Document vB20nQv4yXerJd35OVZ5e5EvE
ARLG-O133 Final Report
Salmonella - Escherichia coli/Mammalian-Microsome Reverse Mutation Assay with PFOS
-- EL
01923
COVANCE
FINAL REPORT SALMONELLA - ESCHERICHIA COLIMAMMALIAN-MICROSOME REVERSE
MUTATION ASSAY WITH PFOS
AUTHOR Michael S. Mecchi, MS
PERFORMING LABORATORY Covance Laboratories Inc. (Covance)
9200 Leesburg Pike Vienna, Virginia 22182
LABORATORY PROJECT IDENTIFICATION
Covance Study No.: 20784-0-409
3M Study No.: T6295.17
SUBMITTED TO
3M Corporate Toxicology
3M Center Building 220-2E-02 St. Paul, Minnesota 55144-1000
STUDY COMPLETION DATE November 5, 1999
1of24
.
01924
-_
CoCvoavannccee22007784-0044009
QUALITY ASSURANCE STATEMENT
Salmonella-Escherichia colitMammalian-Microsome Reverse Mutation Assay with PFOS
a`TchceorredpaonrctehwaistbhetehnerGeovoidewLeadbobryatthoeryQuParlaicttyicAesrseugrualnatcieoUnnsiatsosfeCtofvoratnhcien tLhaeboErnavtiorroinemseInntc.a,lin TPrhoetefcotliloonwiAnggenincsype(cEtPioAns- wTeSrCeA)c,onTdiutclete4d0oafntdhteheUf.iSn.diCnogdseroefporFteeddertaoltRheegSutluatdiyDoinsrePcatrotr7a9n2d. Cstouvdayndcieremcatonramgaenmaegnetmaecncto.rdWirnigtttoenstsatnadtuasrdreoppoerrtastoifnignsprpoeccetdiuorness.and findings are issued to
Inspection Dates From To 9999 919/99
Phase Preparation of $9 Mix
Dates Reported to Study Director and Study Director Management ___ Auditor
919/99
J. Crouch
1021/99 1021/99 Draft Report Review
1021/99
K. Groeninger
11/04/99 11/04/99 Final Report Review
11/04/99
K. Groeninger
i
<
Representative, Qualify Assurance Unit
ufoy[35 Date
le
01325
Covance 20784-0-409
STUDY COMPLIANCE AND CERTIFICATION
The described study was conducted in compliance with the Good Laboratory Practice regulations
as set forth in the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA - TSCA), Title 40ofthe U.S. Code of
Federal Regulations Part 792, and with any applicable amendments. There were no significant deviations from the aforementioned regulations or the signed protocol that would affect the integrityofthe study or the interpretationofthe test results. The raw data have been reviewed by
the Study Director, who certifies that the evaluation ofthe test article as presented herein
represents an appropriate conclusion within the contextofthe study design and evaluation criteria. All test and control results in this report are supportedbyan experimental data record
and this record has been reviewed by the Study Director.
Study Director:
Wet LS Wheel
Michael S. Mecchi, MS
Genetic and Cellular Toxicology
1-5-9%
Study Completion Date
3.
01926
TAOFBCOL NTEE NTS
Covance 20784-0-409 Page No.
STUDYINFORMATION oie] Sponsor TestArticle AssayInformation StudyDates Supervisory Personnel
OBIICTIVE 1sssumtiossssasessormnmnssnpmctsnttmpimessssstnistammntasasiesd
TEST SYSTEMRATIONALE reer
SE
ns
MATAENDR METI HODA S.LS o.oo
8
Test System
TestArticle
ControlArticles
59 Metabolic Activation System
Dose Rangefinding Assay
Mutagenicity Assay
PlatingProcedures
ScotrheiPlnatges
DATA ssissigessonssssescsssmsmscessnrinesssprsscsstsrtisssssssnicessnssss1s Data Presentation Assay Acceptance Criteria Assay Evaluation Criteria
Test Article Handling Dose Rangefinding Assay Mutagenicity Assay
CONCLUSION iii
eee
17
REC TOO BEMR AIND TAINSED ............ccooomiieinnniinnnesinnnnnnn 18
Co
01927
TABLE OF CONTENTS (Continued)
Covance 20784-0-409
PageNo.
os. }
01923
-_--
CoCvoavnacnece2027078844.-0-44009
ABSTRACT
``Tmhuetaotbijoencsteiivteohefrtihnisthsetpurdeyswenacsetooreavbasleuantceetohfemtaesmtmaartliiclaen, PmFiOcrSo,sofomraltheenazbiylmietystaoti1n)dtuhcee reverse htirsytpitdoipnhealnocluoscuisnoftEhescgheenroimcehoifa scoelviersatlrasitnraWiPn2soufvSraAl.monella typhimurium and at 2) the
rTahnegedfoisnedsintgesatsedsaiynutshienmgutteasgteernisctiratiynsasTsAay10we0raensdelWePc2teudvbraAseadnodntetnhedroesseusltosfotefastdaortsiecle ranging from 6.67 to 5,000 pg per plate, one plate per dose, both in the presence and absenceof$9 mix.
T`TAh9e8t,esTteArLs0t0ra,inTsAuIsSe3d5,inTtAhe15mu3t7agaenndicEistcyhearsiscahyiwaecroeliStaelsmtoernesltrlaaintyWpPh2iumruvrAi.um Ttehsetaersssatryawinass
ccoonntdruocltseudsiinngbotthhretehpelaptreessepnecredoasned. aTbsheencdeosoefs St9esmteidxwailtohngthweiStahlcmoonnceulrlraenttesvteerhisctlreaiannsdweproseitive
35,3030,01,030,,33303,.3,1,1000.00,,333.33,3,1010.,00a,nadnd330..333u3gppgepreprlatpelaitnetihnetphreeasbesnceenocefoSf9Sm9imxixa.ndW5i,t0h00t,es1t,e0r00,
strain in the
WP2uvrA, the doses tested presence and absence of $9
were mix
5,000,
3,330,
1,000,
333,
100,
and
33.3
ug
per
plate
both
iTnhdeicraetseultthsaotfutnhdeerStahlemocnoenldliat-iEosncsohefrtihcihsiastcuodyl,i/3MMamCmoarlpioarnat-eMiTcorxiocsoolmoegyR'esvetersstearMtuitclaet,iPoFnOASs,say sdtirdainnosteciatuhesreianptohseitpirveeseinnccreeoarseabinsetnhceemoefamnicnruomsboemraolferenvzeyrmteasntpsrpeeprarpeldatferwoimth anyofthe tester AsoclorTM-induced rat liver ($9).
"8s
:
01929
Covance 20784-0409 STUDY INFORMATION Sponsor 3M Corporate Toxicology Test Article Sponsor's Identification: PFOS FC-95 Date Received: 08/19/99 Lot217 Physical Description: white crystalline powder Storage Conditions: room temperature Assay Information `TypeofAssay: Salmonella-Escherichia coli/Mammalian-Microsome Reverse Mutation Assay Protocol No.: 409, Edition 5 Covance Study No.: 20784-0-409 Study Dates Initiation Date: 08/20/99 Experimental Start Date: 08/24/99 Experimental Termination Date: 09/15/99 Supervisory Personnel Study Director: Michael S. Mecchi, MS Laboratory Supervisor: Carlos E. Orantes, BS
OBJECTIVE `The objectiveofthis study was to evaluate the test article and/or its metabolites for their ability to induce reverse mutations either in the presence or absenceofmammalian microsomal enzymes at 1) the histidine locus in the genomeofseveral strainsofSalmonella typhimurium and at 2) the tryptophan locusofEscherichia coli strain WP2uvrA.
TEST SYSTEM RATIONALE `The Salmonella/Mammalian-microsome reverse mutation assay detects point mutations, both frameshifts and/or base pair substitutions. The strains ofSalmonella typhimurium used in this assay are histidine auxotrophs by virtue of conditionally lethal mutations in their histidine operon. When these histidine-dependent cells (his-) are exposed to the test article and grown under selective conditions (minimal media with a trace amountofhistidine) only those cells
.7-
.
61930
Covance 20784-0-409
h`iwshtiicdhinreevienrtthteo mhiesdtiiadianlelionwdseaplelntdheenpcleat(ehdisb+a)ctaerreiaabtloe utnodfeorrgmo caolfoenwiecse.ll Tdhiveistiroancse,awmhoiucnhtiosf . essential for mutagenesis to be fully expressed. The his+ revertants are readily discemable as
tceosltoenritersaiangasi,nbsottthhebalsiemiptaeidr bsaucbsktgirtouutinodn gmruotwatthioonfsthanedifsr-amceelslhsi.ftBmyutuatitliioznisngcsaenvebrealdedtiefcfteerde.nt a`cTthievAitmyeosf mTeasntyhmaastbereieanlsshioncwlnudtionbgeaawisednesirtainveg,eorfacpihdemaincdaalccculraastseesi.ndicatorofthe mutagenic
`The Escherichia coli WP2uvrA reverse mutation assay detects point mutations, specifically base apauixrotsurbospthit(u1t7ipo-n)s.byTvhiertEusecohfeariccohnidaitcioolnatlelsytelretshtarlaimnuWtaPt2iuonvratAaussietde wihnitchihsbalsoscakysisaastterpypotfophan tryptophan biosynthesis prior to the formation of anthranilic acid. Since the target site for true back mutation is an ochre nonsense mutation, tryptophan-independent revertants (irp+) can arise cither by a base change at the siteofthe original alteration or by suppression by specific suppressor mutations at a second site in tRNA genes (Brusick et al., 1980). When the tryptophan-dependent cells (1rp-) are exposed to the test article and grown under selective conditions (minimal media with a trace amountoftryptophan) only those cells which revert to tryptophan independence (7+) are able to form colonies. The trace amountoftryptophan in the `media allows all the plated bacteria to undergo a few cell divisions, which is essential for mutagenesis to be fully expressed. The trp+ revertantsarereadily discemable as colonies against the limited background growthofthe trp- cells. While the trp reversion system responds to most alkylating agents, base-analog mutagens and certain metals (i.e. soluble chromates), frameshift `mutagens would not be expected to be detected by this system.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The experimental materials, methods and procedures are based on those described by Ames et al., (1975) and Green and Muriel (1976).
