Document mpG5GbGnq1bJyeob8zYbBddzB

4 E 5800 MKW/kmg IL043.ASB 09/05/89 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT STATE OF ILLINOIS IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT COUNTY OF MC LEAN CAROL ANN COOKE and JUDITH ANN O'NEAL, Special CoAdministrators for the Estate of Ben Smith, deceased and CAROL ANN COOKE, Individually, Plaintiffs, vs. ILLINOIS CENTRAL GULF RAILROAD COMPANY, et al., Defendants. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) NO. 88 L 52 DEFENDANT, OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT. OWENS-ILLINOIS. INC. Q. 11. Which, if any, of the carriers listed in your answer to the preceding interrogatory are providing a defense to this suit? A. 11. The Aetna Casualty and Surety Company. Q. 17. List the following information for each claim, not identified in your answer to the preceding interrogatory, brought against defendant by a present or former employee of defendant or the spouse or child of a deceased employee alleging a disease or condition of ill-being caused by asbestos: 1 SEP 8 1989 (a) The name and address of the person alleged to be diseased or in a condition of ill-being; (b) When the alleged disease or condition of ill-being began; (c) The circumstances under which the employee is alleged to have come into contact with asbestos; (d) Whether the person is represented by an attorney, and if so, the name and address of his attorney; (e) The agency where the claim was filed, the docket number of the claim and the date the claim was filed. A. 17. This defendant is a named defendant, along . with other defendants, in pending lawsuits in which about 70,000 plaintiffs or their representatives have sued defendant claiming bodily injury. Also, this defendant has resolved lawsuits involving about 32,000 such plaintiffs. This defendant does not keep records which permit it to sort from such suits, either pending or settled, suits brought by former employees of its asbestos-containing product manufacturing plants. This defendant further states that its asbestoscontaining product manufacturing facilities were in New Jersey in which state the worker's compensation laws bar suits against employers and former employers; it has not received any worker's compensation claims from former employees; it has not operated any such facilities since mid-1958; and did not own or operate contract units that employed insulators to install asbestoscontaining insulation products. In respect of asbestos exposure at this defendant's asbestos-containing product plants, please see the testimony of Willis G. Hazard of February 11, 1981 and March 27, 1981. Q. 18. List the following information for each claim or report, not identified in your answer to the two preceding interrogatories, alleging a disease or condition of ill-being 2 caused by asbestos or an asbestos-containing product sold by defendant: (a) The name and address of the person alleged to be diseased or in a condition of ill-being; (b) When the alleged disease or condition of ill-being began; (c) The circumstances under which the person is alleged to have come into contact with asbestos sold by you; (d) Whether the person is represented by an attorney, and if so, the name and address of his attorney; (e) Whether the claim has resulted in a lawsuit against you, and if so, the court where suit was filed, the docket number of the suit, and the date the suit was filed. A. 18. This defendant is one of a number of defendants in lawsuits involving about 70,000 pending plaintiffs or their representatives claiming bodily injury as a result of exposure to asbestos or asbestos-containing products. Also, this defendant has resolved lawsuits involving about 32,000 such plaintiffs. It has been sued in such lawsuits, pending and resolved, by over 100,000 plaintiffs or their representatives. The complaints in such lawsuits are, while not identical, very similar to each other and similar to the complaint in this case. Complaints in one hundred of the first such suits filed naming this defendant are provided with these responses. Q. 19. List the following information regarding each document (as defined in Supreme Court Rule 201(b)(1)) authorized by an employee of defendant in the course of his employment, dealing in whole or in part with the consequences of exposure to asbestos: (a) Name, title or other means of identification of the document; 3 (b) Name, position at time document authored, and current address, position and employer of each author of the document; (c) Date prepared or published; (d) The name and address of the entity responsible for its publication and/or distribution; (e) If available in typewritten or