Document 3Q2E3awE04ZozB4MwqgqJMpxn
FILE NAME: DDd DATE: DOC#: Dd OCUMENT DESCRIPTION:t,
;~
. 6R 'r"
)
\
" ....... ," b tJftr"b A.-- oM;' ; idip'irfs=a... " ,..
INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CCM1Issrrn 0'1' THE STATE or CALIFORNIA
CLAIM NO, 60 SF 193-8,54
eLl FORD P. HARDPlO I
Applicant,
VII.
PLII~T ASBEslb.s CO., J. T. THORP &. SONS.
INC METALCL.l.p INSULATION co. J rne, J
J:l1!oN CAW,
ASBt>SroS
&d:bl1supCApWtyrNCSOU. LAATRlOMNS,TROONOGTI'OClO'/ RK
CO. ~ COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CORP. I
C. ~'. BRAUN & CO., . OWENS CORNING
~ RGLAS CORP., JACKSON ~ HOPKIN S CO
mcl., MARINE ENGINEEluNG ... SUP4'LY CO. ,
F[.UbR MJl.lNl'ENANCE, INC. J M, R, CARPENTER, mel., lfI:;snRN ASBESTOS 100. , IND\J~;THlJU,
INrDlNl'rY CO. CALIFORNIil CASUALry ~:MNI1'Y EXCHANO;:, STANDARD ACCIDENT
!N~. co. I TRAVELERS INS. CO., ARGONAUT
lNq. CO. AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO.,
~'nIA CASUALTY &; SURETY CO. I O\lflRANTEE
IN;. co ZENITH NATrONAL IN S.. co.,
. PAc'::PIC EMPLOYERs INS. CO.. ASSOCIATED
lNItilJ1NITY CORP., Ilr.d STATE COMPENSATION
INS 'RANCE FUND.
OfWER APPROVING
OOMPROMIS AND RELEASE
The parties to the c.bove entitled action baving flied a
COl: jlromise and Release herein, on Aug. ~,1961, settling the above
ca .~ for $3,300.00, in Ilddition to 311 II~II which !My have been paId
pr ',-oual}'. and requeatIng that it be approved; and th.13 CommiBa1on
ho. tng cDn~idered tht:l entire record, including ~aldl COlllpN11I1"e and
--...
Re laae, now finds that it sllould be Approved; and, GOOD CAUSE APPEAlUNG TllEREFOR.;
IT IS CBI::ERED that said Compromise and Release be, and 1t 1s
he ~b1 o.pproved, payable as follows:
T!y D1OOSTfUAJ., rNllEMNlT! COMPANY By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY DlDENNITY EXCHANGE
By STANDARD ACC1DENT rNSURANCE COMPANr
$ 337.10 16.96 16.86
By TRAVELERS INSURlINCE; COMPANY
B.~ A.R.GOtiAUT. llIS\IlVllC.F. COMPANY'
50.57 33.7'1
.--
~~~~"~~.~--~------~--~~----------------------------~~-~------~~~
I ) ~ .. : : .~ ,. ... . ~,,,,,,,,,,-
Iai""" , hin h
ZM7?'Cr"f.;... ..... '&
;I" ... ,.
Re: CLIFFORD P. HARDING ClaIm No.
60 SF 193-S54
Y I\MERlCAN MOIOrusn; IN~Ck COMPANY
$ 84.28
.A.E'l'N ~ CASUALTY 0: SURETY COMPANY yCUARANTEE INSURANCE COMPANY ~ ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE CDMPANY "I3Y PACIFIC DlPLO"iEJ\S INsunMICR COMPANY By ASSOClATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION By STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE P\wD
370.81 296.54
33.71
101.13 33.71
193406-8 . .$3300.
1TIS fURTIIER,ORDERED t h n ~ S'rATE COMPENSAnON INSURANCE
~e~et the sum of $352.00 from 1ta contrIbut1on to be ~~~
di ctly~. rQllow~: $300.00 to Sm1th, Parr1~h. F~~uck & Clancy
a~ on attorneye , fee; $Z2.00 to Srnltn. PArrlD,hP~k & Clan~y
to t,ono,,'p' or tho "pooltloo; . ~~ "001, M.D.
}~f4 A.
DI
IAL ACCIDElft cor- ISSION
-f..
