Document xjvedxmwK4a4eq23VLkRRnBKJ
FILE NAME State of the Art Literature SAL
DATE 1930 DOC SAL010
DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Journal Article - Asbestos Bodies in Sputum and Lung
ee!
ASBESTOSIS LYNCH AND SMITH
659
JAMA 95 1930
ASLEST^ SIS LODIES IN
. AND LUNG
SPUTUM
iq
ENNETH
M. LYNCH
AND
M.D.
W. ATMAR SMITH M.D.
CHARLESTON S. C.
Mestosis has of comparatively recent time assumed Gition of prominent and perhaps peculiar inter-
s the field of pneumonoconiosis and occupa1. discase While the asbestos industry is
than two thousand years old it is only
In the past few years that it has assumed
ment place which it now occupies in dustrial arts Until recently asbestosis Been assumed to be essentially silicosis and
free silica has been thought to constitute Kangerous factor in pneumonoconiosis as
inted with the relative harmlessness of
two cases are apparently the only records of autopsies
in cases of asbestosis up to that time
In a companion article McDonald recorded a histologic study of the lung tissue in Cooke's case and stated that the appearances were practically the same
as in another case the sections of which were in the
possession of Dr. I. M. D. Grieve of Armlay Leeds McDonald found in addition to well marked diffuse interstitial pneumonia chronic bronchitis and emphysema anthracosis and extensive tuberculosis certain
peculiar foreign bodies in the alveoli bronchioles and
er dusts
A has come to attention within the last three
our years that there is a peculiar character-
in the state of asbestosis not found in sili-
> and it is our purpose in this report to
dome dome data that lave come to hand since
erkan medicine thus far has no report on
jeculiar condition and to the end that
wunae interest may be stimulated in its
in the extensive asbestos industry It is
ated that a further report of our studies
made at a later time ~~ Cookerecorded Cookerecorded an autopsy on an
ker who had been exposed for
iN, the last five years intermittently sing extensive fibrosis of the lungs and
e tuberculosis At this time there was
Fig Asbestosis bodies in sputum magnification about 950 diameters
in the lungs only black particles from 3 to 393
ons in length of various shapes
interstitial fibrotic areas This is the first recorded
-observation of these objects which have since been
called asbestosis bodies There was considerable
tain Ne
Asbestosibsodies in sputum concentrate reduced from a photowith a inagnification of 705 diameters
disagreement among zoologists botanists and others as to their nature McDonald advanced the hypothesis that they are portions of asbestos in process of alteration and absorption by hydrolysis with the passing of the silica into a colloidal state and later into a gel
In 1928 Simson followed with a report of four
autopsies on asbestos mill workers in South Africa the
first being done in 1926 without discovery of the asbestosis bodies at the time One of these subjects
worked for twelve months in the mill developed tuberculosis and died ; the second worked for two years in the
same mill and had a prolonged pneumonia during this time This patient had neither tuberculosis nor pneu-
monia at autopsy but fibrosis of the lungs The length
of exposure of the third and fourth patients is not
given but both died of lobar pneumonia and both
showed very little fibrusis In the lung tissues of all of
the four were found golden yellow segmented struc-
tures with rounded ends
1927
se
r
* Cooke again recorded this case and cited
which a patient who had worked in an
for ten years showed at autopsy pulmonary
spicules of asbestos in the lungs These
=
.
MF Departments of Pathology and Internal Medicine Medical
the State of South Carolina
WE WE Fibrosis n^ Lungs Due to the Inhalation of Asbestos
31 12 147 July 2n 1924 W. Pudeionary Asbestosis Brit M. 3. 1024 Dec. 3
The descriptions and illustrations by McDonald and
Simson make it clear that they were dealing with the
same object and that it is the same as we have found
in the lungs and sputum of asbestos workers
service
of
In October 1929 there occurred in the service of
one of us K. M. an autopsy on a patient dead of
J. McDonald .: Histology of
1025 Dec. 31 1927
4. 4. Simson F. W Pulmonary
M.
