Document 2RXBxJjDo04x0LNrLbG09eEqb

FILE NAME: RT Vanderbilt (RTV) DATE: 1971 Aug 3 DOC#: RTV149 DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION: FDA Asbestos & Talc Discussion Session Minutes f * DiVlSXOM 0 ? COLORS AtW-COSiKTlCS tfKCHUOLOGY' rooD'Aiii)-iiitif;; /.'i'iiST,VtTio:i WASHINGTON, D.C, -^ SftESTOS, AW YAT.C - Diacufiion Section, -Avgust 3, 1971, Hoot .1409, 200 c 'Street, S,'V, Moderator; dr, Alfred Valsnlcv .n ire v s s f o n Tot> XV A sbestos and Talc'Jfin'arhX D e p o s its - Cr. H n tc o la Rosa . ti. <,i I - Survey 2, F ibro u s C ontent o f Cc<tt:ctic Telc<ini P ro d u c ts - Dr, L, J , O ra llc y 3 , ^ B iological-M ed icalPlp.nJ,ficpiw <>? :rrti Other Fibers - hr, 7, J, irolikrff, Me, Siiini School t.f Medicine , ' ; / Pr, tv v.iJriieVSMt'h;- Onhnron f<. ,ioh.v/>: , . D j, f ) 1ii 111. 1 _11iii * r. i' *- i y e 1 4 , C u rren t FDA I n t e r e s t s in .Ashes'tofl - Dr, R,. K, B iiv s ila i, .Bureau o f Drop,a Dr. J. K, 3 Bu iOmi of. Pr'ur,/; - hr, 13, Y. Yruyblllf Bureau of Foods 5 , Coniiuiner I n t e r e s t in A sb esto s <* M o rris K splair 1 concuratra Union . . '! r ' . y _' ; v -V -y - f 6, c o e ^ o tic s. Industry In te r e st i.n Achcr-tos - Bi\yWon.*ttn l's tr in I. . . C: 7 A n a ly tic a l Method f o r A sb esto s - W illi cm E ire n b e rg , FDA JV. f>. ' i . i ' i 'lf J^un'i li;.:wiU.C * . * / . ,, 8, ):, i,!ot>nC i;i.o r,r.J r,y W hitt nicer,C lriv!;. &-Par i,o. U r, />, M. _f Mi:. hr, Y',\.\s, F i l t e r U Company ` V. ; , t: j;1, ^ J' C'i;-' C'rt h J im; - ', - 5 . .IHWHAWWM i'V A ?.Y>?(:;il'M . Aucune 3| O'/ sircaras /.iw ,<7-:.c Hold oc th o food a1lu ln'u* Adi Ini i.t'r a tio n ioo "c" 'u'vv.t'., : .m \Ui(Aitfi& *u, 1;.C. `UVA T-fdorriov: 55r. Al fra;) M d .ir.tv. )>!:: vor D ivioi.on o Colevi/' Coo?>**fK*; '/e <../1 %.*y IUl'v'i'V Vho m o n n e o f ojScnfOfl; f tb oro 5.\ f n i cusa pna.b-r >m c : u, > rf: i.bsi/. . h e a lth hasarda a sso c ia te d w ith cheli* pyooonco, ovo oubjocto o c u rra n t .'i n te r e s t hue d i f f e r i n g rep o rt:c , A t ft r A T '> :i i \ i u b o /,: .on 'A M;y.'.>U T o t tV .O I ' d i.' i .n .l i Ad.*.:! ` l u t v: !. i v m o-/ by-f/voy A r c ^ v ttto to , p h y a iH rira s:o;.i''r-'V, i f ganar.*.