Document 44VzX3gVLXGgNmJjVgyn57K8G
FILE NAME Insulation Contractors & Distributors ICD
DATE 1973 June DOC ICD026 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Trade Journal - NICA
June 197.3
VOU
NO ?
I.
20 YEARS OF PROGRESS
1953-1973
6 849391
ae
T aE Cee
:
TRE
Officers 1973
Terms Ending 1975
EASIC NP
W. E. Wally Munsey President C. B. Wheatley
W. Robert Murfin President Herbert McLaughlin NA
Meage
William A. Bayer Vice President
Herbert Mullenir SEIG
1
B. Long Treasurer
E. N. Dillard SWIC
Wayne W. Killion Secretary
James W. Liddell Atsa
Board of Directors
Henry Trueblood WICH
Immediate Past Pres
Terms Ending 1973
R. F. Pat Yount
J. Rodger Hartley CSICA
George Cummings III BASICA
National Insulation Contractors Association
Montgomery Center
20910 8630 Fenton Street 500
Silver Spring Maryland telephone 301-585-662
John C. Pollock Executive Director Walter Shipe Chuirman
A. H. Wotherspoon MICA Raymond U. Wopperer NYSICA Homer C. Porter SWICA J. S. Royer Large
Terms Ending 1974 Robert Bright CSICA Dee C. Luse MICA Palmer Covil SECIA
cluded in the Membership
. Single
copy 1.50 Controlled circulation paid
Statements | opinion Silver at
fact and
Spring Md
of
are made on the re-
sponsibility of the author alone and do
not necessarily express the opinions of
the Association Material may not be re-
produced without written consent
Copyright National Insulation
co ,
NICA Publications Committee
Leroy Whitaker WICA
Contractors Association OQ
if
/
TATABBLLE ETABLE
OF
OF
CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS CONTENTS
VOL 18
JUNE 1973
NO 6
PRESIDENT'S LETTER
3
YOUR EXECUTIVE DIRECTor's Report
S
THERMAL INSULATING FOR LIGHT WATER
NUCLEAR RESEARCH PLANTS
6
PROGRAM
CONVENTION PROGRAM
20
20
ELECTRIC
HEATING
ELECTRIC HEATING OF PREMISES AND
IINSUNLATISON ULATION
23
JORS AND HEALTH
25
THE CONCEPT OF PRODUCTIVITY HAS
CHANGED
35
ASBESTOS PRODUCER ASSAITS PUBLICITY
38
ARE YOU SHARING IN THIS MARKET
38
A BIOGRAPHY OF A YOUNG Company
39
CALENDAR OF EVENTS
39
WHAT'S NEW FROM MANUFACTURERS
41
WWE E SSAALLUUTTE
43
FUND
CONTRIBUTING
ARE YOU CONTRIBUTING TO A StrikE FUND 51
KNOWS
KNOWS
INDUSTRY
INDUSTRY
IN
IS IN TROUBLE
53
53
YOU DON'T SAY
55
ARE YOU PEOPLE ORIENTED
60
VERMIN Jellitac PROOFED
USED NATIONALLY BY THE INDUSTRY
WAREHOUSES IN PRINCIPAL CITIES
ARTHUR S. HOYT CO INC
20 JERUSALEM AVE e Tate
HICKSVILLE N.Y. 11902
JUNE 1973
BRUSHES for the insulation trade
IMMEDIATE DELIVERY ON LOW PRICED ADHESIVE BRUSHES WRITE FOR FREE SAMPLE AND QUOTATION
MARCUS BRUSH COMPANY
444 West 23rd Place
Chicago Illinois 60616
Phone 312-326-2707
Environmental Sciences
Laboratory
of The City University of New York
INSULATION HYGIENE HYGIENE
PROGRESS
FROM THE
PROGRESS
INSULATION INDUSTRY
REPORTS
HYGIENE RESEARCH PROGRAM
Irving J. Sollkoff M.D. Program = Director
Vol 5 No. 2
ER2 | Summer 1973
International Experts Meet on Mesothelioma
.
at ending Members
of
the
International
Association
of
Heat
and
Frost
Insulators
and
Asbestos
Workers
Workers
attending
a conference
on the health hazards
of asbestos
work
presented by
Local
Local
95
in
Toronto
Canada
Health and Safety Meeting
Held in Toronto
On Saturday January 13 1973 a
meeting was held in Toronto to discuss
health hazards in insulation work Drs
Irving J Selikoff and William Nicholson of Mount Sinai School of Medicine spoke to nearly 200 members of Local 95 about the risks of asbestos
work and described what can be done
'o improve working conditions Because of the general interest in the health problems of insulation work a
_ selection questions and answers that
followed these taiks is published here
Tom Carson A few years ago I was doing insulation in a room where painters were spraying The fumes bothered me and I came out of the room but like a dope I went back in and got this tremendous pain in my chest They took me to the Doctor and after looking looking
Tom Carson
at the ray he said my lung had collapsed Could this have been caused by
Continued on fifth page
On April 2 and 3 an international working group met to discuss research
programs for the treatment and cure of
mesothelioma The meeting was held at the National Headquarters of the American Cancer Society under the auspices of the Mount Sinai School of Medicine Environmental Cancer Research Program The treat ment experiences of several medical
centers were reviewed and future research programs discussed
Cooperation Pledged
Andrew Haas Asbestos Workers
President pledged the full support of
the Union in any research efforts to find
a cure for mesothelioma He described
how nearly 10 of the deaths in the
membership of his union were from mesothelioma and that finding
cessful treatment for this cancer should
be one of the priority items of the Federal Government Similar support for such research work was offered by Jack Solon President of the JohnsManville Corporation
Attending the meeting from Great
Britain were Dr. Muriel Newhouse of the London School of Hygiene and
Tropical Medicine Dr. Margaret Warwick of the Institute of
Diseases of the Chest London and
Dr. Geoffrey Sheers of the Beaumont House Chest Clinic in Plymouth England Dr. Sheers report on the incl-
dence of mesothelioma in workers other than insulators in the Devonport
Dockyard was especially disturbing Here the frequency of cases 10 painters electricians or shipfitters etc. appeared to be nearly as great as in
insulation workers
Continued on second page
Insulation Hygiene Progress Reports
Vol 5 No. 2
Summer 1973
from the
Results of Asbestos
Workers Survey In
Insulation
Program
Industry
Hygiene
Research
Over five thousand members of the
Asbestos Workers Union responded to
maintenance locals members of these
As many of the locals work in
Editor W. J. Nicholson Ph.D. Published at the Environmental Sciences
Laboratory Irving J. Schkoff M D.