printed form, the number of pages. A. 19. This defendant states that this interrogatory is vague and finds it not possible to formulate an answer. This defendant has provided in this and other lawsuits, advertising literature about its asbestos-containing products. That literature is attached hereto as Exhibit II to these interrogatories. Without waiving the above objection, to the extent this interrogatory inquires as to asbestos-containing products manufactured or sold by other defendants, this defendant states that it does not have any records from which it can obtain information sufficient to answer this interrogatory, nor can it locate any present employees with knowledge thereof. Insofar as this interrogatory inquires as to asbestos- containing products manufactured by this defendant, this defendant states that it ceased the manufacture, sale and distribution of asbestos-containing products effective April 30, 1958 and has not engaged in any such business since. During May, 1979, various papers and reports were produced by an employee of the Trudeau Institute, Mr. Allan Logie, regarding animal experiments conducted at laboratories at Saranac Lake involving dust collected during the Kaylo manufacturing process. These papers and reports may contain information relating to the substance of this interrogatory. This defendant has not been able to find these papers and reports in its business records or correspondence although it has searched for and continues to search for them. 4 This defendant's counsel obtained copies of some of the papers and reports produced by Mr. Logie. However, these copies constitute only a portion of a larger volume *of papers and reports which this defendant has not copied. This defendant also has reason to believe that plaintiffs' counsel has copies of the documents produced by Mr. Logie. They are available through Winne, Banta, Rizzi, Hetherington & Basralian, 25 E. Salem Street, Hackensack, New Jersey. Other documents possibly relating to this interrogatory may have been produced by Owens- Corning Fiberglas Corporation. Those documents indicate that experiments referred to in the documents produced by Mr. Logie were published in an AMA publication in September, 1955. As with the documents produced by Mr. Logie, the documents produced by Owens-Corning Fiberglas Corporation have not been found as part of this defendant's records. The foregoing documents indicate that during the time in which this defendant engaged in the manufacture, sale and distribution of asbestos-containing products, its products contained a relatively small proportion of asbestos when compared to other asbestos-containing products in use during and prior to the same period of time. It appears that this defendant's employees at its asbestos product manufacturing plants were x- rayed periodically and displayed no asbestos-related chest disease, although in the course of their employment they were exposed to the raw materials of this defendant's products as well as the dust of the finished product. Furthermore, these documents indicate that there were no worker's compensation claims filed by its employees for asbestos-related diseases. It was this defendant's understanding of the state of medical and industrial hygiene knowledge that exposure to asbestos in excessive amounts over a prolonged period of time (years), in the conditions typically experienced in factories, workshops, and possibly mines and mills could lead to the potential hazard of contracting a disease known as asbestosis. 5 However, the state of medical and industrial hygiene knowledge was also to the effect that there was a safe level (threshold limit value) of asbestos to which' a person could be exposed without risk of injury. This defendant was aware of the threshold limit value for asbestos as published by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) in the 1940's and 1950's through publications by the Industrial Hygiene Foundation, ACGIH and from the above referenced "Logie" and "OCF" documents. In addition, it appears that an employee of this defendant subscribed to and received the Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology which contained in January, 1946 an article published by the Navy entitled, "A Health Survey of Pipe Covering Operations in Constructing Naval Vessels," by Fleischer, Viles, Gade and Drinker. This article stated that persons who worked as insulators in shipyards were not exposed and did not work in conditions similar to those experienced in factories, workshops, mines and mills, and were not exposed to levels of asbestos above the recognized safe limits. Therefore, the article concluded that such