* 1y o ; . : t > t h a t t;o:;. in ic u o pevCrws'r.f. r.:.jo r kiv.iv,cCu,,v *j ra L a in liv e ly >.es />;' /U*U*'l . _ 1 ncverthC').coi ou b e h a lf o f con\n?oiro, H> io w orking on -tbci d o m ilo o o la b o ra to r y p r o e c . J u ' c h e ni'v' >*.;io di' f .; lo f . J /.. vs<v..h;:v i,,,; v: w i l l . p iv a conili?! e u / r : ih iio g ftl. w:;v5/:i,, , A ccu rate annJyofl Sor th e amount o f er. beo ton in tnlciss. powder w i l l bo obi i.to :b leV .i'.ccdVifinj', ^cii-my^uC. tl:O jt iri'ic l\;ri;ih , .`ty t ftruu^h' tl.-u i i r . >1. h b a tte ry o f opeciaJ ite ti ii'iutniuiriitii r.d.-'tocbaiqueo, itic iu jin g sr-rr.y tUffri'c*' t i on ; poi. '.ri.i'i.rjT o p ticeli .Kici'OtRopy,' el c e tra j.tf'v e rn o p y ,. r d e le ; i reu I. i.;./. X. .I-'I;/ .... 1 f t'X II pVI. 11.0 * n r.ddicion co cntenaf.ve dis.cu.'rcin: o f th e a n a l y tic a l' r.ictlio-.la e*v acbm t by vr i;f ti 1 V. : vi. iv i . >;* . i.t.;- ";.,,h " ' tiftdicf.l: a i g o lf W.iictv- of- r,.-.bi:ftte mul ot;-; `.-lib/sy., .rnd ' 1 r. pif..vvilu:.r. - avien to :: ( >.' i ..ic ove t o.. //; '-_-V -a-_- i:>r/T,oi>ucr);o:} h i . Mei e,fi) o r o;ono<] th e noctiug, by o u tlln i } : cono o f th e iw cnta which hod brou};'/ . ip ieotion o f r.r.heoCn/'J p a r t i e l en in tu ie to elio n tt e iu i o n o f )J5A, H P.indies led thiit 'in r r oponeo to n J o tte r fro;,v Jero v a Jfotohsac.f (/.dsft/M crtoih ' l v i r r ot c c t i oo A^ntxey, Kow York C ity) to H!': fcciv'tary Ro.hni:<hoa,.'. on Joro ?tt, ' 1971. th e THA won tr.'w'vif, fitcpn to invonCiRoto'/tfic;'problem- o f ...be;.- too particl.c a in tr.)c. ; -; ' CRMC-HT-TAr.C-000143 fyj;i; of f> T.lu* H)A i;ti*1 Jilt* fio erKj.M loit /, I >[wrr.wrjr pvcee/furtt f r U * if H e * c v i ' l n t ' . ) ^ n e T r r ' K o r o o J n fc-' . l e u yo' :Crr,r ,tUt,' v i l i f/v e mcf'htf.Ci.il oVl rent*,or.out teryU f Once, lto iwfipdoJoay io. n?,roed Mjif'f Vl?,V vw M bp 1p o jyr ir;? oj to dctinwJLno :l auch >n'thtCo on tbo tmxtot ruitn/.. fiber tco fiSovVi,' Aio f i'Vt-'v; of! t h r. i />/*(frf, ed f tbi-vf p v c W - 'o t f oi'C'Vy crol, poffic.**- }r>t f r U ! > y !fv.f .!;.!f'.) ' I r r w f r'.'iih * nc`O.1 cfi .v'?*,-:< r r , A 1/ rtf. t\ r i * ' ; <' p.f'tr'<: </ fit;!:;' h o il. . . . - r;v.f UVil, njsCUSKtf 1. }>r. '*;yo ofc tfio-'U .t '?0<>W,ieM Soxvey wein eut; i i r . i t >jw.kY',;<U.v*. !>;, -ft f.n'M.X'io'jioV, oye.1ir*cd ih e vcvlovy f;0';v in tie r a iei' e;boPiv,i.'. v.ifcfi'jrr-J. or/cAvi* vielt .^1>;* T ' Ui3 proo'.oit.'.