwhaatnndmsa. hat youre Potton 2t1 daindyyywooauuyhwhaaavvheeaaanfnyyaccocontnttaaicncttWioarnivsnvohollivvenemCmgeoentuntnioitnntyn, :533 During the time that you were a Pollution Ciontmr oSpalcoaflvastn1oy.kmaiddyewoiuhnhaStvHe?any. Conlrol Specialist I. did you have any 432 3 any way with a facility in Washington County, MLinannodsoita.knownas he Wostingion County Minnesota, known as the Washington County 5455 .AA. inNNivooo..~nemsentpof apr~1y9kr8in8drowoilhx,3hMme?nayotubelcayme| 545 AAQ._ DLutladrngiidddnfinnlglo?toth. at sampridofte, cidyouhav) 6787 Q. In approximate|y 1988 or so, when you loacPaotlolnioiniGonrMoP!CSApcordee?I,6dyour a Pollution Controf Specialisl If, did your became 7567 Q_aafnnDayyuciritinnvgkonltvheamtvnsaeansmttcoooehrrecpcWoheoonrwnitootadadecbcottnuifirnnmtiymaanneLyoy,wadwaindanyayy?owwuititthhhaaave 18950, 0AA.. IoNNYocoo.a.uliocnowninthuinedMiPoCwAorchkacnugieo?fhaSLPau |1089. AA.. facility known as the Woodbury Landfill? Dludridnngotthatpint tm, hatsomepoint I did not. 10 1121 i Q. You continued AofCfosmcoone? office, correct? to work out of the St. Paul I 10 1412.11 Qw. tthiimDmieuerbiybneeogttuwwthwoeaoectnnrpeo11oi99nt88t68MianaPntniAmdd.eaa,pdptiphpdrayortoxosiumaxmiaatemevalpey1ot1ia9en9n8tl9yi00ny,, i2 A. 1"3 AQ. 13 Q_ Correct. ANno.dwas your And was your immedi supervisor immediate supervisor hesame? the same? | 11113234. fawiinchviiolnelkvyeomvunewnoteooorsaerclcoawonttrthM~vaetanPc3ctCte1iAinnC,aamhdnnideyywymewaooauyynwhwpiaiavttthenhtaaanoyr 111140550AQA... WWNWahOhy.ooneodiiAddnyycooeuurrsreoepnpo.rrt otoaatt hatthatpon? point? 11115645 facility known as the 3M AColtadgoe Grorepint? Cottage Grove plant? Chemofite plant or 111178670AQ.. rHWHooeawwyn,sieifapAatntadolelI r-nsa-wow5hnsha.3atitPwwoebeurrioeaoyynoetCuurorponaprrasidocilcuuilaarr 11117876 A. (3 WthIWdha ihMdyyentddoriiotdd.pyyaOobLut~ aelenaaCvvoeeuMMnPCcC?AAtotobbeeggiimnwworokrikningg for 18 2019 A. responsibilities as a Po~lutior} Control SIpuevdoteoiasnidroded ho 305)ror which Specialist I? (11128990 AA. aAtnhAegtt otMhogeeetttdriiommnpeeo,a,ltintthhaoenoffMMCoroeatutrfnotocpcirolu?lsioteadnpoCCnooouounincngtici-llawtwaoanmss 20 2212:21 A. I wrote and edited the 305(b) report, vahich Ai casreocoomaqcuiunadderwrahteurCslmeaamnpeWlafotonserAtct. is a requirement under lhe Clean Water Act. |22221102 Awwennaagtaerargssesuupdappgilpnoylyaonpoplgleaainfnfnsonirinntwggfaoffcsoourvrstetehhrdeaymomnoneetrftoroeonsrgtre-eetgegdi~iooirnnnn.. 22222603 cpAcolonmamdnpspif.laiaaAlnsanocoocdcpopululperrcpoetosegsedaesrwsdfafootrerswrwhostaasssmnsleaupwtleeaaestresfvorwotrroelaitmmeenntt |22226233 ttAthhnaatdt..haAAsandeadgitealhaollolssotoogoi|aasltlhlloo1aowwdwegaedrdsomovmoenemrofy1do.oiwniuuhtcesioerecnsssaoottemmgdtoehioneoff | 2245 as oerbesum or amps plants. And I prepared fish tissue as well 25__PolutonControlAgency.Solohelphe. 24 the learning that I had gleaned while at the Pollution Control Agency. So to help the 25 as other lissue for enalysis. Pogo 42 25 Pag1e4 21TQ.Q coAAtnnded.c, oaogdgawaiionns,nfnooovnomeoaofnfttyhh3eewMwaaatteo~crskasma:pmtlephsltyPyoooasuuge |42 21 pplrlaanannniionnggfefvfoort. oCoupncs,ath twas wainiPnnahge.44 332 3 collected AcNomer co rrect? was from any 3M facility; is that 432 3 Q. The Metropolitan Council, this was within ACTawrnrCotiysesr.eaIsof Mreogioonlalap?loning Twin Cilies a~ea of Minnesota? the 5645 .AQ..fDsNDitoiddo. tyyoaoluu,evwvoeerrrecctoootllesecetasaumnryyfwawactaeetwerarstsaaemvrpelses -- 4 A. 56. 