Document 4aRQqKvMBmM1dbm9y7KV62zp

' /. --. - in the mtno states distict court FOR ns DISTRICT OF BANAll IN RE: ALL ASBESTOS CASES VOLUME VI Of VI (EXHIBITS 27-38) 11, a yi'' ; '' yj'-w ^ EXHIBITS TO THE DEPOSITION OF REAR ADMIRAL JOHN C. MCARTHUR ____________VOLUMES I, II, III 6 IV Taken on behalf of Defendants Keene Corp.; Pittsburgh Corning Corp.; Forty-Eight Insulation, Inc.; Garlock, Inc.; GAF Corp. and Ruberoid Co., at the offices Case, Kay & Lynch, 2600 Grosvenor Center, 737 Bishop Stree Honolulu, Hawaii, July 6, 7, 96 10, 1984, pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. L FIUBECX REPORTING SERVICE HONOLULU, HfMAtl M4-W33 AL102 9 ; BtvS .M&S-003208 Cl 1C cr \ DEPARTMENT OP THE NAVY riAXL ha aeon naval iniataao 1 HIM " winwwimiwii 'Pearl .Harbor,HI ; 96860 v. , |/* * W 006 46 Str 211-3021 19 Fab ruary 1979 ;From: 'Commander, Pearl Harbor Naval;Shipyard 1 To: . Coamandlng Officer, USS PREBLE (006 46) SubJ: Memorandum of Agreement Regarding Purl Harbor Naval Shlpyif Occupational Health Controls Ref: (a) Title-29 - labor - Part 1910 Occupational Safety and Health Standards (b) OPNAVINST 6260.1 , (c) NAVSHIPYOPEARIINST S100.1A. PKNS Safety Supplement2051 (d) * Nsm.Chapter 635,; Thermal Insulation ^ *4* ^'etorddhe^irtttrrfer4nes: (a)i^^Cb)r(c)'Ffani?(d)V Pearl Halbor aloped;ahdjestabl1shed|,.1nter1w criter1 and gherf! :#0-' - ... --------Isrlze/exposure of individuals (both military am civilian) to-airborne concentrations of asbestos fibers during the availability perlod of this ship, the following agreement Is hereto established. .. J ^a. Ship's Forge. The Coeinandlno Officer shall: . i(l) Prohibit ship's personnel from undertaking work which ,, requires the rmaoval. repair, and Installation of thermal Insulation material containing asbestos T (2) Prior to removing deck Insulation such as vinyl asbestjbs tile, terrazso, etc., notify Code 185 (telephone 474-7227). Code IBS and the Naval Regional Medical Clinic (NRMC) will provide the shlp't personnel with the necessary asbestos control training and procedures for accomplishing this work. (3) Continue to perform Ship's Force work Involving repair!: to pipe flanges. Joints, etc., where gaskets containing fixed asbestos normally Identified by trade names such as Conseco. Flexltalllc. ani Oarlock are present and removlng/lnstal11ng'Tsbestos"rope pack!ng, brake 1fnlngs, etc. Code 185 and NRMC shall conduct surveillances of the _ processes to Insure that concentrations of airborne fibers are not belna generated during these operations. n* f" ` ' : I <JV IS Exhibit t 43.A Page 2864 IT--- I1- " cr c 008 46 Ser 214-3021 19 February 197'I SubJ: . Memorandum of Agreement Regarding Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard Occupational Hoalth Controls - iVV'' v>^{4)^Prohibit.antranca Into araai narked off by Shipyard perso V as "A*hasto*' Restrlctad Area".These areas shall be specifically Idan: ^led to Ship!