Document 2j30YXD2BKpprYB9D80MVZRyN
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT
CCS-74
1230
LEdSLAUVE JOURNAL--SENATE
DECEMBER 11,
An Act mamOrng the act efAugust 6, 2941 (RLS61, o-3r3), xafertd to as Tie PeoflsyJvaela Baud ofppehaiwn and Ftrale hat,
fir noobenb^ TaAatPim}rcaaQamc
Ccositered die secaod teaand agreed m, Ordered; To fee printed on the Calendar for fozrd considerfaaa.
BUXSOVHUHOJUDBR.
SB 533 and SB S8T -- Wslwat objeefido, tke bUh wax passed over in ibeir erdkr S tt>C7t<jocst ofSenatorFIOCOLA.
BILL QN SECOND CONSIDERATION
SB 56 (Pt No. 1574) -- Tbe Scaale proceeded to cnaslderatiDotjftbe tall rruftlrtfc
AaAct SBKoSag Htfar 18 (bias and Offense*) and 42 (hft day end M&aa& Faesdaie) offtePmsyfabb Consolidated Stxs tats.fx&B(xovnSogferdeSaSfcsa; definiteAtdBaseofenbwftl access tohfams&ajisdiar&crpnNa&cfiraahadUmedciat* peter and for bases ofpcoagal janmfirtiou ou poaam otasSdc tbb OaroiBwedBu
Considered Ac seeondtine sad agreed lo, Ordered. To be printed na&t CalendarforthfedconsicIa>> aticur.
BILL OVER.2N ORDER
SB 56 (Pk Na 1618) (Amended) (Rerponsd) fCoBC*^
An Act *0*5aSngflic ms ofMyk'l51S fTT 11?" "r **1.11 n nr e the S^regs Tact and gpfll Pxventioo Ac. drfimne *eavnootng^tt roofa"; end providing for ctnam Dotiffcarfian niioj Gjor jtre rtfe*se*
thorn nane taste
SB 337 ff*. N*. ll9) (Amended) Otcrrportod& nga^l
An A*t amraffiflBlbcacurfAdjf^, I5fi9 (pJ_Jfl9,Ktx32lliBDn be die Scxage T*nk cml Sylfl fieviaalna Ari, Saber previfiogfor paj^neaefcexiainctwaBTOaihetlbdqBcqadStoneclktlBdeiiat* fc&o Fond; sod fir Uwtopoiod soia^p Task Bnwrwanripl Ctegrep VtbffMO.
HB 1633()^ Noe 3033) (Rertporwl)/Co*Ew*o?)
AsActzsnms&^TbeectcCJineZ, 1?**-|TT TTf? Tfn TT|. iiui
foe Wtafcajf CotnpensajonAi^ ferthtj-defioiog 'Viocopeifanalfis-
ease.*
_________ _
SPECIAL ORDER OTBUSINESS
sximjaEmvu^
SENA3E CONCURS IN BOOSE AMENDMENTS ASAMENDS*
SB^6 (Px No. 1637)-Tie Sewdeproceeded tococsii*afScat nffbe: InS, cntii&d?
BB1333 -- VRAow otgeoin^ 8w HBms passed over iq ceder at die rapes! cSM*ar FIOCQLA.
REPORTS &Z0M COMMITTEES
Senator THOMPSON; from das Ctmmifcfw. ao Approjaja* tkos, reported AefoSowOTgbll:
HB 1944 Qhz Na.3078)(Atnended) (Rcnjx*tcd)
,,-fc|- t
orfters5pal*pe>sonsfcosie
deSsqoas ni m paijcbeds er arc is Potmen ofeatds eodta^ Oanaet
crjepdaiiaB; exfiftiog pn**fcfa eo tmtioa s&d *cJ aSBo fat
s&s *e fist ebss; making fepol^ and pawifiaj far fiadi Sx
qxk&cd fitws aad fenat&s.