J. 835 May 26 1928
Pulmonary Asbestuan
Asleitons Brit M.
in South Africa Brig
AP
CTE
ote?!
Ab ere
=
ee
We ok Lo
Ss
Sho
nerPe; Cen
HIM
De Lebn weee
De
aTGamewee par
MMT
h,
ORIEL uaa!a= Vee os
meteSan,ames Se Mpehaoeie
abDyee
ook
Wen
ee U1
Na
enisald
ons
sv
i
PRT
yi we
WEAPONS:
'.
ET
SPLIT
EeeTee
ge
ORT ware
<P sad
arens
a
ORI Towa CE me
me Sa
te
pename
kk
Cc
oS Re
da
TT
we
bi
tow
pk
1S a
eos.
y
pee
elyr ar
a
wert
~
om
Sene
;
660
;
ASBESTOSIS
AND
SMITH
Jour M. :
AGG JU 1930
a gunshot wound This was a Negro man who at the time of his death was a worker in an asbestos mill having done such work for a total of twenty months during a period of about three years At the autopsy there was nothing of significance beyond the
gunshot wounds of the chest and abdomen In micro-
scopic examination of the tissues however the peculiar
bodies under consideration here were found in the sec-
The peculiar bodies in the lungs of these two patients were first suspected of being mycelia and spores of a
occupation fungus possibly dispergillus On investigation of the
subjects and after we had learned of their
the reports of McDonald and Simson were encountered and identification with the objects observed by them
was established
It then occurred to mind that these bodies should be
numbers found in the sputum of
occurred in considerable
such
patients since they in the alveoli and
bronchi and that sputum examination might prove to be
an important measure in the diagnosis of asbestosis
*
Consequently search was made for them in sputum of
asbestos workers from the clientele of one of us
W. A. S. Specimens of sputum were examined by
direct wet smear preparation and by examining the
concentrated sediment of sputum after digesting it in
10 per cent sodium hydroxide solution kept warmed to
about 80 C. until the mucus was well digested and the
mixture watery
.
The first sputum examined came from a man who by
clinical and roentgen examination had active fibro-
caseous tuberculosis and also a moderate grade of pneumonoconiosis He had not worked in asbestos for
approximately a year but had been previously so occupied for about ten years The sputum contained
great numbers of tubercle bacilli Asbestosis bodies
Fig pigment Asbestosis bodies in lung with phagocytes and black granular pigment within alveoli in pneumonia reduced from a photomicrograph
with a magnification of 475 diameters
tions from both lungs in alveoli associated with fine black granular pigment and mononuclear cells some being intimately associated with large mononuclear phagocytes in the bronchioles where there was also the black granular material and some mononuclears in the alveolar walls which were thickened and within the connective tissues of the interlobnlar areas along the
course of vessels and bronchi Here there was a de^-nite
were readily found in direct wet slide preparations and
in large numbers in the sodium hydroxide digest con-
,
centrate
It was at this point that it came to attention that
such sputum tests had already been made In 1929
Stewart and Haddow and in 1930 Wood and Gloyne
showed that they could be found by digesting the sputum with equal parts of concentrated antiformin
and examining the centrifugated deposit Subsequently
we have found the asbestosis bodies in the sputum of
two other asbestos workers and have failed to find them
in one
, -
increase of fibrous tissue and much accumulation of
black granular pigment
At about the same time occurred another autopsy
on a Negro man who was working in an asbestos mill at the time of development of lobar pneumonia from which he died He had been in this occupation almost continuously for a period of four and half years In this case also it was in the microscopic study of the
tissues from the autopsy that the asbestosis was dis-
covered gross examination revealing only massive pneumonia of the whole right lung upper left lobe
Sections of all parts of the lungs from this case
revealed the asbestosis bodies There were great numbers of them in the alveoli the walls of the alveoli
the deeper pleural tissues the bronchi and the inter-