-+___________~F11ed and served on;
C 1Ifora ? HardIng, l ti 07 Howe Ave., Sacramento 25
P ant Asbestos Co., 1300 - 64th st" Emeryville
] T. Thory &: Sons, Inc., 1351 Ocean Ave., DneI')'Vl11e
M ta1ela.d nsulation Co., Inc., PO. :Box 173, Torrance
w Insuilltioo, 3600 - 20th Avo Sacramento w
ttOn AB.bestos 5: Su~~ly Co . 53<! Natoma St., SF
~00~a35ttr
o I
n n
g su
CorK
lat1n
CO' g P
I
r
o
18~4
duct
e
ogden corp
_
D .
rive 2684
aurl1ngame taCt street,
Lo~
~gele5
31
11. Bl"!IUl1 & Coo, 1000 South Fremont Ave'l Alh8lllhra
en~-Cornlns Fiberglas Corp., P.O. Box ~9. Sacramento
aC:<30n & BQpkJns eo.~" InC.,. ". O. Box 490. Bakllrl:fl.Qld
arlne Engineering & Supply co.) 941 East Second St 105 Angele~
~ luor ~laintenance, Inc., 2500 South At1antic SIver., Loa Angeles '22
~. R. Carpenter. Zno., 907 Front St., SlIcrnmento 7
oJestern Asbestos Co., 675 TOlolTlljand S~., ~F 3
~/1dVHr1al Indemnity Co. I 350 SM180me St., SP
Bl1tornlA Casualty :::/1demnity EXChange, 550 Kearny St., SF
Jtandard Accident Ine. Co., 8liO West San 13=0 Ave . San Bruno raveicrs Itl$. Co., 550 Ciilll.fornia se" SF rgonaut Ins. Co" 550 CaI'[ornia St:., SF rnerlcan ~otOl'iSt3 Ina. (b., 417 Montgoll\Qry St., SF etna Caaualty !: S".lI'et:y Co., 220 Montgomery St., SF uarantV9 Ins. Co" ;50 l\,,,tl,y 3t . sP enHh National Ins. Co., 582 Market st . .- SF :l.cH10 Employ~r& Ina. Cb' r 244 Pine SI;" SP eSocia.ted Indomnity Corp., 332 Pine St" SF' State COmllen~&t10n 1n s. Fund Personal Se~vico
f
.I
)
1!1 CLIFFORD P. !!AlIDINO - Claim 1-0:>. 60 SF 193-654
s::~ ::.:.. 1861
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ._J.:1.l.eI:1.and servad on: continued
Smj ~, parr1~h, Paduck ~ clanoy, 501 F1nane1al Center Bl~" H!l1 ,a II: Bropby, 1540 San Pablo Ave., Oakland
Sec ;WiCK, Detert, Moran Ik Arnold, 100 Bush st . SF - Attn:
:t>n.ll J.
'-eM-tr"icPk1G11opopd1ln.LJ)3, 1541MSounttg~oemr eSr~y.,StOu:;.I!'
3i1
Oakland GKoerdiothn
8
.I
)
I
CL FroRD P. !!ARDING A. R NELSON. Referee S tember 21, 1961
.. VII.
PL1INT ASEESTOS CO.,
J. T. THOR!> & SCN$ I lJ'IC.,
et al
Cl&l..rn No.. 60 SF 193-854 InJ; Asbestosis
REPORT Cf' REFEREE CN OMlER APPROVING COXPROMISE ;\NI) RElEASE
Asbestos worker, born February 28, 1896, cl aims Ii e5tosil! e.e the result of industrial exposure in employmentS Cor n~l!roua employers go1ng back lIome l~ yearo. Overall, including hl~ employments 1n the 1nduAtry 1n varlouD out-ot-State localltieo, h haa a h1atory of approxi~ately 30 years of 1ntermittent e~pooure t aabestos dust.
~e record BhoWIl that BPplloant eont1nue~ WOrking until M Y. 1959. ~h~n he was 5~i%e~ With sudden feVere ~eat palno. He w ~ hOSP1talized on a d1agnosis or coronary occlusion. Chea~ X raya taken at that time were interpreted a8 shoWing eY1den~c 0: Il balltos1s.
I~ la now propo~ed to ~e~tl~ the cae. by tho ~~ent or
$ 300.00, nothln~ hav1ng been paid he~etofor&.
