Document 15ojVMLMgNQ8gaL60pzR61Nkq

1 VIRGINIA: 1 2 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS 3 CHARMAINE G. McLEAN, Executrix and 4 personal Representative of the Estate of Maynard F. McLean, Deceased, 5 Plaintiff, 6 v. 7 OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC., et al.. 8 Defendants. 9 ( ( ( ( Law Docket ( 31799V-04 ( ( ( ( 10 ZEBULON A. LITTLE, JR., 11 Plaintiff, 12 v. 13 DANA CORPORATION, et al.. 14 Defendants 15 WILLIAM R. PYATT, 16 Plaintiff 17 v. 18 GARLOCK, INC., a/k/a/ Garlock 19 Sealing Technologies, LLC., et al.. 20 Defendants. 21 ( (( ( ( Law Docket ( 37073V-04 ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( Law docket ( No. 36688H-02 ( ( ( ( ( ( 22 DEPOSITION UPON ORAL EXAMINATION OF MARCELLA L. DUNCAN 23 TAKEN ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF 24 Norfolk, Virginia 25 September 17, 2004 iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 2 1 Appearances: 2 GLASSER & GLASSER, P.L.C. By: RICHARD S. GLASSER, ESQUIRE 3 KAREN M. ZELLO, ESQUIRE. Counsel for the Plaintiff 4 LeCLAIR RYAN 5 By: ERIK D. NADOLINK, ESQUIRE and 6 CELBA & DesROCHERS LLP By: STEVEN W. CELBA, ESQUIRE 7 Counsel for Defendant Dana Corporation 8 VANDEVENTER BLACK LLP (Telephonically) By: ROBERT L. O'DONNELL, ESQUIRE 9 Counsel for Defendant Owens-Illinois 10 SIGAL, McCAMBRIDGE, SINGER & MAHONEY By: JOHN A. TURLIK, ESQUIRE (Telephonically) 11 Counsel for Defendant Garlock 12 HUNTON & WILLIAMS By: RAYMOND F. GEOFFROY, ESQUIRE 13 Counsel for Defendant 14 'k 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 DEPONENT 2 INDEX PAGE 3 3 Marcella L. Duncan By Mr. Glasser 4 4 5 6 EXHIBITS 7 8 NO. DESCRIPTION PAGE 9 1 Victor Gasket Guide 16th Edition, 10 May 1955,consisting of sevenpages 28 11 2 Victor 1909 - 1959 50th Anniversary Gaskets - Oilseals, VMG-25-0000150 12 through 157 andVMG-25-0000159 47 13 3 Quotation and Selling Record, Victor No. 1861 14 4 Quotation and Selling Record, Victor 15 No. 34305 92 99 16 5 Quotation and Selling Record, Victor No. 1861 17 103 18 k k k 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 4 1 Deposition upon oral examination of MARCELLA L. 2 DUNCAN, taken on behalf of the Plaintiff, before Richard W. 3 Zahn, RPR-RMR, a Notary Public for the Commonwealth of 4 Virginia at large, taken by agreement of counsel, commencing 5 at 9:10 a.m., on September 17, 2004, at the offices of 6 Glasser & Glasser, P.L.C., Crown Center, 580 East Main 7 Street, Suite 600, Norfolk, Virginia, 23510-2212, and this 8 in accordance with the Rules of the Supreme Court of 9 Virginia, 1950, as amended. 10 11 MR. GLASSER: Good morning. 12 MR. O'DONNELL: Good morning. 13 MR. GLASSER: Who is on the phone, please. This 14 is Richard Glasser, and we will identify ourselves. 15 MR. GEOFFROY: Ray Geoffroy. 16 MR. GLASSER: Good morning, Ray. 17 MR. TURLIK: John Turlik. 18 MR. GLASSER: Good morning, John. 19 Anyone else? Is anyone on for Garlock? 20 MR. TURLIK: Yes. John Turlik. 21 MR. O'DONNELL: Richard, this is Bob O'Donnell. 22 MR. GLASSER: How are you feeling. 23 MR. O'DONNELL: I have had better days, but I 24 can't miss the show, so I am here. 25 MR. GLASSER: Where are you? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 5 1 Mr. O'DONNELL: I am in my office. I have my 2 door closed so nobody will feel bad that I am here. 3 MR. GLASSER: Okey-doke. I am, of course, 4 appearing here on behalf of the plaintiffs, and I have Karen 5 Zello, a lawyer in my office, and I am going to ask the 6 other people to introduce themselves. 7 THE DEPONENT: Marcy Duncan. 8 MR. CELBA: Steve Celba for Dana. 9 MR. NADOLINK: Erik Nadolink for Dana. 10 MR. GLASSER: I am going to ask that the witness 11 be sworn in just a moment. But I want to at least on the 12 record clarify one thing. 13 There is ongoing discovery with regard to Dana in 14 these matters. I have been in some conversation with Tom 15 Biggers with regard to privileged documents, and we hope to 16 get going through those documents, and we certainly reserve 17 the right to conduct additional discovery of this witness if 18 we find that some of the documents that come out of our 19 in-camera hearing with regard to privilege require further 20 inquiry. 21 I don't need a response to that. That is simply 22 a statement. 23 And I'm going to ask the court reporter please to 24 swear the witness. 25 MR. NADOLINK: Erik Nadolink. I am not privy to iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 6 1 Mr. Glasser's discussions with Mr. Biggers that relate to a 2 case pending in Portsmouth, and we haven't had any such 3 discussions with respect to this case pending in Newport 4 News. 5 6 MARCELLA L. DUNCAN, was sworn and deposed on 7 behalf of the Defendants, as follows: 8 EXAMINATION 9 BY MR. GLASSER: 10 Q. Would you state your full name, please? 11 A. Marcella Lee Duncan. 12 Q. And can you give us a little bit about your 13 background and your current residence? 14 A. I live at 13710 South Kendall Drive in 15 Plainfield, Illinois. I have worked for Dana Corporation 16 since November 4th, 1968. I am currently the Sales 17 Operations Manager for the Ceiling Products Division of Dana 18 Corporation. I work in the Lisle, Illinois office. It is 19 called the Lisle Technical Center in Lisle. 20 Q. And you have been designated as a witness by Dana 21 in certain trials here in Virginia? 22 A. Yes, sir. 23 Q. Can you tell us what your understanding is of the 24 role that you are to play as a witness? 25 A. That I am to speak to you concerning sales iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 7 1 records that I am the custodian for. 2 Q. And you are talking about the sales records that 3 exist, am I correct? 4 A. Yes, sir. 5 Q. And do these sales records include all products 6 that were made by Victor and Dana? 7 A. No, sir. Just Victor, the old records for Victor 8 Manufacturing and Gasket Company, and then when Dana 9 acquired Victor, the sales records that have been created 10 subsequently through the Victor Products Division. There 11 has beenseveral names for the divisions, Victor Reinz, and 12 now called the Ceiling Products Division, and it isrelated 13 to gaskets. 14 Q. Do you know how early the records go back that 15 you will be testifying about? 16 A. 1 don't know the exact dates. But I have seen 17 records back to the 1930s. 18 Q. And when you started with Victor, you started 19 right out of high school? 20 A. Yes, sir. 21 Q. And you had no specialized training or 22 information concerning the sales that had been made by 23 Victor prior to your coming on board? 24 A. No, sir. 25 Q. What was your salary for the year 2003? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 8 1 A. Let's see. It was $62,000. 2 Q. And are you a salaried or an hourly employee? 3 A. Salaried employee. 4 Q. And does your responsibilities at Dana include 5 the responsibility to testify? 6 A. My job responsibilities are not -- I am Sales 7 Operations Manager. It has nothing to do with any testimony 8 that I might give on Dana's behalf. 9 Q. Are you paid extra when you testify, or 10 differently? 11 A. No, sir. 12 Q. What about your travel arrangements? 13 A. They do pay all of my business travel expenses. 14 Q. But you receive no extra compensation whatsoever? 15 A. I receive nothing extra. No, sir. 16 Q. Do you have stock in Dana, either in your own 17 name or in your retirement account? 18 A. No stock in Dana. 19 Q. Do you have stock in anything related to Victor 20 or Dana, or the nature of the job that you have? 21 A. No. The only thing that I have is a 401-K 22 through the company. And I believe it is managed by 23 Vanguard. 24 Q. And did I understand you to say that does not 25 include stock in the Dana Corporation? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 9 1 A. Correct. I have no stock in Dana. 2 Q. The $62,000 compensation that you received, is 3 that inclusive of all bonuses? 4 A. No. Depending on our -- if we meet our sales 5 forecasts for the division, it will depend on whether we get 6 a bonus every year based on sales, meeting our sales 7 forecast, so once in a while we will get a bonus. That's 8 usuallyanywhere from 5 to 10percent of ourannual salary 9 if we made a bonus. 10 Q. But yourannual salary for 2003 wasapproximately 11 $62,000? 12 A. Yes. 13 Q. How many times have you testified at the request 14 of Victor Dana? 15 A. I don't know exactly. I believe it is probably 16 around a half dozen, or a dozen times. Twelve to fifteen 17 times. 18 Q. And does that include your testimony both in 19 depositions, such as we are doing now, and in trials? 20 A. Yes, sir. 21 Q. And when was the first time that you testified? 22 A. Approximately four years ago. I believe it was 23 January. And it was either 2000 or 1999. I can't remember. 24 Q. Do you rememberwhere? 25 A. Yes. In Texas. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 10 1 Q. And was the purpose of that testimony the same as 2 you have previously described, namely to tell of existing 3 sales records or cards? 4 A. Yes. 5 Q. And are you scheduled to testify in Virginia in 6 the next several weeks? 7 A. Just today that I know of. 8 Q. Have you been told about whether or not you will 9 be coming as a witness to trial in Virginia? 10 A. No, sir. 11 Q. Do you generally get advance warning? 12 A. No, sir. 13 Q. Or notice? 14 A. No, sir. 15 Q. And so they simply tell you to be in Newport 16 News, Virginia, and you will make sure that you are there? 17 A. As a general rule they will tell me like a 18 schedule, ask me what days I have available for deposition 19 testimony, if I am going to be travelling for the company, 20 and my sales responsibilities, to make arrangements, and 21 they will ask me for certain days. Usually, I will know a 22 week or so ahead of time. 23 Q. But has anyone told you about any trial that's 24 upcoming in Newport News, Virginia? 25 A. No. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 11 1 Q. Now, I saw mention in one of the depositions a 2 witness fee of $2,700? 3 A. Yes. For expenses. 4 Q. And that was paid to you? 5 A. No, sir. 6 Q. That was paid to the company? 7 A. Yes, sir. 8 Q. And it was based on what expenses? 9 A. My travel expenses and hotel out to California. 10 Q. You showed me a photograph of your husband. I 11 just need to clarify. Am I correct that he had his accident 12 on Sunday? 13 A. Sunday morning. 14 Q. And was it an automobile, or bicycle? 15 A. Bicycle. 16 Q. And what were his injuries? 17 A. Shall I describe the event? 18 Q. Well, in terms of fractures? 19 A. He had a cheek bone fracture and nose fracture. 20 Because he is on heart medicine, Plavix -- it is an 21 anticoagulant -- he had a lot more swelling than he would 22 normally. So he had swelling like from above his eye and 23 all the way down, a lot of blood pooling in his -- the side 24 of his face. 25 Q. And I trust that he is doing better now? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 12 1 A. I hope so. 2 Q. Did he have surgery? 3 A. No, he did not have to have surgery. On Tuesday 4 we went to multiple doctors. One of them was a plastic 5 surgeon so that they could view the x-rays and the damage to 6 see if surgery was needed to get the bones aligned up, and 7 they said that the bones were in line and would heal 8 naturally. So he does not have to have surgery. And 9 nothing -- he had no tooth or jaw damage, so the oral 10 surgeon didn't have to do anything there. And they will 11 check him out again in about three weeks to make sure 12 everything is doing well. 13 Q. Who at Dana did you notify of your husband's 14 injuries? 15 A. I went to work Monday morning and I notified my 16 boss and the people that I work with, because they were 17 going to have to take some of my responsibilities for 18 Tuesday when I had to take him to the doctor. And human 19 resources. 20 Q. Now, you have previously mentioned in another 21 deposition that you had family in Tidewater? 22 A. Yes. 23 Q. What type of family do you have in Tidewater? 24 A. One of my mother's brothers lives in Chesapeake, 25 and his children. I have six cousins and their families iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 13 1 that live in this area. 2 Q. And you had a grandfather and/or an uncle who 3 worked at a shipyard? 4 A. Yes, sir. 5 Q. And tell me about that? 6 A. It was my grandmother and grandfather that moved 7 their family out here in the '40s. And my mother went to 8 school here, and my grandfather worked at the Naval 9 shipyards. And two of my uncles, for a short period of 10 time, and one uncle who still resides here retired from the 11 shipyards after 40-some years. 12 Q. And when you say that they lived here, where was 13 that, Chesapeake or where? 14 A. It was called Deep Creek. I guess it is now 15 called Chesapeake. It was where they lived. 16 Q. And what was your grandfather's trade? 17 A. I think -- I guess -- I really don't know. I 18 remember him having a farm in Illinois. So I don't know 19 exactly what he did here. 20 Q. But do you know the details of any of the work 21 that your grandfather or your two uncles did at the 22 shipyard? 23 A. I know the one uncle that ultimately retired from 24 the shipyard worked on engines and things like that. He is 25 a mechanic. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 14 1 Q. Would they be engines aboard ship, or -- 2 A. I don't know. 3 Q. Now you indicated that you had made sales calls 4 in this area? 5 A. Yes. 6 Q. When did you make those calls? 7 A. It has probably been about five years ago. It 8 was the last time that I made a direct sales call here four 9 or five years ago. 10 Q. So we are talking 1999? 11 A. Approximately, yes. 12 Q. And I am assuming that these calls did not 13 involve the sale of any asbestos-containing materials made 14 by Victor or Dana? 15 A. No, sir, they did not. 16 Q- And what did they involve? 17 A. Part of my sales responsibilities are house 18 accounts. And I have gasket sales, and sales of gasket 19 sheet material are part of my responsibilities, and those 20 are the items that I would handle here. 21 Q. And who are your customers? 22 A. General Electric Apparatus in Chesapeake is one 23 of them. Southland Industries. Stihl chain saws in 24 Virginia Beach was one of my customers. Still is. 25 Q. And did you have customers in other areas other iond Tel , England (757) 627--6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 than southeast Virginia? 15 2 A. Yes. 3 Q. And how far was your sales area? 4 A. Because I have house accounts, I had the entire 5 United States. And raw materials, entire United States, and 6 some outside of the U.S. 7 Q. And by house accounts you are describing sales 8 made directly by Victor or Dana to the distributor? 9 A. No, sir. A house account is an account that is 10 small dollars, small volume, and so it doesn't justify a 11 full blown sales account manager. They get company cars and 12 that type of thing, and they have to go on regular visits to 13 the customer. House accounts are mainly maintained 14 in-house. The customers will call in orders, or talk to one 15 of my people, or to me. And that type of thing. They don't 16 require the same kind of customer care. 17 Q. Were all of your customers the actual users of 18 the product? Did any of them, to your knowledge, resell the 19 product? Southland, for example? 20 A. Southland would buy gaskets from us that they 21 would use on like Ford, assemblies for Ford Motor Company or 22 General Motors. Like a water pump assembly, or something 23 like that. I'm not sure exactly what all they do make. And 24 they would place the gasket on the assembly and then sell 25 the end assembly to Ford. So I don't know exactly what you :ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 16 1 would call that. It didn't go on the actual vehicle at that 2 time. 3 Q. Southland didn't use it itself. Southland sold 4 it to another purchaser who was the ultimate end user? 5 A. Yes. 6 Q. Do you know who the -- did you have any gasket 7 distributors here in the Virginia area that Victor Dana sold 8 to? 9 A. We didn't sell to distributors. We sold to, as I 10 said, like someone who would put a kit together or something 11 like that, or would actually apply the gasket to the vehicle 12 themselves and sell the vehicle. So we would sell to like 13 General Motors, OE service. I believe they would stock 14 dealers and things like that. 15 Q. Did you sell sheetgasket materialto entities 16 who resold it? 17 A. I don't know what the resale conditions were of 18 any of those type of customers. We sold the materials to 19 them. Many of them consumed them in their own gasket 20 manufacturing. 21 Q. So I take it from what you are saying that you 22 did not deal with any distributors here in Virginia? 23 A. Not distributors. 24 Q. And you did not deal with anyentities who 25 redistributed your product in the North Carolina area? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 17 1 A. I don't know what they did with the materials 2 other than manufacturing their own gaskets. 3 Q. Do you have any way to determine what your sales 4 were to Virginia in any given year? Going back to the 5 times that we are dealing with, times of the microfiche 6 records? 7 A. The only way to determine sales is to go through 8 all the microfiche records. Our sales records are -- normal 9 course of business, the old records were not kept by 10 customer, they were kept by part number. Or by the material 11 number, raw material number on our sales cards. And the 12 only way that I can tell by a particular customer, you have 13 to go through all the microfiche cards, all the sales 14 records and physically look for a specific customer. 15 Q. We will talk about that at some length later. 16 But let me continue with some preliminary questions that I 17 have. 18 Have you ever been to the Newport News 19 Shipbuilding Company? 20 A. No. Not to Newport News -- not to Newport News. 21 Q. Have you ever been to Norfolk Naval Shipyard? 22 A. I don't know what the name of the one my uncle 23 worked for. I went with him one time. 24 Q. And was that simply a family visit, or a sales 25 visit? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 18 1 A. He took me to talk to a couple of his old work 2 people. It wasn't really a sales visit. It was just to 3 show me. 4 Q. When was this? 5 A. Oh, brother. Four years ago. 6 Q. And what were you supposed to talk to these 7 people about? 8 A. Basically just he introduced me to some of the 9 people that he worked with. He showed me -- he was still 10 working as a consultant at that time, so I got to go in with 11 him to see what they did. 12 Q. It was a social visit, not a visit for Victor 13 Dana? 14 A. Yes. More or less. 15 Q. Have you ever been to Norfolk Shipbuilding and 16 Dry Dock Company? 17 A. I don't know the name of the one that I went to. 18 It -- I know where it is at. Norfolkco? 19 Q. Norshipco? 20 A. Norshipco. Yes, that's the one. 21 Q. Have you ever been present when gasket material 22 was being manufactured? 23 A. At our plants, yes. 24 Q. And that would include themanufacturer of 25 asbestos-containing gasket materials? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. I dobelieve, yes. 19 2 Q. Have you ever beenpresentwhen gasket materials 3 were being installed? 4 A. Yes. 5 Q. And whenwas that? Or howfrequently has that 6 occurred? 7 A. Not that frequently. We had -- I worked in 8 Churubusco at the oil seal manufacturing plant for many 9 years. One of the buildings on the property was a training 10 center for the product planning technicians. They would 11 tear engines down and put them back together, and I was 12 present at several of the demonstrations there for showing 13 where the gaskets would go on the engines and that type of 14 thing. 15 Q. Have you been present when gasket material was 16 being ripped out or removed? 17 A. Yes. 18 Q. Have you been present when gasket material was 19 being sanded or filed? 20 A. No. 21 Q. Do you know whether the gasket operations that 22 you have described were asbestos-containing gaskets? 23 A. No, Idon't know. 24 Q. Have you been present when Dana Victor 25 asbestos-containing gaskets or gasket materials were being iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 tested for the release of airborne asbestos fibers? 20 2 A. No. 3 Q. If I understood your priortestimony, your first (oaP~ 4 testimony was for or five years ago? 5 A. Yes, sir. 6 Q. When were youfirstcontacted aboutthat 7 testimony? How did the fact of your providing testimony 8 come about? 9 A. As I recall, I was asked to read an affidavit and 10 fill out an affidavit for this particular litigation. And I 11 signed that, and as a result of that I was called to testify 12 in Texas concerning what I had written on the affidavit. 13 Q. Who asked you to sign the affidavit? 14 A. It would have been our Dana legal group. 15 Q. In-house, or outside counsel? 16 A. I think it was a combination. I have worked with 17 many people over the last few years and I really don't 18 recall who specifically asked me that first time. 19 Q. And who drafted that affidavit? Was it drafted 20 by the lawyers? 21 A. They drafted part of it. And I filled, I put in 22 my verbiage to the questions that they asked me. 23 Q. And what was the nature? Do you remember the 24 contents of that affidavit? 25 A. No, sir, I don't. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 21 1 Q. Do you have a copy of it available with your 2 records? 3 A. I probably might have, yes. 4 Q. Would you make an inquiry and let Mr. Celba know? 5 A. Yes. 6 MR. GLASSER: And we, of course, in our notice, 7 issued a request that she bring with her materials. We 8 would like a copy. Is that a problem with you all? 9 MR. NADOLINK: We can look into it. I think the 10 notice you had says documents she has to rely on in this 11 case. 12 MR. GLASSER: I would like to see the affidavit. 13 Is that a problem? 14 MR. CELBA: We have to take a review of it, 15 Richard, and get that to you immediately. 16 MR. GLASSER: Thank you. 17 BY MR. GLASSER: 18 Q. Did you in fact testify in Texas? 19 A. I had a deposition. Is that the same as 20 testifying? 21 Q. Yes, ma'am. 22 A. Yes, sir. 23 Q. And since that time whenyour testimony has been 24 presented againroughlytwelve tofifteen times, you meet 25 each time with counsel for Dana? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. Not always, no, sir. 22 2 Q. Are you provided information about what you are 3 to testify about? 4 A. It says records, yes. They tell me that I am 5 being asked about the sales records that I am the custodian 6 of. 7 Q. And by the sales record you are referring to the 8 microfiche? 9 A. Microfiche. The, like the customer master 10 listing. Things like that. 11 Q. Have you ever testified for Victor Dana in a case 12 other than on the issue of the microfiche or the records 13 that still exist? 14 A. No. It has always been sales records relating to 15 our gaskets. 16 Q. If I understood correctly, you are not even aware 17 that there is a trial scheduled in Newport News, to start 18 Monday, September 20th? 19 A. I didn't know. 20 Q. And no one has talked to you about providing any 21 testimony there? 22 A. They haven't. 23 Q. Are you aware as to whether there is a trial set 24 where you have been named as a witness in Newport News in 25 November of 2004? ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. No. 23 2 Q. Have you done anything to prepare for a trial in 3 Virginia, be it in September, or November, 2004? 4 A. No. 5 Q. Have you been asked to do anything to prepare? 6 A. No. 7 Q. Do you know what the case involves? 8 A. Asbestos. 9 Q. But you are simply assuming that that's what is 10 involved, or you don't have any details on the case? 11 A. No. 12 Q. And I know the answer, but so the record is clear 13 you don't have any indication of the work history of the 14 people who are involved in these asbestos cases? 15 A. No, sir. 16 Q. No one has shared with you any of the testimony 17 that has come forward in discovery depositions about the use 18 of the Victor products? 19 A. No, sir. I have to go back a little bit. All I 20 know is this relates to shipyards. That's all I know. 21 Q. Well, tell me what you know about which 22 shipyards, or what it relates to? 23 A. U.S. Norfolk Naval Shipyard is involved in what I 24 am testifying on today, I understand. 25 Q. And do you know anything about the Newport News iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 24 1 Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company? 2 A. No. 3 Q. And I am probablyrepeating myself, but to be 4 sure, you haven't done any review of any records as they 5 relate to Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company? 6 A. The only review of Virginia records that I have 7 ever done was for a case last year that I was involved in 8 here with you where I did go through our customer listing 9 for customers in Virginia. 10 Q. And you have not done anything for the cases that 11 I am describing in September and November of 2004? 12 A. No, sir. 13 Q. When you werehired in 1968, to yourknowledge 14 who was the most knowledgeable person concerning sales of 15 asbestos-containing gaskets and gasket materials by Victor 16 Dana? 17 A. I had no idea when I was hired at that time. 18 Q. And you don't know who oversaw the sales? 19 A. No, sir. 20 Q. Okay. 21 A. Not at that time. 22 Q. Am I correct that ;you have never been in charge 23 of recording sales or shipments of asbestos-containing 24 Victopac, gaskets and raw material during your years at 25 Victor Dana? iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 25 1 A. I have recorded sales of asbestos-containing 2 gaskets while working for Dana Corporation in my years of 3 service, yes. 4 Q. To what extent has that been your responsibility? 5 A. Part of my job responsibilities and inventory 6 record keeping and sales. 7 Q. And when did those responsibilities start? 8 A. In 1968. 9 Q. But you have never been in charge of that 10 operation? 11 A. No, I wasn't in charge of the operation. No. 12 Q. Do you know when you made your first sales of 13 asbestos-containing gaskets or gasket material, raw material 14 for Victor Dana? 15 A. It would have been the early 1980s. 16 Q. Is the first time you made a sale? 17 A. That I recall. 18 Q. And any information that you have today about 19 sales prior to 1980 would not be based upon your personal 20 experience? 21 A. Only on my personal knowledge. 22 Q. On knowledge that you have acquired starting 23 when? . 24 A. I would say since I worked with Victor. 25 Q. But as I understand your testimony you were never ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 26 1 directly involved with any sale of asbestos-containing 2 gasket or gasket material manufactured by Victor Dana until 3 the early 1980s, am I correct? 4 A. Me personally selling it? 5 Q. You personally. 6 A. Correct. 7 Q. Can you tell me thetotal volume of 8 asbestos-containing gaskets and gasket materials sold by 9 Victor, whether it is measured in weight, sheet, gaskets, or 10 dollars for any time during the 1930s? 11 A. No, sir. 12 Q. The 1940s? 13 A. No, sir. 14 Q. The 1950s? 15 A. No. 16 Q. The 1960s? 17 A. No. 18 Q. The 1970s? 19 A. No. 20 Q. And into the 1980s? 21 A. No. 22 Q. Can you tell me how 23 rials, how many different ' 24 rials were manufactured by 25 A. No. iond Tel l, England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 Q. The 1940s? 27 2 A. No. 3 Q. The 1950s? 4 A. No. 5 Q. The 1960s, prior to 1968? 6 A. Not off the top of my head without researching I 7 cannot, no. 8 Q. We will talk about researching. 9 What about the 1970s. 10 A. No. 11 Q. What about the 1980s up until 1988? 12 A. No. 13 Q. You are aware, are you not, that Victor 14 Manufacturing and Gasket Company promoted itself as being 15 the world's largest gasket manufacturer. Are you aware of 16 that? 17 A. The Victor Manufacturing andGasket Company? 18 Q. Yes. 19 A. I am not aware of that. 20 Q. Are you able to identify this 1955brochure that 21 I have placed in front of you? 22 A. It appears to be a copy of one of the catalogs 23 issued by the Victor Manufacturing Gasket Company, yes. 24 Q. And you see where it says the world's largest 25 gasket manufacturer? jond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. Yes, sir. 28 2 Q. Do you have any information todispute that claim 3 that they made? 4 A. No, sir. 5 Q. Do you have any reason tosuspect the, or 6 question the authenticity of this document? 7 A. I would have no way of knowing if it was correct 8 or not. 9 MR. GLASSER: Mr. Court reporter, if you will 10 work with us we will get you a clean copy of this, and I 11 would ask that it be marked as Duncan exhibit number 1. 12 (Victor Gasket Guide 16th Edition, 13 May 1955, consisting of seven pages, was 14 marked Exhibit No. 1.) 15 BY MR. GLASSER: 16 Q. Based on your answers to this line of questions, 17 Mrs. Duncan, am I correct that you can't tell me how long 18 Victor Manufacturing and Gasket Company was the largest 19 gasket manufacturer in the world? How long before 1955, or 20 how long after 1955? 21 A. I don't know who or what company was the largest. 22 We use a lot of methods of advertising to promote our 23 business. 24 MR. GLASSER: Let's go off the record just for a 25 second. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 (Discussion off the record) 29 2 (Recess) 3 BY MR. GLASSER: 4 Q. Mrs. Duncan, I am showing you what has been 5 marked as Duncan number 1. Have you seen this before? 6 A. I believe that I have the actual catalog, yes. 7 Q. And I trust then that you are aware that Dana 8 indicated that it made gaskets for a number of industries, 9 including marine engines, industrial engines? 10 A. Yes, sir. 11 Q. And they also boasted of the fact that their 12 products met military requirements. 13 MR. CELBA: I object to the form there. 14 MR. GLASSER: What is the objection. 15 MR. CELBA: Argumentative, boasted. I don't 16 think it is necessary to include that term. 17 BY MR. GLASSER: 18 Q. That they stated that they represented -- 19 A. I see the writings in the book, yes. 20 Q. And you agree that they indicated that they met 21 the military requirements for the sale of the gasket 22 material? Just a yes or a no? 23 A. It doesn't say we need to meet military 24 requirements specifically in this statement. 25 Q. Do you know whether the products met military iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 requirements or not in 1955? 30 2 A. Some of our materials met military specs, yes. 3 Q. And that's because of the QPLs, isn't it? 4 A. I forget what QPL exactly means. 5 Q. Have you heard that term before? 6 A. Yes, yes. 7 Q. In the past you have said that you weren't 8 familiar with that term. 9 A. May I explain? 10 Q. Surely. 11 A. The concept I am very familiar with. I simply 12 didn't know that the term was used to describe the concept. 13 Q. Do you know what you need do to be approved for 14 the qualified products list known as QPL? 15 A. Yes. 16 Q. What do you need to do to be approved on that 17 list? 18 A. The military will provide material specifications 19 required for a particular vehicle application. And our 20 materials, we will list what our materials are capable of, 21 temperatures, compressibility, recovery, the actual 22 characteristics of the gasket or the material. If the two 23 are the same, then the government would put our material as 24 listed as one of the approved materials on the list. 25 Q. But it is not restricted to any vehicle? It can iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 be for gasket sheet material, can't it? 31 2 A. It depends on the military spec. 3 Q. But on the QPLs that Victor had its Victopac 4 approved for, it was for an asbestos-containing compressed 5 asbestos material, wasn't it? 6 A. I am not familiar with the actual specifics of 7 the mil specs. 8 Q. Do you know when Victor first sought and received 9 approval to make sales to the military? 10 . A. No. 11 Q. You have no information on that? 12 A. No. 13 Q. It talks in this brochure, exhibit 1, about 14 asbestos millboard. Are you familiar with the asbestos 15 millboard product? 16 A. I have seen it. I know what it is. Yes. 17 Q. And was it a product from which gaskets could be 18 cut? 19 A. It was a product used in combination with other 20 materials to make a gasket. 21 Q. And do you know whether it contained 22 approximately 80 percent asbestos content by weight? 23 A. I don'tknow how much asbestos was in it, no. 24 Q. But you are aware that it did contain asbestos? 25 A. Yes, sir. ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 32 1 Q. As reflected by its name? 2 A. Yes, sir. 3 Q. And in terms of the last page of exhibit number 4 1, in terms of the industries served, does it show a large 5 vessel or ship? 6 A. It shows a picture of a large ship in the 7 industries served area, yes. 8 Q. And does it also talk in terms of Victor being a 9 supplier of OER equipment. 10 A. It lists suppliers of OER equipment on this page. 11 Q. Does it specifically list ships and submarines? 12 A. It lists submarines and ships, but we didn't make 13 submarines and ships. 14 Q. I am not suggesting that you made submarines and 15 ships, but you made equipment for submarines and ships, 16 gasket equipment; is that correct? 17 A. Well, I wouldn't call it gasket equipment, but we 18 made gaskets that would go on -- 19 Q. Submarines and ships? 20 A. Vehicular type stuff for submarines and ships. 21 Q. When you say vehicular, I think automobile? 22 A. Oh, there's trucks. There's tanks. There's 23 internal combustion engines is what our primary gasket 24 production -- that's our market. And predominantly 25 vehicular. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 33 1 Q. Predominantly vehicular. And there are a bunch 2 of things that are included here, including cars and trucks. 3 But I am asking, doesn't this brochure confirm that they 4 sold material for use aboard submarines and ships. 5 MR. CELBA: I object. It has been asked and 6 answered. But go ahead and answer. 7 A. We sold to those markets, yes, for specific 8 engine applications. I am not familiar with any engine on a 9 ship that we supplied a gasket for that ran the ship. No. 10 BY MR. GLASSER: 11 Q. Firstly this is 1955, and you finished high 12 school in 1968, and you have already testified that you knew 13 nothing about the Victor operation prior to your coming on 14 board. 15 MR. CELBA: I object to the form. I don't think 16 that was the correct testimony. 17 BY MR. GLASSER: 18 Q. Was that not your testimony? 19 A. When I started with Victor in 1968 -- I am sorry. 20 When I started with Dana in 1968, that day that I walked in 21 I had no prior knowledge of any of their materials, 22 customers, sales, products, et cetera. 