As Act amending TWe tS (CwpoottSot and Ifriititra) w4< ' i ' ~ir nir* P frr-''~-'~i v~'*i~lT,t*-----* i '1 "n i Pi nafl Tania CtrasoBdatai Strtsas, p*ovig ft* Kdtttiens on a&estOMOo
jBisdBdbiEiieandan^nceimnsnsasorQa&SDSdnee^ and Bite ..... . fin i i~>i ttttttt- rfiimliVii i riu< fTmtiln Trurfdi
Ctodieqt^stkicv
558 fbe Senate concur mihe axneadnciteindeirrffacHflmi as anjavied by <beSeoatt.ro Same BiR No.21fi?
SensorPJOOOLA. Ma*n PresidentItnoae tbatdie Soma
towBfatlKeBtoas!iiafiyfcB^Maior;ddly
tLe Senate, to Stoaec BUI No. 216, tM *? < !*** '-f
*
Ontbcipesdot, W3I the SaatE ogrw 10 the rootiao?
Saatcr BRIGBTE3LL, from the Committee ct> Rules and Bosenfiwe Nem&a&ins, xtjponed die fisOowiSf bfik:
SB 216 flffc No. 1617} (Amende^ (Renporred) (Cmoermw)
As Act asiaxKat `Tides 15 {Corpcranoos and Usfaearpomted AJBDC&fdonj)wd fhxfieiajyandJudicial Procedure}cf&e Pessjjy}TOTaCocaoJVgu^SooaieafjapvieV^SarH^rTtfMtanaTVicrrTK w Ia*cd fiaWfifie*relafiag certain ra^ea er taaeBdaSoBj; ajdiirier
The PRESIDING OfTiCHR. Tie Cftaoiecosabestbe pafl*.
man fiets Buds, Saxator TbenSnscD.
Samor^TCJiLINSCftL b^adsn 'Btes&at, m amendaeat dm was pur jatp Senate BH1No. 216 iadrCaum2BgeaplbAeT d
Bxectjlive HoamatJons is ax anmodaMtdot sfl! the a-
paay Crown Code & Seal, aa ndoiodaiol eanpaay wfi )tt world fcasAjosssns Joczied m PbSadelpisia, Jxm 5 ndnatts 6nm my dSsirict CrawB Ccsk & Seal 5s a company fad mates cam and bcOLes sail bolQe ceps. K las a t&OttKUd employees aj a
payroll cfabooli47mSEoi^pays kxal taxes sad StamtsneetC about S4 mUIhm, itfJdbesidmttotdoesaliomnInIBoBdonacf
2002 LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL-- SENATE 1331
worth cfbcsiness in tbs State ofPezmsylvaiua wi8i odJcrPcaa:yh&anmccKnpank3.So,fa fcnancal impaetenthusStaieEVtl^ vay nBpojont, and at d tone \Ao we tn losing mans and mete jobs end at a time wben we sre losing good, fmiDy-ncstaining jabs, and at a time wttes we art Jewing rsaJOTfiauring.job*, this oawpsnyis aitialfy anportasi to the fincacia! welfare of muoy fennBrt in ngr district
But sxoeOuog las hypoed to them, TJxy hart bero under
Scoatcr STACK. Madam Picadcnt, I abn rise in supportof Smalr EiB No, 236.1 rise today tSsctoS Icgislatxia Thai"wifi Jbave an imprntaitf fapaa oa Pcnnqdraaia public polky. S abenldbe a basic govexaiental ksaestto sake sure oar cacptw tsw ujoger laws do pat sutfiniXjr expose smoout compeniacto ndn $o)4fbecause of* merger. it is now evident tot as n esfiaemcn oortsequtpex ofmetg-
as that bappeoed ja tie past, Pem^Jrania cosparatietn'fart
siege by firigante and lawyers from Texas* and Mississippi, rod pevtr itxagyelvcs produced, sold, or jnt??iFW*? asbestos, prodootl
ibey are nowjEgripgto tbe tot ofabout JlfGjnflHnn a year fa maybecexis sid^tsto2slodco^cfattd&dSde3iSSn^dbr
Rrigjfinn zed claims fc> "people who have asbestos chins sgpins srotngH ofgssete Izzrty available to sadilj those asbeatowdSaad
Crown Oak & Sod.