Test System Salmonella typhimurium. The tester strains used were the Salmonella typhimurium histidine auxotrophs TA98, TA100, TALS3S, and TALS37as described by Ameetasl, (1975). The tester strains in use at Covance were received directly from Dr. Bruce Ames, Department of Biochemistry, UniversityofCalifornia, Berkeley. The specific genotypesofthese strains are: shown in the following table.
Tester Strain Genotypes
Histidine Mutation HsG46 hisCI0T6 hisD30S2 TAIS3S TALS}
"Additional Mutations LPS Repair R Factor da wrB -
-8-
0191
-_-- Covance207840 Covan4 ce 200 784-0 0409
`Imnuatdadtiitoinosnwthoiachmuetnahtainocne itnhetihre sheinsstiitdiivnietyopteorsoon,methmeutteasgteernistcrcaionmspcoounntdaisn. tTwhoeadrdfiatwiaolnallmutation
results in the lossofoneofthe lipopolysaccharide barrier that
enzymes forms the
responsible for the synthesisofpart of surfaceofthe bacterial cell wall. The
the resulting
cell
wall
rdienfgicsiyesntceymisnc(ir.eea.sbeesnpzeor[maelapbyirleintey)ttohcaterwtoaiunldclaostsheesrowficsheebmeicexacllsudsuecdhbaysatnhoosremaclonitnatianctincgelllarwgalel.
sTyhsetseemcwohnidcmhutgraetaitolny,eanhdealnecteisontohfetshenesiutrivBitygeofnteh,erseseulsttsraiinnsatdoefsiocmieentmuDtNagAenesx.ciSsiionnceretphaeiruvrB vdeilteatmiionnbeixotteinndfsorthgrroowutghh.the bio gene, alofthe tester trains containing this deletion require the
Strains TA98 and TA100 also contain the PKMI01 plasmid which further increases the sseennssiittiivviittyyotfotmhuetsaegsetnrsaihnasstobeseonmesumgugteasgteednst.o bTehbeymmeocdhiafnyiisnmg bany ewxhiiscthintghibsacptleraisamliDd NinAcreraepsaeisr polymerase complex involved with the mismatch-repair process.
Tester strains TA98 and TA1537 are reverted from histidine dependence (auxotrophy) to
histidine independence (prototrophy) by frameshift mutagens. TAIS35 is reverted by base
substitution mutagens substitutions.
and
TA100
is
reverted
by
mutagens
which
cause
both
frameshifis
and
base
Escherichia coli. The tester strain used was the tryptophan auxotroph WP2uvrA as described by C`GorleleenctainodnoMfuIrnideulst(r1i9a76l)B.actTehreiat,esTtoerrrsetyraRiensienaurscehaSttaCtoivona,ncSceowtalasnrde(cUeniivteeddfKrionmgTdhoem)N.ational In addition to a mutation in the tryptophan operon, the tester strain contains a uvrA DNA repair tdheefisctireanicnytowhsihcohweennhhaanncceesditmsutseanbsiiltiitvyitsyitnocestohmeeumvurtAagreepnaiicr csoymsptoeumnwdosu.ldTnhoirsmdaelfliyciaecntctyoallows remove the damaged part of the DNA molecule and accurately repair it afterwards. iTensdteeprenstdreaninceW(Pp2routvortrAopihsyr)evbeyrtbeadsefrsoubmsttirtyupttioopnhmauntdaegpeennsd.ence (auxotrophy) to tryptophan
gFrroowzienngPferresmhaonveenmtiSgthotckcusl.tuFrerso,zeanddpienrgmdainmeentthysltsouclkfsooxfitdhee(tDeMstSeOr ,str0a.i0n9swmeLr/emprLoepfacrueldtubrye) and freezing small aliquots (0.5-1.5 mL) at <~70C.
Master Plates. Master platesofthe tester strains were prepared by streaking each tester strain from a frozen permanent stock onto minimal agar appropriately supplemented with 1) for
9.
.
01932
Covance 20784-0409 `STaAl1m0o0n,elalmapitcyiplhliinmu(r2i5umu,g/amnLe)x,cteosseonfsuhriesttihdeinset,abalnedmbaiionttine,naanncdefoofr tthesetperKsMtr1a0in1s pTlAa9sm8ida;ndand 52)23forCE.scherichia coli, an excessoftryptophan. Tester strain master plates were stored at
iInnooccuullaatteidonbyoftrOavnsefrenrirignhgtaCcuolltounryesf.roOmvtehmeiagphptrocpurlitautreesmafosrteursepliantealltotaesftliansgkpcrooncteadiunriensgwceurlteure o`pmeerdaituimo.n (Isnhoackuilnagt,ed12fl5as+ks25weprme;pliancceudbaitnioans,h3ak7e+r/2incCu)bastootrhwathitchehowvaesrnpirgohtgrcualmtmueredstwoebreegiinn log phase or late log phase when turbidity monitoring began.
lHeanrgvtehosftoinfcuObvaetrinoinghwtasCudlettuerremsi.neTdobeynsspuercettrhoapthcoutlotmuertersiwcemroenihatrovreisntgeodficnullattuerelotgurpbhiadsitey,.the tCrualntsumrietstwanecree(h%aTrv)esrteeaddionngcoenaparsepdeectterropmhionteodmetturebri.diTthyiwsatsarrgeeatcthuerdbiadsitdyeteensrumriensedthbatyaculpteurrceesnt have reached a densityofat least 0.5 X 10 cells per mL and that the cultures have not Couvletrugrreoswnw.erOevreregmroovwend (fsrtoamtiionncaruyb)atciuolntuwrehsemnatyheetxahrigbeitt%deTcrweaasserdesaecnhseidtiavnitdywteorseopmleacmeudtaagtens. 53C.
Confirmation of Tester Strain Genotype. Tester strain cultures `genetic markers on the dayoftheir use in the mutagenicity assay.
were
checked
for
the
following
#fa Wall Mutation. For the Salmonella typhimurium tester strain cultures, the presenceofthe vfiaolewta.llAmnutaaltiiqouontowafasncoonvfeimrimgedhtbcyudletumroenosfteraacthionsotfratihnewasesnsoivteirvliatiydofontthoe pclualtteusrecotnotcariynsitnagl selective media and an antibiotic sensitivity disk containing 10 pgofcrystal violet was added. Sensitivity was demonstrated by inhibitionof bacterial growth in a zone immediately surrounding the disk.
PKMI01 Plasmid. The presenceofthe pKM101 plasmid was confirmed for the appropriate tester strain cultures by demonstrationofresistance to ampicillin. An aliquotofan overnight cultureof each strain was overlaid onto plates containing selective media and an antibiotic sensitivity disk containing ampicillin was added. Resistance was demonstrated by bacterial `growth in the zone immediately surrounding the disk.
Characteristic Number of Spontaneous Revertants. The numberofspontaneous revertants. per plate in the vehicle controls that is characteristicofthe respective strains was demonstrated by plating 100 uL aliquotsofthe culture along with the appropriate vehicle on selective media.
-10-
01933
Covance 20784-0409 VCuolgteulr-iBnognnBerrotsahl.t sTohleutbiroont(hVuosgeedl taongdrBoownnoevre,rn1i9g5h6t)csulutpuprleesmoefnttheedtweisttehr2st.r5a%ins(ww/avs) Oxoid Nutrient Broth No. 2 (dry powder).
Agar Plates. Bottom `mediumE (Vogel and
agar (25 Bonner,
mL per 15 x 100mm 1956), supplemented
petri with
dish) 1.5%
was Vogel-Bonner minimal (w/v) agar and 0.2% (w/v)
glucose.
O(wvievr)laanydA0g.a5r%fNoarCSlel(ewc/tvi)onaonfdRweavserstuapnptlse.meOnvteerdlwaiyt(hto1p0) magLaorfw1a)s p0.r5epmarMedhwisittihdi0n.e/7b%ioatgianr solution per 100 mL agar for selection ofhistidine revertants, or 2) 0.5 mM tryptophan solution `tpheer s1u0p0pmleLmoefntaegdartofporagsaerlewcatisonuosfetdryinptthoephoavenrlraeyv.ertHaontwse.veWrh,ewnhSen9 mSi9xmiwxaswaresquniortedr,eq2u.i0remd,L of `water was added to the supplemented top agar (0.5 mLofwater per 2 mLof supplemented top daiglaurt)iaonndentshuerreedsutlhtaitntgh2e.5finmalLotfodpaiglautreadndsuapmpilnemoeanctieddstuoppplaegamrenwtascounsceendtfroartitohnesorveermlaaiyn.edThtihse same both in the presence and absence of S9 mix.