Director Mount Sinai School of Medicine
of the City University of New York N.Y.
Advisory Council of IIHRP
the questionnaire distributed by Gen-
eral President Andrew Huas in De-
cember , 1972 to find out what effects
the new asbestos regulations had hadin reducing exposures of Asbestos Workers The important provisions of these regulations as they applied to insulation work were covered by the questions
One of the mandatory requirements
facilities which have an industrial
health program this results results uncerstandable
In order to reduce dust concen-
trations below the establishedThresh-Thresh-
old Limit Value of 5 fibers longer
than 3 microns per milliliter of
air certain procedures were listed in
the standard These included the use of
Irving J. Selikoff M. and Chairman
Program Director
of the new standard was that each work
place where asbestos fibers were released should be monitored by De-
plastic bags for mixing cement vacuum cleaning ofasbestos debris the
use of containers for waste material
E. Cuyler Hammond Sc.D Vice Presi-
cember 6 1972. The number of dust
disposal and exhaust ventilation on all
dent American York NY
Cancer Society
New
counts seen by Asbestos Workers in the
different regions of the United States and Canada are shown in Table 1
power equipment Workers were also quened on the availability of this equipment as well as the availability of
Andrew Haas General President Interna-
nonal Association of Heat and Frost
Insulators
und = Asbestos = Workers
Few Dust Counts Seen
One hundred and seventy mem-
hers observed an air sample being
taken 4956 did not see any such
respirators and change facilities
No Widespread Adoption
TableTable
II
lists
lists lists
tthhee
questions
and
com-
plete results obtained in the survey is
Fred Lo Pundsack Ph.D Vice President
Research
and
Development
Johny-
activity six months After making all
reasonable allowances for unobserved
evident that there has not been any
widespread adoption of work practices
Manville Corporation Denver Colo
surveys it must be concluded that there
has been no major effort to comply with
recommendedor mandated in the stan dard As with the Just counts the pres-
This part of the regulations
ence of un ndustria health program
INSULATION
INDUSTRY HYGIENE RESEARCH PROGRAM
1. To develop.mproved develop.mproved methods for minimizing exposure of insu-
lation workers to dusts and fumes
encountered in their work
3. To disseminate knowledge of
these improved methods of dust
control wherever they may be
ie
applied applied ap lied
advantageously
and
to
rec offer cooperation advice and assistance toward their universal
adoption
ore
By itself air sampling does nothing
and stable work location in main-
to reduce exposures In this situation however it is an indication of the activ
tenance and shipyard locals resulted in
a lower percentage of never re-
ity of employers or official agency industrial hygienists in complying with at
sponses to the questions on the avail-
ability of change rooms respirators
least the mandatory provisions of the and personal protection equipment
regulations
However across the United States
tyre
The distribution of the surveys was
the standard had de effect in
noteworthy Fifty or about one-
ing conditions in construction
third of
reported
the observed surveys
were
by the relatively few 165
from members of shipyardand
Reportedly been an there has
crease in the properion propproeperiorn ion of
in-
tree insulationbeing installed
TABLE I
Numberofof dust countsseen by insulation workers
December 6 1972
during the period June 7 1972.10
Region
Dust counts seen
Percentage of men
Yes
No
seeing a dust count
Continued from page li
Also present at the meeting were Dr.
Marcus Key Director ofthe National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health Dr. Douglas Lee of the Na-
Bonal Institute of Environmental
Health Sciences Captain George Lawon of the S. Navy and representatives of the National Cancer Institute
New York England
-Middle Atlantic
Southeast Soutnwest
Midwest Centra
West
Canadian Maintenance Locals
Shipyard Locals All regions
12 25
8 ...
