Document 5b906MboRq346yyGGgov18knD
FILE NAME Power Generation POW
DATE 1990 DOC POW031
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Mesothelioma in Power Plant Workers
$
Zmesos Zmesos Zmesos Zmesos
British Journal of Industrial Medicine 281-282
281
Asbestos related health hazards among power plant
workers
itvn
ironic -
house
linical olvent
dom-
-case-
-term Work
Mixed
idy of
ents on
hagen
effects
al fluid sure to
| 100
tides as
versen Menum
men i
Pr
atogra-
acids by
Idialde-
neuro-
669-78
acids
7-8
plasma -
587
9
tbook of em 2nd
aurine in
able RJ urology
update
jima H. > in lum-
iousness
and their
between
the hip-
lenod M.
ne in rat
cortex in
ree amino bethylene 1-7
Y Lerman A Finkelstein Y Levo M Tupilsky Mimi Baratz A Solomon G Sackstein
asbestos Studies of
insulation workers have shown - pleural effusion was present The attentuation
higher death rate than expected
due to malignant
mesothelioma Although asbestos has been
bers of the irregularly thickened pleura were con-
widely used in power plants to provide thermal insulation
siderably higher than the accompanying free pleural fluid The suggested diagnosis was of
for steampipes and turbines asbestos related health effects are rarely described
pleural mesothelioma The
extensive presence of a calcified
J workersand
among power plant Bonnell et al XVIII International
pleural plaque on the right posteriorpleural surface indicated exposure to asbestos in the
Conference on Occupational Health Brighton )
fig remote past fig
1975 We report two cases of malignant pleural mesothelioma in a clerk and an insulator worker of an
A pleural biopsy showed a thickened fibrous
electric
pleura partially covered by hyperplastic mesothelial
power plant
cells and fibrin Within the fibrous
stroma were
family failure Case report
bundles of spindle cells some with enlarged hyper-
year old man was admitted because of left chromatic nuclei These findings were interpreted as
4
pleuritic chest pain productive cough dysp-
consistent with cellular fibrous mesothelioma fig 2
The
noea and progressive weakness Past and
patient died seven months later from respiratory
:
..
history were contributory Family history was
a
bone - positive for
cancer and cancer in two Case report
=
=
year siblings The patient was a retired employee of a A 54
because old man admitted because because of recurrent -
.. , power plant where he had worked for years as pleural effusion He had been an insulator
. |. clerk until seven years before admission Before his
employment in
worker for . 31 years and worked the same power
:
the power plant he had been
as
the first patient He had no history of exposure to
construction worker for five years anda manager in asbestos On examination the patient
of . the
wood industry
for nine
years
No history
nourished and not in
was well- well-
|
- exposure to asbestos other than in the power plant
pulmonary distress Expansion
*
of the left chest was decreased The
wasobtained _
;
.
to
lunwg as dull
Ca,
On examination the patient was malnourished
percussion and breath sounds were decreased over
oS in
There
and the same A chest radiograph showed a massive *-
'
mild pulmonary distrmeasssses , tenderness or palpable
was no chest wall left pleural effusion - Pleuroscopy showed the -
On percussion the
;
sounds lung .left
field dull and breath
|
were gp
~ appreciably decreased chest radiograph showed a
left pleural thickening with effusion the right
hemithorax was normal A pleural tap yielded 800 cc '
pomevnr ' of haemorrhagic exudative fluid Histological
examination of the fluid showed many lymphocytes
histiocytes with few mestothelial cells
,
Computed tomography of the chest showed that
the left hemithorax was of small volume compared to the right There was circumferential crenated pleural
cncasement affecting the left lung and a left basal
Prnpeusma Israel Defence Forces Medical Medical Centre Tel Aviv Israel
Corps
Ichilov
Y A
Lerman A
Solomon
Finkelstein
Y
Levo
M
Tupilsky
M
Baratz
Israel Electric Company Medical Division Tel Aviv
ene rae G Sackstein
Figure Computed tomography of chest showing
encasement of left lung with thick pleural mass accompanied pboystpelreiuorralsuerfffaucseioonfpClaelcuirfaied pleural plaque is seen on right
282
Lerman Finkelstein Levo Tupilsky Baraiz Solomon Sackstein