persons were not engaged in a hazardous occupation. From the foregoing papers, reports and articles, this defendant had no reason to believe that exposure to its asbestoscontaining products would result in a foreseeable risk of harm to users. This defendant reserves the right to supplement this response as discovery and the case warrant. This defendant has reason to believe that plaintiffs' counsel is in possession of a substantial library of asbestos-related literature containing articles that defendant may wish to rely upon. To the extent that this interrogatory seeks the production of documents, such documents, as outlined in this response, have not been found as part of this defendant's records and, to the extent that this defendant is in possession of copies of documents, it possesses copies only of documents collected in 6 preparation for litigation. This defendant objects to producing the same. The documents are available from their proper source. Willis G. Hazard, a former industrial hygienist employed by this defendant, testified on February 11, 1981 and , also on March 27, 1981, concerning these documents. Please see his testimony and the exhibits thereto. These documents have not been found in this defendant's records, and, to the extent that this defendant has copies of them, defendant has only copies of what has been produced by others in litigation. Q. 30. State the following as to the first information defendant or its corporate predecessor(s), received that exposure to asbestos caused disease. (a) The form in which it was received, e.g., orally, in writing; (b) The name and address of the employee or employees who received the information; (c) Briefly describe the information; (d) If the information was received in written form, give the author and the title of the document; (e) The date the information was received. A. 30. This defendant cannot respond further to this interrogatory than it has in its initial response to it. This defendant refers plaintiff to the testimony of Willis G. Hazard, an industrial hygienist employed by this defendant from the mid 1930's until the 1970's. Mr. Hazard testified on February 11, 1981 and on March 27, 1981 concerning his understanding of asbestos threshold limit values and other matters. Please see his depositions and the exhibits thereto which depositions and exhibits defendant will agree are admissible in this lawsuit. Q. 31. Does defendant have information that Ben Smith was told anything about the relationship between asbestos exposure and health? If so, state the following: 7 (a) When he was told; (b) Where he was told; (c) By whom he was told; (d) Who was present at the time; (e) What was said. A. 31. This defendant has found no information that it provided to Ben Smith any such information. As to any information Ben Smith obtained from his union, his employers, other defendants' warnings on containers, the government or any other source, defendant relies on the testimony and discovery in this case. Q. 35. List the name and present address of all persons who have been a director in defendant from 1950 to the present and list the dates during which the person was a director. A. 35. Please refer to Exhibit II. This defendant has no records of present or last known addresses of the persons identified in this exhibit, although defendant's headquarters were in Toledo and its officers could be expected to have lived in Toledo. Q. 36. List the name and current address of each person who has held any of the following offices in defendant from 1950 to the present and also list the office held and the inclusive date during which the office was held: President; Vice-President; Secretary; and Treasurer. A. 36. Please refer to Exhibit II. This defendant has no records of present or last known addresses of the persons identified in this exhibit, although defendant's headquarters were in Toledo and its officers could be expected to have lived in Toledo. 8 Q. 41. During the period from 1951-1973 did defendant have a national, regional, or local sales office whose responsibility included serving the state of Illinois or areas within the State of Illinois? If yes, state the following: (a) Where the sales office was located; (b) The name and current address of the head of that sales office; (c) The name, position title, and last known address of the person whose responsibility it was to cover the area which included Illinois. A. 41. This defendant ceased the manufacture, sale and distribution of asbestos-containing products in 1958. This defendant has not found information in its records sufficient to enable it to answer this interrogatory. Q. 42. During the period from 1951-1973 which of defendant's employees were responsible for marketing defendant's products for the area which included Illinois? As to each individual who held such a position, state the following: (a) His name and last known address; (b) The name of the position he held; (c) The dates during which he held the position; (d) The address of his office during the time he held the position. A. 42. This defendant ceased the manufacture, sale and distribution of asbestos-containing products in 1958. This defendant has not found information in its records sufficient to enable it to answer this interrogatory. 