3 3
9 % 31 171
743 705 328
474 936
740 500 363
---- 73 1956
16 3 1.3 3.7 0.5 2+ 4.5 2.5 37.7 29 3.4
Few Improvements Seen
may be a positive effect of the standard
to However if substitute materials are
used with no regard control of dust it
is possible that other health hazards can
be created Exposure to high atmos-
pheric concentrations of any inorganic
dusts can be injurious
Along with returned questionnaires
workmen sent excellent letters many describing conditions in the field An
especially good one was sent by Jay H. Mackley of York Pennsylvania and
because of its relevance we are publish-
ing excerpts from it
Dear Sirs
i
hope this
let
r
letter letter letter
attracts
attracts
more
attention than the numerous question-
naires that I have been returning My
seven years of being an asbestos
worker I have not yet seen one precau-
tion taken to prevent dust or any other efforts taken to better our working condi-
tions I'm a young man with many years ahead of me in the trade From the few
years 1 worked I observed there isn't those golden years of retirement to look forward to The few asbestos work-
ers that do reach retirement age soon
after succumb to cancer or a related dis-
ease associated with asbestos
working The good
practices that were
suggested in the November journal are
very seldom used and some are not
even practical Trying to get the
company to furnish a downdraft cutting
table for uses during hand sawing and a
portable vacuum cleaner for proper ventilation is next thing to impossible we're very lucky if we even have a box to lock
up our personai jonis
If we are going to change and improve our working conditions let's start with a few of them than can be corrected im-
mediately For instance have a change
shanty large enough for the crew and well ventilated most of them are
cramped and very dusty On larger jobs have adequate wash rooms or at least be given time to clean up Have a wash
machine or vacuum cleaner in the
shanty for work clothing there is no need
to carry the dirt home Have questionnares that an insulator could write in his
own suggestions that he might think will improve his conditions Have regulation
on dust control that the local can enforce
and the journeymen can very well un-
derstand use old cliche An ounce of pre-
vention is worth a pound of cure would apply very well to our trade I think it
would be lot easier to eliminate the dust and try to clean up the trade try to find the cure for lung cancer and all the
other dreadful diseases I hope my letter does not go unanswered I'm anxious to read your reply Thank-
you
TABLE ||
QUESTIONNAIREOBSERVATION OF ASBESTOS STANDARDS STANDARDSSTANDARDS
in the period June 7 1972 to December 6 1972
1. Dust counts
I did not see a dus^<count done
1 personally saw one or more dust counts done
4358 171 171 171
2. Work clothes and facilities
facilities are recommended
In order not to bring dusts home home from the job special
Facilities and supplies for clothes change were available
1291
All the time
100
Usually
50-75 of the time
340
Occasionally
1-49 of the time
372 1964
Never
%
3. Respirators masks }
Were provided by the employer
At all times
100
Usuaily
Occasionally
Never
50-75 of the time 1-49 of the time %
4. The following materials and equipment were available
2038 1014 1242
787
Always
Usually
Occasionally
594
402
603
Exhausted power table saws Exhausted power hand saw
112 203
74 136
176 425
Vacuum cleaner for clean up
407
388
681
Bagging of waste for disposal
Drop cloths & collector for hand sawing
190 125
227 154
513 443
Portable exhausts for confined spaces
where there was no
exists in the repiles repiles to the availability of axhausted power saws On some jobs
It should be noted that an ambiguity
of exhausted saws
was never as to the availability use of power equipment the response
Never
3004 4425 4127 3439 3943 4150
Cigarette Smoking Is Dangerous to Your Health
Results from the health survey con-
insulation workers approximately
Two factors account for the
ducted by Dr. Irving J. Selikoff and Dr. E. Cuyler Hammond of the full membership of the International Association
of Heat and Frost Insulators and Asbes-
ninety times over that
neither worked with
of men asbestos
who
nor
smoked cigarettes
The results of the current more ex-
improved mortality data of insulation workmen Firstly at the beginning of
the observation period most of the in-
sulators were working and thus
tos Workers dramatically point to the severe effects of cigarette smoking on
Asbestos Workers