station workers and J Bonnell 1975 Bonnell reported on asbestos related disease among 77 insula-
among
tion of workers an electric power station in London _
eight cases ofmesothelioma were described Another
survey of55 full time power station workers in
France showed that the risk of exposure to asbestos
was not confined to workers engaged in lagging
operations ferruginous bodies and asbestos related
o9
abnormalities abnormalities
mainly
pleural
thickening
and
lead cification were also present among workers in other
y
eSe!aco nee,at ly
,
y
G
the i)
Figure 2 Bundles of spindle cells within fibrous stroma ( Haematoxylin & eosin ^ 100
presence of 1500 cc of greenish exudative fluid and a gelatinous mass covering the lower third of the
visceral pleura diaphragm and pericardium Biopsy of the pleural mass showed malignant epithelial
mesothelioma with many Schauman bodies The patient received intrapleural treatment with
nitrogren mustard thiotepa and yttrium Itrium
and intravenous treatment with adriamycin An
abdominal tap of ascitic fluid four months later
showed malignant mesothelial cells He died 12 months later from respiratory failure
job categories Inrecent review Cammarano et al
reported on site specific mortality among thermoelectric power plant workers in Italy Eighteen
patients with neoplasms were observed whereas only
8.32 were expected There were five cases of lung cancer expected 83 but no cases of mesothelioma
workers exposure The nature of
exposure of the first patient reported
here is a low level long term exposure type Several
authors have suggested that even minimal
such as experienced by maintenance
by-
stander exposure or by neighbourhood or house-
hold members induce malignant mesothelioma The risk of asbestosis after this type of
~ exposure is minimal Under suchconditions of low
level exposure to asbestos cases of mesothelioma
serve as an index of the potential health hazards The
cases reported here emphasise the need for popula-
tion based studies among power plant workers to evaluate the risk accurately
Discussion
Thermal power stations produce electric energy by generators The generators are complex units consis-
ting of two principal units the boiler and the turbine The heat generated by the turbines and steampipes is one of several health hazards in power stations and
it is essential to provide thermal insulation Asbestos has been widely used for this purpose
Measurements of asbestos in air inside and outside
power stations show low fibre counts but higher
concentrations are found in storerooms where asbes-
tos is deposited and handled The asbestos related health risk in power plants was also confirmed by the presence of ferruginous bodies in the sputum of
power station workers.
1 Selikoff IJ Lee DHK Academic Press 1978
Asbestos
and
disease
New
York
electricity 2 Hirsch A Di Menza L Carre A. Asbestos risk
workers in an
among time
Acad Sci 137
45
power station Ann NY
3 Parmeggiani L ed Encyclopaedia of occupational health and
safety Vol 2. 3rd 1778-80
ed
Geneva
International
Labour
Office
4 Burger H. Asbestos fundamentals Origin properties mining
processing utilisations New York Chemical Publishing Com-
pany 1963
thermoelec- 5 Cammarano G Crosignani P Bernino F et al Additional
follow of cancer mortality among workers in
tric power plant Scand J Work Environ Health 631
2
Epler GR Gerald MXP Gansler EA et al Asbestos related
disease from household
229-40
exposuure Respiration 1980
Although asbestos related health effects have been well described among insulation workers only rarely have such effects been described
among power
7 Chen W Mottel NK Malignant mesotheloma with
asbestos exposure Human Pathol
minimal
253
8
Accepted 12 June 1989
British Jour
Hydr
conce
P J^/ppine
Hydrogen
several occi
mills P Ji refineries indicator of
exposure ]
are known been deterr combined u high conce
could be d method us
improved b sodium hyc
allows bloo trations and
hydrogen si Although
enzymes es thase ALA been repor
hydrogen si
been difficu sulphide poi present worl
sulphide cor thesising en
Material a There were
poisoning
Finland but cases origina The subject from about c
of Draeger :
after the ac
hydrogen su
hundred ppr
were most p
Occupationa
55800 Imatra
P J^/ppinen Department Helsinki Hel
R Tenhunen