* Force personnel by the: Shipyard prior to all asbestos wpi .. Only asbestos certified personnel and qualified Ship's Force Match sta shall ba al lowed gantry Into asbestos work spaces during rl pout phase of ship's availability. Ship's Force watch standers shall be briefed by Code 185 on asbestos work procedures such as wearing personal protactly equipment and logging In/out procedures.. , i * ', , 4 * ** -* ` , . v (5) Shlp's'Force personnel shall submit work requests to the Type Oesk for work Involving thermal Insulation removal and Installatlj) If required. n'Jhls work shall; beaccomplished by .certified Shipyard .asbestos workers, 'suy,. oi 3mm , lihyavprtgTf'aiiRfdr^nfterhan'ebritrdlfofJasbestosIrelal lsdl sposal -as s 1 nstnicted .by Cade 185ffgl $$i (1) The Safety Director, Code 18S, Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard Is designated the point of contact for asbestos controls: ` Mr. Charles Bolton, Code 185 Telephone: 474-6109/7227 '.''.;."'.::'":iLocat1on:>f".Bu11d1ngf.l40A;"2nd'Deck' Alternate: Frank Roberto, Code 185.5 (2) The Shipyard shall provide the following: (a) AM asbestos Indoctrination and any required training , (b) Monitor asbestos work to ensure that only authorized properly equipped personnel are accomplishing the work In accordance with existing standards and procedures. (e) Ensure all asbestos work areas are restricted to authorized personnel only and appropriate warning signs posted. (d) Ensure the overall compliance with NAVSHIPYDPEARl policies and Instructions relating to asbestos control. (e) Conduct sampling and analyzing deck Insulation for asbestos material as requested by Ship's Force. II Exhibit 43.A Page 865 'RMC-M&S-003210 cr IRR, 40 ' ; Ser 214-3021 . II '' - , . iii ^" - SubJ: Memorandum of Agreement Regarding Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard Occupational Health Controls (f)` Provldo Ship's Force with personnel protective equip ment (disposable) and red poly bags for disposal. ' ' * * '/ '<, i ACCEPTED: F. W. BAILEY, COMMANDER, USN, CO. USS PREBLE (DOG 46) rWV* - r ,, ,* i VT >*#****&* (, - ; , " . ,, 71 yi* V 0. C. McARTHUR, CAPTAIN, USN COMMANOER, PEARL HARBOR NAVAL SH1PYAR0 Copy to: C0MNAVSURF6RU MIOPAC COMOESRON TWO FIVE Code 100 140 142.17 185 200 210 214 214.15 214.01 219 225 240 300 330 331 331.4 NRMC iSiPSS Exhibit 43. p#9e 2866 i;:rmc-m&s-003211 co DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY flAAL MAMO* NAVAU IHIPVAftO IWlM ' IA4b HAAtOM. HAWAII HHO FOR.'OFFICIAL USE ONLY .From: Conriander, Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard To: Companding Officer, USS EDUAROS (00 950) M C> DO 950 Ser 214.1-30)97 16 May 1979 SubJ: Memorandum of Agraament Regarding Pear! Harbor Naval Shipyard ...,, Occupational, Haalth Controls * v, ,, . ',!. - -1 - * P ' J* *'-J * * St* ** 1 ' Ref: (a) Title 29 - Labor - Part 1910 Occupational .Safety and Health Standard*)-: v* , (b).I.0PNAVINST.62fiQglA' - so,.. 'ySLfy -.-t * t ,iti `Up* , y mM v. (cUfNA\HlMDPEARLINSTil5100l^iils^*Sfii)1 ii*htl20Saf2ttlM ' (d) V^NSTMl Chapter. 63^TheiTMiSlnsulat`1dn^^^Lf*f'^Mi O^NAYSHIPYDPEARLNOTE 5100 Of 23'Mar-79?; 1. In accordance with reference* (a), (b), (e), and (d), Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard hasdeveloped and established Interim criteria and requirements for Occupational Health Controls fop'Tflb'Ystas-.- Reference (e) delineates this Shipyard's policy to restrlct-thmiVe of asbestoscontalned deck and floor unless specifically authorized. 