5 C~rrect, yes. It's a aWuasrt.hopaybor authority. regional planning at teMetcpoltan 876 7 A first of all, sCamopnietss samples? were these surface water 576 7 Q. A Was the pay clobseierveo. Council? better at t~e Metropolitan 19 890 AQ.. WSCWhpoheerrecenncaty_ysoo.uubbeoecwcaa,mmaee aatPPoolilultutteionyn,oCuCoronnttrodl 19890 0AQ_5HIaHbaaedMdliPyeyoCvoueuAshhopaar.ddioarann1yyngneoegngagaitvioveetrhreeevvMiieeewwosspbobylyaiananyynoonneeaatt 11111012 A rSreTopmssepopcovoinaensldsisitbiloiilIifitt,ihoehesso,wccwhh,haaiafnntaggtseeca'~?lol, ediddbyoounrengont I 0 1[112 A the MPCA CNoo.mer Council? prior !# going to the Metropolitan 11112343 A. I moved to the, what's calle~ the non-point spourrcepiwotiitmosnacunioc.awgaatyer,fbouctuhsoesdewas source pollution unit. again focused 111[12330 AQQD..inNDdoiid.dyyaooluushhaayvvoeeuwaaonnyryedfwifofuickLit~nltigeswwwiiithhhaoanlnyIooPffChtAhoe 11115485 rapaolrwwivmaaoyaywsrsoilydalwggorirtcohaousnuwudanrwtfdaeacerteerprcwlcoaonmtmeprfpo,oonbrneucenotnntthts..eirsAAetnnowdnda|cIsy 111[14558 individuals you were working with at MPCA Cotulnacdi?oyougonglotha etopaitan Ihal led to you going to the Metropolilan 11118778, 0."wwtrAeihttvhiasenswotyaetttdeinmlorueeclwaeslshowianandtdyerorreuopgwlsauontlrasektifoeorndrsscf.oornsiPstCenAcbyetween 1117867. AQA.. CounciI? ANleigh. No. Wile youwere at met 211099 Q. At any time while you worked for MPCA between y1o98u6suanrdeawporekicnsg fiormta1h9et9iy0t,othpapaoanntwhen 198,6 ~nd approximalely 190, the point when 2[1118909 Q. All right. While you were at the met we,DldetymoaubavcekrueponmwoimhenMta.tar well, lel me back up on moment. 2212 you started working for the Metropolitan tCoaucnhindMd yaouhvaveeansyaschaoirntgawocntwCaoiunnsnty Council, did you have any cor~ta~ with a 2(2221102 Did you ever intern with 3M at any A.piNon.in mowhoyouwereaf colege" point in time while you were at college? 22222336 facility in Minnesota ir= Washi#gton County AJo1oawdonoa.s theOodle disposal ste? known as the Oakdale disposal .~ite? 22225233 Q.A. Q. Wi[WNdhyoh.ioileuyoyoovueurwwheeraerveeaaattnthhyeWnMveelttvroeopmoeplnittaenoClrCoctouuoannaccncil,.h 2245 0A.. Ddyou i d~d not. cum hatsamepofrtomde. |2245 witrepreofSsMoenanny stess? did you ever have any involvement or contact with representatives oF 3M on any issues? 25 O. Did you -- during that same period of time, 25 1111 ((PPaaggeess 44111to04444)) 221100~0 331rdd AAvvoennuuse NNoorr"tt1hh-,,8SS0u0ui-itt8ee5899-66D00E"*PBBOii.rrmmiirn~gghhaarmm,, AAI[ 3355220033"* 1-800-888-DEPO D`CCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUALRLT--,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7-TTCTTVO-O1A0A-PP28RR3OO6T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 33MW_NM0N000040433442277 22775599..00112222 i TN EHR Lil fe I DVR | ies | I [INR jFE==EE=R=EeRaEr s=EESkyb; i t HHH i i EET EET I EET WEE i J H errE r T od f H Hii SEE a Te memes a + rior | iE ACr OOTR ES ii SH HH FH ee IN] HH sl CE [ance] 5 A Pr 2635; swewe| HH I | Te 1i R ! i i| ,i ; 3 i: LLC H|Liien CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..001123 3M MN00043428 NN B 7 I TRTTTITIIR| El i | EEE em i