-.U Pt /.svi V.t .y,in form i',vi V .rh nonM fcbo 'fnXlcvi*'g nei.f.cut p u i^tf- <?rw*T,**slf a. ]. :iX:'.;i A r ; !>c-;:ou \:j a (;;novlc :or. ; io:; a vr.v.lr.ey c f hydVetod n im ic a te ninovnl./: vii ich have ovo corctrm rctv/lnefrc, jFf f.M'. ' t v f:o I'O.'c "; .'i ;V;i:A J. ; i r r o**. ( "' - f l , AIi.boi,1:.'i' i w e fr* o t'd in o rily ocoocioftcd v;f ?.b thonc v/ticlotieo vAifch hovo tecutyiop.f. ft oovr.i/.Ko, f f in r y p li - it'j i * t f r>?I Juvv'! o .-. /.i'.; e.-K.' f,?;vo tio; c, ')>'. yi.. '. V.'iO t<-5 *i * Ott'* PV-t M/.oPVoli-.-' i<%'pxhn>> w s t d eo crip tiv o -(A) l`.' Vt'O 1-'*',.Yi vrv*"'( i/'o c f /sebe*'ft r.'t*",.' i vo"r1r een. b-e A'*vi.t*rd <n?;o '(*.vo r e in e i c c t ' f . h a brafn e?- r.ho/v fttyoto) of.'.'accuvc.n; y*. o^iKCiVir';' /.i'd t.V'h.jOc;:. Tot* N-"); o f ti Kt ' clono io c-itfrysotile oobeotoo, vh ich i by fo r th soot coarctors o f ;U'3'r-?)V;ii.`V*:.3 t.vcirio, Xc. cc.cur!.; r; v.ovo ?;,h:.n v i tV,;r (tnltootoo filvsy p'votVtc*id todey. \ ;.V: . f, > ,'*> / i / I- ' 'fi t-l t ' P'if*?' j. . f,. 'iy .' \ . u j v.u; i f , !>'. i..'.. : t >; ;' - /iifchcttf> tito '.fitapniboloo. r e coriuon ro ck o tilin g ;Ltto'iitlo^ tnc! ' '- rfl'c.ctio^om V trie tic c a r e t;ych l ?o abundant 'titn-'.c h fy & c tll (1)* c./.Th em pirica), f o r^ ju v ); t-c repveopMtcd- cu i l 3c>'.;o: i'ul ' . o f;>ivi ; ; /, ;'k .-.u'!- !; < r.}'v ( Serpentine eleo . ' ; ClU -ynotile, tf3 5 (OH)A ( i ) Speli., s . od /iit!/;vclter> J . P . , K n v iv o n to n en l.P.oeootch & .IG67:Q$O M 9 ) CRMC-HT-TALC-I000144 Ar,j)Jif.bolo-Cl>fl Autlit,*l;U|.t'0 <!1,|, Vi) y !'>1y : riu lca 'Ciijj '>5 S tj (d )y A c tln o U to C'ijj (;' 5*0)5 S iy <j.-.j, <ti>2 d. r t o uet 'u',!f'.u.;l to f l v 'l' In.1.;',,1. v<.i:i <.>.),>..ir .:s 'd ?-y.*, i d t*>j o f n ;\,'.tv.r:*.\ \;J t.tsfrt r, ^ ;],vJ y ;'] y f e d !. {,:::\> .j1: n ...ve fb:,.vd <` ' 'd o ti Clk'riioor d<.ycn..l fco a ;v*:ni; cuumU; o;j Cha v-.lr.fc'i'ii'.ofiy " . . involvfid. . ' -.. ' \i: ?, r>>\ Jhv.J^.Usi.V.. /. i . r ' f t , . .o d ..n d . "... . ,* Hinlch c polco on thc 'J.bxoua contcnt o 'costcnelc tttlcum p w i u c t e . Mi pvevpMw.ti.ovt, nix red -ir ph;:c nn- n pnpcv i).; m s i A I'v 'O.i e o li i:W<l '`Vi.bxous .tiii il),uc>f;4 CmitiU. </ iniuiuticv U icu ia i' twauccu/' ' dtfjfH-^V Kvfj/'ue. A/xoni_eMon Vnirn^l , 5V, SO d (JOfl), Y)' fo.ovn?, concj.ooa v;are nodo i ch is pepcr; " ttith Clic c ccp tio n c 4 o f Che 22 co tm etic tnluir ' ' : i- 1 *c i',*ni 0dy (.;*> U v e lo o? jiar-o n l c a , . n ickel., 'chre.iluni, -and rmnc.'Vttcno-tiuvA ponnrp.ll > o 0 i ov u>'.