Document 0JypMddKoKG0znZRRJkGG9VRb
DATE: SUBJECT: FROM: THRU:
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY REGION 5
77 WEST JACKSON BOULEVARD CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 60604
May 19, 2025
CLEAN WATER ACT INSPECTION REPORT Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park, Warsaw, Indiana
Jonathan Moody, Environmental Engineer WECAB, Multimedia Section
Brooke Furio, Section Chief WECAB, Multimedia Section
BASIC INFORMATION
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Type: Privately owned sewerage treatment system NPDES Permit Number: IN0025208 Date(s) of Inspection: April 2, 2025
EPA Inspector(s): 1. Jonathan Moody 2. Megan Zale 3. Jennifer Bush
Attendees: Name
Jonathan Moody Megan Zale Jennifer Bush
Harley Asher
Ed Nix
Justin Stouder (not present for the field portion)
Title
Organization
Lead Inspector U.S. EPA
Inspector Inspector
U.S. EPA U.S. EPA
Operator in Charge Daily Operator
Former Operator
Services by Stouder Services by Stouder Services by Stouder
Email
moody.jonathan@epa.gov
zale.megan@epa.gov Bush.jennifer@epa.gov
Livefree.asher@gmail.com
-
servicesbystouder@live.com
Phone
440-250-1708
440-250-1711 312-886-0879
260-388-7770
260-402-3751
-
Contact Email Address: infrastructure@rentstackhouse.com Kellen Buss, kbuss@rentstackhouse.com
Owner Contact Kellen Buss 2310 S. Miami Boulevard Suite 238 Durham, NC 27703 kbuss@rentstackhouse.com
Operator Contact Harley Asher 260-388-7770 Livefree.asher@gmail.com
Physical Facility Address Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park 3699 N 175 E Warsaw, IN 46582
Inspection Type: Compliance Evaluation Inspection without sampling, with field monitoring.
Facility Notification:
Unannounced Inspection Announced Inspection
Arrival Date and Time: 4/2/2025, 8:00 AM Departure Date and Time: 4/2/2025, 11:30 AM Closing Conference Phone Call: 4/14/2025 1:00 PM
Page 2 of 9
OPENING CONFERENCE
Presented Credentials Stated authority and purpose of inspection Provided Small Business Resource Information Sheet Small Business Resource Information Sheet not provided. Reason: uncertain if the
current version of the factsheet complies with recent Executive Orders. Provided CBI notification to facility
The following information was obtained verbally from Harley Asher and Ed Nix unless otherwise noted.
Background: The Suburban Acres property is a Manufactured Home Community (MHC) operated by Jones Estates, LLC. Per the Indiana Department of Environmental Management (IDEM) Drinking Water Viewer, the property has an estimated population of 190 persons. Since January 2020 the facility has had exceedances for total suspended solids (TSS), total ammonia, E. coli, carbonaceous biological oxygen demand (CBOD), and total chlorine residual. A list of effluent exceedances is included in Appendix D.
Process Description: The treatment facility is an extended aeration system with a fixed screen, two aeration basins in parallel, a polishing pond and a free chlorine/dechlorination disinfection system. This report does not contain Confidential Business Information (CBI).
Staff Interview(s): Harley Asher is the certified operator in charge of the facility, while Ed Nix is responsible for maintenance and performs onsite operations and monitoring when Harley is not present.
According to Harley Asher and Ed Nix, daily operations, sampling, and recording are conducted by Ed Nix, who is onsite daily. Ed also collects compliance samples. Harley Asher completes the Discharge Monitoring Reports (DMRs). Harley Asher began as the operator in charge at the site towards the end of 2023. Before Harley Asher, Justin Stouder served as the operator in charge from July or August 2023 until the transition.
Ed Nix said he records the electrical runtime gage for the lift station south of N 175 E, and the total flow volume from the flow meter. The volume recorded by Ed Nix is the daily totalizer volume from the Siemens LUT 430 readout. This value is reset each day.