HsfciKtks b^W become tmfiify nd tnjnstty etiksspdL TVcei
Notq the thing that srfeves zae 2bont fast i that Crown is an cnpnyedcrtad gvalandie cfasbestavretaxed ciaiaa cade
Calk & Sod do<ps net and new has
asbestos or used as in ihc United States today. What ls bees described tytbe IXS.
bestos in its products, ft <& bowever, fa 123 acqmrc a tonic Supreme Ctnsn as an eJtpbaniine ness flatdie coon has called ap company That bad an asbestos division, but wiiliii SO days oat feeJejisJaSve sefadens. fa Sew ofdds fasaadcalbr nspceew
sold trffthat division rodleBevtd itselfcflhai busines. Because dafled stance, itisox essential spvetmjeocal iofcrea andart*
of that sad as investment ofabort 56 suffiaa, iky now bn ter oTpobSc peBq'datffte amoart ofassets avulaUe to satfagr
paid a* afcust S300 m2&iB ia ebons fa Tees and l^osss^tpL asbesucHebted tfafas lc
fiifaed Id fae vafae ofactm of
What thatlas doneft tizs mnprvyh desreyedits bendraring. tbe pasta et companytot acfaalfa caocedtbe damaoe dttoo^
hs band taring is sow jadc-me basis, it is having difficchy *e piwtooicn, sale, re iostaftaSon ofasbestos.
barrewfag moocy, rod that bss fapaned on the company ya%
Wba dm aS be* doc m isre^ty a tew offitness. Hk
yaysevatfy.ltoAhkSa)iuttaja1h^tVKVytepnittelFtat- is fae goal offl kgfefa**, to dUeveactoe mexsme ofJMrneas syJvacs&johs aodsl'tms^vsiai eaopany agafast oateZSutc fir Ptsasylvania cospanfcs Hot Cnme Cnk Jt Seal. "Usm, I
Wriffunre wbaj they do not even hare asbesttafa. Kot on* cflhe believe many ofytm are famdisr wSh tbe problems tbit Cnmti
cbimans ltsS beca fcusi to be side c lave sbestods, and fiie Co* & Sed is faefag, but I want to provide * briefsmnmaqrfi
evapay doessat make asbestos. So^ wjtat wt have dccc hereif pot&ia fame aoopojpeerirt-
tried to Bmit tbe KiHlity ofthe crnapzny to the saoese that tt ' paid fcrfee adwdiayfbaiitbo^gttj ISO, and toisaboaSe
OownCoikA Sesl, soiidPenagdvaafacxBnpaEQrdisteBi-
pfay* 14>00 Pmssijdvaxifa readerts and enoirxbaes doae to S! b2^m<bcSsareeencaaJvfaterteifagaafaebciBlcorboBfe-
Msdam President. Jt does sat make any sense to me tol**t njpny.lt it falhispinfiismfcn^falo^part, baososeof
Hdj^fahfississ^'tdmdoeiKXlKeasberty- batbe ofasbestos-tdsied fawants the Baywy feces; buaicafat si* get as award of25 raUEcc from a company that did not ofdumsands oflswsuhs amumaing to lanidrah ofmgSaaa of
aiakc asbestos. Yet, 1 have * retired couple fa n^r (fenia who doQsis m sfakas. Qow* Cask JS Seal faces these bsmofat aod
wwkrd all their Hfe> raised a Stauix, fbeyhave nowroared, day tbk dbg facaiCTil s&Bttioo despite fao factfee etnpaayaowr have iSooe evoylSung right, they bzw: saved tbdr zeaocy, sod xsaatsfactoicd, sold, nr icst^Scd a nogfa asbcstavcontaisjqg
tnf ibty ate kfafcfag at being thempojwsa, and cmafaty iavrJodtcdat^sic^ivylxx^fittBBixBi^aByilittJlMy
prodact.ixit a saoglcsiestas product inda: coC3pajjr*> 1003ear A*i&- U--I^
ororkod ftr &cr Ixfb gp iracn S45 to J50 a done dos to
2be cs^Do of4ds problem begaa aeae 40 yeaK asp erfaea
abort SIJO a date.