<:nj,i.ul<: av.ci virJ.n a murcar v;.>ir;0. Ifc J.n v,cz .vc:!jok !.': lowc p*.uiit'cLJ j,*.- yo'.* ;*uc r^' i * .A-- cent tiwrt o (ui-`j i n d i o n d w u r y o r to wbac .citecnt fclio r-otnxco of, vre t e l e l a t'heoij fe/* ot.;** In t.w e ero Che V;".v.p 43 r.enteca '< : t.;1.e f.n :e. f'-.A 0r u.' -y in otl.'..` calcn producto u thc etenpecitivo im 'Uet !ie l v e le o f t i l i c o , c!v;o..utj> nnl n clxl ' iti theou dui producto aro o u f i c i c n t l y hj-Ji, hoiever,- Lo Ve b conenrn u fci.citf i o i u i i i r .1 tu lcvlc dir.o&so, y 1 A l of. f i n 22 te le n a nrcriku'.tn r>o yero;!. heve '.rs r.-'p;.*.-.- < ^ ? l . i 1 - -o.; 1 .i', \ C t u . t u y i-v. / o f; i:ha t c u i l tplcuin p rtlc ii) ntcri. ' /.r,d ?iv.0i.'0'yin;j 19/i. , O.neyibi:,0io i;ir,Lci*ftl \:o.c* j>rc*!o;_a1n.-uitly t e l e but pro- . j bf.bly conCnJ.iivc!-rilno?; r.noivnfca o tira ii.to /-.iatitxophy> K t o y n^d ch t^ A o tilc rr ul.c.r.o cv nft'-n nrw f!7.t:-n.' '.' . >,:.i.' >; '. ; ` V,. I * ..i, f >.' C;i ci-i.<a'C*C-'1C-0 . . . y ; ntfnii..t vn lu c uc./d y: \ v! '.. .b '? v ;,, f -cru' ^ y 'nhinh t:`,y be d o r jv :A 1'r.4v>1y;ii'oi'r. ...i. ? v...;c .-.. y .'y tilo la;, o it*.c'fii'ti'. 4 n:: t iuihA i t h c :ptcci-iico o / thooc cvru^lnbut;y bodieo, houesve-r, ic Mneottetirt,^ Z ..`0 tUlx-fl fHocuoolon copie on tn'-prQCi'oiw d c a lt w ith tlio b io lo g c n l ond ciciUcfli oif;ncpncc c* rebeotoo ond ochcr fU o r n . Thrcc opcAkoro nddfonocthcv.ncivco to t'hio Copie. r . ViV, J'f''.:) Tr ' !! i \>*S Pebr 'V c i u.': .v- J . t - .*- r>7. -'.y,i' - 5./-. * CRMC-HT-TALC-000145 afri 4 ' > . pfoblotu ptVfiCuiLotl. lo ibo p ii'W'ol (->; ti)u l'io.j '/U h lo iii'bc/jro.T, I t o'coi*ti*fw* ne ii. i'it.ti- t< ho winJ.y oc-c;>*tonnJ. -probi eu'. )h> repoi;!'.'! t:h/:t i% r o d y moyil'jv.J V.noyXcdyo lift; r.veiitl.y \k m m c < Ititi cpocCi*! o r et* .tb c v h o lo ' qinwjtipn Of r/.hc;i con i i b ero in tho cn>v} ionw.cnt, Vo i r l e thf t <:)io vcm i i r w . l u o /iiiitfil co triti? p ra H .'ii \tc*t t !; t (</.