2. In order to minimize exposure of Individuals (both military and civilian) to airborne concentrations of asbestos fibers during the availability period of this ship, the following agreement Is hereby established. a. Ship's Force. The Comnandl Officer shall: (1) Prohibit ship's personnel from undertaki"? work which reaulres the removal, repair, and Installation of the. :al Insulation material containing asbestos. (2) Prior to removing deck Insulatle.i such as vinyl asbestos tile, terrazxo underlayment, ate., notify Code 125 (telephone 47c-72:r). Code 185 and the Naval Regional Medical Clinic (;:7.MC) will provide the ship's personnel with the necsssary asbestos control training and procedures for accomplishing this work, (3) Continue to perform Ship's Forte work Involving reoaird to pipe flanges, join*:, etc., where gsskots containing flxod astestos normally identified by trade nax.-os such as Contacs. Pexitallic. and Si 7- <?9- FY ' -l i r FM **: ***"* *1 "CT 4 `"`KHtllTJff'.A ... A'if. Cr1v1C-M&S-003212 . Ki * (' r FOR OFFICIAL USE 0*lY c 950 214.1:C97 SubJ: Memorandum of Agreement Regarding Pearl Harbor Naval Shipyard Occupational Health Controls Garlock are present and removlng/lnstalllng asbestos rope packing,' brake TTnTng?, etc. Code 135 and NRMC shall conduct surveillances of these processes to insure that concentrations of airborne fibers are not being generated durlng these operations. (4)'?Prohlblt:entrance Into aireas marked off by Shipyard personnel ,as `Asbestos Restricted Area'*. These areas shall be s'p- Ical'y idantl- f1ed to Ship's Force personnel by the Shipyard prior to asbestos work. Only asbestos certified personnel and qualified Ship's Forbe watch stenders shall be allowed entry Into asbestos work spaces during rljout phase of the ship's availability; Ship's Force watch standers snail be Code 135 on asbestos work procedures such'es.wearing persoial protective^. 'CLUj.p^tane^gg1ng4Jn4ouMpttfeiduf1^'"J'`i`~'"'i`' ' ................... . FartdTCOMNAV^W^!MIOPW*io^e"^^^el^fo^^rk ^nwlvilig' theraai' Insulation removal and Installation If required. This work shall be accomplished by certified Shipyard asbestos workers. (5) Establish a program for Internal control of asbestos related work and mater: ' disposal as Instructed by Code 135. (7) Restrict the Installation of asbestos-conta1n|d deck and floor coverings. b- Shipyard !. (1) The Safety 01rector. Code 185, Pearl Harbor n|va1 Ship-erd Is designated the point of contact fcr asbestos controls: ] Hr. Charles Bolton, Code 133 Telephone: 474-4109/7227 Location: Building ICOA, 2nd Co.:: Alternate: Frank Rcterto, Cede 143.4 (2} The Shipyard shall provide the following (a) All asbestos Indsctrinatlan and any requl 'ed training. (b) Monitor asbestos work to ensure tnat cnlv au:r mi m * S properly ecuipped personnel art accerplishlng the .icr!; in accord*-:? with existing standards arc procedures oo kr cf?:; ;l <:n ;; EXHIBIT I*.a *r,r 42Z? c LMC-M&S-003213 I '5i I 1 '* \ ' ' " - C Wr>- , vv` V< FOR OFFICIAL IBsCtf . . 'f'Pi - C s! 214.1-2037 Subd: Memorandum of Agreement Regarding Paarl Harbor Naval Shipyard Occupational Health Controls I . (c) Ensure all asbestos wor!