Document 4vr5dB3yGzmweQxENxEarwpYV
Or Paul Kotin
George W. Wright, M. D.
rile
TtLZPHOrt OOWnSATIOB WZTH HIL90H LB*IMSC*M. 9/19/74
(1) tfco Tonwr trotter'* cohort has now boon anlrg*d
to 391 by bringing in thoao lndividwl* ooployod
since 1933 who hovo 10 or aore yooro ojqpoooro and
incroaaing tho porlod of observation frcx tte lato
'60`s to 1972. Itey have followed not only tho
--yloyooa atill on tho Job but alao thoao
hovo
loft oqploynaat.
Zn tbio cohort of opployaao vbo atartod tmk oinoo 1933. thoy hovo now rooordod coooo of a^ootooio ifltpioood by tho aora liberal criteria proposed by tho woxSBMn'a CtagianoaUon board of Oroat Britain, thoao criteria are oonoiderahly noro liberal than thoao originally otlllaod by Or. Boon in hie provisos observations on tho orleiaaieohort of 291. tony
good"ovidanoa thet*3oro boo boon a arteinitial *
a^ooura for thin papalatlow oppooially daring that
period batuoan 1933 and ptwh^ia 1960. Mna X apokn
about thin with Or. Lowftnoohn and ha agrooa with no
that there anet hovo boon o transition period daring
which tho fiber oooat dropped following tho institution
of tho renal atI one in 1933. Z have no pertain way of
knowing nnt thano ooonta any bavo boon bat on thn
bools of vhot X know abort other oboorvationo X weald
ogoet that thn earnto at tho beginning of 1933 ad pit
have boon in thn range of 99-100 fibers per oo and X
weald a^oct that even aa naoartly aa lad# 1990'a it
weald bevo boon annothlnp of thn otdnr of IS fihnra par. on*
wo know that la the nftdfio 1960-a whan Mrtratt filter*
worn bogianian to bo need and fiber r-utio ho node hr
tho Tamer brother's %gionloto tho oounto wore in no
neighborhood of 10 fibers par oo. Woroovnr. it ban
rosily only boon in thn period edbeogaoet to I960 or
1969 whan they hod n fairly high proportion of their oper
ation going et nolow 9 fihoro por oo. Z aake thoao poartn
boeaooo Z would antiolpoto that those individuals who
ore ohowiag any ovldonooo of oaboatoaia or of brondhn*
genic eanear and possibly
laotbolioan
V'
Dr. Paul Kotin Septaafcer 23. 1974 Page 42
persona ho am auposed in that pariod prior to 1990 or 1999 than Oa fihor counts war* aoch hl^or than oar currant atandard of 9 and tha projected etaadard of 2. (2) At prcaant there have bean 29 death# in the oofaort of 391 persons. On tha basis of tha Pritt-h national Statistics for a population of thie eras uaving the age dietrlbatlon that thla population haa they would have anticipated 40 daathe during the period of oboorraticn. this indicate# dearly that a haa bean eheerved in other induetrlal pepulstions the porting population in a ealected grew and been a louur nortality art wot during their worsting agea than la true of the general pohlic. Per thie feeon it ia aoneuhat lading ia validity to eeapara the patterae of Mortality in any uothiag population to dnt are cal lad tho Kattonal tatletice which le a population having a vaetly different nortality pattern.
an anaafa laud. Or. Inrineohn ie rending na this
k
Baal Kotin, M. D
23. 1974
fago 3
in gnttor 4aUU an noon u bn can. I Mkad
ecaelfically whether or net the eanoar deathe and
the naaotliaHoaia daatha had boon in thoaa people dn
had bean employed prior to 1935 and ho indicated that
hie recoil action in that thin wa the cane hot he will
look into thin and oak* satin*
he i errraet.