Test Article
`The Sponsor was characteristics as
responsible for the defined in the GLP
dreetguelramtiinonast,ionof
the
test
article
stability
and
the
test
article:
Control Articles Vehicle Controls. Vehicle controls were plated for all tester strains both in the presence and `ambsaexnicmeuomfaSl9iqmuioxto.fTtehsetvaerhtiicclleedciolnuttriooln wplaastepdl)a,taedl,onugsiwnigtha 5a010p0LuaLliaqluioqtuooftvoefhitcheleap(perqouparlitaotethe tester strain and a 500 kL aliquot of$9 mix (when necessary), on selective agar.
Positive Controls. The combinationsofpositive controls, activation condition and tester strains plated concurrently with the assay are indicated in the following table.
on
01934
Positive Controls
Covance 20784-0-409
Tester Strain TA9S TA98 TA100 TA100 TALS3S TAIS3S TAI537 WTAPI2Su3r7A WP2uvrA
59 Mix +
Positive Control benzofalpyrenc
Conc_perPlate 2518
= +
22-naimtionfolaunotrhernaecene
10g 25pg
= +
sodiumazide 2aminoanthracene
204g 254g
= +
2saomdiinuomaanztihdreacene
204g 251g
+-ICR2-Iam9in1oanthracene
204g 250ug
= dnitroguinolineN-oxide 10g
`The sources and gradesofthe positive control articles are as follows:
2be-nazmoi[naoJapnytrhernaece(nCeA(SC#A5S0-#3621-38-)1,3-S8i)g,mSaiCghmeamiCchaelmiCcoa,l pCou.r,itpyu2ri9t8y%297% 2-nitrofluorene (CAS #607-57-8), Aldrich Chemical Co., 298% sodium azide (CAS #26628-22-8), Sigma Chemical Co, purity 298% ICR-191 (CAS #1707-45-0), Sigma Chemical Co, purity 298% 4-nitroquinoline-N-oxide (CAS #56-57-5), Sigma Chemical Co., purity 299%.
pSltaertiilnigtya CSoOnktrLolasli.quTohte(tmhoesstacmoencveonlturmaeteudsteedstianrttihcelaesdsialyu)toionn wsealseccthieveckaegadr.forTshteerSil9itmyibxywas checked for sterility by plating 0.5 mL on selective agar.
$9 Metabolic Activation System
T$o9xHicoomlooggey,naItnce.., BLaitvcehr0m9i7c2ro(s4o2m.8almegnofzpyrmoetse(iSn9pheormmoLg)e.naTteh)e hweormeogpeunracthaesweadsfprroempaMroeldecfurloamr
male Sprague-Dawley com oil) at 500mg/kg
rats that had as described
been injected (i.p.) with by Ames ef al, (1975).
AroclorTM
1254
(200
mgpermL
in
T$h9eMi$x9.miTxheco$n9tamiinxedwtahse cproemppaorneednitmsmienddiiactaetleydpriniotrhteofoiltslouwsienigntaabnlye.experimental procedure.
-12-
01935
$9 Mix Components
Covance 20784-0-409
CHOomponeAm0n .o7u0 nmt Lt_
0I2M5NMaHGl,uPcOo/seN-aG;-pHhPoOsp,hpatHe
7.4 ~~
0.10 0.02
mL mL
0.10M NADP
004mL
0.825M KCU0.2M mgCly 004ml
$9 Homogenate
010ml
100 mL
Dose Rangefinding Assay `The growth inhibitory effect (cytotoxicity)ofthe test article to the test system was determined in order to allow the selectionofappropriate doses to be tested in the mutagenicity assay.
Design. The dose rangefindingassaywas performed using tester strains TA100 and WP2ivrA both in the presence and absence of S9 mix. Ten dosesoftest article were tested at one plate per dose. The test article was checked for cytotoxicity up to a maximum concentration of5 mg per plate.
Rationale. The cytotoxicityof the test article observed on tester strain TA100 is generally representativeofthat observed on the other tester strains and because ofthe comparatively high `numberofspontaneous revertants per plate observed with this strain, gradationsof cytotoxicity can be readily discemed from routine experimental variation. The Escherichia coli tester strain WP2uvrA does not possess the rfa wall mutation that the Salmonella typhimurium strains have and thus, a different rangeofcytotoxicity may be observed. Also, the cytotoxicity induced by a test article in the presence of S9 mix may vary greatly from that observed in the absence of S9 mix. Therefore, this would require that different test article dose ranges be tested in the `mutagenicity assay based on the presence or absenceofthe S9 mix.
Evaluation of the Dose Rangefinding Assay. Cytotoxicity is detectable as a decrease in the `numberofrevertant colonies per plate and/or by a thinning or disappearanceofthe bacterial background lawn.
Selection of the Maximum Dose for the Mutagenicity Assay. Cytotoxicity was observed in the dose rangefinding study and the highest concentrationoftest article used in the subsequent `mutagenicity assay was a dose which was expected to exhibita thinningofthe bacterial background lawn.
Mutagenicity Assay Design. The assay was performed using tester strains TA9E, TA100, TAS35, TALS37, and WP2uvrA both in the presence and absenceofS9 mix along with the appropriate vehicle and
.3-
.
01936
-_--
CCoovvaannccee2200778844:-00409
positive controls. The rangefinding assay.
dosesoftest
article
were
selected
based
on
the
resultsofthe
dose
tFhreepqluaetenciyncaornpdorRaotuiotnemoeftAhdomdionliosgtyraotriigoinn.alTlyhdeetsecsrtiebresdtrbayinAsmweerseefexaplo,s(e1d97to5)thaendteMstaarrotinclaenvdia mAumteagsen(1s9.83)I.n tThheipslamteetihnocdoorploorgaytihoansmbeetehnodsohloowgny,tothdeetteecstt aarwtiicdlee, rtahnegteeostfecrlsatsrsaeinsoafndchtehemiSc9al pmliatxe.(wFhoelrleoawpipnrgopirnicautbea)tiwoenr,ercevoemrbtianntecdoilnonmioelstweenraegacrouwnhtiecd.h wAalls doovserelsoaifdtohnetoteastmairntiicmlea,ltahgear `vehicle controls and the positive controls were plated in triplicate.
Plating Procedures `These procedures were used in both the dose rangefinding assay and the mutagenicity assay.
aEcatcihvaptliaotnecwoandsiltaiboenlaedndwidtohsea lceovdele.wThhicehSi9demnitxifiaenddtdhieltuetsitonasrotifclte,hetetsetstphaartsiec,letewseterresptrraeipna,red immediately prior to their use.
`When 9 mix `were added to
was not required, 2.5 mL ofmolten
100 iL oftester strain and 50 selective top agar (maintained
uL of at 45
vehicle + 2C).
or test article dose When S9 mix was
aredqdueidretdo,25.000muLLooffmSo9ltmeinx,se1l0ec0tiuvLeotfotpeasgtaerr.stArfatienratnhde5r0eqpuLiroefd vceohmipcolneeonrttseshtaadrtbiecleendaodsdeedw,erteh:e
i`mniaxt1u5rexw1a0s0vmormtepxeerdiadnidsho.veArfltaeird othnetoovtehrelasyurhfaadceosofli2d5ifimeLd,ofthmeipnliatmeaslwebroettionmveargtaerd caonndtained
incubated aliquot.
for
52%
4
hr
at
37+
2C.
Positive
control
articles
were
platedusing
a
50
L plating
Scoring the Plates Plates which were not evaluated immediately following the incubation period were held at 5:+3C until such time that colony counting and bacterial background lawn evaluation could take place.
eBvaacltueartieadl bBoatchkmgarcoruosncdopLiacawlnlyEavanldumaitciroons.coTphiceaclolnyd(iutsiionngofatdhiessebaccttienrgimalicbraocskcgorpoeu)nfdorlawn was rienldaitciavteiotnostohfecvyethoitcolxeicciotntyraonldpltaestteaarntdiclweapsrerceicpiotradteed. aElvoingdewnictehotfhecyrteovteorxtiacnittcyowuanstsscfoorreadll plates 4at) tehxattrdeomseelylerveedlu.ceLda,w5n)sawbseernet,scoorr6e)doabssc1)urneodrmbayl,pr2e)cispliitgahttel.y rIefdpurceesde,nt3)onmotdheerpaltaetelsy,reduced, macroscopic precipitate was scored as slight, moderate or heavy.
14.
01927
-_
CCoovvaannce 220778844-00-4409
cCoonutnrtolisnagnRdeavlel rptlaatnetsCcoolnotnaiiensi.ngTtheset narutmicbleerwoefrreevceorutnatnetd cmoalnounailelsyp.erTphleatneufmobr etrhoefverheivcelretant ecoxlcoenpiteisonpoefr ptlhaetepofsoirtitvhee cpoonstirtoilvse fcoornttreosltserwsetrraeincoTunAt9edibnythaeutpormeasteendcecoofloSn9ymcioxunitnerExwpiethritmheent 20784-B, which were counted manually.
DATA
Data Presentation cFaolrcualllatreedp.liTcahtee rpleastuilntgsos,ftthheesmeeacanlcruelvaetritoannstsarpeerprpelsateentaendditnhteasbutlaanrdafrodrdmeviniatthieonDawteareTables sectionofthis report.