Concerning the preaent oaoee or diDSbilit7. Dr. Horton C Hin8~w, Jr" ~tates aD tollO~8:
[
"The degree of asbestosis evident on X-ray here w01,llr;l.
n. t be expected to lead to heart dilleallc, and alBO the type of
heart disease produced by lung disease is quite different fro~
~Iaa&a which lead. to toronftry oc~usion, whioh thi4 pAt.ant
parentlY has had. Consequently, i-c would be my opinion that
II heart disease iEi a eeparate condition and not dHectly
~. l.atcd to hIs asbestosis".
Ql the basis of pulmonary function tests, the doctor neluded 1n his final report thnt the patient'/! 8ymptoms were to
~ Ia.rge degree due to his heart disease and not to asbestosis.
ndeed' on the baala of diffusion capacity test, it was his udgnlant that the asbestosis wns $0 mild as not to be disabling r producti ve of any symptOms.
j In an earlier ~rt<, Dr. Norbert Frey, lin behalf of
're applicant, bad conc1
tnat the patient had a moderate
cgt"~e of pulmonary fibrosis, which was productive ox some
hortncss of breath. Th expressed no opinIon concerning the
ndustrial contribl,ltion to the over- all disability.
-
OJ. the record, the settlement h .hlr and adequa.te.
4 IS~SITION: Order Approving Compromiu and Release to be paId
o said applicant. less $30.00 to Norbert PreY. M.D., and lellS
ctorneYB; fee of $300.00 and reimburG~~~nt costa ot 22.00 to
c paId to 9.ppHcan~'a attorneys Oul of the am
yabll! by
t a I e Compensation Insurance Fund.
A.liN:11l1m
4(fd ON. e
r . ,,
l~TII1e.~ N$Y l"O~~ _.~~.ull<i
T. lOU1S _,,,CACO
l1'lS ""c:t.:.s
A''''"''U
I'In!.tIJ 11(;1<
~ ~w.CJSCO
II... CQlOII!
H' ...... ' .... n..!U:1."Pi-411
February 27, 1962
nr. wtl11am L. ~ghe ~.ger Insurllllcc Department M1!!$tl'Ong, Cork Company
L4nc4'te~, pennsylvania.
n-avtl ~r' Po Ii cy No. __R_lrn__-44_9M_59_ _ __
Dear SU:
nUH notq dilpo6i t 1on IUdt of the following cbim; Date of Accident: January 9, 1955 -::l.i.....nt' Clifford p. Harding l.oeati.o~ ; Sacramento, California Claim NO.; B 9527634
Disposition: 50.57 Perm. Partiid
Rell'.arks ;
.~~ ~~n;,.
T[l.tn'~ .. ~
(J"'E~ -.\I,.iXl~
PLAINT/IF'S
- EXHI81T f 1119.D
- t.rf-,.
Very truly yours,
Indicate wnethor:
\Vorkmen's comp, ."...:.;:'<::-_ _ __ 'Uta lUbilley B.1. _ _ __
l',O. _ _ __
General L{~biltty S.I.
P,D.-
A. 1-1. NELSON. ~ero:.-ee
September 2:1., 1961
va.
:r~ AS!!!S1'CS CO.,
J. T. Tr:ORP .i: SONS, INC,.
et 1.1
Cl~ No. 60 SP 193-854 InJ: A3t>eo ~o, 1~
A~bueo:l worker, born ~t~rw.C"Y ;?8, lS96, da.1.tM a:Oe~tO~l$ ,~ the re3ul~ of ln~u5tr~al exposure 1n em?loym~n~~ for numerous eall>~()'1@1"S gNng back somo 15 :years. Overall, including his employments in the 1nrj\J. cry- in various out of- Stale ~oob~1tl~ll', he has a history of II\lPt'O~H~ly 30 J'el.M of inter!l!ltunt e;r:pO$Ut'1!
t o b~beeos ~U4~.
'!'h! record shows that applicant continued work1r:~ untll M4y. 1959, when he was seized with sudden severe el\e~t pains. i-lt bas hO'l'Hwltuc1 on a diagnosis of corona,ry cccl.l.I.:Ilcn. Cr.lSt X-rays takon at that t1.':I' Wore LnterpNlted as showing evidence of asbestosis_
It 1~ noW proposed to settle the case by the ~rm~nt of $3300,00, noth.lO_ having been paid heretofore.