lobular framework tissues and they even occurred in thrombi of veins and in the peribronchial lymph nodes Associated with them was much black granular pigment in the alveoli interstitial tissues and lymph nodes and in these nodes was also a heavy deposit of yellowbrown granular substance of the same color as the
NS ONp yy Nuyay J ves a ee
in Fig Ashestosis bodies with phagocytes and in ubrous lung reduced from a photomicrograph
250 diameter
black granular pigmon
al
with a magzocat~-na
asbestosis bodies Mononuclear and polynuclear giant cell phagocytes were prominent in intimate connection
with the asbestosis bodies in the alveoli bronchi and
veins They contained much of the black granular material in the alveoli and bronchi also In the walls
of the alveoli and bronchi and in the framework struc-
tures where these bodies lay was a cellular increase in fibrous tissue
The second patient was a Negro woman who had worked in an asbestos factory from 1918 to 1924 but not since She had no evidence of pulmonary disease and was under treatment for syphilis None of the asbes1004
asbes1004
5. Stewart M. J. and Haddow A. C. Dentonstration of
Pr Asbestosis Babies in Matend Obtained br
Bories Hung and in the Sputum J. Path & Duct 32
It Asbes totem 6. Wood W.
D and Cloyne H.
X 445 March ) 1930
172 Jan 1929 Pulmonary
Pr the Pr .Laced
rs
.
pecumonoconiosis The Ladies were found in direct unconcentratedunconcentrated wer preparac- losely deposit anong uit tij iai tij iai
...
...
...
1. In the sodium hydroxide digest concentrate they There sparse and were not as long as those found in the
winry 1 interval rene
closely together or they may be separated by an interval
at which the needle central
ae se The
crystal may be seen
'
sputum was mucopurulent
Sometimes the shaft is covered by a homogeneous non-
third patient had not worked in asbestos for segimented deposit
ximately two years He was employed in an
In the lungs they are of the same forms but their
Thestos factory for seven months in 1924 and for full length may not be seen and they usually
out two years from 1926 to 1928. He had active
shorter
appear
The size of the body varies widely in length
brocaseous tuberculosis of the lungs with tubercle and thickness with the length of the filament and the
lecalli in the sputum but no condition distinguishable as amount and uniformity of the deposit No extensive
2
first sputum was mucoid in measurements have been made in this study but in the
aracter and insufficient for concentration No asbes- lungs they have been measured from 12 to 100 microns
is ladies were found in direct wet unconcentrated long and from 1 to 12 thick the shaft being narrower
preparations In this specimen were large numbers of than the ends In sputum they have been measured
$ Hast cells with fine black particles and numerous fine from 1 to 12 microns thick and up to 140 microns long
like crystals The second sputum was muco-
Asbestosis bodies do not take the ordinary tissue and
rulent A few asbestosis bodies were found in the sputum dyes and they have been found in their natural
. ditam hydroxide digest concentrate but none in the form in one of these cases in slide preparations of
inconcentrated preparations These sparse bodies were sputum stained by the ordinary carbolfuchsin method
Ivetally small but some were long and thick
for tubercle bacilli
The fourth sputum examination was done in the case
: si white man who had worked in an asbestos factory
for about fourteen years but not since 1926. He had
@ advanced fibrosis of the lungs thought to be a late stage
af pacumonoconiosis without any evidence of tuber-
z sis and was in a state of advancing cardiac failure
'g Examination of sputum on three separate occasions by bin direct and concentrated preparation failed to reveal
any asbestosis bodies
3 It was anticipated that this case on account of the ength of exposure and the extent of pulmonary disease
could have the best opportunity of exhibiting these lies but this expectation has not been realized The
tient had been exposed within about a year and
They may be stained on the slide by the prussian blue
reaction for iron the heavier and darker brown bodies
taking a deep indigo blue this shading to a lighter color in proportion to the heaviness and darkness of the