PSR=asEsm) mssdEcl (RE i | | WP l EEl E aRseaad i i 5-3 & i | A Err EEE - Frere 3 iE 5 ee ih | ifT oY ee S b ST T E ]R fms ih I HHH TT i [PEE ERE k eee fal EERERNNR: weit i I COoH it i117 i i \ i: LLC | 1H 3MAOO23OZ42 II I m CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00112244 3M MN00043429 [ThHPHCHHbREe 2IThId. I i |N]NF| ES(EEE EEE EEEE RErreREe ii 3 HE E i i i E EErrrrrEd i q Ee I A Er I; S I EE i B 8 H Oe 3i E I CT ) T T CJT er 3 Tl R TT eT n]n[esmr a] i52 FFEEEHR lefnoree -- FEET [osnae i | Eo E n| i |]% i i: | LL ;: HH :1... CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00112255 3M MN00043430 SHE i[l TNTTRHEEEE sfiellet 0| E FE EE E ah] eR ey | | i m HFE EEEHH TEETFtE BEH : ETHRr ]ee] I1 sLE] EHR | ei Xa 5 IT H EH rHH H; oe i; 3ido| [8 1 fi, 1 i LTT HH CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..0011226 3M MN00043431 H= e I TNA HHT HTE LITT. {[| |||LEE) il EEE Ee 5|1 | BEL EEE | [T BF F Er E E RE| PE ST ee| 4 I NEE rrrke il S: HHH HHA i] ' [1] i] reo HHH [es iIF i NCO F : i LR of] CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..0011227 3M MN00043432 TTA ; i i (IL x OT 1 ; HHH FOE TaeTEe H bE[&pn | 1 [RE Thi FER 51 "FE i =i] 2 4 TTI SLL 1 ok HII y Ie | ! | : ULL Tre 33% Fa | ng gn CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00112288 3M MN00043433 SE: ] I A IiH ] H mi n HHI ai |` C HE HH T mi edi 3i IITs [CNR 2 FH) SE 2: LITO ei I WTAE en2 BN 3 oz! CCOONNFFIIDDEENNTTIIAAL-L- SSUUBBJJEECCTT TTOO AA PPRROOTTEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY. DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..0011229 33M_MMN0N000004433443344 - on SITE Bla t"oEvteemenet series tiboraeory, Teiegy b!s 123505! praia Gi a sem.> - 293 Bhtv osc. rm, Miron S510 ! iro. Ppp o - . , an mots eee tent Peoducs Code / k wo Description :- Ha " 1 onl aE td smn | sen Jem wl ""onnh n - n1o!o " wh "w on ! h"n . =n h " '- | e" tc1 Tp BeDutcfir nAe Ny --~ ormtcp(ontvcotae EinscosrRerazn1200 Thon s0t6a13 ? es ven segtens - Peacces ores so te urn |! tre | wm tats x casromos on 0 Bp om pvor"e re 4 'ja Jr-- eo oo @ Ly svmoRzzATion vr 2 ion LbI br !1i.n a1 gas wom DCCIOOSNNTFFRIIIDDCEETNNCTTOIIAUARLL-T-,SSUUNBOB.JJEE2CC7T.TCTTVOO-10AA.PP28RR8OO5T2TEECCTTIIVVEE OORRDDEERR EENNTTEERREEDD IINN HHEENNNNEEPPIINN CCOOUUNNTTYY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775509..00113300 3aMM_UMNN0000004433443355 flTRIREE TEpEesE LFE RRIE I] Diet ig || | RE EFEs REE a | kBE [RE NSR F F EL l Tae t TH"Ti E(3B ES i FEE emo wo= aor 3 i Ni H T R]fe | i i PEHEEEEE| Ey {TR renee HEAR R]aarmee EE i | HHH I i |B TW i ; ES| i LETTE; LA)Lo CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00113311 3M MN00043436 TR ERT Ihe PEE il 4 I [BH EE dFp |i EE re = Ne> HHHI HeEb Er]eLm s ] ` I C CHTEE eed [fmlaen--e1 n|Hzipesee ] BR AH [1 5 ALL ITT fe 1H | CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..00132 3M MN00043437 MERRILLLEGALSOULTIONS MERRILL LEGAL SOULTIONS Coun RoparioVidneoggra'phLyTraoilgSoarcels Court Reportiong*Legal Videography*Trail Services Pages Pag4o7 Page 45 Page 47 1A dante. tombsso. RT ---- 1 I don't recall. ! don't believe so. 1 Q. And during the time that you wore working for 20. Woy ayo me th aeolCioawrna | 2 ht conyoa u prov nry Why did you leave the Metrog~olitan Council to 2 that consulting firm, did you provide any 5% vesg o sain i | 3 Sirontotra Swen? 3 begin working in Seattle in approximately 3 services to the 3M Company? ioe 3 0 Vado tui adsoesavesto 4 1992 ? 