Conee~jn~ the present cause ot dt8a~ility, Dr. HortOn C. ~1n3haw, Jr. I 't&te~ i3 follows:
"The degree of asbestosis tvidont on X- ray here would not be e~eoCt.c:! to lead to heart dlHiS~, and aHO the type of
heart disease rroduced by lunG <lisease los quite ditrft'tnt; fror: d!HaH which cads to <:Ql"Qn~1"Y occlusion. which IOhH patient apparently has had. Consequently, It wouJd be ~. OJ?inlon that
l1is heart dl.!~a&1t 1: ;l separate condition and not dlfcctlv
r-eht~d to his U'c*stQ~H.
-
on the basis of P\llmon~r-; function tests, the aoetol'
concluded in his final reporc that tr.. patient'~ ,,~eom: \o'~N to
a large degree ~\le to his hl!i!.;''' <ll~.ase and not to asbestosis. IndeeC!, on the basis of dHf1.JUon capacity test. i I has his
.1\J,i16m~n~ that. 1:h~ a..,'tIei!lt.Q~:'~ WQ.~ lJQ mild ao bor 't(:l bo diS;abring
or pM(\lJol;1ve of any symptOmS.
In nn earlier rt?O;O~, ~, Norbert F~;I, On behulf of th .. lI.ppl~"s.llt. n~c concluded that -he Pat~!nt had ~ moderate degree of J;lUlmor:a.:oy C:'O!'oH3, \oIr,lcn was proc...ctl.y~ of ~OI')I! ehortne'$ of breach. H; ~xp:,e~~~(\ no c~~nlon concerning the industr:!.al Qontr~bu~lon to e~le over-all di3ability.
On the rocord, the H,;~~oene ~~ fair and adequate.
DIS?OS!'i!O!!; Order ;'~\l:-~"!n6 Co;:,.Por.:1H ",r.d Release to be paid to said ~cp\lea:'lt, ~o,~ $30_30 tc NorJ~r~ Frey. ~.:>., and lea a
~ttor~ty~1 ~BB o~ $300.CO and ~Cl~~~~3em~~~ co3~~ of !~2&Qa ~o
be paJd to a?;;l~ca~t'5 at~c~Cy" 01,;, of ~he ..:nount. pAl'able by State CO(!lpen~.a1;.~on !:lour-MOE: E'ur:<!.
A. H. H2..S0N, Referee
...I.f:, . .
) / 1, .
>
il
I '
':
",
THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT CDI'II'lISS10N OF' THE STATE OF CALJFORNIA
lrodullfiol l,c"'..., eo.....~
fA RECEIVED AuG 2 !I 1961
FILED
,
, Sc:rom.ntQ Office
CLIPf flO P.
HOIn Avenue
Saer&monto 25. eallrQrn~o
PLANT ItSGCSTOS COl'lPANY EmplO),Gl'
J. T. THORP I SOHS. JNC. Elllplo>,
n(TAl L~O I~SULATICN CO., I~C. Employer
OAR C W, dba CAW INSULATIDM
mploy.p
DUllO , ASBESTOS' EUPPtV CD.
Employer ~~MST~NG CORK CD.
E"'ployar
COAST INSULATING PAO OUCTS CORP. Employer
C. r. BRAUIJ a: CO. Employ." OWENS CORNING FIIlE:RGLAS CORP.
Employer JAC ~.t HOPXlNS CO. , INC.
Fnplayer MARlh C~GtNEERING I SUPPLY CD.
""l'!.Qlt'.e..
~oaa MA1~T~QNC[. INC. Ero.PJ.q.y.u
M. ~. CARPEnTER, IWC.
[llflllcyU'
wtsTE N nsecS1DS CO.
Employer
1 I~OUS
CALIF' STAND TRAV& ARGON
~IAL r~OenNITY COnPANY In.u... no.. Cllrrier
IirlIA CASUALTY INOH1Nllv EXCHANGE Insurance Carrier
flO N::.c DENT INSlJfHWCf: COMPf\"Y In'Urlll1Ca CarriHr
t:~S INSURANCE COI'tPANl'
I nelJl'ijnell Carrier
UT INSURANCE COf'lPAIW
Insurance Carrier
AMttn[AN I'lOTOfWiTS fIJSURArlC COMPIWY
!r~'tl'anCB Carrier
AtTl/A CASUAllY & SURETY t:DNPAN'r
"
Ineuranca Carrier:'
CUARAmTtE INSURANCE COMPANY
r
Inoll':-.dInvw Carrie,.
