Document omj8kx5opbqEdddVgKyqK249D
M z i G - I D S 0!
Benchmark Doses for Tumors in Sprague Dawley Rats fed N-Ethyl Perfluorooctanesulfonamido Ethanol (N-EtFOSE)
David W. Gaylor, Ph.D. Sciences International, Inc.
January 31, 2002
Introduction
PTrhoeteccatricoinnoAggeennrciysk(1a9s9se9s)smreecnomt gmueidnedlitnheesupsreopoofsaedbebnychthmeaUrk.Sd.oEsnev(iBroMnmD)enatpaplroach for
low dose cancer risk assessment. Unless stipulated otherwise, which the excess lifetime tumor incidence is 10%, denoted by
BthMe DBiMo.DAisvtahleuedoosfe1a0t%
was selected as this is precision from typical
about the lowest incidence that can be chronic bioassays in rodents. Further,
eastliomwaetred95w%ithcoandfeiqduenatcee
limit is calculated for the variation of the bioassay.
bTenhcehBmMarDkLdioosise
(BMDLio) to account for the experimental then used as a point-of-departure for low dose
cancer risk assessment. When a nonlinear dose response curve is expected in the low
dose range, a margin levels is considered. low dose cancer risk
eoOsfttihemxearpwtoiosisuner.,elIibnneeteawirtheeeexrntrctaahpseeoB,latMhtieoDnBLMfirooDamnLdtihoaesneBtriMcviepDsaLatesidoththoeumzpeoarinontei-sxopuf-osesdurfeor
departure.
Bioassay Data
The data used for calculation o f the BMDLio were collected in the 104-Week Dietary
Carcinogenicity Ethanol in Rats.
STtuhdeyBwMitDhLNiasrrcoawlcuRlaatnegdef(o9r8t.h1y%ro)iNd -fEoltlhicyalrPceerlflluaodreonoocmtaanseasunldfonamido
carcinomas combined in males and for hepatocellular adenomas and carcinomas
combined for females. All tumors were adenomas except for one carcinoma in the
30 mg/kg group in males and one carcinoma in the 100 mg/kg females.
In order to calculate lifetime incidence rates for each dose group, it is necessary to calculate the number o f animals at risk. Clearly, animals that were removed from the study for interim sacrifices or that died before the terminal sacrifice were not at risk for a lifetime. The Poly-3 approach developed by the National Toxicology Program (Bailer and Portier, 1988) is used here to calculate the effective number o f animals at risk. Obviously, an animal that survives for the lifetime o f the study until the terminal sacrifice counts as a whole lifetime exposure. Also, any animal that is removed from the study with a tumor o f interest (thyroid follicular cell in males or hepatocellular in females) prior to the terminal sacrifice lived long enough to develop the tumor is counted as a lifetime exposure. All other animals are given a weight of (t/T)3, where t is the week that an animal was removed from the study without the tumor of interest and terminal sacrifices began at
000317
i
week T=105. Relatively little weight is given to an animal removed early in a study. For example, the animals removed at an interim sacrifice halfway through the study at 53 weeks receive a weight o f (53/105)3 = 0.13 o f a lifetime, whereas an animal that died on week 96 receives a weight o f (963/105) = 0.76 o f a lifetime. The weights are summed for each dose group to obtain the effective number o f animals at risk for each group. The number o f male rats with thyroid follicular cell adenomas or carcinomas combined, effective number o f animals at risk, and average serum levels o f PFOS at 14 weeks for each dose group are displayed in Table 1.
Table 1. Results from the 104-week carcinogenicity study in male SD rats fedN-EtFOSE.
Group Dose (ppm)
Serum PFOS at 14 weeks
(ug/ml)
Number of rats with thyroid tumors8
Effective number of rats at risk
1 0 0.078 2 3 6.14 3 30 59.1 4 100 192 8 0 0.039 9 1 2.19
0 3 2 6 1 2
34 35 36 37 34 37
*Thyroid follicular cell adenomas except one carcinoma in Group 3.
000318
2
The number o f female rats with hepatocellular adenomas or carcinomas combined, effective number of animals at risk, and the average serum levels o f PFOS at 14 weeks are shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Results from the 104-week carcinogenicity study in female SD rats fed N-EtFOSE.
Group Dose (ppm)
Serum PFOS at 14 weeks
(ug/ml)
Number of rats with liver tumorsa
Effective number of rats at risk
1 0 0.196 2 3 12.2 3 30 104 4 100 268 8 0 0.126 9 1 3.26
0 1 3 7 2 1
32 32 33 38 33 36
*Hepatocellular adenomas except one carcinoma in Group 4.
Benchmark Dose Calculations
The numbers o f animals with hepatocellular adenoma/carcinoma and the effective number o f animals at risk were entered into the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency benchmark dose software program (BMDS). Estimates ofthe benchmark dose were obtained using the multistage model
P = 1 - exp[-( qo+qid + q2d2+ q3d3 +q4d4)]
where P represents the proportion o f animals with tumors, d is the dietary dose or serum
level, and the q's are estimated from the experimental dose response data.
Goodness-of-fit p-values for the multistage model are above 0.1 indicating an adequate
fit of the model. Small p-values would indicate a statistically significant deviance from
the multistage model. The goodness-of-fit p-values, BMDio, and BMDLio in terms o f
dietary concentration o f N-EtFOSE and 14-week serum levels o f PFOS for males and
females are displayed in Table 3.
,,^
000319
3
Table 3. Goodness-of-fit p-values for the multistage model, BMDio, and BMDLio values obtained using the US EPA benchmark dose software program (BMDS).
Sex p-value BMDio BMDLio
Male Female
Male Female
Dietarv Concentration 0.23 89 ppm 0.99 58 ppm 14-Week Serum Level 0.23 171 ug/ml 0.98 166 ug/ml
40 ppm 32 ppm
77 ug/ml 91 ug/ml
References
Bailer, A. mortality
Jo.natnedstPsofrotriecra,rCci.Jn.oEgeffneicctistyoifntrsemaatmll esnatm-ipnldeusc. eBd
imomorettarliictys
and tumor-induced 44:417-431 (1988).
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Guidelinesfo r Carcinogen Risk Assessment NCEA-F-0644, Risk Assessment Forum, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC. July, 1999.
000320
4