Document 3QRG1GLprvaq02J9rnn8RRrZJ
MG
OSQfili PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT
WRG-786
GRACE
TO:
R. C Walsh
FROTI: W. J HeCaig
CC:
J. W. Wo1tar
As I mentioned during our visit in Washington, I was not comfort-
abla with subjnet quota from tho draft raapensa to Public
Cltizan.
Earl Lovick ratumad from his trip and I had him
rasaareh tha statamant using tha fleGill Study eomputarizad
amployaa history fils.
Tho attaehad is a list of all known
lung eanear daaths to data.
I would Ilka to suggast that wo obtain Or. HeDonald's coneurranco to a statamant in placo of subject quota. L suggest*
The oecurranca of lung cancer prior to 1*78 among Libby employees with exposures to high tramollts levels was net above what might hayo been expected among tha group given their ago f^noking history* amd-ettar tmdaaat andtwg of the--eAfscXS--tfgllLg Mliuiiu a during 11 i.wr~Uwa pel-ju. In other words* the occur rence of known cases was not alarming.
Tha original statamant ia incorrect and Inconsistent with tha data in both tha ftcGlll and tho NIOSH studies.
i
if
w. J. ftcCaig/rim Attachment
7
OCT 2 'MS
0420*80
'/yK-e . 'Tffj; ~ ~
%M
c4"r c^CTZlcck^J*.
\ a.jEG.'C,- / *7 ~7'5~ fi't- -^2*.
^0
c&s/'r/i*Fa. 'yttL' '7u:y.ft
Yv Y\J -<i
sz'"4. yC'-*z*cc-'/
3RACE
Zonal**
Lmc CAtea deaths
9/17/83
fR. OF 3EATK DEATHS
EMPLOYEE NAME
NUMBER OF YEARS EMPLOYED
1950
1935 I960 1963
1966 1967 1968 1969
*1970 1973
1976
1977 1978
1979 1980
1981
1982
1983
1984
1 J A. Blackmail
1 y R. Field 1 y R. Engle 2 y 0. Mast
>7 R. Orsborn 1 / J. Ludwig
1 <J M. McComas
1 y R. Bleich
2 1 W. Shows
J. Starr
1 J W. Smithars 1 y L. VanHorn 2 y E. Dinwiddle
J R. Dawson
1 J R. Cohanour 3 H. Day
7 L. Millar
J G. Mitchell
P. Roberta VT. Wright 1 V. Olson
2 C. Paterson R. Rayeme
2 *M. Ahrankial
J R. Dahms 4 J M. Baker
J. Garrison
yj. Gidlay
'V. Priest
2 K. Koehler M. McNair
1 H. Kimble
1.08
2.90 14.08 9.83
2.00 9.16 8.91 29.30 1.08 4.00 1.75 23.50 9.83 5.08 24.33 11.08 28.16 15.33 4.00 5.08 13.66 6.66 29.00 3.16 9.66 1.91 15.23 23.75 16.91 6.91 31.33 2.83
1947-1948 <Office Janitor)
1932-1955 1946-1960 1947-1936 1948-1930 1957-1966 1938-1967 1935-1968 1947-1946 1952-1956 1930-1932 1930-1973 1945-1955 1938-1943 1948-1974
1965-1976 1948-1976 1962-1978 1970-1974 1951-1956 1946-1962 1946-1953 1946-1975 1947-1950 1957-1972 1947-1949
1950-1965 1953-1978 1961-1978 1957-1964
1943-1975 1962-1965
Earl Lovick found these paopla to have diad only bacasue ha uas tracing them for the McGill and NICSH studies.
"* These people had insufficient time to have davalopad tfta problan as a result of employment.
** These paopla diad mora than tan yaars aftar leaving amploynant. Without a study such as tha McGill/NICSH Studies, no tia to amploynant at Libby ueuld ba mada.
0620781
ZB4OZ90
: ; sssssssssssisssssssssss s
**+ + ++*+** +><0 +'+>*'
"\ ^
tuo o9popoooeeeoopeoocooeoooeoooeoooo9eeoooooeoe
S M<n*iy # * <# tok.^
* -- ***^ --**
_Vit. oeflvceoceccers:o:te:eoosfccDoeee:eeooeooeee
*ai m. n .
I
ZB40Z90
C. i Ul a< oo...oo....oo...o.o...o.e...o.e...o.o...oo.. .oe...oe....oo....oo...o.e...o.e...o.e...o.e...o....o....o.o...oo...o.o...o.o...oo... fatr irtr^s^v *M0 0Mrt0 iao
Xs *u oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ...........................................................................................
* Win
^^
r
w V) oooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo i. ...m.......s.....r...^....t..n.....o.....^....*...i..^.........y.....m.....c...s........e.......*...B...
mi? e *i et *oinaar^o^yeoo..o....N....O.........m......a...
oy fv
-- -- -- -- a
iv
* iOjt yN..e.i.r.^.H...a..0.N..4...a.0...c.0...t.M......N..9..>.O.0....^-...a...a.*...Oa....a.e...N.....a0...9.N..>...CO....N^...9.^.>..^B.
IV IV IV fV
fW
w eoBee9>OB9>ty eno/tBne^i
ux ...*......................................................^...........e....a.......N.....n..
* _ uo
m n y o--
#
^ u ooanmainn bbbn
.
fv mm
n o
2 t.........................................................................;-----------------
fcvc**
^9
^^ s^^--v tS
_: 2**
-. ^
a8
V- x
v
o. v
>r ks. -2 C_ -
Ctsi ^2"
^ UJ
^
# ."-- * \^. o u i *** > 0 ^2 \r
IV
*s W8
...*....#.......00..T.....m.....N.....S...*.^..0.f.k...*....N....0p........f.f.w......0....0....^...^..00
--1 0f
4T 01 0v
o
*\. (V 0*
A S ^tV00000^0fk00fOOfnN0l0l0
03
X 1
0^Ov tefmt00-- N00Np emn--
amfVMme^l^o<evif*ton01
z
.
* -
-
na
g .l"li..-.l.(lll-----K(A-U
2t
* -
2 mo
* >io - -- -- - -- -- --8 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- - --
--^ ir
O MMMfUtVNUfNfV ^0# NNMNN^^NNN^NV) J
y -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- --~ -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ~--XS*5
S*oXu NKV*N"*eax0oooNm0eVioi00oo00*e*0O--ea0o^n^fe>*00N0M00^00^oNN----a*/*>>eNo^e00e--^^nM0oN*NVo0#0O0y2
oa
o ax
ua
v *0*00^0000X000 m0#0fUta0
* 2
o-- o0* N--*--**0-- 0-- na*I^0IV0N00 M0OV 0N0I0V--O--*
S
x*
O "
2 *> SS
0 00000000000000000000000*0 --
g 00M0fV0O0ir00000000)>ltOO*(0OO9
^ wg> y yj = ^0e^ffM0P0f0e00M0af.ya|^ y . 2
wau 2 -2;2*rr^",s:!r"''"o^M'"o^^.^.20* 2 " M iv -- 00 -- -- IV <v WV-- -- --V-- -- u
*
8to
hA\
yy m 0jy*sw0yyhOw003n0^sw orr80oa)xoa8on0Xo osy uyM 0oe
Ti .r
tuMC
CflnceR MoarRtrf
//-. *.;. w.
iv
^
#-7sg
I
r