Justin Stouder, owner of Services by Stouder, was not present for the field portion of the inspection, but did participated in the closing conference phone call and provided additional information about the June through November 2023 period when the DMRs reported no
Page 3 of 9
discharge. He explained that the discharge pump from the polishing pond had been turned off due to the high ammonia levels, and efforts were being made to bring the water into compliance. There was an approximate two-week period during which the effluent pumps were replaced. Justin confirmed that there was no discharge from the effluent pumps during the June through November 2023 time period. This included no discharges in September 2023 despite the reported values on the September 2023 DMR, which Justin Stouder said were a discrepancy.
The EPA asked whether any alternative means of wastewater disposal had been used from June to November 2023, or if there were any overflows from the polishing pond. Justin Stouder stated that no alternative disposal methods were used, and there was no indication of wastewater loss from the polishing pond. He also mentioned that he was unaware of any infiltration or integrity tests performed on the polishing pond.
FACILITY WALK-THROUGH OCCURRED:
Yes Data Collected and Observations: There are two lift stations for the sewer collections system. One lift station is located south of N 175 E. A daily log of the electrical runtime gauge is kept at the list station south of N 175 E. The second is located at the headworks for the sewer treatment plant. A record of the runtime gauge is not kept for the lift station located at the headworks of the sewer treatment plant.
The plant has two aeration basins, east and west. At the time of the inspection the east basin had brown foam on the surface (Photos 5, 25, and 26). The clarifier on the east basin had scum accumulating on the surface (photos 6, 7, and 8).
The west aeration basin clarifer had flocs flowing up toward the surface and over the weir (Photos 10, 11, 13, 14 and videos 12, 15, and 16). The splitter box at the headworks was prioritizing flows to the east aeration basin, and away from the west basin (Photo 40).
The outlets from the aeration basins join upstream of the flow measuring weir shown in photos 17 through 21). At the time of the inspection, the water at the outlet from flow measurement device was discolored and cloudy as shown in Photo 29. The turbidity of the water was approximately 446 NTU. The ultrasonic device, used for flow measurements, was located above a side chamber adjacent to the chamber with the weir. There was floating material in the side chamber (photo 27).
At the time of the inspection, the readout from the flow meter was showing 11.2 gal/min.
Water from the flow measurement device went into a polishing pond. The south end of the polishing pond was filled with a black solid material as shown in Photos 30 and 31. There was
Page 4 of 9
algae near the north end of the pond as shown in Photo 36. An electrical pole and tree stumps were located on the inside of the embankment forming the pond (Photos 36 and 37).
Water from the polishing pond overflows by gravity through a chlorinator using free chlorine tablets. The water continues into a lift station which pumps the final discharge to the receiving stream, Tippecanoe River. A bisulfite based liquid dechlorination chemical is added to the lift station with the final discharge pump. Compliance samples are collected from a yard tap located downstream of the effluent A record of the electrical runtime gage is not maintained.
Photos and/or Videos: were taken during the inspection. A log of the photos is included in Appendix B.
Field Measurements: were taken during this inspection. Field measurements are documented in Appendix C.
RECORDS REVIEW
List of Records Reviewed Onsite:
DSCN2385.JPG - November 2024 Daily Log Sheet DSCN2386.JPG - Daily total flows March 2025 DSCN2387.JPG - DSCN2393.JPG - November 7, 2024 Through March 31, 2025 log book entries DSCN2394.JPG - DSCN2401.JPG - August 2023 to January 2024 log book for daily totals DSCN2402.JPG - Inspection Sign In Sheet DSCN2403.JPG - Certificate of Calibration for flow meter, June 1, 2023 (2024 certificate kept with readout for the flow meter) DSCN2404.JPG - DSCN2445.JPG - DMRs, Daily Log Sheets and Lab Reports for June 2023 through November 2023.
A review of the Chain of Custody for the July and August 2024 showed that the facility has begun using ice with samples sent to the contract lab.