9 AFFIDAVIT STATE OF OHIO COUNTY OF LUCAS ) )SS: ) A. H. SMITH, being duly sworn according to law, deposes and says that he is an Assistant Secretary of Owens-Illinois, Inc., a defendant herein; that as such he is authorized to make an Affidavit on its behalf; and that the facts set forth in the foregoing DEFENDANT, OWENS-ILLINOIS, INC.'S ANSWERS TO SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES, are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information and belief. SWORN TO and subscribed /? H S>~JL A. H. SMITH awaifiT l ttoczTNsiri Notary fcfctlc, Slat* of Ohio My Coanluion Expir* Oct. 15, 199; PROOF OF SERVICE The undersigned certifies that a copy of the foregoing instrument was served upon the attorneys of record of all parties to the above cause by enclosing same in an envelope with postage fully prepaid, and by depositing said envelope in a United States Post Office mail box in Peoria, Illinois, on lift.. 7 __ , 1989, addressed to such attorneys at their business address as disclosed by the pleadings of record herein. HEYL, ROYSTER| VOEl\KER & ALLEN David R. Sinn mEvL. ROYSTER VOElKER a allEn BOfCSS'ONAi. C0*O*A^ON / AT LAW j'Tf too jC'^CSO*< 8*n ButuD'NS PCO'A 'LL.NO'S 6`6G2 <308' 76 0*00 4 E 5800, Carol Ann Cooke, and Judith Ann O'Neal, Special Co-Administrators Estate of Ben Smith, Deceased and Carol Ann Cooke, Individually COOKE - COOKE.E IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE.ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT McLEAN COUNTY, NO. 88 L 52 ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFFS James Walker P.0. Box 3455 Bloomington, IL 61702-3455 ATTORNEYS FOR A & N INSULATION Edward J. Matushek, III HASKELL & PERRIN 200 W. Adams St. - Suite 2600 Chicago, IL 60606 Gregory C. Knapp SAINT & AMBROSE, P.C. 5th Floor - Suite A 200 V. Front St. Bloomington, IL 61701 ATTORNEYS FOR ABEX CORPORATION Robert W. Scott SWAIN, HARTSHORN & SCOTT 1806 Savings Center Tower 411 Hamilton Blvd. Peoria, IL 61602 W.R. GRACE & CO. Bret S. Babcock Reardon, Orr, Dvorak & Babcock 2515 E. Washington St. East Peoria, IL 61611 EAGLE-PICHER Lloyd E. Williams WILLIAMS & MONTGOMERY 20 N. Wacker Dr. - Suite 2100 Chicago, IL 60606 ATTORNEYS FOR RAYMARK and CELOTEX Fred B. Moore LIVINGSTON, BARGER, BRANDT & SCHROEDER 115 W. Jefferson St. - Suite 400 P.0. Box 3457 Bloomington, IL 61702-3457 4 E 5800, Carol Ann Cooke Raymond H. Modesitt PATRICK, WILKINSON, GOELLER & MODESITT 333 Ohio St. P.0. Box 1567 Terre Haute, IN 47808 ATTORNEYS FOR SPRINKMANN SONS CORP., GATKE CORPORATION and EMPIRE ACE James A. Carter HAFELE, THIEMANN & ASSOCIATES 1100 First National Bank Building Peoria, IL 61602 OWENS-CORNING FIBERGLAS Robert L. Martier LUNDBLAD & BAKER 401 S. LaSalle St. Chicago, IL 60605 GARLOCK Edward F. Ruberry Brinton, Bollinger & Ruberry 54 W. Hubbard St. - Suite 500 Chicago, IL 60610 CHESAPEAKE & OHIO RAILWAY COMPANY, ILLINOIS CENTRAL INDUSTRIES, INC. and ILLINOIS CENTRAL RAILROAD COMPANY William R. Gavin Gundlach, Lee, Eggmann, 5000 W. Main St. Box 692 Belleville, IL 62222 Boyle & Roessler ATTORNEYS FOR BRAND INSULATIONS, INC. Corey P. O'Dell KURNIK, CIP0LLA, STEPHENSON, 120 W. Eastman - Suite 302 Arlington Heights, IL 60004 BARASHA AND O'DELL, LTD. Don C. Hammer Hayes, Schneider, Hammer, Miles & Cox 202 N. Center St. P.0. Box 3067 Bloomington, IL 61702 ATTORNEYS FOR FLINTK0TE Francis A. Spina Tressler, Soderstrom, Maloney & Priess 2100 Manchester Road - Suite 950 Wheaton, IL 60187 2 r, jouu, l^arol Ann cooKe ATTORNEYS FOR H.K. PORTER Gary D. Sharp MacArthur, Cheatham & Acker 400 Buhl Bldg. Detroit, MI 48226 ATTORNEYS FOR ARMSTRONG, GAF, KEENE, NATIONAL GYPSUM David R. Sinn Christopher P. Larson Heyl, Royster, Voelker & Allen 600 Jefferson Bank Bldg. 124 S.W. Adams St. Peoria, IL 61602 ATTORNEYS FOR FIBREBOARD, OWENS-ILLINOIS, PITTSBURGH CORNING Robert Filey Schiff, Hardin & Waite 7200 Sears Tower Chicago, IL 60606 3 EXH IBIT 1 O W E N S -IL L IN O IS SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWEKS TO P L A IN T IF F S ` F IR S T INTERROGATORIES SYSTEM NO. WORKER DISEASE