>f ~ b llifc y th/t ).np cen e er u v / K i.u lr uve li;.,.. <!; looo tlirn o;v,ii(';!i in a l e r c i o , b . Ut1. lil.i-Uck' SH'Ith, liirc c i'.o r n-C).i\1c>:.l Y. -n^r.xcU f-n* '.Thnru-a end JolindOa ( J f 7 ) , o u t lin ci! b r i o f i y Che r.c d ie o l aopoct o . t e l e p ro d u c tio n Aijd eoa Ile r pori: ed th n t J J Inno ben in th o t a l e hoc. filtro* f* v nv*t*. 70 y o n ro . Tr la , ."'l.vf: *.i >h n- *. b o a t vi: o tlio r rtyL erlolo can i>iv r id o t r. b in i c i l e n i re.niicn"o ; Ji;,7 li.".-) noe. note.! ny nve reo o if o c c t fi;o,n vbe or,a. o r t a l e />. c i ti or c ty lo /e a r re eri in Ut. icorfifcuvo. T ele p n m ifaete rcd ;'l>y 0W 1 hip.hly re fin ti! lo produce n " p e iy t r .l c ," AvivilaMo <!cea ita lic e c c s .thttC cl'icro te. no h o u lin heanrd'fdcificiflced triti clic uno. o f co s fttic p.riHls t e l e , l e v /n i *)o pr-i.i)tc-!i. i-i.it:' t/in t ent e ' i a t i ofbcon tu r a le t.i'/y due:; noe .>1: c n tly canct iwn.ofcliolier.3. e . ]);r. Ci'oar.'oZ .d o IhAiup.l Uni vi*v aie >' u t Si.pj:;, iiiU 'oiiiia r e p e r ed fchfi tlu 'i'c in 'vcvy l i e t i e i l cny d a te on th offc-ctii oj: t a l e in ri ox mi ir.:,i l . In t r a tr a c b en i i n j o c ti n o f t a l e in hocr.torj? counc r>o i l i c i frr.tr... Vn tifin o ei m> hiiVjp r:.eci-h y y -:u ' ticon.. Asber.Con p r .r tic lc n J.o./S i.hr.n 5 ulttu*,.: irv le a r d i rep ertr, U> no',: crn.,;;;: e'. *0. li./..': p o '/n t, howeves?, bar; n o e-te un e fin ito iy ponitrm od.. A. l)r. ' K rr.ybi.li o f VOA'v Jh.irreu o Foorto re p o rte d i.hel; .'i - , - of r.flfcni oo ir. feed rm.i th e 'e!Vlwr..-.nr.t hr.'.', tl.fi <. C' j ' - r. <1 il.''.'' .` ..li r o' i'Cf ii. v::j nj-CiO.. /u i. r r.^.lou . iiuccnL ev en to , however, may. re q u i rp ."that tb a .-p ro b i eia be ree tu o i ed. J ) r . P a r s i.la i g> th e lsurenu. o Urne/' r e p o rte d th a t f i r r t l c u l r t n - !:' produci ;;l.wf.:! -tv--/:,.'), nv t:.f ,i: no v...y i.-t-r. '.;tc.< in f ).e :-,y, ' ' / f 1' f u r ./y t/c n l r-nthodolosy v h lc h enn be uned f o r tint it.u. i d r !. J A'.'.. C < 5 M orric lieplnn o f Cond*;.;'t Union iiuiicfitcc. tim e d nlvuyn r r e u ed !;> Vcoh/p'; r.t prv'*.*r.i-j of'-er. :!:ey .ucur i...i hor ti'.-.; ?.fpr.: iny tli'.ri. l.ii Iioprd il c.;U>tini know) ed (jo^ cdi Che d u b jc e t o f on he 3too, arid t a l e v;ould ho rc::c ,,;d in th e i n t e r n e t b tb c .coni:uiier r a t h e r "th a n i n th e in te ro ti t of the producer. ft ;'f CRMC-HT-TALC-000146 ' f , br. Kutv. "o* the OcoioCic, VolUtvy 'n't \r,i.u,nr </.