23 Q. And in 1955 you had no information as to where 24 Dana or Victor sold asbestos-containing gaskets and gasket 25 materials, correct? iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 34 1 A. When I was five years old in 1955, I had no 2 knowledge at that time. 3 Q. And anything that you have now is based upon what 4 you have been told or shown? 5 A. Or researched myself. 6 Q. And we can talk about the completeness of the 7 ability to research, but you have no personal knowledge to 8 in any way contradict the limit, or limit what this brochure 9 says in 1955? 10 A. I am familiar with all the records that I have 11 looked at that go back to the 1930s. I have never, ever, 12 seen any reference to a gasket made for an engine that ran a 13 ship or a submarine, period. 14 Q. What about a gasket that went on a pipe? Have 15 you seen that? You understand that gaskets made by Victor 16 went on pipes, don't you? Just yes or no? 17 A. We made flange gaskets. 18 Q. And you knew your gaskets could go on a flange, 19 correct, and you knew your gaskets could go on a valve, 20 correct? 21 A. I am not familiar with valve gaskets. 22 Q. Are you familiar with gaskets that go on pumps? 23 A. Water pumps, yes, sir. Yes. 24 Q. I think the problem in our communication is you 25 are talking about vehicles, and I am not talking about .one! Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 something that had to be used aboard a ship. 35 2 I am talking about something that was usable 3 equipment on a ship, such as pipes, valves, flanges, and 4 pumps. And you have no information to suggest that Victor 5 gaskets couldn't be used in that mode, do you? 6 A. I don't show any -- I have not found any sales of 7 specific gaskets to a specific application on a ship or a 8 submarine. 9 Q. But you found sales to the United States Navy? 10 A. There are sales of gaskets. Some gaskets to the 11 U.S. Navy. They are vehicular gaskets. 12 Q. You have found sales to the U.S. Navy. True or 13 false? 14 A. I found -- 15 MR. CELBA: I object. Asked and answered. 16 MR. GLASSER: Steve, you can object if you want, 17 but I am going to repeat the question. 18 MR. CELBA: Go ahead. 19 A. I have seen gasket, vehicular gasket sales to the 20 U.S. Navy, yes. 21 BY MR. GLASSER: 22 Q. Is Victopac a vehicular gasket, or a gasket 23 material in your mind? 24 A. Victopac is a gasket material that can be used in 25 multiple applications. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 36 1 Q. You don't know from the records that you have 2 reviewed who the end user is of products that were sold by 3 Victor, isn't that correct? 4 A. In some cases we are selling to the end user, 5 such as the original equipment manufacturer. So, yes, we do 6 know what the end use of that gasket is, and we are selling 7 to that original equipment manufacturer. Yes, we do have 8 some of that knowledge. 9 Q. I thank you for that answer, but my question was 10 not that. My question was in all instances, not in some 11 instances, you don't know who the end user of your product 12 is going to be, do you? Your records do not reflect who 13 installed the gaskets that were sold, do they? 14 A. We know where the gaskets went, but not the 15 specific person who may have installed the gaskets. 16 Q. And you don't know where they were installed, do 17 you? 18 A. Gaskets are manufactured for a specific 19 application. 20 Q. Is Victopac manufactured for a specific and only 21 one specific application. That's not correct, is it? 22 A. I am sorry. My statement was for gaskets. 23 Victopac is a gasket material that when sold to someone you 24 do not know, I do not know what they are going to do with 25 it. Where they are going to cut it. We sell it as a sheet ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 37 1 of material with specific characteristics. And then what 2 you cut from it, I do not know. 3 Q. Thank you for that clarification. And what you 4 are saying is that you don't know when it is going to be 5 used, correct, when you sell Victopac sheet gasket. You 6 don't know when it is going to be used? 7 A. Not exactly when. We give them shelf life 8 information if they need it, yes. 9 Q. And you don't know where it is going to be used? 10 A. Only the general temperature application 11 characteristics. 12 Q. And you don't know how it is going to be used? 13 A. To seal some engine, or a joint, or something, 14 you know, what it does. 15 Q. It has multiple uses, and you don't know the 16 specific use it is intended? 17 A. I know the use it is intended for, what we sell 18 it for, yes. We give -- we will give specific 19 characteristics. If someone uses it for something outside 20 of that, we don't know, or can't control. 21 Q. But when you sell it you don't know whether the 22 Victopac compressed asbestos-containing sheet is going to be 23 used on a car or on a ship, or on a pipe or a flange, or a 24 valve or a pump. Am I correct? 25 A. If I am selling you a Victopac material it has iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 38 1 limited uses. It could not be used on say a head gasket. 2 You couldn't use that material on a head gasket. So there 3 are some -- you wouldn't want to -- I couldn't say that you 4 would not do that, but you wouldn't want to. 5 Q. The limitations that you are describing don't 6 limit the fact that Victopac was able to have multiple uses? 7 A. Victopac has multiple uses, but there is limits. 8 Q. The limit in terms of maybe temperature needs, or 9 compression needs? 10 A. Suitability. Robustness. Things like that would 11 make a difference as to whether you would use it in a 12 particular application. 13 Q. Where was Victopac manufactured within the 14 corporate locations of Victor Dana? 15 A. During what years? 16 Q. During the 1950s. 17 A. It was made at the ChicagoChurubusco based 18 facilities. 19 Q. And in Chicago did the plant burn? Was there a 20 fire in Chicago? 21 A. That wasn't until the 1990s. There may have been 22 something earlier that I am not aware of. 23 Q. When -- excuse me. Were you through? 24 A. Part of -- we had a fire in the building in the 25 1990s. lOnct Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 39 1 Q. For what period of time were the Victopac 2 materials manufactured at the Robinson plant? 3 A. The Robinson plant was built in 1965. So they 4 would have started manufacturing some of the Victopac 5 material after the completion of the plant. 6 Q. And did they continue to manufacture the Victopac 7 asbestos-containing materials at Robinson until 1988? 8 A. Yes. 9 Q. And you were neveremployed at Robinson? 10 A. That is correct. 11 Q. And I might have misspoken, but am I correct that 12 the Chicago plant as it was initially was, was torn down? 13 A. The Chicago plant was torn down, yes. 14 Q. And that was before you wereemployed? 15 A. No. 16 Q. After you were employed? 17 A. Yes, sir. 18 Q. And some of their records were burned in the 19 early 1990s? 20 A. There were records in the tower that were burned 21 in the fire in the 1990s. 22 Q. Prior to 1967, to your knowledge did Dana ever 23 manufacture, sell or distribute any asbestos-containing 24 material? 25 MR. CELBA: Object. Lack of foundation. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 BY MR. GLASSER: 40 2 Q. If you know. 3 A. Dana Corporation was a customer of the Victor 4 Gasket and Manufacturing Company. And there were -- they 5 did purchase some of the gaskets from them that contained 6 asbestos, yes. 7 Q. And they had been doing that over what period of 8 time? 9 A. I don't know. 10 Q. But they had been a long-term customer? 11 A. I don't know. 12 Q. They had been long-termenough so they were 13 interested in buying the company in 1967? 14 A. I know they purchased the company in 1967. I 15 don't know their legal terms of the acquisition. 16 Q. And there were a number of the Victopac 17 asbestos-containing asbestos gasket materials in terms of 18 size and thickness, were there not? 19 A. Physical? You are asking about physical size? 20 Q. Yes, ma'am. 21 A. We would make a specific Victopac material and 22 shear it in different sizes and would manufacture it in 23 different gauges, thicknesses. 24 Q. And much of it had asbestos-containing contents? 25 A. Several of the gasket materials did contain iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 asbestos as one of the components, yes. 41 2 Q. And many of them contained, you have told me 3 before when we met in the court in Portsmouth, roughly 80 4 percent asbestos to -- asbestos content by weight? 5 A. I don't know by weight. The composition of 6 Victopac was approximately 80 percent fibers and 20 percent 7 binders and what we call rare-earth like micas and clays and 8 those types of things. 9 Q. But by 80 percent fibers you are saying 80 10 percent asbestos fibers? 11 A. Yes, sir. 12 Q. And do I understand that of the numbers assigned 13 to the various forms and gauges of Victopac, anything that 14 did not end with a 9 was asbestos-containing? Victopac 1, 15 Victopac IB. Victopac 14 would be -- 16 A. That was the general -- how do you say it? How 17 you told -- when we converted the materials to nonasbestos, 18 we changed the number to have a 9 at the end for the 19 Victopacs. 20 Q. Do you know how many plants worldwide in the 21 Victor Dana corporate family made asbestos-containing sheet 22 gasket material in the 1950s? 23 A. No. 24 Q. Or '60s, and the same is true for the '70s and 25 the '80s? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. No. 42 2 Q. The same is not true, or you don't know? 3 A. Not without just off the top of my head guessing, 4 no. 5 Q. So you don't know where, other than Robinson, 6 Victopac asbestos-containing material was made around the 7 world in the Victor Dana organization? 8 A. I know we made it in Mexico. That's the only one 9 that I am sure of. 10 Q. Were any of the Mexican manufactured products 11 brought to this country? 12 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to that. Lack 13 of foundation. 14 BY MR. GLASSER: 15 Q. Do you know? 16 A. I don't know. 17 Q. Now, am I correct that there was the ability to 18 make markings, or stamps, or logos on the 19 asbestos-containing gasket material manufactured by Victor 20 Dana? 21 A. You could mark the material, yes. 22 Q. And some of it was marked? 23 A. Yes, sir. 24 Q. And some of it was marked with the Victor logo? 25 A. Yes. ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 43 1 Q. And some was marked with the logo of a customer 2 who wanted it marked with their name on it? 3 A. Yes. We would put Caterpillar's name on the 4 material, or if you were talking about gaskets, you stamped 5 the part number sometimes. 6 Q. Did you ever see a Victor or Dana gasket or 7 gasket material that had the word "caution" on it? 8 A. No. 9 Q. Hazard? 10 A. No. 11 Q. Warning? 12 A. On the gaskets? 13 Q. Yes, ma'am. 14 A. No. 15 Q. Did you ever see any document where Victor Dana 16 stated any caution or hazard concerning exposure to 17 asbestos-containing gaskets or gasket material that it was 18 manufacturing or distributing? 19 A. I have seen what iscalled MSDS sheets. 20 Material Safety Data Sheets that will have specific 21 information related on them about components used in gasket 22 materials. 23 Q. Over what period of time, Mrs. Duncan, have you 24 seen MSDS sheets? 25 A. For sure, absolutely since I have been back with iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 44 the Victor Division since 1988 I have seen lots of MSDS 2 sheets. 3 Q. Now the MSDS sheets that you saw when you came 4 back in 1988, did you return in May of 1988? 5 A. Yes, sir. 6 Q. And in June of 1988 you have testified that they 7 stopped making the asbestos-containing gasket material, 8 gasket raw material? 9 A. That is correct. 10 Q. And the MSDS sheets that you saw, were they 11 before or after the asbestos had been taken out of the 12 Victor Dana product in June of 1988? 13 A. There are both. I have seen both. 14 Q. And when you saw the earlier ones before they had 15 taken asbestos out, did they talk in terms of diseases? 16 Have you seen the term mesothelioma on the MSDS sheets? 17 A. I don't know that I have seen that word on the 18 sheets. 19 Q. Have you seen diseases mentioned or described? 20 A. The only thing that I recall seeing is, as far as 21 an MSDS, I don't know if you are familiar with them. It 22 lists all of the materials that are in them. And any 23 precautionary characteristics or things that you would want 24 to do around the materials, if it is like a chemical that 25 smells, or anything like that, we ship these to our , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 45 1 customers. I don't really read them specifically. 2 Q. But to focus on asbestos, do you remember what 3 the precautions, MSDS sheets said about using, installing, 4 modifying or removing asbestos-containing gasket materials? 5 A. I know it has got spaces on there for health, but 6 I have not really read them. I know it is there. 7 Q. You know it is there, but you haven't read them. 8 A. Not really read them, no. 9 Q. Do you remember any mention of protective 10 equipment that should be worn when working with Victor Dana 11 asbestos-containing gasket material? 12 A. (Deponent shook head) 13 Q. You are shaking your head no? 14 A. I am sorry. No. I know we have masks in the 15 chemical area for some of the chemicals and coatings. I 16 would not be the one to ask about all those. I would ask 17 engineering. 18 Q. Let me show you a copy of a document which on its 19 face states that it is a Victor gasket guide for the 50th 20 anniversary from 1909 to 1959. Have you seen this before? 21 A. Yes, sir. It is a copy of the catalog front 22 cover. 23 Q. And this is at least a 1959 publication? 24 A. Yes, sir. 25 Q. And did Victor start making its gaskets as early ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 46 1 as 1909? 2 A. Yes, sir. 3 Q. And Victor was a rather heavy user of asbestos 4 material. was it not? 5 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to the form. 6 BY MR. GLASSER: 7 Q. Was it? 8 A. I don't know. I couldn't classify heavy or light 9 as far as their use. 10 Q. I am turning in this document to page 2. And it 11 talks about Victor, the world's largest manufacturer of 12 gaskets, oil seals and packing. Do you see where I am 13 referring to? 14 A. I see where you are referring to, yes. 15 Q. And it talks about raw materials. 16 A. Yes. 17 Q. And it talks about raw materials that are used 18 annually? Am I correct? 19 A. Yes. 20 Q. And would you read for me the raw material that I 21 have highlighted here on my copy of this document? 22 A. Right here? 23 Q. Yes, ma'am. 24 A. It says 7 million pounds of asbestos millboard. 25 Q. Is that, in your opinion, a substantial amount of iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 annually used asbestos by Victor Corporation? 47 2 A. That's asbestos millboard. That's a combination 3 of components, including asbestos. 4 Q. And asbestos ran approximately 80 percent of the 5 millboard too, didn't it? 6 A. I don't know, sir. On the millboard I don't 7 know. 8 MR. GLASSER: I am going to offer this, please, 9 as Duncan exhibit number 2. 10 And off the record. 11 (Discussion off the record) 12 (Victor 1909 - 1959 50th Anniversary 13 Gaskets - Oilseals, VMG-25-0000150 14 through 157 and VMG-25-0000159 was marked 15 Exhibit No. 2.) 16 BY MR. GLASSER: 17 Q. Mrs. Duncan, how were the Victopac 18 asbestos-containing compressed gasket sheets wrapped when 19 they were being sold in volume? 20 A. If we sell gasket, the Victopac, it can be sold 21 in rolls. Of the paper goods. It can be sold in rolls. It 22 is rolled up and has like a, looks like grocery bag paper, 23 brown paper, with wrapping paper like rolled up around it. 24 Sheets were sold laying flat on a metal, or, I am 25 sorry, a wooden skid. And wrapped like with shrink wrap. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 .v:. ~ -.r,--* .-I-.-.---..----:- -.-'r : 1 You band it to keep them. You don't want them to get 48 2 damaged, because they can't use the whole sheet if anything 3 is damaged. 4 Q. To your knowledge did any of the wrappings or the 5 rolls that you have described ever contained any type of a 6 health warning about the use of those asbestos-containing 7 products? 8 MR. CELBA: I object. Lack of foundation. 9 Go ahead. . 10 A. I am not familiar with warnings on the gasket 11 materials. 12 BY MR. GLASSER: 13 Q. But you never saw one. You never saw a warning 14 on any of the wrappings of any of the Victopac? 15 A. I didn't see any warnings on the wrapping of the 16 Victopac. 17 Q. Or on the product itself? 18 A. I have not seen any warnings on the product. 19 Q. And you have never seen any indication as to how 20 or what precautions should be taken when using the product? 21 A. Please repeat that. 22 Q. You have never seen anything on the wrapping or 23 on the product itself to tell you how, what precautions 24 should be taken when using the product? 25 A. We give instructions on application with gaskets iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 49 1 that are sold to other -- in kits, and things like that. 2 You have instructions on how to install the gaskets. 3 Q. Do you give special instructions for 4 asbestos-containing gasket material as distinguished from 5 non asbestos-containing gasket material? 6 A. I don't know about those. 7 Q. When did you first hear the term mesothelioma? 8 A. Probably five years ago. Four or five years ago. 9 Q. Were you aware of the term asbestosis? 10 A. I heard that term, yes, sir. 11 Q. You mentioned your grandfather and uncles. To 12 your knowledge did any of them -- were any of them ever 13 diagnosed with any asbestos-related disease? 14 A. No, sir. 15 Q. Do you of your own knowledge know from whom \< 16 Victor Dana purchased the asbestos that he used? 17 A. No, sir. 18 Q. Do you know what type of asbestos was used? 19 A. (Deponent shook head.) 20 Q. You are shaking your head no? 21 A. I heard a term called -- 22 Q. Of your own knowledge, do you know what type of 23 asbestos was used in the asbestos-containing products 24 manufactured by Victor Dana? 25 A. No. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 50 1 Q. Do you know how the asbestos was inventoried? 2 A. No. 3 Q. Did you know how much was used? 4 A. No. 5 Q. Who were the buyers of the asbestos that was 6 purchased by the Victor Dana Corporation? 7 A. I don't know. 8 Q. Was Mark Birch a purchaser at the Robinson plant? 9 A. He was up until just recently. I don't know for 10 how long. 11 Q. Do you know whether he would have been the one to 12 have purchased the asbestos that was used by Victor Dana 13 when it was making asbestos-containing gasket material? 14 A. No.I wouldn't know. I don't know. 15 Q. Is he related to Susan Birch? 16 A. I believe she is his sister-in-law. I know she 17 is his sister-in-law. 18 Q. Was Tom Millsinvolved withpurchasing? 19 A. Tom Mills was a purchaser of Caterpillar kit 20 components. I know that. 21 Q. Would he have purchased asbestos-containing 22 materials for use in the Dana Victor asbestos-containing 23 materials? 24 A. I don't know. 25 Q. What about Larry Irvin? :Ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 51 1 A. He is also -- he is a purchaser now. I don't 2 know for how long he has been purchasing. 3 Q. Who would have been purchasing for Robinson in 4 the '70s? 5 A. Jack Cunningham was one of the purchasing people, 6 though I do not know what components he was responsible for 7 purchasing. 8 Q. What about the '60s? 9 A. I don't know how long he was there. I know names 10 of some of the people who were in purchasing when I came to 11 work for Dana in the Robinson plant, but I do not know what 12 they purchased specifically. 13 Q. And when was Robinson built? 14 A. 1965. 15 Q. And where was Victopac manufactured, the 16 asbestos-containing Victopac asbestos sheet gasket material 17 prior to 1965? 18 A. In the Chicago plant. 19 Q. Any other plants in the United States? 20 A. Not that I know of. 21 Q. Who in the Victor Dana organization was 22 responsible for health and safety of employees as it relates 23 to asbestos exposure in the 1940s? 24 A. I don't know. 25 Q. In the 1950s? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 52 1 A. I don't know. 2 Q. In the 1960s? 3 A. I don't know. 4 Q. In the 1970s? 5 A. I don't know. 6 Q. In the 1980s, up until 1988? 7 A. When I came to Victor in 1988, came back to 8 Victor, Tom Staub was the environmental manager person for 9 the division at that time. I don't know how long he had 10 been. 11 Q. Did Victor Dana have an industrial hygiene 12 department, or employ any industrial hygiene firm, to your 13 knowledge? 14 A. I don't know. 15 Q. And that would be true from the '40s, '50s, '60s, 16 ' 70s? 17 A. I don't know. 18 Q. And into the '80s? 19 A. I don't know. 20 Q. Did Victor Dana have a medical department to 21 address any issues relating to asbestos disease that you are 22 aware of? 23 A. I don't know of anything like that. 24 Q. Have you seen any documents while at Victor Dana 25 to confirm that it did testing to determine the release of iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 53 1 asbestos from the cutting or installation or removal of 2 asbestos-containing gaskets? 3 A. I am not familiar with anything like that. 4 Q. And you have neverseen any suchdocumentation? 5 A. No, sir. 6 Q. Do you know whether any oftheVictor Dana 7 asbestos-containing materials have ever been tested to 8 determine how much fiber is released? 9 A. I don't know. 10 Q. Do you know whether dust counts have ever been 11 done at Robinson, 1965 or later, or at Chicago, where the 12 asbestos-containing sheet gasket material was being 13 manufactured? 14 A. I don't know. Those are not my areas of work. 15 Q. Whose area of knowledge and responsibility would 16 that be? 17 A. I would probably talk to Rich Kucharski. He is 18 engineering. That's probably where I would go. 19 Q. Mrs. Duncan, are you aware of any OSHA visits to 20 any of the Dana Victor clients where asbestos-containing 21 materials were being manufactured or used? 22 A. I don't know about any of those things. 23 Q. Are you aware of any OSHA violations -- 24 A. No, sir. 25 Q. -- that have been -- that have resulted from the iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 use of asbestos in any of the Victor Dana plants? 54 2 A. I am not familiar with any OSHA violations at 3 all, because that's not an area that I am familiar with. 4 Q. I have previously asked you when you first became 5 aware of mesothelioma, and I think you answered in the last, 6 maybe in the last five years. When did you first become 7 aware of the term asbestosis? 8 A. Probably about in the last four or five years. 9 It is on TV all the time. 10 Q. Are you aware of any worker's compensation claims 11 having been filed against Victor or Dana, or arising out of 12 claimed asbestos-related disease or injury? 13 A. I am not aware of any, no, sir. 14 Q. Do you know when the first lawsuit was filed 15 against Victor and/or Dana alleging exposure to asbestos? 16 A. No, sir. 17 Q. Are you aware that there areseveral hundred 18 thousand suits that have been filed? 19 A. I have heard such. 20 Q. Have you ever heard of the Wellington Group? 21 A. No. 22 Q. Have you ever heard of the Center for Claims 23 Resolution? 24 A. No. 25 Q. Do you know whether Dana was a member of either iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 of those groups? 55 2 A. No, sir. 3 Q. Did Victor Manufacturing and Gasket Company ever 4 have any contract units to actually install, modify or 5 remove the asbestos-containing gasket materials that it 6 manufactured and sold? 7 A. I don't know. 8 Q. Who was in charge of sales to the United States 9 Government? 10 A. Sales of -- 11 Q. Of asbestos-containing materials to the United 12 States Government? 13 A. Gaskets? 14 Q. Gaskets? 15 A. When? What time period. 16 Q. If you know, in the 1970s? 17 A. It would have been Henry Kerner. 18 Q. And what about the 1960s? 19 A. Henry Kerner was the sales operations 20 believe almost 30 years. 21 Q. And he is deceased? 22 A. Yes, he is. 23 Q. And remind me, when did he pass away? 24 A. Approximately, it was the late 1970s. 25 be. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 Q. And he was replaced by Mr. Abernathy? 56 2 A. Yes, sir. 3 Q. Was Mr. Kerner also in charge of sales to the 4 U.S. Navy? 5 A. He was in charge of the same type of house 6 accounts that I currently am, and those would be considered 7 miscellaneous accounts, so he would have been responsible 8 for those particular sales of gaskets to any of the Navy 9 accounts. 10 Q. From your own personal knowledge, do you know how 11 long Victor Dana has been selling asbestos-containing gasket 12 material to the United States Government? 13 A. I don't know exactly what gaskets were sold to 14 the Navy, asbestos or otherwise, or when they started 15 selling gaskets to the Navy. 16 Q. When was the document repository set up at 17 Cooper & Walinski? 18 A. I believe it was started to be set up probably 19 three or four years ago. I am not sure exactly. I 20 shouldn't say that. I don't know exactly when. 21 Q. Prior to three or four years ago, if you know, 22 was there any central source for documents at Dana Victor? 23 A. At Victor Division the sales records are all 24 generally kept in the Lisle, what was then the division 25 offices, now called the Lisle Technical Center, is where we tond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 57 1 keep all of our sales records. 2 Q. And did the company have a document destruction 3 policy? 4 A. We have one, and have had a document retention 5 and destruction policy for several years. 6 Q. And was that roughly six or seven years, once a 7 document had been retained for that long it was okay to 8 destroy it? 9 A. It depended on the document. They are 10 categorized by sales type documents, purchase orders, or 11 outside supplier purchase orders, invoices. There are 12 personnel records. There are any type of document, company 13 document is listed in those different years. Some are 14 forever, or fifty years past the, fifty years after the 15 death of the last employee is one of them. I don't know 16 what document, but there is some that are ten years and some 17 that are six years. 18 Q. Do you know how long if -- the retention policy 19 that you are talking about, was that put into writing in 20 1996? 21 A. Oh, no. There was one before that. There has 22 been one before that. 23 Q. And was there a document retention policy with 24 regard to sales invoices? 25 A. Yes. Yes. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 Q. And what is it? 58 2 A. I don't know exactly the years on all of them. 3 I'd have to look at the book to do that. 4 Q. And where are those sales invoices that have been 5 retained? 6 A. Some of the invoices -- the invoices are at the 7 plants. It is the plants that actually make the sale of the 8 gasket, and so invoices would have been a plant record, 9 along with shippers, copies of shippers, those types of 10 things. Those are kept at the plants. 11 Q. And are any records retained at Robinson 12 concerning the Victopac asbestos-containing compressed 13 gasket materials that were made there from 1965 forward? 14 A. I don't know what the year span is, but they have 15 the sales invoice records. They have some there for 16 Robinson plant, yes. 17 Q. And were the prior records maintained at the 18 Chicago plant when the Victor product was being manufactured 19 there? 20 A. They would keep, each plant would keep their own 21 plant specific records in the plant, so they would keep 22 invoices at the plants. 23 Q. Have you attempted to look at those records with 24 regard to Victopac asbestos-containing manufacturing records 25 or invoices? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 1 A. I don't -- I didn't look at them, no. 59 2 Q. In your process of offering testimony, you never 3 had occasion to go look at the invoices? 4 A. I have not gone to look at the invoices, no. 5 Q. Am I correct that some of the invoices at Chicago 6 were in fact burned in a fire in the 1990s? 7 A. There were records burned. 8 Q. Do you know how many of them were invoices? 9 A. No, sir. 10 Q. Do you know who would know? 11 A. If anyone would know it would probably be Gary 12 Austin. He was the plant manager of the Chicago plant at 13 that time. 14 Q. Mrs. Duncan, we know now that QPL -- you 15 understand that means qualified products list? 16 A. Yes, sir. 17 Q. Do you know when Victor Dana first sought to have 18 its asbestos-containing compressed gasket material approved 19 on the qualified products list? 20 A. I don't know anything about the approval process. 21 When, dates, no. 22 Q. Do you know who was responsible for obtaining it? 23 A. No. 24 Q. Do you know how many times Victor Dana has 25 renewed its status as an approved listee on the qualified iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 60 1 products list for asbestos-containing compressed sheet 2 gasket material? 3 A. I don't -- no. No. What you are saying, as far 4 as getting approval on the list, I don't know that you -- I 5 am not aware of anyone with within Dana Victor soliciting 6 government to get on the list. I don't know how that is 7 done. 8 Q. You are aware that Victor Dana has requested that 9 its Victopac be approved for government purchases? 10 A. No. 11 Q. You are not aware of that? 12 A. No. 13 Q. All right. 14 A. I don't know how the process is done. 15 Q. Are you aware that it has been done by Dana 16 Victor? 17 A. I don't know what -- I don't know what that 18 process is. 19 Q. But my question is, are you aware that Victor 20 Dana has sought to have its asbestos-containing compressed 21 gasket material approved and placed on the qualified 22 products list? 23 A. No. 24 Q. You are not even aware that it has been done? 25 A. No. I don't know how to explain this. I know iond Tel ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. , England (757) 627-6554 E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, VirginiaFax (757) 625-7077 61 1 that if my, say, for example, Victolex material, Victorite 2 material is on a government print for a gasket. I don't 3 know the process to have gotten it there. I don't know how 4 that is done. 5 Q. Do you know why it is done? 6 A. It is done -- it is a qualified supplier list. 7 It is like, unless they have approved certain suppliers for 8 materials, it is a validation of a material that works for a 9 particular application that they want, I guess. 10 Q. Is it fair to state that your understanding is 11 unless you have sought and received approval on the 12 qualified products list you can't sell the product to the 13 government? 14 A. I know if you are not on the list you can't sell 15 the product to the government. 16 Q. And if you want to sell it to the government 17 you've got to take the initiative to get on the list? 18 A. Somehow you have to get on the list. I don't 19 know how that process is done. I don't know. 20 Q. Are you aware of the various purchasing agencies 21 of the United States Navy? 22 A. No. 23 Q. Do you know what agencies purchase materials for 24 the United States Navy? 25 A. No. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 62 1 Q. Are you familiar with the General Services 2 Administration? 3 A. I've never heard of that one. 4 Q. Are you familiar with the Defense Industrial 5 Supply Center? 6 A. I've heard of Defense Industrial Supply Center, 7 yes. 8 Q. Are you familiar with the Navy Supply Center? 9 A. I haven't heard that one. 10 Q. Are you familiar with the Fleet Industrial Supply 11 Center? 12 A. I don't recall that one. 13 Q. Are you familiar with the Defense Construction 14 Supply Center? 15 A. I've never heard of that. 16 Q. Have you heard of other agencies that do purchase 17 for the Navy? 18 A. I have seen like supply officer, but I don't know 19 the name of the group that they are with. 20 Q. Victor Dana sold to Sears Roebuck, didn't it? Or 21 do you know? 22 A. I don't know. 23 Q. You are not able to state today that all purchase 24 contracts for asbestos-containing compressed asbestos 25 material made by Victor Dana exists today, am I correct? , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 63 1 A. Can you ask me that again. 2 Q. You are not -- can you not state that all 3 purchase contracts exist today that reflect sales by Dana 4 Victor of asbestos-containing compressed gasket material? 5 A. What do you mean purchase contracts? I have 6 got -- 7 Q. Purchase orders. Evidence of sale. You can't 8 say that all that exists today? 9 A. Our manufacturing plants are the keepers of any 10 purchase orders when we process them through my department, 11 and this has been historical. The plants keep the copies of 12 the purchase orders because they are the ones who make the 13 gaskets. They are the ones who sell the gaskets. So they 14 also would keep the copies of the sales invoices. 15 Q. But my question to you, can Marcy Duncan state 16 that every contract for the sale of asbestos-containing 17 gasket material that we have sold at Victor Dana is still 18 available? 19 A. I don't know. 20 Q. You can't state that? 21 A. I can't tell you that, no. 22 Q. When did you first learn of the microfiche 23 records? Was that when the attorneys approached you? 24 A. No. 25 Q. About your testimony? iond Tel ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. , England (757) 627-6554 E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 64 1 A. No, sir. I am the Sales Operations Manager and 2 part of my responsibilities are the maintenance and 3 retention of sales records, and those were sales records in 4 my department when I got the job in 1988. 5 Q. And my question is when did you first learn of 6 those microfiche records? I assume from what you are saying 7 it is sometime after 1988, and I am asking approximately 8 when? 9 A. I am sorry. May of 1988 when I became the sales 10 operations manager I was given all the records that I would 11 be responsible for, and those were part of them, the 12 microfiche records. 13 Q. And that was the first time that you were aware 14 of -- 15 A. Yes, sir. 16 Q. Can you tell me today from your own knowledge as 17 to what dates the microfiche records cover? 18 A. I can't tell you the dates that they cover 19 beginning -- I have to go through every single microfiche 20 record. But the records that I have looked at, I have seen 21 some that date back into the 1930s. And the microfiche was, 22 were created in 1988. I have the date written somewhere. 