Ur.lIT! NATIONAL I NSURAlJCE COMPANY In.ur~n~~ Carrier
PACl, C I'lPl.DYERS IIJSURArJCf. I:OI'lPAIJ'(
Insurance Carrier
300 64th Street
[mgryv111;, Ca11rOrn11
Ocean Avenue E:msrYIIUl.8. California
Poot arrica Bex 178
Torrance, California 3600 20th AII~nue
Saoramonto ~n. C~llrarni.
532 Nateml Street San Francisco 3, California
10110 Ogden Drive BurlingAllIa, CllliCornin
26Bw Lacy str;.'
Lei AngtlQ8 )1, California 1000 South Fremcnt Avenue
Alhambra. California Poat arr1cI Box 89
Sacramento, Ca lifo rnia Past Orne!! 90l( ~9[)
Bakersfield, California 9~1 East Second Street
LOB AngDla., California 2500 South A;lDnt1~ eoulovar~
l.c~ Angalas 22, CoHrcrn1a
~07 Front Strut: Sacramanto 7, Ca !iCorn i.!l
675 Toun~'nd Street Slln rl'lln~hcc 3, California
350 S,nooml Street
~a" Fr.~oi.oo. C.llFbP"ia 550 Ktamy Street
SlIn Fr!Mt.co, California
S~O wo,t San Bruno ~~.nu.
San Bruno, Califofnill 550 Cltlifornia Street
San F'ranc!eeo, Cijliror"ia 550 California Street
San Franc1!!!;o, California ~17 Ment~ome~y Street
San rrlmchco. California 220 ~ontgo~ery Street
San FranCISco, California 5,0 Kearny Street
~an rr8n~!.~D, C.llrg.n!. 562 ~~:~~~ Street
Slin franciSCO, Callfornia 3730 Piedmont Avenue
CI~t.nd 11. Ca11rern11
t
-! ) . ~ .. ~ ....'\, : ;
b t tii . [1Mh > 4 .. ' 'M iiI' . ,,- ... ,. lie: CLIFFORD p. HARIl~Cl ell im No 60 SF 193-8S4
Y AMEA.lCAN MOTORISTS INSUR~C1i: COMPANY .AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY COMPANY GUARANTEE INSURANCE COMPANY
1l'l ZENITH NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY By PACIFIC DU'LOYERS INSURANCE COMPANY By ASSOCIATED INDEMNITY CORPORATION By STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND
$ 84.28 370.91 2136.54 33.71
101.13
33.71
193~'6'2
$33Qt1. 0
I TIS FUR.THFR ORDERED t hat STATE COM PENS ATION INSURANCE
D ded~~t the eum or $352.00 from ita contribution to be paid
01 ot1y Be followel _ $300.00 to Smith. rarr1eh l PaduQk & C1anc1
Illi an attorney!!' reft; $22.00 to Sm1th, fllrr'l.s~hP~dI( k C19oP c1
<0 " ..".", 0< .....,0."'''; . ~~;. 'r". M.D.
tl'f4 A.
ll{
RIAL ACCIDENT COl' fISSION
A ;1'II1m
-4_ _ _~~_ _ _ _ _ _-:Fl.led and served on:
C lfford P. HardIng, 11.107 Howe Ave., Sacramento 25
P ant Asbestos Co., 1300 - 64th St., Emeryville
J T Thorp &, Sons, Inc., l351 Ocean Ave., Emeryvilll!
