Document 1QqXeg1ndBVDz15ZQjJo7Mm7q
Message
From: Sent: To: Subject:
Noonan, Jenny [Noonan.Jenny@epa.gov] 3/24/2025 4:18:16 PM Dunkins, Robin [Dunkins.Robin@epa.gov] RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Me either.
From: Dunkins, Robin <Dunkins.Robin@epa.gov> Sent: Monday, March 24, 2025 12:00 PM To: Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gov> Subject: Fw: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Well I never noticed these two gullets added to our fact sheet
Get Outlook for iOS
From: McLamb, Marguerite <McLamb.Marguerite@epa.gov>
Sent: Monday, March 24, 2025 11:01:01 AM
To: Anderson, Lea <dnderson.lea@epa.L >; Marks, Matthew <Marks.Matthew@epa.gov>; Dunkins, Robin
< nk -- n@epa.gov>; Srinivasan, Gautam < nivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@ .
>; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gov>; Petuya, Lauren
.infepa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan < 'iou-Lee.J-- "epa.gov>
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
I understood that
Ex. 5 Deliberative Process SDP)_
The fact sheet PDF regarding the reconsiderations and
that appears on each individual affected rules website is here: https://www.epa.govisystem/files/documents/2025-
03/neshap_powering-the-great-american-comeback fact-sheet 2.pdf
The relevant language from this fact sheet copied here:
Clean Air Act Section 112(i)(4) states the President of the United States may grant up to a 2-year exemption from compliance obligations for any source if the President finds that "the technology to implement such standard is not available and that is in the national security interests of the United States to do so."
Any source interested in a Presidential exemption, should provide their recommendations to EPA by March 31, 2025.
Sources need only provide why technology is unavailable and why it is in the national security interests of the United States to provide the exemption.
Discussion of the exemption may appear other places; this is the one of which I'm aware.
From: Anderson, Lea <
Sent: Monday, March 24, 2025 10:25 AM
To: Marks, Matthew <milarks.Matthew@epa.gov>; Dunkins, Robin <Dunkins.Robin@epa.gov>; Srinivasan, Gautam
<
_Jtam@epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr- >, Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gr- >, Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <Thrtelyou-Lee.Jan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite
" "1.P"
"rlepa. >
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
The directions have changed a bit since I last reviewed it,
Ex. 5 Deliberative Process !DPI_
Ex. 5 Deliberative Process (DP)
Sierra Club FOIA 2025-EPA-04883
ED_018865_00000267-00001
SC_EVERSPLIT0007977
Ex. 5 Deliberative Process (DP)
Lea Anderson (202) 564-5571
From: Marks, Matthew <
Sent: Monday, March 24, 2025 9:44 AM
To: Dunkins, Robin <Ounkins.Robin@epa.gov>; Srinivasan, Gautam <Srinivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>; Anderson, Lea
<- det
-.@epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr., >; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gc- >; Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <,..ortelyou-Lee.Jan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite
<I`"
>
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Sorry to be late to the party. I had a few tweaks/additions to the paper.
Matthew C. Marks Deputy Associate General Counsel Air and Radiation Law Office Office of General Counsel U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20460 T: 202-564-3276 M: 202-603-6170 E: marks.matthewgepa.gov
From: Dunkins, Robin <
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 4:50 PM
To: Srinivasan, Gautam <winivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>; Anderson, Lea <anderson.lea@epa.gov>; Marks, Matthew
< .rk
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr- >; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gr- >; Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <-ortelyou-Lee.Jan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite
<F
"-9- epa.1 >
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Gautum, Go ahead and talk with on Monday.
gaff. I will share with Aaron your concern and let him know we will follow up with him
Robin Dunkins, Senior Advisor Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 109 T.W. Alexander Drive Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 O:919-541-5335 M: 919-605-1178 dunkins.robingepa.gov
From: Srinivasan, Gautam < Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 4:10 PM To: Dunkins, Robin <Ounkins.Robin@epa.gov>; Anderson, Lea <anderson.lea@epa.gov>; Marks, Matthew <wiarks.Matthew@epa.gov>
Sierra Club FOIA 2025-EPA-04883
ED_018865_00000267-00002
SC_EVERSPLIT0007978
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr.>; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gc-, >; Petuya, Lauren <Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <..ortelyou-LeeJan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite <V' -- b.Marg - rite@epa. > Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Two notes from me. First, I think it would be good to have
Ex. 5 AC/DP
Ex.