Assay Acceptance Criteria
Before assay data were evaluated, the criteria criteria were used (0 determine a valid assay:
foar
valid
assay
had
to
be met.
The
following
Tester Strain Integrity. #fa Wall Mutation. To demonstrate the presence of the rfa wall mutation, Salmonella typhimurium tester strain cultures exhibited sensitivittoy crystal violet.
`PaKppMr1op0ri1atPeltaessmteird.strTaionsdeemxohinbsittreadteretshiestparnecseetnoceaompfictihleliPnK. MI01 plasmid, cultures ofthe
hCihsatriadcitneeroirsttriycpNtoupmhabne,rthoeftSepstoenrtsatrnaeionucsulRteuvreesrteaxnhtisb.iteTdoadcehmaornacstterraitsetitchneurmebqeuirroefment for Tsphoentacacnecpotuasblreevrearntagnetssfpoerrthpelamteeawnhevnehpilcalteedcoanltoronlgswwietrhethaes vfeohlilcowlse:under selective conditions.
TA98 8-60 TAI00 60 - 240 TAISIS 4-45 TAISY 2. 25 WP2uwrA 5 - 40
t`TheesdteenrsSittryaoifntCeustletrusrteraDinencsuilttyur.esTwoedreemogrnesattrearttehtahnatorapepqruoaplritaot0e.5nuxmb10ersboacftbearicatepreiramarLe apnladt/eodr, thhaadnroeracehqeudalattoar0g.e5txle1v0elobfatcutrerbiiadipteyrdmeLm.onstrated to produce cultures with a density greater
-15-
01938
Covance 20784-0-409
Positive Control Values in the Absence of $9 Mix. capable of identifying a mutagen, the mean valueof a
To demonstrate positive control
that the tester strains were for a respective tester
strain strain
exhibited
at
least
a
3-fold
increase
over
the
mean
valueofthe
vehicle
control
for
that
tPhoesiSt9ivmeiCxonwtarsoclaVpaabllueeosfimnetthaeboPlriezsienngcae pofroSm9utMaigxen(5190 iMtis xmuItnatgeegnriitcy)f.orTm(os)d,emtohensmteraantevtahlaute ofthe positive control for a respective tester strain in the presenceofthe S9 mix exhibited at least a 3-fold increase over the mean value ofthe vehicle control for that strain.
hAanviancgcedpetmaobnlsetproastietdivbeoctohnttrhoeliinntetghreitpyroefstehneceSo9fmSi9xmainxdftohreaabsipleictiyfoifctshteraitneswtaerssetrvaailnuatoteddetaesct a `mutagen.
Cytotoxicity. A minimumofthree non-toxic doses were required to evaluate assay data.
Assay Evaluation Criteria Once the criteria for a valid assay had been met, responses observed in the assay were evaluated as follows:
Tester Strains TASS, TA100, and WP2uvrA. For a test article to be considered positive, it had
10 produce at least a 2-fold increase in the mean revertants per plateofat least oneofthese tester
strains over the mean revertants per plateofthe appropriate vehicle control. This increase in the
mean numberofrevertants per plate concentrationsofthe test article.
had
to
be
accompanied
by
a
dose
response
to
increasing
`Tester Strains TA1535 and TA1537. Foratest article to be considered positive, it had to produce at least a 3-fold increase in the mean revertants per plateofat least oneofthese tester strains over the mean revertants per plateof the appropriate vehicle control. This increase in the `mean numberofrevertants per plate had to be accompanied by a dose response to increasing `concentrationsofthe test article.
RESULTS
Test Article Handling `The test article formed unworkable, non-homogeneous suspensions in water at concentrations of 500, 399, 300, 200, 99.9, and 50.0 mg/mL. In dimethylsulfoxide, the test article formed a non-homogeneous suspension at 501 mg/mL and a homogeneous suspension at 401 mg/mL. For this reason, dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO, CAS# 67-68-5, Acros Organics, Lot No. A012649701) was used as the vehicle. At 100 mg per mL, which was the most concentrated stock dilution prepared for the mutagenicity assay, the test article formed a translucent white suspension. The
-16-
}
01939
Covance 20784-0-409
test article formed a solution at 2.00 prepared for the mutagenicity assay.
mg/mL
and
remained
a
solution
in
all
succeeding
dilutions
Dose Rangefinding Assay Doses tested in the mutagenicity assay were selected based on the resultsofthe dose trhaengperfeisnednicnegaansdsaaybcsoenndcueoctfedS9onmithxewtietsht aornteiclpelautseipnegrtedsotseer.stTreainnsdoTsAe1so0f0taesntd aWrPti2clue,vrfrAomin6b.o6t7h 105,000 ug per plate, were tested and the resultsarepresented in Tables 1 and 2. These data `were generated in Experiment 20784-A1. Indications ofcytotoxicity were observed with tester strain TA100 at 10.0 ug per plate and above in the absence of S9 mix as evidenced by the thinning ofthe bacterial background lawn. No cytotoxicity was observed with tester strain `TAL00 in the presenceofS9 mix or with tester strain WP2uvrA in either the presence or absence of$9 mix as evidenced by no decrease in the numberof revertants per plate and a normal background lawn.
Mutagenicity Assay `The mutagenicity assay results for PFOS are presented in Tables 3 through 5. These data were `generated in Experiment 20784-B1. The data are presented as individual plate counts (Tables 3 and 5)and as mean revertants per plat+e standard deviation (Tables 4 and 5) for each treatment and control group.
`The resultsofthe dose rangefinding study were used to select the doses tested in the `3m3u3t,ag1e0n0i,caitnyda3s3s.a3y.pgThpeerdpolsaetsetiensttehde wpirtehsetnhceeSoaflmSo9nemlilxaatnedste5r,0s0t0r,ain1s,0w0e0r,e3353,,00100,03,,3333.03,, 11,00.000,, 3.33, 1.00, and 0.333pgperplate in the absence of S9 mix. With tester strain WP2uvrA, the doses tested were 5,000, 3,330, 1,000, 333, 100, and 33.3 pg per plate both in the presence and absence of S9 mix.
In the mutagenicity assay (Experiment 20784-B1, Tables 3,4 and 5), all data were acceptable and 10 positive increases in the mean number ofrevertants per plate were observed with anyofthe tester strains either in the presence or absenceof S9 mix.
All criteria for a valid study were met.
CONCLUSION
`The resultsofthe Salmonella-Escherichia coliMammalian-Microsome Reverse Mutation Assay indicate that under the conditionsofthis study, 3M Corporate Toxicology test article, PFOS, did not cause apositive increase in the mean number of revertantsperplate with anyofthe tester strains either in the presence or absence of microsomal enzymes prepared from AroclorTM-induced rat liver (S9).
17-
01910
-_--
CoCvoavnanccee220077844-004-4p099
RECORDS TO BE MAINTAINED
tAhlilsrsatwuddyatwai,lldboceuamrecnhtiavteidonin, trheecosrtdosr,atgheefapcrioltiotcieoslo,fanCdovtahnecfein-aVlireenpnoartfgorenaetrlaetaestd oasnea yreesaurlt of
following `may elect
submissionofthe final report to the Sponsor. to have the aforementioned materials retained
After in the
theone yearperiod, storage facilities of
the
Sponsor
Covance-Vienna Sponsor.
for
an
additional
periodof
time
or
sent
to
a
storage
facility
designated
by
the
REFERENCES `Awmitehst,hBe.SN.a,lMmconCealnlna,/MJ.a, mamnadliYaanm-aMsiackrio,soE.m,e"MMuettahgoednsicfiotrydTeetsetc.t"inMguctaartciionnogReensseaarncdh,mu3t1a:g3e4n7s3641975).
tBhreusEiscckh,erD.iJc.h,iSaicmolmionW,P2V.Fa.n,dRWosPe2nukvrarnAz,reHv.eSr.s,eRmauyt,atVi.oAn.aasnsdayS.t"afMfuotrda,tiRo.Sn.R,e"seAanrcehv,alu7a6t:i1o6n9-of 190 (1980).
Green, M.H.L. and Mutation Research,
Muriel, W.J., "Mutagen 38:3-32 (1976).
testing
using
trp"
reversion
in
Escherichia
coli."
Maron, D.M. and Ames, B., "Revised Research, 113:173-215 (1983).
methods
for
the
Salmonella
Mutagenicity
Test."
Mutation
Vogel, HJ. and Bonner, D.M., "AcetylomithinaseofE. properties." J. Biol. Chem. 218:97-106 (1956).
coli:
Partial
purification
and some
18.
01911
Covance 20784-0-409
DATA TABLES
19}
01942
Covance 20784-0-409 TABLE 1 : DOSE RANGEFINDING ASSAY RESULTS
TEST ARTICLE ID: PROS. EXPERIMENT ID: 20764-A1
VEHICLE: DMSO
"DATE PLATED: 2-Aug99 "DATE COUNTED: 27-Aug:99
bePLATE 000 (VehicleS041)
"TAIO0 REVERTANTS PER PLATE
wins
WITHOUTS)
REVEPRETRANTS BACLKaGwROnUND. REVEPRETRANTS BACKLGARWONUND,
PATE EVALUATION
PATE EVALUATION
E)
v
w%
1
Tes Aric:
oer
w
'
'
100
0
'
"
2
ns
9%
'
2
wr
108
'
%
2
0
u
'
"
2
"
'
2
wn
"
'
=
2
100
9s
'
w
2
EN)
7%
'
5s
2
sao
=
'
3
B4a=c7kgnoroorummnadlLeawnn Evsaluation Coe2Ss:==sbieghnyreduced pn Sigprepiaie mp - m{roeidreeshparncdicuotune)
3 == Gmodsemcelbyuyrperrdecceeidpd bp =(breequyirpesreacnpdraceou)
-20-
01943
-
coCvovmacnecel2o07m8e4-o0u-4n09
TABLE 2: DOSE RANGEFINDING ASSAY RESULTS
TEST ARTICLE 0: FrOS
EXPERIMENT ID: 078401
DATE PLATED,24Aug59
venicLE puso
DATE COUNTED: 27:Aug9
nate Sov Torani
pr --
EIorSwm Broicsn
ae evibamow
.