23 But, it was in the, I believe it was, 1988. It is when they 24 were created off the original sales records. 25 Q. When the microfiche was done, when the film was iond Tel ' , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 65 1 done -- 2 A. Yes, sir. 3 Q. -- was it done under your direction? 4 A. No, sir. 5 Q. I take it, but I want the record to be clear, of 6 all the writing that appears on the roughly 69,000 cards, 7 none of that writing is you? 8 A. That is correct. 9 Q. And you played no role whatsoever in creating the 10 cards that ultimately were microfiched? 11 A. That is correct. 12 Q. And you have no means of determining how complete 13 or incomplete those records were in 1998 when they were 14 microfiched? 15 A. Those records were the manual record keeping 16 system used in the course of business for the Victor 17 Manufacturing Gasket Company, and subsequently Victor Dana, 18 and when it became Victor Dana, that was their method of 19 recording quotations and sales, so they would be as complete 20 as anything that I would ever know about. 21 Q. But my question is, you can't state how complete 22 or how incomplete they are? 23 MR. CELBA: I object to the form of the 24 question. It has been asked and answered. 25 MR. GLASSER: Your objection is noted. I would iond Tel ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. , England (757) 627-6554 E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 66 1 like an answer to my question. 2 BY MR. GLASSER: 3 Q. They were just presented, and you are saying 4 that's what I got, and I can't tell you how complete or 5 incomplete they are? 6 A. It is a complete record of all the sales records 7 that were generated. 8 Q. That existed. Not generated. Not generated. 9 That were existing. Am I correct? 10 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. It has been 11 asked and answered and you are being argumentative with the 12 witness now. 13 MR. GLASSER: You can note the objection. I want 14 an answer to my question. 15 BY MR. GLASSER: 16 Q. The microfiche was done of the records that 17 existed in 1998, correct? 18 A. Yes, it was a compilation of sales records used 19 in the normal course of business for many, many, many years. 20 I can't tell you the exact beginning. I can only tell you 21 some of the dates. 22 Q. You can't tell the beginning, when it started, 23 and you can't tell whether it is complete or not with regard 24 to sales that were actually made, from your own personal 25 knowledge? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 67 1 A. If you are asking me if there is a card missing, 2 I could not tell you if there was, or was not. 3 Q. And you can't say whether there is a card 4 missing, or a thousand cards missing? 5 A. I would certainly hope there are not a thousand 6 cards missing in our business records, sir. 7 Q. But you can't testify that there are not. You 8 can only hope that there are not. 9 MR. CELBA: Again, argumentative. Asked and 10 answered. I object. 11 A. These are records that we have and it is as 12 complete as anything that I know of. If you are asking me, 13 do I know that every single one of them exists, I cannot 14 tell you that. 15 BY MR. GLASSER: 16 Q. Do you know how many different people made 17 entries on the cards that are a part of the microfiche? 18 A. No. 19 Q. Do you know the names of any of the people who 20 did? 21 A. Oh, yes. 22 Q. What portion of the cards have youlooked at, all 23 69,000? 24 A. No. 25 Q. What portion of the onesthat you have looked at iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 68 1 are illegible? 2 A. I am sorry. We have to go back over that number 3 of 69,000. That is a number of records that I believe you 4 got from the last, the case last year. Those are records -- 5 that's a number of records that, specific sales line records 6 that I reviewed for a previous case. There are not 69,600 7 records. There are 900,000 records of sales history. There 8 are 103 microfiche cards. Each of the cards contain 624 9 sales cards, of which each of those contain 15 lines of 10 sales history. 11 Q. And -- 12 A. I have personally looked at, at least for that 13 case last year, 69,600 lines of records. That's where that 14 number is coming from. 15 Q. You looked at 69,000 lines of roughly 900,000 16 lines? 17 A. Over 900,000 lines. I looked at lots more, but 18 that was the figure specific to a specific case. 19 Q. In that instance you looked at substantially less 20 than 10 percent of all there was on microfiche? 21 A. I reviewed all raw material records and they 22 consisted of 69,600 lines of sales records. That was a 23 specific area that I was asked to look at. And those were 24 the only records for those. 25 Q. The only records that you know of that exist for iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 69 1 those, would that be a correct restatement? 2 A. Those are the historical sales records for the 3 raw materials that we have. 4 Q. That exist? 5 A. For sales and quotation history. 6 Q. That exist, and existed in 1988? 7 A. Yes. 8 Q. Am I correct that in order for Victor Dana to 9 make a sale there was no requirement in order to complete 10 the sale that a notation be made on the line of the index 11 card; is that correct? 12 A. If you made a sale, you didn't. 13 Q. If a sale was made by one of the people who had 14 entered on the cards, and they forgot to put it on the 15 cards, that didn't mean the sale didn't go through, it was 16 intended to be a handwritten record of sales, am I correct? 17 MR. CELBA: I object. That's a compound 18 question now. 19 But answer it the best that you can. 20 A. The sales card records that are microfiched are a 21 compilation of quotations, handwritten lines, whenever 22 quotation was issued to a customer, and they are also 23 records of purchase orders received from customers for a 24 subsequent sale. These are orders recorded from a customer 25 that they expected us to deliver the product to them from. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 70 1 It is not the shipping record. 2 BY MR. GLASSER: 3 Q. And in fact it doesn't show where the product was 4 shipped? 5 A. Some of the records list the name of the company 6 and the city and state address of the customer. Some of 7 them only list the name of the company or the entity. 8 Q. And my question again, it doesn't show where the 9 products were shipped? 10 A. I understand your question. It shows who ordered 11 the product. 12 Q. But that's not my question. My question is, does 13 it show where the products were shipped. Yes or no? 14 A. The assumption is that the entity who ordered it 15 is who we shipped it to. But that is an understood in the 16 course of business it does not specifically state where the 17 product was shipped to. 18 Q. And so if it shows U.S. Navy, you don't know, and 19 the records can't tell where it was shipped to? 20 A. The sales cards list U.S. Navy. It does not list 21 anything other than the name U.S. Navy. Where it was 22 shipped would not be on that record anywhere. 23 Q. And you wouldn't know? 24 A. From looking at that record I would not know. 25 Q. Nor would you know when that product was used? iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 71 1 Correct? 2 A. You do not know exactly when a product is used. 3 You are assuming that it will be used within an expected 4 shelf life period of the purchase. 5 Q. What is the shelf life for asbestos-containing 6 compressed gasket sheeting? 7 A. It would depend on the manner in which it is 8 stored and kept. Atmospheric conditions. If it is near 9 salt water, if it is in air conditioning, climate 10 controlled. 11 Q. It can last a long time though? 12 A. As a general rule we say around five years in 13 optimum conditions. 14 Q. And to repeat my question, you don't know when 15 the products that you shipped were used? 16 A. A specific date, no. 17 Q. And you don't know where they were used? 18 A. The normal business assumption is that they are 19 used at the entity where you ship the product. . 20 Q. My question is, Mrs. Duncan, is you from your own 21 knowledge don't know where the products that were shipped 22 were used? Correct? 23 Correct or incorrect? 24 A. Well, sometimes. 25 Q. What was my question? iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 72 1 A. I am sorry? 2 Q. What was myquestion? 3 MR. CELBA: Now you are getting argumentative. 4 Repeat the question back, or read it back. 5 MR. GLASSER: I ask the court reporter to read it 6 back. All I ask that I get an answer to my question. 7 (The pending question was read by the court 8 reporter.) 9 A. I did not see where the product was used, no 10 BY MR. GLASSER: 11 Q. And you didn't see who used it? 12 A. No. 13 Q. And you don't know around whom it was used? Yes 14 or no? 15 A. You assume that the people ordering the product 16 are using the product, but, no, I did not physically see who 17 was using the product. 18 Q. And you don't know how long it was used? 19 A. Correct. I do not know how long what was used? 20 Q. You don't know how long the product sold by 21 Victor Dana, the asbestos-containing compressed gasket 22 material, was used? 23 A. I am getting lost. 24 Q. I don't mean to get you lost. When you come in 25 here, someone brought you records in 1988 and microfiched iOnd i, England Tel (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 73 1 them, and you don't know where those products were shipped? 2 When they were shipped. Where they were used. How they 3 were used. How long they were left where they were used. 4 When they were removed. Whether they were ever altered, you 5 don't know any of that information. Am I correct? 6 MR. CELBA: I object. Asked and answered. 7 Compound question. 8 Go ahead. 9 BY MR. GLASSER: 10 Q. Do you understand my question? I am asking it in 11 this fashion to orient you. I would prefer it to have the 12 individual questions that I have asked, but you are saying 13 that you are confused. I don't want you to be confused. 14 You are under oath and I want to know exactly what you can 15 personally and truthfully testify to, and what you have to 16 say, I don't know. That's a fair answer if in fact you 17 don't know. 18 And you don't know when it was used, or how long 19 it was used; do you? 20 MR. CELBA: Same objection. 21 A. I do not know. 22 BY MR. GLASSER: 23 Q. To make sure that I'm clear, Mrs. Duncan, if some 24 of the records that are referred to on the lines of the 25 cards that were microfiched go back to the 1930s, and this iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 74 1 microfiche process was not done until 1988, some of those 2 entries would have been more than 50 years old when the 3 microfiche was done; is that correct? 4 A. Yes, sir. 5 Q. And a number of them would have been done before 6 you were born? 7 A. Yes, sir. 8 Q. And the cards thatweremicrofiched are not 9 sequentially numbered, are they? 10 A. They are numbered by part number, gasket part 11 number. We have part numbers for all the gaskets, and they 12 are in sequence of the gasket number, in consecutive 13 sequence number. 14 Q. All of the cards did not come out of one pile, 15 the first one being numbered 1, the second being numbered 2, 16 the third one being number 3, and so on? 17 A. No, sir. Thecardsthemselves do not have a 18 specific record number for the blank card. 19 Q. Now, did I understand you to say that the 20 purchase orders, the invoices, would have been created and 21 issued at the plant of manufacture? 22 Can I help? 23 A. Which purchase orders? 24 Q. When Robinson, when the Robinson plant was making 25 Victopac in 1965 and forward, the invoices reflecting sales iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 75 1 of asbestos-containing Victopac would have been generated at 2 Robinson and kept at Robinson. Is that correct? 3 A. I am confused. In this question here, you first 4 were asking me, started asking me about purchase orders. I 5 thought that you might be talking about the plants buying 6 supplies. And then you asked me about invoices. 7 Q. Let me try to clarify. 8 When asbestos-containing compressed gasket 9 material was made at Chicago, or Robinson, and there was a 10 purchase of that material, the plant that made it would be 11 the plant that created the paperwork concerning that sale? 12 A. The shipper and the invoices, yes. The plant 13 that manufactured the goods and shipped the goods would 14 create the invoice to the customer and the shipper that 15 would accompany the product. 16 Q. Am I correct that sales and quotation records 17 were done at division headquarters and not at the individual 18 plants? 19 A. That is correct. The division headquarters was 20 in the Chicago plant up until 1978. 21 Q. So from '65 to '78 if someone ordered Victopac 22 from Robinson, the sales and quotation records would be kept 23 at Chicago? 24 A. Up until 1978 they were at the Chicago plant. 25 Q. And the purchase and the information and the iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 76 1 shipping information would have been maintained at the 2 Robinson plant? 3 A. The shipper and the invoice for the product 4 shipped would be retained at the Robinson plant. 5 Q. And the people who would be involved in the sales 6 and quotations? 7 A. Can you go back for a minute? 8 Q. Yes. 9 A. I might have misstated. Did you ask me if the 10 purchase order -- the quotation and purchase order were 11 maintained at division? The customers' purchase order. 12 Q. The sales information and the quotation were 13 maintained at the headquarters, but the specific 14 documentation relating to a sale would stay with the plant 15 of manufacture, is that correct? 16 A. The quotation and the recorded written record of 17 the receipt of the customer's purchase order was maintained 18 at the division level. The actual hard copy of the 19 customer's purchase order, along with the shipper for the 20 product, and the invoice for the goods shipped, were all 21 maintained at the manufacturing plant. 22 Q. Have you attempted to review the records at 23 Chicago and Robinson concerning the sale of 24 asbestos-containing gasket materials? Yes or no? 25 A. Any record -- iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 77 1 Q. All the records? 2 A. -- at the plant, I don't look at records at the 3 plants. 4 Q. Help me to understand the corporate history of 5 the use of commuters at Victor Dana. Am I correct that 6 prior to 1971 or 1972 there were no computers? 7 A. No, that's not correct. The Robinson facility 8 had a computer service that was local prior to that time. 9 Q. And what did that computer service do? What type 10 of documents, data base records were involved? If you know? 11 A. I don't know. 12 Q. Am I correct that in 1971 or 1972 that Dana 13 Victor converted from more or less manual record keeping to 14 a computer? 15 A. At the oil seal plant in Churubusco, and at the 16 Chicago plant, the transition from manual record keeping in 17 production inventory sales started in 1971 and 1972. 18 Q. And the sales records for 1972 to 1980 are in a 19 raw data form. Is that correct? 20 A. Say that again. 21 Q. The sales records from 1972 to 1980 are in a raw 22 data form? 23 A. The gasket sales records for that period, I 24 believe up to 1980 -- maybe a little later than that even, 25 are on what is called our base. It is raw computer data. .ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 78 1 Q. All right. And they are not readable by lay 2 people? 3 A. Correct. 4 Q. And if you wanted to review that information you 5 would have to program a format to get back into that 6 information? 7 A. Our base is a software package that I don't even 8 know if it exists any more as a usable tool, current tool. 9 It is, in 1989, when we went to the current computer system 10 that we have right now, all of those previous records that 11 were on computer from the '71, '72 period up to then were 12 put on this, our base, data base for historical purposes and 13 interchange purposes. And as time passed we did not need to 14 use those records as much and so they were never converted 15 to anything that's current. 16 Q. And now the data base on which that information 17 is obsolete and is not, you are not able to access it by the 18 computers, by the subsequent computer program? 19 A. That is correct. 20 Q. And so the information from '72 to '80 is no 21 longer the subject of any current computer program that 22 works? 23 You are shaking your head yes. 24 A. I am kind of half thinking. We cannot currently 25 access that information on anything we have right now. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 79 1 Q. You are unable to look at the records from 1972 2 to roughly 1980? 3 A. You can look at them, but you can't read them. 4 They are like -- I don't know what it is called in computer 5 language, but it is the symbols, binary stuff. 6 Q. You can't read them in a meaningful fashion? 7 A. Correct. 8 Q. Now am I correct that you don't know if Victor 9 Dana maintained invoices from the 1947 to 1967 period? 10 A. I don't know -- you mean right now do we have 11 this? 12 Q. Do you have them now, invoices from the 1947 to 13 '67 time frame. Do you know? 14 A. I don't know what is available with invoices. 15 Q. Am I correct that you may not be able to research 16 the sale of gaskets even by part number prior to 1988, due 17 to the computer problems, the computers speaking to one 18 another and the problems that you have with the incompatible 19 databases? 20 A. The information from the 1971, 1972 time period 21 up to 1988, basically, the sales records and quotation 22 records that are the R base files, they are there, they 23 would have to be, and I don't even know what would be 24 required to program and format that so it would be legible. 25 But the records exist. But I can't go to them today and iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 80 1 look at it and give you information from it. It would have 2 to, computer programming people would have to take the 3 information, and my computer today cannot read it. 4 Q. No one has requested you to look at it, am I 5 correct. No one connected to Dana? 6 A. They can't ask me to look at it. I can't look at 7 it. I am not a programmer to be able to put it in a 8 layman's legible format. 9 Q. Going back to Cooper & Walinski, I understand 10 from what you said that that repository was set up four or 11 five years ago? 12 A. I am not sure when it was started. I was made 13 aware of it then might be better. 14 Q. Thank you. Do you know when it was set up? 15 A. No. 16 Q. Do you know who set itup? 17 A. I don't know who set it up. I know I have 18 contributed a lot of data to it. 19 Q. Do you know who initially requested it? 20 A. No. 21 Q. Do you know what it was for? 22 A. It is records that might be used for, might be 23 called upon for use in asbestos litigation. 24 Q. Is this the first time, to your knowledge, that 25 there has been a document repository for purposes of iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 81 1 asbestos litigation at Victor Dana? 2 A. At Dana. On Dana's behalf. Yes. 3 Q. And I have asked the question before, but let me 4 make sure that I am clear on your answer. 5 It is possible to have a sale of gasket material 6 without their being a card line entry completed that would 7 now appear on the microfiche. Let me state that better. 8 Even when the cards were being used, you could 9 complete a sale, Victor Dana could complete a sale whether 10 or not it put the notation on the cards that were eventually 11 microfiched; isn't that true? 12 A. All I can tell you is that the record keeping was 13 the way of the normal business. That's our job now, and 14 people in the past, to record the daily business records. 15 And that's what we were supposed to do. That's what people 16 were to do before. So that it is part of our job to do 17 that. I can't tell you if there is information, all the 18 information was to be put on cards. 19 Q. Should have been. You can't say that it was? 20 MR. CELBA: I object to the calls for 21 speculation. 22 MR. GLASSER: That's exactly my point. You can't 23 speculate and say it was always done. All you can say is 24 that it should have been done. 25 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 /. . . .. 82 1 Argumentative. 2 BY MR. GLASSER: 3 Q. Am I correct? 4 Yes or no. 5 A. It is our job to do that. 6 Q. Do you recall my question? 7 A. I cannot tell you if somebody never did it. I am 8 screwing my answer up. 9 All I can tell you is that that's what we were 10 expected to do for our job. I can't tell you if a person 11 did or did not do their job. 12 Q. The cards that ended up on the microfiche were 13 not the actual order form and they were not the invoice, 14 were they? 15 Yes or no. 16 A. They are a record of quotations delivered and 17 orders received from customers, not the invoices. Invoices 18 were not on the sales cards. I mean a record of an invoice 19 is not on the sales card. 20 Q. The records that were shown on the cards that 21 were microfiched in 1988 identify certain products by code; 22 am I correct? 23 A. They are part numbers. Or it specifically says 24 what the product is. Like on the raw materials, at that 25 time they didn't have a part number. It said, Victopac 1. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 83 1 It actually gave the name of the product. Everything else 2 is by Victor internal part number. Gasket number. 3 Q. Are there any existing records today to fully 4 explain the codes that were used? Yes or no? 5 A. The part number system that's used to record the 6 gaskets, there is a written, I guess template. I use 7 template for lack of a better word. There is a scheme to 8 tell you what the numbers mean and how to assign part 9 numbers. 10 Q. Do you have a copy of that? 11 A. In my office. I don't have one with me. But, 12 yes, I do have a copy of that. 13 Q. Can you make that available to Mr. Celba? 14 A. Yes, I can. 15 Q. And would you make it available to us, please? 16 MR. CELBA: We will review the request and get 17 back to you immediately on it. 18 BY MR. GLASSER: 19 Q. Mrs. Duncan, you don't know whether the codes 20 that identify parts changed, or how much they changed 21 between the 1930s and the 1980s, do you? 22 A. Of course I do. They are part numbers. They are 23 each, when a gasket is made for a specific application, it 24 has a print, it is identified. It has an identification. 25 Like a tag. That is a part number. That's an internal part iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 84 1 number that is assigned based on a specific criteria set up 2 by Victor when they started making gaskets. 3 It exists today. It is the same system I use 4 today for a brand new vehicle, for a brand new gasket we 5 will go to this numbering system and choose a number based 6 on the type of gasket that is. 7 Q. Please listen closely to my question. 8 A. I am sorry. 9 Q. I appreciate your words, but my question was, has 10 the code changed from the 1930s to the 1980s for a given 11 part? 12 You don't know, do you? 13 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. 14 But go ahead. 'mzs) 15 A. You are using the cord code. It is not a code. 16 BY MR. GLASSER: 17 Q. Has the part number changed? If a product has 18 been made from the 1930s to the 1980s you don't know whether 19 that part number was ever changed during those intervening 20 50 years, do you? 21 A. For this, for a particular gasket, for one 22 particular gasket, and I am talking indicative of all the 23 gaskets that I want to pick one. It has a part number. It 24 was created for a 1930 engine. And we started making the 25 gasket and gave it a number. If I am still making that iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 85 1 gasket today, the materials may have changed, but the part 2 number has not. 3 Q. When did Victor Dana start making the compressed 4 asbestos-containing sheet, raw material for gaskets? 5 A. I don't know. 6 Q. Was it making it in the '30s? 7 MR. CELBA: Object to that. That has been asked 8 and answered. 9 BY MR. GLASSER: 10 Q. You don't know? 11 A. I don't know when theystarted making it. 12 Q. You don't know of anyone who can truthfully 13 testify that the microfiche records going back to the 1930s 14 is a complete set of every sale and quotation record? 15 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. It has been 16 asked and answered. It is argumentative and calls for 17 speculation. Vague and ambiguous. 18 But go ahead. 19 BY MR. GLASSER: 20 Q. Do you know of anyone who can say that the 21 microfiche records are complete for every sale and quotation 22 given since the 1930s? 23 A. I can't name anyone that can tell you that we 24 don't have everything that we kept over the years in the 25 microfiche. I don't know if all the records are not there. .ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 86 1 Q. My question is, do you know of anyone at Victor 2 Dana who can testify that they are all there? Yes or no. 3 MR. CEL A: B Same objection. 4 A. I am no different than anyone else. I can tell 5 you I don't know if anything is not there. I can't tell you 6 if everything is there, or is not there. 7 Y ML. GLASSER: 8 Q. And you don't know of anyone who can tell 9 definitively yes, it is all there. No, this portion is 10 missing. 11 MR. CEL A: B Same objection. 12 A. I can't give you the name of anyone that could 13 give you any other different answer than I have just given 14 you. I know of no person. 15 Y MR. GLASSER: 16 Q. Is there a complete customer list that exists 17 today for the purchasers since the 1940s of the Dana Victor 18 asbestos-containing gasket materials? 19 A. We have a complete compiled customer list right 20 here. I brought one of them. 21 Q. And how large is that list? 22 A. It is 177 pages of customer record, addresses, on 23 computer paper. 24 Q. And when was that generated? 25 A. This list was compiled in 1988. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 87 1 Q. Was it compiled under your supervision? 2 A. This record was compiled under my supervision, 3 yes. 4 Q. And was the record accurate as of 1988? 5 A. It was a complete compilation of all of the 6 records up to 1988. 7 Q. And compilation starting when? How far back does 8 it relate. If you know? 9 A. I don't know exactly. 10 Q. And how was it compiled? 11 A. This particular record was printed off of our 12 existing computer system at that time. 1988. 13 Q. And do you of your own personal knowledge know 14 how the information that was on the existing computer system 15 in 1988 got there? What it represented? 16 A. Yes. 17 Q. And what was that information? 18 A. It represented the history, historical customers 19 and current customers of the Victor Manufacturing and Gasket 20 Company and subsequently the Victor Products Division of 21 Dana. 22 Q. And did it name, for example, the U.S. Navy? 23 A. There are listings for the U.S. Navy, yes. 24 Q. You say listing. Is there more than one? 25 A. Yes. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 88 1 Q. And is it your testimony that if any agency or 2 any entity of the United States Navy purchased it would be 3 on that list? 4 A. If any -- what do you call group? 5 Q. Agency? 6 A. Group, agency of the U.S. Navy requested a 7 quotation and purchased product, it would be on this list. 8 Q. They would all be listed? 9 A. They would all be listed. 10 Q. I asked you earlier whether Sears Roebuck was a 11 customer. 12 A. Yes. 13 Q. Can you determine if they were? 14 A. If they were a direct customer of Victor they 15 should be listed in this book. 16 I don't show them as a direct customer of the 17 Victor Gasket Division in this book. 18 MR. GLASSER: We would like to get a copy of this 19 book. 20 MR. CELBA: Richard, I don't know the 21 proprietary thing about this. We are talking customer list, 22 but we can work that out, I am sure. 23 MR. GLASSER: Well, time is of the essence. And 24 if the proprietary thing is a concern to you, I am happy to 25 clear it with the court. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 89 1 MR. CELBA: I haven't discussed it with someone 2 who has this. We haven't discussed that with Marcy. Like 3 everything else, we will immediately get back to you on 4 this. Okay. 5 MR. GLASSER: Just because of the time. This is, 6 Friday. 7 MR. CELBA: Righ . 8 MR. GLASSER: Close to noon. And we have a 9 trial that starts Monday. What does immediate mean? 10 MR. CELBA: It means that I can make a call at a 11 break. Okay? 12 MR. GLASSER: Okay. 13 A. May I clarify something about this list. 14 BY MR. GLASSER: 15 layQ. You may always clarify things. I want you to 16 clarify everything so that when we read this record we know 17 what your fullest, most truthful understanding is to every 18 question I asked. So I thank you. What do you want to 19 clarify? 20 A. This is a customer master list. And this would 21 reflect people that we quoted to and had subsequent sales 22 to. If I quoted someone and didn't have a sale to them, 23 they wouldn't be in here, necessarily, at all. Okay? 24 Q. Thank you. 25 Mrs. Duncan, we talked about 1955 and whether you iond Tel i, England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 90 1 could tell me what the gross sales for that year were. 2 Either measured in terms of gasket sheets, or dollars, for 3 sale. And my understanding is that it can't be done. Is 4 that correct? 5 MR. CELBA: I don't think -- she did not have 6 knowledge. 7 BY MR. GLASSER: 8 Q. You don't know how that can be done? 9 MR. CELBA: I don't think that was the question. 10 I object. 11 BY MR. GLASSER: 12 Q. Do you know whether it can bedone? 13 A. I don't know if it can bedone. I don't know 14 what the sales were at that year. 15 Q. Do you know whether or not Victor Dana has 16 attempted to reconstruct what its sales were for any year in 17 the 1950s? . 18 A. I don't know that, no. 19 Q. And is the same true for the 1960s and the 1970s? 20 A. I don't know of any reconstruction of sales 21 records that do not exist. 22 Q. Back in those -- 23 A. Back for those dates. 24 Q. Tell me what you are saying here. Have they 25 attempted to reconstruct their sales for any given year of iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 91 1 asbestos-containing compressed gasket material? 2 A. I don't know. 3 Q. Who should I address that question to? 4 MR. CELBA: If you don't know -- 5 A. I don't know. I don't know. 6 BY MR. GLASSER: 7 Q. Are you aware of anything that Victor Dana has 8 done to request or hire anyone to independently validate the 9 completeness of the microfiche records? 10 A. I don't -- that's not ever been done to my 11 knowledge. I don't know how in the world it ever could be 12 done. 13 Q. When you initially briefly testified here in 14 February 2003 in Virginia, did I understand that you had 15 personally reviewed 69,000 of the line entries on the 16 microfiche cards? 17 A. Yes, sir, I did. 18 Q. And you did that yourself? 19 A. Yes, I did. 20 Q. Can you tell me approximately what percentage of 21 them were illegible, unreadable? 22 A. With the naked eye, on the microfiche reader, 23 very little is illegible with -- let me explain. 24 The microfiche reader you can hold a little 25 magnifying thing up to and it obviously magnifies what is on iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 92 1 there. If you are familiar with, and I have the knowledge 2 of a lot of the information that's on there, and if you can 3 read part of a customer name, you know who the customer is. 4 So sometimes though only a portion of it may be legible you 5 can figure it out. So I would have to say that there is 6 very little of the records on the microfiche that are 7 impossible to make out or read. 8 Q. Did I understand when you testified here before 9 that you found no records of sales to the Norfolk Naval 10 Shipyard? 11 A. I found no raw material sales to the Norfolk 12 Naval Shipyard during my research of the raw material 13 records for that specific instance, that is correct. 14 Q. I am going to show you an exhibit and ask you, 15 can you identify what this is? 16 A. This is a copy of a sales card that was 17 microfiched. 18 MR. CELBA: Excuse me. Should we mark this 19 Richard, right now. 20 MR. GLASSER: We can. 21 MR. CELBA: Let's mark it now. 22 (Quotation and Selling Record, Victor 23 No. 1861, was marked Exhibit No. 3.) 24 MR. GLASSER: We were off the record just for an 25 instant and we marked this as exhibit number 3. iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 93 1 BY MR. GLASSER: 2 Q. And you have identified this as a quotation and 3 sales record? 4 A. This looks like a copy of one of the sales cards 5 that was put on microfiche, and it is for a cylinder head 6 gasket. 1861 is the part number. And it lists 15 lines of 7 quote and purchase order, customer, purchase order records, 8 listing about, looks like three different, three or four 9 different customers. It lists actually eight actual 10 purchase orders. 11 Q. And the first one is identified as what customer? 12 A. It says, U.S. Navy, Norfolk Navy Yard, 13 Portsmouth, Virginia. 14 Q. And what is second one? 15 A. U.S. Naval Supply Depot. 16 Q. And where is that U.S. Naval Supply Depot? 17 A. It does not list the location. 18 Q. Where is the location of customer in lines 3, 4 19 and 5. Do you know? They are also U.S. Navy Supply Depot? 20 A. No. 21 Q. Do you know whether they are the same depot, or 22 different depots? 23 MR. CELBA: Wait a second. Could you read that. 24 I think we have the question here, but I am confused. 25 Richard, I am sorry to interrupt. Can you just iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 "~ 94 1 ask that question again. 2 BY MR. GLASSER: 3 Q. I understood your testimony to be that the 4 listing of the U.S. Naval Supply Depot in line 2, you don't 5 know where that depot is located? 6 A. I do not. 7 Q. And the same would be true, would it not, for the 8 next three entries? 9 A. That is correct. It appears to be the same. 10 They were quotations issued, and with the use of ditto marks 11 it is apparently the same facility. Where, it does not 12 list. 13 Q. They may not have been the same U.S. Naval Supply 14 Depot? 15 A. They may not have been the same. 16 Q. And then the next entry is the U.S. Navy? 17 A. It is U.S. Navy. 18 Q. And you don't know where that was shipped? 19 A. No, sir, I don't. 20 Q. And no way of telling? 21 A. Not without the original purchase order that's 22 listed on the far right corner. 23 Q. And would you have that purchase order? 24 A. I would not have that, no. That would not be at 25 the Lisle office. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 95 1 Q. So there is no way the determine where that was 2 shipped? 3 A. I cannot tell by looking at this record the 4 location, no. 5 Q. And if you skip down one, it says, U.S. Naval 6 Supply. Do you see that? 7 A. Yes, I do. 8 Q. Do you know the location of that? 9 A. No, I don't. Not for that line. A few down it 10 says Norfolk, with ditto marks. 11 Q. And that says U.S. Naval Supply, Norfolk, and 12 that's on the third line from the bottom? 13 A. Yes, correct. 14 Q. And the fourth line from the bottom says U.S. 15 Naval Supply Shipyard. You don't know where that was 16 shipped either, do you? 17 A. No. 18 Q. And the last line on this, U.S. Naval Supply 19 Depot. You don't know where that was shipped either? 20 A. No. I could look this up in my customer master 21 book to see what possible locations it could have been 22 shipped to. 23 Q. Why don't you look up U.S. Naval Supply Depot and 24 see how many customers appear on your list of that. 25 A. You have to bear with me because I have to go ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 96 1 through all the Us because they are not necessarily listed 2 in real alphabetical. 3 Q. We are happy to bear with you, and my record 4 reflects that it is between 12:05 and 12:06. You take your 5 time. 6 A. You have to be creative sometimes. 7 Q. Why do you say that? 8 A. Because many people created these records, and it 9 may start out with Norfolk Naval Shipyards. Or just Navy. 10 I have Navy Public Works Center, San Diego, California. 11 National City, California. 12 Q. Now you are turning to another document, and it 13 is about 11 minutes after 12? 14 A. I apologize. 15 Q. Tell me what you are looking at now? 16 A. These are copies of pages of this. And these, we 17 printed them out in multiple sequences when we printed them 18 out. And I have several of them. Some of them are in 19 customer code number identified here. Some of them are done 20 in alphabetical sequence. And the one that I brought about 21 may not have been the one I wanted to bring. But these are 22 the -- these are information off the same stuff. 23 Q. The one that you brought may not have? 24 A. Customer master. 25 Q. Is there more than one customer? Is there more iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 97 r than one master customer list? 2 A. This is the identical information arranged in 3 multiple listings. Some of them are pure alphabetical. But 4 it is the exact same information. Just arranged 5 differently. 6 Q. Who asked you to bring this exhibit? 7 A. Tom Radcliffe asked me to bring one of the 8 customer lists, and I just grabbed one of them. 9 MR. GLASSER: Don't you think -- Steve, don't 10 you think if he wanted her to bring it, he wanted her to 11 bring it for me? 12 MR. CELBA: I don't know, Richard. I don't 13 know. He may have just wanted an example of the customer 14 list. I don't know. 15 What is this document? Maybe you ought to 16 identify that too. 17 A. This is copies from customers from this same 18 master batch listing that I used last year. That has got -- 19 let me find them for you. And I don't mean to waste your 20 time. I am very, very sorry. 21 MR. CELBA: He is trying to understand, Marcy, 22 and we are all trying to understand what that list is. If 23 you have another one, or it is the wrong one, tell us so you 24 don't waste our time. 25 A. That's what I was looking for. I didn't look at iOnd Tel ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. , England (757) 627-6554 E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 98 1 it very good before I brought it. I apologize for that. He 2 just asked me to bring one of the customer listings. There 3 is one in different sequence by their code number, and 4 that's why I am not able to find them in the alphabetical 5 sequence that I am trying to find them in. 6 BY MR. GLASSER: 7 Q. How many customer lists are there? 8 A. The exact same information is on five different 9 arrangements. But it is the exact same customers arranged 10 just in five different manners. It is the same information, 11 but it is not all like this one. I should have brought the 12 one that was in purely alphabetical sequence, and I would 13 have been able to find the ones we are talking about very 14 easily. 15 Q. Do you know what you are looking for? 16 A. Yes. 17 Q. If you will continue to please look. It is now 18 12:13. 19 A. I am very sorry. This is my fault. I should 20 have brought the pure alphabetical one. 21 I am very sorry. I am having to go through every 22 one of these, and I don't want to waste your time. I can 23 provide you with a list in alphabetical sequence. I don't 24 have that one with me. I apologize. I don't want to waste 25 your time. I'm sorry. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 99 1 Q. I thank you for your efforts. It is 12:16 2 according to my watch and I am -- 3 A. I will have to go through every record to find 4 the information. It is not in alphabetical sequence I 5 thought I brought. I am very sorry. 6 MR. GLASSER: Give us just a moment. 7 MR. CELBA: Sure. 8 (Recess) 9 MR. GLASSER: Okay. We are back in and it is 10 12:18, and we are back on the record. 11 BY MR. GLASSER: 12 Q. Mrs. Duncan, if an entry is made on the quotation 13 and selling record -- and I am now going to pass you and 14 counsel another sheet. 15 MR. GLASSER: I ask the court reporter please to 16 mark this as Duncan exhibit number 4. 17 (Quotation and Selling Record, Victor 18 No. 34305, was marked Exhibit No. 4.) 19 BY MR. GLASSER: 20 Q. Do I understand you to say that if there is an 21 entry U.S. Navy Portsmouth, which is seen prominently on 22 five lines of Duncan exhibit number 4, that some place in 23 the master customer list there should be a U.S. Navy 24 Portsmouth? 25 A. Yes. ,ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 100 1 Q. And, in fact, every other reference that we are 2 attempting to read off of these sheets, whether it be U.S. 3 Naval Supply Depot, or U.S. Naval Supply, or U.S. Naval 4 Supply Shipyard, or U.S. Naval Supply Norfolk, each of those 5 should appear on the master customer list? 6 A. They should appear on the master customer list. 7 Q. What is product number 34305 as shown in the top 8 right-hand corner of Duncan exhibit 4? 9 A. That particular part would be a valve cover 10 gasket. 11 Q. And the first entry there a shows a sale to -- 12 how do you read that? 13 A. Buda Company. 14 Q. And what are the spec and remarks? What is the 15 language. Can you read that to me? 16 A. Quantity quoted was 7,000. Price, 48 cents -- 17 that can't be one hundred. .486 each. I am sorry. Date 18 quoted is 3/5/1943. Did not buy. 19 Then it lists a die. Then it lists l/32nd number 20 3 Victopac is what it appears to say. That record would be 21 the record of a quotation. 22 Q. And what is the next entry? 23 A. The next entry is for U.S. Navy Portsmouth. 24 Quoted a quantity of 78,000. I am sorry. 7,850. That's 25 difficult to read that. That first line, the price. Date iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 101 1 quoted was 5/4/43. 2 Then it says quantity ordered, 7,850. And the 3 price looks like 32. Date ordered would be 6/8/43. And 4 then over to the right it lists their order number, which on 5 the copy it is very difficult to read. 6 Q. And can you read the next one? 7 A. It is ditto marks for the same U.S. Navy 8 Portsmouth. Same quantity quoted, 7,850. Looks like 48 9 cents. Quoted on 5/4/43 and says, lost. 10 Q. What does that mean? 11 A. That means they didn't get the order. They lost 12 the order. Quote, they didn't get it. Sometimes when you 13 quote you don't always get the business. 14 Q. And is this also for Victopac number 3? 15 A. No. That's what they are talking about, a die 16 down here on the first one. This is actually a record for a 17 gasket sale. These sales in quotes are for this gasket up 18 here. That's what this card is for. 19 Q. But this is a Victopac gasket? 20 A. The valve cover gaskets are cork rubber. I am 21 not sure why they got Victopac on there except they are 22 referencing a buy and I did not buy on that first line. So 23 I'm not sure what they got Victopac listed there for. 24 l/32nd it says die. But this gasket here is a valve cover, 25 gasket number, and those are cork rubber, or cork. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 102 1 Q. But the Victopac we have described, unless it 2 ended with a 9, is asbestos-containing gasket sheet 3 material? 4 A. I can't -- I do not know why the reference to 5 Victopac is listed on the line with this quote for these 6 gaskets. I don't know what the notation here is for. I can 7 tell you that the Buda Company, 7,000, was a quote that was 8 not subsequently provided an order. I do not know what the 9 reference to a die here was in the l/32nd number 3, 10 Victopac. 11 And to the best of my knowledge, we didn't make 12 Victopac. There was not a Victopac 3 anyway. So I am not 13 sure what this notation here is for. 14 Q. But the best of your knowledge, this record 15 happens to deal with something long before you were born? 16 A. Yes. 17 Q. And there arereferences on the top half of this 18 page, are there not, to two more U.S. Navy Portsmouth sales, 19 or quotes, excuse me, quotations or selling records that 20 again refer to Victopac. Do you see that in line 5 and in 21 line 7? 22 A. Yes, I do. 23 Q. And can you read the entry that is on line 6 24 under order number? 25 A. It looks like it says N 181 S 584/27. ond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 103 1 Q. Does that mean it was ordered? 2 A. It -- that number is in the order number field, 3 so I -- and it has a date in the area where it would list a 4 date for the date ordered. So I would say that was an 5 order, yes, for quantity of 3100 at 32 cents. Ordered, 6 looks like 8/2/43. 7 (Quotation and Selling Record, Victor 8 No. 1861, was marked Exhibit No. 5.) 9 BY MR. GLASSER: 10 Q. I showed you what has now been marked Duncan 11 exhibit 5, and on the last five entries on this particular 12 exhibit it identifies ships parts control. And all of those 13 appear to be completed orders; correct? 14 A. They are orders received. They list orders 15 received. 16 Q. Do you know where any of these orders were 17 shipped? 18 A. Not from looking at this record, no. 19 Q. Thank you. You can't tell by the writing on 20 Duncan exhibits 3, 4, or 5 who made any of those entries? 21 A. No, I can't. No. Not at these dates. 22 Q. Would it be different if the dates were in the 23 1950s? 24 A. No. 25 Q. And would it be different if these dates were in iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 104 1 the 1960s? 2 A. Some of them, yes, I could tell. 3 Q. By handwriting? 4 A. Yes. 5 Q. You would make what would be, I am sure, your 6 best guess as to who may have made an entry, is that 7 correct? 8 A. Without having seen the person actually sit and 9 write, it would be from my recognition of the handwriting of 10 specific people, and the uniqueness of it would be a guess. 11 Q. And you never made any entry on any of the 12 microfiche records, whether there are 69,000 or 900,000. 13 None of them are Marcy Duncan's entry? 14 A. That is correct. 15 Q. You indicated that Tom Radcliffsuggested that 16 you should bring the mastersales list with you. Did you 17 review anything else in preparation for coming down here to 18 offer your deposition? 19 A. I reviewed the items that I looked at last year 20 to prepare for that case that I was here in February of last 21 year. And I brought with me the items that I had researched 22 and used at that time. 23 Q. You did not look at anything relating to Newport 24 News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company, correct? 25 A. Correct. iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 105 1 Q. You did not look for anything under Newport News 2 Ship? 3 A. Correct. 4 Q. You did not look at Newport NewsShipyard? 5 A. I didn't look foranythingNewport News. 6 Q. You did not look for Navy -- U.S., excuse me -- 7 Navy, Newport News Ship? 8 A. No. 9 Q. And you have not been instructed or requested by 10 anyone to make such an inquiry in the event that you are 11 called down here to testify in the trial in Newport News 12 either in September 2004, or November 2004, or any time 13 thereafter. 14 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to the form. 15 MR. GLASSER: What is the objection? 16 MR. CELBA: Foundation for that. The way you 17 phrased it. That's my only objection. 18 BY MR. GLASSER: 19 Q. Has anyone instructed you to do it to prepare for 20 your testimony in a trial in Virginia, to look and check the 21 existing records for sales to Newport News Shipbuilding and 22 Dry Dock Company, or any combination involving Newport News 23 or shipyard to prepare you for your testimony? 24 A. I have not been asked to do any research for any 25 company or entity that had Newport News or Newport News in iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 106 1 its name, location, at all. 2 Q. You indicated earlier that you were responsible 3 for some accounts and they were more or less smaller 4 accounts that did not justify a salesman in a car and a 5 specific responsibility. Who does handle the large accounts 6 like the Navy, or Norfolk Naval Shipyard? 7 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to form. Lack 8 of foundation. But go ahead. 9 A. Those are not large accounts for us. Those are 10 not current accounts today. And when they were accounts, to 11 the best of what I have seen in the historical record, they 12 have always been handled by the sales operations manager as 13 a house account, which are the smaller, not high dollar 14 accounts. 15 Q. How do you define high dollar? 16 A. Probably multi million dollars a year accounts. 17 Q. And you did not reach the position that you are 18 in until 1988? 19 A. My current position, Sales Operations Manager, I 20 have been since May of 1988. 21 Q. Mrs. Duncan, you are not saying that if a worker 22 at Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company, or 23 Norfolk Naval Shipyard, testifies that she saw 24 asbestos-containing Victopac gasket material being used in 25 the 1950s, '60s, '70s or even in the 1980s, that they are iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 107 1 lying or mistaken, are you? 2 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to the form as 3 being argumentative. And it is -- it asks her to improperly 4 comment upon any other evidence that might be presented 5 opinionwise in this case. 6 MR. GLASSER: Your objection is noted. 7 MR. CELBA: And lack of foundation with respect 8 to the question. 9 BY MR. GLASSER: 10 Q. Can you answer my question? 11 A. I have no way of knowing what anyone else has 12 said or not said about any use, I guess use of gaskets, at 13 any location here. 14 Q. If someone says I was there, I saw it, it was 15 being used, you can't say that they are wrong? 16 MR. CELBA: Again, same objection. 17 BY MR. GLASSER: 18 Q. Yes or no? 19 A. I can only tell you the things that I know. I 20 have not heard anybody else say anything. I don't know -- I 21 can't call somebody, tell whether somebody is being truthful 22 or not on something that I have not heard. I don't know how 23 to answer that. I am sorry. 24 Q. What I am saying is that from the records, the 25 records that you have seen, you can't dispute whether Victor iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 108 1 asbestos-containing products were or were not at the Newport 2 News Shipyard, isn't that true? In the 1950s, is it true 3 for the 1950s? You can't say one way or another? 4 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. This has all 5 been asked and answered before with reference to records in 6 this case, the sales records. I object to this type of 7 questioning. 8 But go ahead. 9 A. I am having trouble with understanding the 10 question you are asking me. I don't know anybody that's -- 11 other than my uncle who has worked'at shipyards. I don't 12 know how to answer that. I am sorry. 13 MR. GLASSER: We are going to take a short 14 break. It is now 20 minutes to 1. And I am going to review 15 my notes and see whether I have any additional questions. I 16 may be through. 17 It may be, if you want, and your schedule 18 permits, you may want to grab lunch downstairs, or if you 19 prefer I will go out and look at my notes and come back. 20 MR. CELBA: I prefer the latter, Richard. 21 MR. GLASSER: Let me do that. 22 (Recess) 23 BY MR. GLASSER: 24 Q. You mentioned the R base, the records between 25 1972 and '80 that are unreadable. Does your master customer iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 109 1 list include customers that were during that time frame, 2 namely 1972 to 1980? 3 A. Yes. 4 MR. GLASSER: I have no further questions. 5 MR. CELBA: Richard she has some clarification 6 for you. 7 A. I have some clarification for you on the customer 8 master list. I have given you a misrepresentation of this. 9 Let me explain. 10 The reason that I could not find the customers 11 listed on those cards from the 1940s on here, they are not 12 on here, necessarily. And I will explain that. 13 When we changed from a manual record keeping 14 system in 1971-72 and started to go on computer for the 15 first time at the Victor Chicago plant in the oil seal 16 plant, we took all records that were available, historical 17 or current, anywhere at that time, throughout any of the 18 facilities, and we loaded those records for part records and 19 customer records on the computer. 20 Those records you showed me were from 1943. If 21 there had not been any recent -- and I am just going to say 22 probably throughout the '60s at least -- sale to that 23 entity, it may very well not be -- and nothing since -- it 24 may very well not be listed as a customer in this book. 25 BY MR. GLASSER: iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 110 1 Q. What I understood is that you couldn't find it 2 anyway because they weren't in order? 3 A. That is correct. But I should have been able to 4 find something, and that's what was bothering me so much. I 5 should have been able to find whether it was under U.S. 6 Navy, or Norfolk or Portsmouth. I should have been able to 7 find it one way or another in here, and I couldn't. I 8 couldn't. 9 So then it came back to me what exactly, where, 10 what is really in this customer master. And I wanted to 11 clarify that with you. 12 Q. And I take it in a different vein, unless there 13 is some record there that because you have no personal 14 knowledge of your own, you are totally dependent upon the 15 completeness of the record that you looked at in attempting 16 to answer a question? 17 MR. CELBA: I am going to object. 18 BY MR. GLASSER: 19 Q. Yes or no? 20 A. No, I am not completely at a loss. Okay. And I 21 will explain why. The whole basis of the Victor system is 22 applications, part numbers that fit specific applications. 23 So our business is, if you have an engine that you need 24 sealed, we will either -- either already making a gasket for 25 you for that, or you are coming to me to design one, and iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 111 1 this has been the history since day one. 2 So it is based on the part number and specific 3 application. And then the customers who buy, or have had 4 you create that gasket for them, for whatever application. 5 It is not a simple record system as saying, this is a list 6 of my customers, and this is what they have purchased. 7 I can do research on microfiche cards, and if I 8 had somebody sitting there going through every record and 9 making a complete list of every name that's on there, on all 10 900,000 records, there are things that can be done to create 11 different lists for different purposes. In our normal 12 business, we have developed record keeping to meet the 13 business needs that we have. 14 Q. I understand. But as I further understand, you 15 have not been asked to do that for Newport News Shipbuilding 16 and Dry Dock Company, or any combination of the names of 17 Newport News and Ship; is that correct? 18 A. That is correct. 19 Q. And you don't intend to do it? 20 MR. CELBA: I am going to object to the form 21 again. We are going back to the form again. She hasn't 22 been asked. She hasn't been asked to do it yet. I don't 23 know if they intend to do it or not. 24 MR. GLASSER: Just so we are communicating with 25 one another, clearly if she does anything now in preparation iOnd Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 112 1 of trial, at the very least, it is not that I am trying to 2 open this matter up for more discovery, but the purpose of 3 today was to find out what she knew, what she had been 4 expected to testify as to. I mean the record will speak for 5 itself on that issue. 6 But I think that it would be totally improper to 7 show her anything at this stage forward, between now and the 8 trial in which -- the trial in which this discovery is being 9 taken. 10 But I have no further questions. And the 11 deposition is completed. 12 And, Mr. Celba can tell you, but do you want her 13 to sign, or waive the signing? 14 MR. CELBA: She should review and sign it. 15 MR. GLASSER: I am going to ask the court 16 reporter, once this record is ready, to get it to her with 17 all deliberate speed. 18 We do have a trial that starts Monday. And 19 though there has been no indication she is aware of any 20 attempt to use her, if she intends to testify, certainly I 21 want a transcript in a form that it is usable before she 22 comes into court. 23 (Discussion off the record 24 MR. GLASSER: Back on the record. There being 25 nothing further, this deposition is concluded. tond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 113 1 Thank you. 2 3 (Whereupon, the deposition was concluded at 1:05 4 p.m.) 5 6 I, MARCELLA DUNCAN, do hereby certify that I have 7 read the foregoing transcript of my testimony and further 8 certify that said transcript, with the corrections noted 9 below, is a true and accurate transcript of said testimony. 10 Dated at ________________________this_________day of____________________ 2004 . 11 12 13 ERRATA SHEET 14 15 REASON FOR 16 PAGE LINE CORRECTION CHANGE 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 114 1 2 3 4 MARCELLA DUNCAN 5 6 COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA AT LARGE, to wit: 7 8 9 Subscribed and sworn to before me 10 this day of , 2004 11 12 13 14 15 Notary Public 16 17 MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 115 1 COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA AT LARGE, to wit: 2 I, Richard W. Zahn, RPR, a Notary Public for the 3 Commonwealth of Virginia at large, of qualification in the 4 Circuit Court of the City of Norfolk, Virginia, and whose 5 commission expires January 31, 2005, do hereby certify that 6 the within named deponent, MARCELLA L. DUNCAN, appeared 7 before me at Norfolk, Virginia, as hereinbefore set forth, 8 and after being first duly sworn by me, was thereupon 9 examined upon her oath by counsel for the respective 10 parties; that her examination was recorded in Stenotype by 11 me and reduced to computer printout under my direction; and 12 that the foregoing constitutes a true, accurate and complete 13 transcript of such examination. 14 I further certify that I am not related to nor 15 otherwise associated with any counsel or party to this 16 proceeding, nor otherwise interested in the event thereof. 17 Given under my hand and notarial seal this 18 18th day of September, 2004, at Virginia Beach, Virginia. 19 20 21 Notary Public 22 23 24 25 iond Tel , England (757) 627-6554 ZAHN HALL & ZAHN, LTD. E-mail ZHZ@AOL.COM Norfolk, Virginia Fax (757) 625-7077 Word Index $ $2,700 [1] 11:2 <08:19> $62,000 [3] 8:1 <08:14> 9:2 <08:16> 9:11 <08:16> i 30s [1] 85:6 <10:41> 40s [2] 13:7 <08:22> 52:15 <09:40> '50s [1] 52:15 <09:40> '60s [5] 41:24 <09:18> 51:8 <09:38> 52:15 <09:40> 106: 25 <11:36> 109:22 <11:47> 65 [1] 75:21 <10:22> '67 [1] 79:13 <10:31> 70s [4] 41:24 <09:18> 51:4 <09:37> 52:16 <09:40> 106: 25 <11:36> '71 [1] 78:11 <10:28> '72 [2] 78:11 <10:28> 78:20 <10:29> '78 [1] 75:21 <10:22> '80 [2] 78:20 <10:29> 108:25 <11:45> '80s [2] 41:25 <09:18> 52:18 <09:40> 1 1 [10] 3:9 28:11 <08:48> 28:14 29:5 <08:55> 31:13 <08:59> 32:4 <09:00> 41:14 <09:17> 74:15 <10:19> 82:25 <10:37> 108:14 <11:39> 1/32nd [3] 100:19 <11:20> 101:24 <11:23> 102:9 <11:24> 10 [2] 9:8 <08:16> 68:20 <10:09> 103 [2] 3:16 68:8 <10:08> 11 [1] 96:13 <11:09> 12 [1] 96:13 <11:09=* 12:05 [1] 96:4 <11:05> 12:06 [1] 96:4 <11:05> 12:13 [1] 98:18 <11:13> 12:16 [1] 99:1 <11:15> 12:18 [1] 99:10 <11:17> 13710 [1] 6:14 <08:12> 14 [1] 41:15 <09:17> 15 [2] 68:9 <10:08> 93:6 <10:59> 157 [2] 3:12 47:14 16th [2] 3:9 28:12 Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 17 [2] 1:25 4:5 177 [1] 86:22 <10:45> 181 [1] 102:25 <11:25> 1861 [5] 3:13 3:16 92:23 93:6 <10:59> 103:8 18th [1] 115:18 1909 [4] 3:11 45:20 <09:26> 46:1 <09:27> 47:12 1930 [I] 84:24 <10:41 > 1930s [II] 7:17 <08:14> 26:10 <08:45> 26:24 <08:45> 34: 11 <09:04> 64:21 <10:03> 73:25 <10:18> 83:21 <10:39> 84:10 <10:40> 84: 18<10:40> 85:13 <10:42> 85:22 <10:43> 1940s [5] 26:12 <08:45> 27:1 <08:45> 51:23 <09:39> 86: 17 <10:44> 109:11 <11:46> 1943 [1] 109:20 <11:47> 1947 [2] 79:9 <10:30> 79:12 <10:30> 1950 [I] 4:9 1950s [10] 26:14 <08:45> 27:3 <08:45> 38:16 <09:11> 41: 22 <09:18> 51:25 <09:39> 90:17 <10:52> 103:23 <11:29> 106:25 <11:36> 108:2 <11:38> 108:3 <11:38> 1955 [II] 3:10 27:20 <08:47> 28: 13 28:19 <08:49> 28:20 <08:49> 30:1 <08:56> 33:11 <09:03> 33:23 <09:03> 34:1 <09:03> 34:9 <09:04> 89:25 <10:51 > 1959 [4] 3:11 45:20 <09:26> 45:23 <09:27> 47:12 1960s [6] 26:16 <08:45> 27:5 <08:46> 52:2 <09:39> 55:18 <09:45> 90:19 <10:52> 104: I <11:29> 1965 [6] 39:3 <09:12> 51:14 <09:38> 51:17 <09:38> 53: II <09:41 > 58:13 <09:51 > 74:25 <10:20> 1967 [4] 39:22 <09:14> 40:13 <09:15> 40:14 <09:15> 79:9 <10:30> 1968 [7] 6:16 <08:12> 24:13 <08:40> 25:8 <08:42> 27:5 <08:46> 33:12 <09:03> 33: 19 <09:03> 33:20 <09:03> 1970s [6] 26:18 <08:45> 27:9 <08:46> 52:4 <09:39> 55:16 <09:45> 55:24 <09:46> 90: 19 <10:52> 1971 [4] 77:6 <10:25> 77:12 <10:26> 77:17 <10:26> 79: 20 <10:31 > 1971-72 [1] 109:14 <11:46> 1972 [9] 77:6 <10:25> 77:12 <10:26> 77:17 <10:26> 77: 18<10:26> 77:21 <10:27> 79:1 <10:29> 79:20 <10:31 > 108:25 <11:45> 109:2 <11:46> 1978 [2] 75:20 <10:22> 75:24 <10:22> 1980 [6] 25:19 <08:43> 77:18 <10:26> 77:21 <10:27> 77: 24 <10:27> 79:2 <10:30> 109:2 <11:46> 1980s [9] 25:15 <08:42> 26:3 <08:43> 26:20 <08:45> 27: 11 <08:46> 52:6 <09:39> 83: 21 <10:39> 84:10 <10:40> 84:18 <10:40> 106:25 <11:36> 1988 [27] 27:11 <08:46> 39:7 <09:13> 44:1 <09:22> 44:4 <09:22> 44:4 <09:22> 44:6 <09:22> 44:12 <09:23> 52:6 <09:39> 52:7 <09:39> 64:4 <10:02> 64:7 <10:02> 64:9 <10:02> 64:22 <10:03> 64: 23 <10:03> 69:6<10:09> 72: 25 <10:16> 74:1 <10:18> 79: 16 <10:31> 79:21 <10:31> 82:21 <10:37> 86:25 <10:45> 87:4<10:46> 87:6 <10:46> 87:12 <10:46> 87: 15 <10:46> 106:18 <11:35> 106:20 <11:35> 1989 [1] 78:9 <10:28> 1990s [5] 38:21 <09:12> 38:25 <09:12> 39:19 <09:13> 39: 21 <09:13> 59:6 <09:52> 1996 [1] 57:20 <09:50> 1998 [2] 65:13<10:04> 66:17 <10:05> 1999 [2] 9:23 <08:17> 14:10 <08:23> 1:05 [1] 113:3 IB [1] 41:15 <09:17> 2 2 [6] 3:11 46:10 <09:27> 47:9 <09:29> 47:15 74:15 <10:19> 94:4 <11:01> 20 [2] 41:6<09:16> 108:14 <11:39> 2000 [1] 9:23 <08:17> 2003 [3] 7:25 <08:14> 9:10 <08:16> 91:14 <10:55> 2004 [10] 1:25 4:5 22:25 <08:37> 23:3 <08:37> 24:11 <08:40> 105:12 <11:32> 105:12 <11:32> 113:10 114:10 115: 18 2005 [1] 115:5 20th [1] 22:18 <08:37> 23510-2212 [1] 4:7 28 [1] 3:10 3 3 [10] 3:13 74:16 <10:19> 92: 23 92:25 <10:59> 93:18 <11:01> 100:20 <11:20> 101:14 <11:22> 102:9 <11:24> 102:12 <11:24> 103:20 <11:29> 3/5/1943 [1] 100:18 <11:20> 30 [1] 55:20 <09:46> 31 [1] 115:5 3100 [1] 103:5 <11:25> 31799V-04 [1] 1:7 32 [2] 101:3 <11:21> 103:5 <11:25> 34305 [3] 3:15 99:18 100:7 <11:19> 36688H-02 [1] 1:17 37073V-04 [1] 1:12 4 4 [8] 3:3 3:14 93:18 <11:01> 99:16 <11:17> 99:18 99:22 <11:18> 100:8 <11:19> 103: 20 <11:29> 40-some [1] 13:11 <08:22> 401 -K [1] 8:21 <08:15> 47 [1] 3:12 48 [2] 100:16 <11:20> 101:8 <11:22> 486 [1] 100:17 <11:20> 4th [1] 6:16 <08:12> ____ 5 5 [7] 3:16 9:8 <08:16> 93:19 <11:01 > 102:20 <11:25> 103:8 103:11 <11:27> 103:20 <11 ;29> 5/4/43 [2] 101:1 <11:21> 101:9 <11:22> 50 [2] 74:2 <10:18> 84:20 <10:41 > 50th [3] 3:11 45:19 <09:26> 47:12 580 [1] 4:6 584/27 [1] 102:25 <11:25> 6 6 [1] 102:23 <11:25> 6/8/43 [1] 101:3 <11:21> 600 [1] 4:7 624 [1] 68:8<10:08> 69,000 [6] 65:6 <10:03> 67:23 <10:07> 68:3 <10:07> 68:15 <10:08> 91:15 <10:55> 104: 12 <11:30> Index Page 1 (ffcn pooao 0082 OC8> 7 142 031321 4ia> TPOQ |Ut 0307 021 7 102 0302 030! 024- 78P0D 102 oa SBC lixoas80 |32 <8543 <914f <9149 <914! 0144 <923- 8 9 oraoa<nym P <0090 ooai oc-m 10301093- se po SB ps 9D 1-5 |16 10-14 l" |9 ___ dy |OQ A A6 Its /tardy |3" <944- A* |31 <9047 <913- Afe J22 <8436 <9162 <95 1 <0371 <03t aiosg-oo- 910103 040! 0410 fO> Arad |1" <8334 <BC3- <9- AsdLty (42 <92- Ans pt 432JCS <03> Aribt |1T<B13- Ainrpay [71<02t> AracbtE 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From $2,700 to Accordance Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 2 [1] 4:8 According [1] 99:2 <11:15> Account [5] 8:17 <08:15> 15:9 <08:25> 15:9 <08:25> 15:11 <08:25> 106:13 <11:34> Accounts [15] 14:18 <08:24> 15:4 <08:24> 15:7 <08:24> 15:13 <08:25> 56:6 <09:46> 56:7 <09:46> 56:9 106:3 <11:33> 106:4 <11:33> 106: 5 <11:33> 106:9 <11:34> 106:10 <11:34> 106:10 <11:34> 106:14 <11:34> 106:16 <11:35> Accurate [3]87:4<10:46> 113:9 115: 12 Acquired [2] 7:9 <08:13> 25:22 <08:43> Acquisition [1] 40:15 <09:15> Actual [8] 15:17 <08:25> 16:1 <08:26> 29:6 <08:55> 30:21 <08:57> 31:6<08:58> 76:18 <10:23> 82:13 <10:36> 93:9 <11:00> Additional [2] 5:17 <08:11> 108:15 <11:39> Address [3] 52:21 <09:40> 70:6 <10:11 > 91:3 <10:53> Addresses [1] 86:22 <10:45> Administration [1] 62:2 <09:58> Advance [1] 10:11 <08:18> Advertising [1] 28:22 <08:49> Affidavit [7] 20:9 <08:33> 20:10 <08:33> 20:12 <08:33> 20: 13 <08:33> 20:19 <08:33> 20:24 <08:34> 21:12 <08:34> Agencies [3] 61:20 <09:57> 61:23 <09:58> 62:16 <09:58> Agency [3] 88:1 <10:47> 88:5 <10:48> 88:6 <10:48> Ago [10] 9:22 <08:17> 14:7 <08:23> 14:9 <08:23> 18:5 <08:29> 20:4 <08:32> 49:8 <09:34> 49:8 <09:34> 56:19 <09:48> 56:21 <09:48> 80: 11 <10:33> Agree [1] 29:20 <08:56> Agreement [1] 4:4 Ahead [9] 10:22 <08:18> 33:6 <09:02> 35:18 <09:06> 48:9 <09:32> 73:8 <10:17> 84:14 <10:40> 85:18 <10:43> 106: 8<11:34> 108:8 <11:38> Air [1] 71:9 <10:13> Airborne [1] 20:1 <08:32> Al [3] 1:7 1:13 1:19 Aligned [1] 12:6 <08:20> Alleging [1] 54:15 <09:44> Almost [1] 55:20 <09:46> Alphabetical [8] 96:2 <11:05> 96:20 <11:10> 97:3 <11:10> 98:4 <11:12> 98:12 <11:13> 98: 20 <11:13> 98:23 <11:15=99:4 <11:15=* Altered [1] 73:4 <10:17> Ambiguous [1] 85:17 <10:43> Amended [1] 4:9 Amount [1] 46:25 <09:28> Anniversary [3] 3:11 45:20 <09:26> 47:12 Annual [2] 9:8 <08:16> 9:10 <08:16> Annually [2] 46:18 <09:28> 47:1 <09:28> Answer [15] 23:12 <08:38> 33:6 <09:02> 36:9<09:07> 66:1 <10:05> 66:14 <10:05> 69: 19 <10:10=- 72:6 <10:15> 73: 16 <10:17> 81:4 <10:34> 82: 8 <10:36> 86:13 <10:44> 107:10 <11:36> 107:23 <11:37> 108:12 <11:38> 110:16 <11:49> Answered [10] 33:6 <09:02> 35:15 <09:06> 54:5 <09:43> 65:24 <10:05> 66:11 <10:05> 67: 10<10:06> 73:6 <10:17> 85: 8 <10:42> 85:16 <10:42> 108:5 <11:38> Answers [1] 28:16 <08:49> Anticoagulant [1] 11:21 <08:20> Anyway [2] 102:12 11:24> 110:2 <11:48> Apologize [3] 96:14 <11:10> 98:1 <11:12> 98:24 <11:15> Apparatus [1] 14:22 <08:24> Appear [5]81:7<10:34> 95:24 <11:04> 100:5 <11:19> 100: 6 <11:19> 103:13 <11:27> Appearances [1] 2:1 Appeared [1] 115:6 Appearing [1] 5:4 <08:10> Application [11] 30:19 <08:57> 35:7 <09:06> 36:19 <09:08> 36: 21 <09:08> 37:10 <09:09> 38:12 <09:11> 48:25 <09:33> 61:9 <09:56> 83:23 <10:39> 111:3 <11:49> 111: 4 <11:49> Applications [4] 33:8 <09:02> 35:25 <09:07> 110:22 <11:49> 110:22 <11:49> Apply [1] 16:11 <08:27> Appreciate [1] 84:9 <10:40> Approached [1] 63:23 <10:01> Approval [4] 31:9 <08:58> 59:20 <09:53> 60:4 <09:54> 61:11 <09:56> Approved [9] 30:13 <08:57> 30:16 <08:57> 30:24 <08:58> 31:4 <08:58> 59:18 <09:53> 59: 25 <09:53> 60:9 <09:54> 60: 21 <09:55> 61:7 <09:56> Area [11] 13:1 <08:21> 14:4 <08:23> 15:3 <08:24> 16:7 <08:26> 16:25 <08:28> 32:7 <09:00> 45:15 <09:25> 53: 15 <09:42> 54:3 <09:43> 68: 23 <10:09> 103:3 <11:25> Areas [2] 14:25 <08:24> 53:14 <09:42> Argumentative [7] 29:15 <08:55> 66:11 <10:05> 67:9 <10:06> 72:3 <10:14> 82:1 <10:36> 85:16 <10:42> 107:3 <11:36> Arising [1] 54:11 <09:43> Arranged [3] 97:2 <11:10> 97:4 <11:11 > 98:9 <11:12> Arrangements [3] 8:12 <08:15> 10:20 <08:18> 98:9 <11:12> Asbestos [45] 20:1 <08:32> 23:8 <08:38> 23:14 <08:38> 31:5 <08:58> 31:14 <08:59> 31: 14 <08:59> 31:22 <08:59> 31:23 <09:00> 31:24 <09:00> 40:6 <09:14> 40:17 <09:15> 40:17 <09:15> 41:1 <09:16> 41:4 <09:16> 41:4 <09:16> 41:10 <09:17> 41: 14 <09:17> 44:11 <09:23> 44:15 <09:23> 45:2 <09:24> 46:3 <09:27> 46:24 <09:28> 47:1 <09:28> 47:2 <09:28> 47:3 <09:28> 47:4 <09:28> 49:13 <09:34> 49:16 <09:35> 49:18 <09:35> 49: 23 <09:35> 50:1 <09:35> 50: 5 <09:36> 50:12 <09:36> 51: 16 <09:38> 51:23 <09:39> 52:21 <09:40> 53:1 <09:41 > 53:20 <09:42> 54:1 <09:43> 54:12 <09:43> 54:15 <09:44> 56:14 <09:47> 62: 24 <09:59> 80:23 <10:33> 81:1 <10:34> Asbestos-containing [62] 14:13 <08:23> 18:25 <08:30> 19:22 <08:32> 19: 25 <08:32> 24:15 <08:40> 24:23 <08:41 > 25:1 <08:41 > 25:13 <08:42> 26:1 <08:43> 26:8 <08:44> 26:22 <08:45> 26:23 <08:45> 31:4<08:58> 33:24 <09:03> 37:22 <09:10> 39:7 <09:13> 39:23 <09:14> 40:17 <09:15> 40: 24 <09:16> 41:14 <09:17> 41:21 <09:18> 42:6<09:19> 42:19 <09:19> 43:17 <09:21 > 44:7 <09:22> 45:4 <09:24> 45:11 <09:25> 47: 18 <09:30> 48:6 <09:32> 49: 4 <09:33> 49:5<09:34> 49: 23 <09:35> 50:13 <09:36> 50:21 <09:37> 50:22 <09:37> 51:16 <09:38> 53:2 <09:41 > 53:7 <09:41 > 53:12 <09:41 > 53:20 <09:42> 55:5 <09:45> 55:11 <09:45> 56: 11 <09:47> 58:12 <09:51 > 58:24 <09:52> 59:18 <09:53> 60:1 <09:54> 60:20 <09:55> 62:24 <09:59> 63:4 <10:00> 63:16 <10:01> 71:5 <10:13> 72:21 <10:16> 75:1 <10:20> 75:8<10:21> 76:24 <10:24> 85:4 <10:41 > 86:18 <10:45> 91:1 <10:53> 102:2 <11:23> 106:24 <11:36> 108:1 <11:37> Asbestos-related [2] 49:13 <09:34> 54:12 <09:43> Asbestosis [2] 49:9 <09:34> 54:7 <09:43> Assemblies [1] 15:21 <08:26> Assembly [3] 15:22 <08:26> 15:24 <08:26> 15:25 <08:26> Assign [1] 83:8 <10:38> Assigned [2] 41:12<09:17> 84:1 <10:39> Associated [1] 115:15 Assume [2] 64:6 <10:02> 72:15 <10:16> Assuming [3] 14:12 <08:23> 23:9 <08:38> 71:3 <10:13> Assumption [2] 70:14 <10:12> 71:18 <10:14> Atmospheric [1] 71:8 <10:13> Attempt [1] 112:20 <11:52> Attempted [4] 58:23 <09:51> 76:22 <10:24> 90:16 <10:52> 90: 25 <10:53> Attempting [2] 100:2 <11:19> 110:15 <11:48> Attorneys [1] 63:23 <10:01> Austin [1] 59:12 <09:52> Authenticity [1] 28:6 <08:48> Automobile [2] 11:14 <08:19> 32:21 <09:01 > Available [7] 10:18 <08:18> 21:1 <08:34> 63:18 <10:01 > 79: 14 <10:31> 83:13 <10:38> 83:15 <10:39> 109:16 <11:47> Aware [28] 22:16 <08:37> 22:23 <08:37> 27:13 <08:46> 27: 15 <08:46> 27:19 <08:47> 29:7 <08:55> 31:24 <09:00> 38:22 <09:12> 49:9 <09:34> 52:22 <09:40> 53:19 <09:42> 53:23 <09:42> 54:5 <09:43> 54:7 <09:43> 54:10 <09:43> 54:13 <09:44> 54: 17 <09:44> 60:5 <09:54> 60: 8 <09:54> 60:11 <09:55> 60: 15 <09:55> 60:19 <09:55> 60:24 <09:55> 61:20 <09:57> 64:13 <10:02> 80: 13<10:33> 91:7 <10:54> 112:19 <11:52> B Background [1] 6:13 <08:12> Bad [1] 5:2 <08:10> Bag [1] 47:22 <09:31 > Band [1] 48:1 <09:31> Base [8]77j10<105>725 <10:27> 78:7 <10:28> 78:12 <10:28> 78:12 <10:28> 78: 16 <10:29> 79:22 <10:32> 108:24 <11:45> Based [9] 9:6 <08:16> 11:8 <08:19=> 25:19 <08:43> 28: 16 <08:49> 34:3 <09:04> 38: 17 <09:12> 84:1 <10:39> 84: 5 <10:40> 111:2 <11:49> Basis [1] 110:21 <11:49> Batch [1] 97:18 <11:11> Beach [2] 14:24 <08:24> 115:18 Bear [2] 95:25 <11:04> 96:3 <11:05> Became [3] 54:4 <09:43> 64:9 <10:02> 65:18 <10:04> Become [1] 54:6 <09:43> Beginning [3] 64:19 <10:03> 66:20 <10:06> 66:22 <10:06> Behalf [6] 1:23 4:2 5:4 <08:10> 6:7 8:8 <08:15> 81:2 <10:34> Below [1] 113:9 Best [5] 69:19 <10:10> 102:11 <11:24> 102:14 <11:24> 104:6 <11:29> 106:11 <11:34> Better [5] 4:23 <08:09> 11:25 <08:20> 80:13 <10:33> 81:7 <10:34> 83:7 <10:38> Between [4] 83:21 <10:39> 96:4 <11:05> 108:24 <11:45> 112:7 <11:51> Bicycle [2] 11:14 <08:19> 11:15 <08:19> Biggers [2] 5:15 <08:10> 6:1 <08:11> Binary [1] 79:5 <10:30> Binders [1] 41:7 <09:17> Birch [2] 50:8 <09:36> 50:15 <09:36> Bit [2] 6:12 <08:11> 23:19 <08:38> BLACK [1] 2:7 Blank [1] 74:18 <10:19> Blood [1] 11:23 <08:20> Blown [1] 15:11 <08:25> Board [2] 7:23 <08:14> 33:14 <09:03> Boasted [2] 29:11 <08:55> 29:15 <08:55> Bob [1] 4:21 <08:09> Bone [1] 11:19 <08:19> Bones [2] 12:6 <08:20> 12:7 <08:20> Bonus [3] 9:6 <08:16> 9:7 <08:16> 1625 Unique Words.TD Firm Name Here From Accordance to Bonus Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 3 9:9 <08:16> Bonuses [1] 9:3 <08:16> Book [7] 29:19 <08:56> 58:3 <09:50 88:15 <10:48> 88: 17 <10:49> 88:19 <10:49= 95:21 <11:04= 109:24 <11:47> Born [2] 74:6 <10:18> 102:15 <11:24> Boss [1] 12:16 <08:21> Bothering [1] 110:4 <11:48> Bottom [2] 95:12 <11:03=- 95:14 <11:03> Brand [2] 84:4 <10:40> 84:4 <10:40 Break [2] 89:11 <10:50 108:14 <11:39> Briefly [1] 91:13 <10:55> Bring [8] 21:7 <08:34> 96:21 <11:10 97:6 <11:11> 97:7 <11:11> 97:10 <11:11> 97: 11 <11:11> 98:2 <11:12> 104:16 <11:30> Brochure [4] 27:20 <08:47> 31:13 <08:59> 33:3 <09:02> 34:8 <09:04> Brother [1] 18:5<08:29> Brothers [1] 12:24 <08:21> Brought [10] 42:11 <09:19> 72:25 <10:16> 86:20 <10:45> 96: 20 <11:10= 96:23 <11:10= 98:1 <11:12=- 98:11 <11:13= 98:20 <11:13= 99:5 <11:15= 104:21 <11:31 = Brown [1] 47:23 <09:31 = Buda [2] 100:13 <11:20 102:7 <11:24= Building [1] 38:24 <09:12= Buildings [1] 19:9 <08:31 = Built [2] 39:3 <09:12= 51:13 <09:38= Bunch [1] 33:1 <09:02= Burn [1] 38:19 <09:12= Burned [4] 39:18 <09:13= 39:20 <09:13= 59:6 <09:52= 59:7 <09:52= Business [14] 8:13 <08:15= 17:9 <08:28= 28:23 <08:49= 65: 16 <10:04= 66:19 <10:05= 67:6 <10:06= 70:16 <10:12= 71:18 <10:14= 81:13 <10:35= 81:14 <10:35= 101: 13 <11:22= 110:23 <11:49= 111:12 <11:50= 111:13 <11:50= Buy [5] 15:20 <08:25= 100:18 <11:20= 101:22 <11:23= 101:22 <11:23= 111:3 <11:49= Buyers [1] 50:5 <09:36= Buying [2] 40:13 <09:15= 75:5 <10:21 = c California [3] 11:9 <08:19= 96:10 <11:06= 96:11 <11:07= Camera [1] 5:19 <08:11= Cannot [6] 27:7 <08:46= 67:13 <10:07= 78:24 <10:29= 80:3 <10:32= 82:7 <10:36= 95:3 <11:03= Capable [1] 30:20 <08:57= Car [2] 37:23 <09:10= 106:4 <11:33= Card [9] 67:1 <10:06= 67:3 <10:06= 69:11 <10:10= 69: 20 <10:10= 74:18 <10:19= 81:6 <10:34= 82:19 <10:37= 92:16 <10:58= 101:18 <11:23= Cards [29] 10:3 <08:17= 17:11 <08:28= 17:13 <08:29= 65:6 <10:03= 65:10 <10:04= 67:4 <10:06= 67:6 <10:06= 67:17 <10:07= 67:22 <10:07= 68:8 <10:08= 68:8 <10:08= 68:9 <10:08= 69:14 <10:10= 69: 15 <10:10= 70:20 <10:12= 73:25 <10:18= 74:8 <10:18= 74:14 <10:19= 74:17 <10:19= 81:8 <10:34= 81:10 <10:35= 81:18 <10:35= 82: 12 <10:36= 82:18 <10:37= 82:20 <10:37= 91:16 <10:55= 93:4 <10:59= 109: 11 <11:46= 111:7 <11:50= Care [1] 15:16 <08:25= Carolina [1] 16:25 <08:28= Cars [2] 15:11 <08:25= 33:2 <09:02= Case [14] 6:2 <08:11= 6:3 <08:11= 21:11 <08:34= 22: 11 <08:36= 23:7 <08:37= 23: 10 <08:38= 24:7 <08:39= 68: 4 <10:07= 68:6 <10:08= 68: 13 <10:08= 68:18 <10:09= 104:20 <11:31= 107:5 <11:36= 108:6 <11:38= Cases [3] 23:14 <08:38= 24:10 <08:39= 36:4 <09:07= Catalog [2] 29:6 <08:55= 45:21 <09:26= Catalogs [1] 27:22 <08:47= Categorized [1] 57:10 <09:49= Caterpillar [1] 50:19 <09:37= Caterpillar's [1] 43:3 <09:20= Caution [2] 43:7 <09:20= 43:16 <09:21 = Ceiling [2] 6:17 <08:12= 7:12 <08:13= Celba [58] 2:5 2:6 5:8 <08:10= 5:8 <08:10= 21:4 <08:34= 21:14 <08:34= 29:13 <08:55= 29: 15 <08:55= 33:5 <09:02= 33: 15 <09:03= 35:15 <09:06= 35:18 <09:06= 39:25 <09:14= 42:12 <09:19= 46:5 <09:27= 48:8 <09:32= 65:23 <10:04= 66:10 <10:05= 67:9 <10:06= 69:17 <10:10= 72:3 <10:14= 73:6 <10:17= 73:20 <10:17= 81:20 <10:35= 81: 25 <10:36= 83:13 <10:38= 83:16 <10:39= 84:13 <10:40= 85:7 <10:41= 85:15 <10:42= 86:3 <10:43= 86:11 <10:44= 88:20 <10:49= 89:1 <10:49= 89:7 <10:49= 89:10 <10:50= 90:5 <10:52= 90:9 <10:52= 91:4 <10:54= 92:18 <10:58= 92:21 <10:59= 93: 23 <11:01= 97:12 <11:11= 97:21 <11:12= 99:7 <11:16= 105:14 <11:32= 105:16 <11:32= 106:7 <11:34= 107: 2 <11:36= 107:7 <11:36= 107:16 <11:37= 108:4 <11:38= 108:20 <11:39= 109:5 <11:46= 110:17 <11:49= 111:20 <11:51= 112:12 <11:52= 112:14 <11:52= Center [11] 4:6 6:19 <08:12= 19:10 <08:31= 54:22 <09:44= 56: 25 <09:48= 62:5 <09:58= 62: 6 <09:58= 62:8 <09:58= 62: 11 <09:58= 62:14 <09:58= 96:10 <11:06= Central [1] 56:22 <09:48= Cents [3] 100:16 <11:20= 101:9 <11:22= 103:5 <11:25= Certain [4] 6:21 <08:12= 10:21 <08:18= 61:7 <09:56= 82:21 <10:37= Certainly [3] 5:16 <08:10= 67:5 <10:06= 112:20 <11:52= Certify [4] 113:6 113:8 115:5 115:14 Cetera [1] 33:22 <09:03= Chain [1] 14:23 <08:24= CHANGE [1] 113:16 Changed [8] 41:18 <09:18= 83:20 <10:39= 83:20 <10:39= 84: 10 <10:40= 84:17 <10:40= 84:19 <10:40= 85:1 <10:41 = 109:13 <11:46= Characteristics [5] 30:22 <08:58= 37:1 <09:08= 37:11 <09:09= 37: 19 <09:09= 44:23 <09:24= Charge [6] 24:22 <08:41= 25:9 <08:42= 25:11 <08:42= 55:8 <09:45= 56:3 <09:46= 56:5 <09:46= CHARMAINE [1] 1=3 Check [2] 12:11 <08:21= 105:20 <11:32= Cheek [1] 11:19 <08:19= Chemical [2] 44:24 <09:24= 45:15 <09:25= Chemicals [1] 45:15 <09:25= Chesapeake [4] 12:24 <08:21= 13:13 <08:22= 13:15 <08:22= 14: 22 <08:24= Chicago [17] 38:17 <09:12= 38:19 <09:12= 38:20 <09:12= 39: 12 <09:13= 39:13 <09:13= 51:18 <09:38= 53:11 <09:41= 58:18 <09:51= 59:5 <09:52= 59:12 <09:52= 75:9 <10:21= 75:20 <10:22= 75: 23 <10:22= 75:24 <10:22= 76:23 <10:24= 77:16 <10:26= 109:15 <11:47= Children [1] 12:25 <08:21= Choose [1] 84:5 <10:40= Churubusco [3] 19:8 <08:31= 38:17 <09:12= 77:15 <10:26= Circuit [2] 1:2 115:4 City [4] 1:2 70:6 <10:11= 96:11 <11:07= 115:4 Claim [1] 28:2 <08:47= Claimed [1] 54:12 <09:43= Claims [2] 54:10 <09:43= 54:22 <09:44= Clarification [3] 37:3 <09:09= 109:5 <11:46= 109:7 <11:46= Clarify [8] 5:12 <08:10= 11:11 <08:19= 75:7 <10:21= 89:13 <10:50= 89:15 <10:51= 89: 16 <10:51= 89:19 110:11 <11:48= Classify [1] 46:8 <09:27= Clays [1] 41:7 <09:17= Clean [1] 28:10 <08:48= Clear [5] 23:12 <08:38= 65:5 <10:03= 73:23 <10:18= 81:4 <10:34= 88:25 <10:49= Clearly [1] 111:25 <11:51= Clients [1] 53:20 <09:42= Climate [1] 71:9 <10:13= Close [1] 89:8 <10:50= Closed [1] 5:2 <08:10= Closely [1] 84:7 <10:40= Coatings [1] 45:15 <09:25= Code [6] 82:21 <10:37= 84:10 <10:40= 84:15 <10:40= 84: 15 <10:40= 96:19 <11:10= 98:3 <11:12= Codes [2] 83:4 <10:38= 83:19 <10:39= Combination [5] 20:16 <08:33= 31:19 <08:59= 47:2 <09:28= 105: 22 <11:33= 111:16 <11:50= Combustion [1] 32:23 <09:02= Coming [6] 7:23 <08:14= 10:9 <08:18= 33:13 <09:03= 68: 14 <10:08= 104:17 <11:30= 110:25 <11:49= Commencing [1] 4:4 Comment [1] 107:4 <11:36= Commission [2] 114:17 115:5 Commonwealth [4] 4:3 114:6 115:1 115:3 Communicating [1] 111:24 <11:51= Communication [1] 34:24 <09:05= Commuters [1] 77:5 <10:25= Company [32] 7:8 <08:13= 8:22 <08:15= 10:19 <08:18= 11:6 <08:19= 15:11 <08:25= 15: 21 <08:26= 17:19 <08:29= 18:16 <08:30= 24:1 <08:39= 24:5 <08:39= 27:14 <08:46= 27:17 <08:46= 27:23 <08:47= 28:18 <08:49= 28: 21 <08:49= 40:4 <09:14= 40: 13 <09:15= 40:14 <09:15= 55:3 <09:44= 57:2 <09:48= 57:12 <09:49= 65:17 <10:04= 70:5 <10:11= 70:7 <10:11= 87:20 <10:47= 100: 13 <11:20= 102:7 <11:24= 104:24 <11:31= 105:22 <11:33= 105:25 <11:33= 106:22 <11:35= 111:16 <11:50= Compensation [3] 8:14 <08:15= 9:2 <08:16= 54:10 <09:43= Compilation [4] 66:18 <10:05= 69:21 <10:11= 87:5 <10:46= 87:7 <10:46= Compiled [5] 86:19 <10:45= 86:25 <10:45= 87:1 <10:45= 87:2 <10:46= 87:10 <10:46= Complete [17] 65:12 <10:04= 65:19 <10:04= 65:21 <10:04= 66:4 <10:05= 66:6 <10:05= 66:23 <10:06= 67:12 <10:06= 69:9 <10:10= 81:9 <10:34= 81:9 <10:34= 85:14 <10:42= 85: 21 <10:43= 86:16 <10:44= 86:19 <10:45= 87:5 <10:46= 111:9 <11:50= 115:12 Completed [3] 81:6 <10:34= 103:13 <11:27= 112:11 <11:52= Completely [1] 110:20 <11:49= Completeness [3] 34:6 <09:04= 91:9 <10:54= 110:15 <11:48= Completion [1] 39:5 <09:12= Components [5] 41:1 <09:16= 43:21 <09:22= 47:3 <09:28= 50:20 <09:37= 51:6 <09:38= Composition [1] 41:5 <09:16= Compound [2] 69:17 <10:10= 73:7 <10:17= Compressed [14] 31:4 <08:58= 37:22 <09:10= 47:18 <09:30= 58: 12 <09:51= 59:18 <09:53= 60:1 <09:54= 60:20 <09:55= 62:24 <09:59= 63:4 <10:00= 71:6 <10:13= 72:21 <10:16= 75:8 <10:21= 85:3 <10:41 = 91:1 <10:53= Compressibility [1] 30:21 <08:57= 1625 Unique Words.TD Firm Name Here From Bonus to Compressibility Word Index Compression [1] 38:9 <09:11> Computer [18] 77:8 <10:25> 77:9 <10:25> 77:14 <10:26> 77: 25 <10:27> 78:9<10:28> 78: 11 <10:28= 78:18 <10:29> 78:21 <10:29> 79:4 <10:30> 79:17 <10:31> 80:2<10:32> 80:3 <10:32> 86:23 <10:45> 87:12 <10:46> 87:14 <10:46> 109:14 <11:46> 109:19 <11:47> 115:11 Computers [3] 77:6 <10:25> 78:18 <10:29> 79:17 <10:31> Concept [2] 30:11 <08:57> 30:12 <08:57> Concern [1] 88:24 <10:49> Concerning [8] 6:25 <08:12> 7:22 <08:14> 20:12 <08:33> 24: 14 <08:40> 43:16 <09:21 > 58:12 <09:51> 75:11 <10:21> 76:23 <10:24= Concluded [2] 112:25 <11:54> 113:3 Conditioning [1] 71:9 <10:13=- Conditions [3] 16:17 <08:27> 71:8 <10:13> 71:13 <10:14> Conduct [1] 5:17 <08:11> Confirm [2] 33:3 <09:02> 52:25 <09:41 > Confused [4] 73:13 <10:17> 73:13 <10:17> 75:3 <10:20> 93:24 <11:01 > Connected [1] 80:5 <10:32> Consecutive [1] 74:12 <10:19> Considered [1] 56:6 <09:46> Consisted [1] 68:22 <10:09> Consisting [2] 3:10 28:13 Constitutes [1] 115:12 Construction [1] 62:13 <09:58> Consultant [1] 18:10 <08:30> Consumed [1] 16:19 <08:27> Contacted [1] 20:6 <08:32> Contain [4] 31:24 <09:00> 40:25 <09:16> 68:8 <10:08> 68:9 <10:08> Contained [4] 31:21 <08:59> 40:5 <09:14> 41:2<09:16> 48:5 <09:32> Containing [3] 40:17<09:15> 41:14 <09:17> 53:20 <09:42> Content [2] 31:22 <08:59> 41:4 <09:16> Contents [2] 20:24 <08:34> 40:24 <09:16> Continue [3] 17:16 <08:29> 39:6 <09:12> 98:17 <11:13> Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Contract [2] 55:4 <09:45> 63:16 <10:01 > Contracts [3] 62:24 <09:59> 63:3 <10:00> 63:5<10:00> Contradict [1] 34:8 <09:04> Contributed [1] 80:18 <10:33> Control [2] 37:20 <09:09> 103:12 <11:27> Controlled [1] 71:10 <10:13> Conversation [1] 5:14 <08:10> Converted [3] 41:17 <09:17> 77:13 <10:26> 78:14 <10:29> Cooper [2] 56:17 80:9 <10:32> Copies [5] 58:9 <09:50> 63:11 <10:00> 63:14 <10:01> 96: 16 <11:10> 97:17 <11:11> Copy [14] 21:1 <08:34= 21:8 <08:34> 27:22 <08:47> 28: 10 <08:48= 45:18 <09:26> 45:21 <09:26> 46:21 <09:28> 76:18 <10:23> 83: 10<10:38> 83:12 <10:38> 88:18 <10:49> 92:16 <10:58> 93:4 <10:59> 101:5 <11:22> Cord [1] 84:15 <10:40= Cork [3] 101:20 <11:23> 101:25 <11:23> 101:25 <11:23> Corner [2] 94:22 <11:02> 100:8 <11:19> Corporate [3] 38:14 <09:11> 41:21 <09:18> 77:4 <10:25> Corporation [9] 1:13 2:6 6:15<08:12> 6: 18<08:12> 8:25 <08:16> 25: 2 08:41 = 40:3 <09:14> 47:1 <09:28> 50:6 <09:36> Correct [67] 7:3 <08:13> 9:1 <08:16> 11:11 <08:19= 24: 22 <08:41 > 26:3 <08:43> 26: 6 <08:44> 28:7 <08:48> 28: 17 <08:49= 32:16 <09:01> 33:16 <09:03> 33:25 <09:03> 34:19 <09:05= 34: 20 <09:05> 36:3 <09:07> 36: 21 <09:08> 37:5 <09:09> 37: 24 <09:10> 39:10 <09:13> 39:11 <09:13> 42:17 <09:19= 44:9 <09:23> 46:18 <09:28> 59:5 <09:52> 62:25 <09:59> 65:8<10:03> 65:11 <10:04> 66:9 <10:05> 66:17 <10:05> 69:1 <10:09> 69:8 <10:10> 69:11 <10:10> 69: 16 <10:10> 71:1 <10:13> 71: 22 <10:14> 71:23 <10:14=- 72:19 <10:16= 73:5 <10:17= 74:3 <10:18= 75:2 <10:20= 75:16 <10:21= 75:19 <10:22= 76:15 <10:23= 77:5 <10:25= 77:7 <10:25= 77:12 <10:26= 77:19 <10:26= 78:3 <10:28= 78:19 <10:29= 79:7 <10:30= 79:8 <10:30= 79:15 <10:31= 80:5 <10:32= 82:3 <10:36= 82:22 <10:37= 90:4 <10:52= 92:13 <10:58= 94:9 <11:02= 95:13 <11:03= 103: 13 <11:27= 104:7 <11:30= 104:14 <11:30= 104:24 <11:31= 104:25 <11:31= 105:3 <11:31= 110:3 <11:48= 111:17 <11:50= 111:18 <11:51= CORRECTION [1] 113:16 Corrections [1] 113:8 Correctly [I] 22:16 <08:37= Counsel [II] 2:3 2:6 2:8 2:10 2:12 4:4 20:15 <08:33= 21:25 <08:35= 99:14 <11:17= 115: 9115:15 Country [1] 42:11 <09:19= Counts [1] 53:10 <09:41 = Couple [1] 18:1 <08:29= Course [7] 5:3 <08:10= 17:9 <08:28= 21:6 <08:34= 65:16 <10:04= 66:19 <10:05= 70: 16 <10:12= 83:22 <10:39= Court [12] 1:2 4:8 5:23 <08:11= 28: 9 <08:48= 41:3 <09:16= 72:5 <10:15= 72:7 88:25 <10:49= 99:15 <11:17= 112: 15 <11:52= 112:22 <11:53= 115:4 Cousins [1] 12:25 <08:21= Cover [6] 45:22 <09:27= 64:17 <10:02= 64:18 <10:02= 100: 9 <11:19= 101:20 <11:23= 101:24 <11:23= Create [3] 75:14 <10:21= 111:4 <11:49= 111:10 <11:50= Created [7] 7:9 <08:13= 64:22 <10:03= 64:24 <10:03= 74: 20 <10:20= 75:11 <10:21= 84:24 <10:41= 96:8 <11:06= Creating [1] 65:9 <10:03= Creative [1] 96:6 <11:06= Creek [1] 13:14 <08:22= Criteria [1] 84:1 <10:39= Crown [1] 4:6 Cunningham [1] 51:5 <09:37= Current [9] 6:13 <08:12= 78:8 <10:28= 78:9 <10:28= 78:15 <10:29= 78:21 <10:29= 87: 19 <10:47= 106:10 <11:34= 106:19 <11:35= 109:17 <11:47= Custodian [2] 7:1 <08:13= 22:5 <08:36= Customer [44] 15:13 <08:25= 15:16 <08:25= 17:10 <08:28= 17: 12 <08:28= 17:14 <08:29= 22:9 <08:36= 24:8 <08:39= 40:3 <09:14= 40:10 <09:15= 43:1 <09:20= 69:22 <10:11= 69:24 <10:11= 70:6 <10:11 = 75:14 <10:21= 86:16 <10:44= 86:19 <10:45= 86: 22 <10:45= 88:11 <10:48= 88:14 <10:48= 88:16 <10:48= 88:21 <10:49= 89: 20 <10:51= 92:3 <10:56= 92: 3 <10:56= 93:7 <11:00= 93: 11 <11:00= 93:18 <11:01= 95:20 <11:04= 96:19 <11:10= 96:24 <11:10= 96: 25 <11:10= 97:1 <11:10= 97: 8 <11:11= 97:13 <11:11= 98: 2 <11:12= 98:7 <11:12= 99: 23 <11:18= 100:5 <11:19= 100:6 <11:19= 108:25 <11:45= 109:7 <11:46= 109: 19 <11:47= 109:24 <11:47= 110:10 <11:48= Customer's [2] 76:17 <10:23= 76:19 <10:24= Customers [21] 14:21 <08:24= 14:24 <08:24= 14:25 <08:24= 15: 14 <08:25= 15:17 <08:25= 16:18 <08:27= 24:9 <08:39= 33:22 <09:03= 45:1 <09:24= 69:23 <10:11= 82:17 <10:36= 87:18 <10:47= 87: 19 <10:47= 93:9 <11:00= 95: 24 <11:04= 97:17 <11:11= 98:9 <11:12= 109:1 <11:46= 109:10 <11:46= 111:3 <11:49= 111:6 <11:50= Customers' [1] 76:11 <10:23= Cut [3] 31:18 <08:59= 36:25 <09:08= 37:2 <09:08= Cutting [1] 53:1 <09:41= Cylinder [1] 93:5 <10:59=____________ D Daily [1] 81:14 <10:35= Damage [2] 12:5 <08:20= 12:9 <08:20= Damaged [2] 48:2 <09:31= 48:3 <09:31= Dana [89] 1:13 2:6 5:8 <08:10= 5:9 <08:10= 5:13 <08:10= 6:15 <08:12= 6:17 <08:12= 6:20 <08:12= 7:6 <08:13= 7:8 <08:13= 8:4 <08:14= 8:16 <08:15= 8:18 <08:15= 8:20 <08:15= 8:25 <08:16= 9:1 <08:16= 9:14 <08:16= 12:13 <08:21= 14:14 <08:23= 15:8 <08:24= 16:7 <08:26= 18:13 <08:30= 19:24 <08:32= 20: 14 <08:33= 21:25 <08:35= 22:11 <08:36= 24:16 <08:40= 24:25 <08:41= 25:2 <08:41= 25:14 <08:42= 26:2 <08:43= 29:7 <08:55= 33:20 <09:03= 33:24 <09:03= 38: 14 <09:11= 39:22 <09:14= 40:3 <09:14= 41:21 <09:18= 42:7 <09:19= 42:20 <09:20= 43:6 <09:20= 43:15 <09:21= 44:12 <09:23= 45:10 <09:25= 49:16 <09:35= 49: 24 <09:35= 50:6 <09:36= 50: 12 <09:36= 50:22 <09:37= 51:11 <09:38= 51:21 <09:39= 52:11 <09:40= 52: 20 <09:40= 52:24 <09:40= 53:6 <09:41= 53:20 <09:42= 54:1 <09:43= 54:11 <09:43= 54:15 <09:44= 54:25 <09:44= 56:11 <09:47= 56: 22 <09:48= 59:17 <09:53= 59:24 <09:53= 60:5 <09:54= 60:8 <09:54= 60:15 <09:55= 60:20 <09:55= 62:20 <09:59= 62:25 <09:59= 63:3 <10:00= 63:17 <10:01= 65: 17 <10:04= 65:18 <10:04= 69:8 <10:10= 72:21 <10:16= 77:5 <10:25= 77:12 <10:26= Index Page 4 79:9 <10:30= 80:5 <10:32= 81:1 <10:34= 81:2 <10:34= 81:9 <10:34= 85:3 <10:41 = 86:2 <10:43= 86:17 <10:44= 87:21 <10:47= 90:15 <10:52= 91:7 <10:54= Dana's [2] 8:8 <08:15= 81:2 <10:34= Data [8] 43:20 <09:22= 77:10 <10:25= 77:19 <10:26= 77: 22 <10:27= 77:25 <10:27= 78:12 <10:28= 78:16 <10:29= 80:18 <10:33= Databases [1] 79:19 <10:31= Date [9] 64:21 <10:03= 64:22 <10:03= 71:16 <10:14= 100: 17 <11:20= 100:25 <11:21 = 101:3 <11:21= 103:3 <11:25= 103:4 <11:25= 103: 4 <11:25= Dated [1] 113:10 Dates [9] 7:16 <08:14= 59:21 <09:53= 64:17 <10:02= 64: 18 <10:02= 66:21 <10:06= 90:23 <10:53= 103:21 <11:29= 103:22 <11:29= 103:25 <11:29= Days [3] 4:23 <08:09= 10:18 <08:18= 10:21 <08:18= Deal [3] 16:22 <08:28= 16:24 <08:28= 102:15 <11:24= Dealers [1] 16:14 <08:27= Dealing [1] 17:5 <08:28= Death [1] 57:15 <09:49= Deceased [2] 1:4 55:21 <09:46= Deep [1] 13:14 <08:22= Defendant [4] 2:6 2:8 2:10 2:12 Defendants [4] 1:8 1:14 1:20 6:7 Defense [3] 62:4 <09:58= 62:6 <09:58= 62:13 <09:58= Define [1] 106:15 <11:34= Definitively [1] 86:9 <10:44= Deliberate [1] 112:17 <11:52= Deliver [1] 69:25 <10:11= Delivered [1] 82:16 <10:36= Demonstrations [1] 19:12 <08:31= Department [4] 52:12 <09:40= 52:20 <09:40= 63:10 <10:00= 64:4 <10:02= Depended [1] 57:9 <09:49= Dependent [1] 110:14 <11:48= Deponent [5] 3:1 5:7 <08:10= 45:12 49: 19 <09:35= 115:6 Deposed [1] 6:6 Deposition [9] 1:22 4:1 10:18 <08:18= 12:21 <08:21= 21:19 1625 Unique Words.TD Firm Name Here From Compression to Deposition Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 5 <08:35> 104:18 <11:31> 112:11 <11:52> 112:25 <11:54> 113:3 Depositions [3] 9:19 <08:17> 11:1 <08:19> 23:17 <08:38> Depot [10] 93:15 <11:01> 93:16 <11:01> 93:19 <11:01> 93: 21 <11:01> 94:4<11:01> 94: 5 <11:02> 94:14 <11:02= 95: 19<11:03> 95:23 <11:04> 100:3 <11:19> Depots [1] 93:22 <11:01> Describe [2] 11:17 <08:19> 30:12 <08:57> Described [5] 10:2 <08:17> 19:22 <08:32> 44:19 <09:23> 48:5 <09:32> 102:1 <11:23> Describing [3] 15:7<08:24> 24:11 <08:40> 38:5 <09:10> DESCRIPTION [1] 3:8 Design [1] 110:25 <11:49= Designated [1] 6:20 <08:12> DesROCHERS [1] 2:5 Destroy [1] 57:8 <09:49> Destruction [2] 57:2 <09:48> 57:5 <09:49> Details [2] 13:20 <08:22> 23:10 <08:38> Determine [6] 17:3 <08:28> 17:7 <08:28> 52:25 <09:41 > 53:8 <09:41> 88:13 <10:48> 95:1 <11:03> Determining [1] 65:12 <10:04=- Developed [1] 111:12 <11:50=* Diagnosed [1] 49:13 <09:34> Die [4] 100:19 <11:20> 101:15 <11:22> 101:24 <11:23> 102:9 <11:24> Diego [1] 96:10 <ii:06> Difference [1] 38:11 <09:11> Different [18] 26:23 <08:45> 40:22 <09:16> 40:23 <09:16> 57: 13 <09:49> 67:16 <10:07> 86:4 <10:44> 86:13 <10:44= 93:8 <11:00> 93:9 <11:00= 93:22 <11:01> 98:3<11:12> 98:8 <11:12> 98:10 <11:13= 103:22 <11:29> 103:25 <11:29> 110:12 <11:48> 111:11 <11:50> 111:11 <11:50> Differently [2] 8:10 <08:15> 97:5 <11:11> Difficult [2] 100:25 <11:21 > 101:5 <11:22> Direct [3] 14:8 <08:23> 88:14 <10:48> 88:16 <10:48> Direction [2] 65:3 <10:03> 115:11 Directly [2] 15:8 <08:24> 26:1 <08:43> Discovery [5] 5:13 <08:10> 5:17 <08:11> 23:17 <08:38> 112: 2 <11:51> 112:8 <11:51> Discussed [2] 89:1 <10:49> 89:2 <10:49> Discussion [3] 29:1 <08:50= 47:11 112: 23 Discussions [2] 6:1 <08:11> 6:3 <08:11> Disease [3] 49:13 <09:34> 52:21 <09:40> 54:12 <09:43> Diseases [2] 44:15 <09:23> 44:19 <09:23> Dispute [2] 28:2 <08:47> 107:25 <11:37> Distinguished [1] 49:4 <09:33> Distribute [1] 39:23 <09:14> Distributing [1] 43:18 <09:21= Distributor [1] 15:8 <08:24= Distributors [4] 16:7 <08:26> 16:9 <08:26> 16:22 <08:28> 16: 23 <08:28> Ditto [3] 94:10 <11:02> 95:10 <11:03> 101:7 <11:22> Division [14] 6:17 <08:12> 7:10 <08:13> 7:12 <08:13> 9:5 <08:16= 44:1 <09:22> 52:9 <09:39> 56:23 <09:48> 56: 24 <09:48> 75:17 <10:22> 75:19 <10:22> 76:11 <10:23> 76:18 <10:23= 87: 20 <10:47> 88:17 <10:49> Divisions [1] 7:11 <08:13> Dock [7] 18:16 <08:30> 24:1 <08:39> 24:5 <08:39> 104: 24<11:31> 105:22 <11:33> 106:22 <11:35> 111:16 <11:50> Docket [3] 1:6 1:12 1:16 Doctor [1] 12:18 <08:21 > Doctors [1] 12:4 <08:20> Document [17] 28:6 <08:48> 43:15 <09:21 > 45:18 <09:26> 46: 10 <09:27> 46:21 <09:28> 56:16 <09:47= 57:2<09:48> 57:4 <09:49> 57:7 <09:49> 57:9 <09:49> 57:12 <09:49> 57:13 <09:49> 57:16 <09:49> 57:23 <09:50> 80: 25 <10:34> 96:12 <11:09> 97:15 <11:11> Documentation [2] 53:4 <09:41 > 76:14 <10:23> Documents [8] 5:15 <08:10> 5:16 <08:10> 5:18 <08:11= 21:10 <08:34> 52:24 <09:40> 56: 22 <09:48= 57:10 <09:49> 77:10 <10:25> Doke [1] 5:3 <08:10> Dollar [2] 106:13 <11:34> 106:15 <11:34> Dollars [4] 15:10 <08:25> 26:10 <08:45> 90:2 <10:52> 106: 16 <11:35> Done [32] 23:2 <08:37> 24:4 <08:39> 24:7 <08:39> 24:10 <08:39> 53:11 <09:41 > 60:7 <09:54> 60:14 <09:55> 60: 15 <09:55> 60:24 <09:55> 61:4 <09:56> 61:5<09:56> 61:6<09:56> 61:19 <09:57> 64:25 <10:03> 65:1 <10:03> 65:3<10:03> 66:16 <10:05> 74:1 <10:18=- 74:3 <10:18> 74:5 <10:18> 75:17 <10:22= 81:23 <10:35> 81:24 <10:36> 90:3 <10:52> 90:8 <10:52> 90:12 <10:52> 90: 13 <10:52> 91:8 <10:54> 91: 10 <10:54> 91:12 <10:54> 96:19 <11:10> 111:10 <11:50= Door [1] 5:2 <08:10> Down [9] 11:23 <08:20> 19:11 <08:31 > 39:12 <09:13> 39: 13 <09:13> 95:5 <11:03> 95: 9<11:03> 101:16 <11:23> 104:17 <11:30> 105:11 <11:32> Downstairs [1] 108:18 <11:39> Dozen [2] 9:16 <08:17> 9:16 <08:17> Drafted [3] 20:19 <08:33> 20:19 <08:33> 20:21 <08:33> Drive [1] 6:14 <08:12> Dry [7] 18:16 <08:30> 24:1 <08:39> 24:5 <08:39> 104: 24 <11:31 > 105:22 <11:33> 106:22 <11:35> 111:16 <11:50> Due [1] 79:16 <10:31> Duly [1] 115:8 Duncan [30] 1:22 3:3 4:2 5:7 <08:10> 6:6 6:11 <08:11= 28:11 <08:48> 28:17 <08:49> 29:4 <08:55> 29:5 <08:55> 43:23 <09:22> 47:9 <09:29> 47:17 <09:30> 53:19 <09:42> 59: 14 <09:53> 63:15 <10:01> 71:20 <10:14> 73:23 <10:18> 83:19 <10:39> 89: 25 <10:51> 99:12 <11:17> 99:16 <11:17> 99:22 <11:18> 100:8 <11:19= 103: 10 <11:27> 103:20 <11:29> 106:21 <11:35=* 113:6 114:4 115:6 Duncan's [1] 104:13 <11:30> During [7] 24:24 <08:41 > 26:10 <08:45> 38:15 <09:11> 38: 16<09:11> 84:19 <10:40> 92:12 <10:58> 109:1 <11:46> Dust [1] 53:10 <09:41> _______ E_______ Early [5]7:14<08:13> 25:15 <08:42> 26:3 <08:43> 39:19 <09:13> 45:25 <09:27> Earth [1] 41:7 <09:17> Easily [1] 98:14 <11:13> East [1] 4:6 Edition [2] 3:9 28:12 Efforts [1] 99:1 <11:15> Eight [1] 93:9 <11:00> Either [9] 8:16 <08:15> 9:23 <08:17> 54:25 <09:44> 90:2 <10:52> 95:16 <11:03> 95: 19 <11:03> 105:12 <11:32> 110:24 <11:49> 110:24 <11:49> Electric [1] 14:22 <08:24= Employ [1] 52:12 <09:40= Employed [3] 39:9 <09:13= 39:14 <09:13= 39:16 <09:13= Employee [3] 8:2 <08:14= 8:3 <08:14= 57:15 <09:49= Employees [1] 51:22 <09:39= End [8] 15:25 <08:26= 16:4 <08:26= 36:2 <09:07= 36:4 <09:07= 36:6 <09:07= 36:11 <09:07= 41:14 <09:17= 41: 18 <09:18= Ended [2] 82:12 <10:36= 102:2 <11:23= Engine [6] 33:8 <09:02= 33:8 <09:02= 34:12 <09:04= 37: 13 <09:09= 84:24 <10:41 = 110:23 <11:49= Engineering [2] 45:17 <09:25= 53:18 <09:42= Engines [7] 13:24 <08:23= 14:1 <08:23= 19:11 <08:31= 19: 13 <08:31= 29:9 <08:55= 29: 9 <08:55= 32:23 <09:02= Entered [1] 69:14 <10:10= Entire [2] 15:4 <08:24= 15:5 <08:24= Entities [2] 16:15 <08:27= 16:24 <08:28= Entity [6] 70:7 <10:11= 70:14 <10:12= 71:19 <10:14= 88:2 <10:47= 105:25 <11:33= 109:23 <11:47= Entries [6] 67:17 <10:07= 74:2 <10:18= 91:15 <10:55= 94:8 <11:02= 103:11 <11:27= 103:20 <11:29= Entry [11] 81:6 <10:34= 94:16 <11:02= 99:12 <11:17= 99: 21 <11:18= 100:11 <11:19= 100:22 <11:21= 100:23 <11:21= 102:23 <11:25= 104:6 <11:29= 104:11 <11:30= 104:13 <11:30= Environmental [1] 52:8 <09:39= Equipment [9] 32:9 <09:01= 32:10 <09:01= 32:15 <09:01= 32: 16 <09:01= 32:17 <09:01= 35:3 <09:05= 36:5 <09:07= 36:7 <09:07= 45:10 <09:25= Erik [3] 2:4 5:9 <08:10= 5:25 <08:11 = ERRATA [1] 113:13 ESQUIRE [6] 2:2 2:4 2:6 2:8 2:10 2:12 Essence [1] 88:23 <10:49= Estate [1] 1:4 Et [4] 1:7 1:13 1:19 33:22 <09:03= Event [3] 11:17 <08:19= 105:10 <11:32= 115:16 Eventually [1] 81:10 <10:35= Evidence [2] 63:7 <10:00= 107:4 <11:36= Exact [5] 7:16 <08:14= 66:20 <10:06= 97:4 <11:11= 98:8 <11:12= 98:9 <11:12= Exactly [15] 9:15 <08:17= 13:19 <08:22= 15:23 <08:26= 15: 25 <08:26= 30:4 <08:56= 37: 7 <09:09= 56:13 <09:47= 56: 19 <09:48= 56:20 <09:48= 58:2 <09:50= 71:2 <10:13= 73:14 <10:17= 81:22 <10:35= 87:9 <10:46= 110:9 <11:48= Examination [5] 1:22 4:1 6:8115:10115:13 Examined [1] 115:9 Example [4] 15:19 <08:25= 61:1 <09:55= 87:22 <10:47= 97: 13 <11:11= Except [1] 101:21 <11:23= Excuse [4] 38:23 <09:12= 92:18 <10:58= 102:19 <11:25= 105:6 <11:31= Executrix [1] 1:3 Exhibit [17] 28:11 <08:48= 28:14 31: 13 <08:59= 32:3 <09:00= 47: 9 <09:29= 47:15 92:14 <10:58= 92:23 92:25 <10:59= 97:6 <11:11= 99:16 <11:17= 99:18 99:22 <11:18= 100:8 <11:19= 103: 8 103:11 <11:27= 103:12 <11:27= Exhibits [1] 103:20 <11:29= Exist [8] 7:3 <08:13= 22:13 <08:36= 63:3 <10:00= 68:25 <10:09= 69:4 <10:09= 69:6 <10:09= 79:25 <10:32= 90: 21 <10:53= Existed [3] 66:8 <10:05= 66:17 <10:05= 69:6 <10:09= Existing [6] 10:2 <08:17= 66:9 <10:05= 83:3 <10:38= 87:12 <10:46= 87:14 <10:46= 105: 21 <11:32= Exists [6] 62:25 <09:59= 63:8 <10:00= 67:13 <10:07= 78:8 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Deposition to Exists Word Index <10:28> 84:3 <10:40> 86:16 <10:44> Expected [4] 69:25 <10:11> 71:3 <10:13> 82:10 <10:36> 112: 4 <11:51=- Expenses [4] 8:13 <08:15> 11:3 <08:19> 11:8 <08:19> 11:9 <08:19> Experience [1] 25:20 <08:43> Expires [2] 114:17 115:5 Explain [7] 30:9 <08:57> 60:25 <09:55> 83:4 <10:38> 91:23 <10:56> 109:9 <11:46> 109: 12 <11:46> 110:21 <11:49> Exposure [3] 43:16 <09:21> 51:23 <09:39> 54:15 <09:44> Extent [1] 25:4 <08:41 > Extra [3] 8:9 <08:15> 8:14 <08:15> 8:15 <08:15> Eye [2] 11:22 <08:20> 91:22 <10:55> _______ F Face [2] 11:24 <08:20> 45:19 <09:26> Facilities [2] 38:18 <09:12> 109:18 <11:47> Facility [2] 77:7 <10:25> 94:11 <11:02> Fact [8] 20:7 <08:32> 21:18 <08:35> 29:11 <08:55> 38:6 <09:10> 59:6 <09:52> 70:3 <10:11 > 73:16 <10:17> 100: 1 <11:19> Fair [2]61:10<09:56> 73:16 <10:17> False [1] 35:13 <09:06> Familiar [19] 30:8 <08:57> 30:11 <08:57> 31:6 <08:58> 31:14 <08:59> 33:8<09:02> 34:10 <09:04> 34:21 <09:05> 34: 22 <09:05> 44:21 <09:23> 48:10 <09:32> 53:3 <09:41 > 54:2 <09:43> 54:3 <09:43> 62:1 <09:58> 62:4 <09:58> 62:8 <09:58> 62:10 <09:58> 62:13 <09:58> 92:1 <10:56> Families [1] 12:25 <08:21 > Family [5] 12:21 <08:21 > 12:23 <08:21> 13:7 <08:22> 17:24 <08:29> 41:21 <09:18> Far [6] 15:3 <08:24> 44:20 <09:23> 46:9 <09:27> 60:3 <09:54> 87:7 <10:46> 94:22 <11:02> Farm [1] 13:18 <08:22> Fashion [2] 73:11 <10:17> 79:6 <10:30> Fault [1] 98:19 <11:13> February [2] 91:14 <10:55> 104:20 <ii:3i> Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Fee [1] 11:2 <08:19> Few [2] 20:17 <08:33> 95:9 <11:03> Fiber [1] 53:8 <09:41> Fibers [4] 20:1 <08:32> 41:6 <09:16> 41:9 <09:17> 41:10 <09:17> Field [1] 103:2 <11:25> Fifteen [2] 9:16 <08:17> 21:24 <08:35> Fifty [2] 57:14 <09:49> 57:14 <09:49> Figure [2] 68:18 <10:09> 92:5 <10:56> Filed [4] 19:19 <08:32> 54:11 <09:43> 54:14 <09:44> 54: 18 <09:44> Files [1] 79:22 <10:32> Fill [1] 20:10 <08:33> Filled [1] 20:21 <08:33> Film [1] 64:25 <10:03> Finished [1] 33:11 <09:03> Fire [4] 38:20 <09:12> 38:24 <09:12> 39:21 <09:13> 59:6 <09:52> Firm [1] 52:12 <09:40> First [25] 9:21 <08:17> 20:3 <08:32> 20:6<08:32> 20:18 <08:33> 25:12 <08:42> 25: 16 <08:42> 31:8<08:58> 49: 7 <09:34> 54:4 <09:43> 54:6 <09:43> 54:14 <09:44> 59: 17 <09:53> 63:22 <10:01> 64:5 <10:02> 64:13 <10:02> 74:15 <10:19> 75:3<10:20> 80:24 <10:33> 93:11 <11:00> 100:11 <11:19> 100:25 <11:21> 101:16 <11:23> 101:22 <11:23> 109:15 <11:47> 115:8 Firstly [1] 33:11 <09:03> Fit [1] 110:22 <11:49> Five [14] 14:7<08:23> 14:9 <08:23> 20:4 <08:32> 34:1 <09:03> 49:8 <09:34> 49:8 <09:34> 54:6 <09:43> 54:8 <09:43> 71:12 <10:14> 80: 11 <10:33> 98:8 <11:12=- 98: 10 <11:13> 99:22 <11:18> 103:11 <11:27> Flange [3] 34:17 <09:05> 34:18 <09:05> 37:23 <09:10> Flanges [1] 35:3 <09:05> Flat [1] 47:24 <09:31> Fleet [1] 62:10 <09:58> Focus [1] 45:2 <09:24> Follows [1] 6:7 Ford [3] 15:21 <08:26> 15:21 <08:26> 15:25 <08:26> Forecast [1] 9:7 <08:16> Forecasts [1] 9:5 <08:16> Foregoing [2] 113:7 115:12 Forever [1] 57:14 <09:49> Forget [1] 30:4 <08:56> Forgot [1] 69:14 <10:10> Form [13] 29:13 <08:55> 33:15 <09:03> 46:5 <09:27> 65:23 <10:04> 77:19 <10:26> 77: 22 <10:27> 82:13 <10:36> 105:14 <11:32> 106:7 <11:34> 107:2<11:36> 111: 20 <11:51> 111:21 <11:51> 112:21 <11:52> Format [3] 78:5 <10:28> 79:24 <10:32> 80:8 <10:32> Forms [1] 41:13 <09:17> Forth [1] 115:7 Forward [4] 23:17 <08:38> 58:13 <09:51 > 74:25 <10:20> 112: 7 <11:51> Foundation [6] 39:25 <09:14> 42:13 <09:19> 48:8 <09:32> 105: 16 <11:32> 106:8 <11:34> 107:7 <11:36> Four [9] 9:22 <08:17> 14:8 <08:23> 18:5 <08:29> 49:8 <09:34> 54:8 <09:43> 56:19 <09:48> 56:21 <09:48> 80: 10 <10:33> 93:8 <11:00> Fourth [1] 95:14 <11:03> Fracture [2] 11:19 <08:19> 11:19 <08:19> Fractures [1] 11:18 <08:19> Frame [2] 79:13 <10:31> 109:1 <11:46> Frequently [2] 19:5 <08:31> 19:7 <08:31 > Friday [1] 89:6 <10:49> Front [2] 27:21 <08:47> 45:21 <09:26> Full [2] 6:10 <08:11> 15:11 <08:25> Fullest [1] 89:17 <10:51> Fully [1] 83:3 <10:38> G Garlock [4] 1:18 1:18 2:10 4:19 <08:09> Gary [1] 59:11 <09:52> Gasket [116]3:9 7:8<08:13> 14:18 <08:24> 14:18 <08:24> 15: 24 <08:26> 16:6<08:26> 16: 11 <08:27> 16:15 <08:27> 16:19 <08:27> 18:21 <08:30> 18:25 <08:30> 19:2 <08:31 > 19:15 <08:31 > 19: 18 <08:32> 19:21 <08:32> 19:25 <08:32> 24:15 <08:40> 25:13 <08:42> 26:2 <08:43> 26:2 <08:43> 26:8 <08:44> 27:14 <08:46> 27: 15 <08:46> 27:17 <08:46> 27:23 <08:47> 27:25 <08:47> 28:12 28:18 <08:49> 28:19 <08:49> 29: 21 <08:56> 30:22 <08:58> 31:1 <08:58> 31:20 <08:59> 32:16 <09:01> 32:17 <09:01 > 32:23 <09:02> 33:9 <09:02> 33:24 <09:03> 34: 12 <09:04> 34:14 <09:04> 35:19 <09:06> 35:19 <09:06> 35:22 <09:06> 35: 22 <09:06> 35:24 <09:06> 36:6 <09:07> 36:23 <09:08> 37:5 <09:09> 38:1 <09:10> 38:2 <09:10> 40:4<09:14> 40:17 <09:15> 40:25 <09:16> 41:22 <09:18> 42: 19 <09:19> 43:6<09:20> 43: 7 <09:20> 43:17 <09:21 > 43: 21 <09:22> 44:7 <09:22> 44: 8 <09:23> 45:4 <09:24> 45: 11 <09:25> 45:19 <09:26> 47:18 <09:30> 47:20 <09:30> 48:10 <09:32> 49:4 <09:33> 49:5 <09:34> 50:13 <09:36> 51:16 <09:38> 53: 12 <09:41 > 55:3 <09:44> 55: 5 <09:45> 56:11 <09:47> 58: 8 <09:50> 58:13 <09:51> 59: 18 <09:53> 60:2 <09:54> 60: 21 <09:55> 61:2<09:55> 63: 4<10:00> 63:17 <10:01> 65: 17 <10:04> 71:6 <10:13> 72: 21 <10:16> 74:10 <10:19> 74:12 <10:19> 75:8<10:21> 76:24 <10:24> 77:23 <10:27> 81:5<10:34> 83:2 <10:38> 83:23 <10:39> 84:4 <10:40> 84:6 <10:40> 84:21 <10:41> 84:22 <10:41 > 84: 25 <10:41 > 85:1 <10:41> 86: 18 <10:45> 87:19 <10:47> 88:17 <10:49> 90:2<10:52> 91:1 <10:53> 93:6 <10:59> 100:10 <11:19> 101:17 <11:23> 101:17 <11:23> 101:19 <11:23> 101:24 <11:23> 101:25 <11:23> 102:2 <11:23> 106:24 <11:36> 110:24 <11:49> 111:4 <11:49> Gaskets [60] 3:11 7:13 <08:13> 15:20 <08:25> 17:2 <08:28> 19:13 <08:31 > 19:22 <08:32> 19: 25 <08:32> 22:15 <08:37> 24:15 <08:40> 24:24 <08:41 > 25:2 <08:41> 25:13 <08:42> 26:8 <08:44> 26:9 <08:45> 29:8 <08:55> 31:17 <08:59> 32:18 <09:01 > 33: 24 <09:03> 34:15 <09:04> 34:17 <09:05> 34:18 <09:05> 34:19 <09:05> 34: 21 <09:05> 34:22 <09:05> 35:5 <09:05> 35:7 <09:06> 35:10 <09:06> 35:10 <09:06> 35:11 <09:06> 36: 13 <09:08> 36:14 <09:08> 36:15 <09:08> 36:18 <09:08> 36:22 <09:08> 40:5 <09:14> 43:4<09:20> 43:12 <09:21> 43:17 <09:21> 45: 25 <09:27> 46:12 <09:27> 47:13 48:25 <09:33> 49:2 <09:33> 53:2<09:41> 55:13 <09:45> 55:14 <09:45> 56:8 <09:46> 56:13 <09:47> 56: 15 <09:47> 63:13 <10:00> 63:13 <10:00> 74:11 <10:19> 79:16 <10:31> 83:6 Index Page 6 <10:38> 84:2 <10:39> 84:23 <10:41> 85:4 <10:41> 101: 20 <11:23> 102:6 <11:24> 107:12 <11:36> Gauges [2] 40:23 <09:16> 41:13 <09:17> General [8] 10:17 <08:18> 14:22 <08:24> 15:22 <08:26> 16: 13 <08:27> 37:10 <09:09> 41:16 <09:17> 62:1 <09:58> 71:12 <10:14> Generally [2] 10:11 <08:18> 56:24 <09:48> Generated [5]66:7<10:05> 66:8 <10:05> 66:8<10:05> 75:1 <10:20> 86:24 <10:45> Geoffroy [3] 2:12 4:15 <08:09> 4:15 <08:09> Given [8] 17:4 <08:28> 64:10 <10:02> 84:10 <10:40> 85: 22 <10:43> 86:13 <10:44> 90:25 <10:53> 109:8 <11:46> 115:17 Glasser [89] 2:2 2:2 2:2 3:3 4:6 4:6 4: 11 <08:09> 4:13 <08:09> 4: 14 <08:09> 4:16 <08:09> 4: 18 <08:09> 4:22 <08:09> 4: 25 <08:10> 5:3 <08:10> 5:10 <08:10> 6:9 <08:11 > 21:6 <08:34> 21:12 <08:34> 21: 16 <08:34> 21:17 28:9 <08:48> 28:15 28:24 <08:50> 29:3 <08:55> 29:14 <08:55> 29:17 33:10 33:17 35:16 <09:06> 35:21 40:1 <09:14> 42:14 46:6 47:8 <09:29> 47:16 48:12 <09:32> 65:25 <10:05> 66:2 66:13 <10:05> 66:15 <10:05> 67:15 <10:07> 70:2 <10:11> 72:5 <10:15> 72:10 73:9 73:22 <10:17> 81:22 <10:35> 82:2 83:18 84:16 85:9 85:19 <10:43> 86:7 86: 15 88:18 <10:49> 88:23 <10:49> 89:5 <10:49> 89:8 <10:50> 89:12 <10:50> 89: 14 90:7 90:11 91:6 92:20 <10:59> 92:24 <10:59> 93:1 94:2 97:9 <11:11> 98:6 99:6 <11:16> 99:9 <11:17> 99:11 99:15 <11:17> 99:19103:9 105:15 <11:32> 105:18107:6 <11:36> 107:9107:17 <11:37> 108:13 <11:39> 108:21 <11:39> 108:23 109:4 <11:46> 109:25 110:18 ill: 24 <11:51> 112:15 <11:52> 112:24 <11:53> Glasser's [1] 6:1 <08:11> Goods [4] 47:21 <09:31> 75:13 <10:21> 75:13 <10:21> 76: 20 <10:24> Government [10] 30:23 <08:58> 55:9 <09:45> 55:12 <09:45> 56: 12 <09:47> 60:6 <09:54> 60:! 