. ft mate so tease to toe that I kryt people wfeo art 55 ^cats at age 'vakzqg fa Brmafaa. Pfataid^bfa, WlQccs^aat;-
Crovm Cock4b Scad^ a mimu&cBBa-batde caps aodbevoage and fiod comainen, was seekingto eapnd fa opcotSm As
p^afto eSart, kaojuiitdastodtfctcrcstinldnedeaCodc
CcnmeDsnBt^ wwiii* asd giving a lotaftfcdr Efc to flife eeo> Coa^Basy, a mawriacmrcr cfced>fioedbottfa odled <xvm
paayvrfto ate nowsot aw sregofeg to bawt ajdk svbeaa corks, that we first invented fa die ISOQa by Crown Cost fa.
55-ycar-old litigant fa Massdpfif gets a $25 anllice attazd. Seal^foadocAaaiBdividioncfMttsde^pafaapatyCtPM
Wbstwc are doing is tratis&iiingiimcy ftoma cocy^syfeat inrohrenjeat-wfai dm crunpsi^y, bed at qqc *i{ wmwwfiu'iii^f^
snakes battles sod cans to people ia Maassippi and Texas v&d cc& and asbestos fasaJssfan. Hewwe^ Aoee aAesms maajfao*
doaotjaweaAegOife. Yct,XlieitojicexsvAoBievrarifagSir taring Dperatfaas woe dun dovmbc&ce anyChTwa favoIvaHK
a companj' who zto \wsned tbrot thtjrjobs, 'vto ait wearied vrisbV&&dafasdrib&.Ndfatwk8<fisfasdrtfaadIvUirt
abedfadrlunro, vAo amvoefad about tJuarjefineqjents, and was sold offfiaac^bcrmi^aoywidriaSS days cfCrown's &at
fiio Kt wocried about tbdr pcnit*K.
sxotk. hoenst in Manrirt, end 2 ycars Irtirfae *w.uitwi<w at
So, Msdam Fn-adan; I aA dTCjdppeSetaeBiB No.226 Moodec was mergedfata Crens.
v& tiic BK3i4i>fint flat SenatorCacti pat 3bto i m the CaaSB&
Kow Crownb vety oefeteuee is flseeteoed, theresokefaa
tee as J&fcs *d EwccuriwtHoB&atwai, and I adc Car fee Meow avatercbe oflswstdts REeinsittio empeay ftra prodart k amr
bensC support ot &is isroa liePRESIDING QKEKiR. the Chair rcccgcacs tbc genfle-
xoas oss Hufadclpbfa, Senator Stadt
pniucedrtSoId.Teidty,v%bavea(faQcelQiestaipfikiKsifir
cotiqiaaies Ete CtownCcskA Sert.'Msbavefat&itaraeodamt Bfeirandetyfltabidsoifltioc. Onescriooof&e smer>dnynra.
its JiabiSty faberiied snkly because offtmmossrtar to fie mtrt
1232
LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL -- SENATE
DECEMBER 11,
value oflie assets ofthe inagpd company that was actually fa
the aabesto badness. Aroian independent recfiaa, the staeadmereplaces Ac aascteofa Ecreuylraub ccupprgiop flat exceed that tool value beyood Ae met ofcUhaants. Tl axucndn>at j-twwirv-rfw yTO-ntnPy a WtftdfeH to rbimonK, g vmwtim
that is destroying mooconl emporaticas apfl innocent woddpg
peopledjC&S. Tbe amendment to Title IS fat vvtD hemrne fey as part of
Sena BSE No. 256 Issubstantivelythe same.osfix amredroatt toscctm7104 ofTitled Senate BillNo. Big, with revroacj
Seoaor WAUGK, bfadam Preadea^ the kgutbdoo brfarc as
today, Secase BiB Na 216, i$ legis^adm dsat I soppott. I two
today to jest mate a ttegcnamu-ntefttthc record oolhe p
pos^ IrhM bbvjcaslybceobar fix qratesacQc-fime latheOco-
ad Assembly 2ndbtaaideniifiqL as nhcnwDqxeafcasbefiee bbo
so eloqttexalypointed cat, aadeCrgW Cede &. Seal lrgrthtitifc.
