Document 37G72m42MmweLk2m7O87Ne9RO

FILE NAME: Wagner (WAG) DATE: 2003 DOC#: WAG003 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: Legal - Amended Appendix to Plaintiffs' Opening Brief on Appeal IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE IN RE: ASBESTOS LITIGATION No. 704, 2002 Court Below: Superior Cour Of the State of Delaware in and for New Castle County Arthur Fleetwood John Cash John Rigby Dennis Carr William Miller James Desmond James Wilson William Cooper Billie Chaney Virginia Mason (Charles) George Hill Ella Morris (Samuel) Jackie Donovan Clifford Scruggs Raymond Nack James Williams Conrad Fassel Larry Hollis Charles Fleetwood Leroy Messick Joseph Messick Albert Griffith Paul Hitchens Robert Truitt George Willey Kenneth Miller Freddie Pusey Raymond Peters Lois Lyons Harold Porter Calvin Musser Larry Surricchio Jerome Wells Jack Brasure Edgar Wilson Richard Mccabe Roland Wingate Clark Spicer William Lane C .A. No. 99C-02-278 C .A . No. 00C-04-I62 C.A. N o . 00C-05-O45 C .A . No. 01C~02-003 C.A. N o . 00C-05-024 C.A. N o . 0C-08-209 C.A. No. 00C-12-224 C.A. NO. 86C-08-070S C.A. NO, 97C-08-087 C.A. NO. 84C-05-145J C.A. NO. 97C-08-064 C.A. NO. 84C-05-145N C.A. NO. 99C~ 09-074 C.A. NO. 99C-11-106 C.A. NO. 98C-05-047 C.A. N o . 00C-06-047 C.A. No. 00C-11-159 C.A. No. 97C-08-128 C.A. No. 96C-05-2G6 C.A. No. 96C-10-150 C.A. No. S5C-03-123 C.A. No. 97C-02-220 C.A. No. 97C-10-153 C.A. No. 97Ci12-019 C.A. No. 97C-03-056 C.A. No. 98C-04-123 C.A. N o . 94C-01-038 C.A. N o . S8C-09-007 C.A. No. 97C-09-135 C.A. No. 97C-11-228 C.A. N o . 88C-09-199 C.A. No. 89C-10-130 C.A. No. 89C-10-128 C.A. N o . 89C-10-129 C.A. N o . 90C-05-038 C.A. No. 90C-05-037 C.A. N o . 90C-07-101 C.A. No . 9OC-07-102 C.A. No. 90C-07-103 John Garris Ronald Davidson Parker Turner Robert Steele William West Robert Harding James Reed Claude Marvel Orville Somers Sidney Taylor Alton Scott Kenneth Marvel Richard Bowdle Leroy Hill Eugene Hastings Donald Hill Ben Peterson Shelly Ewell Woodrow Butler Herman English Thomas Marine Albert Mcdowell Doris Fernandes Edward Kowalewski Lester Trice Erman James Bradely Edward Barto (John Barto) Calvin Collins Griffin Conley G. Robert Dickerson Calvin Foskey Allen Hickman, Sr. Lloyd Hopkins Charles Isenberg Jack Messick Ulysses Mills Joseph Moore Donald Powell Lewis Powell Harry Schiff Joseph Spicer Andrew H. Bjorson, Urias Graham, Granville W. Brittingham Ernest M. Derrickson Roy D. James Hayward Roe C A. C A. C A. C A. C A. C A. C A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. C A. c A. c A. c A. C A. c A. c A. c A. C A. c A. C A. c A. C A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. C A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c A. c .A. c .A. c .A. c .A. c .A. c .A. c .A. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. 