The 17,800 men enrolled on January
tensive survey substantiate the earlier data on the added effects of smoking on
the production of lung cancer in asbestos workers However they also
healthier than many in the general
population where many deaths occur in
those who are disabled sick or other-
wise unable to hold a job This factor
1. 1967 in the International were
llustrate The importance of 300
usually will reduce the expected mor-
completed studied through December 31 1971
11,656
a questionnaire pro-
smoking in lowering the incidence of
vascular disease In the non-
tality over five year pencd by no more than 20 from that of the generalpopu-
popu-
vading among other details informa-
cigarette smoking group only 36
lation
we
non concerning their smoking habits deaths from all causes other than cancer The second major factor is the ab- Pk
The results of the causes of death of all
compared with eS members listed according to their
9 smoking habits is shown in Table 1
including Among the 9.590 men with lustory
of regular cigarette smoking there
were 596 deaths 134 of which were
were seen where 93 were expected
Most of these other deaths were from
vascular disease which WAS
significantly reduced in the = non-
smoking isbestos workers
In fact comparing the number of
ence of cigarette smoxing in this group
of Asbestos Workers
compared
The generalgeneral
general
population population population population
population
many smokers Even
deaths
that occurred from asbestos exposure
Tasbestosis mesothelioma and G
due to lung cancer Of the 2.066 men who had never smoked cigarettes regu-
deaths of cigarette smoking asbestos workers with those expected from
cancer these data show that over this
ave year penod of time the effects of
Iarly only 1 of 73 deaths were from
lung cancer Mortality studies of Locals 12 and 32
statistical data on the mortality the
general population itis seen that only
73 insulators died where 112 or H
health cigarette smoking on
than the effects of
is greater
working with
asbestos Containing insulation ff-
reported havebeen
which indicated that
cigarette smoking increased the risk of
during Jeaths were expected
the
1967-19711967-1971 period Forty fewer
forials
death of lung cancer among asbestos
were seen than expected
Table |
Expected and Observed Deaths among 17,300
U.S. and Canada Asbestos Insulation Workers Jan. 1 1967 31 1971
Total
No history of cigarette
smoking
History of cigarette
smoking
Smoking habits
not known
Number of man Jan. , 1067 Person of observation
17.300 36.000
Expected
deaths
Observed
deaths
2,066 70,153
Expected
deaths
Observed deaths
9,590 16,515
Expected
deaths
Observed
deaths
0,144 0,144 19,522
Expected
deaths
Observed
deaths
Cancer all sites
Lung cancer
Pleural mesothelioma Peritoneal mesothelioma Cancer of stomach
Cancer of colon rectum _ Cancer of esophagus
144 09 44.42
oa
***
562 1751 1751
321 321
450
213
26 51 16 26 12
19.92 5.98
o
its
0.95 2.52 044 044
33 2 ,, 9 1 4 0
79.58
25.09
vee
7
3.50 9.53 1:30
265 134
17 29
3 14
7
14.59 13.35
***
T
2.07
5.46
097
181 ne
7
13
me
300 300
Asbestosis
ad
78
**
~
4
45
39
All other causes
C61 34
555
92.87
36
356.67
288
2 20
233
Total deaths
305.63
1,092
112.39
73
436.25
596
256.79
423
Expected deaths cased soon age specair $ Traunea categories 162 and 153
mortality rates for whre males disregarding smokingLung cancer slimalas based based upon 5 rates for cancer or ung Ji~ ur^gr^nonusand
Included 609 mer who smoked pipes or cigars Unded States Cala ct available butthese are are causes of death in the generalcopulation
How much
do you smoke
Can Asbestos
Dust be
Inactivated
Continued from first page the asbestos and the fumes together
Dr. Selikoff The condition from which Mr. Carson suffered is known as
"
spontaneous pneumothorax That is the lung develops a leak and ruptures The air leaks out of the lung
and since it can't get out of the chest it fills the space between the lung and the chest wall collapsing the lung
bronchi and blood vessels appear as
this smal
round holes in this normal lung
pack
Small holes in upper lung typical of early emphysema
2 or more
A later stage showing larger holes om a
in thelung
Many large holes representing advanced
far advanced emphysema
me
The National Cleaning House on Smoking and Health has published a description of some of the
from various amounts of cigarette smoking This description of
changes that can occur in human lungs
Dr. Oscar Auerbach and Carmine Benantc
sigarette smoking induced emphysema is based on work by
E.