yellow substance This reaction indicates a considerable iron content to the deposit This iron has been thought to signify that the asbestosis body comes from
the iron content of asbestos Since the material is
evidently a deposit within the lung on an asbestos crystal this does not appear to be a satisfactory explana-
tion It is suggested that the iron content if not the whole substance of the deposit is of tissue origin probably from the blood
ved by far the greatest number of asbestosis
sues in the sputum but the other two patients had not
lea more recently exposed one had not worked in
for about five years and neither of these two
aslestosany distinguishable evidence of pneumonoconiosis
gaveit remains a subject for further study as to the rela-
tion the occurrence and time of duration of these
LadiesLadies in the sputum to the extent of exposure to
asicstos dust and as to the state stage of asbestosis or sither associated conditions in relation to their expul-
-on the sputum
Clinical Notes Suggestions and
New Instruments
THE
EXECUTION OF ROBERT HYDROCYANIC ACID
H. WHITE BY
GAS
EDWARD E. Hamer M.D. CARSON CITY Nev
State Health Officer
Robert H. White was executed by hydrocyanic acid gas at
The asbestosis bodies are quite variable in size vlor and form but generally are of a characteristic
the Nevada State Prison June 2 1930. A study of the heart and respiratory action was made at the time of the execution
Aructure In the sputum from which they may be 4% Petter studied alone they have a central filament of a
parent slightly greenish tinged needle crystal This taken to be an asbestos crystal On this filament
se deposited in varying quantity nodules blobs and
7 egments of a homogeneous refractive substance vary4 from shining light yellow or greenish to a
a Bowles stethoscope being applied on the bare chest wall over
the apex of the heart The tube leading to the ear pieces on
the outside of the prison wall was connected to the stethoscope while the prisoner was being strapped to the chair
This was at 4:36 m The heart action at that time was
10 strong and regular The gas was started generating at ;
4:37
A small
At 4:38 the pulse rate was 120 regular and strong inspiration was taken at 4 3734 at which time the
Pte The mahogony brown depending on the thickness of
Amities deposit
Amities
In general this deposit occurs more on the
Amities usually in a spherical blob here tapering
ward ward the middle of the filament which may be hare
Ne ng the appearance of two clubs or baseball bats
prisoner indicated that he smelled the gas At 4:38 he took a very deep inspiration turning his head toward the gas He gave a spasmodic cough his head fell forward and he became unconscious Following this first deep inspiration there was a complete stopping of the heart action for fifteen seconds
wed hm
small end to small end Again there may be a
Ae
the deposit on the extremities and the shaft have
sere cilindric cilindric cilindric deposit of segments or disks of uniform
.regular size giving the whole body the appearance
hell The clubbed form may break in the
ye and leaving two indian forms Again the
me
metrical ...
Way
metrical ...
Way
...
deposits extremities may be the seat of more or less
of globules piled up to give a architectural figures The segments or disks
After that short period of time or at 4 38the heart again
began to beat in an irregular manner continuing thus for
fiteen seconds when it became regular and strong thus There
was no apparent loss of power in the heart action Aiter this
time times
for two minutes the heart became slower heating 100 a minute at % and eighty times a minute at 4:44
At 46the heart beats were distinctly regular but becom-
ing very weak The last heart beat was noted at 4.47 4.47
Respirations during this time after the first deep inspiration inspiration inspiration were convulsive and irregular
...
...
rot
VES Seme e of
ee resr. . 1 a
rra%
SIAL tae ee
ey _
ET
s-
e re
Sree tmn ET
es
NET
arryn
ane OI -po wert ee Ae
Sey
Sa
SES SRN NS
RI
RE
UOT) FR eR
De OCP sy
REY
pee
OUTPane
rey
TOFE
Se
a
SORA
ne
#
dntW
Sr
DW
ome
ee
on
WS
aie
ee
I
RE
Oe
e De