:
REoIo Smousmoornmton
Wee van
-
;
5s
;
wo
,
M
,
.
,
wo
.
,
"
\
s erm oneetca o3E2 gat
SIT
e ----p --
g+=n-- pmrteimiloreaasts
a. 01944
Covance 20784-0-409
TABLE3 : MUTAGENICITY ASSAY RES-UINDLIVITDUSAL PLATE COUNTS
TEST ARTICLE ID: PFOS. EXPERIMENT ID: 20784-51 "DATE PLATED: 09-5p-99. "DATE COUNTED: 13-5p-99, 14-5699
VEHICLE: DMSO PLATING ALIQUOT: 50 hL.
DOSEPLATE
VMEIHCIRCOLSEOMCEOSN:TRRAOTLLIVER
TESTARTCLE
033 ug 1f0ried 3200 uugg
POSITIVE CONTROL**
MVEIHCIRCOLSEOCMOENS:TNROONLE
TEST ARTICLE
o10n0 sug 130303 busg w533ubg 0505 wupg 00 ug
POSITIVE CONTROL**
REVERTANTSPER PLATE.
TTags s TToAI:
7Ta2ss3
Tas 1 27
BoB ou sows 0B
5s 60
0m0o2monnssowwoews wsonwr 32 ssoonn m"9omNeowm as e6 o9w257 651100 2BowmBBwwoswo 47m9mH 47s86
Hs M0 4 ms Eos 2 Wm 1% me
2M 2P1osw 28 2 oB n 1Mo3ds2%a BBooaass 6ds 613 6 195 20
mows 8 92 38 8
ome ommoos Mmoem ow 19 osmoas 88 omos7m momo
86 s7u0 s5nM 96 mowas d9 i0s3 os 70s
a1 s2 s4 7220954s8 4ss9nm 3454 87
en Te To ee e443 507 sie
STTAAIO bZeanmcilnaclapnyiernaecene 2235ppgppitne TTAAISIITS ZZaammiinnccaenniibbraacceennee 2233uupppp * BTac=kgnroomunadlLawn Evaation Code2s=:sighiyreduced p4n= osixgpyrcrpeidaceed mp5== ambosdeknnttepreciptie equines and count)
TTAAI sZaoidvuomfalozrdcene TTAAIISTS IsCoRdIu9m1aide
63+= moodbereilbycyrperudeuccirpeidadic bp =h(eaevypqreuchiapnridceousm)
2100gppgipnee 2200mign
GBRAOCUKN.D Lave
' 11 ii 'i '
' '' i'' i1 2i '
-2201915
Covance 20784-0-409
TABLE 4: MUTAGENICITY ASSAY RES-USULMMTARSY
TEST ARTICLE ID: PFOS EXPERIMEINDT: 2084.81 "DATE PLATED: 09-Sep-99 "DATECOUNTED:13-Sep-99, 14-Sep-99
VEHICLE: DMSO PLATING ALIQUOT: 50 4
TTDOSEPLATE VMEIHCIRCOLSEOMCEOSN:TRROALT LIVER
TESTARTICLE
w333u4g 1300 uugg 0prog 4s
POSITIVE CONTROL**
VMEIHCIRCOLSEOCMOENS:TNROONLE.
TESTARTCLE
0103034ss 130303 4ug w33uug 13050 uugg 00 bg
POSITIVE CONTROL***
MEAN REVERTANTS PER PLATE WITH STANDARD DEVIATION
WEWTasssb MEWTAIs0o WWTassso WENTisssb
no
0
Bos
7a
Fna o
0an 13
2no 2
76ss
220 170
mnooae
05 3
0732
02 82
25 39
05 34
5so 1
as as
929 113
wow
mou
ve
24
02
63
1w5o3s
s8 1s5
[5I 2
:6 22
2a 42
8 160
2no3s
+5 22
2nos4
75 07
nBooss
s[a 3
H1o2e
B@o 5
2no33
672
os
Ea
95
52
won
wow
as 1
ar
STTAAIO bZeanmoilnaclapnyierniecene 2255 ppppilnee TTAAIISSHSTS ZZaammiinncaanniivvaacceennee 2255 ppgpple * Bac=kgnrooumnad Lawn EvalusionCode2s=:sighiyreduced p4n= scixgepmrecyprieadtuceed mp5 == mabsoendte precipice eguires andcom)
TTAAIO Zsaoidvuomfaunoirdeene TTAAIISTS IsCoRdIu9m1aide
63%= omobderselcbyyuperdrecdeipdi bp = h(easvyperehqcainpidcoeunst)
2010uppglpienee 2200upi)ne
GBRAOCUKN.D Awe
1 iT i1 '' '
' i' 11| ii 21 '
-2301916
- Covance20dum TABLES: MUTAGENICITYASSAYRESULTS INDIVIDUAL PLATECOUNTS AND SUMMARY
TESTARTIIC: LFOES
EXPERIMENT ID: 2075451
DATE PLATED: 09-5ep99
VEHICLE DMSO
DATECOUNTED: 1350p99,14:50p9
PLATING ALIQUOT: 50 41
------ee------------------------------------------------
pm oseriure EVERTANLISEFENRFLATE A I WT STANDhAeReDnORATION CS--RoSnA
i MicRosouES: RATLVER
on om
w
,
-2 wn
BHHI RE]R
3FvI o8l
i;i
rosmvecontro sictrosoowes:rnove TARE 35
as as aa ---
5 now
PY
,
wa
\
noe
\
[----
0
NPBA Zamnombrcee 250ys pBiB=tkiLupnnEoeonsonn odls3s:tyrenReRR
----tay
wn
\
[EN
432SomooyteLnotse o_o)
"2-
01947
ANCE
COVANCE.
COVANCE STUDY NO.: 20 784 -(-4C 7
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION
SALMONELLA - MUTATION ASSAY ESCHERICHIA COLIIMAMMALIAN-MICROSOME REVERSE
LCaobvoarnacteorLyabPorraacttiocreie(sGILnPc.)
(rCegouvlaantcieo)nswialnldcsotnadnudacrtdsth.isTshtiusdypriontoccoomlp,laitalnecaestwointeh
Good
critical
phase
of
the work in progress, and the final report will be audited by Quality Assurance in accordance
`with SOPs at Covance. This study will be conducted at 9200 Leesburg Pike, Vienna,Virginia
22182 (Covance-Vienna).
PART 1. SPONSOR INFORMATION AND APPROVALS
10 SPONSOR IDENTIFICATION
ACdodmrpesasn:y Name:
33MM CCoernptoerration
`Building 220-2E-02 St. Paul, MN 55144-1000
20 TEST ARTICLE IDENTIFICATION
PFOS
3m Hed, No Te295,/7
30 TEST ARTICLE ANALYSIS
Determination of the test article stability and the test article characteristics as defined in the GLP regulations is the responsibilityof the Sponsor.
40 NOTIFICATION OF REGULATORY SUBMISSION
Inorderto comply with GLP regulations and standards, consulting laboratories must be
notified if all or part ofa study is intended for regulatory submission. Covance maintains `a master schedule of studies which fall under regulatory review. Please indicate which agency, if any, might receive the results of this study:
Oundeermined Ora Kepatsca 0 eparirra
Omarr Owmonw Doeep Oomer
12198
Lof18
01918
Cc 0 VANCE.
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
50 STUDY DATES
Proposed Experimental Start Date: Proposed Experimental Termination Date:
6.0 APPROVAL OF STUDY PROTOCOL
Study Director:
WAALS Wal
Michael S. Mecchi, M.S.
`Testing Facility Management:
nC
Brian C. Myhr, Ph.D.
Associate Director
Sponsor's Authorized Representative:
Me TG e Marvin T. Case, D.V.M,, Ph.D.
A. gost 999 October 1999
pae 3-pe-98
pa: __[20]29
yA N
12/98
'
20f 18
01919
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
PART 2. STUDY PROTOCOL SALMONELLA - ESCHERICHIA COLIMAMMALIAN-MICROSOME REVERSE
MUTATION ASSAY 1 OBIECTIVE
`aTbihleitoybjteocitnivdeucoef rtehivserssteudmyutiasttiooenvsaeliutahteer tihnettheestpraretsiecnleceanodr/aobrsietsncmeetoafbomlaimtmeaslfiorantheir Smailcmroonseolmlaalteynpzhyimmeusriautm1a)ntdheathi2s)titdhienetrlyopctuospihnanthleocguesnoofmEescohfesreivcehriaal sctorlaiisntsroaifn WP2uvrA.