Hammond and
of the East Orange New Jersey Veterans Administration Hospital and Dr.
Cuyler
Lawrence Garfinkel of the American Cancer Society
ea aa
Stan Roos
Spraying Can Be Dangerous
This condition can occur to anyone
but it is more likely to occur from irri-
tation by fumes or cust Spraying general can be an extremely dangerous procedure If something may be harmful to you to deliberately spray it
into the air makes it worse
Some of the new epoxy paints can be especially irritating and if there is a little weak spot on the lung which might occur from scarring produced by asbestos additional irritation by the
epoxy painis can cause rupture Tom Carson I now n ticethat paint
happened
Dr. Seliko
That's correct
Whenever the lung has been so injured
it is left weaker Stan Roos I have a condition called
bronchiectasis and have to sleep on the
bed with the foot raised Would I be
more susceptible either to asbestos OT O
various fumes
Dr.
Selikoff Bronchiectasis is a big
word for condition in which the
airway tubes the bronchi are dilated
.
With this condition mucus tends to col-
lect in the bronchi and when it does it
can become infected Sometimes we
even have to almost stand a person on
Continued on sixth page
Dr. Selikoff Yes this was first done
that dust may have on your heart First
at the McIntyre Foundation in Ontario
the right side of your heart pumps blood
for silica exposures As you know the
through the lungs in order that it pick up
silica produced in the dust of hard rock
oxygen The blood then remrns to the
mining is also an irritant The fine par-
ticles can get into the lungs and cause
heart and is pumped to the rest of the body where the oxygen is released
scarring as asbestos does although it is
When the lungs are scarred your heart
different type of scarring The disease
has to pump that much hander some-
td
ears that is produced is called silicosis
times so hard that it fails This
In Ontario it was thought that if these
condition is called cor pulmonale
Pe
miners inhaled aluminum dust the
Heart disease caused by the ung
aluminum would coat the silica
We used to think that there was not
Dr J. E. Cowie
particles and prevent them from injuring the lung The idea of coating the particles to neutralize them is a good one However at this time there
is very little evidence that aluminum is
much that we could up for this condition because the primary cause was in the lung but in the last 5 years we have learned that there are ways to
strengthen the heart so that can do its
especially effective in this regard
Chemical Prevented Scarring
jub The second problem is that when the
Jungs are scarred not enough oxygen
In fact though this has led to the
whole idea of such mactivation In
enters your blood so the blood which goes to your heart itself doesn't have
Germany at this time studies are
enough oxygen Instead of being 95
S
under way by a scientist named Schlip-
saturated with oxygen it might only ice
EARS
koter who has found that administration
70 saturated The hear must do more
HUW
of a plastic polymer called polyvinyl
work at time when is receiving less
sner pyridine- oxide administered in ani-
mals either before or after inhalation of sibca can prevent the scarring caused
oxygen so that a coronary disease trouble
man nas
with ordinary
even greater
by the silica particles This clearly es-
As you know coronary disease is
tablishes the principle that even after
dust the lungs can be neutralized
epidemic in our society today Let me give you some statistics In the general
This is why we believe that for every dust silica beryllium asbestos or
US population out of 6 male deaths
in smokers is caused by coronary
coal we may find chemicals that can
disease In Cigarette smokers the
inactivatent inactivatent What urgent at this time
number is 1 out of 3
Tvice as many
is that we get 20 50 100 scientists to
work on the problem to find appropriate
chemicals that can neutralize these
This is another reason for you to stop
smoking Not only will it reduce the risk of lung cancer but it will reduce
his
out
head so that the Bronchiectasis
mucus can can come
drain from
dusts in your lungs
your risk of coronary disease an even more significant cause of death
childhood infections and sometimes t
can come from asbestosis Joc Mathews You have raised the
question of the possibility of macuvat
ng dust the lungs Isn't there something now being done for amers in this
Where Do We Start
Barney MacDonald Most of your
a
studies were done the States
or
years behind
regard
7
How do we put the prespresssureuprerssure e
some of these things that you have
described We have no venulation
ail
equipment no maskmassks no nothing
Where do we start
Dr. Selikoff Thai's the key
question ofthe whole afternoon Where do we start Who is going to do what
flow is anything going to get done
Mr Kirton would you care to answer
John Beardwood
Alex Taggart Taggart
Effects on the Heart
Joe DeWit Does the dust that gets into our lungs cause any special kind of heart conditions
Dr. Selikoff That's a very good question Let me tell you of two affects
President Some things are being
done We just had a meeting in Sama
with some of the contractors They told
me that in 3 different insutation mate-
rals they are taking the asbestos out
That's one step As I understand it
the manufacturers have been given a
deadline to getit out of all insulation
materials or they will be banned
extent possible activity on health problems should be joint activity Their cooperation can certainly be beneficial in solving health problems
year but every year thereafter the risk goes down until after 10 years or so
your risk is nearly back to normal The
risk is then about the same as someone
who never smoked at all While it may
take 10 years for you to get back to the level of non smokers the 10 years has to begin sometime I suggest that it
begins now Joe Berlasty What's the average
life expectancy of a pipe coverer
Dr. Selikoff For a male child born
in the United States or Canada the odds
are that he will live about 68 years For
man 20 the life expectancy will be a
little longer He will live on average to
age 70. The odds are that a man of 40 will live to age 72. A man of 70 will be
expected to live to the age of 81. So when you calculate life expectancy it
Alfred Kirton
must always be age specific
It even becomes more complicated
rhe
,
be
ay
Q
wont
eta HOU
CU
de
ame
Dr. Selikoff That's a good answer
May I add to it There is no reason why insulation workers shouldn't have dis-
posable masks on the job They cost less than a dollar a day to use There is no reason that you peopie should be inhaling any of the other dusts in insu-
lation materials There is culcined
diatomaceous earth in insulation mate-
rials which can also produce lung scarring Fibrous glass is another material that shouldn't enter your lungs It has
been shown to produce cancer in an~-mals just like asbestos You shouldn'i
have to breathe in any mineral mat-
erials They belong in pipe covering
not in your lungs Secondly is there any reason why
every power saw should not he exhausted when an effective dust
collector costs only 350.00 The jobs you're working on Cost Tens of
thousands of dollars Is there any
reason why asbestos cement shouldn'tshouldn't
be supplied in plastic bags so that can te mixed without creating dusi These
mings may cost a little bit more money but if all the employers have to do them it simply adds to the cost of the job and no one is at a disadvantage
Joe DeWit
Clean Up Necessary
Joe DeWit I think one of the main
problems that we have comes from ourselves If you're working on a job and you start to clean up the foreman might come by and say Look you're not paid to clean up you're paid to put covering on pipes So you leave the dusi on the floor and meanwhile you're
walking through it all the time Dr. Selikoff You're right Not only
do we have to clean up the jobs in some