Requested documents: Copies of Monthly Operating Reports (MORs), lab reports with results and operator notes for the period January 2023 through December 2024. Additional measurements, photos or laboratory reports for additional monitoring conducted on the polishing pond during the June to November 2023 period when the facility was not discharging. Reports and/or photos of the condition of the pond after the most recent dredging. Date of the most recent dredge of the polishing pond.
Documents Received From Facility:
Page 5 of 9
Copies of Monthly Operating Reports (MORs), lab reports with results and operator notes for the period January 2023 through December 2024.
In the document "Suburban Acres June 2023.pdf" provided in an email from Harley Asher on April 23, 2025 to Jonathan Moody, there is a printout from the Siemens LUT400 flow monitoring data logger. The Totalizer value (RT or Running Total) for June 1, 2023 is 62,257,800 gallons. In the document "Suburban Acres December 2023 Scan 1.pdf", also provided in an email from Harley Asher on April 23, 2025, there are photos of daily logsheets with the totalizer volume for December 25, 2023 as 65,233,200 gallons. This is a total volume of 2,975,400 gallons (or 9.1 acre-feet) over 206 days, which is approximately 14,400 gallons per day. The approximate area of the polishing pond is 11,400 sf, which is less than 0.3 acres. See the map included in Appendix A. CLOSING CONFERENCE Provided U.S. EPA point of contact to the facility. Explained Inspection Report Process Confirm CBI status at end of closing conference. No CBI claimed. Discussed Preliminary Area(s) of Concern
Areas of Concern: 1. NPDES Permit No. IN0025208 Part I A.1 Table 1 and Table 2: Effluent Limitations Between January 1, 2020 and March 31, 2025 the facility has had 69 effluent exceedances. A chart of the effluent exceedances is included in Appendix D. The chart below provides a summary of the number and type of exceedances per year.
Page 6 of 9
2. NPDES Permit No. IN0025208 Part II Standard Conditions for NPDES Permits, B. Management Requirements, 1. Facility Operations, Maintenance, and Quality Control a. In accordance with 327 IAC 5-2-8(9), the permittee shall at all times maintain in good working order and efficient operate all facilities and systems (and related appurtenances, i.e., equipment used for measuring and determining compliance) for collection and treatment that are: (1) installed or used by the permittee; and (2) necessary for achieving compliance with the terms and conditions of the permit. At the time of the inspection the system had the following conditions: a. The west aeration basin had brown foam on the surface (photos 5, 25 and 26), b. There was scum on the surface of the west aeration basin clarifier (photos 6, 7, and 8) c. The east aeration basin clarifier had flocs moving up toward the surface indicative of high flows or disruptions in the clarifier flow (Photo 14 and videos 15 and 16), d. The flocs in the east aeration basin were visible flowing over effluent weir (photos 10, 11, 14 and video 12), e. Excessive black solids material was present in the southern end of the polishing pond (photos 30 and 31), f. Excessive algae growth was present at the north end of the polishing pond (photo 36), g. An electrical pole and tree stumps were present on the inside edge of the berm surrounding the pond (photos 36 and 37).
Page 7 of 9
3. NPDES Permit No. IN0025208 Part II Standard Conditions for NPDES Permits, B. Management Requirements, 1. Facility Operations, Maintenance, and Quality Control d. Maintenance of all waste collection, control, treatment, and disposal facilities shall be conducted in a manner that complies with the bypass provisions set forth below. And Part II, B. 2. Bypass of Treatment Facilities, Pursuant to 327 IAC 5-2-8(12): a. Terms as defined in 327 IAC 5-2-8(12)(A): (1) "Bypass" means the intentional diversion of a waste stream from any portion of the treatment facility.
The DMRs for June 2023 through December 2023 report no discharge. Justin Stouder confirmed that the flow measurement on the September 2023 DMR was a discrepancy, and that there were no discharges from outfall 001 in September 2023. The flow monitoring device, located on the outlet from the mechanical plant, but upstream of the polishing pond recorded a total volume of 2,975,400 gallons (or 9.1 acre-feet) during the June 1, 2023 through December 25, 2023 period. Justin Stouder confirmed during the closing conference that no water was discharged from Outfall 001, nor were there known transfers or overflows from the polishing pond during this time period.