0. IESTSYSTEM
A. Salmonella typhimurium: The Salmonella/Mammalian-microsome reverse `sumbusttaittiuotnioansss.ayTdheetescttrsaipnosionftSmaultmaotinoenlsl,abtoytphhfirmaumreisuhmifutsaendd/inorthbiassaesspaayirare hoipsetriodni.neWahuxeontrtohpehsse bhiysvtiirdtiuneeo-dfecpoennddietnitonceallllsy(lheitsh-a)larmeuteaxtipoonssedintothtehier theissttiadritincele ahinsdtigdrinoew)nonulnydetrhsoesleeccetlilvsewchoindcihtireovnesrt(mtionhiimsatildimneediinadweiptehndaetnrcaece(haimso+u)natreoafble to form colonies. The trace amount of histidine in the media allows all the plated bfualcltyereixaprteosusnedde.rgTohea hfiesw+creelvledritvainstisonasr,e wrehaidcihlyidsiesscseernntiaabllefoarsmcuoltoangieesneagsatiinosstbethe limited background growthofthe his- cells. By utilizing several different tester strains, bothbasepair substitution mutations and frameshift mutations can be detected. The Ames Test has been shown to be a sensitive, rapid and accurate cihndeimciactaolr oclfatssheesm.utagenic activity of many materials including a wide range of
B. Escherichia coli: The Escherichia coli WP2uvrA reverse mutation assay detects point mutations, specifically base pair substitutions. The Escherichia coli tester strain WP2uvrA used in this assay is a tryptophan auxotroph (rp) by virtue of a conditionally lethal mutation at a site which blocks a step of tryptophan biosynthesis prior to the formationofanthranilic acid. Since the target site for true back mutation is an ochre nonsense mutation, tryptophan-independent revertants (trp) can arise either by a base change at the site of the original
12/98
3of18
01950
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
talRteNrAatgioenneosr (bByrsuuspipcrkeestsialo,n1b9y80s)p.eciWfhicensutphperetsrsyoprtompuhtaant-idoenpseantdaenstecceolnlds s(ittrep-i)nare `ewxipthoasetdratcoetahmeotuesnttarotfictlreyapntodpgharno)wnonulnydtehrosseelceecltlisvewhciocndhitrievoenrst(tmoitnriympatlopmheadnia tihnedempeednidaenaclleo(wtsrpa+ll) tahree palbalteetdboafcotrermicaoltoonuiensd.erTghoeatfreacwecaelmloduinvtisoifontsr,ywpthoipchhanisin desissecnetimaalblfeoramsuctoalgoennieessiasgationbste tfuhlelyliemxiptreedssbeadc.kgTrhoeuntdrpg-r+orwetvehrtoafnttshea1rrep-recaedlills.y m`Wuhtialgeetnhse atnrpdrceevretrasiniomnestaylssteim.r.essoplounbdlsetcohrmoomsatteasl)k,ylfartaimnegsahgiefnttsm,utbaagsee-nasnawloougld not be expected tobedetected by this system.
I. MATERIALS
A. TesterStrains
1. SSaallmmoonneellllaa ttyypphhiimmuurriiuumm:htihsetitdeisnteeraustxroatirnospthosbTeAuSse,dTwiAl1l0b0e,tThAeLS35, and
`TA1537 as described by Ames et al these strains are shown in Table 1.
(1975).
The
specific
genotypes
of
_--
TABLE I. TESTERSTRAINGENOTYPES
Histidine Mutation
__ AdditionalMutations
hisG46 hisC3076 hisD3052 LPS Repair R Factor
TAIS3S TAIS37
fa wrB -
TAL00
TAS ofa wwrB +R
_--_--
tInwoadaddidtiitoinontaolammuuttaattiioonns iwnhithcehheinsthiadnicnee otpheeirronse,nstihteivteisttyetrosstroamien.s contain t`hmeuteangzenyimcescormepsopuonnsdisb.leTfhoer trhfeaswyanltlhemsuitsaotfipoanrrteosfulttsheinlitpheoploolsyssaocfcohnaeriodfe w`baalrlrideerftihcaitefnocrymisnctrheeassuersfpaecremoefabtihleibtaycttoerciearltaceilnlcwlaalsls.esTohfecrheesmuilctailnsg cseulclh oatshtehrowsiesecobnetaeixncilnugdleadrgbeyrainngosrymsatleimnsta(ci.te.ceblelnwzaol(la.)pyrene) that would
12/98
4of 18
01951
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
TDhNeAseecxocinsdimountraetpiaoinr,saysdteleemtiwohnicohf tghreeautvlyrBengheanne,cersestuhletsseinnsiatdievfitiycioefnt tthheesbeiostgreainnes, taolsoofmtehemuttesatgeernsst.raiSnisnccoentthaeinuivnrgBthdiesledteiloentieoxntaelnsdosrtehqruoiurgeh the vitamin biotin for growth. `SwthriaicnhsfTurAt9he8r ainncdreTaAse1s00thealsseonsciotnitvaiityn otfhethRe-sfeacsttorraipnlsatsomisdo,mpeKmMu1ta0g1e,ns. Thahsebmeeecnhsaungisgmesbtytewodhibcehbtyhimsopdliafsymiindg ianncrexeiassteisnsgebnascittievriitayl tDoNmAutaregpeanisr `polymerase complex involved with the mismatch-repair process. `(Taeusxtoertrsotprahiyn)s tToAh9is8tiadnindeTiAn1d5ep3e7ndaernecreev(eprrtoetdotfrroopmhyh)isbtyidfirnaemdesehpiefntdence misutreavgeerntse.d bTyAmLuSt3a5geinssrewvheirtcehdcbayusbeasbeotshubfsrtaimteusthioinftmsuatnadgebnasseand TA100 substitutions. 2. E`asucxhoetrriocphhiaWPco2liu:vtrhAe taesstdeerssctrriabiendbtoybGereuesend wainldlMbuertiheel t(r1y9p7t6o).phan cIonnatdadiintsioanutvoraAmDutNaAtiorenpaiinrthdeeftircyipetnocpyhwahniocphereonnh,antcheesteisttsesresntsriatiinvity to `seonmheanmcuetdamguetnaibcilciotympifotuhnedsu.vrTAhriespadierfiscyisetnecmy awloluolwds ntohermsatlrlaiynatcotsthoow rafeimeorwvaerdtsh.e damaged part of the DNA molecule and accurately repair it
`(Taeusxtoetrrsotprahiyn)WtoP2truyvprtoAphisanreivnedretpeednfdreonmcetr(ypprtootpohtarnopdheyp)ebnydebnacsee. substitution mutagens.
3. Soou fTesr terc Strae ins.
a SreaclemiovneedlldiaretcytplhyifmruormiuDmr:.tBhreutceestAermestsr,aiDnsepianrutsmeeanttCoofvance were Biochemistry, University of California, Berkeley.
1298
Sof 18
01952
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION
4. 5.
12/98
b. rEesccehievreidchfiraocmolTih:eteNsatteriosntarlainCoWlPle2cutivornAofinInudsuestartiaClovBaacntceeriaw,as Torrey Research Station, Scotland (United Kingdom).
Storage oftheTesterStrains
a Frozen Permanent Stocks Forvoezmeinghptercumlatnuernest,satdodciknsgwDilMl bSeOpr(e0p.a0r9emdibmyigroofwciunlgtufrree)sahnd freezing away appropriately vialed aliquots. Frozen permanent stocks of the tester strains will be stored at $-70C.
b. Master Plates aMafsrtoezrenplpaetremsawnielnltbestporcekpaornetdo bmiynsitmraelakaignagreaapcphrtoepsrtieartestlryain from csounptpalienmienngttehdewRi-tfhacetiotrh,earmhpiisctiildliinne)aonrdtbriyopttionph(aann.d fToerststerrasitnrsain `master plates will be stored at 5 + 3C.
PrepoafOvreranigthti Culoturnes
a Inoculation Oinvoecmuilagthetd cbuyltturraenssffeorrriunsgeaincoalllotneysftirnogmprthoeceadpuprreosp,riwaitlel bmeaster pbleatpela1c0aed filnaaskschoankteari/innicnugbcautlotrurwehmicehdiwuimll.beInporcuolgartaedmmfeladsktso wbielglin othpeeroavteironnig(hsthackuilntgu,re1s2a5r=e i2n5lropgmp;haisnceuobratliaotne,l3o7g p+h2aseC)whseonthat turbidity monitoring begins.
b. Harvest iTnocuebnastuiroentwhialtlcbuletdueretseramrienheadrvbeystsepdecitnrloaptheoltoogmepthraisce,motnheitloernigntgh ooff ctuurblideittyuirsbirdeiatyc.heCdualstudreetserwimlilnebde bhyaravepsetrecdenotntcreaanspmrietdteantceerm(i%nTe)d
6of 18
01953
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
cruelatduirnegs ohnavaesrpeeaccthreodphaotdoemnestietry.ofTahtisletaasrtg0e.t5tuXrb1id0itcyelelnssupreersmtlhat
caunldtutrheast mthaeycuelxthuirbeist hdeacvreenaostedovseenrsgirtoiwvint.y tOovseormgeromwunta(gsetnatsi.onary)
Cultures will be removed reached and placed at 5 +
from 3C.
incubation
when
the
target
%T
is
6. ConfoifTrestmerSatratinGienootypnes a. tShaelmfoonlellolwaintgygpehniemtuircimuamr:kteerssteornsttrhaeindcauylotfurtehseiwrilulsbeeicnhtehceked for `mutagenicity assay:
(1) fa Wall Mutation
`dTehmeonpsrtersaetnicoenooffthtehe1fcaulwtaulrlesmusetnastiitoivnitwyiltlobcerycsotanlfivriomleedt.by @ pPKMIO0I Plasmid
`cTuhletuprreessoefncteeostfetrhsterapiKnsMT1A0918palnasdmTiAd1w0il0l bbye confirmed for demonstration of resistance to Ampicillin.