< areas are restrljctad to authorized personnel only a.id appropriate warning signs pcs 3(1. (d) Ensure tha overall compliance with NAVSHI YDPSARL policies and Instructions relating to asbestos control. i '.'{) .Conduct smoling rnd analysis; deck Inc::! asbestcsoaijfialas revues tod by .Ship's Force. cion for eft] ;*. 1v,#'fl, % &l '4-^J V.J-1 '' "rI`"i " "" **CU . S*4' Ship's-,Force vri^personnel protec Ive *^7'*POl^^b49*^^;>S`P: 11 * ft 2$; i CO, Ur. S3XAR0S (DO 950)' .* V Ilia S ,y -y/\- C/VvV^ t* WwkiH^TT^Piniii.TjSiT*** v^OSWOS. PEARL HAR30R NAVAL SHIPYARD Cooy to: CCHNAVSURFGRU MICPAC CCtOESRCl THREE FIVE Code 2C0, 210, 214, 214.1, 214.14, 2W.01, 2i0. 2<1, 3C0, 330 920, 930, 950, 970. Xll, X41, X9S?t, UO, 1S5 331, 331.10, 9?7 (BIT JF.a PAGE 4240 CRM C-M&S-003214 [4*\ itfr* ;*"*'.**' .V^f%.}? ,- , ^V-VS* Division: July 27, 1991' >e-:Wi V. 0. Winblai, Washington, D.C. J-JK Asbestos Textiles Cosnltaents ,! t' In oooneetlon with N.P.A. aesting held July 17tfa, F. 3. wikan has asked aa to te you la detail aa to hofr such J-M la edonlttod for to:various defense agencies requlrsnents aa of this data, la you know, we have aada anoetjijiJwtantlal eoni 'ibutlon of doth and othar aatarlala In tha past several Booths havini up tha total Lap, Roving, and Tarn raqulraaents.of 3 of tha 9 oable aanufaoturars invdved Is tha Navy program. We are still eoonitted for vital defense needs, Is pounds, as folLowsi r*"^!C : fThe itavy program, sable insulation,materials''.. i.Javr^ feOlothi(ovar|i3,'0Q0lyds,).g 69,315 aSilil'" Petroleum tank seal' cloths Procurement Office, TJ3B0 " S3 l^ooql 50.000 14.000 2*1,215 lbs. la of today, the textile orders on Msnvllle are 14.75 D.O. and,' upon analysis, 3 $ of then are indloated as being for use Is weapons or other fighting forces equipment. Tou aay advise the l.S.O. that we oan take on 1000 yds. per aonth of either Type 1 glass with asbestos or Type B plain weave, shipment to start after we have ccsiplirted the 13,000 odd yards now on the books aa per previous arrangement with Lieutenant Pond at l.S.O. In this connection. It is realised that there la probably not enough i factoring eapaelty In America to ecae dose to aeetlng the consolidated Navy dol requirements as stipulated at the reoent Meting. Ton should, therefore, Invite attention of the Interested parties to the fleet that Carolina labestos Company, Oarlock Packing Company, the Qatke Corp. of Chicago and the Keasbey & Mattiaon Cc. do not, aa yet, appear to have taken any Important percentage of the Navy cloth requirements nor, Indeed, have they; to our knowledge, taken aay of the cable iniulatlon requirements. *" There are ethere In the business of producing asbestos yarns such as Bussell Mant featuring Co. and Isten-Hlll Manufacturing Co. of Philadelphia who might be persuaded to aacufacture yarns for others who have weaving eapaelty but who are abort on asbestos yam supplies. For your personal Information, tabulation of all Asbestos Textile' Dept, orders os hand today at Maavllle total 743,020 lbs,, of which 331,269 lbs. are oa D.O. and the ajejority of these1 are not D.O. 97 priorities,y, ,.; ai If we ean furnlah any additional Information to help you in your efforts to avoid being assigned doth orders In an unreasonable, arbitrary aaouht, please advise - * SVDiab oei B. 0. Blaaoas, QBQ ' J. 4. O'Brien, DBQ ' C. 0. Dondrow, '-* F. J. WakM.' -- J , v, ' , S. . DILLON y "V- te-'X1*!