M t$.~clad Insulation Co, Inc., P.O. Box l7$, Torrance
W' Insulation, 3600 ~ 20th Ave Sacramento 20
tton Asbestos & Sup~ly Co., 532 ~atoma st" SF
~&trong Cork Co., 1814 Ogaen Drive Bur11n~ame
2684 Coast InBulatlng Product! corp.,
Lacy Street, Lo3 Ange1e5 31
d. F. Braun & Co., 1000 South Fremont Ave., Alhamb~a
~ens-COrn1ng FlbergA~8 Corp., P.O. Box ~9, S~;ramento
<lCk:lon &: Hqpk:.lns Co.,. InC." P.O. Eox ~90, ~kwr&fiQld
rarln~ En~~"eer1ng & Supply co., 9~1 Ea8t Second S~ 1.oe Angele~
luor Halntenance, Inc., 2500 south Atlantic Blvrf" Loll Angeles 2<l
. R. Carpenter, rnc., 907 Front Ct., Sacrllmento 7
~ estern Asbestos Co., 675 TOWl'lGend St. J SP 3
"dust ria 1 Indemnity Co., 350 San,ome St., SF
aHforn1.1 C asualty I~at!mnHY Exchange, 550 Kearny SC., SP
tand~rd Accident Ins. Co., 840 West San Bruno Ave. , San lJruno
raVel<;Ts Ins. Co.. 550 Californl.a SI;.., 091"
rgOMut Ins'. Co., 550 California Sc . SF'
merlcan lo'.oi:or1ets Ins. (b. I 417 Montgollery St., SF'
!e tn a Casual ty to: S",rety Co. f 220 Montgomery St., SF' uarante~ Ina. Co" 550 Kc~rpy ~~., ~p enlth Net10nal Ins. (b., 582 Market st.; SF acif1c wplo::era Ina. Co., 244 Pine st . .9? esoo1ated Indemnl.ty Corp.. 332 Pine St., SF State COmpensation Ins Fond ~ Personal BerviCQ
!
'1
I
j
)
I' .
,
)
I
,
tMl
'i
dnd',-;aiutn,,?I...... SIri.iilL<;:l
,,; .
.,t;a.
'
t<a..;ettms
1
'
,
.
&6s
steil
RI CLIfllORD P. HAJU>JJW - Claim NJ. 60 Si' 1'93-8:14
. ,.1-
S::,: ::.:., 1961 .. ,_~. ____ . _ _ _~ and served on:
continued
Srnj ~, ~ar~oh.
RaJ' ,a & Brophy,
PAdUck & Clancy, 501 Finanoial 1540 San Pe.blo AV9., OaklllDd
Center Bld~.,
Oakl~nct
Bee ;w1ek, Detart, Moran" Arnold, 100 Bush S~., SP M Attn: Gordon
Keith
I-1\tl J.
. '
en at
r
&
lc
F)
K
.Glolpot~l'l.q1n.3145
1
MOll,tomcrY SUtter 81;
s
t
.
1.. Illl'
SP
-3-
8
/
)
,.'
CLIERJRD p, HARD~O
A. H. NELSON, Referee 59 tember 21, 1961
~ .... . ~
VB.
PIAN'l' ASBESTOS CO"
J. T. THORP &< SQffi, ct al
INC
Cla1m No.. 60 SF 193-854 Inj: AsbestoSis
REPORT CF REFEREE eN ORDEIt APPROVlNG COXl'RQM1S E }N) REl.EA<:;
II
~$tos111Ausbetshtocs rewsourkltcr,ofboinrnduFsetbrriuaal ryex2p8o,su1re8916n,
claims employments
for
n erouo ~m~loyere hjS employmcnt~ 1n
gOing blle~ some the lndu~try in
15 ~earll. OVerall. lneluo1ng
va~lou8 ovt-ot-State localltlell,
h
t
h~a & hl~to~ of asbestos Oust,
appro~lItely
30
yearD
of
intermittent
axpooure
~
y,
The reco~Q vho~ that &ppll~ant 1959. wh~~ h~ Willi ~Bized with 8udden
continued working until dever@ che~t pains. He
w X
rsayh~ostpa1kteanlizaetdthOan tatidmlaegnw0e4r@1Binotrer~porreotneadrya~ocBclhuoswiionng .
Chest evidence
or
II beBtoais.
$ ~OO.OO,
It la now propolleO to D~ttl~ ~e eooe b~ nothing having been p~~~ ~~rO~ofore.
~e
p~yman~
or
C HinsnawC, oJnrc.e,rn&intgatethveaps retoslelnowt oca:UBe or dlsabil1ty, Dr. Horton
n
t
be
e
x
p
"T ec
he ted
deg to
r
ee lea
o d
f
t
a o
sbes hca
t r
o t
sis evide
d1~eMe.
nt on nnd
a
X-r 180
a
y th
h e
ere typ
w e
oul of
d
hbart discase
di.~se wnich
produced Jea~s to
by lung disease is
coronary oec1~~~on,
quite different from
whioh ~hi, pAt~Qnt
~,
parentlY has had. 8 heart disease is
Consequcntly, it would be my a eePsl'a\;e condition and not
opinion that directly
luted to hIs asbestos~s".