The approximate area of the polishing pond is 11,400 sf, which is less than 0.3 acres. See the map included in Appendix A. The volume of wastewater generated between June and December 2023 would result more than 20 feet of elevation change in the polishing pond. At the time of the inspection the polishing pond did not have sufficient free board to stored more than 9 acre-feet of wastewater. Since the disinfection system is located directly upstream and inside the effluent pump station, any wastewater leaving the polishing pond through means other than the effluent pump would not have received full treatment.
DIGITAL SIGNATURES
Report Author: Jonathan Moody, PE, Environmental Engineer
JONATHAN JONATHAN MOODY Digitally signed by
MOODY
Date: 2025.05.19 16:01:01 -04'00'
Report Author Signature:_________________________________
Section Supervisor: Brooke Furio, Multimedia Section Chief
BROOKE
Digitally signed by BROOKE FURIO
Section Supervisor Signature:_F_U__R_I_O________16_:1_1:_12_-0_4_'00_' ____________ Date: 2025.05.19
Page 8 of 9
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025 APPENDICES
A) Aerial Photo and estimate of the Polishing Pond Surface Area B) Digital Image Log C) Field Measurement Data D) Table of Effluent Exceedances
Page 9 of 9
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025 APPENDIX A: AERIAL AND ESTIMATE OF POLISHING POND AREA
Disinfection and final discharge effluent pump
Polishing Pond
Flow Measurement East Aeration
West Aeration Digester Screen and Splitter Lift Station at Headworks
Appendices Page 1 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Appendices Page 2 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
APPENDIX B: DIGITAL IMAGE LOG
Photolog for Suburban Acres Mobie Home Park Warsaw, Indiana Camera: Nikon Coolpix W300, S/N: 31034420
Photos DSCN2385.jpg through DSCN2445.JPG are photos of daily records and laboratory reports for the period June 2024 through November 2024
1: DSCN2446.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:07 AM Camera Direction: South Description: Control panel for the lift station located south of N 175 E.
2: DSCN2447.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:13 AM Camera Direction: East Description: Control station for the lift station at the headworks of the sewage treatment system. had an alarm and two pumps which were both set to `Auto'.
The station
3: DSCN2448.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:15 AM Camera Direction: Northeast Description: Bar screen and flow splitter at the sewage treatment system. the scrapings from the screen are disposed of in a garbage can.
The screen is manually cleaned and
Appendices Page 3 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
4: DSCN2449.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:17 AM Camera Direction: North Description: West aeration basin at the sewage treatment plant.
5: DSCN2450.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:17 AM Camera Direction: North Description: East aeration basin at the sewage treatment plant. basin.
Brown foam was on the surface of the aeration
Appendices Page 4 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
6: DSCN2451.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:18 AM Camera Direction: Northwest Description: The east aeration basin, at the time of the inspection there was solid material floating on the surface of the clarifier.
Appendices Page 5 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
7: DSCN2452.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:18 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: The east aeration basin, at the time of the inspection there was solid material, scum, floating on the surface of the clarifier.
Appendices Page 6 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
8: DSCN2453.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:18 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: The east aeration basin, at the time of the inspection there was solid material floating on the surface of the clarifier.
9: DSCN2454.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:19 AM Camera Direction: West Description: At the west aeration basin looking at the west clarifier.
Appendices Page 7 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
10: DSCN2455.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:19 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the west clarifier, at the time of the inspection, flocs were visible near the surface, and were observed flowing over the weir and out the clarifier. The circle shows a location where the flocs were visible flowing over the weir.
Appendices Page 8 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
11: DSCN2456.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:19 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the west clarifier, at the time of the inspection, flocs were visible near the surface, and were observed flowing over the weir and out the clarifier. The circle shows a location where the flocs were visible flowing over the weir.