I -woold Hoe to,' first of jost sy farfiie jceerd, tadoe ao
aastake; this XegisbdioD does a&ct seme 150 to 200jots ii<r l^sfedve Estnctthat I represent. In Haoovex; fhae Ss a OtniB
Co* & Seal plant Bm I-wtwld 13* tojttstflpto *e>l4amba
to certain pcxaHteccojfbtm wifi) fee dcfmmots inTide 15.
briefly Hot tba Ss really more to this fegislatiao finaijust the
Now; 1 know assay ofniy coBeagnes are ccoceraed abort jdhs Ihai we lave heard abort. Before yon auie yonr dectrinq,
insuring that indK'xteis injured by **>esias rccefrejost compso- please consHorthe subject, and ihat soycetis ediestos Etxgatk*. sswjq, brn It shock! be those companies liar twere acfaslfy jj*. Under the histoiy aad fixture ofasbesto^Rdaied JSo^&ta In the
clvcd in the prodoction rad inxtaQaticc ofasbestos fat should
bear ibo cofit ofoanpenssiu^ fnvi&tofe exposed to adiestot and suficring health problems. Qowa Ctxk &. Seal ie not one of
United States, asbestos claims have been ge&jE a firneatlya
>i^nn> T>wKaitnf TWvc 1/
rMlT-- ---
Sled 4 year by a relatively stoaH tuanbor of"spcdaEBcd,'
iose congmics. Beyondfat 6a, there ere ijpicalJy Amos, If qooos, ttoqnots; hw firaa; It bs beat said Aat the asbestos atev*
not hundreds, ofcompanies tamed in asbestos lawsuit*. Do ot
s 69 tec calk* J5k <lsiaB n^ a jho^in ^ppreodt
ktjmyoncfD^ywiby*2yjagtlrefarepeopkw21:jc*bcccuh This method ofnaming rlrfmnts Isfiatibtyfcpwypoaagtfc
pcasafal 1 thUk t is dear fayw3L Me** importantly, fay w# mnottfaenHa ofssbesos products era pares* cnpcnaSoeAK
be compensated by fi* companies that actually bear some to* assy hEe bt*n the cause ofharm to ftdr cSoats. A&era co^a
sponaMmu I baVe also beanlsffsotMWS against the bai flat ssyii will
only apply to PeancylvsnH cjainoBSs. Thai is plain wrong. "Tbit
finds Babffity tribe cotcpniyfe realtoragreesto sesfe^telnw ndt, fije bvryca siaqily p> after ibe deepest pockets to safi^ fatjodgmrnr.
biQ will apply to il-Qf~Stz!r ctomanrs ax cut-ofiStaa Contis.