cases we also have to clean up our minds The foreman sees din on the
ground and knows that it will go away tomorrow or the next day He doesn't think of 20 or 30 years from now when the dust that got into your lungs can cause trouble That's the problem with all of us we don't feel the urgency over something that will happen 30 years from now We must get to the point that good housekeeping is automatic se that it is not left up to the foreman
li Lunn have the same problem
as Stan Roos I find that I can work in
any dust except fibrous glass I If work
with that for 4 or 5 hours my lungs
because you must do this for each calendar year For example a man of
age 40 today has a different life expec-
tancy than a man age 40 in 1950
Taking into accout all these factors we
have found that the average life expec
tancy at any age for a pipe coverer is
about 15 less than some one in the
general population This is a result of
past asbestos exposure but it also will
be the case in the future unless somTIC-
thing is done about work conditions Something has to be done because a
his
pipe coverer should be able to
full life span
Significant Benefits
Ron Aldham If I would quit
smoking and wear a mask woulid my life expectancy become conger
Dr. Selikoff Yes To stop smoking
will bring significant benefits Firstly
it will decrease your risk of having a
Secondly
coronary Secondly
your risk of lung
within
a few years also de-
crease Thirdly it will reduce the pro-
gression of asbestosis Finally
wearing a mask will prevent any more dust from entering your lungs There-
GeRUTaNUT Local eSature
Especially you
anton
Here your International is doing a
would begin to hemorrhage
fore it can only help you to stop
Ua
bang up job It has appointed a full time
Dr. Selikoff Yes we have found
smoking and to wear a respirator
09 1a
man to work on the problems of health
that in other circumstances fibrous
However one thing that we have
hazards Roy Steinfurth formerly
glass can be irritating
found is that mesothelioma is not as-
oto
sociated with smoking and often is no
business agent of
45 in Toledo
associated with extensive asbestos ex-
FAA
now has the job of coordinating all
The Lung Clears Up
in the International and
posures What is needed at this time is sci-
osgyrs
health activities
Paul Pasztor If a person has been
considerable research by many
amas
am sure he will be able to help you
for 10-15
how long will
entists in many centers to obtain ^ cure
6
people here in Canada get the things
smoking
years
done that
need to make the work-
it be before his lung clears up
for this disease
you
Dr. Selikoff The American Cancer
Here as well as in the area of dust
place safe
Society has some good information on
inactivation your International is now
The employers are not our enemy
this Not much change happens the first
beginning to take steps to stimulate
They They are in this with you and to the
Coweenen Continued on eighth page
Continued Continued from seventh
on
cientfic cientific activity activity and pu governmet nt pressure
ae American American Canadian Canadian government government support
rsts to tists find answers answers these
the Dr. J. BE. Cowle, Ontario En
Dr. E. Ontario En-
vironmental vironmental vironmental Health Health Department Department
scien- would would just say that absolutely absolutely
use small ray films pipe
do
All our mobile units units units
equipped coverers
standard standard standard x
inch equipped to take the
gilt inch rays
Additionally workers workers . yOu that
we do Additionally assure you
we
information information to confidential confidential medical
the employers employers only only to you to any
wish
cunction
nad physicians. a pulXm-oranyarytechnician
physicians and 40
pulmonary function function
technician physicians physicians
technician technician
available available technician and an X ray
ener sianatern
any
ee
#
cena
MNS
re Mam
manne
enaptomreuemanm
tree
cue Warrews
com
Help Barney McDonald
How Often aC heck- Luc
Dees Barney MacDonald
? that your cause Do fibers
thai are more active active you're you're scars active
more scraping scraping active active
gre they
How Often Check
? said that
it might Mathews Mathews Selikoff Selikoff that ot
useful useful for people twenty or a 5
might
the trade have have
thirty in
months every months months every every
they Dr. Selikoff Selikoff
Larry Graham
Could
will have effect upon amount
your office Yes
wii] scarring scarring that place . Most Pulmonary Function
office
Dr. Cowie if will will weal, me
are within cells there there is
Measurements
you will recall the ox-
of fibers scraping scraping as such In fact chemical
suggestion a 6 month ex- SIPs
interval
processes perhaps perhaps even more
processes
be impor
device we also have to blow into this can
amination interval was was those
coverers
pipe pipe
processes seem
the do it as hard as we
had had history years the trade
physical production lung lung scarring So production
What
Dr. Selikoff Selikoff purpose of this
who
smoking
Young history cigarettu cigarettu
need
not so So you can exercise exercise you
signed Selikoff That instrument de- de-
examinations fellows often
So only long as you don't overdo it can a. Thwaa
how much things Firstly #
determines determines
take take
often the effect effect of Parsons Parsons
from so Unidentified Unidentified Unidentified beneficial you
your lung much air vou
fumes fumes some of
sue of Unidentified Questioner Questioner
pulmonary measures what 1
called your pulmonary
adhesives
normal takes get back to
vital capacity Secondly Secondly measuring
Selikoff Selikoff have very little hitle @-
smoking smoking will exer- exer-
cise cise reduce reduce that
blow the measuring how fast
effects in- OF formation the long term
Dr. Selikoff Selikoff Selikoff think wallsere
us something something about about your airway lungs
tells
obstructed or airway
materials materials many the oOff tthhee
nerves the
you're youy'ou're re of think
scar-
passages , they
adhesives poison the
ring though breath breath to because scartry
problems problems problems are obstructed huve huve
They it ASA AUTOORU AUTOORU Mg
\
do
dous alcohol So ae
because
excessive
additional stain on your exercise can an
X and
measurements are
both
function
the same way dous
men have much much greater greater
additional
doing work heart pump is
enough doesn't important
job or in or a
already
to pump
Often
people rel
chance accidents accidents
blood through scarred lungs
whole whole story story Sometimes Sometimes
from work work.
What Type extra lungs ta pump
who have great difficulty breathing
other
home
Do We Change The Law Line?
What Type Rays ?
have normal X rays
Unidentified times people no breathing breathing
can
What
these that taken
have difficulty
terrible rays We We so
done change change the laws Canada Canada Canad.
Selikoff around small films about or look the whole picture
Selikoff
inches
good enough to
the
aholecicnire so
Selikoff better better conditions conditions
a very good good your
inches inches size Are they
produced produced by 3
Joe Mathews individual The
Selikoff That
see changes changes that be
not Mathews
sure
asbestos asbestos Selikoff Are they aood produced 10
rays are
prob-
not familiar with our Toronto can preb-
answer
Cowte
Cowte
There
No. No. 70mm 70mm not Dr. Selikoff
there a place Toronto
for
of asbestos asbestos you
and that is go 6 10 Zo
need regular regular 14 inch full
What
disease good good diagnosis diagnosis
of to
Dr. Selikoff Selikoff that
men that makoef Parliament Go to Go lo
local member member
John ray for Are eoverers
Cowle
what your Parliament Let Let
John Beardwod Beardwod Beardwood Are the results results of
Cowle Our ofice office that question him
know
are.
you going to are
the
where
the and ine
Province Province
of
anytime On
solution you you to find
given employers employers ? Province the
anytime occasions occasions we have even (0 solution
we have even
solution.