12: DSCN2457.MP4
Appendices Page 9 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:22 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: 11 second video of the flocs passing over the weir.
13: DSCN2458.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:20 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the west clarifier, at the time of the inspection, flocs were visible near the surface and were observed flowing over the weir and out the clarifier. The circle shows a location where the flocs were visible flowing over the weir.
Appendices Page 10 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
14: DSCN2459.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:21 AM Camera Direction: Down, South Description: At the west clarifier, flocs were observed rising and swirling near the surface.
Appendices Page 11 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
15: DSCN2460.MP4 Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:21 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: 9 second video of the west clarifier showing the flocs rising and swirling near the surface.
16: DSCN2461.MP4 Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:24 AM Camera Direction: Description: 20 second video of the west clarifier showing the flocs rising and swirling near the surface.
Appendices Page 12 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
17: DSCN2462.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:24 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, a v-notch weir, there was a transducer mounted in a concrete block.
18: DSCN2463.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:24 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, a v-notch weir, there was a transducer mounted in a concrete block.
19: DSCN2464.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:25 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, a v-notch weir, there was a transducer mounted in a concrete block.
20: DSCN2465.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:25 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, during the inspection, the operator relocated the device from a side chamber to directly over the weir and then back to the side chamber. The operator said there were holes under the water line between the side chamber and the chamber with the weir.
21: DSCN2466.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:25 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, during the inspection, the operator relocated the device from a side chamber to directly over the weir and then back to the side chamber. The operator said there were holes under the water line between the side chamber and the chamber with the weir.
Appendices Page 13 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
22: DSCN2467.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:26 AM Camera Direction: Inside Description: Readout on the flow measurement device, at the time of the photo, the device was showing 11.2 gal/min, 3.6 in head and a daily totalizer flow of 75.
23: DSCN2468.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:27 AM Camera Direction: Inside Description: Readout on the flow measurement device, this was the totalizer screen. the device showed: Flow: 78.499695 / 3.764883 Avg: 12.542150 DT: 18060.2 RT: 7.24237e+07 Temp: 13.200408 / -0.213137
At the time of the photo,
Appendices Page 14 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
24: DSCN2469.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:28 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Annual calibration report for the flow measurement device. calibration was May 16, 2024.
Date of the
25: DSCN2470.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:36 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Brown foam at the east aeration basin, this was also the location of MP03.
Appendices Page 15 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
26: DSCN2471.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:38 AM Camera Direction: South Description: East aeration basin, foam on the surface near the north end.
Appendices Page 16 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
27: DSCN2472.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:42 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: At the flow measurement device, looking inside the side chamber where the transducer is located. There was a piece of floating debris in the chamber that may interfere with the depth measurement.
28: DSCN2473.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:42 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Location of MP05 at the flow measurement device, immediately upstream of the pond.
Appendices Page 17 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
29: DSCN2474.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:42 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Treated wastewater from the weir. turbidity at this location was 446 NTU.
The water was discolored.
This was the location of MP05, the
Appendices Page 18 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
30: DSCN2475.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:43 AM Camera Direction: Northwest Description: Polishing pond at the location where the treated wastewater from treatment plant. excessive quantity of solid black material accumuated at this side of the pond.
There was an
31: DSCN2476.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:43 AM Camera Direction: Description: Polishing pond at the location where the treated wastewater from treatment plant. excessive quantity of solid black material accumuated at this side of the pond.
There was an
Appendices Page 19 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
32: DSCN2477.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:44 AM Camera Direction: Down, South Description: At the final effluent pumps to the discharge, at the location where dechlorination chemical is added, and the pump to the final outlet at the receiving stream.
33: DSCN2478.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:48 AM Camera Direction: Down, South Description: At the final effluent pumps to the discharge, at the location where dechlorination chemical is added, and the pump to the final outlet at the receiving stream.
34: DSCN2479.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:48 AM Camera Direction: East Description: Sample tap with green handle is the location of the final compliance monitoring sample.
35: DSCN2480.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:48 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Location of chlorine dosing.
Appendices Page 20 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
36: DSCN2481.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:50 AM Camera Direction: East Description: North end of the polishing pond. the berm, and algae at this location.
There were stumps remaining from trees on the interior side of
Appendices Page 21 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
37: DSCN2482.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:52 AM Camera Direction: North Description: Along the west side of the polishing pond. berm.
There was an electrical pole on the interior side of the
Appendices Page 22 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
38: DSCN2483.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:53 AM Camera Direction: West Description: Piping for the aeration near the headworks for the wastewater treatment plant.
39: DSCN2484.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:54 AM Camera Direction: East Description: Digester and the upstream end of the east aeration tank.
Appendices Page 23 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
40: DSCN2485.JPG Location: Suburban Acres MHP Photographer: Jonathan Moody Date/Time: 4/2/2025 10:59 AM Camera Direction: Down Description: Splitter box at the headworks of the plant at the location immediately downstream from the screen. At the time of the inspection, the divider was prioritizing flow to the east aeration tank.
Appendices Page 24 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025 APPENDIX C: FIELD MEASUREMENT DATA
Dates and times used in this appendix are in the timezone local to the inspection site. Jonathan Moody conducted field monitoring using an In-Situ AquaTROLL 600 (AT600) S/N 1079129. The AT600 was equipped with a temperature/conductivity sensor, pH/ORP sensor, Rugged Dissolved Oxygen (RDO) sensor and a turbidity sensor. Table 1 summarizes the methods used by the AT600 sensors. Table 2 below shows the summary of the monitoring. The AT600 was calibrated on March 27, 2025 at 2:00 PM using a 3-point pH calibration with pH 4, 7, and 10 buffers, and an ORP/conductivity calibration with a 230mV/8,000 uS/cm QuickCal solution. This calibration was performed in the Westlake, Ohio office. The RDO sensor was calibrated using the 100% saturation method on April 2, 2025 The RDO sensor calibration was performed on-site just before starting the field monitoring. The turbidity and temperature sensors both have a factory calibration. Calibration information is documented in the field notebook for this compliance inspection and in the Calibration Report generated by the VuSitu App and appended to the end of this appendix. A sensor verification was conducted on the pH sensor on April 3, 2025 at 11:30 AM. The summary of the verifications are included in Tables 3 and 4. The pH sensor drift was within 0.1 pH SU. Table 4 summarizes the sensor verification results.
Appendices Page 25 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Table 1 - AT600 Sensors and Methods
Parameter Sensor
Units
pH
pH/ORP
SU
ORP Specific Conductance
Temperature
pH/ORP Conductivity/ Temperature Conductivity/ Temperature
mV uS/cm Celsius
Dissolved Oxygen Turbidity
RDO Turbidity
mg/L NTU-eq
Method SM 4500-H+/EPA 150.2
SM 2580
SM 2510/EPA 120.1 +/- 1,400 mV
EPA 170.1 EPA-approved In-Situ Methods: 1002-8-2009, 1003-8-2009, 10048-2009 Compliant with ASTM D888-18 Method C and ISO 17289 methods ISO 7027
Appendices Page 26 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Table 2 - Monitoring Summary
Date/Time Ref. #
Location
4/2/2025 10:34
4/2/2025 10:36
4/2/2025 10:38
4/2/2025 10:40
4/2/2025 10:42
4/2/2025 10:47
MP-001 MP-002 MP-003 MP-004 MP-005 MP-006
At the upstream end of the west aeration tank At the downstream end of the west aeration tank At the upstream end of the east aeration tank At the downstream end of the east aeration tank At the flow measurement device, upstream of the polishing pond. Photo 29. At the final effluent pump. Photo 33.
Sp. Cond pH DO (ug/cm) (SU) (mg/l)
1991.5 7.74 5.98 1901.1 7.71 6.44 1715.6 7.47 5.12 1810.2 7.45 5.19
1967.5 7.60 4.16
1877.8 7.44 9.09
Turbidity (NTU)
489.0 623.2 1115.2 928.7
445.6
84.8
Appendices Page 27 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Table 3: Duplicate Check Date/Time Ref. #
4/3/2025 11:30 N/A 4/3/2025 11:12 N/A
Difference
DO Sat. 101.92 % 100.00
DO (mg/L) 9.02 8.85 0.17
Table 4: pH Sensor Verification Check
Post-
Pre-
Date/Time Inspection
Verification Buffer
Inspection
Difference2
pH
pH1
4/3/2024 11:30 4.08 pH 4.00 buffer verification 4.00 0.08 check
7.09 pH 7.00 buffer verification 7.02 0.07 check
10.08 pH 10.00 buffer verification 10.05 0.03 check
1. Pre-inspection pH is the post calibration pH from the pre-inspection calibration report.
2. Difference between pre-inspection and post-inspection values
Appendices Page 28 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582 Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025 APPENDIX D: TABLE OF EFFLUENT EXCEEDANCES Monitoring Period Date Range: 01/01/2020 to 03/31/2025 Obtained from ECHO on March 6, 2025 IN0025208: SUBURBAN ACRES MOBILE HOME PARK, WARSAW, IN 46582
Appendices Page 29 of 29
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582
Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Monitoring
Period
Date
Outfall Parameter Description
BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day,
4/30/2020 001-A 20 C
E. coli, colony forming units
6/30/2020 001-A (CFU)
BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day,
6/30/2020 001-A 20 C
BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day,
6/30/2020 001-A 20 C
BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day,
6/30/2020 001-A 20 C
BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day,
6/30/2020 001-A 20 C
BOD, carb-5 day, 20 deg C,
6/30/2020 001-A percent removal
Nitrogen, ammonia total (as
7/31/2020 001-A N)
Nitrogen, ammonia total (as
7/31/2020 001-A N)
5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A 5/31/2021 001-A
Solids, total suspended Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carb-5 day, 20 deg C, percent removal
Statistical Base Type MX WK AV
DAILY MX MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV
MO AVG MO AV MN MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV MO AV MN
DMR Value
66 291 10.30126 67.5 144 4.24036 77.6 18.2 12.7
66 14 36 11.804 54 190 81.2
DMR Value Unit mg/L CFU/100mL kg/d mg/L mg/L kg/d % mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L kg/d mg/L mg/L %
Limit Value
40 235 5.7658
25 40 3.5866 85 18 12 45 12 18 5.7658 25 40 85
% Exceedance
65 24 79 170 260 18 49
1 6 47 17 100 105 116 375 25
Days with Exceedances
7 1
30
30
31 7
31
31
31
Appendices Page 1 of 5
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582
Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Monitoring
Period
Date
Outfall Parameter Description
6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A 6/30/2021 001-A
Solids, total suspended
Solids, total suspended Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carb-5 day, 20 deg C, percent removal Solids, suspended percent removal
7/31/2021 001-A 7/31/2021 001-A 9/30/2021 001-A 9/30/2021 001-A 10/31/2021 001-A 4/30/2022 001-A 6/30/2022 001-A 6/30/2022 001-A 7/31/2022 001-A
Solids, total suspended E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU)
Chlorine, total residual E. coli, colony forming units (CFU)
Solids, total suspended
Statistical Base Type MX WK AV MO AVG
MO AVG MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV MO AV MN MO AV MN MX WK AV
DAILY MX
MO GEO
DAILY MX
DAILY MX
DAILY MX DAILY MX
DAILY MX MO AVG
DMR Value
202 58
24.7 34.6 55.75 208 82.8 73.8
48 345 178 1550 1990 1050 0.22 649 31.5
DMR Value Unit mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L % % mg/L CFU/100mL CFU/100mL CFU/100mL CFU/100mL CFU/100mL mg/L CFU/100mL mg/L
Limit Value
45 30 12 18 25 40 85 85 45 235 125 235 235 235 0.06 235 30
% Exceedance
349 93
106 92
123 420
15 75
7 47 42 560 747 347 267 176
5
Days with Exceedances
30 30
30
30 30
7 1 30
1 1 1 1 31
Appendices Page 2 of 5
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582
Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Monitoring
Period
Date
Outfall Parameter Description
7/31/2022 001-A 7/31/2022 001-A 7/31/2022 001-A 9/30/2022 001-A
Solids, total suspended E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) Solids, suspended percent removal E. coli, colony forming units (CFU)
10/31/2022 001-A 10/31/2022 001-A
4/30/2023 001-A 5/31/2023 001-A 12/31/2023 001-A 12/31/2023 001-A 1/31/2024 001-A 1/31/2024 001-A
Solids, total suspended E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N)
4/30/2024 4/30/2024 4/30/2024
001-A 001-A 001-A
4/30/2024 001-A
4/30/2024 001-A
Solids, total suspended
Solids, total suspended
Chlorine, total residual BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C Solids, suspended percent removal
Statistical Base Type MX WK AV
DAILY MX MO AV MN
DAILY MX MX WK AV
DAILY MX
DAILY MX
DAILY MX
MO AVG MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV MX WK AV MO AVG DAILY MX MX WK AV MO AV MN
DMR Value
90 770 81.9 2420
54 687 2420 2420 24.9 25.7 16.9 28.5 130
50 0.15
87 79.7
DMR Value Unit mg/L CFU/100mL % CFU/100mL mg/L CFU/100mL CFU/100mL CFU/100mL mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L %
Appendices Page 3 of 5
Limit Value
45 235
85 235
45 235 235 235
12 18 12 18 45 30 0.06 40 85
% Exceedance
100 228
21 930
20 192 930 930 108
43 41 58 189 67 150 118 35
Days with Exceedances
1 31
1 7 1 1 1 31
31
30 1 7
30
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582
Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Monitoring
Period
Date
Outfall Parameter Description
5/31/2024 001-A Solids, total suspended
5/31/2024 001-A 5/31/2024 001-A 5/31/2024 001-A 5/31/2024 001-A 6/30/2024 001-A 7/31/2024 001-A 7/31/2024 001-A 7/31/2024 001-A 8/31/2024 001-A 8/31/2024 001-A 8/31/2024 001-A 8/31/2024 001-A 9/30/2024 001-A 10/31/2024 001-A 12/31/2024 001-A
Solids, total suspended Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) E. coli, colony forming units (CFU) BOD, carbonaceous, 05 day, 20 C Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N) Nitrogen, ammonia total (as N)
Solids, total suspended
12/31/2024 001-A Solids, total suspended
Statistical Base Type MO AVG MX WK AV MX WK AV MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV
MO AVG MX WK AV
DAILY MX
MO AVG MX WK AV
DAILY MX MX WK AV MX WK AV MX WK AV MO AVG MX WK AV
DMR Value
41.6 73
19.6 91
28.8 22.8 37.75 41.8 1550 29.68 44.6 1050
43 19 23.8 56 14.3918
DMR Value Unit mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L CFU/100mL mg/L mg/L CFU/100mL mg/L mg/L mg/L mg/L kg/d
Appendices Page 4 of 5
Limit Value
30 45 18 40 25 18 12 18 235 12 18 235 40 18 18 30 6.4922
% Exceedance
39 62
9 128
15 27 215 132 560 147 148 347
8 6 32 87 122
Days with Exceedances
31
7
31 7
31
1 31
1 7 7 7 31
Facility Name: Suburban Acres Mobile Home Park
Facility Location: 3699 N 175 E, Warsaw, IN 46582
Date of Inspection: April 2, 2025
Monitoring
Period
Date
Outfall Parameter Description
12/31/2024 001-A 12/31/2024 001-A
Solids, total suspended Solids, suspended percent removal
Statistical Base Type MX WK AV MO AV MN
DMR Value
190
64.2
DMR Value Unit
mg/L
%
Limit Value
45
85
% Exceedance
322
139
Days with Exceedances
31
Appendices Page 5 of 5