~ oncluded
00 In
the his
basis final
of pulmonary function tests, the doctor report that the patient's :lymptoms were
to
large ndeeo.
degree on the
due to his heart disease and not to asbestosis. bsa1a of diffusion capacity lest, i t was his
lJdgrnent that I' productive
the asbestosis was of any symptoms.
so
mild
as
not
to
br::
disabling
l're applicaInnta, nhaedarcloieorcl;~rttJnaDt r.thNe oprabteiret nFt rheyad,
an behalf of a moderate
cgr<!e of hortness
pulmonary of breath.
fibrosis, which was productive of some H: expressed no opinion concerning the
ndustrial contribution to the over-all disability.
OJ. tile record, [be settlement 19 ,fail' and adequate.
4 - IS
o
roS sai
IT d
ION, <lpp
l
l
Orde cant,
r l
App ess
roving $30.00
COlnprom1ae' to Norber
t
a
nd Re
Pr~y.
lease M.D.
,
t
o an
be d
l
pa
UI
Id
)
t~orn~ya'
e pal d to
fee of $300,00 and reimbureement appl1ean t I ij attorney s out of the
costs amo
or
22.00 to
yatlle by
tate Compens31ion Insurance Fund.
AJiN:1111m
k/.~ ON,
/
)
eo
THE INDUSTRIAL ACCIDENT tDr1J1'lISSID~ OF THE STATE: OF CALIFORNIA
CLAt~ NO. 60 Sf 193-9$4
l...sutlrlol &'eI~.~' C~'''';''';''ft
ri' KECEIVO AuG 2 !I 1961
FILED . S..:ramOnIQ 00"
CLIFF ftO p.
HtxoIlII Avenue
SAcramento 2'. Csl1rc~n1a
RRl'lstf,NG PLANT
J. T.
neTAl OAN C
DUTTO
orr1c. ~SBSlOS CO~PANY
300 - 64th Street
[111,,1 "Ylllr
E~Gryvtll., C-11rorn1s
THORP I SONS, II'IC;~.~.B-:!.~~'----,
Ocean Avenue
[mpley
Emaryvillo, California
LAO IN9UlATIOM CO INC.
Pout
90~ 1'8
'E:mplIlYlllr
Torrance, C:llifornia
~. ~b~ CAw lHSULA1IDV
3600 - 20th Avenue
&:tnplDyal'
SAcrBlllento 20, C.11'orn1e
ASBESTOS. SUPPLY CD.
532 Netoma StroEt
Employer
San Francisco 3, California
CORK C(O",.,,1 DyDr
1814 Ogdeo DrJ v e Surl1l"1g5mc. Clllifor)1ia
COAST
c. r.
OW~NS
JACK nQR1~ F1.UOfl
n. ~.
WESTE
INSuLATING PRO DUCTS COIlP.
Employer
SRAUIJ u CD.
Employar
CORNING ~lS~AGLAS CORP.
Employer
/I a 1I0P!UNS CO. , INC. ~hyor EN~I~EERI"G! SUPPLY CD.
rJA1NT(IU'Ar;cf~~ E.1l].1i~
CARPENTtR, INC.
eMplOY,,"
~ ASBEsros co,
Employer
Z~B4
1000 Poot Past
l'~y st~&.t
LOll Angal,., 31, California
South Fremcnt Avenue Alhambra, Clllifornia
orrico Box 99 Sacramento, California Orrico 80)( "90 Bakersfield, California
941 East Second Street
LOS An~D~a Californi~ 2500 South A\~~nt1e Bculavar~
LoCi Angales 22, CelHornia
90'1 Front street
$;lcramanto '1. ClIlifornia
675 TOuns,"d Street Son F'1'a"~1.CD 3, California
IIIOUS RIAl INOEn"'ITY COMPA/IY
In ..f.Jt>ana Carrier
1 I;i\UF'
STAND TAAVf;
IiUIA CASUALTY IND~I'NITY EXCHANGE InSl.lral'lce Carrier
RD AOC I DENT lIlSUFW;CE tOMPI\"Y
rn"tJrsn~e Carriar
eRS INSURANCE COf1PAIIJ't'
InaUrllr"lC'9 Carrier ARGON ) UT INSURANCE CtJl'lPAriY
Insurance Carrier
AM'R~AN f'lQtORI!OfS IIJSURArJCf; ~OI'1PMY Y"'-:',Iranclt Carrier
AET~11 CASUALTY ~ SURETY CONPIIr/'r Insurance Carrier,"
GUIlR TeE INSURANCE COI'l~ /tHY
4E~nl
NATIONAL
Jt"N,S",UuR"A".rnJ,,~, E..