90C--12--040 90C- 11--222 90C- 12--039 90C--11--221 91C- 04--124 91C- 04- 153 91C- 04- 125 90C- 09--067 90C- 09--068 90C- 12--139 90C--12--108 90C- 12--106 90C- 12--107 90C- 12- 109 91C- 07--251 91C--07--259 91C- 07--127 91C- 04--046 91C- 07- 252 91C--01--153 88C- 07--146A 89C--05--197 87C--07--037 88C--11--109 86C--02--100A 84C--05--145A 84C--05--145B 84C--05--145C 84C--05--145D 84C--05--145E 84C--05--145F 84C--05--145G 84C--05--145H 84C--05--1451 84C--05--145K 84C--05--145L 84C--05--145M 84C--05--1450 84C--05--145P 84C--05--145R 84C--05--145S 85C--05 -013 85C--11--119A 85C--11 -119B 85C--11 -119C 85C--11 -119D 85C--11 -119E Roy D. James : Hayward Roe Dale V. Shaffer Harley G. Watkins, Jr. Dathiette M. Hearn, Donald Lowe, C .A. No. 85C-11-119D C.A. No. 85C-11-119E C .A . No. 85C-11-119F C.A. No. 85C-11-119G C.A. No. 86C-06-160 C.A. No. 86C-08-070A Plaintiffs, v. CHARLES A . WAGNER C O ., INC. , Defendants. APPEAL FROM THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY AMENDED APPENDIX TO PLAINTIFFS'/APPELLANTS'OPENING BRIEF ON APPEAL JACOBS & CRUMPLAR, P.A. Date : By: Thomas C. Crumplar (I.D. #0943) David A. Arndt (I.D. #3925) 2 East 7th Street P.O. Box 1271 Wilmington, DE 19899 (302) 656-5445 Attorneys for Plaintiffs/Appellant APPENDIX January 29, 1969 DuPont Letter to Charles A. Wagner Co., Inc A-l January 31, 1969 Charles A. Wagner Co. Letter to DuPont A-2 January 13, 1970 Asbestos Corporation Limited Letter to Edward Rabon "Re: Bag Markings - Caution Notice" . . . . A-3 Deposition Testimony ACL's Vice-President of Operations William Callan dated November 24, 1980 . . A-4 - A-8 Wagner Shipment Records to DuPont Seaford From 1958 - 1973 ...... A-9 - A-15 Charles A. Wagner Co., Inc. Brochure . . . A-16 - A-17 3/15/61 Letter . . . . . . . . . A-18 1947 Pennsylvania Workmen's Compensation and Occupational Disease Laws (From PA State Archives) . . . . . A-19 - A-28 Rules and Regulations of the Department of Environmental Resources regarding Threshold Limits of Occupational Dusts, effective November 1, 1971 ...... A-29 - A-33 1971 Federal Register Rules and Regulations Part 1910 - Occupational Safety and Health Standards "Emergency Standard for Exposure To Asbestos Dust . . . . . - f 1972 Federal Register Rules and Regulations Part 1910 - Occupational Safety and Health Standards "Standard for Exposure to Asbestos Dust" . . . . . . A-34 - A-35 A-36 - A-40 Trial Testimony of John Dement, Ph.D. dated September 23, 1999 . ... A-41 - A-45 Article from Chemical Week, September 10, 1966 "Asbestos: Awaiting 'Trial'" A-46 APPENDIX Page 2 (cont.) Deposition Testimony of Edward Rabon dated June 19, 1985 . . . . . A-47 - a -84 Deposition Testimony of Edward Rabon Dated September 21, 1988 . . . . A-85 - A-101 Deposition Testimony of Edward Rabon Dated June 13, 1989 .................... A-102 - A-151 Deposition Testimony of Wayne Rabon Dated April 23, 1997 . . 1 . A-160 - A-176 Charles A. Wagner Co,, Inc.'s Answers to Interrogatories filed in the Bradley case Dated October 29, 1985 . . . . A-177 - A-180 October 6, 1958 Asbestos Corporation Limited Letter to Charles A. Wagner Co. . . . . A-181 February 11, 1958 Asbestos Corporation Limited Letter to Charles A. Wagner Co. .... A-181a June 21, 1966 Asbestos Corporation Limited Letter to Edward Rabon "Re-. Manual Testing Of Procedures" . . . . . . A-182 - A-183 November 19, 1973 Asbestos Corporation Limited Letter to Arthur H. Thomas Company . . . . A-184 November 21, 1975 Amoco Intra-Company Correspondence Regarding Polypropylene - Talc Grades . . . A-185 May 5, 1978 Memorandum from B.F. Eby .... A-186 Wendel, Clarence, "Special Report of Talc Resources - A Supply and Marketing Study" United States Department Of the Interior/National