-,> ^luwittn u th rtt- fclie fitty o c ln k im \uw vcfiy to jo i n n i i b 1'dA etti .o />v<.(Ser4c c.ijiiicy to (totoritiso i t thcuru lo <i cpnouti'ir. o a fc ty p ro b lc n w ith t o j o , /.u i.v.'Wdi. /A". r:iv,'> v.nrf-/ h o nTtfityio'c) hcu tjo w \:.\$ d ev o ad to o di'.et.c.Jiv <> acX) ti./! i/meln-h'i tuoi, conici b ufieel. i'o r 'th e Idi. lic itic i! cion on'.! c?/;r,/*.*,:! <>i: ted in lu id . S is p rco eiitr.tio n n v e r e Riven o u c lin ln y mc-cIiiao nuod l u vai leniti lidio r o t ut i .od . 1-* )fr JT!;dn!'rti r, o-r f.1,c JKvfi*<vi o? Mii'vr-M.olo'r/ tep ei'ccd m fv. ,; ; ! wiMK, iiili i;i il*, uso liso i>u,ut,v;.i .;lxCOvO(s i w tt--d cieclo n m colfcstoo.*!? ii h'I o Xn t n l c , 2; Dr pctil of, JohiKi h 'n n v iilo -icoociovcli CoftCnv 7.*/-1 > : v .h t fye..n<M,f<.; /\ And c l.ty '.o tiic coni be .<iytoi,'i.,ir.<J vi c a ie r e o io v.vi c> about / O.X y voy di. i ' i7.ci>.r. ) n . .'-pe? '.-.l.e, ic.tjtvci;, l!:/.; i!... ' f.ipor!.r*nt qucccor. to be cucirete d io;- lien much.(et i n t o tb e Inno off vot' *ro mI-.c ir- esposod? Me t.kxr,:r>cc th e t n i.wr.:! , bo n o t p t e df;t<:)Yiiifto io r e n i expoourc v/'.lucci. 3 . J'r . */., '?!.!/; r. <?-i-.t.Jlv.;i fov UuAii .'.V. r .CJ.-.r!: r.rf. t o r i r.Jn x - y - n - / , (iic-.: pr-i.*.ir.- von'id t-n en c fe c n in f, c - v r mc of vop..(iy rtf'v'iniij; i.iiid i /.pica o t r i e c o n ta in {Watca ' 'n i.n e r ie . U e-ir-.lbete;ri t h n t choro e re t r i e n on the. werkefc ubi e itbjiOfljr-to lio o>jeoi:10\vi:>.'.. 4 . Di*. Lengen,' end D r, Maggioro o Mount S irm ! re p o rte d th u t th e y uto H io - o llr ;'r ," tec-bulriic'! to d rice!: nV.h; rieto'.v.in r'ib o r(:.o fcmv ri "v :w c.I r ; l i f ' i t 'p .c? -?ciV>V x-tfny poirdcf ' i C V actio t;,1o )Acereti r.ici-orc.upyy c loefc rep i w it a.u o. c e t i on u r li: m e lo n . r/u tiii y tb e ciociiseiosi t h a t o llo rid Dr. J.nn?.cv*- p rc a n te tio he vea. eske-d ho bed -',V , i r ; V/^-A '. -V . ' > . lie v.td th a t !k: h rn ;<n vhr.t, .fc ivia r. high- tjo.n'iJ.ty c e le , lie Added..- t h a t nil-- th e co le pr&dueerV roprcoenteel n t th e R e s tin g .'pro duced i a high q u a lity 'tele; produce. 5. De. lltmrcod n t Cir.vtcd 'Hizo.: r;v. ..-;.:pr. vv g u sd ,'tbc.c y .i: I f i fr,t v >' r * ' i; h Wr .: ' i . : ' !M i*t S fc p fC frfV M . ' lO f^ h ty ffc n ( !'