(3) Spontaneous Reversion
`vTehheicnluemcboentrroolfsstphoanttiasncehoaursacrteevreirsttainctosfptehreprleastpeeicntitvhee scturlatiunrse waillolnbgewditehmotnhsetrapaptreodprbiyatpelavteihnigcalleioqunotsesleocftievaec.h medium.
b. fEoslclhoewriincghigaenceotlii:cemsatrekresrtroanintWhePd2auyvorfAitwsilulsebeincthheecmkuetdafgoernitchiety assay:
(1) Spontaneous Reversion
V`TehheicnluemcboentrrooflsstphoanttiasnechoaursacrteevreirsttainctospfeWrPp2luatveriAn
the will
be
12/98
Tof18
01951
COVANTCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
demonstrated by plating aliquots of the appropriate vehicle on selective
each culture medium.
along
with
7. Tester StrainMedia
a Culturing Broth
b`TeheVobgroetlh-Buosnendetrosgarltoswolouvteimoing(hVtogcuelltuarnedsBoofntnheert,es1t9e5r6s)trains will
supplemented powder).
with
2.5%
(w/v)
Oxoid
Nutrient
Broth
#2
(dry
b. Minimal Bottom Agar Plates
BBoontntoemr maiganrim(a2l5 mmledpieurm15E(xV1o0g0elmamndpeBtroinndeisrh,)1w9i5ll6)be Vogelsupplemented with 1.5% (w/v) agar and 0.2% (wiv) glucose. . Top Agar for Selection of Revertants
NTaoCpl(o(vwe/rvl)aya)ndagwairllwiblel sbueppprleepmaernetdewdiwtiht0h.170%malgaorf1()w/0v.)5amndM0.5% rheivsetritdainntes/,bioorti2n)s0o.l5utmioMn pterryp1t0o0phmaInasgoalrutfioornspeelrec1ti0o0nmolf ahigsatridfionre the selection of tryptophan revertants.
f`oWrhethneSo9veirslarye.quiHroewde,v2e.r0,mwohfetnhSe9siuspnpoltemreeqnutierdedt,opwaatgearriiss audsdeedd s0uptphleesmuepnptleedmteonpteadgatro)paangdar2.(50.m5lmoifotfhweadtielrutpeedrs2upmplleomfented top aaggaarriasnudsaemdifnoor tahceidovseurplpalye.meTnhtiscodnicluetnitornateinosnusrersemthaaitntthheefsinaamletop both in the presence and absence of S9 mix.
12/98
.
8of 18
01955
COVANTCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
B. Liver Microsomal Enzyme Reaction Mixture (S9 Mix;
1 5H9omogenate
cLoimvemrermciicarlolsyoamnadl ewinlzlybmeespr(eSp9arheodmforgoemnamtael)ewSilplrabgeupeu-rDcahwalseeyd rats that
have been 500 mg/kg
injected (i.p.) as described
with AroclorTM 1254 by Ames et al, 1975.
(200
mg/ml
in
corn
oil)
at
2. $9Mix.
e`TxhpeerSi9memnitxalwiplrlocbeedpurree.parTehdeiSm9memdiixatweillylpcroinotraitno tithseucsoemipnoanneynts indicated in Table 2.
--_--
TABLE2.S9MIXCOMPONENTS
HO IMNaH,PO/NaHPO, pH7.4 0.25M Glucose-6-phosphate 0.10M NADP 0.825M KCU0.2M MgCl, 9 Homogenate: _--
070m! 010ml 002ml 0.04 ml 0.04mi 210ml 100ml
C. Controls
1. Vehicle Controls
aApnpdraobpsreinactee voefhSi9clmeicxo.ntrVoelhsicwliells cboempplaattiebdlfeorwiatllhstthriasintsesitnstyhseteprmeisnecnlcuede #b6u7t-w6i8l-l5)n,otetbhealniomlit(eCdAtSo:#D6e4i-o1n7-i5z)e,d aHn,d0,didmiemtehtyhyllfsourlmfaomxiiddee ((CCAASS #68-12.2).
12/98
:
90f 18
01956
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
2. PositiveControls
`sTthraeicnosmpbliantaedticoonnscuorfrepnostiltyiwvietchontthreoalsss,aaycatriveatiinodniccaotnedditiinoTnaabnlde t3.ester
_--
Tester TABLE3.POSITIVECONTROLS Conc.
Simin SOMix Positive Control
perPlate
TAS
+
TA
-
TAI00 +
TA100 -
TAIS3S +
TAISIS
TAISY? +
TAIS37 ~
WP2rA +
WP2urA -
benzofalpyrene 2-nitofluorene 2-aminoanthracene sodium azide 2-aminoanthracene sodium azide 2-aminoanthracene ICR-191 2-aminoanthracene 4-nitroquinoline-N-oxide
25ug 10g 25ug 20g 25ug 20g 25g 20g 250g 10g
3. Sterility Controls
a TestAnicle `The most concentrated test article dilution will be checked for sterility by plating an aliquotofthe same volume used in the assay on selective agar.
bo S9Mix `The S9 mix willbe checked for sterilitybyplating 0.5 ml on selective agar.
12/98
:
100f18
01957
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
IV. METHODS A. DRosaengefindiStnudgy b`Tehedegtreorwmtihneidnhiinbiotrodreyretfofeacltl(ocwyttohteosxieclietcyt)ioonfotfheaptperstoparritaictleedtoostehsett0esbtestyesstteemd iwnill the mutagenicity assay.
1. Design
a`TnhdeWdPos2eurvarnAgefbiontdhiinngtshteudpyrewsielnlcbeeapnedrafbosremnecdeuosfinSg9tmesitxe.r sAtramiinsnTimAu1m00 ootfhteernwidsoesedsiroefctteesdt bayrttichlee Swpiolnlsboer,tetshteedteastt oanrteicplleatweilplebredocshee.ckUendlefosrs scoyltuobtiolxiitcyi/tmyisucpibtioliatympaexrimimtus.m Icfontcheenttersattairotnioclfe e5x,h0i0b0itusglipmeirtpeldate if `swolourbkialbiltey/cmoinscciebnitlriattyi,oint waitltlaibneabtleestiendthfeorvceyhtioctloexoifcicthyouicpet.o the maximum
a Rationale
t`eTshteegrrsotrwatihn TinAh1ib0i0toirsygeefnfeerctal(lcyytroetporxeisceinttya)toifvtehoef ttehsatt oarbtsieclrevoedn on
`tThAe1o0t0h'esr cSoamlpmaornaetlilvaeltyyphhiigmhunruimumbetresotferssptornatinasneaonudsbreecvaeurtsaenotsf per
rploauttei,negreaxdpaetriiomnesontfalcyvtaortioaxtiicoint.yTchane bEescrheeardiiclhyidaiscocleimteedstferrostmrain
S`aWlPm2ounverlAladtoyepshniomturpoisusmessstrtaihnesrhfaavwealalnmdutthautsi,oandtihfaftertehnet range of
tceysttotaorxtiicclietyinmtahye pbreeosbesnecreveodf.miAclrsoos,otmhaelceytnoztyomxiecsitmyaiyndvuacreyd by a
`gTrheeartelfyofrer,otmhitshawtooublsderrveeqduiirne tthheatadbisfefnecreenotftemsitcarrotiscolmeadloseenzryamnegse.s
be tested in the mutagenicity assay based absence of the microsomal enzymes.
on
the
presence
or
12/98
11of18
91353
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
2. Evaluation of the Dose Rangefinding Study Cpyetroptloaxtieciatnyd/iosrdebtyecattahbilnenaisnga odrecdriesaaspepeianrtahnecenuofmbteher boafctreerviearltabnatcckoglroonuineds lawn.
3. SelectionoftheMaximumDosefortheMutagenicityAssay a. Cytotoxicity Observed `When cytotoxiciitsy observed in the dose rangefinding study, the `hmiugthaegsetnciocnicteynatsrsaatyiownilolfbteestthaarttwichliecthobgeiveusseaddientetchteasbulebsreeqduuecnttion of revertants per plate and/or a thinning or disappearance of the bacterial background lawn. b. No Cytotoxicity Observed If no cytotoxicity is observed in the dose rangefinding study then the highest dose of test articletobe used in the mutagenicity assay will be the same as that tested in the rangefinding study unless 1) the Sponsor specifies an alternate maximunn dose, 2) there is limited availability of the test article and/or 3) the test article precipitates heavily in the top agar.
B. MutagenicityAssay
I Design `TTAhLe5a3s7s,ayawnidllWPbe2upverrfAo,rmbeodthusiinntghetepsrteersestnrcaeinasnTdAa9b8s,enTcAe1o0f0S,9TmAiLxS.35, Unless the Sponsor specifies doses to be tested, the doses of test article will be selected based on the results of the dose rangefinding study. If cytotoxicity has been demonstrated in the dose rangefinding study, a minimum of six doses of test article will be tested along with the appropriate vehicle and positive controls.Ifno cytotoxicity has been demonstrated, a minimum of five doses will be tested.