--ff-~j--iTtirmlnpiiiil^
Yes; in ibe ease cfCto* IX* ft Seal, Barns against Mmdei toafastos maonfiaOuthB end xnsbtaiQBi las tallybeen deft*,
will centime to be fifed Id oot-cf-Stxl* courts; and each out in*. Carpeadms named as defisncbabix tbc salts have boa#
wid ase Its omo Stot* HafaEty Jawto detranue the impact fa* falling into bralonpto^ tpitt fiankiy, 'Whes ecw offite !>%%*
bfaadefs productshid pp chJuiarrts. However, each Qrt-ofSrate USs, <bdr pockets are finallyempty, fa.asbestos mtnmeys fixaa
eooat win bsve to kob to Peox^baoSa ocaponto few to
flicireffiatts oolhe jtna biggest,andthenibenetO; aodfta**
none the extent which Ctown, as successor bymga, it so* imcl Right ce tmsfai isJnst the way the pnneipky^k
sponsible firMutxfert fidbifitjt Penosytanb pdbfirpcBey sbemM name Oat domestic cwpo-
xaticosl&s Clown Code it Sealfat engage fa a mager do not
asbestos Stfetriaa.StooeiP82>2<atitpalnnM;mfellewed
dared or been invoked ia fcmkrnpiry because of nt<
tos>idaled cbm)S.AnKngthose CatpornfionsfiMtlDMefidleB In
become the rfgedofonfib; mgnstiEable, and aapreccdoBa! jast fte past year done; Owens Gonao* bafetxadooa^ \K.E.
SabDily soldy as a icadtf'dte xoa^K Ti&fcsjsfctiaD also provides fraotcriaos iarwortfegfimiBes
rad rOgera. Sjprrificalfo fa fcgikferinn statesfiatfee yuri-aora
Grace Caoqn& BabcodeanA Wifea* Ceufmafr AnosfrWB
Wold Wnsteiesi and G-l Roidkgs. AH ffibeae coaptaarinoa bev scKJ^sf baufenyty ptatuAm bwsasat. ofKaHHrfet fioaa
then not yplyto tasarenec cranpaafe^
ebons fcr *sbesJossrttabilngpfodiKitarthqr striped os%
benefits, collective beigalafeg s^eoneqia, pr cbEgatiom arfefeg
ThofefXfe, WMgafim^nnOaAf^teMiBlwtwAeMWf
radar ibe National Labor Rebrfodf Act. These prorectiana, as are fifed radjjert;<!O^XasbescwHtcfetd cases aw fifedcadi
wet as a ^grdSoaSbomber ofDesKylvania job* tfajs bin wiB year. Even tncreaarffin& ISSAeosapotam banebeen damnjots
saw; ire vfy so natnr Wwrraxas are backing this fcgcstetkn. asbestos Btjgaricai sc fee. Even thoo^h asbestos be awteen --t
The brttaafitei** Association of Wadmnitj sad Aoojpoce face ftc mij-1970s, insurance experts believe ttat cldnw9l
WoTiECs, tfie Teamans, tod At Sca&ms foterazdoatl Utooo, cooficsietobefikdinlfi>eyear2aSa.^ftQi|fi)ttabSoradbQ
as well as eto local Peonsj^wana tndoos; areal! stpports^flas tos-rebaEd dsbns is expected xo b% $200 blSotxJn compencarioa
bilL 6 is not flaitlaa Pnnsyfratiab basnaas ctwamBrnyand and ptnoAia damage pajments. bfedatn ftreifa*,fia* is eq/aettr
labor aafcoc join together m si^poR of aa ssue swdt ss fliSs. letfto fte budget ofthe Cennnonwedlh ofFqmsyknniate 1
WhtJj flxy tlo, I fttrfrit k snpottaal to take notice.
fbSyean.
Todafc we haw the u^portBuil/ to unite a sigozScaor scat> meat fe.tenw ofPea^jrKaaa pAbc poEcy. By vofetg myes,m you oa esnveCta * loader Peeaqdvaai* eojnpaoy BsQtmi Code 4 Sed Istreated cqwtoHy; and fistjobs willbe protected
A recent snxdy cendocted by tbeRandCe^naonSs lis*alo fix CSvil Asoce preifctsfiistall ofdie rnnsHog asbestos reasO>
fatarexe wQ! be ArivcobcobaiifacqpiqfwWKaaaeaoecZyCOfa.
alone; The smify goes on topiedfcflijal when tfe; cconpamESAm.
for oa PennsyiYaaa dtt2ens and finaiKcs.