9 <09:54> 61:2<09:55> 61: 13 <09:56> 61:15 <09:56> 61:16 <09:56> Grab [1] 108:18 <11:39> Grabbed [1] 97:8 <11:11> Grandfather [5] 13:2 <08:21 > 13:6 <08:22> 13:8 <08:22> 13:21 <08:22> 49:11 <09:34> 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Exists to Grandfather Word Index Grandfather's [1] 13:16 <08:22> Grandmother [1] 13:6 <08:22> Grocery [1] 47:22 <09:31 > Gross [1] 90:1 <10:51> Group [5] 20:14 <08:33> 54:20 <09:44> 62:19 <09:59> 88:4 <10:47> 88:6<10:48> Groups [1] 55:1 <09:44= Guess [7] 13:14 <08:22> 13:17 <08:22> 61:9 <09:56> 83:6 <10:38> 104:6 <11:29> 104: 10 <11:30> 107:12 <11:36> Guessing [1] 42:3 <09:18> Guide [3] 3:9 28:12 45:19 <09:26> H Half [3] 9:16 <08:17> 78:24 <10:29> 102:17 <11:24> Hand [2] 100:8 <11:19> 115:17 Handle [2] 14:20 <08:24> 106:5 <11:33> Handled [1] 106:12 <11:34> Handwriting [2] 104:3 <11:29> 104:9 <11:30> Handwritten [2] 69:16 <10:10> 69:21 <10:11 > Happy [2] 88:24 <10:49> 96:3 <11:05> Hard [1] 76:18 <10:23> Hazard [2] 43:9 <09:21> 43:16 <09:21 > Head [10] 27:6 <08:46> 38:1 <09:10> 38:2 <09:10> 42:3 <09:18> 45:12 45:13 <09:25> 49:19 <09:35> 49: 20 <09:35> 78:23 <10:29> 93:5 <10:59> Headquarters [3] 75:17 <10:22> 75:19 <10:22> 76:13 <10:23> Heal [1] 12:7 <08:20> Health [3] 45:5 <09:24> 48:6 <09:32> 51:22 <09:39> Hear [1] 49:7 <09:34> Heard [13] 30:5 <08:57> 49:10 <09:34> 49:21 <09:35> 54: 19 <09:44> 54:20 <09:44> 54:22 <09:44> 62:3 <09:58> 62:6 <09:58> 62:9 <09:58> 62:15 <09:58> 62:16 <09:58> 107:20 <11:37> 107:22 <11:37> Hearing [1] 5:19 <08:11> Heart [1] 11:20 <08:20> Heavy [2] 46:3 <09:27> 46:8 <09:27> Help Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 [2] 74:22 <10:20> 77:4 <10:25> Henry [2] 55:17 <09:45> 55:19 <09:46> Hereby [2] 113:6 115:5 Hereinbefore [1] 115:7 High [4] 7:19 <08:14> 33:11 <09:03> 106:13 <11:34> 106:15 <11:34= Highlighted [1] 46:21 <09:28> Hire [1] 91:8 <10:54> Hired [2] 24:13 <08:40> 24:17 <08:40> Historical [6] 63:11 <10:00> 69:2 <10:09= 78:12 <10:28> 87: 18 <10:47> 106:11 <11:34> 109:16 <11:47> History [7] 23:13 <08:38= 68:7 <10:08> 68:10 <10:08> 69:5 <10:09> 77:4 <10:25> 87:18 <10:47> 111:1 <11:49> Hold [1] 91:24 <10:56> Hope [4] 5:15 <08:10> 12:1 <08:20> 67:5 <10:06> 67:8 <10:06> Hotel [1] 11:9 <08:19> Hourly [1] 8:2 <08:14> House [9] 14:17 <08:24> 15:4 <08:24> 15:7<08:24> 15:9 <08:25> 15:13 <08:25> 15: 14 <08:25> 20:15 08:33= 56:5 <09:46> 106:13 <11:34= Human [1] 12:18 <08:21> Hundred [2] 54:17 <09:44> 100:17 <11:20> HUNTON [1] 2:11 Husband [1] 11:10 <08:19> Husband's [1] 12:13 <08:21 > Hygiene [2] 52:11 <09:40> 52:12 <09:40> I Idea [1] 24:17 <08:40> Identical [i] 97:2 <11 :i os- identification [1] 83:24 <10:39> Identified [4] 83:24 <10:39> 93:2 <10:59> 93:11 <11:00> 96: 19 <11:10> Identifies [1] 103:12 <11:27> Identify [6] 4:14 <08:09> 27:20 <08:47> 82:21 <10:37> 83: 20 <10:39> 92:15 <10:58> 97:16 <11:11> Illegible [3] 68:1 <10:07> 91:21 <10:55> 91:23 <10:56> Illinois [4] 1:7 6:15 <08:12> 6:18 <08:12> 13:18 <08:22> Immediate [1] 89:9 <10:50> Immediately [3] 21:15 <08:34> 83:17 <10:39> 89:3<10:49> Impossible [1] 92:7 <10:56> Improper [1] 112:6 <11:51> Improperly [1] 107:3 <11:36> In-camera [1] 5:19 <08:11> In-house [2] 15:14 <08:25> 20:15 <08:33> INC [2] 1:71:18 Include [7] 7:5 <08:13> 8:4 <08:14> 8:25<08:16> 9:18 <08:17> 18:24 <08:30> 29:16 <08:56> 109:1 <11:46= Included [1] 33:2 <09:02> Including [3] 29:9 <08:55> 33:2 <09:02> 47:3 <09:28> Inclusive [1] 9:3 <08:16> Incompatible [1] 79:18 <10:31> Incomplete [3] 65:13 <10:04> 65:22 <10:04> 66:5<10:05> Incorrect [1] 71:23 <10:14> Independently [1] 91:8 <10:54> Index [1] 69:10 <10:10> Indicated [5] 14:3 <08:23> 29:8 <08:55> 29:20 <08:56> 104: 15 <11:30> 106:2 <11:33> Indication [3] 23:13 <08:38> 48:19 <09:33> 112:19 <11:52> Indicative [1] 84:22 <10:41> Individual [2] 73:12 <10:17> 75:17 <10:22> Industrial [6] 29:9 <08:55> 52:11 <09:40> 52:12 <09:40> 62:4 <09:58> 62:6 <09:58> 62:10 <09:58> Industries [4] 14:23 <08:24> 29:8 <08:55> 32:4 <09:00> 32:7 <09:00> Information [32] 7:22 <08:14> 22:2 <08:35= 25:18 <08:43> 28:2 <08:47> 31:11 <08:59= 33: 23 <09:03> 35:4 <09:05> 37: 8 <09:09> 43:21 <09:22> 73: 5 <10:17> 75:25 <10:22> 76: 1 <10:22> 76:12 <10:23> 78: 4 <10:28> 78:6 <10:28> 78: 16 <10:29> 78:20 <10:29> 78:25 <10:29> 79:20 <10:31> 80:1 <10:32> 80:3 <10:32> 81:17 <10:35> 81: 18 <10:35> 87:14 <10:46> 87:17 <10:47> 92:2<10:56> 96:22 <11:10> 97:2<11:10> 97:4 <11:11> 98:8 <11:12> 98:10 <11:13> 99:4 <11:15> Initiative [1] 61:17 <09:56> Injuries [2] 11:16 <08:19> 12:14 <08:21= Injury [1] 54:12 <09:43> Inquiry [3] 5:20 <08:11> 21:4 <08:34> 105:10 <11:32> Install [2] 49:2 <09:33> 55:4 <09:45> Installation [1] 53:1 <09:41 > Installed [4] 19:3 <08:31 > 36:13 <09:08> 36:15 <09:08> 36: 16 <09:08> Installing [1] 45:3 <09:24> Instance [2] 68:19<10:09> 92:13 <10:58> Instances [2] 36:10 <09:07> 36:11 <09:07> Instant [1] 92:25 <10:59> Instructed [2] 105:9 <11:32= 105:19 <11:32> Instructions [3] 48:25 <09:33> 49:2 <09:33> 49:3 <09:33> Intend [2] 111:19 <11:51> 111:23 <11:51> Intended [3] 37:16 <09:09> 37:17 <09:09> 69:16 <10:10> Intends [1] 112:20 <11:52> Interchange [1] 78:13 <10:28> Interested [2] 40:13<09:15> 115:16 Internal [3] 32:23 <09:02> 83:2 <10:38> 83:25 <10:39> Interrupt [1] 93:25 <11:01> Intervening [1] 84:19 <10:40> Introduce [1] 5:6 <08:10> Introduced [1] 18:8 <08:30> Inventoried [1] 50:1 <09:35> Inventory [2] 25:5 <08:41 > 77:17 <10:26> Invoice [6] 58:15 <09:51> 75:14 <10:21=- 76:3 <10:22> 76:20 <10:24> 82:13 <10:36> 82: 18 <10:37> Invoices [22] 57:11 <09:49> 57:24 <09:50> 58:4 <09:50> 58:6 <09:50> 58:6 <09:50> 58:8 <09:50> 58:22 <09:51> 58: 25 <09:52> 59:3<09:52> 59: 4 <09:52> 59:5 <09:52> 59:8 <09:52> 63:14 <10:01> 74: 20 <10:20> 74:25 <10:20> 75:6 <10:21> 75:12 <10:21 = 79:9 <10:30> 79:12 <10:30> 79:14 <10:31> 82:17 <10:36> 82:17 <10:36> Involve [2] 14:13 <08:23> 14:16 <08:23> Index Page 7 Involved [8] 23:10 <08:38> 23:14 <08:38> 23:23 <08:39> 24:7 <08:39> 26:1 <08:43> 50:18 <09:37= 76:5 <10:22> 77:10 <10:25> Involves [1] 23:7 <08:37> Involving [1] 105:22 <11:33=- Irvin [1] 50:25 <09:37> Issue [2] 22:12 <08:36> 112:5 <11:51=- Issued [5] 21:7 <08:34= 27:23 <08:47= 69:22 <10:11= 74: 21 <10:20= 94:10 <11:02= Issues [1] 52:21 <09:40= Items [3] 14:20 <08:24= 104:19 <11:31= 104:21 <11:31 = Itself [5] 16:3 <08:26= 27:14 <08:46= 48:17 <09:32= 48: 23 <09:33= 112:5 <11:51 = J Jack [1] 51:5 <09:37= January [2] 9:23 <08:17= 115:5 Jaw [1] 12:9 <08:20= Job [9] 8:6 <08:15= 8:20 <08:15= 25:5 <08:41= 64:4 <10:02= 81:13 <10:35= 81: 16 <10:35= 82:5 <10:36= 82: 10 <10:36= 82:11 <10:36= John [4] 2:10 4:17 <08:09= 4:18 <08:09= 4:20 <08:09= Joint [1] 37:13 <09:09= JR [1] 1:10 June [2] 44:6 <09:22= 44:12 <09:23= Justify [2] 15:10 <08:25= 106:4 <11:33= K Karen [1] 5:4 <08:10= Keep [7] 48:1 <09:31= 57:1 <09:48= 58:20 <09:51= 58: 20 <09:51= 58:21 <09:51= 63:11 <10:00= 63:14 <10:01= Keepers [1]63:9 <10:00= Keeping [7] 25:6 <08:42= 65:15 <10:04= 77:13 <10:26= 77: 16 <10:26= 81:12 <10:35= 109:13 <11:46= 111:12 <11:50= Kendall [1] 6:14 <08:12= Kept [8] 17:9 <08:28= 17:10 <08:28= 56:24 <09:48= 58: 10 <09:51= 71:8 <10:13= 75: 2 <10:20= 75:22 <10:22= 85: 24 <10:43= Kerner [3] 55:17 <09:45= 55:19 1625 Unique Words.TD. Firm Name Here From Grandfather's to Kerner Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 8 <09:46> 56:3 <09:46> Kind [2] 15:16 <08:25= 78:24 <10:29> Kinds [1] 26:23 <08:45> Kit [2] 16:10 <08:27> 50:19 <09:37> Kits [1] 49:1 <09:33> Knowing [2] 28:7 <08:48> 107:11 <11:36> Knowledge [27] 15:18 <08:25> 24:13 <08:40> 25:21 <08:43> 25: 22 <08:43> 33:21 <09:03> 34:2 <09:04> 34:7 <09:04= 36:8<09:07> 39:22 <09:14> 48:4 <09:32> 49:12 <09:34> 49:15 <09:35> 49:22 <09:35> 52:13 <09:40> 53: 15 <09:42> 56:10 <09:47> 64:16 <10:02> 66:25 <10:06> 71:21 <10:14> 80: 24 <10:33> 87:13 <10:46> 90:6 <10:52= 91:11 <10:54> 92:1 <10:56> 102:11 <11:24> 102:14 <11:24> 110:14 <11:48> Knowledgeable [1] 24:14 <08:40> Known [1] 30:14 <08:57= Kucharski [1] 53:17 <09:42> L Lack [6] 39:25 <09:14> 42:12 <09:19> 48:8 <09:32= 83:7 <10:38> 106:7 <11:34> 107: 7 <11:36> Language [2] 79:5 <10:30> 100:15 <11:20> Large [9] 4:4 32:4 <09:00> 32:6 <09:00> 86:21 <10:45> 106: 5 <11:33> 106:9 <11:34> 114:6 115:1 115:3 Largest [5] 27:15 <08:46> 27:24 <08:47> 28:18 <08:49> 28: 21 <08:49> 46:11 <09:27> Larry [1] 50:25 <09:37> Last [17] 14:8 <08:23> 20:17 <08:33> 24:7 <08:39> 32:3 <09:00> 54:5 <09:43> 54:6 <09:43> 54:8 <09:43> 57:15 <09:49> 68:4 <10:07> 68:4 <10:07> 68:13 <10:08> 71: 11 <10:14> 95:18 <11:03> 97:18 <11:11> 103:11 <11:27= 104:19 <11:31> 104:20 <11:31 > Late [1] 55:24 <09:46> Latter [1] 108:20 <11:39> Law [4] 1:6 1:12 1:16 50:16 <09:36> Lawsuit [1] 54:14 <09:44> Lawyer [1] 5:5 <08:10> Lawyers [1] 20:20 <08:33> Lay [1] 78:1 <10:27> Laying [1] 47:24 <09:31 > Layman's [1] 80:8 <10:32> Learn [2] 63:22 <10:01= 64:5 <10:02> Least [5] 5:11 <08:10> 45:23 <09:27> 68:12 <10:08> 109: 22 <11:47> 112:1 <11:51> LeCLAIR [1] 2:4 Lee [1] 6:11 <08:11= Left [1] 73:3 <10:16> Legal [2] 20:14 <08:33> 40:15 <09:15= Legible [3] 79:24 <10:32> 80:8 <10:32> 92:4 <10:56> Length [1] 17:15 <08:29> Less [4] 18:14 <08:30> 68:19 <10:09> 77:13 <10:26> 106: 3<11:33> Level [1] 76:18 <10:23> Life [3] 37:7 <09:09> 71:4 <10:13> 71:5 <10:13> Light [1] 46:8 <09:27> Limit [4] 34:8 <09:04> 34:8 <09:04> 38:6<09:10> 38:8 <09:11=- Limitations [1] 38:5 <09:10> Limited [1] 38:1 <09:10> Limits [I] 38:7 <09:10> Line [18] 12:7 <08:20> 28:16 <08:49> 68:5 <10:08> 69:10 <10:10> 81:6 <10:34> 91:15 <10:55> 94:4 <11:01= 95:9 <11:03> 95:12 <11:03> 95: 14 <11:03=- 95:18 <11:03> 100:25 <11:21> 101:22 <11:23> 102:5 <11:23> 102: 20 <11:25> 102:21 <11:25= 102:23 <11:25= 113:16 Lines [II] 68:9 <10:08= 68:13 <10:08= 68:15 <10:08= 68: 16 <10:08= 68:17 <10:09= 68:22 <10:09= 69:21 <10:11= 73:24 <10:18= 93:6 <10:59= 93:18 <11:01= 99: 22 <11:18= Lisle [6] 6:18 <08:12= 6:19 <08:12= 6:19 <08:12= 56:24 <09:48= 56:25 <09:48= 94: 25 <11:03= List [46] 30:14 <08:57= 30:17 <08:57= 30:20 <08:57= 30: 24 <08:58= 32:11 <09:01= 59:15 <09:53= 59:19 <09:53= 60:1 <09:54= 60:4 <09:54= 60:6 <09:54= 60:22 <09:55= 61:6 <09:56= 61:12 <09:56= 61:14 <09:56= 61: 17 <09:56= 61:18 <09:56= 70:5 <10:11= 70:7 <10:11 = 70:20 <10:12= 70:20 <10:12= 86:16 <10:44= 86: 19 <10:45= 86:21 <10:45= 86:25 <10:45= 88:3 <10:47= 88:7 <10:48= 88:21 <10:49= 89:13 <10:50= 89:20 <10:51= 93:17 <11:01= 94: 12 <11:02= 95:24 <11:04= 97:1 <11:10= 97:14 <11:11= 97:22 <11:12= 98:23 <11:15= 99:23 <11:18= 100: 5 <11:19= 100:6 <11:19= 103:3 <11:25= 103:14 <11:27= 104:16 <11:30= 109:1 <11:46= 109:8 <11:46= 111:5 <11:50= 111: 9 <11:50= Listed [11] 30:24 <08:58= 57:13 <09:49= 88:8 <10:48= 88:9 <10:48= 88:15 <10:48= 94: 22 <11:02= 96:1 <11:04= 101:23 <11:23= 102:5 <11:23= 109:11 <11:46= 109:24 <11:47= Listee [1] 59:25 <09:53= Listen [1] 84:7 <10:40= Listing [6] 22:10 <08:36= 24:8 <08:39= 87:24 <10:47= 93:8 <11:00= 94:4 <11:01= 97:18 <11:11= Listings [3] 87:23 <10:47= 97:3 <11:10= 98:2 <11:12= Lists [11] 32:10 <09:01= 32:12 <09:01= 44:22 <09:24= 93:6 <10:59= 93:9 <11:00= 97:8 <11:11= 98:7 <11:12= 100: 19 <11:20= 100:19 <11:20= 101:4 <11:22= 111:11 <11:50= Litigation [3] 20:10 <08:33= 80:23 <10:33= 81:1 <10:34= Live [2] 6:14 <08:12= 13:1 <08:21 = Lived [2] 13:12 <08:22= 13:15 <08:22= Lives [1] 12:24 <08:21= LLC [1] 1:19 LLP [2] 2:5 2:7 Loaded [1] 109:18 <11:47= Local [1] 77:8 <10:25= Located [1] 94:5 <11:02= Location [6] 93:17 <11:01= 93:18 <11:01= 95:4 <11:03= 95:8 <11:03= 106:1 <11:33= 107: 13 <11:37= Locations [2] 38:14 <09:11= 95:21 <11:04= Logo [2] 42:24 <09:20= 43:1 <09:20= Logos [1] 42:18 <09:19= Long-term [2] 40:10 <09:15= 40:12 <09:15= Look [26] 17:14 <08:29= 21:9 <08:34= 58:3 <09:50= 58:23 <09:51= 59:1 <09:52= 59:3 <09:52= 59:4 <09:52= 68:23 <10:09= 77:2 <10:24= 79:1 <10:29= 79:3 <10:30= 80:1 <10:32= 80:4 <10:32= 80:6 <10:32= 80:6 <10:32= 95:20 <11:04= 95:23 <11:04= 97: 25 <11:12= 98:17 <11:13= 104:23 <11:31= 105:1 <11:31= 105:4 <11:31= 105: 5 <11:31= 105:6 <11:31= 105:20 <11:32= 108:19 <11:39= Looked [10] 34:11 <09:04= 64:20 <10:03= 67:22 <10:07= 67: 25 <10:07= 68:12 <10:08= 68:15 <10:08= 68:17 <10:09= 68:19 <10:09= 104: 19 <11:31= 110:15 <11:48= Looking [6] 70:24 <10:13= 95:3 <11:03= 96:15 <11:10= 97: 25 <11:12= 98:15 <11:13= 103:18 <11:27= Looks [7] 47:22 <09:31= 93:4 <10:59= 93:8 <11:00= 101:3 <11:21= 101:8 <11:22= 102: 25 <11:25= 103:6 <11:26= Loss [1] 110:20 <11:49= Lost [4] 72:23 <10:16= 72:24 <10:16= 101:9 <11:22= 101: 11 <11:22= Lunch [1] 108:18 <11:39= Lying [1] 107:1 <11:36= M Ma'am [4] 21:21 <08:35= 40:20 <09:16= 43:13 <09:21= 46: 23 <09:28= Magnifies [1] 91:25 <10:56= Magnifying [1] 91:25 <10:56= MAHONEY [1] 2:9 Main [1] 4:6 Maintained [8] 15:13 <08:25= 58:17 <09:51= 76:1 <10:22= 76:11 <10:23= 76:13 <10:23= 76: 17 <10:23= 76:21 <10:24= 79:9 <10:30= Maintenance [1] 64:2 <10:02= Managed [1] 8:22 <08:15= Manager [10] 6:17 <08:12= 8:7 <08:15= 15:11 <08:25= 52:8 <09:39= 55:19 <09:46= 59: 12 <09:52= 64:1 <10:01= 64: 10 <10:02= 106:12 <11:34= 106:19 <11:35= Manner [1] 71:7 <10:13= Manners [1] 98:10 <11:13= Manual [4] 65:15 <10:04= 77:13 <10:26= 77:16 <10:26= 109: 13 <11:46= Manufacture [5] 39:6 <09:12= 39:23 <09:14= 40:22 <09:16= 74: 21 <10:20= 76:15 <10:23= Manufactured [16] 18:22 <08:30= 26:2 <08:43= 26:24 <08:45= 36: 18 <09:08= 36:20 <09:08= 38:13 <09:11= 39:2 <09:12= 42:10 <09:19= 42:19_______ <09:19= 49:24 <09:35= 51: 15 <09:38= 53:13 <09:42= 53:21 <09:42= 55:6 <09:45= 58:18 <09:51= 75:13 <10:21= Manufacturer [7] 18:24 <08:30= 27:15 <08:46= 27:25 <08:47= 28: 19 <08:49= 36:5 <09:07= 36: 7 <09:07= 46:11 <09:27= Manufacturing [17] 7:8 <08:13= 16:20 <08:27= 17:2 <08:28= 19:8 <08:31= 27:14 <08:46= 27: 17 <08:46= 27:23 <08:47= 28:18 <08:49= 39:4 <09:12= 40:4 <09:14= 43:18 <09:21= 55:3 <09:44= 58:24 <09:52= 63:9 <10:00= 65:17 <10:04= 76:21 <10:24= 87:19 <10:47= Marcella [8] 1:22 3:3 4:1 6:6 6:11 <08:11= 113:6114:4115:6 Marcy [5] 5:7 <08:10= 63:15 <10:01= 89:2 <10:49= 97:21 <11:12= 104:13 <11:30= Marine [1] 29:9 <08:55= Mark [5] 42:21 <09:20= 50:8 <09:36= 92:18 <10:58= 92: 21 <10:59= 99:16 <11:17= Marked [13] 28:11 <08:48= 28:14 29: 5 <08:55= 42:22 <09:20= 42: 24 <09:20= 43:1 <09:20= 43: 2 <09:20= 47:14 92:23 92:25 <10:59= 99:18103:8 103:10 <11:27= Market [1] 32:24 <09:02= Markets [1] 33:7 <09:02= Markings [1] 42:18 <09:19= Marks [3] 94:10 <11:02= 95:10 <11:03= 101:7 <11:22= Masks [1] 45:14 <09:25= Master [13] 22:9 <08:36= 89:20 <10:51= 95:20 <11:04= 96: 24 <11:10= 97:1 <11:10= 97: 18 <11:11= 99:23 <11:18= 100:5 <11:19= 100:6 <11:19= 104:16 <11:30= 108:25 <11:45= 109:8 <11:46= 110:10 <11:48= Material [66] 14:19 <08:24= 16:15 <08:27= 17:10 <08:28= 17: 11 <08:28= 18:21 <08:30= 19:15 <08:31= 19:18 <08:32= 24:24 <08:41= 25: 13 <08:42= 25:13 <08:42= 26:2 <08:43= 29:22 <08:56= 30:18 <08:57= 30:22 <08:58= 30:23 <08:58= 31:1 <08:58= 31:5 <08:58= 33:4 <09:02= 35:23 <09:06= 35: 24 <09:06= 36:23 <09:08= 37:1 <09:08= 37:25 <09:10= 38:2 <09:10= 39:5 <09:12= 39:24 <09:14= 40:21 <09:16= 41:22 <09:18= 42:6 <09:19= 42:19 <09:19= 42: 21 <09:20= 43:4 <09:20= 43: 7 <09:20= 43:17 <09:21= 43: 20 <09:22= 44:7 <09:22= 44: 8 <09:23= 45:11 <09:25= 46: 4 <09:27= 46:20 <09:28= 49: 4 <09:33= 49:5 <09:34= 50: 13 <09:36= 51:16 <09:38= 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Kerner to Material Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 9 53:12 <09:41 > 56:12 <09:47> 59:18 <09:53> 60:2 <09:54> 60:21 <09:55> 61:1 <09:55> 61:2 <09:55> 61:8 <09:56> 62:25 <09:59> 63:4 <10:00> 63:17 <10:01> 68: 21 <10:09> 72:22 <10:16> 75:9 <10:21> 75:10 <10:21> 81:5<10:34> 85:4 <10:41> 91:1 <10:53> 92:11 <10:58> 92:12 <10:58> 102:3 <11:23> 106:24 <11:36> Materials [45] 14:13 <08:23> 15:5 <08:24> 16:18 <08:27> 17:1 <08:28> 18:25 <08:30> 19:2 <08:31 > 19:25 <08:32> 21:7 <08:34> 24:15 <08:40> 26:8 <08:44> 26:23 <08:45> 26: 24 <08:45> 30:2 <08:56> 30: 20 <08:57> 30:20 <08:57> 30:24 <08:58> 31:20 <08:59> 33:21 <09:03> 33: 25 <09:03> 39:2<09:12> 39: 7 <09:13> 40:17 <09:15> 40: 25 <09:16> 41:17 <09:17> 43:22 <09:22> 44:22 <09:24> 44:24 <09:24> 45:4 <09:24> 46:15 <09:27> 46: 17 <09:28> 48:11 <09:32> 50:22 <09:37> 50:23 <09:37> 53:7 <09:41 > 53:21 <09:42> 55:5 <09:45> 55:11 <09:45> 58:13 <09:51> 61:8 <09:56> 61:23 <09:58> 69:3 <10:09> 76:24 <10:24> 82: 24 <10:37> 85:1 <10:41> 86: 18 <10:45> Matter [1] 112:2 <11:51> Matters [1] 5:14 <08:10> Maynard [1] 1:4 McCAMBRIDGE [1] 2:9 McLean [2] 1:3 1:4 Mean [11] 63:5 <10:00> 69:15 <10:10> 72:24 <10:16> 79: 10 <10:30> 82:18 <10:37> 83:8 <10:38> 89:9<10:50> 97:19 <11:11> 101:10 <11:22> 103:1 <11:25> 112: 4 <11:51> Meaningful [1] 79:6 <10:30> Means [5] 30:4 <08:56> 59:15 <09:53> 65:12 <10:04> 89: 10 <10:50= 101:11 <11:22> Measured [2] 26:9 <08:45= 90:2 <10:52> Mechanic [1] 13:25 <08:23> Medical [1] 52:20 <09:40> Medicine [1] 11:20 <08:20> Meet [4] 9:4 <08:16> 21:24 <08:35> 29:23 <08:56> 111: 12 <11:50> Meeting [1] 9:6 <08:16> Member [1] 54:25 <09:44> Mention [2] 11:1 <08:19> 45:9 <09:25> Mentioned [4] 12:20 <08:21 > 44:19 <09:23> 49:11 <09:34> 108: 24 <11:45> Mesothelioma [3] 44:16 <09:23> 49:7 <09:34> 54:5 <09:43> Met [5] 29:12 <08:55> 29:20 <08:56> 29:25 <08:56> 30:2 <08:56> 41:3 <09:16> Metal [1] 47:24 <09:31> Method [1] 65:18 <10:04= Methods [1] 28:22 <08:49> Mexican [1] 42:10 <09:19> Mexico [1] 42:8 <09:19> Micas [1] 41:7 <09:17> Microfiche [32] 17:5<08:28> 17:8 <08:28> 17:13 <08:29> 22:8 <08:36> 22:9 <08:36> 22:12 <08:36> 63:22 <10:01> 64:6 <10:02> 64:12 <10:02> 64: 17 <10:02> 64:19 <10:03> 64:21 <10:03> 64:25 <10:03> 66:16 <10:05= 67: 17 <10:07> 68:8 <10:08> 68: 20 <10:09> 74:1 <10:18> 74: 3<10:18> 81:7 <10:34> 82: 12 <10:36> 85:13 <10:42> 85:21 <10:43> 85:25 <10:43> 91:9 <10:54> 91:16 <10:55> 91:22 <10:55> 91: 24 <10:56> 92:6 <10:56> 93: 5 <10:59> 104:12 <11:30> 111:7 <11:50> Microfiched [9] 65:10 <10:04> 65:14 <10:04> 69:20 <10:10> 72: 25 <10:16> 73:25 <10:18> 74:8 <10:18> 81:11 <10:35> 82:21 <10:37> 92:17 <10:58> Might [9] 8:8 <08:15> 21:3 <08:34> 39:11 <09:13> 75:5 <10:21 > 76:9 <10:23> 80:13 <10:33> 80:22 <10:33> 80: 22 <10:33> 107:4 <11:36> Mil [1] 31:7 <08:58> Military [8] 29:12 <08:55> 29:21 <08:56> 29:23 08:56= 29: 25 <08:56> 30:2 <08:56> 30: 18 <08:57> 31:2<08:58> 31: 9 <08:58> Millboard [6] 31:14 <08:59= 31:15 <08:59> 46:24 <09:28> 47:2 <09:28= 47:5 <09:28> 47:6 <09:28> Million [2] 46:24 <09:28> 106:16 <11:35> Mills [2] 50:18 <09:37> 50:19 <09:37> Mind [1] 35:23 <09:06> Minute [1] 76:7 <10:23> Minutes [2] 96:13 <11:09= 108:14 <11:39> Miscellaneous [1] 56:7 <09:46> Misrepresentation [1] 109:8 <11:46> Miss [1] 4:24 <08:10> Missing [5] 67:1 <10:06> 67:4 <10:06> 67:4 <10:06> 67:6 <10:06= 86:10 <10:44> Misspoken [1] 39:11 <09:13> Misstated [1] 76:9 <10:23> Mistaken [1] 107:1 <11:36> Mode [1] 35:5 <09:05> Modify [1] 55:4 <09:45> Modifying [1] 45:4 <09:24> Moment [2] 5:11 <08:10> 99:6 <11:16> Monday [4] 12:15 <08:21> 22:18 <08:37> 89:9<10:50> 112: 18 <11:52> Morning [6] 4:11 <08:09> 4:12 <08:09> 4:16<08:09> 4:18 <08:09> 11:13 <08:19> 12: 15 <08:21 > Most [2] 24:14 <08:40> 89:17 <10:51= Mother [1] 13:7 <08:22> Mother's [1] 12:24 <08:21> Motor [1] 15:21 <08:26> Motors [2] 15:22 <08:26> 16:13 <08:27= Moved [1] 13:6 <08:22> MSDS [8] 43:19 <09:21 > 43:24 <09:22> 44:1 <09:22> 44:3 <09:22= 44:10 <09:23> 44: 16 <09:23> 44:21 <09:23> 45:3 <09:24> Multi [1] 106:16 <11:35> Multiple [7] 12:4 <08:20> 35:25 <09:07= 37:15 <09:09> 38:6 <09:10> 38:7 <09:10> 96:17 <11:10= 97:3 <11:10> N Nadolink [6] 2:4 5:9 <08:10> 5:9 <08:10= 5:25 <08:11> 5:25 <08:11= 21:9<08:34> Naked [1] 91:22 <10:55> Name [18] 6:10 <08:11> 8:17 <08:15> 17:22 <08:29> 18: 17 <08:30> 32:1 <09:00> 43: 2 <09:20> 43:3 <09:20> 62: 19 <09:59> 70:5 <10:11> 70: 7 <10:11> 70:21 <10:13> 83: 1 <10:37> 85:23 <10:43> 86: 12<10:44> 87:22 <10:47> 92:3 <10:56> 106:1 <11:33> 111:9 <11:50> Named [2] 22:24 <08:37> 115:6 Namely [2] 10:2 <08:17> 109:2 <11:46> Names [4] 7:11 <08:13> 51:9 <09:38> 67:19 <10:07> 111: 16<11:50> National [1] 96:11 <11:07> Naturally [1] 12:8 <08:20> Nature [2] 8:20 <08:15> 20:23 <08:34> Naval [21] 13:8<08:22> 17:21 <08:29> 23:23 <08:39> 92:9 <10:57= 92:12 <10:58> 93: 15 <11:01> 93:16 <11:01> 94:4<11:01> 94:13 <11:02> 95:5 <11:03> 95:11 <11:03> 95:15 <11:03> 95:18 <11:03> 95:23 <11:04> 96:9 <11:06> 100:3 <11:19> 100: 3 <11:19> 100:3 <11:19> 100:4 <11:19> 106:6 <11:34=- 106:23 <11:36> Navy [35] 35:9 <09:06> 35:11 <09:06> 35:12 <09:06> 35: 20 <09:06> 56:4 <09:46= 56: 8 <09:46= 56:14 <09:47= 56: 15 <09:47= 61:21 <09:58= 61:24 <09:58= 62:8 <09:58= 62:17 <09:59= 70:18 <10:12= 70:20 <10:12= 70: 21 <10:13= 87:22 <10:47= 87:23 <10:47= 88:2 <10:47= 88:6 <10:48= 93:12 <11:00= 93:12 <11:00= 93:19 <11:01= 94:16 <11:02= 94: 17 <11:02= 96:9 <11:06= 96: 10 <11:06= 99:21 <11:18= 99:23 <11:18= 100:23 <11:21= 101:7 <11:22= 102: 18 <11:24= 105:6 <11:31 = 105:7 <11:32= 106:6 <11:34= 110:6 <11:48= Near [1] 71:8 <10:13= Necessarily [3] 89:23 <10:51= 96:1 <11:04= 109:12 <11:46= Necessary [1] 29:16 <08:56= Need [8] 5:21 <08:11= 11:11 <08:19= 29:23 <08:56= 30: 13 <08:57= 30:16 <08:57= 37:8 <09:09= 78:13 <10:28= 110:23 <11:49= Needed [1] 12:6 <08:20= Needs [3] 38:8 <09:11= 38:9 <09:11= 111:13 <11:50= Never [16] 24:22 <08:41= 25:9 <08:42= 25:25 <08:43= 34: 11 <09:04= 39:9 <09:13= 48: 13 <09:32= 48:13 <09:32= 48:19 <09:33= 48:22 <09:33= 53:4 <09:41= 59:2 <09:52= 62:3 <09:58= 62:15 <09:58= 78:14 <10:29= 82:7 <10:36= 104:11 <11:30= New [2] 84:4 <10:40= 84:4 <10:40= Newport [25] 1:2 6:3 <08:11= 10:15 <08:18= 10:24 <08:18= 17: 18 <08:29= 17:20 <08:29= 17:20 <08:29= 22:17 <08:37= 22:24 <08:37= 23: 25 <08:39= 24:5 <08:39= 104:23 <11:31= 105:1 <11:31= 105:4 <11:31= 105: 5 <11:31= 105:7 <11:32= 105:11 <11:32= 105:21 <11:32= 105:22 <11:33= 105:25 <11:33= 105:25 <11:33= 106:22 <11:35= 108:1 <11:37= 111:15 <11:50= 111:17 <11:50= News [25] 1:2 6:4 <08:11= 10:16 <08:18= 10:24 <08:18= 17: 18 <08:29= 17:20 <08:29= 17:20 <08:29= 22:17 <08:37= 22:24 <08:37= 23: 25 <08:39= 24:5 <08:39= 104:24 <11:31= 105:1 <11:31= 105:4 <11:31= 105: 5 <11:31= 105:7 <11:32= 105:11 <11:32= 105:21 <11:32= 105:22 <11:33= 105:25 <11:33= 105:25 <11:33= 106:22 <11:35= 108:2 <11:38= 111:15 <11:50= 111:17 <11:50= Next [6] 10:6 <08:18= 94:8 <11:02= 94:16 <11:02= 100: 22 <11:21= 100:23 <11:21= 101:6 <11:22= Nobody [1] 5:2 <08:10= Non [1] 49:5 <09:34= Nonasbestos [1] 41:17 <09:17= None [2] 65:7 <10:03= 104:13 <11:30= Noon [1] 89:8 <10:50= Norfolk [17] 1:24 4:7 17:21 <08:29= 18:15 <08:30= 23:23 <08:39= 92:9 <10:57= 92:11 <10:58= 93:12 <11:00= 95: 10 <11:03= 95:11 <11:03= 96:9 <11:06= 100:4 <11:19= 106:6 <11:34= 106:23 <11:36= 110:6 <11:48= 115: 4 115:7 Norfolkco [1] 18:18 <08:30= Normal [5] 17:8 <08:28= 66:19 <10:05= 71:18 <10:14= 81: 13 <10:35= 111:11 <11:50= Normally [1] 11:22 <08:20= Norshipco [2] 18:19 <08:30= 18:20 <08:30= North [1] 16:25 <08:28= Nose [1] 11:19 <08:19= Notarial [1] 115:17 Notary [4] 4:3 114:15 115:2 115:21 Notation [4] 69:10 <10:10= 81:10 <10:35= 102:6 <11:24= 102: 13 <11:24= Note [1] 66:13 <10:05= Noted [3] 65:25 <10:05= 107:6 <11:36= 113:8 Notes [2] 108:15 <11:39= 108:19 <11:39= Nothing [6] 8:7 <08:15= 8:15 <08:15= 12:9 <08:20= 33:13 <09:03= 109:23 <11:47= 112:25 <11:54= Notice [3] 10:13 <08:18= 21:6 <08:34= 21:10 <08:34= Notified [1] 12:15 <08:21= Notify [1] 12:13 <08:21= 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Material to Notify Word Index November [5] 6:16 <08:12> 22:25 <08:37> 23:3 <08:37> 24:11 <08:40> 105:12 <11:32> Number [51] 17:10 <08:28> 17:11 <08:28> 17:11 <08:28> 28: 11 <08:48> 29:5 <08:55> 29: 8 <08:55> 32:3 <09:00> 40: 16 <09:15> 41:18 <09:18> 43:5 <09:20> 47:9 <09:29> 68:2 <10:07> 68:3 <10:07> 68:5 <10:08> 68:14 <10:08> 74:5 <10:18> 74:10 <10:19> 74:11 <10:19> 74:12 <10:19> 74:13 <10:19> 74: 16 <10:19> 74:18 <10:19> 79:16 <10:31> 82:25 <10:37> 83:2<10:38> 83:2 <10:38> 83:5 <10:38> 83:25 <10:39> 84:1 <10:39> 84:5 <10:40> 84:17 <10:40> 84: 19 <10:40> 84:23 <10:41 > 84:25 <10:41> 85:2 <10:41> 92:25 <10:59> 93:6 <10:59> 96:19 <11:10> 98:3 <11:12> 99:16 <11:17> 99:22 <11:18> 100:7 <11:19> 100: 19<11:20> 101:4 <11:22> 101:14 <11:22> 101:25 <11:23> 102:9 <11:24> 102: 24 <11:25> 103:2 <11:25> 103:2 <11:25> 111:2 <11:49> Numbered [4] 74:9 <10:18> 74:10 <10:19> 74:15 <10:19> 74: 15 <10:19> Numbering [1] 84:5<10:40> Numbers [7] 41:12 <09:17> 74:11 <10:19> 82:23 <10:37> 83:8 <10:38> 83:9<10:38> 83:22 <10:39> 110:22 <11:49> o O'Donnell [6] 2:8 4:12 <08:09> 4:21 <08:09> 4:21 <08:09> 4:23 <08:09> 5:1 <08:10> Oath [2] 73:14 <10:17> 115:9 Object [27] 29:13 <08:55> 33:5 <09:02> 33:15 <09:03> 35: 15<09:06> 35:16 <09:06> 39:25 <09:14> 42:12 <09:19> 46:5 <09:27> 48:8 <09:32> 65:23 <10:04> 66: 10 <10:05> 67:10 <10:06> 69:17 <10:10> 73:6<10:17> 81:20 <10:35> 81:25 <10:36> 84:13 <10:40> 85:7 <10:41 > 85:15 <10:42> 90: 10 <10:52> 105:14 <11:32> 106:7 <11:34> 107:2 <11:36> 108:4 <11:38> 108: 6 <11:38> 110:17 <11:49> 111:20 <11:51> Objection [10] 29:14 <08:55> 65:25 <10:05> 66:13 <10:05> 73: 20 <10:17> 86:3 <10:43> 86: 11 <10:44> 105:15 <11:32> 105:17 <11:32> 107:6 <11:36> 107:16 <11:37> Obsolete [1] 78:17 <10:29> Obtaining [1] 59:22 <09:53> Obviously [1] 91:25 <10:56> Occasion [1] 59:3 <09:52> Occurred Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 [1] 19:6 <08:31> OE [1] 16:13 <08:27> OER [2] 32:9 <09:01 > 32:10 <09:01 > Offer [2] 47:8 <09:29> 104:18 <11:31> Offering [1] 59:2 <09:52> Office [5] 5:1 <08:10> 5:5 <08:10> 6:18 <08:12> 83:11 <10:38> 94:25 <11:03> Officer [1] 62:18 <09:59> Offices [2] 4:5 56:25 <09:48> 011 [4] 19:8 <08:31> 46:12 <09:27> 77:15 <10:26> 109: 15 <11:47> Oilseals [2] 3:11 47:13 Okey [1] 5:3 <08:10> Okey-doke [1] 5:3 <08:10> Old [5] 7:7 <08:13> 17:9 <08:28> 18:1 <08:29> 34:1 <09:03> 74:2 <10:18> Once [3] 9:7 <08:16> 57:6 <09:49> 112:16 <11:52> One [73] 5:12 <08:10> 11:1 <08:19> 12:4 <08:20> 12:24 <08:21> 13:10 <08:22> 13: 23 <08:23> 14:22 <08:24> 14:24 <08:24> 15:14 <08:25> 17:22 <08:29> 17: 23 <08:29> 18:17 <08:30> 18:20 <08:30> 19:9<08:31> 22:20 <08:37> 23:16 <08:38> 27:22 <08:47> 30: 24 <08:58> 36:21 <09:08> 41:1 <09:16> 42:8 <09:19> 45:16 <09:25> 48:13 <09:32> 50:11 <09:36> 51:5 <09:37> 57:4 <09:49> 57:15 <09:49> 57:21 <09:50> 57: 22 <09:50> 62:3 <09:58> 62: 9 <09:58> 62:12 <09:58> 67: 13 <10:07> 69:13 <10:10> 74:14 <10:19> 74:15 <10:19> 74:16 <10:19> 79: 17 <10:31> 80:4<10:32> 80: 5<10:32> 83:11 <10:38> 84: 21 <10:41> 84:23 <10:41> 86:20 <10:45> 87:24 <10:47> 93:4<10:59> 93:11 <11:00> 93:14 <11:01 > 95:5 <11:03> 96:20 <11:10> 96: 21 <11:10> 96:23 <11:10> 96:25 <11:10> 97:1 <11:10> 97:7 <11:11 > 97:8 <11;11> 97:23 <11:12> 97:23 <11:12> 98:2 <11:12> 98:3 <11:12> 98:11 <11:13> 98: 12 <11:13> 98:20 <11:13> 98:22 <11:15> 98:24 <11:15> 100:17 <11:20> 101:6 <11:22> 101:16 <11:23> 108:3 <11:38> 110: 7 <11:48> 110:25 <11:49> 111:1 <11:49> 111:25 <11:51> Ones [5] 44:14 <09:23> 63:12 <10:00> 63:13 <10:00> 67: 25 <10:07> 98:13 <11:13> Ongoing [1] 5:13 <08:10> Open [1] 112:2 <11:51 > Operation [3] 25:10 <08:42> 25:11 <08:42> 33:13 <09:03> Operations [8] 6:17 <08:12> 8:7 <08:15> 19:21 <08:32> 55: 19 <09:46> 64:1 <10:01> 64: 10 <10:02> 106:12 <11:34> 106:19 <11:35> Opinion [1] 46:25 <09:28> Opinionwise [1] 107:5 <11:36> Optimum [1] 71:13 <10:14> Oral [3] 1:22 4:1 12:9 <08:20> Order [20] 69:8 <10:10> 69:9 <10:10> 76:10 <10:23> 76: 10 <10:23> 76:11 <10:23> 76:17 <10:23> 76:19 <10:24> 82:13 <10:36> 93:7 <11:00> 93:7 <11:00> 94:21 <11:02> 94:23 <11:02> 101: 4<11:22> 101:11 <11:22> 101:12 <11:22> 102:8 <11:24> 102:24 <11:25> 103:2 <11:25> 103:5 <11:25> 110:2 <11:48> Ordered [8] 70:10 <10:12> 70:14 <10:12> 75:21 <10:22> 101: 2 <11:21> 101:3 <11:21> 103:1 <11:25> 103:4 <11:25> 103:5 <11:25> Ordering [1] 72:15 <10:16> Orders [17] 15:14 <08:25> 57:10 <09:49> 57:11 <09:49> 63:7 <10:00> 63:10 <10:00> 63: 12<10:00> 69:23 <10:11> 69:24 <10:11> 74:20 <10:20> 74:23 <10:20> 75:4 <10:20> 82:17 <10:36> 93: 10 <11:00> 103:13 <11:27> 103:14 <11:27> 103:14 <11:27> 103:16 <11:27> Organization [2] 42:7 <09:19> 51:21 <09:39> Orient [1] 73:11 <10:17> Original [4] 36:5 <09:07> 36:7 <09:07> 64:24 <10:03> 94: 21 <11:02> OSHA [3] 53:19 <09:42> 53:23 <09:42> 54:2 <09:43> Otherwise [3] 56:14 <09:47> 115:15 115:16 Ought [1] 97:15 <11:11> Ourselves [1] 4:14<08:09> Outside [4] 15:6 <08:24> 20:15 <08:33> 37:19 <09:09> 57: 11 <09:49> Oversaw [1] 24:18 <08:40> OWENS [1] 1:7 Owens-Illinois [2] 1:7 2:8 Own [12] 8:16 <08:15> 16:19 <08:27> 17:2 <08:28> 49:15 <09:35> 49:22 <09:35> 56: 10 <09:47> 58:20 <09:51> 64:16 <10:02> 66:24 <10:06> 71:20 <10:14> 87: 13 <10:46> 110:14 <11:48> p P.L.C. [1] 2:2 Package [1] 78:7 <10:28> Packing [1] 46:12 <09:27> Page [7] 3:1 3:8 32:3 <09:00> 32: 10 <09:01 > 46:10 <09:27> 102:18 <11:24> 113:16 Pages [4] 3:10 28:13 86:22 <10:45> 96:16 <11:10=- Paid [3] 8:9 <08:15> 11:4 <08:19> 11:6 <08:19> Paper [5] 47:21 <09:31 > 47:22 <09:31 > 47:23 <09:31> 47: 23 <09:31 > 86:23 <10:45> Paperwork [I] 75:11 <10:21 > Part [34] 14:17 <08:24> 14:19 <08:24> 17:10 <08:28> 20: 21 <08:33> 25:5 <08:41> 38: 24 <09:12> 43:5 <09:20> 64: 2 <10:02> 64:11 <10:02> 67: 17 <10:07> 74:10 <10:19> 74:10 <10:19> 74:11 <10:19> 79:16 <10:31> 81: 16 <10:35> 82:23 <10:37> 82:25 <10:37> 83:2<10:38> 83:5 <10:38> 83:8<10:38> 83:22 <10:39> 83:25 <10:39> 83:25 <10:39> 84: 11 <10:40> 84:17 <10:40> 84:19 <10:40> 84:23 <10:41> 85:1 <10:41> 92:3 <10:56> 93:6<10:59> 100:9 <11:19> 109:18 <11:47> 110:22 <11:49> 111:2 <11:49> Particular [II] 17:12 <08:28> 20:10 <08:33> 30:19 <08:57> 38: 12 <09:11> 56:8 <09:46> 61: 9 <09:56> 84:21 <10:41> 84: 22 <10:41> 87:11 <10:46> 100:9 <11:19> 103:11 <11:27> Parties [1] 115:10 Parts [2] 83:20 <10:39> 103:12 <11:27> Party [1] 115:15 Pass [2] 55:23 <09:46> 99:13 <11:17> Passed [1] 78:13 <10:28> Past [3] 30:7 <08:57> 57:14 <09:49> 81:14 <10:35> Pay [1] 8:13 <08:15> Pending [3] 6:2 <08:11 > 6:3<08:11> 72:7 People [22] 5:6 <08:10> 12:16 <08:21> 15:15 <08:25> 18:2 <08:29> 18:7 <08:29> 18:9 <08:30> 20:17 <08:33> 23: 14 <08:38> 51:5<09:37> 51: 10 <09:38> 67:16 <10:07> 67:19 <10:07> 69:13 <10:10> 72:15 <10:16> 76:5 <10:22> 78:2 <10:28> 80:2 Index Page 10 <10:32> 81:14 <10:35> 81: 15 <10:35> 89:21 <10:51> 96:8 <11:06> 104:10 <11:30> Percent [9] 9:8 <08:16> 31:22 <08:59> 41:4 <09:16> 41:6 <09:16> 41:6 <09:16> 41:9 <09:17> 41:10 <09:17> 47:4 <09:28> 68:20 <10:09> Percentage [I] 91:20 <10:55> Period [II] 13:9 <08:22> 34:13 <09:04> 39:1 <09:12> 40:7 <09:15> 43:23 <09:22> 55: 15 <09:45> 71:4 <10:13> 77: 23 <10:27> 78:11 <10:28> 79:9 <10:30> 79:20 <10:31> Permits [1] 108:18 <11:39> Person [6] 24:14 <08:40> 36:15 <09:08> 52:8 <09:39> 82:10 <10:36> 86:14 <10:44> 104: 8 <11:30> Personal [8] 1:4 25:19 <08:43> 25:21 <08:43> 34:7 <09:04> 56:10 <09:47> 66:24 <10:06> 87: 13 <10:46> 110:13 <11:48> Personally [5] 26:4 <08:43> 26:5 <08:44> 68:12 <10:08> 73: 15 <10:17> 91:15 <10:55> Personnel [1] 57:12 <09:49> Phone [1] 4:13 <08:09> Photograph [1] 11:10 <08:19> Phrased [1] 105:17 <11:32> Physical [2] 40:19 <09:16> 40:19 <09:16> Physically [2] 17:14 <08:29> 72:16 <10:16> Pick [1] 84:23 <10:41> Picture [1] 32:6 <09:00> Pile [1] 74:14 <10:19> Pipe [2] 34:14 <09:04> 37:23 <09:10> Pipes [2] 34:16 <09:04> 35:3 <09:05> Place [2] 15:24 <08:26> 99:22 <11:18> Placed [2] 27:21 <08:47> 60:21 <09:55> Plainfield [1] 6:15 <08:12> Plaintiff [6] 1:5 1:11 1:161:23 2:3 4:2 Plaintiffs [1] 5:4 <08:10> Planning [1] 19:10 <08:31> Plant [34] 19:8 <08:31> 38:19 <09:12> 39:2 <09:12> 39:3 <09:12> 39:5 <09:12> 39:12 <09:13> 39:13 <09:13> 50:8 <09:36> 51:11 <09:38> 51: 18 <09:38> 58:8 <09:50> 58: 16 <09:51> 58:18 <09:51> 58:20 <09:51 > 58:21 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From November to Plant Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 11 <09:51 > 58:21 <09:51 > 59: 12 <09:52> 59:12 <09:52> 74:21 <10:20> 74:24 <10:20> 75:10 <10:21> 75: 11 <10:21> 75:12 <10:21> 75:20 <10:22> 75:24 <10:22> 76:2 <10:22> 76:4 <10:22> 76:14 <10:23> 76: 21 <10:24> 77:2 <10:24> 77: 15 <10:26> 77:16 <10:26> 109:15 <11:47> 109:16 <11:47> Plants [13] 18:23 <08:30> 41:20 <09:18> 51:19 <09:38> 54:1 <09:43> 58:7 <09:50> 58:7 <09:50> 58:10 <09:51 > 58: 22 <09:51 > 63:9 <10:00> 63: II <10:00> 75:5 <10:21 > 75: 18 <10:22> 77:3<10:24> Plastic [1] 12:4 <08:20> Plavix [1] 11:20 <08:20> Play [1] 6:24 <08:12> Played [1] 65:9<10:03> PLC III 4:6 PM [1] 113:4 Point [1] 81:22 <10:35> Policy [4] 57:3 <09:49> 57:5 <09:49> 57:18 <09:50> 57: 23 <09:50> Pooling [1] 11:23 <08:20> Portion [4] 67:22 <10:07> 67:25 <10:07> 86:9<10:44> 92:4 <10:56> Portsmouth [9] 6:2 08:11= 41:3 <09:16> 93:13 <11:01> 99: 21 <11:18> 99:24 <11:19> 100:23 <11:21> 101:8 <11:22> 102:18 <11:24> 110:6 <11:48> Position [2] 106:17 <11:35> 106:19 <11:35> Possible [2] 81:5 <10:34> 95:21 <11:04> Pounds [1] 46:24 <09:28> Precautionary [1] 44:23 <09:24> Precautions [3] 45:3 <09:24= 48:20 <09:33> 48:23 <09:33> Predominantly [2] 32:24 <09:02> 33:1 <09:02> Prefer [3] 73:11 <10:17> 108:19 <11:39> 108:20 <11:39> Preliminary [1] 17:16 <08:29> Preparation [2] 104:17 <11:30> 111:25 <11:51> Prepare [5] 23:2 <08:37> 23:5 <08:37> 104:20 <11:31> 105:19 <11:32> 105:23 <11:33> Present [6] 18:21 <08:30> 19:2 <08:31> 19:12 <08:31> 19: 15 <08:31> 19:18 <08:32> 19:24 <08:32> Presented [3] 21:24 <08:35= 66:3 <10:05> 107:4 <11:36> Previous [2] 68:6 <10:08> 78:10 <10:28> Previously [3] 10:2 <08:17> 12:20 <08:21 > 54:4 <09:43> Price [3] 100:16 <11:20> 100:25 <11:21> 101:3 <11:21> Primary [1] 32:23 <09:02> Print [2] 61:2 <09:55> 83:24 <10:39> Printed [3] 87:11 <10:46> 96:17 <11:10> 96:17 <11:10> Printout [1] 115:11 Privilege [1] 5:19 <08:11> Privileged [1] 5:15 <08:10> Privy [1] 5:25 <08:11> Problem [3] 21:8 <08:34> 21:13 <08:34> 34:24 <09:05> Problems [2] 79:17 <10:31> 79:18 <10:31> Proceeding [1] 115:16 Process [8] 59:2 <09:52> 59:20 <09:53> 60:14 09:55= 60: 18 <09:55> 61:3 <09:56> 61: 19 <09:57> 63:10 <10:00= 74:1 <10:18> Product [37] 15:18 <08:25> 15:19 <08:25> 16:25 <08:28> 19: 10 <08:31 > 31:15 <08:59> 31:17 <08:59> 31:19 <08:59> 36:11 <09:07> 44: 12 <09:23> 48:17 <09:32> 48:18 <09:33> 48:20 <09:33> 48:23 <09:33> 48: 24 <09:33> 58:18 <09:51 > 61:12 <09:56> 61:15 09:56= 69:25 <10:11> 70:3 <10:11= 70:11 <10:12> 70: 17 <10:12= 70:25 <10:13> 71:2 <10:13> 71:19 <10:14> 72:9 <10:15> 72:15 <10:16> 72:16 <10:16> 72:17 <10:16> 72:20 <10:16> 75: 15 <10:21 > 76:3 <10:22> 76: 20 <10:24> 82:24 <10:37> 83:1 <10:37> 84:17 <10:40> 88:7 <10:48> 100:7 <11:19> Production [2] 32:24 <09:02> 77:17 <10:26> Products [26] 6:17 <08:12> 7:5 <08:13> 7:10 <08:13> 7:12 <08:13> 23:18 <08:38> 29: 12 <08:55> 29:25 <08:56> 30:14 <08:57> 33:22 <09:03> 36:2<09:07> 42:10 <09:19> 48:7 <09:32> 49:23 <09:35> 59:15 <09:53> 59: 19 <09:53> 60:1 <09:54> 60: 22 <09:55> 61:12 <09:56> 70:9 <10:12> 70:13 <10:12> 71:15 <10:14> 71:21 <10:14> 73:1 <10:16> 82:21 <10:37> 87:20 <10:47> 108: 1 <11:37> Program [4] 78:5 <10:28> 78:18 <10:29> 78:21 <10:29> 79: 24 <10:32> Programmer [1] 80:7 <10:32> Programming [1] 80:2 <10:32> Prominently [1] 99:21 <11:18> Promote [1] 28:22 <08:49> Promoted [1] 27:14 <08:46> Property [1] 19:9 <08:31 > Proprietary [2] 88:21 <10:49> 88:24 <10:49> Protective [1] 45:9 <09:25> Provide [2] 30:18 <08:57> 98:23 <11:15> Provided [2] 22:2 <08:35> 102:8 <11:24> Providing [2] 20:7 <08:32> 22:20 <08:37> Public [5] 4:3 96:10 <11:06> 114:15 115:2115:21 Publication [1] 45:23 <09:27> Pump [2] 15:22 <08:26> 37:24 <09:10> Pumps [3] 34:22 <09:05> 34:23 <09:05> 35:4 <09:05> Purchase [28] 40:5 <09:14> 57:10 <09:49> 57:11 <09:49> 61: 23 <09:58> 62:16 <09:58> 62:23 <09:59> 63:3 <10:00= 63:5<10:00> 63:7 <10:00= 63:10 <10:00> 63:12 <10:00> 69:23 <10:11> 71:4 <10:13> 74:20 <10:20> 74: 23 <10:20> 75:4 <10:20> 75: 10 <10:21> 75:25 <10:22> 76:10 <10:23> 76:10 <10:23= 76:11 <10:23> 76: 17 <10:23> 76:19 <10:24> 93:7 <11:00> 93:7 <11:00> 93:10 <11:00= 94:21 <11:02= 94:23 <11:02> Purchased [9] 40:14 <09:15> 49:16 <09:35> 50:6 <09:36> 50:12 <09:36> 50:21 <09:37> 51: 12 <09:38> 88:2<10:47> 88: 7 <10:48> 111:6 <11:50> Purchaser [4] 16:4 <08:26> 50:8 <09:36> 50:19 <09:37> 51:1 <09:37> Purchasers [1] 86:17 <10:44> Purchases [1] 60:9 <09:54> Purchasing [7] 50:18 <09:37> 51:2 09:37= 51:3 <09:37> 51:5 <09:37> 51:7 <09:38> 51:10 <09:38> 61:20 <09:57> Pure [2] 97:3 <11:10> 98:20 <11:13> Purely [1] 98:12 <11:13> Purpose [2] 10:1 <08:17> 112:2 <11:51 > Purposes [4] 78:12 <10:28= 78:13 <10:28> 80:25 <10:34= 111: 11 <11:50> Put [12] 16:10 <08:27> 19:11 08:31= 20:21 <08:33> 30: 23 <08:58> 43:3 <09:20> 57: 19<09:50> 69:14 <10:10> 78:12 <10:28> 80:7 <10:32> 81:10 <10:35> 81:18 <10:35> 93:5 <10:59> PYATT ms______________ Q QPL [3] 30:4 <08:56> 30:14 <08:57= 59:14 <09:53> QPLs [2] 30:3 <08:56> 31:3 <08:58> Qualification [1] 115:3 Qualified [7]30:14<08:57> 59:15 <09:53> 59:19 <09:53> 59: 25 09:53= 60:21 <09:55> 61:6 <09:56> 61:12 <09:56> Quantity [5] 100:16 <11:20= 100:24 <11:21 > 101:2 <11:21> 101: 8<11:22> 103:5 <11:25> Questioning [1] 108:7 <11:38> Questions [7] 17:16 <08:29> 20:22 <08:34> 28:16 08:49= 73: 12 <10:17> 108:15 <11:39> 109:4 <11:46> 112:10 <11:52> Quotation [20] 3:13 3:14 3:16 69:5 <10:09> 69:22 <10:11= 75: 16 <10:21> 75:22 <10:22> 76:10 <10:23> 76:12 <10:23> 76:16 <10:23> 79: 21 <10:31> 85:14 <10:42> 85:21 <10:43> 88:7<10:48> 92:22 93:2 <10:59> 99:12 <11:17=- 99:17 100:21 <11:20> 103:7 Quotations [6] 65:19 <10:04> 69:21 <10:11= 76:6 <10:23= 82:16 <10:36= 94:10 <11:02= 102: 19 <11:25= Quote [5] 93:7 <11:00= 101:12 <11:22= 101:13 <11:22= 102:5 <11:23= 102:7 <11:24= Quoted [8] 89:21 <10:51= 89:22 <10:51= 100:16 <11:20= 100:18 <11:20= 100:24 <11:21= 101:1 <11:21= 101: 8 <11:22= 101:9 <11:22= Quotes [2] 101:17 <11:23= 102:19 <11:25= R Radcliff [1] 104:15 <11:30= Radcliffe [1] 97:7 <11:11 = Ran [3] 33:9 <09:02= 34:12 <09:04= 47:4 <09:28= Rare [1] 41:7 <09:17= Rare-earth [1] 41:7 <09:17= Rather [1] 46:3 <09:27= Raw [17] 15:5 <08:24= 17:11 <08:28= 24:24 <08:41= 25: 13 <08:42= 44:8 <09:23= 46: 15 <09:27= 46:17 <09:28= 46:20 <09:28= 68:21 <10:09= 69:3 <10:09= 77:19 <10:26= 77:21 <10:27= 77: 25 <10:27= 82:24 <10:37= 85:4 <10:41= 92:11 <10:58= 92:12 <10:58= Ray [2] 4:15 <08:09= 4:16 <08:09= RAYMOND [1] 2:12 Reach [1] 106:17 <11:35= Read [24] 20:9 <08:33= 45:1 <09:24= 45:6 <09:24= 45:7 <09:24= 45:8 <09:24= 46:20 <09:28= 72:4 <10:14= 72:5 <10:15= 72:7 79:3 <10:30= 79:6 <10:30= 80:3 <10:32= 89:16 <10:51= 92:3 <10:56= 92:7 <10:56= 93:23 <11:01 = 100:2 <11:19= 100:12 <11:20= 100:15 <11:20= 100:25 <11:21= 101:5 <11:22= 101:6 <11:22= 102: 23 <11:25= 113:7 Readable [1] 78:1 <10:27= Reader [2] 91:22 <10:55= 91:24 <10:56= Ready [1] 112:16 <11:52= Real [1] 96:2 <11:05= Really [7] 13:17 <08:22= 18:2 <08:29= 20:17 <08:33= 45:1 <09:24= 45:6 <09:24= 45:8 <09:24= 110:10 <11:48= Reason [3] 28:5 <08:48= 109:10 <11:46= 113:15 Receipt [1] 76:17 <10:23= Receive [2] 8:14 <08:15= 8:15 <08:15= Received [7] 9:2 <08:16= 31:8 <08:58= 61:11 <09:56= 69: 23 <10:11= 82:17 <10:36= 103:14 <11:27= 103:15 <11:27= Recent [1] 109:21 <11:47= Recently [1] 50:9 <09:36= Recess [3] 29:2 99:8 108:22 <11:39= Recognition [1] 104:9 <11:30= Reconstruct [2] 90:16 <10:52= 90:25 <10:53= Reconstruction [1] 90:20 <10:53= Record [62] 3:13 3:14 3:16 5:12 <08:10= 22:7 <08:36= 23:12 <08:38= 25:6 <08:42= 28:24 <08:50= 29:1 <08:50= 47:10 <09:29= 47:11 58:8 <09:50= 64:20 <10:03= 65:5 <10:03= 65:15 <10:04= 66:6 <10:05= 69:16 <10:10= 70:1 <10:11= 70:22 <10:13= 70: 1625 Unique Words.TD Firm Name Here From Plant to Record Word Index 24 <10:13> 74:18 <10:19> 76:16 <10:23> 76:25 <10:24= 77:13 <10:26> 77: 16 <10:26> 81:12 <10:35> 81:14 <10:35> 82:16 <10:36> 82:18 <10:37> 83:5 <10:38> 85:14 <10:42> 86: 22 <10:45> 87:2 <10:46> 87: 4 <10:46= 87:11 <10:46> 89: 16 <10:51 > 92:22 92:24 <10:59> 93:3 <10:59> 95:3 <11:03> 96:3 <11:05> 99:3 <11:15> 99:10 <11:17> 99: 13 <11:17> 99:17 100:20 <11:20> 100:21 <11:20> 101:16 <11:23> 102:14 <11:24> 103:7 103:18 <11:27> 106:11 <11:34> 109:13 <11:46> 110:13 <11:48> 110:15 <11:48> 111:5 <11:50> 111:8 <11:50> 111:12 <11:50> 112:4 <11:51> 112:16 <11:52> 112:23 112:24 <11:53> Recorded [4] 25:1 <08:41> 69:24 <10:11> 76:16 <10:23> 115: 10 Recording [2] 24:23 <08:41> 65:19 <10:04> Records [113] 7:1 <08:13> 7:2 <08:13> 7:5 <08:13> 7:7 <08:13> 7:9 <08:13> 7:14 <08:13> 7:17 <08:14> 10:3 <08:17= 17:6 <08:28= 17:8 <08:28> 17:8 <08:28> 17:9 <08:28> 17:14 <08:29> 21:2 <08:34> 22:4 <08:36> 22:5 <08:36> 22:12 <08:36> 22: 14 <08:36> 24:4 <08:39> 24: 6 <08:39> 34:10 <09:04> 36: I <09:07> 36:12 <09:07> 39: 18 <09:13> 39:20 <09:13> 56:23 <09:48> 57:1 <09:48> 57:12 <09:49> 58:11 <09:51 > 58:15 <09:51> 58: 17 <09:51 > 58:21 <09:51> 58:23 <09:51> 58:24 <09:52> 59:7 <09:52> 63:23 <10:01 = 64:3<10:02> 64:3 <10:02> 64:6 <10:02= 64:10 <10:02> 64:12 <10:02> 64: 17 <10:02> 64:20 <10:03> 64:24 <10:03> 65:13 <10:04> 65:15 <10:04> 66:6 <10:05> 66:16 <10:05> 66: 18<10:05> 67:6 <10:06> 67: II <10:06> 68:3 <10:07= 68: 4 <10:07> 68:5<10:08> 68:5 <10:08> 68:7 <10:08> 68:7 <10:08> 68:13 <10:08> 68: 21 <10:09> 68:22 <10:09> 68:24 <10:09> 68:25 <10:09> 69:2 <10:09> 69:20 <10:10> 69:23 <10:11=- 70:5 <10:11> 70:19 <10:12> 72: 25 <10:16> 73:24 <10:18> 75:16 <10:21> 75:22 <10:22= 76:22 <10:24> 77:1 <10:24> 77:2 <10:24> 77:10 <10:25> 77:18 <10:26> 77: 21 <10:27> 77:23 <10:27> 78:10 <10:28> 78:14 <10:29> 79:1 <10:29> 79:21 <10:31> 79:22 <10:32> 79: 25 <10:32> 80:22 <10:33> 81:14 <10:35> 82:20 <10:37> 83:3 <10:38> 85:13 <10:42> 85:21 <10:43> 85: 25 <10:43> 87:6<10:46> 90: 21 <10:53> 91:9 <10:54> 92: 6 <10:56> 92:9<10:57> 92: 13 <10:58> 93:7 <11:00> 96: 8<11:06> 102:19 <11:25> 104:12 <11:30> 105:21 <11:32> 107:24 <11:37> Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 107:25 <11:37> 108:5 <11:38> 108:6 <11:38> 108: 24 <11:45> 109:16 <11:47> 109:18 <11:47> 109:18 <11:47> 109:19 <11:47> 109:20 <11:47> 111:10 <11:50> Recovery [1] 30:21 <08:57> Redistributed [1] 16:25 <08:28> Reduced [1] 115:11 Refer [1] 102:20 <11:25> Reference [5] 34:12 <09:04= 100:1 <11:19> 102:4 <11:23> 102: 9 <11:24> 108:5 <11:38> References [1] 102:17 <11:24= Referencing [1] 101:22 <11:23> Referred [1] 73:24 <10:18> Referring [3] 22:7 <08:36> 46:13 <09:27> 46:14 <09:27= Reflect [3] 36:12 <09:07> 63:3 <10:00> 89:21 <10:51> Reflected [1] 32:1 <09:00> Reflecting [1] 74:25 <10:20> Reflects [1] 96:4 <11:05> Regard [6] 5:13 <08:10> 5:15 <08:10> 5:19 <08:11> 57:24 <09:50> 58:24 <09:52> 66: 23 <10:06> Regular [1] 15:12 <08:25> Reinz [1] 7:11 <08:13> Relate [3] 6:1 <08:11> 24:5 <08:39> 87:8 <10:46> Related [7] 7:12 <08:13> 8:19 <08:15> 43:21 <09:22= 49: 13 <09:34= 50:15 <09:36> 54:12 <09:43> 115:14 Relates [3] 23:20 <08:38> 23:22 <08:39> 51:22 <09:39> Relating [4] 22:14 <08:36> 52:21 <09:40> 76:14 <10:23> 104: 23 <11:31 = Release [2] 20:1 <08:32> 52:25 <09:41 > Released [1] 53:8 <09:41 > Rely [1] 21:10 <08:34= Remarks [1] 100:14 <11:20> Remember [6] 9:23 <08:17> 9:24 <08:17= 13:18 <08:22= 20: 23 <08:34> 45:2 <09:24> 45: 9 <09:25> Remind [1] 55:23 <09:46> Removal [1] 53:1 <09:41 = Remove [1] 55:5 <09:45> Removed [2] 19:16 <08:31> 73:4 <10:17> Removing [1] 45:4 <09:24> Renewed [1] 59:25 <09:53> Repeat [4] 35:17 <09:06> 48:21 <09:33> 71:14 <10:14> 72:4 <10:14=- Repeating [1] 24:3 <08:39> Replaced [1] 56:1 <09:46> Reporter [6] 5:23 <08:11> 28:9 <08:48= 72:5 <10:15> 72:8 99:15 <11:17> 112:16 <11:52> Repository [3] 56:16 <09:47> 80:10 <10:33> 80:25 <10:34> Representative [1] 1:4 Represented [3] 29:18 <08:56> 87:15 <10:46> 87:18 <10:47> Request [4] 9:13 <08:16> 21:7 <08:34> 83:16 <10:39> 91:8 <10:54> Requested [5] 60:8 <09:54> 80:4 <10:32> 80:19 <10:33> 88:6 <10:48> 105:9 <11:32> Require [2] 5:19 <08:11> 15:16 <08:25> Required [2] 30:19 <08:57> 79:24 <10:32> Requirement [1] 69:9 <10:10> Requirements [4] 29:12 <08:55> 29:21 <08:56> 29:24 <08:56> 30:1 <08:56= Resale [1] 16:17 <08:27= Research [5] 34:7 <09:04= 79:15 <10:31= 92:12 <10:58= 105: 24 <11:33= 111:7 <11:50= Researched [2] 34:5 <09:04= 104:21 <11:31 = Researching [2] 27:6 <08:46= 27:8 <08:46= Resell [1] 15:18 <08:25= Reserve [1] 5:16 <08:10= Residence [1] 6:13 <08:12= Resides [1] 13:10 <08:22= Resold [1] 16:16 <08:27= Resolution [1] 54:23 <09:44= Resources [1] 12:19 <08:21= Respect [2] 6:3 <08:11= 107:7 <11:36= Respective [1] 115:9 Response [1] 5:21 <08:11= Responsibilities [9] 8:4 <08:14= 8:6 <08:15= 10:20 <08:18= 12:17 <08:21= 14:17 <08:24= 14: 19 <08:24= 25:5 <08:41= 25: 7 <08:42= 64:2 <10:02= Responsibility [4] 8:5 <08:14= 25:4 <08:41= 53:15 <09:42= 106: 5 <11:33= Responsible [6] 51:6 <09:38= 51:22 <09:39= 56:7 <09:46= 59:22 <09:53= 64:11 <10:02= 106: 2 <11:33= Restatement [1] 69:1 <10:09= Restricted [1] 30:25 <08:58= Result [1] 20:11 <08:33= Resulted [1] 53:25 <09:42= Retained [4] 57:7 <09:49= 58:5 <09:50= 58:11 <09:51= 76:4 <10:22= Retention [4] 57:4 <09:49= 57:18 <09:50= 57:23 <09:50= 64:3 <10:02= Retired [2] 13:10 <08:22= 13:23 <08:23= Retirement [1] 8:17 <08:15= Return [1] 44:4 <09:22= Review [9] 21:14 <08:34= 24:4 <08:39= 24:6 <08:39= 76:22 <10:24= 78:4 <10:28= 83:16 <10:39= 104:17 <11:30= 108:14 <11:39= 112:14 <11:52= Reviewed [5] 36:2 <09:07= 68:6 <10:08= 68:21 <10:09= 91: 15 <10:55= 104:19 <11:31 = Rich [1] 53:17 <09:42= Richard [12] 2:2 4:2 4:14 <08:09= 4: 21 <08:09= 21:15 <08:34= 88:20 <10:49= 92:19 <10:58= 93:25 <11:01= 97: 12 <11:11= 108:20 <11:39= 109:5 <11:46= 115:2 Right-hand [1] 100:8 <11:19= Ripped [1] 19:16 <08:31= RMR [1] 4:3 ROBERT [1] 2:8 Robinson [22] 39:2 <09:12= 39:3 <09:12= 39:7 <09:13= 39:9 <09:13= 42:5 <09:18= 50:8 <09:36= 51:3 <09:37= 51:11 <09:38= 51:13 <09:38= 53: 11 <09:41= 58:11 <09:51 = 58:16 <09:51= 74:24 <10:20= 74:24 <10:20= 75:2 <10:20= 75:2 <10:20= 75:9 <10:21= 75:22 <10:22= 76:2 <10:22= 76:4 <10:22= 76:23 <10:24= 77:7 <10:25= Robustness [1] 38:10 <09:11= Roebuck [2] 62:20 <09:59= 88:10 <10:48= Role [2] 6:24 <08:12= 65:9 <10:03= Rolled Index Page 12 [2] 47:22 <09:31= 47:23 <09:31 = Rolls [3] 47:21 <09:31= 47:21 <09:31= 48:5 <09:32= Roughly [6] 21:24 <08:35= 41:3 <09:16= 57:6 <09:49= 65:6 <10:03= 68:15 <10:08= 79:2 <10:30= RPR [2] 4:3 115:2 RPR-RMR [114:3 Rubber [2] 101:20 <11:23= 101:25 <11:23= Rule [2] 10:17 <08:18= 71:12 <10:14= Rules [1] 4:8 RYAN [1] 2:4 s Safety [2] 43:20 <09:22= 51:22 <09:39= Salaried [2] 8:2 <08:14= 8:3 <08:14= Salary [3] 7:25 <08:14= 9:8 <08:16= 9:10 <08:16= Sale [27] 14:13 <08:23= 25:16 <08:42= 26:1 <08:43= 29:21 <08:56= 58:7 <09:50= 63:7 <10:00= 63:16 <10:01= 69:9 <10:10= 69:10 <10:10= 69: 12 <10:10= 69:13 <10:10= 69:15 <10:10= 69:24 <10:11= 75:11 <10:21= 76: 14 <10:23= 76:23 <10:24= 79:16 <10:31= 81:5 <10:34= 81:9 <10:34= 81:9 <10:34= 85:14 <10:42= 85:21 <10:43= 89:22 <10:51= 90:3 <10:52= 100:11 <11:19= 101:17 <11:23= 109:22 <11:47= Sales [106] 6:16 <08:12= 6:25 <08:12= 7:2 <08:13= 7:5 <08:13= 7:9 <08:13= 7:22 <08:14= 8:6 <08:15= 9:4 <08:16= 9:6 <08:16= 9:6 <08:16= 10:3 <08:17= 10:20 <08:18= 14:3 <08:23= 14:8 <08:23= 14:17 <08:24= 14: 18 <08:24= 14:18 <08:24= 15:3 <08:24= 15:7 <08:24= 15:11 <08:25= 17:3 <08:28= 17:7 <08:28= 17:8 <08:28= 17:11 <08:28= 17:13 <08:29= 17:24 <08:29= 18:2 <08:29= 22:5 <08:36= 22:7 <08:36= 22:14 <08:36= 24: 14 <08:40= 24:18 <08:40= 24:23 <08:41= 25:1 <08:41= 25:6 <08:42= 25:12 <08:42= 25:19 <08:43= 31:9 <08:58= 33:22 <09:03= 35:6 <09:06= 35:9 <09:06= 35:10 <09:06= 35:12 <09:06= 35:19 <09:06= 55:8 <09:45= 55:10 <09:45= 55:19 <09:46= 56:3 <09:46= 56:8 <09:46= 56:23 <09:48= 57:1 <09:48= 57:10 <09:49= 57:24 <09:50= 58:4 <09:50= 58:15 <09:51= 63:3 <10:00= 63:14 <10:01= 64:1 <10:01= 64:3 <10:02= 64:3 <10:02= 64:9 <10:02= 64:24 <10:03= 65:19 <10:04= 66:6 <10:05= 66:18 <10:05= 66: 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Record to Sales Word Index 24 <10:06> 68:5 <10:08> 68: 7 <10:08> 68:9<10:08> 68: 10 <10:08> 68:22 <10:09> 69:2 <10:09> 69:5 <10:09> 69:16 <10:10> 69:20 <10:10> 70:20 <10:12> 74: 25 <10:20> 75:16 <10:21> 75:22 <10:22> 76:5<10:22> 76:12 <10:23> 77:17 <10:26> 77:18 <10:26> 77: 21 <10:27> 77:23 <10:27> 79:21 <10:31> 82:18 <10:37> 82:19 <10:37> 89: 21 <10:51> 90:1 <10:51> 90: 14 <10:52> 90:16 <10:52> 90:20 <10:53> 90:25 <10:53> 92:9 <10:57= 92:11 <10:58> 92:16 <10:58> 93:3 <10:59> 93:4 <10:59> 101: 17 <11:23> 102:18 <11:24> 104:16 <11:30> 105:21 <11:32> 106:12 <11:34> 106:19 <11:35> 108:6 <11:38> Salesman [1] 106:4 <11:33> Salt [1] 71:9 <10:13> San [1] 96:10 <11:06> Sanded [1] 19:19 <08:32> Saw [8] 11:1 <08:19> 44:3 <09:22> 44:10 <09:23> 44: 14 <09:23> 48:13 <09:32> 48:13 <09:32> 106:23 <11:36> 107:14 <11:37> Saws [1] 14:23 <08:24> Schedule [2] 10:18 <08:18> 108:17 <11:39=- Scheduled [2] 10:5 <08:18> 22:17 <08:37> Scheme [1] 83:7 <10:38> School [3] 7:19 <08:14> 13:8 <08:22> 33:12 <09:03> Screwing [1] 82:8 <10:36> Seal [5] 19:8 <08:31 > 37:13 <09:09> 77:15 <10:26> 109: 15 <11:47=- 115:17 Sealed [1] 110:24 <11:49> Sealing [1] 1:19 Seals [1] 46:12 <09:27> Sears [2] 62:20 <09:59> 88:10 <10:48> Second [4] 28:25 <08:50> 74:15 <10:19> 93:14 <11:01> 93: 23 <11:01 > See [19] 8:1 <08:14> 12:6 <08:20> 18:11 <08:30> 21: 12 <08:34> 27:24 <08:47> 29:19 <08:56> 43:6<09:20> 43:15 <09:21 > 46:12 <09:27> 46:14 <09:27> 48: 15 <09:32> 72:9 <10:15= 72: 11 <10:15> 72:16 <10:16> 95:6 <11:03> 95:21 <11:04> 95:24 <11:04> 102:20 <11:25> 108:15 <11:39> Seeing [1] 44:20 <09:23> Sell Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 [15] 15:24 <08:26> 16:9 <08:26> 16:12 <08:27> 16: 12 <08:27> 16:15 <08:27> 36:25 <09:08> 37:5 <09:09> 37:17 <09:09> 37:21 <09:10> 39:23 <09:14= 47: 20 <09:30> 61:12 <09:56> 61:14 <09:56> 61:16 <09:56> 63:13 <10:00> Selling [14] 3:13 3:14 3:16 26:4 <08:43> 36:4 <09:07= 36:6 <09:07> 37:25 <09:10> 56: 11 <09:47= 56:15 <09:47= 92:22 99:13 <11:17> 99:17 102:19 <11:25> 103:7 September [7] 1:25 4:5 22:18 <08:37> 23:3 <08:37> 24:11 <08:40> 105:12 <11:32=- 115:18 Sequence [8] 74:12 <10:19> 74:13 <10:19> 96:20 <11:10> 98:3 <11:12> 98:5 <11:12> 98:12 <11:13> 98:23 <11:15> 99:4 <11:15> Sequences [1] 96:17 <11:10> Sequentially [1] 74:9 <10:18> Served [2] 32:4 <09:00> 32:7 <09:00> Service [4] 16:13 <08:27> 25:3 <08:41> 77:8 <10:25> 77:9 <10:25> Services [1] 62:1 <09:58> Set [10] 22:23 <08:37> 56:16 <09:47> 56:18 <09:47> 80: 10 <10:33> 80:14 <10:33= 80:16 <10:33= 80:17 <10:33= 84:1 <10:39= 85:14 <10:42= 115:7 Seven [3] 3:10 28:13 57:6 <09:49= Several [7] 7:11 <08:13= 10:6 <08:18= 19:12 <08:31= 40: 25 <09:16= 54:17 <09:44= 57:5 <09:49= 96:18 <11:10= Shaking [3] 45:13 <09:25= 49:20 <09:35= 78:23 <10:29= Shall [1] 11:17 <08:19= Shared [1] 23:16 <08:38= Shear [1] 40:22 <09:16= Sheet [16] 14:19 <08:24= 16:15 <08:27= 26:9 <08:45= 31:1 <08:58= 36:25 <09:08= 37:5 <09:09= 37:22 <09:10= 41: 21 <09:18= 48:2 <09:31= 51: 16 <09:38= 53:12 <09:41= 60:1 <09:54= 85:4 <10:41= 99:14 <11:17= 102:2 <11:23= 113:13 Sheeting [1] 71:6 <10:13= Sheets [13] 43:19 <09:21= 43:20 <09:22= 43:24 <09:22= 44:2 <09:22= 44:3 <09:22= 44:10 <09:23= 44:16 <09:23= 44: 18 <09:23= 45:3 <09:24= 47: 18 <09:30= 47:24 <09:31 = 90:2 <10:52= 100:2 <11:19= Shelf [3] 37:7 <09:09= 71:4 <10:13= 71:5 <10:13= Ship [15] 14:1 <08:23= 32:5 <09:00= 32:6 <09:00= 33:9 <09:02= 33:9 <09:02= 34:13 <09:04= 35:1 <09:05= 35:3 <09:05= 35:7 <09:06= 37:23 <09:10= 44:25 <09:24= 71: 19 <10:14= 105:2 <11:31 = 105:7 <11:32= 111:17 <11:50= Shipbuilding [8] 17:19 <08:29= 18:15 <08:30= 24:1 <08:39= 24:5 <08:39= 104:24 <11:31 = 105:21 <11:32= 106:22 <11:35= 111:15 <11:50= Shipments [1] 24:23 <08:41 = Shipped [20] 70:4 <10:11= 70:9 <10:12= 70:13 <10:12= 70: 15 <10:12= 70:17 <10:12= 70:19 <10:12= 70:22 <10:13= 71:15 <10:14= 71: 21 <10:14= 73:1 <10:16= 73: 2 <10:16= 75:13 <10:21= 76: 4 <10:22= 76:20 <10:24= 94: 18 <11:02= 95:2 <11:03= 95: 16 <11:03= 95:19 <11:03= 95:22 <11:04= 103:17 <11:27= Shipper [4] 75:12 <10:21= 75:14 <10:21= 76:3 <10:22= 76:19 <10:24= Shippers [2] 58:9 <09:50= 58:9 <09:50= Shipping [2] 70:1 <10:11= 76:1 <10:22= Ships [9] 32:11 <09:01= 32:12 <09:01= 32:13 <09:01= 32: 15 <09:01= 32:15 <09:01 = 32:19 <09:01= 32:20 <09:01= 33:4 <09:02= 103: 12 <11:27= Shipyard [14] 13:3 <08:21= 13:22 <08:23= 13:24 <08:23= 17: 21 <08:29= 23:23 <08:39= 92:10 <10:58= 92:12 <10:58= 95:15 <11:03= 100: 4 <11:19= 105:4 <11:31= 105:23 <11:33= 106:6 <11:34= 106:23 <11:36= 108:2 <11:38= Shipyards [6] 13:9 <08:22= 13:11 <08:22= 23:20 <08:38= 23: 22 <08:39= 96:9 <11:06= 108:11 <11:38= Shook [2] 45:12 49:19 <09:35= Short [2] 13:9 <08:22= 108:13 <11:39= Show [11] 4:24 <08:10= 18:3 <08:29= 32:4 <09:00= 35:6 <09:06= 45:18 <09:26= 70:3 <10:11= 70:8 <10:12= 70:13 <10:12= 88:16 <10:48= 92: 14 <10:58= 112:7 <11:51= Showed [4] 11:10 <08:19= 18:9 <08:30= 103:10 <11:27= 109:20 <11:47= Showing [2] 19:12 <08:31= 29:4 <08:55= Shown [3] 34:4 <09:04= 82:20 <10:37= 100:7 <11:19= Shows [4] 32:6 <09:00= 70:10 <10:12= 70:18 <10:12= 100: 11 <11:19= Shrink [1] 47:25 <09:31= Side [1] 11:23 <08:20= SIGAL [1] 2:9 Sign [3] 20:13 <08:33= 112:13 <11:52= 112:14 <11:52= Signed [1] 20:11 <08:33= Signing [1] 112:13 <11:52= Simple [1] 111:5 <11:50= Simply [5] 5:21 <08:11= 10:15 <08:18= 17:24 <08:29= 23:9 <08:38= 30:11 <08:57= SINGER [1] 2:9 Single [2] 64:19 <10:03= 67:13 <10:07= Sister [1] 50:16 <09:36= Sister-in-law [2] 50:16 <09:36= 50:17 <09:37= Sit [1] 104:8 <11:30= Sitting [1] 111:8 <11:50= Six [3] 12:25 <08:21= 57:6 <09:49= 57:17 <09:49= Size [2] 40:18 <09:15= 40:19 <09:16= Sizes [1] 40:22 <09:16= Skid [1] 47:25 <09:31 = Skip [1] 95:5 <11:03= Small [2] 15:10 <08:25= 15:10 <08:25= Smaller [2] 106:3 <11:33= 106:13 <11:34= Smells [1] 44:25 <09:24= Social [1] 18:12 <08:30= Software [1] 78:7 <10:28= Sold [21] 16:3 <08:26= 16:7 <08:26= 16:9 <08:26= 16:18 <08:27= 26:8 <08:44= 33:4 <09:02= 33:7 <09:02= 33:24 <09:03= 36:2 <09:07= 36:13 <09:08= 36:23 <09:08= 47: 19 <09:30= 47:20 <09:30= 47:21 <09:31= 47:24 <09:31= 49:1 <09:33= 55:6 <09:45= 56:13 <09:47= 62: 20 <09:59= 63:17 <10:01= 72:20 <10:16= Soliciting [1] 60:5 <09:54= Someone [8] 16:10 <08:27= 36:23 <09:08= 37:19 <09:09= 72: 25 <10:16= 75:21 <10:22= 89:1 <10:49= 89:22 <10:51= 107:14 <11:37= Sometime [1] 64:7 <10:02= Index Page 13 Sometimes [5] 43:5 <09:20= 71:24 <10:14= 92:4 <10:56= 96:6 <11:06= 101:12 <11:22= Somewhere [1] 64:22 <10:03= Sorry [18] 33:19 <09:03= 36:22 <09:08= 45:14 <09:25= 47: 25 <09:31= 64:9 <10:02= 68: 2 <10:07= 72:1 <10:14= 84:8 <10:40= 93:25 <11:01= 97: 20 <11:12= 98:19 <11:13= 98:21 <11:15= 98:25 <11:15= 99:5 <11:15= 100: 17 <11:20= 100:24 <11:21 = 107:23 <11:37= 108:12 <11:38= Sought [4] 31:8 <08:58= 59:17 <09:53= 60:20 <09:55= 61: 11 <09:56= Source [1] 56:22 <09:48= South [1] 6:14 <08:12= Southeast [1] 15:1 <08:24= Southland [5] 14:23 <08:24= 15:19 <08:25= 15:20 <08:25= 16:3 <08:26= 16:3 <08:26= Spaces [1] 45:5 <09:24= Span [1] 58:14 <09:51 = Speaking [1] 79:17 <10:31= Spec [2] 31:2 <08:58= 100:14 <11:20= Special [1] 49:3 <09:33= Specialized [1] 7:21 <08:14= Specific [28] 17:14 <08:29= 33:7 <09:02= 35:7 <09:06= 35:7 <09:06= 36:15 <09:08= 36: 18 <09:08= 36:20 <09:08= 36:21 <09:08= 37:1 <09:08= 37:16 <09:09= 37:18 <09:09= 40:21 <09:16= 43: 20 <09:22= 58:21 <09:51= 68:5 <10:08= 68:18 <10:09= 68:18 <10:09= 68:23 <10:09= 71:16 <10:14= 74: 18 <10:19= 76:13 <10:23= 83:23 <10:39= 84:1 <10:39= 92:13 <10:58= 104:10 <11:30= 106:5 <11:33= 110: 22 <11:49= 111:2 <11:49= Specifically [7] 20:18 <08:33= 29:24 <08:56= 32:11 <09:01= 45:1 <09:24= 51:12 <09:38= 70: 16 <10:12= 82:23 <10:37= Specifications [1] 30:18 <08:57= Specifics [1] 31:6 <08:58= Specs [2] 30:2 <08:56= 31:7 <08:58= Speculate [1] 81:23 <10:35= Speculation [2] 81:21 <10:35= 85:17 <10:43= Speed [1] 112:17 <11:52= Stage [1] 112:7 <11:51= Stamped 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From Sales to Stamped Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 14 [1] 43:4 <09:20> Stamps [1] 42:18 <09:19> Start [5] 22:17 <08:37> 25:7 <08:42> 45:25 <09:27> 85:3 <10:41> 96:9 <11:06= Started [15] 7:18 <08:14> 7:18 <08:14> 33:19 <09:03> 33: 20 <09:03> 39:4<09:12> 56: 14 <09:47> 56:18 <09:47> 66:22 <10:06> 75:4<10:20> 77:17 <10:26> 80:12 <10:33> 84:2 <10:39> 84:24 <10:41 > 85:11 <10:42> 109: 14 <11:46> Starting [2] 25:22 <08:43> 87:7 <10:46> Starts [2] 89:9 <10:50> 112:18 <11:52> State [10] 6:10<08:ii> 6i:io <09:56> 62:23 <09:59= 63:2 <10:00> 63:15 <10:01> 63: 20 <10:01> 65:21 <10:04> 70:6 <10:11> 70:16 <10:12> 81:7 <10:34> Statement [3] 5:22 <08:11> 29:24 <08:56> 36:22 <09:08> States [11] 15:5<08:24> 15:5 <08:24> 35:9 <09:06= 45:19 <09:26> 51:19 <09:38> 55:8 <09:45> 55:12 <09:45> 56: 12 <09:47> 61:21 <09:58> 61:24 <09:58> 88:2<10:47> Status [1] 59:25 <09:53> Staub [1] 52:8 <09:39> Stay [1] 76:14 <10:23= Stenotype [1] 115:10 Steve [3] 5:8 <08:10> 35:16 <09:06> 97:9 <11:11 > STEVEN [1] 2:6 Stihl [1] 14:23 <08:24> Still [6] 13:10 <08:22> 14:24 <08:24> 18:9 <08:30= 22:13 <08:36> 63:17 <10:01> 84: 25 <10:41> Stock [6] 8:16 <08:15> 8:18 <08:15> 8:19 <08:15> 8:25 <08:16> 9:1 <08:16> 16:13 <08:27> Stopped [1] 44:7 <09:22> Stored [1] 71:8 <10:13> Street [1] 4:7 Stuff [3] 32:20 <09:01 > 79:5 <10:30> 96:22 <11:10> Subject [1] 78:21 <10:29> Submarine [2] 34:13 <09:04> 35:8 <09:06> Submarines [8] 32:11 <09:01 > 32:12 <09:01 > 32:13 <09:01 > 32: 14 <09:01 > 32:15 <09:01 > 32:19 <09:01> 32:20 <09:01= 33:4<09:02> Subscribed [1] 114:9 Subsequent [3] 69:24 <10:11> 78:18 <10:29> 89:21 <10:51> Subsequently [4] 7:10 <08:13> 65:17 <10:04> 87:20 <10:47> 102: 8 <11:24> Substantial [1] 46:25 <09:28> Substantially [1] 68:19 <10:09> Suggest [1] 35:4 <09:05> Suggested [1] 104:15 <11:30> Suggesting [1] 32:14 <09:01 > Suitability [1] 38:10 <09:11> Suite [1] 4:7 Suits [1] 54:18 <09:44> Sunday [2] 11:12 <08:19> 11:13 <08:19= Supervision [2] 87:1 <10:45= 87:2 <10:46> Supplied [1] 33:9 <09:02> Supplier [3] 32:9 <09:01= 57:11 <09:49> 61:6 <09:56= Suppliers [2] 32:10 <09:01> 61:7 <09:56> Supplies [1] 75:6 <10:21> Supply [20] 62:5 <09:58= 62:6 <09:58> 62:8 <09:58= 62:10 <09:58> 62:14 <09:58> 62: 18 <09:59> 93:15 <11:01> 93:16 <11:01> 93:19 <11:01> 94:4 <11:01> 94:13 <11:02> 95:6 <11:03> 95:11 <11:03> 95:15 <11:03> 95: 18 <11:03> 95:23 <11:04> 100:3 <11:19> 100:3 <11:19> 100:4 <11:19> 100: 4 <11:19> Supposed [2] 18:6 <08:29> 81:15 <10:35> Supreme [1] 4:8 Surely [1] 30:10 <08:57> Surgeon [2] 12:5 <08:20> 12:10 <08:20> Surgery [4] 12:2 <08:20> 12:3 <08:20> 12:6 <08:20> 12:8 <08:20> Susan [1] 50:15 <09:36> Suspect [1] 28:5 <08:48> Swear [1] 5:24 08:11= Swelling [2] 11:21 <08:20> 11:22 <08:20> Sworn [4] 5:11 <08:10= 6:6 114:9 115:8 Symbols [1] 79:5 <10:30> System [10] 65:16 <10:04> 78:9 <10:28= 83:5 <10:38> 84:3 <10:40> 84:5 <10:40> 87:12 <10:46> 87:14 <10:46> 109: 14 <11:46> 110:21 <11:49> 111:5 <11:50> _______ T Tag [1] 83:25 <10:39> Talks [4] 31:13 <08:59> 46:11 <09:27> 46:15 <09:27> 46: 17 <09:28> Tanks [1] 32:22 <09:01> Tear [1] 19:11 <08:31> Technical [2] 6:19 <08:12> 56:25 <09:48> Technicians [1] 19:10 <08:31> Technologies [1] 1:19 Telephonically [2] 2:7 2:10 Temperature [2]37:10<09:09> 38:8 <09:11> Temperatures [1] 30:21 <08:57> Template [2] 83:6 <10:38> 83:7 <10:38> Ten [1] 57:16 <09:49> Term [10] 29:16 <08:56> 30:5 <08:57> 30:8 <08:57> 30:12 <08:57> 44:16 <09:23> 49:7 <09:34> 49:9 <09:34> 49:10 <09:34> 49:21 <09:35> 54:7 <09:43> Terms [9] 11:18 <08:19> 32:3 <09:00> 32:4<09:00> 32:8 <09:00> 38:8 <09:11> 40:15 <09:15> 40:17 <09:15> 44: 15 <09:23> 90:2<10:52> Tested [2] 20:1 <08:32> 53:7 <09:41 > Testified [7] 9:13 <08:16> 9:21 <08:17> 22:11 <08:36> 33: 12 <09:03> 44:6 <09:22> 91: 13 <10:55> 92:8 <10:57> Testifies [1] 106:23 <11:36= Testify [13] 8:5 <08:14> 8:9 <08:15> 10:5 <08:18> 20:11 <08:33> 21:18 <08:35> 22:3 <08:35> 67:7 <10:06> 73:15 <10:17> 85:13 <10:42> 86:2 <10:43> 105:11 <11:32> 112:4 <11:51= 112:20 <11:52> Testifying [3] 7:15 <08:14> 21:20 <08:35> 23:24 <08:39> Testimony [22] 8:7 <08:15> 9:18 <08:17> 10:1 <08:17> 10:19 <08:18> 20:3 <08:32> 20:4 <08:32> 20:7<08:32> 20:7 <08:32= 21:23 <08:35> 22: 21 <08:37> 23:16 <08:38> 25:25 <08:43> 33:16 <09:03> 33:18 <09:03> 59:2 <09:52> 63:25 <10:01 > 88:1 <10:47> 94:3 <11:01> 105: 20<11:32> 105:23 <11:33> 113:7 113:9 Testing [1] 52:25 <09:41 > Texas [3] 9:25 <08:17> 20:12 <08:33= 21:18 <08:35> Themselves [3] 5:6 <08:10> 16:12 <08:27> 74:17 <10:19> Thereafter [1] 105:13 <11:32> Thereof [1] 115:16 Thereupon [1] 115:8 Thickness [1] 40:18 <09:15> Thicknesses [1] 40:23 <09:16> Thinking [1] 78:24 <10:29> Third [2] 74:16 <10:19> 95:12 <11:03> Thousand [3] 54:18 <09:44= 67:4 <10:06= 67:5 <10:06> Three [6] 12:11 <08:21= 56:19 <09:48> 56:21 <09:48= 93:8 <11:00> 93:8 <11:00> 94:8 <11:02> Throughout [2] 109:17 <11:47> 109:22 <11:47> Tidewater [2] 12:21 <08:21> 12:23 <08:21 > Today [17] 10:7<08:18> 23:24 <08:39> 25:18 <08:43> 62: 23 <09:59> 62:25 <09:59> 63:3<10:00> 63:8 <10:00> 64:16 <10:02= 79:25 <10:32> 80:3 <10:32> 83:3 <10:38> 84:3 <10:40> 84:4 <10:40> 85:1 <10:41> 86:17 <10:44> 106:10 <11:34> 112:3 <11:51> Together [2] 16:10 <08:27> 19:11 <08:31 > Tom [6] 5:14 <08:10= 50:18 <09:37> 50:19 <09:37> 52:8 <09:39> 97:7 <11:11> 104: 15 <11:30> Took [2] 18:1 <08:29> 109:16 <11:47> Tool [2] 78:8 <10:28> 78:8 <10:28> Tooth [1] 12:9 <08:20> Top [4] 27:6 <08:46> 42:3 <09:18> 100:7 <11:19> 102: 17 <11:24> Torn [2] 39:12 <09:13> 39:13 <09:13> Total [1] 26:7 <08:44> Totally [2] 110:14 <11:48> 112:6 <11:51=- Tower [1] 39:20 <09:13> Trade [1] 13:16 <08:22= Training [2] 7:21 <08:14= 19:9 <08:31= Transcript [5] 112:21 <11:52= 113:7 113:8 113:9 115:13 Transition [1] 77:16 <10:26= Travel [3] 8:12 <08:15= 8:13 <08:15= 11:9 <08:19= Travelling [1] 10:19 <08:18= Trial [12] 10:9 <08:18= 10:23 <08:18= 22:17 <08:37= 22: 23 <08:37= 23:2 <08:37= 89: 9 <10:50= 105:11 <11:32= 105:20 <11:32= 112:1 <11:51= 112:8 <11:51= 112: 8 <11:51= 112:18 <11:52= Trials [2] 6:21 <08:12= 9:19 <08:17= Trouble [1] 108:9 <11:38= Trucks [2] 32:22 <09:01= 33:2 <09:02= True [11] 35:12 <09:06= 41:24 <09:18= 42:2 <09:18= 52:15 <09:40= 81:11 <10:35= 90: 19 <10:52= 94:7 <11:02= 108:2 <11:38= 108:2 <11:38= 113:9 115:12 Trust [2] 11:25 <08:20= 29:7 <08:55= Truthful [2] 89:17 <10:51= 107:21 <11:37= Truthfully [2] 73:15 <10:17= 85:12 <10:42= Try [1] 75:7 <10:21= Trying [4] 97:21 <11:12= 97:22 <11:12= 98:5 <11:12= 112:1 <11:51= Tuesday [2] 12:3 <08:20= 12:18 <08:21 = Turlik [5] 2:10 4:17 <08:09= 4:17 <08:09= 4:20 <08:09= 4:20 <08:09= Turning [2] 46:10 <09:27= 96:12 <11:09= TV [1] 54:9 <09:43= Twelve [2] 9:16 <08:17= 21:24 <08:35= Two [4] 13:9 <08:22= 13:21 <08:22= 30:22 <08:58= 102: 18 <11:24= Type [15] 12:23 <08:21= 15:12 <08:25= 15:15 <08:25= 16: 18 <08:27= 19:13 <08:31= 32:20 <09:01= 48:5 <09:32= 49:18 <09:35= 49:22 <09:35= 56:5 <09:46= 57:10 <09:49= 57:12 <09:49= 77:9 <10:25= 84:6 <10:40= 108:6 <11:38= Types [2] 41:8 <09:17= 58:9 <09:50= _____ u u.s. 1625 Unique Words.TD Firm Name Here From Stamped to U.S. Word Index Marcella L. Duncan 09/17/04 Index Page 15 [35] 15:6 <08:24> 23:23 <08:39> 35:11 <09:06> 35: 12 <09:06> 35:20 <09:06> 56:4 <09:46> 70:18 <10:12> 70:20 <10:12> 70:21 <10:13= 87:22 <10:47> 87: 23 <10:47> 88:6<10:48> 93: 12<11:00> 93:15 <11:01> 93:16 <11:01> 93:19 <11:01> 94:4 <11:01> 94:13 <11:02> 94:16 <11:02> 94: 17 <11:02> 95:5 <11:03> 95: 11 <11:03> 95:14 <11:03> 95:18 <11:03> 95:23 <11:04> 99:21 <11:18> 99: 23 <11:18> 100:2 <11:19> 100:3 <11:19> 100:3 <11:19> 100:4 <11:19> 100: 23<11:21> 101:7 <11:22> 102:18 <11:24> 110:5 <11:48> Ultimate [1] 16:4 <08:26> Ultimately [2] 13:23 <08:23> 65:10 <10:04> Unable [1] 79:1 <10:29> Uncle [5] 13:2 <08:21 > 13:10 <08:22> 13:23 <08:23> 17: 22 <08:29> 108:11 <11:38> Uncles [3] 13:9 <08:22> 13:21 <08:22> 49:11 <09:34> Under [9] 65:3 <10:03> 73:14 <10:17> 87:1 <10:45> 87:2 <10:46> 102:24 <11:25> 105:1 <11:31> 110:5 <11:48> 115:11 115:17 Understood [5] 20:3 <08:32= 22:16 <08:37> 70:15 <10:12> 94:3 <11:01 > 110:1 <11:47> Uniqueness [1] 104:10 <11:30> United [10] 15:5<08:24> 15:5 <08:24> 35:9<09:06> 51:19 <09:38> 55:8 <09:45> 55:11 <09:45> 56:12 <09:47> 61: 21 <09:58> 61:24 <09:58> 88:2 <10:47= Units [1] 55:4 <09:45> Unless [4] 61:7<09:56> 61:11 <09:56> 102:1 <11:23> 110: 12 <11:48> Unreadable [2] 91:21 <10:55= 108:25 <11:45> Up [26] 12:6<08:20> 27:11 <08:46> 47:22 <09:31 > 47: 23 <09:31 > 50:9 <09:36> 52: 6 <09:39> 56:16 <09:47> 56: 18 <09:47> 75:20 <10:22> 75:24 <10:22> 77:24 <10:27> 78:11 <10:28> 79: 21 <10:31> 80:10 <10:33> 80:14 <10:33> 80:16 <10:33= 80:17 <10:33> 82:8 <10:36> 82:12 <10:36> 84:1 <10:39> 87:6 <10:46> 91:25 <10:56> 95:20 <11:04> 95: 23 <11:04> 101:17 <11:23> 112:2 <11:51= Upcoming [1] 10:24 <08:18> Usable [3] 35:2 <09:05> 78:8 <10:28> 112:21 <11:52> User [5] 16:4 <08:26> 36:2 <09:07> 36:4 <09:07> 36:11 <09:07> 46:3 <09:27> Users [1] 15:17 <08:25= Uses [5] 37:15 <09:09> 37:19 <09:09> 38:1 <09:10> 38:6 <09:10> 38:7 <09:10> V Vague [1] 85:17 <10:43> Validate [1] 91:8 <10:54> Validation [1] 61:8 <09:56= Valve [6] 34:19 <09:05> 34:21 <09:05> 37:24 <09:10> 100: 9 <11:19> 101:20 <11:23> 101:24 <11:23> Valves [1] 35:3 <09:05> VANDEVENTER [1] 2:7 Vanguard [1] 8:23 <08:15= Various [2] 41:13 <09:17> 61:20 <09:57> Vehicle [6] 16:1 <08:26> 16:11 <08:27> 16:12 <08:27> 30: 19 <08:57= 30:25 <08:58> 84:4 <10:40> Vehicles [1] 34:25 <09:05> Vehicular [7] 32:20 <09:01 > 32:21 <09:01 > 32:25 <09:02> 33:1 <09:02> 35:11 <09:06= 35: 19 <09:06> 35:22 <09:06> Vein [1] 110:12 <11:48= Verbiage [1] 20:22 <08:34> Vessel [1] 32:5 <09:00> Victolex [1] 61:1 <09:55> Victopac [48] 24:24 <08:41 > 31:3 <08:58> 35:22 <09:06> 35: 24 <09:06> 36:20 <09:08> 36:23 <09:08> 37:5 <09:09> 37:22 09:10= 37:25 <09:10> 38:6 <09:10> 38:7 <09:10> 38:13 <09:11> 39:1 <09:12> 39:4 09:12= 39:6 <09:12> 40:16 <09:15> 40: 21 <09:16> 41:6 09:16= 41: 13 <09:17> 41:14 <09:17> 41:15 <09:17> 41:15 <09:17> 42:6<09:19> 47:17 <09:30> 47:20 <09:30> 48: 14 <09:32> 48:16 <09:32> 51:15 <09:38> 51:16 <09:38> 58:12 <09:51> 58: 24 <09:52> 60:9 <09:54> 74: 25 <10:20> 75:1 <10:20= 75: 21 <10:22> 82:25 <10:37> 100:20 <11:20> 101:14 <11:22> 101:19 <11:23> 101:21 <11:23> 101:23 <11:23> 102:1 <11:23=- 102: 5 <11:23> 102:10 <11:24> 102:12 <11:24> 102:12 <11:24> 102:20 <11:25> 106:24 <11:36> Victopacs [1] 41:19 <09:18> Victor [118] 3:9 3:11 3:13 3:14 3:16 7:6 <08:13> 7:7<08:13> 7:7 <08:13> 7:9 <08:13> 7:10 <08:13> 7:11 <08:13> 7:18 <08:14> 7:23 <08:14> 8:19 <08:15> 9:14 08:16= 14:14 <08:23> 15:8 <08:24> 16:7 <08:26> 18:12 <08:30> 19: 24 08:32= 22:11 <08:36> 23:18 <08:38> 24:15 <08:40> 24:25 <08:41 > 25: 14 <08:42> 25:24 08:43= 26:2 <08:43> 26:9 <08:45> 26:24 <08:45= 27:13 <08:46> 27:17 <08:46> 27: 23 08:47= 28:12 28:18 <08:49> 31:3 <08:58> 31:8 <08:58> 32:8 <09:00> 33:13 <09:03> 33:19 <09:03> 33: 24 <09:03> 34:15 <09:04> 35:4 <09:05> 36:3 <09:07> 38:14 <09:11> 40:3<09:14> 41:21 <09:18> 42:7<09:19> 42:19 <09:19> 42:24 <09:20> 43:6 <09:20> 43:15 <09:21> 44:1 <09:22> 44:12 <09:23> 45:10 <09:25> 45: 19 <09:26> 45:25 <09:27> 46:3 <09:27> 46:11 <09:27> 47:1 <09:28> 47:12 49:16 <09:35> 49:24 <09:35> 50:6 <09:36> 50:12 <09:36> 50: 22 <09:37> 51:21 <09:39> 52:7 <09:39> 52:8 <09:39> 52:11 <09:40> 52:20 09:40= 52:24 <09:40> 53:6 <09:41 > 53:20 <09:42> 54:1 <09:43> 54:11 <09:43> 54: 15 <09:44> 55:3 <09:44> 56: 11 <09:47> 56:22 <09:48> 56:23 <09:48> 58:18 <09:51> 59:17 09:53= 59: 24 <09:53> 60:5 <09:54> 60: 8 <09:54> 60:16 <09:55> 60: 19 <09:55> 62:20 <09:59> 62:25 <09:59> 63:4<10:00> 63:17 <10:01> 65:16 <10:04> 65:17 <10:04> 65: 18 <10:04> 69:8 <10:10> 72: 21 <10:16> 77:5 <10:25= 77: 13<10:26> 79:8 <10:30> 81: 1 <10:34> 81:9<10:34> 83:2 <10:38> 84:2<10:39> 85:3 <10:41> 86:1 <10:43= 86:17 <10:44> 87:19 <10:47> 87: 20 <10:47> 88:14 <10:48> 88:17 <10:49> 90:15 <10:52> 91:7 <10:54> 92:22 99:17103:7107:25 <11:37> 109:15 <11:47> 110:21 <11:49> Victorite [1] 61:1 <09:55> View [1] 12:5 <08:20> Violations [2] 53:23 09:42= 54:2 <09:43> Virginia [28] 1:1 1:24 4:4 4:7 4:9 6:21 <08:12> 10:5 <08:18> 10:9 <08:18> 10:16 <08:18> 10: 24 <08:18> 14:24 <08:24> 15:1 <08:24> 16:7 <08:26> 16:22 <08:28> 17:4 <08:28> 23:3 <08:37> 24:6 <08:39> 24:9 <08:39> 91:14 <10:55> 93:13 <11:01> 105:20 <11:32= 114:6 115:1 115:3 115:4115:7115:18 115:18 Visit [5] 17:24 <08:29> 17:25 <08:29> 18:2<08:29> 18:12 <08:30> 18:12 <08:30> Visits [2] 15:12 <08:25> 53:19 <09:42> VMG-25-0000150 [2] 3:11 47:13 VMG-25-0000159 [2] 3:12 47:14 Volume [3] 15:10 <08:25> 26:7 <08:44> 47:19 <09:30> w Wait [1] 93:23 <11:01> Waive [1] 112:13 <11:52> Walinski [2] 56:17 80:9 <10:32> Walked [1] 33:20 09:03= Warning [4] 10:11 <08:18> 43:11 <09:21> 48:6 <09:32> 48:13 <09:32> Warnings [3] 48:10 <09:32> 48:15 <09:32> 48:18 <09:33> Waste [4] 97:19 <11:11> 97:24 <11:12=- 98:22 <11:15> 98: 24 <11:15> Watch [1] 99:2 <11:15> Water [3] 15:22 <08:26> 34:23 <09:05> 71:9 <10:13> Week [1] 10:22 <08:18> Weeks [2] 10:6 <08:18> 12:11 <08:21> Weight [4] 26:9 <08:45> 31:22 <08:59> 41:4 <09:16> 41:5 <09:16> Wellington [1] 54:20 <09:44> Whatsoever [2] 8:14 <08:15= 65:9 <10:03= Whole [2] 48:2 <09:31= 110:21 <11:49= WILLIAM [1] 1:15 WILLIAMS [1] 2:11 Wit [2] 114:6 115:1 Witness [9] 5:10 <08:10= 5:17 <08:11= 5:24 <08:11= 6:20 <08:12= 6:24 <08:12= 10:9 <08:18= 11:2 <08:19= 22:24 <08:37= 66:12 <10:05= Wooden [1] 47:25 <09:31= Word [3] 43:7 <09:20= 44:17 <09:23= 83:7 <10:38= Words [1] 84:9 <10:40= Worker [1] 106:21 <11:35= Worker's [1] 54:10 <09:43= Works [3] 61:8 <09:56= 78:22 <10:29= 96:10 <11:06= World [3] 28:19 <08:49= 42:7 <09:19= 91:11 <10:54= World's [3] 27:15 <08:46= 27:24 <08:47= 46:11 <09:27= Worldwide [1] 41:20 <09:18= Worn [1] 45:10 <09:25=___________ Wrap [1] 47:25 <09:31= Wrapped [2] 47:18 <09:30= 47:25 <09:31 = Wrapping [3] 47:23 <09:31= 48:15 <09:32= 48:22 <09:33= Wrappings [2] 48:4 <09:32= 48:14 <09:32= Write [1] 104:9 <11:30= Writing [4] 57:19 <09:50= 65:6 <10:03= 65:7 <10:03= 103: 19 <11:27= Writings [1] 29:19 <08:56= Written [4] 20:12 <08:33= 64:22 <10:03= 76:16 <10:23= 83:6 <10:38= Yard [1] 93:12 <11:00= Year [15] 7:25 <08:14= 9:6 <08:16= 17:4 <08:28= 24:7 <08:39= 58:14 <09:51= 68:4 <10:07= 68:13 <10:08= 90:1 <10:51= 90:14 <10:52= 90: 16 <10:52= 90:25 <10:53= 97:18 <11:11= 104:19 <11:31= 104:21 <11:31= 106:16 <11:35= Years [33] 9:22 <08:17= 13:11 <08:22= 14:7 <08:23= 14:9 <08:23= 18:5 <08:29= 19:9 <08:31= 20:4 <08:32= 20:17 <08:33= 24:24 <08:41= 25:2 <08:41= 34:1 <09:03= 38:15 <09:11= 49:8 <09:34= 49:8 <09:34= 54:6 <09:43= 54:8 <09:43= 55:20 <09:46= 56: 19 <09:48= 56:21 <09:48= 57:5 <09:49= 57:6 <09:49= 57:13 <09:49= 57:14 <09:49= 57:14 <09:49= 57: 16 <09:49= 57:17 <09:49= 58:2 <09:50= 66:19 <10:05= 71:12 <10:14= 74:2 <10:18= 80:11 <10:33= 84:20 <10:41= 85:24 <10:43= Yourself [1] 91:18 <10:55= z Zahn [2] 4:3 115:2 ZEBULON [1] 1:10 Zello [1] 5:5 <08:10= 1625 Unique Words.TD, Firm Name Here From U.S. to Zello PEMGAD803 631-C30J 'V-r-.v EXHIBIT ^i/A/Cdw ) GAS K E T 16 EDITION G UIDE MAY 1955 VJC:T.O J VIDTCPRENE \\ OIL SEALS VICTOR MFG. & GASKET CO., C HICAGO, U. S. A. __*Trinl DV -104 Sealing Products Exclusively. The re search, production, and distributing facili ties of the Victor Company are devoted entirely to the manufacture of gaskets, oil seals, gasket materials, sheet packings, and kindred sealing products. Practically all of these products, with the exception of cork gaskets and sheets, are produced from basic raw materials within Victor Plants. ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT The Victor Company is the largest supplier of gaskets and oil seals for original equipment installa tion to manufacturers and producers of automotive vehicles, passenger cars, light and heavy trucks, tractors, busses, and farm equipment. The same wide variety and quality of product is supplied for REPLACEMENT applications. Also available are our alternate preferred constructions or materials. INDUSTRIAL The Yicfor line embraces a variety of gaskets, oil seals, and packings used in production and mainte nance outside of the automotive field. Special cata logs are available for oil seals and gaskets. RAILROADS Victor products are widely used in diesel loco motives, steam locomotives, and various railroad devices and equipment. MILITARY REQUIREMENTS The builders of heavy duty engines and equip ment depend upon Victor to supply most of their cylinder head and other gaskets. Likewise, U. S. Military and the prime contractors have depended upon the .wide experience of Victor engineers in the development of oil seals for critical applications. GASKETS -V - - Full coverage for all automotive installations in ' - eluding cylinder head, manifold, oil pan, and misV. cellaneous applications of various types and conA&structions- designed to function effectively under all |foperating conditions. f VICTOPRENE OIL SEALS Igf.yictor pioneered the development and manufacfuro qf oil'seals employing a synthetic rubber seal*ng|clement which is .now the preferred type for .