Park Service (June 1978) ...... A-187 - A-188 Castleman, Barry I., "ASBESTOS: Medical and Legal Aspects" , Fourth Edition (1996) A-189 - A-234 APPENDIX Page 3 (cont.) Daum, M.D., Susan/ "Work is Dangerous to Your Health" , A Handbook of Health Hazards in the Workplace and What You Can Do About Them (1973) . . A-235 - A-253 Asbestos Corporation Limited Answers to Interrogatories ..... A-254 - A-256 Arthur Fleetwood Complaint .... A-257 - A-270 May 5, 1953 Eagle-Picher Sales Company letter To Ehret Magnesia Manufacturing Company . A-271 Eagle-Picher Product Brochures . . . A-272 - A-275 Deposition Testimony of Richard Wareham Dated June 8, 1982 . . . . . A-276 - A-283 RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES* ERMAN JAMES BRADLEY C.A. NO. 84C-05-145 DOCKET # DATE ACTION 1 May 30, 1984 Complaint Filed 99a January 25, 1985 Amended Complaint adding Charles Wagner 634 June 9, 1988 Wagner's Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment 635 June 9, 1988 Opening Brief of Wagner In Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment 636 June 9, 1988 Appendix to Opening Brief of Wagner in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment 641 July 21, 1988 Plaintiff's Answering Brief 642 July 21, 1988 Appendix to Plaintiff's Answering Brief 643 August 9, 1988 Wagner's Reply Brief 657 October 11, 1988 Plaintiff's Supplementation to their Answering Brief * Because the docket entries are basically the same for all other plaintiffs', counsel has included these three plaintiffs' as a representative sample. 658 706 878-a 1476 1477 1478 1480 1484 1485 1486 October 19, 1988 Reply of Charles Wagner to Plaintiff's Supplementation June 19, 1989 Order signed by Judge Taylor on Mooion of the Charles Wagner for Summary Judgment...GRANTED August 16, 1989 Order on Plaintiff's Motion for Re-Argument...DENIED February 15, 1995 Motion for Entry of Final Judgment September 27, 2001 August 30, 2002 Entry of Final Judgment Plaintiff's Motion to Set Trial Date October 25, 2002 Charles Wagner's Response to Plaintiff's Motion Set Trial Date November 4, 2002 Plaintiff's Order Regarding Setting Cases for Trial...SO ORDERED November 12, 2002 Wagner's Motion for Summary Judgment and Opening Brief November 19, 2002 Plaintiff's Answering Brief in Opposition of Wagner's Motion for Summary Judgment DOCKET # 1 228 252 269 475 484 486 490 491 RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES RAYMOND NACK C.A. NO. 98C-05-047 DATE ACTION May 5, 1998 Complaint Filed June 9, 2000 Wagner's Motion for Summary Judgment July 21, 2000 Plaintiff's Answering Brier September 1, 200'0 Wagner's Reply Brief July 2, 2001 Judge Babiarz Decision Granting Charles Wagner's Motion for Summary Judgment July 11, 2001 Plaintiff's Application for Certification of the Trial Court's Interlocutory Order for the Puposes of Appeal July 2, 2001 Order Granting Interlocutory Appeal August 30, 2002 Plaintiff's Motion to Set Trial Date October 25, 2002 Charles Wagner's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Set Trial Date November 4, 2002 Plaintiff's Order Regarding Setting Cases for Trial-SO ORDERED November 12, 2002 Wagner's Motion for 1487 November 20, 2002 Wagner's ReplyBrief in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment