February 27, 2025
Document 127 - Attachment 3
Pending court proceedings related to Energy Policy and Conservation Act ("EPCA") preemption and restriction of natural gas/propane appliances and service:
Mulhern Gas Co., Inc. et al. v. Robert J. Rodriguez et al., No. 1:23-cv-1267
(N.D.N.Y.)
Rivera v. Anderson, No. 2:24-cv-00677-KKE (W.D. Wa.)
Colo. Apartment Ass'n, et al. v. Ryan, No. 1:24-cv-01093 (D. Colo.)
Restaurant Law Center, et al. v. City and County ofDenver, No. l :24-cv-0 1862 (D.
Colo.)
Nat'/ Ass'n ofHome Builders v. District ofColumbia, No. 1:24-cv-02942-ACR
(D.D.C.)
Nat'! Ass'n ofHome Builders v. Montgomery County, No. 8:24-cv-03024-PX (D. Md.)
Ass'n ofContracting Plumbers ofthe City ofNew York. et al., v City ofNew York, No
1:23-cv-11292 (S.D. NY)
Rinnai America Corp. v. South Coast Air Quality Management District, No. 2:24-cv-
10482 (C.D. Cal.)
Concluded court proceedings related to EPCA pre-emption:
California Restaurant Ass'n v. City ofBerkeley, 89 F.4th 1094, 1107 (9th Cir. 2024).
Sierra Club v. Dept of Energy, 4:25-cv-5027
SC_EVERSPLIT0020176
February 27, 2025 Jurisdictions that have enacted some form of restrictions on gas/propane
Agoura Hills, CA Alameda, CA Berkeley, CA (inval idated) Brisbane, CA Brookline, MA Burlingame, CA Campbell, CA Carlsbad, CA Contra Costa, CA (suspended) Cupertino, CA (suspended) Daly City, CA Davis, CA East Palo Alto, CA Emeryville, CA Encinitas, CA (suspended) Fairfax, CA Half Moon Bay, CA (suspended) Hayward, CA Healdsburg, CA Honolulu, HI Irvine, CA Los Altos, CA Los Gatos, CA Marin County, CA Menlo Park, CA Mill Valley, CA Millbrae, CA Milpitas, CA Morgan Hill, CA
Petaluma, CA MountaiJl View, CA Multnomah County, OR (county buildings) New Haven, CT (city-owned) Oakland, CA Ojai, CA Pacifica, CA Palo Alto, CA (suspended) Piedmont, CA Redwood City, CA Richmond, CA Sacramento, CA San Carlos, CA San Francisco, CA San Jose, CA San Mateo, CA San Mateo County, CA (suspended) Santa Barbara, CA Santa Clara, CA Santa Clara County, CA Santa Cruz, CA (suspended) San Luis Obispo, CA (suspended) Santa Monica, CA Santa Rosa, CA Saratoga, CA South San Francisco, CA Seattle, WA Sunnyvale, CA (suspended) Tacoma, WA (city owned)
2
Sierra Club v. Dept of Energy, 4:25-cv-5027
SC_EVERSPLIT0020177
February 27, 2025
Windsor, CA ltbaca,NY Denver, CO Solana Beach, CA (suspended) Shoreline, WA New York City, NY Salt Lake City, UT (municipal funding) Olympia, WA (municipal) Burlington, VT Fort Collins, CO Los Angeles, CA Pasadena, CA BeLUngbam, WA District of Columbia Belmont, CA H illsborough, CA Hercules, CA Crested Butte, CO Montgomery County, MD Dublin, CA Atherton, CA Glendale, CA Pleasanton, CA Ventura County, CA Portola VaUey, CA Livermore, CA Martinez, CA Milwaukie, OR Louisville, CO Washington, DC Riverside, CA Corte Madera, CA
San Leandro, CA King County, WA Ulster County, NY (county-owned) Boston, MA (city-owned) Eugene, OR (repea led) Beacon, NY Oak Park, IL Lafayette, CO Traverse City, Ml (rnuu.icipal) San Diego, CA (municipal) Boulder, CO No11hampton, MA Ashland, OR
3
Sierra Club v. Dept of Energy, 4:25-cv-5027
SC_EVERSPLIT0020178
February 27, 2025 Jurisdictions that have proposed some form of restrictions on gas/propane {53)
Everett, WA Thurston County, WA Spokane, WA Whatcom County, WA Calistoga, CA Albany, CA San Diego, CA Las Cruces, NM Minneapolis, MN Hennepin County, MN Salida, CO Santa Ana, CA Richmond, VA Ann Arbor, MI Miami, FL Wellesley, MA San Rafae~ CA Lincoln, MA Lawrence, KS Takoma Park, MD Boston, MA Cambridge, MA Newton, MA Somerville, MA Arlington, MA Lexington, MA Peterborough, NH Portland, ME Tampa, FL
Longmont, CO Worcester, MA Bethlehem, PA Philadelphia, PA Fairfax County, VA Howard County, MD Truckee, CA Salem, OR Prince George County, MD Acton, MA Sioux FaJls, SD San Anselmo, CA Kansas City, MO South Burlington, VT Basalt, CO Gunnison, CO Melrose, MA Aspen, CO Tucson, AZ Evanston, IL Bend, OR Corvallis, OR Ames, IA Bakersfield, CA Skokie, IL Chicago, [L
4
Sierra Club v. Dept of Energy, 4:25-cv-5027
SC_EVERSPLIT0020179