^yhost severe as well as standard applications ond.is rapidly replacing other types for general use. Jtly engine applications of oil seals are listed in Wvcatalog; For a complete listing, including wheel PPB^OtiohSj 'see'the latest Victor Oil Seal Guide. GASKETS OIL SEALS and other Sealing Products SPECIAL PACKING MATERIALS Among Victor sealing products are especially compounded pocking materials used in fabricating . gaskets and oil seals. These, for the most part, are developed and manufactured from basic materials and for specific requirements. ' Asbestocork Asbestopoc Asbestoprene Asbestos Millboard Corbestos . Silicone * Teflon YictoUne Victolex * Ylctopac Yictorite ' . > Yicfoplate '. ARMSTRONG-VICTOR CORK GASKETS The Armstrong, Company, the world's leading ` producer of cork products, and the Victor Company are associated in supplying the -trade the finest quality and best Merchandised line of cork gaskets; cork sheets, and other cork products. The dimen sional accuracy and uniform density of ArmstrongVictor sheet cork, from which gaskets are blanked, is assured by the new dielectric curing process de veloped by the Armstrong Cork Company. . GASKET SETS Head gasket sets, general overhaul, and other gasket sets are in wide demand. While Victor Gasket set coverage is. by far the most comprehen sive, facilities for making sets are constantly being expanded. . . NUMBERING AND LABELING The Yictor numbering system is simple apd con venient. Packages and sets bear legible. printed labels listing the manufacturer's part number and also the corresponding Victor Replacing number in bold figures. Gasket and oil seal numbers are also imprinted upon the product. CATALOGING Clear, concise, and comprehensive cataloging is essential to the marketing of any quality product.. The Yictor Company is justly proud of the- wide ! acceptance and use of their printed matter of which this Guide is an example. Equally well prepared are catalogs covering industrial, oil seals-and in dustrial gaskets. .. . Victor Sealing Products have world wide distribution JYIO-A convenient counter or Aoor disptoy of sturdy wire construction. There *s no charge for this display rack' in this assortment and it in dudes t roll each' of JV11, JV12, JV1$. VICTORITE A Quality Treated Paper Packing Use--Cutting gaskets for applications where high tem peratures ore not encountered--examples--oil pan, valve cover or gear cover gaskets. Characteristics Leolhertike in toughness High tensile strength Pliable Compressibility less than cork but odequafe for most applicolions. Absorption. Highly resistont to absorption of oil, gosoline, woter ond most acids. Shrinkage. Very slight except of higher tempera* tures. Effect of storage. Pliobility ond other characteristics retained for a long time unless exposed to ab normal conditions of heat and dryness. Thickness t Standard roll thicknesses are ICf, Hi* and Jf*w. Other thicknesses produced to order ore .006", .010", .020", .045" ond .125". The or .125" thickness is made by laminating twd sheets ond can be supplied in sheets Rolls . Viclorife is supplied In rolls 36" wide or 18" wide. JY-93C--Asturdy wire display rock pic tured here will be loaned to dealers who carry 36" rolls of Victorite packing. Furnished with first order for 3 rolls. This rock is shipped in a sturdy corru gated carton. Shipping weigh! 40 lbs. VICTORITE BY THE ROLL Shipping Weight Thickness length Width lbs. Kilos JV-11 & <0.4 m.m.)......... ,.10yds. 4V-12-J6 <0.8 m.m.)......... ..10 yds. JV-13-Xs <1-5 m.m.).......... 18" 4 18" 8 18" 8 2 4 4 The above rolls may be purchased separately for refills: JV-90-% <0.4 m.m.)-------- .50 yds. 36" 50 23 JV-94-% <0.4 m.m.);... ...25 yds. 36" 25 12 JV-97-%4 <0.4 m.m.)--------..25 yds. 18" 13 6 JV-91-% <0.8 m.m.)......... 36" 95 43 JV-9S-K, <0.8 m.m.)_____ ' ' 36" 48 22 JV-98-% (0.8 m.m.).......... . 25 yds. 18" 24 It Thickness length JV-92-% (1.6 m.m.)____ ..25 yds. JV-96-% (1.6 m.m.)____ ..15 yds. JV-99-% (1-6 m.tn.)____ Shipping Weight Width lbs. Kilos 36" 36" 18" 90 . 41 55 25 28 13 HANDY ROLL IN JV-NM--.010" (.25 m.m.). ...36" JV-103-.010" (.25 m.m.). ...36" JV-100-& (0.4 m.m.)... ...36" JV-IOl-Xs <0.8 m.m.)___ ...36" JV-102-J<i <1.6 m.m.)... ...36" JV-105-% <2.4 m.m.)..: ...36" JV-106--*4 (3.2 m.m.)___ ...36" CARTON 18" 8 oz. 36" 12 or. 18" 10 oz: 18" 1 18" 36" 1 'A 3 lbs. 36" 4 lbs. .23 .34 .23 .45 .68 1.36 1.81 JV-40--Handy Tube Assortment, containing: one piece of Victorite 10x36x36" one piece of Yictopac 10x40x36" Every repair shop should have one YICTOPAC Compressed .asbestos or high pressure sheet pocking, long fibre osbeslos ond small rubber content--a superior grade pack ing: of tbfs type. If. is resistant to oil, water and gasoline, and will withstand.comiderable heat and pressure. Ordinarily sup plied not gropbited. Can be supplied graphited on one or both sides. .* ` * . SHEETS ' Vidor . .. Weight No. ' `Sheet ' per sheet iV-97 .......... I'..............................12%"x25"*%" JY-88 .......... ............................12%"x25"xX," JV-85 .......... ................................ 25" x25"x)6" %lb. 1 % lbs. 1%lb. JV-86 ........................................... 25" x25"*X<" 2>/j lbs. , -- " - -*25x50" or 50"x5O" sheet supplied if desired. / j It. packing is desired to provide minimum oil swell ond in- \__ / 4"ie<* resistance, specify Victopac #50V or #60Y. Aaje 328 HANDY CARTONS Rolls 50" long and 10" wide in square carton convenient for keeping in stock. JV-210--J6" both sides plain. JV-213-36" both sides plain. JV-211 --36" one side graphited. JV-2! 4--36" one side graphited. JV-212--36" both sides graphited. JV-215--36" both sides graphited. ' ' l 2 I f ri Jr D Order Armstrong-Victor electronically baked cork mi CORBESTOS Sheet gasket material consisting of steel core with treoted ond graphited asbestos on both sides, the asbestos being held by smalt tangs punched from the steel. This material is used for cylinder head gaskets and other applications where heat and pressure is encountered. Warning. This material is difficult to cut by hond. best pro* cedure is to lay out gasket on a board. Then place corbestos between two boards and cut design on o band sow. Use punches for small boles. Material con be cut with straight and curved chisels or cutting Modes. ' JV-222. Corbestos sheet 10yi"x36"x&'V . Corbestos con be- supplied in sheets up to 24" wjde and 36" long, (not carried in stock) O ARMSTRONG-VICTOR CORK SHEET New Electronic Baking Process makes Better Cork Gaskets The greatest advance in cork gasket making since modern Armstrong cork composition was first Introduced. Fast efficient electronic cork baking takes the place of slow uncertain steam curing. The result--stronger, livelier, better-sealing .gaskets than ever before. The Manufacturer. Armstrong-Victor cork sheets ore mode by the Armstrong Cork Compony for many years the world's leading manufacturer of cork products. The Armstrong Company operates in Spain and Portugal where cork is grown ond is in position to obtain the best bark available. Quality. The Armstrong cork sheet is mode from selected clean cork granules free from hard-back. The binder has been developed by Armstrong through years of research and test. In the Armstrong sheet the qualities of natural cork are retained to a greoter degree thon most other sheets on the market. Shrinkage-Stability. Armstrong cork sheet has the highest degree of stability ond does not shrink perceptibly unless subject to extreme conditions of heat ond dryness. This is a mosf im portant point of superiority in the Armstrong-Victor sheet and cut goskets. Sizes. Three standard sheet sizes and four standard thicknesses as shown below. Thicknesses up to %" and sheets as long as 50" con be supplied to order. * Packaging. Ten sheets in a flat box, except *4" which is packed 5 to a box, clearly lobelfed on the end. Fine Granule. For some uses fine granule cork sheet is desir able, although for ordinary uses, the standard coarse granule sheet (No. 9530) is the best. There are several grades of density in fine granule sheet, the most commonly used being No. 114. ? Such sheets are supplied to order--prices on request. ' Resin-Bonded Cork. In some tropical climates standard cork composition is subject to mold which causes disintegration. Resin-bonded cork composition is effective in meeting this con dition. Coarse granule resin-bnoded cork is No. 414. Fine granule No. 514. . Sheets and cut gaskets of resin-bonded cork con be supplied to order if the quantity is targe enough to warrant o special run. Quotations on request. Cork Sheet (Coarse Granule Standard Binder) Yidor No. 32500 32501 32502 32503 32600 32601 32602 32603 39960 '39961 39962 39963 Sheet Size 36" * 12" 36"x12" 36" x12" 36"x12" 36"x16" 36"x16" 36"x16" 36" x16" 36"x18" 36"x18" 36"x18" 36"x18" Thickness K" 36" X," 36" %" %" x<r 36" o ASBESTOS MILLBOARD . Manufactured by Victor The Yicfor Company manufactures asbestos millboard under exacting specifications for making gaskets. It is even in thickness .and uniform in density. No organic binders are used. In normal tifoes this high quality sheet is offered to trade and industry in large or small quantities. Sheet size. Full size sheet 42"x48". Smaller sizes to order. ' Stock sizes as follows; '. JY-310 10"x36"x%" JV-311 15"x40"xJ6" Thicknesses. to %" 1 Prices. Quoted on request. Samples sent if desired. Page 329 mm V^! Vidor Sealing Produds used thruout the world THE MOTOR BUILDERS' H#ICE MULDERSf That Victor gaskets for many years have been the most widely used for original equipment can be attributed to the pioneering of new ideas and the science of gasketing by Victor engineers, the thousands of dies built over the past forty-six years, the exacting specifications covering raw materials demanded by Victor of. their suppliers--all of which has been a part of the evolution of a product that must keep not abreast, but ahead, of the rapid prog ress of automotive engineering. ' The dedication of all of its vast facilities .by the Victor Company solely to the manufacture of sealing products of wide variety has enabled it to gain and maintain its pre-eminent position in the automotive industry. PASSENGER* CARS (In production in 1955) Buick Codilloc Chevrolet - Ford Hudson Kaiser Chrysler DeSoto Dodge . Lincoln Mercury Nash Oldsmobite Packard Plymouth Pontiac Studebaker Willys TRUCKS AND BUSES ACF Autocar Brockway Chevrolet Diamond T Divco Dodge Federal Ford FWO GMC International Mach Oshkosh . Reo Studebaker While also various other makes using engines below. ENGINES--TRUCK, BUS, TRACTOR, INDUSTRIAL ACF Budo Caterpillar Continenlal Hall-ScoU Hercules leRoi Lycoming Waukesha Wisconsin and others. TRACTORS Allis Chalmers Case Caterpillar Deere Ford Ferguson International Harvester Massey-Harris McCormick-Deering Minneapolis-Moline Oliver ptso other makes using engines lisled below. DIESEL ENGINES Buda Caterpillar Continenlal Cummins Fairbanks-Morse General Motors * Hercules Internationa! Harvester Mack Murphy Nordberg Waukesha AIRCRAFT ENGINES Allison Boeing Continental Fairchild ' Franklin General Electric Jacobs Lycoming MARINE ENGINES Chris-Oaft Chrysler Gray Hall-Scolt Johnson Kermath Noy.o Scripps Standard Pratt-Whitney Westinghouse Wright MOTORCYCLES Harley-DaYidson ' fdge 336 JC& INDUSTRIES SERVED a X\ i Automotive Transportation Passenger Cars Trucks Buses Motorcycles Tractors Air Transportation oPlane Engines Fuselages Water Transportation Large Diesel and Gasoline Power Units Medium Gasoline and Diesel Engines Steam Power Units Outboard Motors Miscellaneous Auxiliary Equipment Rail Transportation Diesel Locomotives Steam Locomotives Rail Cars Motor cats and other light units Freight handling Equipment Air Brake equipment Maintenance equipment Agriculture Tractors Various Farm Equipment Mowers Miscellaneous Power Equipment Construction Equipment Tractors Bulldozers Derricks and Hoists Power Shovels Graders Ditch Equipment Road Construction Equipment Miscellaneous Power Units Power and Transmission Large Diesel Units Small Diesel Units. Pipe Flanges Boiler Handholes and Manholes Oil Industry Oil Refineries Oil Transportation Machinery and Machine Tools Oil Seals on shafts etc. Electrical Motors Refrigeration and Air Conditioning Large Commercial Units Household Units Household Appliances Washing Machines Kitchen Mixers Miscellaneous Industry in General Wherever Gasoline and diesel engines are used there are numerous uses for gaskets, oil seals and other sealing products. Suppliers of War Equipment Prime movers, tanks, guns, jeeps, submarines, ships, airplanes and various lighting equipment. .m\ vV HE SUN NEVER SETS ON HE VICTOR TRADEMARK R ITS PRODUCTS Wherever there are American passenger cars, trucks, tractors or engines, the users have learned to depend on Victor sealing products for maintenance. Victor catalogs and the distinctive Victor packages are as well known in the export market as in .the domestic. Victor is the acknowledged leader in its field. The Victor trademark is registered in each of the following countries. Argentina Belgium Brazil Canada Chile ..--Colombia Denmark France Holland India Italy Mexico Peru Philippine Islands Puerto Rico Spain Sweden Switzerland Union of South Africa United States VICTOR ""P .*~v! % STANDARD A H.1^ mmm% } fjokti Harvey Victor 1882-1957 Founder of the Victor Manufacturing & Gasket Com pany in 1909, John Harvey Victor wasactive in man agement of the company up to die day of his unexpected death, December 8,1957, in Wilmette, Illinois. He Was chairman of the board. Bom in Chicago in 1882, he became a master tool and die maker at an early age, and was but 27 when he launched his gasket busings. Dedication But could the hand of fate be stayed for a fleeting year, John Harvey Victor would have led the business he founded in Chicago in 1909 to the very dawn of its golden anniversary year. - His anticipation of this event was great--not with a self-centered prideof achieve ment, for he was a truly modest man. His expectation was the simple, rightful heritage of a courageous business pioneer--Bering the enterprise he launched with little capital become a well-established, vigorous industry leader at its half-century mark. It was sheer vision, courage and determination in the young man of 27 that gave birth to the Victor Manufacturing and Gasket Company of today. John Victor had an idea for building a better gasket -- but be had no machinery, no facilities, no affluent financial backers. ' t .. Still, together with his brother,. Joseph B., he ventured forth. And when the first ' machine was acquired and installed in his tittle basement shop, the future looked bright to John Victor--he was in business to stay. I t At this major milepost in the company's history, we proudly salute the spirit and traditions of our founder . . . and therefore, in com memoration of John H. Victor,- we dedicate this 50th Anniversary Issue of the Gasket Guide. We are confident this would be the wish of alt who knew him. VMG-25-0000151 The first factory--a stare building on Chicago's West Side, into which the business moved tram a basement shop. Here John H. Victor produced gaskets for the early automotive industries. years in sealing products There's a distinct parallel in the history of gasket and oil seal development and the 50-year growth of Victor Manufacturing and Gasket Company. John H. Victor had an idea for building & better gasket than was generally available at the time. Against the toughest odds--for he had no ready access to capital--he was determined to do some thing about it A skilled tool and die maker, he had the manufacturing know-how, and already he owned at least one basic- patent on gasket construction. But more so, he -held the conviction there would al ways be a market for better-made sealing products. That was in 1909, and that's haw the Victor Manufacturing and Gasket Company was bom in an apartment house basement shop. Later that year, still in the modest basement quarters but now with five employees, the business was incorporated. Quickly John H. Victor took his product to the several similarly pioneering automotive builders. They liked what they saw--a new copper-asbestos gasket construction that promised tighter engine seal ing, with longer life and greater protection against blow-out. -. . It wasn't long before the-Victor company became the major gasket supplier to the rapidly growing, automotive industry--and young John H. Victor's business philosophy was completely vindicated. On his better-product philosophy his company would grow--and grow it did. NEW GROWTH ERA In 1919, after, two earlier expansion moves, Victor was established in its own built-to-order plant with quadrupled space. The plant was completely equipped for quality mass production and personnel numbered about 185. But this major move was only the beginning of a new growth era for the still young company. , While automobile manufacturing boomed, new markets across industry opened for Victor. Each new application need was a challenge to design and build the best gasket possible. Each such challenge was met with constantly improving manufacturing tech niques, quality control, and testing methods. Steel and asbestos gasket structures grew in use along with the original copper-asbestos combination. New packing materials were added. Developments in these products enlarged the company's basic patent holdings. OIL SEALS ADDED Early in the '30's John H. Victor was ready to ex pand into oil seal production. Again he saw the opportunity for product improvement; he wasn't satisfied that leather was the best sealing element In a few short years Victor Research Laboratories-- the first in the sealing products industry--pioneered the development of the synthetic rubber sealing element . The next decade marked wide expansion in both product lines and production techniques. There was development in packings--asbestos, cork, and rubber compositions. New machinery, much -of it built to the company's own specifications, replaced the old. During World War II, Victor's .total facilities worked at full capacity to keep our war machine on the road to victory. . MORE NEW PLANTS With the war won and business booming, more plants were added to take care of the now world wide demand for Victor sealing products. These plants included a complete gasket manufacturing unit at St Thomas, Ontario, Canada. As a result of this steady growth and expansion, Victor today produces over 100,000 different sealing products--gaskets, oil seals, packings. These prod ucts are sold the world over, direct to every auto motive and machinery industry for original equip ment--and through thousands of jobbers and whole salers for every replacement need.- VMG-25-0000152 Pag "Setter Seating Products Through, Research**-- a living slogan at Vidor. Established In 1933, Vidor Research laboratories steadily have led the industry. The World's largest manufacturer of Gaskets...Oil Seals... and Packings Precision oil seat and gasket manufacturing begins with precision-made dies, tools, and molds--an Integral depart ment of Victor since Its Inception. 4 Dynamometer testing of sealing products was initialed by Vidor, and this department indudes the latest type of equip ment to insure products dependability. Ia strong contrast with the company's humble origin, from a small basement shop, Victor .plants today comprise more than ll/i million square feet of manufacturing area in seven separate units. Victor Sealing Products reach to the four cor ners of the earth with a world-wide distribution system. PERSONNEL From five employees in 1909, Victor's personnel today numbers in excess of 2000. Fifty per cent of these employees have been with Victor for more than five years. The 25-Year Club has 115 active members and approximately 45 inactive. RAW MATERIALS Approximately 1000 carloads of raw materials are needed annually to produce Victor products. These include approximately 4% million pounds of cop , per ... % million pounds of brass ... 32 million pounds of steel ... 7 million pounds of asbestos millboard . . . and more, than % million pounds of synthetic rubber. ... ___________ _________ ~_:M0RE `THAN ONE MILLION :SQUARElFEETjb^FACXpRY;^S General Offices and Manufacturing--Plant No. 1 *ii iilliiij sipLj s j 3ggf?|_ Pcge 2 Oil Seal Manufacturing-- Plant No. 3 Commercial laboratory and Packing Materials Manufacturing |teft)--Research laboratory and Asbestos Millboard Manufacturing {right}-- Plant No. 2 .......... . ^ VMG-25-0000153 % rt k<' SSMitfzu ' NUMBER OF PRODUCTS The number and variety of Vidor products total more than 100,000 different items--including gaskets, oil seals and packings. INDUSTRIES SERVED Typical industries served, by Victor are: automo tive, air, water and rail transportation; agricul ture; construction, power and power transmission equipment; the oil industry; machinery and ma chine tools; electrical, refrigeration and air-condi. tioning industries; household appliances; and sup pliers of war equipment. DISTRIBUTION Victor products are distributed in the United States and Canada through thousands of auto motive and industrial parts jobbers and distribu tors. In addition, Victor products are sold in for eign countries from north to south and east to west. The sun never sets on the Victor trade-mark or its products. Vidor's automation techniques indude this three story high conveyor system that deans, applies and hakes on the alumiaom coating to steel gaskets aU in one continuous operation. Asbestos millboard -- Victor knows' and controls the proper ties of this packing material. Yidor has operated Its awn sheeting mill since 1935. Asbestos fiber and synthetic rubber is mixed ond bonded . under heat and pressure to form a tough homogeneous sheet of V1CTOPAC packing material. SPACE FOR SEALING PROD`UHC^TTCS EexXcClLuUsSiIvVeElLyY.^^. ^ Bulk Stocking and Labeling Division-' Plant No. 4 _ i EREP iifbiBebcchne, ; `Jim BV* BHB'j ESSEJSi'i Merchandising, Packaged Stock and Shipping Division-- Plant No. 5 VMG-25-0000154 Complete Gasket Manufacturing in CanadaVictor Mfg. & Gasket Ca. of Canada limited -Thomas, Ontario pAt Pioneering Skill To meet the demand for better gaskets, the Victor Company through the years has developed and patented the principal reinforced designs that are in common use today, some of which are illustrated on these pages. Among them are the steel grom met reinforcement (U.S. Patent 1748582), the United grommet re inforcement (U. S. Patent 1472133), the wire insert reinforcement IU. S. Patent 1819694) and the Victoprene grommet reinforce ment (U. S. Patent 2395243). HYDRO-BRIGHT-ANNEALED COPPER The early copper gaskets were discolored and some times covered with scale due to necessary anneal ing before forming. Victor first introduced into ' gasket making, "Hydro-Bright-Annealed" copper that maintained the bright and attractive appear ance of copper even after annealing. ASBESTOS With the demand for better gaskets came the search for an asbestos sheet of more uniform thick ness and density and with improved binder. In 1935 Victor installed its own equipment to make asbestos sheet especially for gaskets. Probably no single development has contributed more to better gasket performance than the type of sheet made on the Victor equipment USE OP STEEL Steel offers greater resistance to burning and pres sure than copper, although the softer copper makes a better fluid seat than bare steel. Victor has de veloped several types of gaskets where the ad vantage of both metals are retained. Standard practice today is to use tin plate. PRECOTE In 1937, Victor developed "Precote" (Reg. U. S. Patent office), a coating that is applied and dried on the he&dgasket in manufacture. It gives added sealing qualities needed' in a steel faced gasket Victor was the originator of this type of treatment and today, Victor steelfaced gaskets are precoated. VICTOCOR A complete departure from' conventional design, Victocor Motor Seal has a metal core with a spe- YJctoccr -- Special combination of Vtdoprene and asbestos mechanically clomped to o steel Inter! by prongs resulting from 800 perforations per square Inch. Single Overlap -The standard copperasbestos or steel gasket, light duty. Yic-2-fotd --Using material from top and bottom layers to form overlap in alt holes to be sealed assures a balance of com pressed thickness at all openings. Corbestos--Treated asbestos combmed to both sides of a perforated steel sheet and surface coated. Grommets applied tc cylinder openings and water openings as required. Rubber grommets maided to retaining steel washers Inserted in Vc-2*fold or other constructions to assure fluid seal at areas not sufficiently damped for metal to metal contact. (U.S. Patent 2395243} A single thickness of precoated, special hardness steel, pre-formed to assure con centration of loading at points to be sealed. VMG-25-0000155 clal asbestos-elastomeric compound bonded to both faces. The exclusive core design combines the resili ence of rubber, the'heat resistance of asbestos and the strength of steeL The extreme resiliency of Victoeor's sealing ele ment helps compensate for head warpage and de fects on mating surfaces of head and block. No pre-coating is needed for installation, yet, there is no sticking ifit is necessary later to remove the head. . Approved by leading car builders, Victocor gaskets are available for replacement in most late model passenger cars. . VICTOR PATENTS The preeminence of the Victor Company in the origination of improvements in gasket design is evidenced by a long list of patents which includes nearly all of the patentable constructions now in common use. Shown at right is a list of patents covering gaskets and oil seals that have been issued to the Victor Company. VICTOR STANDARDS In toe Victor laboratories and in a very complete testing department, which includes the various types of internal combustion anginas mounted on dynamometers, gasket developments of tomorrow are in process. IIST OF PRESENT VICTOR PATENTS GASKETS 1*241,587 1,238,817 1,398.6(2 1,472,133 1,626,962 1,492,857 1,740.760 1,748,582 1,768,995 1470,548 1,771,596 1,779,416 1.789.594 1.189.595 1,789,770 1,793,423 1,798>246 1,804,574 1,8(4,283 1.815.601 1.815.602 1.819.494 1,823,264 1.823.341 1.823.342 1,828,471 1,829,248 1,835,356 1.838.494 1,839,336 1,843.297 1.846.401 1.846.402 1,853,175 1,862.703 1,864,328 1,664,854 . 1,893,881 1,904,651 .1,911.484 1,913,736 1.932.538 1.932.539 1,956,183 1.957,798 1,974,633 1.965.473 1,985,475 RE-19,874 2,021.571 2,026,854 2,070,918 2,092,231 2,127,372 2,130.110 2,157,102 2,209,230 2,211,247 2,289.620 22,439459,424335 2471,075 2,593448 2481441 2,793462 2,729,483 2.753.19? OIL SEALS 1,938.648 1.985.474 1.992.790 2422404 2,040479 2,055,917 2455.918, 2,061,153 22,407701.410236 2,073*768 , 2492,237 2,114,908 2,116440 2,145,928 2,149,147 2,161,767 2,166,293 2,167403 2,172425 2,173406 2.185.790 2.191,873 2,208,482 2,209,578 2409,750 2410,723 2.210,748 2,210,823 2.212,291 2,213,116 2424.449 2427471 2433,147 2433459 2,233,902 2435,735 22444^00,423522 2448451 2459.607 2459.608 2,259459 2,301,993 2,319,067 2,330,104 2434,349 2.348.586 2.348.587 2,347,403 2,367,411 2.405,279 2,468,247 2,483,988 2,465,011 2,493,255 2,558.183 2475,818 2,637,574 2,646,295 2,647477 245(434 2495.801 2,709498 2,729,482 2,806,725 2,826,441 2,855,219 2,868,566 ' 2484,267 A Corbestos layer with a thin metal tap and heavy copper or steel <jQt5-.020) bot tom formed at combustion openings, laminated metal -- Metal layers, usually aluminum used as the filler far a basic Vic-2-fold construction fa furnish maximom fire power and torque loss resist ance. Steel grommet reinforcement around cylin der openings. Copper or steel layers. U.S. Patent 174858. Web or united grommets. Flat copper or steel layers with inserted grommets joined together. U.S. Patent 1472133. Wire insert reinforcement (copper or sleet) around cylinder opening. U. S, -Patent 1819694. Twin type Corbestos consists of two sheets of single sided Corbestos held together fay individual combustion chamber flanges and other grommets. ;?'T\.'\\mnas VMG-25-0000156 ORIGINAL EQUIPMENT The Victor Company is the largest supplier of gaskets and oil seals for original equipment instal developed and manufactured from basic materials and for specific requirements. Asbestocork Silicone Victoplate 1i lation to manufacturers and producers of auto Asbestopac Teflon Victorite motive vehicles, passenger cars, light and heavy Asbestoprene , Victolene Victocor trucks, tractors, busses, and farm equipment The Asbestos Millboard Victolex Victocork same wide variety and quality of product is sup Victopac Victoprene plied for REPLACEMENT applications. ARMSTRONG-Y1CTOR CORK GASKETS INDUSTRIAL The Armstrong Company, the world's leading The Victor line embraces a variety of gaskets, producer of cork products, and the Victor Com oil seals, and packings used in production and pany are associated in supplying the trade with maintenance outside of the automotive field. Spe the finest quality and best merchandised line of cial catalogs are available for industrial. gaskets cork gaskets, cork sheets, and other cork products. and oil seals. The dimensional accuracy and uniform density RAILROADS of. Annstrong-Victor sheet cork, from which gas kets are blanked, is assured by the new dielectric Victor products are widely used in diesel loco curing .process developed by the Armstrong Cork motives, steam locomotives, and various railroad Company. ) devices and equipment GASKET SETS MILITARY IUQUIREMENTS Head gasket sets, general overhaul, and other The builders of heavy duty engines and equip gasket sets' are in wide demand. While Victor ment depend upon Victor to supply most of their Gasket set coverage is by far the most compre cylinder head and other gaskets. Likewise, U. S. hensive, facilities- for making sets are constantly .Military and the prime contractors have depended being expanded. upon the wide experience of Victor engineers in the development of oil seals for critical applications. NUMBERING AND LABELING GASKETS The Victor numbering system is simple and convenient. Packages and sets bear legible printed Full coverage for all automotive installations labels listing the manufacturer's part number and including cylinder head, manifold, oil pan and also, the corresponding Victor Replacing number miscellaneous applications of various types and in bold figures. Gasket and oil seal numbers are constructions designed to function effectively un also imprinted upon the product. der all operating conditions. . CATALOGING VICTOPRENE OIL SEALS Clear, concise, and comprehensive cataloging Victor pioneered the development and manu is essential to the marketing of any quality prod facture of oil seals using a compounded elastomer uct. The Victor Company is justly proud of the sealing element which is now the preferred type for" wide acceptance and use of their printed matter the most severe as well as standard applications of which this Guide is an example. Equally well and is rapidly replacing other types for general prepared are catalogs covering industrial oil seals use. Only engine applications of oil seals are listed and industrial gaskets. in this catalog. For a complete listing, including wheel applications, see the latest Victor Oil Seal FOREIGN CAR GASKETS Guide. . With increased demand for imported cars in the SPECIAL PACKING MATERIALS United States and its .ultimate need for replace ment parts, Victor has made available the entire Among Victor sealing products are especially line of Payen Foreign Car Gaskets. A special list compounded packing materials used in fabricating contains the gaskets for replacement on the most gaskets and oii seals. These, for the most part, are popular foreign car makes and models. Page 6 VMG-25-0000157 TOR ...in accuracy .. in completeness ... in convenient arrangement ... in the trade's esteem Again the Victor Gasket Guide provides the trade with the most accurate, complete, up-todate and best arranged information on gaskets. Since the last issue of the Guide, a.staff of ex perienced people have been accumulating and compiling data on the thousands of gaskets required for the servicing of passenger cars, trucks, tractors, airplanes, marine engines and industrial engines now in service. In this issue there are 4,300 new items and 369 new gasket illustrations, a large part of which have not appeared in any other gasket catalog. Since the Victor Gasket Guide is usually first to supply full information on the gaskets and oil seals for new models, the information must be compiled from original sources. Hundreds of parts books, speci fication tables and other sources of information are checked and rechecked to bring under one cover comprehensive data on Victor Products. Shortly af ter its beginning in 1909, the Victor Company began supplying gasket data to the trade. Prior to the issues listed below the Victor Company published a num ber of Catalogs and Charts which were the principal sources of information on gaskets for the early models. VICTOR MANUFACTURING & GASKET COMPANY 5750 W. ROOSEVELT ROAD CHICAGO SO, ILLINOIS, U.S.A. DETROIT OFFICE: 17SI5 West Eighth Milo Road, Detroit, Michigan NEW YORK OFFICE: 808-809 Fisk Bldg., 250 W. S7th Street, New YorklB, N.Y. in Canada: Victor Manufacturing & Gasket Company of Canada, St Thomas, Ontario - COPYRIGHT IP59 i Page 8 Victor Gasket Guide (1923) Victor Gasket Guide No. 2 Victor Gasket Guide No. 3 Victor Gasket Guide No. 4 Victor Gasket Guide No. 5 Victor Gasket Guide No. 6 Victor Gasket Guide No. 7 Victor Gasket Guide No. 8 Victor Gasket Guide No. 9 Victor Gasket Guide No. 10 Victor Gasket Guide No. 11 Victor Gasket Guide No. 12 Victor Gasket Guide No. 13 Victor Gasket Guide No. 14 Victor Gasket Guide No. 15 Victor Gasket Guide No. 16 Victor Gasket Guide No. 17 Issued November 1922 Issued November 1924 Issued March 1932 Issued March 1927 Issued April 1928 Issued March 1929 Issued March 1930 Issued March 1931 Issued March 1932 Issued April 1934 Issued April 1S36 Issued May 1938 Issued April 1940 Issued January 1945 Issued January 1951 Issued May 1955 Issued November 1959 25.000 copies 28.000 copies 40.000 copies 35.000 copies 38.000 copies 40.000 copies 45.000 copies 40.000 copies 40.000 copies 43.000 copies 54.000 copies 50.000 copies 50.000 copies 60.000 copies 65.000 copies 75.000 copies 80.000 copies VMG-25-0000159 EXHIBIT EXHIBIT