actaal^y caused fa bann sffl go undo; asbestos tokroeyt wBl Se
Thanks*, Madam TieoiesL
claims against a whtile ne Kst of'targets, fadndSng Q jcSning
The PRESIDING OFFICER, lie OxaSrnxognitesihe gniflo- bnsinessas, xdaSeis, emranobBe tsaru&aoRZs tod dkttftaret
mza irott Ycd:; Scaator WinJet.
ofatttorooMfcs; textileganufectmec, and ocher bhrtftCTtrs.busi-
/2001
LEGISLATIVE JOURNAL--SENATE
1233
m gooses that had Bttlc of Bbgctoejyno rribnionfirip to ssbcstoa
prodntas or asbestos iuSnsttks, K, y I *sk the MawbetS'Cfthis bo<^io]o<^to'tfCT<nwr^cinal
dlsnrcfc, Think eboa it Consider vdxtherym have a company, a nuunrf&cfans; a retailer, & reSaay Aat could be named as a defendant m aa asbestvc-ichtstl chko sometime in fie near fi*.
Tore. According so *e Jtsoi Ctuporatjaa sad^ eiay Sexme Mcoba Ekdy does, and h Sag asso, as 3 poh*c out ezrRs; thesr arc mart than 250 employees ofibe Crow Cent & Sea] Cawpsag ia Ybik County. J am deeply coocemed about those Vrajkers, sad I an concerned abed fit futow for their feaaQcs. I have received a number efTeffierp, pbanr calls, and feces freon them tw the hat severe!-weeks. j would 251* to you one
cample. This one constituent wrote to mewib J& perspective;
Senator RBOaDES. Madam President wHl das wBcadnaot pfffrt Emfaracosj5cosfc or any blwdc long claims?
Senator TOMLINSON. Madam Ffcddant. no, it vrill nOL I*
6a, as Santor %ngb and Senator Sad: have szted, it will not affert tbnse even wife asbcstcgfc cfete, so & will pm affect
black loot. g>ptd.7r TfHOADSS.Madam Presaifegt, fc effectsno puscctt.
no fiorare bbtk tang cla&niT Sesmar TOMUNSON. Nos Msdajn Pircoidenl. Santor JCftCADES. Madam President andit fc not intended
to IfontagtfaracosiBppfias cr black tang cbrtiwi? Sanstet ^OMUSSCSfl. Madam Raideat, dot is tn*^ jtisnot
intended toBrit tfat Sajsaar RHOADES. HiEakjae,MadamPtcsideot.
Hk swtinrajis were echoed tine Bad fane againTn &c messages I neervuL Here what he wrae qaece, "the company Iwoefc
POINT OF ORDER.
fiarwas ao Aowwog place at the wrong tne. They air getting hanjrocrcd 40 years *& 6e wrajxwtry ownership ofa csbct-
xa-jXDdnc)Bg company, even finagli theynever w produced nslirsicrg tu^xarw vw; are berat pghi^ torhet^yfr-nffm-T^ia) ritmfryfaweriTt-;," tm^xrm They Wr frroiKr-c; hmv-t, frop<- fiy
TinPKESHONG eanCER.The ChairmtipMaat the pea^ g^C^raaaddptoi. Senator S&tfc.
Senator STACK. MadamPnstdax, Ime load: 6e ChairJbr
a mEts nodet Senate Rtde XXI. soawt2. As pawnera a tmr
die figure dmmy welltidean fee passage ofttfe bill. Make ao zdst&t, MatfemfltcadeB;J stjipcrtSenatefijHlfe,
236for feejobs, the consomeiH that! havejest alluded n, hat any fcggTntioa, in saybook at least, flat -wepass hoc realty baa tohe fenfiameDtaHy 66; nodfeat **smentioned wrSertySem-
tvSbA SttnBilN(i.2ItiBfikIdoiib(ibitftatisMyoBt
who wouMstmd op fins Senase floor today and pJe fiat per`V sets afflicted wife adbesoafa oramafignani cancerofiome type
theory. There is w> ooe in this Sesne who woaii say compare*.
tkm b not dneif)^ havethattypeofaninjwy.Ciraintyf!Jxy should restive con^etsaiiaa. Tley have beaj foame^ They should be allowed go after fee cotnpante tat mamfijcared and installed asbestos prodaca atdhepeoaiitcd to extneta fib; a 6ft- amaafl pfomniKTMifiru rfte barm dray- tn
fitm ttatttptesents Cnwm Cotk&Seal, Is 2 qprapdtfe finme to voce tmflamerdbcddlietnaemysdf?