4 A. I did not, although I did provide services to 5 A ostresors.iyhaardnhsd gon 5 th hy Wash, 5 Personal reasons, My h~sband and I had grown 5 the City of Woodbury. 5" soCo mRaa ate h:n 5 0. cuntsomes you provi 6 L~p in the St. Croix River Valley, which Js 6 Q. And what services did you provide to 7 orenuatind Anime wot | 7 Von? 7 where wP. lived. And we thought it woukt be 7 Woodbury~ 2 mesingammesana [5 a Votes 8 interesting to live in a new place. And 8 A. Well fie~d analysis. 5 Sommommoymia bots. | 0G. Ansthals he Oyof och,Mencsa, 9 Seattle was very inviting from thal regard. 9 Q. And this is the City of Woodbury, Minnesota, 10 oa seheaposnton Bang Comyn [10 comet? 10 And, again, the position that King County had 10 correct? TH omens shawnatoms 119 a Cone 11 open was very atlraclive to me [rem a 11 A. CorrecL 3 eamasenmmen 12 Q. Vofet dsnco aityou 12 learning perspective. 12 Q. What kind of well field analysis did you demi manotimess [18 prover 13 I had spent a fair amo#nt of time, as 13 provide? T4 younamovnyosseerepsn, | 14. A. Look ottheiwe sping ani ie you have seen, working in water planning. 14 A. Looking at theirwell spacing and in their 18 Soin may oe batpatcrkoguetr, [15 suingwell 15 And in the early '9Os that particular region, 15 existing well field. 16 hoPugetSomareponwasandcorns.| | 16. Ary ating 0 he cing ater 16 the Puget Sound region, was and continues, I 16 Q. Areyou referring to their drinking water 7 baermuons opoegomans | ve 17 believe, Io experience explosive growlh and 17 well? Curse isnt ahhhcrskeate | 18. A. `Comet 18 changes in tand use, whic~ have considerable 18 A. Correct. To inantonsutachuaasctor nia | 16. Q. hywashe iofWoodyyour 19 impact on surface water resources. And lhe 19 Q. Why was the City of Woodioury, to your teen | eens sa 20 position 1hat I was -- that I took at King 20 knowledge, Io~]king at that issue at that 5 Comesomc mg oomewwn (21 panting? 21 County was engaged in trying to come up with 21 point in time? 52 oocnno mortetmomsgsess [23 A. `ToeGyofWass, tate minth 22 engineering -- innovative engineering ideas 22 A. The City of Woodbury, at that time and in the 53 oumaomatmpoutormeet [78 cuentine saga iniergaaing 23 to ameliorate the pollution concerns that 23 c~Jrrent time, is, again, undergoing quite Te amas eager gon [23 arpa grout Ard veychihna 24 were the result of the explosive growth, in 24 expansive growth. And every city in their 55 oussimmgtotmemoraosain __|25 mioyrs ave tomse re ht Page 46 Page48 25 parficular, trying to save the nalive salmon 25 Page 46 municipal systems have to make sure that they Page 48 1 aint 1 hive cru worfor rrlane coc. runs in thal area.. 1 have enough water for their planned capacity, 3 Vstnern an crnsaiapy whey matic| 2 forth haha at hy ave ht 2 Q. Was there an increase in pay when you went to 2 for Ihe -- lhe plan that they have in their 3 voposton Sever 5 Comprfoantnpaarinng storisavnd 3 the position in Seattle? '3 comprehensive efforts, planning efforts and Da umeatos 4 A. No. 4 that's why we took a look at it. 5 Q Wokesusosoinpor? 