Carrier C:OI'IPANY
Inl!U%'3I'fc" Carrier
PACIF C E~PLOYER5 INSURA~CE COMPANY
Insurance Carrier
350 550
~~"!lcm. Street Sa" F'~_net.eo. Kearny S t r e e t San rr~nCl,co,
C.11'e~"1.
Galiforn la
9'<0 ~,at San Bruno ~V'nu'
to,,' Siln BrunQ, C;tlifornia
550 Califonia Street San Frenc1scp, Califcrnia
550 California Street
Sar'l F'~lInC1Dl;p, Californlll ~ontgomery Street
San f'rl'ln<;1.sco. California
220 ~ontgo~.ry street San FrancIsco, Calltorn.a
HO K..lIrny street ~.n rrHncl_Cg. Ce11rgrnl.
582 "a:k.t Street Sin francIsco, Cal~fornla
3730 Piedmont Avenue Oakland 11. C~l1rolnl'
.. ,.
,
'." ~,;."* '. " ,: t
)
r by 3"
#4 - G& i (54,8';,;8. +
,.
INDIJSTRlJ\L ACClDENT CQ>WSSICN OF THE STATE Oi" CALIFORNIA
CLAIM NO. 60 SF 193.(\54
CLIProrm P. HAFIDnlG,
Appric~n t.
VB.
PLA~T ASBESTOS CO., J. T. TIIORP to SONS,
INC METALCLAD INSULATION CO" DiG.,
r. DAsI'Np'~CSATWOS,
db(\. CAW INSULATION, 00T1'0 & SUPl'L Y CO, ARMSTRONG CORK
CO. COAST INSULATING PRODUCTS CO!U'.,
nC.~~rR-G. LBARASUNCOR&P.cIo.,JACOKWSEONNS fCcOHRONIPN)CGDlS CO.I
!Net I MARINE ENGIN!E~ING &. SUIlIlLY CO
FLOOR MA.lNTF;NANCE, INC. I M. R. CARPENTER,
INC{, \II1tS'l'ERN ASBESTOS co. , INDV:ITH.IAl.
INI1EMN1TY CO". CflLlFORN!A CASUALTY ~'mlTY E:XCKANO~, STANDARD ACCIDEN'r m,\i. CO.. nlAVELERS INS. CO., ARGONAUT DiS. CO. AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS. CO.,
:oleAINE1:/'l,IAcoC.AS,UZAELNTIYTH&
SURElY CO., CUARAN'l'U NA TlONAL IN S. CO.,
PAd::nc EMPLOY!EI.S INS. CO, ASSOCIATED
INI6l:MNITY CORP., and ST AIE COMPENSATION
tllllNCE FUND,
Dafendantu
ORDER APPROVING
OOMPROMISE AND RELEASE
The part1ea to the above entitled action having fiJed a
CQt prom1aa and Release herein, on Aug. 29,1961, settling the above
ea ,! for $3,300.00, in addition to all eUlt3 which miiy have been paid
p. ',lously, lind requeatlng thilt it bQ approved; and th.1:! COtn1Tli80ion
ha tng con5idered the ~ntire record, includil'lg sa1d,Cofllpro"liae llnd
"-r
l\61 Jasti, now finda that it should be npprovedj and, GOOD CAUSE APPEARING TIlEREFOR;
IT IS U<lE<ED th... t aal.d Compromise and Release be, and it 111
he ~b1 approved, payablo as follows:
By D{OOSTRIAI:, INDEMNt'l'! COMPANY By CALIFORNIA CASUALTY L'WEI>!Nt'l' EXCHANGE
By STANDARD ACC!D~T INSVRANCt COMPANY
$ 337.10
16.96 16.86
By TRAVE:LtRS INSURANCE COMPANY
50.57
B!> ARGONAUT. IlISlIRANCE:. COMPANY'
33.7:1.
.. __ __.. .. ____________ .. ______ -- ~ ~~, ~~ ~~~~~.~
~n._~~
.u__~~q~---~~