the X-rays that are taken by
atanyume. Oa occastons
etiployers? Province given to me
Forty Insulations Inc. 1923-1973
A Biography of a Young Company
The company was founded 50 years ago by Louis Weber to manufacture the first plastic insulation in-
sulating cement At that time the only insulating fibers produced were rock wools from a basic raw material of argillaceous limestone Mr. Weber found the fibers produced from lead and copper slag would
not disintegrate in water and would withstand hgher temperatures than rock wool He started the company with one product a mixture of copper slag fibers with clay binders a product he named Weber's 48 Cement because 100 pounds would cover 48 board fect
Since that time FORTY continued to in-
novate to anticipate and serve the needs of the market for thermal insulating materials In the 1930's
it produced the first or one of the first high tem-
mineral wool block insulations to compete perature with 85 magnesia and diatomaceous earth blocks
produced Subsequently in the
1940's
it
The
The
The
both build-
company ccoommppaannyy
in
con- concon-
junction
felts for
with Magic Chef made some home appliances Prior to that
of the first time stoves
and refrigerators were insulated by stuffing loose wool
in the doors around the ovens and in the refrigerator
boxboexses
In
first
the late machine
1940's feited
FORTY introduced the metal mesh blanket insulations
and in the early 1950's was the first or among the first to manufacture batts and blankets with an
aluminum foil vapor barrier Later in the 50's the felted
metal
mesh
blanket
was further developed and modified for use as pipe
insulation In the waterwall
this period between 1945 and 1955
boiler was introduced and FORTY-
EIGHT was the first to provide intermediate tem-
perature insulation batts for steam electric power generators to replace the more costly and more la-
bor intensive block specified in the earlier days of
spaced tubes with refractory back In the 1960's and in 1970 and 1971 FORTY-
EIGHT introduced MF PIPE INSULATION and 1200 BLOCK both of which had advantages of
lower material and application costs reduced ship-
ping and warehousing costs with advantages 100 of the elimination of the asbestos hazard and superior
noise reduction properties
FORTY has consistently supported na-
tional and regional independent insulation con-
distributor associations and will continue to do
so as a part of an industry which serves the public's newest priorities for energy conservation for air and water pollution abatement for a healthier and
safer work environment and for better values for its
customers
Calendar of Coming Events
JUNE 18-19 1973
SEICA Annual Spring Mecting Table Trade Show
HOLIDAY DOWNTOWN INN Myrtle Beach South Carolina
SEPTEMBER 12-16 1973
TIAC Annual Conference
THE SHERATON
Niagara Falls Ontario
OCTOBER 1-2 1973
SEICA Annual Fail Meeting WAYNESVILLE COUNTRY
Waynesville South Carolina Carolina
CLUB
INN
JUNE 1973
OCTOBER 3-5 1973 EASICA Fall Meeting 1973
The Washingtonian Gaithersburg Maryland
OCTOBER 12-13 1973 WICA Annual Meeting Del Coronado Hotel Coronado California
OCTOBER 14-17 1973 NICA's 18th Annual Convention
DEL CORONADO HOTEL Coronado California
39
JOBS & HEALTH
Continued from page 26
nized water The water is used for electrical generation and electronics manufacture among other uses
propiolactone is used to sterilize tissue grafts
and vaccines and also is used in producing acrylates
Dichlorobenzidine is widely used to prepare pigment
colors The pigments in turn are used for inks in strips
everything from the Sunday morning comic and advertising supplements to the highest quality
magazines the producers say naphthylamine is apparently a very ubiquitous
compound says D. J. Carney Vice President for research of U.S. Steel Corporation It has been reported in coal products in cigaret conden-
sate and in flue gases of industrial boilers Therefore
it would appear likely that it would be present in
many organic mixtures which have been subjected to
high temperatures
Wide Exposure
According to the petitioners posed to the chemicals include
workers possibly exequipment operators
ers who clean plants and laundry workers who clean
a
em clothes might be involved Other workers process the gi
Ber materials into dyes rubber antioxidants and phar-
maceuticals new discoveries suggest exposures may
even be much wider
Some manufacturers are sccking substitutes for the carcinogens Celanese Corporation for instance will close its betapropiolactone plant at Pampa Texas by the end of the year and switch to another material made in a new 30 million facility Synalloy Cor-
year ago at an Augusta Georgia plant it had ac-
quired in 1967 "
We had never had any case of
official seemed says a
Synalloy heavy
that
Bur
evidence
the evieviddence ence
carcinogen
"
He
adds
to
:
There was just no way we could manufacture the product and handle it and put it into some other
products without some limited exposure
NICA
WE'RE
CELEBRATING
nae
TOGETHER
FORTY FORTY INSULATIONS INC
- 50TH
AURORA ILLINOIS
JUNE 1973
Some Other Arguments
Control of carcinogens raises several side arguments One company asserts the union's proposed ban on exposure would make it extremely difficult to conduct the highly desirable carcinogenic investigations of
potentially new and valuable medicinal compounds Another argument was that if the regulations are
adopted they should give employers the right to relate a worker's job assignment to his smoking habits Because cigaret smoking and occupational exposure to asbestos may be related in causing cancer an employer should have the right to transfer away from carcinogens any worker who smokes
Companies have been worrying about carcinogens for years Until 1968 one firm only assigned men with prior exposure to plants where carcinogen was produced rather than risk unnecessary exposure to new workmen But the regulations sought now would require the transter at equal pay and seniority of a worker showing urinary tract symptoms of exposure to carcinogens Because cancer from carcinogens often takes 15 to 20 years to develop after exposure transfers might be required even years after the Labor Department establishes standards for handling the
chemicals
16 FEDERAL DEFICITS IN 20 YEARS
The deficit for the 1973 fiscal year is predicted
to exceed the 30 billion mark The Federal Govern-
ment has actually operated at a deficit in v out of the last 20 years Can you imagine that it takes all of the tax revenues of American taxpayers earning less than 10,000 in adjusted gross income just to pay the
annual interest on the Federal From Federal
Spending Control a slide presentation of the Cham-
ber of Commerce of the United States
lh ne te emer
THE RESPONSIBILITY OF BUSINESS
Business in the future will have to manage every dollar of expense and debt with greater care and in-
genuity than ever before Business will have to answer responsibility to the insistent demands of the public for corporate citizenship Business will have to convert the U.S. into the world center of high technology with the developing countries doing more of the manufacturing And business will have to lead in making equality of opportunity a reality within its borders
Cummins En-
J.
gine Company
Common sense is
really quite uncommon
49
Rn
ae ANNE LOS
CERAMOSPRAY ASBESTOS FREE High Temperature
sprayed FIBER INSULATION
In Every Important Category
CERAMOSPRAY has demonstrated
on the job Superiority
Applied Costs - Low > Thermal Conductivity
Low
Flame Spread - Low @ Mechanical Support MinimUM
No Health Hazard
* Tested by Jefferson Medical College
a Application Dust Overspray - Low
Resistance to Weather - Excellent Resistance to Contraction Excellent
Resistance to Expansion Excellent
Resistance to Thermal Shock Excellent Resistance to IV.F.P Has U.L. Label
CERAMOSPRAY SPRAYED FIBER INSULATIONS have the highest use limits of many sprayed moer insulations and have been applied as thermal insulation to many areas where the temperature exceeds 2000
BLENDS have been tested and used by utribes refineries
CERAMOSPRAY
and specifying agencies
They
have
been
approved
for
use
by
many
turbine
.