DISABLED EXPOSURE COURT CASE NO. P IL E D O-1 CLAIM SYSTEM NO. WOHKER DISEASE DISABLED EXPOSURE COURT CASE NO. F IL E D O-1 CLAIM SYSTEM NO. WORKER DISEASE DISABLED EXPOSURE COURT CASE NO. F IL E D O -I CLAIM SYSTEM NO. WORKER DISEASE DISABLED EXPOSURE COURT CASE NO. F IL E D 0 -1 CLAIM SYSTEM NO. WORKER DISEASE DISABLED EXPOSURE COURT CASE NO. F IL E D O -1 CLAIM EXHIBIT II DIRECTORS R. H. Barnard C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh W. W. Knight J. P. Levis w. E. Levis F. H. McAdoo C. J. Root F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1941 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Terre Haute, Indiana Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis R. H. Barnard President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS R. H. Barnard C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh w. w. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis F. H. McAdoo C. J. Root F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1942 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Terre Haute, Indiana Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis R. H. Barnard President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS R. H. Barnard C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh W. W. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis F. H. McAdoo C. J. Root F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1943 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Miami Beach, Florida Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Terre Haute, Indiana Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis R. H. Barnard President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS R. H. Barnard C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein w. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh w. W. Knight J. P. Levis w. E. Levis F. H. McAdoo C. J. Root F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1944 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Miami Beach, Florida Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Terre Haute, Indiana Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis R. H. Barnard President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh w. w. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis F. H. McAdoo C. J. Root F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1945 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Terre Haute, Indiana Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis C. B. Belknap President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS C. B. Belknap Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh W. W. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis G. N. Maxwell F. H. McAdoo F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1946 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Terre Haute, Indiana New York, New York Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis C. B. Belknap President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS Harold Boeschenstein w. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh W. W. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis Col. Evan E. Kimble F. H. McAdoo F. W. Schwenck C. J. Wilcox 1947 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Vineland, New Jersey New York, New York Cincinnati, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis F. J. Solon President Vice-President DIRECTORS Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin T. C. Edwards G. P. Greenhalgh Evan E. Kimble W. w. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen F. H. McAdoo R. L. Snideman H. S. Wade C. J. Wilcox 1948 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Terre Haute, Indiana Berryville, Virginia Ventnor, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis F. J. Solon President Vice-President DIRECTORS Harold Boeschenstein W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin T. C. Edwards G. P. Greenhalgh H. K. Kimble w. W. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen F. H. McAdoo R. L. Snideman H. S. Wade C. J. Wilcox 1949 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Terre Haute, Indiana Berryville, Virginia Ventnor, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P. Levis F. J. Solon C. R. Megowen H. S. Wade R. L. Snideman President Vice-President Vice-President Vice-President Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin T. C. Edwards G. P. Greenhalgh H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight j. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen F. H. McAdoo R. L. Snideman H. S. Wade C. J. Wilcox 1950 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Terre Haute, Indiana Berryville, Virginia Vineland, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS J. P . Levis C. R . Megowen President Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin T. C. Edwards G. P. Greenhalgh H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen F. H. McAdoo R. L. Snideman H. S. Wade 1951 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Terre Haute, Indiana Berryville, Virginia Vineland, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen F. J. Solon H. S. Wade R. L. Snideman President Vice-President Vice-President Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight j. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen F. H. McAdoo C. S. Root R. L. Snideman H. S. Wade C. J. Wilcox 1952 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Vineland, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. S. Wade R. L. Snideman President Vice-President Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Harry G. P. H. K. W. W. H. C. J. P. W. E. C. R. C. S. R. L. C. J. Boshart E. Collin Greenhalgh Kimble Knight Laughlin Levis Levis Megowen Root Snideman Wilcox 1953 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Ocean City, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin G. P. Greenhalgh H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight H. C. Laughlin J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen J. T. Rohr C. S. Root R. L. Snideman C. J. Wilcox 1954 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Berryville, Virginia Ocean City, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight H. C. Laughlin J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen J. T. Rohr C. S. Root R. L. Snideman C. J. Wilcox 1255 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Ocean City, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS C. G. Bensinger W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin H. K. Kimble W. W. Knight H. C. Laughlin J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen J. T. Rohr C. S. Root R. L. Snideman C. J. Wilcox 1956 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Ocean City, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS C. G. Bensinger W. H. Boshart Harry E. Collin H. K. Kimble Samuel Kipnis W. W. Knight H. C. Laughlin J. P. Levis W. E. Levis C. R. Megowen S. T. Olin J. T. Rohr C. S. Root R. L. Snideman C. J. Wilcox 1957 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Ocean City, New Jersey Jacksonville, Florida Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio East Alton, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President DIRECTORS C. G. W. H. Harry A. J. H. K. W. W. H. C. J. P. w. E. C. R. S. T. J. T. C. S. R. L. C. J. Bensinger Boshart E. Collin Hettinger, Kimble Knight Laughlin Levis Levis Megowen Olin Rohr Root Snideman Wilcox Jr. 1958 Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio New York, New York Ocean City, New Jersey Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio Toledo, Ohio East Alton, Illinois Toledo, Ohio Daytona Beach, Florida Chicago, Illinois Toledo, Ohio OFFICERS C. R. Megowen C. G. Bensinger H. C. Laughlin President Executive Vice-President Executive Vice-President G. S. Babcock - Retired 10/31/72 R. H. Barnard - Deceased 4/12/72 C. B. Belknap - Deceased 11/8/53 C. G. Bensinger - Deceased 3/30/63 Harold Boeschenstein - Resinged 7/5/49 W. H. Boshart - Deceased 11/5/66 O. G. Burch - Retired 3/1/65 H. J. Carr - Retired 1959 W. S. Cole - Not Reelected 4/20/49 H. E. Collin - Deceased 9/\l/72 R. A. Cosh - Retired 8/1/60 H. J. Durholt - Not Reelected 4/18/56 M. A. Eddy - Resigned 1/1/49 T. C. Edwards - Resigned 4/18/51 G. P. Greenhalgh - Deceased 9/6/57 J. L. Gushman - Resigned 3/31/61 P. W. Hancock - Resigned 12/15/66 A. J. Hettinger, Jr. - Deceased 5/20/83 Evan E. Kimble - Deceased 3/15/56 H. K. Kimble - Deceased 9/14/62 Samual Kipnis - Resigned 1/7/57 J. G. King - Deceased 1961 W. W. Knight - Deceased 9/30/68 H. C. Laughlin - Retired 7/1/69 J. P. Levis - Deceased 4/17/73 w. E. Levis - Deceased 11/7/62 Garland Lufkin - Resigned 4/19/50 G. N. Maxwell - Deceased 11/10/46 F. H. McAdoo - Resinged 12/31/51 S. J. McGiveran - Not Reelected 4/21/54 C. G. McLaren - Retired 10/1/69 C. R- Megowen - Deceased 7/21/62 R. H. Mulford - Deceased 2/9/73 J. T. Nesbitt - unknown S. T. Olin - Resigned 2/5/60 S. L. Rairdon - Deceased 10/27/78 J. T. Rohr - Deceased 9/17/67 C. S. Root - Resigned 2/5/64 F. W. Schwenck - Deceased 3/27/47 R. L. Snideman - Deceased 10/29/83 F. J. Solon * Retired January 1959 W. J. Stewart - Retired 4/1/69 A. M. Turner - Resigned 8/1/69 H. S. Wade - Retired 7/31/67 C. J. Wilcox - Deceased 12/27/58 J. H. wright - Not Reelected 4/21/48