. .tOcWf.t've y.' rnnlrt pfMh.'.hi y . .Z ('<;,,i (;o 0.1'/, v>: i . l i i : t ' l 1/" lu 1.r. c . 0 Jinahed o f ,,Tolmoon nnd Job no on in tro d u c e d D f. h o llo vho rauo > fiv o iir.b le n ta b le v h lch o u tlin e d "Icthodn o A nalynin o f i?iboro . in T n lc /' (Copy nttftcU ed). D r ,.H ollo foccfwc-udcd th a t o p tie n i . M icroscopy h r need: r,c n f '.v z t M o p ifiA d ctrctlii;; fibci';) in ciilc. / 1C v ery fen o r no fibo.fo e r e n'.ecn,- e l e c ti o n n icro n eo p y with e l e c tv m d j f f r r e v i o n fd'oitl/i/br Meed. Iff r.imy f'ibev.i eve ceor. x - r n y d l / t r r r .t i r .n chould be ur.ed. CRM C-H T-ri.G0()0M7 7 . In cloinf; thft mcCin Di*. V I n a ia r Lhittkn' lJiv- l'/vi/iei|M tii r.,cS ("M-rliitul. eh'? r * v t dein 'i v lt'.c'h tr/./'!i I r vnr.fi ce <f i^%\-}a .i th oC nnbi'.'v'i! In t e l e . P e t t i l / d pi.or-mi' .a h i m e l > i m i ' v i l i -I C(6nt to HiA by oko t>f ih o j-nrl I n lp c n u - nr. tbft m & U M t, nrtd. tbcito v i l i bo c-j?.tf*Ioui,s<el by TRA ?nul c iv c u e tv d io n OV/.eutu, Mti^ f/ 7 ( y ./o.'.; /i Ut; A kt'.tli o A .. / ,i / >/ O -- CC.Vu. ?. ).Cf 111' J>/v ie ion t : C rdrrr h, x.iy.ti c Ve; (i. i <>4 TiiC fo i lo v in g people a tte n d e d th e eyrrpoalum he./; 0 - C c 1 1' y, L'h.K. '. >:. f/.wl- Ir. :v / 'Tifn i*r Or ..fl Pf'feCy end K'/iith, Cincinnecl , Gno S w in g J , SeiUHoXx, ).)>. . A rthur. 11. > J'h -V>. v o li c i" j . Ho;;oVi:'r.i,;r-y-,n. ' C. J . Kczt.or.c, .'h .Jj. lini colta Ruco, Jhil). VUr.on lrr.ticU, VI*-1>. 0`ru' h V;i3 c!'- r.i i t h , .jj. R, y . -'U rtile, Ph.r* ` V. H. RltoU cy, Ph.D. A. Giui-ji-Oj i'u)). . , Prof, r. Yi. Pook;y. . ( 1 \'.fut) W. V. Craic-ftjr (Cci-.ir-uUcUt; le u 11. S e ro rre , Th.V. (Coivu'H G< li. Glielo!.*, Fe.I. ( Connu Icrv.U:) *. V, ' i /V. iJ. ; v , t l'h.D. CoaraT. J/7ro ld Rmer ; ** : ... i ".../.i.. -f .T/., P ro f. S ,Z . Kcnln (ConpuifcnC) l'an],. Gr'-nft, ll./l. Sidney S p e li, Ph.r-- Movrl.fr lormen K a trin , Vit.11# JKiXTf.y Kct'vHcU, Ph.Ji fc.. aut School cui KotUc.iw U M 11 U i*# ).o',I,cX iuxvvy Aohvc.ou & chn'jou H II *1 t* tr h w w . C V i ?:>er ii I ' ! . . i#VrCr IVopt* o A iv i;$ou:cn. Vlhictuhor, C irri; 6 lnoicn it 1 ilvcVcni U nivovnfty o f Soul h C w o H tn JoiinC"lMvvll le ConouMora U nion Cofir/'.e tic , V o lle t r y C< 1'i'fiRriico Aron. II CRMC-HT-TALC-000148