manufacturers and boiler manufacturers
CENAMOSPRAY PRODUCTS are ideal for
Power Stations Marine Boilers
Chemical Process Plants Refineries
Metallurgical Plants Industrial Heating Units
and wherever critically efficient insulation is needed
each chemical instead of the blanket order the petition seeks covering 10 carcinogens Some companies
insist workers already are protected adequately
As the federal safety law already permits the department to block identified health hazards
the
Health
Education
and
Welfare
Department's
Department's
Na-
tional Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
recommended a permit system for manufacturers
that's similar to a plan used in Pennsylvania In that
state manufacturers must have a permit to manufac-
Some companies question whether laboratory CX-
periments on animals prove the chemicals chemicals are dan-
gerous gerous to humans The Benzidine Task Force of the
Synthetic Organic Chemical Manufacturers Associaton asserts that workers are adequately protected a an ndd that
trol measures prevent excludes substances in
less by weight Great
exposures The law however which a carcinogen is % or
Britain India and the Soviet
Union have regulated carcinogens
the proposed rules would close plants and put workers proposed
out of jobs And the group's comment adds if rumors
do occur they are removed long before malignancy
to the carcinogens contrast toto the asbestos standard which permits some exposure peation urges virtual lifetime health monitoring of workers who
is expected to develop. scek a total ban on exposure to
may have been exposed Some medical records would Manufacturing processes
(
The petitioners
to establish a safe
be kept for at least 40 years
;
carcinogens It is really impossible
would be constantly monitored To the dismay of
threshold for a carcinogen insists Dr. Sidney Wolfe
executives unions would have wide access to company
Director of the Health Research Group Every year
!
and more evidence that smaller and
health records
i
_
brings more
While the carcinogens generally
smailer doses still cause cancer
used Benzidine
names some are widely
a High Priority
naphtylamine are starting materials for many syne
Adminis- of some some sort are almost a certainty
Regulations
asked for comment on
total approximately 14 million a year
When the Labor Department
Chain Robbins Administra-
chloromethyl ether is an unavoidable product
ether in turn used
|
the emergency petition
and Health
in the production of chloromethyl
tor of the Occupational Safety
make resins for production of quality deio-
tration said We have established a high priority on
to
Continued on page
setting standards for these substances And last July
NICA OUTLOCK
26
JOBS AND HEALTH
A reprint from the Wall Street Journal
.
/
2 "
The labor department is wrestling with its toughest
health problem yet occupational cancer
It's clear from evidence the department has gath-
ered that
-A number of chemicals and other substances
some widely used in industry can cause cancer Many workers in manufacturing plants continue
to be exposed to these chemicals -The risks of such exposure are persuading some
companies to check workers more carefully for the first signs of health problems and other concerns are abandoning the manufacture use of causing
chemicals Nonetheless the department thus far has issued a
standard for handling only one causing substance or carcinogen And the delay in issuing other standards particularly for a group of key chemicals is dismaying union officials and health researchers who assert workers lives are being sacri-
ficed
Each passing workday without regulatory intervention increases the number of employees who will be effectively exposed to these chemicals and who
subsequently may develop cancer assert the Oil
Chemical and Atomic Workers International Union and the Health Research Group a Washington team
associated with Ralph Nader
Acton Possible This Monik
The two groups in late December petitioned the
Labor Department to temporarily ban companies from letting workers come in contact with any of 10
chemical chemical carcinogens Federal law permits
ban ban
or
standard
cases
in cases
of
"grave grave grave
danger danger
a temporary to workers
The The The
proposal
if
adopted
would
constitute
the
most
Write or Call for information
Moisture and Vapor
Barrier Compounds
Protects insulation @ corrosive
retardant
LION
El
OIL COMPANY
1.on Oil Building Dorado Arkanses 71730
JUNE 1973
reaching health action yet taken by the federal government The temporary ban would be replaced within six months with permanent standards reflecting
studies made during the ban Several other labor groups including the AFL-
CIO's Industrial Union Department have endorsed
the carcinogen petition Labor Department officials insist they recognize the
threat and hint they'll probably act this month Our
purpose is to prevent We don't want to count the
that
bodies first says one specialist But he stresses that
drafting standards for carcinogens is far more compli-
cated than say writing specifications for over
bars on heavy equipment In the occupational area the scientific and
job accidents cause 14,000 deaths a year perhaps 100,000 persons die annually from occupationally
caused discases The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health has identified 8,000 toxic substances capable of harming man and many more are under study
It is particularly difficult to act standards for cancausing chemicals Researchers aren't always sure how or why the carcinogens cause cancer They often don't know what difference the length or amount
of exposure makes
How Do We Mozitor
Even where the scientific data are clear department officials argue totul protection can never be achieved
because test instruments can't be decide how do we monitor to make sure peo-
Chief
ple are being protected says John P. ONeili ONeili Chief Chief Chief Chief Chief of the division of Occupational Health Standards at the Labor Department's Occupational Safety and
Health Administration What do we do about medical surveillance Questions here include how often lung or urine tests should be made and whether
standards should require painful direct examination of the bladder when cancer is feared Workers might
balk at such a procedure some researchers argue
While some workers complain that the department
is moving too slowly some executives fear the carcinogen standards will be too stringent and too hastily
drafted
Most companies that have submitted comments to the department concede some regulations may be appropriate But they prefer a separate making for
25