TTbe PRESIDING OEFK39EL Die Samar 1ms requested a w&jg firm the Chairasto vSw&erbe fetcqmred to tune as tfce motion. He iSies bis maribosSap io a 3t*r &m fim Ss involved fc fie matt*. Tie rales regime that a Member it voting brare a tineapraeanayInterest m the ooa.uuie. ofthe nattierbeforedm
~V/c fedfiiarte xnanooe^Senaicr StwkteatBC3sJ*r<tf e ctassandtos>atbest,iranyintenc^anind5ictpecnmKyiotnxsi; and ills fee niajgoflbeCbalrthai you ate napatd to vote oofeamoticat.
Staalar STACK. Tbackyoo, Madan PreddaOt,
AndAc qaegioftiaBmm. Wia fine Senate apee to fee roatioctf
Madam Presidem; das is eacfiywfctfft* legates be&te
is tody does, ft does seftftgto stop a petsca suflfcring Sen m
astJcsaoic^datedii^vyfitaogpntJtSerlbeaees'aibiaese^peBsMo ice caas>he bum. Tiot kg&btacu t rm=x*xe AH
the IjgoffrptqitSricr possible ddanflagte fa these hwarfanriy iicintesthe cues dot hee actaaUy dbo* bam. TbdsyQatlistof rktftJufciaiacludesiccrmiaoytfaB fcbeadipafV.M^p.^^
vaed*, 4i aoplcyees ayaeaBodaJ c&stdetltBacotzfBZ^
datsem^ eMBuoiaificRiredtrassdfedmadestos prodactfe aI3^yr^ffefpertkeLTod*ytfkCKiCQ*&S*aL]f tbgRa^CtgpotzfibnsoidyiSXObeldfcinE^nti^yf.JHo.Jfe-
taat &bare dis hit list ofxamed^efeodatUt sod asbesloc-fdaJed dsiins w0 possiblyjndode a ectnpacryin fiit soatoltal district
4at yeatrjaesczB, wsh eo^lqjwB flatjto sene as consdraeas;
HmyeasandtaystnereitapuredHySeoatorJlCOOLAoBfi maeasfidloK;tc
YEA-44
AaMI Bom* Boasoti si^fcta
CoaO
rmi
Con Dw tfaffW Tm* OcAtA
Geolat am fC^pTfc AOQRV Kmafc Ota bloortA LtYtSe
tra.imnad UD WaJlPD
%Mrc.n-o--vUMgr
M* otate nteoh bat Hw*7 JbMks Scmml Sfimm
SKk SMC Ttotapstm.
Khps ramfc ifcecf
BU^Marylb 'nabovAsttuarB. TCnaAfc
Jia^^pypatofaBlesd^dfetMBi^
Madam Fitsitea; forftetaae. The 21Rt>2i>lj70 <^-nCE3L Tbc Chair mqwri^x <*~ntb^
9
man feota SdrayJWH Senacr Ritowtes. Seaatnr RHOADES. Madam President.
5H
Senator)
Tcralagoflsafaafc to mtarcgafoL SenatorTOMUNSOM. Yes, Madam Presjdcni.
SHo4nPI0K
VMM One ThtfCne WSBtoe, Cotsmee
A CHtftirimoiial stiooriy.of all fie Senators having voted 1^|^" fixj^esticii wasdcierzaincd aitheaffinnagre.
Ordered, Thrfflbc Seouary cf^fie Senas* sx&ktd the Boot* of
Kcpreseasativcs acczadio^tp.