Ex. 5 AC/DP
Wee-Rend-lb ail.
5 AC/DP
Let us know if you want us to do that. Thanks and happy
+++++++++++++++ (202) 695-6287
From: Dunkins, Robin <
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 2:59 PM
To: Anderson, Lea <anderson.lea@epa.gov>; Srinivasan, Gautam <Srinivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>, Marks, Matthew
<
'-'iew@epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gri..>; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jennv@epa.go >; Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <..ortelyou-LeeJan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite
<IA
-
9epa.f- >
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
It is my understanding that Ex. 5 Deliberative Process (DP) 1 If you have a suggestion please use redline/strikeout. As I will share any edits with Aaron.
Robin Dunkins, Senior Advisor Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 109 T.W. Alexander Drive Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 O:919-541-5335 M: 919-605-1178 dunkinssobin@epa.gov
From: Anderson, Lea <
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 2:40 PM
To: Dunkins, Robin <Ounkins.Robin@epa.gov>; Srinivasan, Gautam <Srinivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>; Marks, Matthew
< ,-1._ t'-iew@epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr,, >; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jennv@epa.ge. >; Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <..ortelyou-Lee.Jan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite
<pl
I
Sega >
Subject: RE: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Ex 5 Deliberative Process (DP)
Ex. 5.1Deliberative 'Process (DP)
wantedto check on the goal for this exercise.
Lea Anderson
Sierra Club FOIA 2025-EPA-04883
ED_018865_00000267-00003
SC_EVERSPLIT0007979
(202) 564-5571
From: Dunkins, Robin <
v>
Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 2:32 PM
To: Srinivasan, Gautam <Jrinivasan.Gautam@epa.gov>; Marks, Matthew <Marks.Matthew@epa.gov>; Anderson, Lea
< der__ .7'. epa.gov>
Cc: Do, Bebhinn <do.bebhinn@epa.gr.>; Noonan, Jenny <Noonan.Jenny@epa.gc-, >; Petuya, Lauren
<Petuya.Lauren@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <...ortelyou-Lee.Jan@epa.gov>; McLamb, Marguerite >
Subject: FW: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
I just discussed with Lea that I wanted to get any OGC feedback on the draft announcement on setting up an email box for entities to request a compliance extension under 112(i((4). OAR would like this to be posted by Monday. I told them I would seek your input/review today and circle back with them on whether we could get this posted by Monday. Let Bebhinn know if you have any problems accessing the shared file linked below.
Link to shared file;
Ex. 5 Deliberative Process (DP)
Robin Dunkins, Senior Advisor Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 109 T.W. Alexander Drive Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 O:919-541-5335 M: 919-605-1178
dunkins.robin@epa.gov
From: Dunkins, Robin Sent: Friday, March 21, 2025 2:15 PM To: Noonan, Jenny <,kloonan.Jennv@epa.gov>, Do, Bebhinn <Do.Bebhinn@epa.gov>; Cortelyou-Lee, Jan <Cortelyou-
Subject: 2025.03.21_Presidential Exemption Directions_ Edits.docx
Please see Aaron's edits attached. We need to share with OGC for their review/input. Who should be on point for that? He would also like to have this posted on Monday. Let me know if that's possible.
Sierra Club FOIA 2025-EPA-04883
ED_018865_00000267-00004
SC_EVERSPLIT0007980