*'...''........ CRMC-I' 1&S-003215 %*& . v '% nrr narxi district AL. /O. OUTGOING DISPATCH MVT TARB. SCSTON irmuion comrfintd in thit diiputt not to b rtltucd to tny ether thin iddmett unl*i*llikKor*ed bjr ronpt>i aauitlhority. r.r o :f Ar-O ^ *r^ isiir,i-.z.-y.rk ;-.~ `r.7.su | Tw* bio ?'.-j ;ti4v:i-.!i a-ai :. r,' it * ..A . -T A?v? ::ai?irrT HS-.uiM7Xoa cas 3/.:* TUiffis jix /iVJ <%: Bsc FROM (Office of Origin) ACTION _*/ 3.4, 1" -{*. ^t,v; -* * ,/Pf ,T r - y wpsL INFORMATION ________________________r.iinV ; RELEASED BY Jiiia- {j Priority ' Routine l Nit* u?!i Wfis** iA I ?; _f*l - Genera! File Copy r*1'' *:: ' '' ' ' * ' ' ~i.; # w:rf*'J ' V - |~ ` t *J*3 `.-S.*' . T- j'h` r o A Urn*>3Kl If rifnHf Ifn vm }&- SubS: memorandum of Agreement ftegardlng flirt Harbor ttont Shipyard Occupations! Health Control* (4) Prohibit tfitrance Into area* parted off by Shipyard otnomal as 'Aibfttoi liitrUtH Am*. Thai# areas full be specifically Identl* fled to Ship's fore# personnel by trio Shipyard prior to alt asbestos work. Only aibtitoi certified personnel and qualified Ship's fe^ watch ttandem shall bo a)towed entry Into asbestos work spaces during rtpout phase of the ship's availability* Ship's force watch stonders shall be briefed by . Code MS on asbestos work procedures such as wearing personal protective equipment end logging In/out proceoures* ' (5) Ship's force personnel shall submit work requests to tho Type Oesk for work Involving thermal IrtsulatlonrcmovaT and Installation If required. This work shall be accomplished by certified Shipyard asbestos workers. ().' Establish a program for Internal control of tibostos related., work and material.disposal as. Inssttructed by Code 18$. 1. daalgnattd th# point of contact for asb!tos control!: Hr. Chariti Bolton, Coda IBS Tolaphono: 474-6109/7227 Location: Building 14M, 2nd Bock Alt.raaUi Frank Ro6.ru, Cod. 1B5.S (2) Tlio Shipyard th.11 provtda tho following: (.) All itbosto. Indoctrination and any requlrtd training. (B) Monitor llbiltc; work to eniurt that only authority, cguIppH tarconnal are accomplishing the work In accordance with ulittng standard and procedures. fcl jiiurn jll wore jr*ii ,r- mstrictrs to iuonor.ajy perscnnai.onl/ and apprcprlata warning ilgm posted., ,, (d) Ensure tha orarall cerpltanca with MVSHI7Y07EABI pollctn and Instructions .rotating to asbestos control. (a) Conduct sanding and analysing dack insulation for asbaites oatarlal as rtgu.tted 0/ Ship's forct. yd./rjoV*/Tj^T ,^1 f ifti . ...a ;.. .; C] ;LMC-M&S-003218 c O KC4I Ur JMOOJ1 <9 SwbJ: Hmrindun of Jtart*ftt Pf^irdtiq Furl MrbQr Naval SMoyard . Occupational Health Controls -10 Pro*!-** Ship's forct with perietal protective equip- aont (disposable) and rod poly bJ)t for disposal. ' ACCCPHO: r. w. uiLtr. ccnwnoER. USN CO. USS PRCSLC (OCG 46) ./ .-itf : ink J.C. HeARTHUR, CAPTAIN. USN COTfANOCR, PEARL HARBOR NAVAL SHIPYARD c Copy to: CCfWAYS'JRFGRU MIOPAC CarOESRON TVO five m terlJZiK' #.$: .c# Wv.t&P* , j.! *M`r iA ** **V ..1.w.* .^;.V,*.rvf,\* JS-. *. ' >' ytsS# .V*i-J*..\ -r\.. .', " .' !.`t - 'i;<lV4~.vV - .w.*1 ---- a.-.j **Ts'.*!* r' *v- H.---s Ir v'/ W; CRM C-M&S-003219