12/98
:
120f18
01959
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
2. Frequency and Route of Administration
`iTnhceortpeosrteartisotnraminestwhioldlobleogeyxpoorisgeidnatlolythdeestecsrtiabretdicblyevAimaetsheetplaalte(1975) and M`wairdeonraanngde Aofmcelsas(s1e9s8o3f).chTehmiiscamletmhuotdagoelnosg.y hIansthbeeepnlastehoiwncnortpoodreatteicotna `methodology, the S9 mix (where appropriate), the tester strain, and the test aprltaitcel.eaFroellcoowmibnigniendcuibnamtoilotneanta3g7ar w2hiCchfoirs 5o2ve2rl4aihdr,onrtevoeartmaintnicmolaolniaegsar willbe counted. All doses of test article, vehicle controls and positive: controls will be plated in triplicate.
C. PlatingProcedures
`These procedures will be used in both the dose rangefinding study and the `mutagenicity assay.
Eteasctehrpsltartaeinw,ialcltbiveatliaobnelceodndwiittihoan caonddedwoshei.chTihdeenSti9fimeisxthaendtesdtilaurttiioclnes,otfestthpehtaesset, article will be prepared immediately prior to their use.
When article
S9 mix is dose will
not required, 100 1of tester be added to 2.5 ml of molten
strain and 50 selective top
1] of vehicleortest agar (maintained at
450521Cof)v.ehiWchleenorSt9estmiarxtiicsleredqousierewdi,ll50b0e 1adodfedS9tom2i.x0,m1l0o0f mIoolftetnessteelrescttriavien taonpd
agar. After the required components have been added, the mixture will be
vionrate1x5exd a1n0d0 omvmerlpaeiudrodnitsoh.theAfstuerrfatchee oovfe2r5lamyihoafs msoilniidmifailedb,otthteopmlaatgeasrwciolnltbaeined
inverted and incubated for 52 + 4 hr at 37 + 2C. When necessary, plating
aliquots of other than 50 1 of test article/vehicle will be used. Positive control
articles will be plated using a 50 1 plating aliquot.
D. `ScothrePilantegs
Plates which are not evaluated immediately following the incubation period will be held at = 3C until such time that colony counting and bacterial background lawn evaluation can take place.
12/98
130f18
01960
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
1. BaBcteariac l kgrLaownEuvalnuatd ion `The condition of the bacterial background lawn will be evaluated for evidenceof cytotoxicity and test article precipitate. Evidence of cytotoxicity will be scored relative to the vehicle control and recorded along with the revertant counts for that dose.
2. Counting Revertant Colonies Revertant colonies fora specific tester strain within a given test article: dilution series will be counted either entirely by automated colony counter orentirely by hand (with the exception of the dose rangefinding study). If there is sufficient test article precipitate on the plates at any dose which interferes with automated colony counting, then the plates at all dose levels for that specific strain and activation condition willbe counted `manually.
E. AnalyofsDiatsa
Forall replicate platings, the mean revertantsperplate and the standard deviation will be calculated.
V. EVAL N T Before assay data can be evaluated, the criteria for a valid assay must be met.
A. CriFot rAe Valridi Assaay
`The following criteria will be used to determine a valid assay: 1. Tester Strain Integrity: Salmonella ryphimurium
a fa Wall Mutation To demonstrate the presence of the rfa wall mutation, tester strain cultures must exhibit sensitivity to crystal violet.
12/98
140f 18
01961
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
b. pKMIOI Plasmid `cTuoltduermeosnosftrteastteertshterapirnesseTnAc9e8ofatnhdeTRA-f1a0c0tomrupsltasemxihdi,biptKrMeIsi0s1ta,nce 10 ampicillin.
ec. Characteristic Number of Spontaneous Revertants `To demonstrate the requirement for histidine, the tester strain `rceuvletrutraenstmspuesrtpelxahtiebiwthaecnhaprlaactteedriasltiocngnwuimtbherthoefvsephiocnlteanuenoduesr selective conditions. The acceptable ranges for the mean vehicle controls are as follows:
TA98 TAL00 TAI535 TAIS37
8- 60 60-240 4.45 2.25
2. TesterStrainIntegrity: Escherichia coli
a Characteristic Number of Spontancous Revertants
`cTuoltduermeomnusstrtaetxehitbhietraeqcuhairraecmteenrtisftoirc tnruympbtoeprhaonf,stphoentteasnteeorusstrain revertantsperplate when plated along with the vehicle under s`veelheicctlievecocnotnrdoiltsioinss.5 toTh4e0 arcecveerpttaanbtlseperarnpgleatfeo.r the WP2uvrA mean
3. TesterStrain CultureDensity
`To demonstrate that appropriate numbers of bacteria are plated, the density
of tester strain cultures must
per ml and/or have reacheda
be greater than
target level of
tourrbeiqduiatly
tdoem0o.5nsxtr1a0tebdatctoeria
produce
per ml.
cultures
with
a
density
greater
than
or
equal
to
0.5x
10 bacteria
12/98
15018
041962
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
4. Positive Control Values
a. Positive Control Values in the Absence of 9 Mix
`mTuotdaegmeonn,stthreatmeeathnatvathleueteostfaerpsotsriatiinsvearceonctarpoalbfloeroafriedsepnetcitfiyvieng a vteasltueer ostfrtaihne mveuhsitcleexhciobnittroalt lfeoarstthaat3-sftroalidn.increase over the mean
b. Positive Control Values in the Presence of $9 Mix (9 Mix Integrity)
pTroodmeumtoangsetnrattoeittshmatuttahegeSn9icmifoxirms(csa)p,atbhleemoefamnetvaalbuoeliozfinthgea Spo9simtiixvemcuosnttreoxlhifboirat artelsepaescttiav3e-tfeosltderinsctrraeianseinovtehretphreesmeenacenovfalthuee of the vehicle control for that strain.
sAtnraianccweipltlabbeleevpoasliutaitveedcaosnthraovlining tdheemoprnessternacteedofboSt9h fthoerainstpeegcriiftiyc
ofthe 89 mutagen.
mix
and
the
ability
of
the
tester
strain
to
detect
a
5. Cytotoxicity
A minimumof assay data.
three
non-toxic
dose
levels
will
be
required
to
evaluate
B. CriteriaForAPositiveResponse
a`rOenceevatlhueactreidtearsiaffoolrloawsv:alidassay have been met, responses observed in the assay
1 `Tester StrainsTA98,TA100,and WP2uvrA.
iFnocrreaatseestinartthieclmeetaobnerecvoenrstiadntesrepderpopsliattieveo,fiat mluesatstpornoeduocfethatesleeatsetstaer2-fold strains over the mean revertants per plate of the appropriate vehicle control. This increase in the mean numofrbeveertarnts per plate must be
12098
16018
01953
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION 5
`accompanied article.
by
a
dose
response
to
increasing
concentrations
of
the
test
2. TesterStrains TAIS35 and TALS37
For a test article to be considered positive, it must produce at least a 3-fold increase in the mean revertants per plate of at least one of these tester strainsoverthe mean revertants per plateofthe appropriate vehicle control. This increase in the mean number of reveriants per plate must be `accompanied by a dose response to increasing concentrations of the test article.
VI REPOTRHTERIESNULGTS
A reportofthe resultsofthis study will be prepared by Covance and describe all methods usedforthe generation and analysis of the data.
will
accurately
Results presented in the report for this assay will include:
The results of the dose rangefinding study Gif applicable) including the number of
rtehveeirdteannttistypeorf
plate and abacterial background lawn the bacterial tester strains used in the
evaluation assay
for
each
dose:
dose levels at which the test article was tested
individual calculated
plate mean
counts for all and standard
treated, positive deviation for all
and vehicle control plates replicate plate counts
cvaluationofresults
VIL CHAANNDRG EVIE SIOS NS
.
Any changes or revisions of this approved protocol will be documented, signed by the Study Director, dated, and maintained with this protocol. The Sponsor will be notified of any changes or revisions.
1298
170f18
0196%
COVANCE>
PROTOCOL 409 EDITION
VII. RECORDS TO BE MAINTAINED
All raw data, documentation, records, the protocol, and the final report generated as a
result of this study will be archived in the storage facilities of Covance-Vienna, for at
least one year following submission ofthe final report o the Sponsor. After the one year
period, the Sponsor may elect to have the aforementioned materials retained in the storage
facilities of Covance-Vienna, designated by the Sponsor.
for
an
additional
period
of
time
or
sent
to
a
storage
facility
IX. REFERENCES
Ames, BN., McCann, J. and Yamasaki, E. (1975). Methods for detecting carcinogens and mutagens with the _Salmonella/mammalian-microsome mutagenicity test. Mutation Research 31:347-364.
Brusick, D.J., Simmon, V.F., Rosenkranz, H. S., Ray, V.A., and Stafford, R.S. (1980). An evaluationofthe Escherichia coli WP2 and WP2uvrA reverse mutation assay. Mutation Research, 76:169-190.
Green, M-H.L. and Muriel, W.J. (1976). Mutagen testing using rp" reversion in Escherichia coli. Mutation Research 38:3-32.
Maron, DM. and Ames B. (1983). Revised Methods for the Salmonella Mutagenicity `Test. Mutation Research 113173-215.
Vogel, HJ. and Bonner, D.M. (1956). Acetylomithinase of Escherichia coli: Partial purification and some properties. J. Biol Chem. 218:97-106.
12/98
180f 18
01955