0. "SomaCty olwoorotdsnedbNortrher 5 Q, Was it a decrease in pay? 5 Q. So the City of Woodbury retained Northern A Kwaiasecome babecoualliog | 6 ErvicomenilTochigi todo ewan 6 A. It wasn't a decrease, but the cost of living 6 Environmental Technologies to do this well 7 atest oer St 7 ornbecome 7 was quite, st~bstentially higher in Seattle, 7 work; is that correct? 5 0 wyddyaipeoimsonoSneseto | 6 A. Uru. 8 Q. And why did you leave the position in Seatlle 8 A. Uh-huh. 5 raganoNorrmkannEmgoninaort | 6G. hndwhotinpwaastiocslmr 9 to begin working for Northern Environment 9 Q. And what in particular was Nodhem 1 Tanimcoyoed naa root [10 EnvtonmarlTechiessodadol 10 Technology back in Minnesota in 19947 10 Environmental Technologies asked to do for 11 A roan. potsd rtesioniromes. | 11 thaGyr 1t A. Again, personal and professional reasons, I 11 the City? 1 vat ny ower Sota oa |12. A. Sut tespc bts hk 12 had had a baby while we were in Seall_~e, our 12 A. Just look at the spacing between their 13 otc Amomenadnolambyceagson | 13 ramcopakaswsrebatrrse first child, And we had no family or support 13 murticipal wells to make sure that there To en. Anas nbommona |14 vou baan sacan raat a5 system. And so it.iust became more -- i~ 14 wouldn't be any significant drawdown as a 15 bucmemooaprons oom [15 remioottsgoonn 15 became more important for us to be back in 15 resu~l of any further growth. To Domaesiatewetatsaosn 10. nyower the Enisnmontt 16 the midwest after we had our son. 16 While you were at Northern Environmental 17 et iawkoeas ohrgoammetnt [17 Technologie dou porswoorneanyh 17 And I also had worked Io~ governmenl 17 Technologies, did you personally work on that TM xonesomatmemsreonn proses 18 for quite some time at various different 18 project? To lo gonas ardiocate ovaiond [10 A108 19 levels, state, regional and local level, and 19 5 rindtom tnoptescr 20 nawer.toyourknow t mores 2O was ready to try the private sector. 20 And were, to your knowledge -- tel me restate 21 0. "Wo rranncmeoorsosoraet0 5 Som 21 Was there an increase in pay going to 21 that_ 72 NoteEmoTens 2" toyourkoonwtasaNcosgtnor,n 22 Northern Environmer~tal Technology'?. 22 To yet~r knowledge, was Northern 25 Vertrosaonil 2 CoomeraTocologassso oo any 23 Yes, but not ;ubstantial. 23 Environmental Technologies asked to do any 240 Andee ms ammocontig? [24 saiofotro vetss mas 24 And was this a private consulting firm? 24 sampling of the water Woodbury water wells 25 A tie apmaioapeuting tyes 2 foranycontomonrnyinndf? 25 It is a private conselting firm, yes. 25 for any contaminants of any kind? 213rd0Ave0nue North,Suit060"BimingAh3a52m0,3" 12 Pages 51048) 2100 3rd Avenue North, Suite 960*Birmingham, AI 35203* 500580.DEP0 1-800-888-DEPO 12 {Pages 45 to 48) CGCIOOSNTNFRIIDFCETINCTDOIAUERL-TN-,SSTUUNBOIBJ.JAEE2CC7LT.T0T1TO.O1AA0.PP2RR8OO8T2TEECCTTIIVVEE ORDER ORDER ENTERED ENTERED IN IN HENNEPIN HENNEPIN COUNTY COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 aw_unoooszess 3M MN00043438 22775599..00113333 le] 5 f BEE |] | ii SRE CbET] i -- I i statin EE lTIiTeSgethe iilah ual UDIITTER rr I CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 2759.0134 3161 MN00043439 Me | Lt I's |C LTH TI Ei| iT sT anT i W WITTT itfgPE ak: 1 4 ii EET IHITTIITT_F CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO A PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN HENNEPIN COUNTY DISTRICT COURT, NO. 27-CV-10-28862 22775599..001135 3M MN00043440