(3) Dr. lewinaohn explained to an how thin rennwnd interact
in the Tumor Brathafa emparlance cana atant. ha
that Tanada Telavinioa ban a progran call World and in thin they had intorrlawnu in. jailtoff on the
eabjact of Vinyl Chloride. Jkt that tine ha told than
luwi uv oBBUvftnr DtoiiiB mam MB BUlM and eoggoatad that they leak * the Tinner Brother' a atory. flranada Telewieloa ban dean no and they plan to have a telerlaioa ahow on thin adjwt. They haao
atandand lataar
nl^pad^^^ aatidBa
t^cnak ^hriknl^a. in
IKHSHS8S 5li!SSS!lS88S^--ji
} --u--i--i tin
JillllilllllifililillliiMJi
itiSiiUUfUitiUfiiUiiiUi
n*
z3
II
iS3?S$SmSi2S23$im?$8?IS
iH2Si!OSiiiiS!i!!ISI3i!
m +1
BOIMtlll C4M tflt
i
III
i Ax
i z*j Ac
x Kaj^L
J A*OX etJcm t*sJL AC* */ A* 4tK** *
<ki J*AdL
KUOAMAj JU*<f <UMcC 4
Cio4>t> JcaCB^ AitMC1* ^itCf i7*! A
4
^fll
r
fitA OK y^Ma 4*4^ fCa f<A> OmA /I04M OA<X XCkOX Qfcrt. yAx*w ouLjL o*JUmX> rr * *** b* C<>0QA4
469CAaJX<
7
/(a SfcT.
4" *3
04)^1 Ttfb* <*.
^ WC flfcCcC CA ^A. </4,M ,jj -l/-'` `-'t^ t #/jJ a *4 COxy /
A-*it 4MI A I /MxO Ca/e t<444M k-4 A.^g <amcu amC 4oa ou*ea o\< * -mo
/ .<M&Aut m iAxut 4caA-o /u*a *tfc ocKtX ********
AAJL + *Q**'*fc</kA*f*( 4***XCK *AjL C*C***M
4a
4weJU^c,
f-- f ^ 4U
Ao> cowfrf 6c
4I
ota A^ibcAcccb Aa Ac niu<jac ^ <u*y
cu>4* ** ^*m/ icm//^ ycUU. a Ac c4c# w<*
4Uu> 4ua . WxA J cUcuCUs* **Jt / t^ <U*c
*f
XCUtCCi Ac jWyMliiw 4/ M**A* ***** A u**g ..
4C**kA C*
AC Ax -nc64.*%'4i J*k*j*9 *J*r*
XX /<3% *UA<J*\JL A* *M C<lx/l Cjf 4m*iJ 4QiC^>
mx Ac toC/ce xo AftiCfc Ac wnftow / c/mami.
fc (CM cc.-4j 6c MC* 4acC Am ca^uxicmC m CHiicci^ /cacuccf. <JXc jkc^MftoM m ***ft+*J 4^
6y a Mi^uAt <a*icx< m Uxo Ma
^ A*- AC 6j/ c **Q4**f **4mC AAaacc m<w Ac AAkJL
xwmiA
cCmCU, </U cumAX *m***v6ca.
carte
A4 4^ AM^iCj/Wo&flt /tUvmttC CO.
*mu.C
AC Acm. x# at* coxAcxtc*
^<m<m m *40i/x114c /C<y yMCu> A*n Ac xcflowftf
mJ**iSu *f Ac ect<<^*iA6Xc x^oouAJL^ *U>
Acxfcict xL cXx cXxvC .
"
c_
^ ^f ^^wXXac
2&&L2 Qqmrtow tetvm Poll 19W on* TMt lf\
(Boll) 19JV5* (KL) 1*6-73
asr
75 4
Hotel
50 105 0 *5
ami Bcwtrlmii totw--n Poll 1W wnd Toblo
(Soil) 1935-52 (BCL) iyoo-72
not punt
TCT!^ 4
75 >0 105
4 25 *5 e
bocaflntl Pwltoimiy In/orratlon oa ?r--nt Op^atlm of Kaaz, lolMft iMll *fld frill (I968J---------------------------------------------
(Obaorrod and opei4 lat) fra all tjrpu f oanoar 1966.1972 la mb with 10 jnui or Born axpoaurt alaoa 1.133)>
total 499
Oaatha abaarvad
Daatha Espaatad
19
OWirud and aayactad daatha fra all oanoare la tka ay datad total population (l.a. anybody with 10 yaaxa or aera azpoaara (including varan) lxraapaatlua of yaar of flint arpoaara), batvaan 1964.1972.
total 1103
taatka abaarvad tr
Daatha Bcpaetad
CT.l
