Document N6aKvnDJ9g8OXMEbk3Z2qJ7b
To:
Millan Hupp[millan.hupp@gmail.com]; Hupp, Sydney[hupp.sydney@epa.gov]
From: Jackson, Ryan
Sent: Wed 5/3/2017 3:19:04 PM
Subject: FW: Presentation
170503 Pruitt.odf
ATT0G001.txt
Here's something for Pruitt's notebook for tomorrow. Place me in this meeting.
--Original Message-- From: Chris Hessier [mailto:CHessier@ajw-inc.com] Sent: Wednesday, May 3, 2017 9:47 AM To: Jackson, Ryan <jackson.ryan@epa.gov> Subject: Presentation
Ryan, Here is our presentation for tomorrow. Let me know if yo have any questions. Hessier
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005136-00001
A History of Technology Innovation, Economic Growth, and Pollution Reduction
Meeting With: Administrator E. Scott Pruitt, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
|^ ^ CLLAN A!R
17ci\906 Siena Club \. EPA - 6.'22 Piociic.ion
Tf V-f*." CLEAN AIR VKjCl Jk j, companies
MEMBERS
//ADA
CARBON SOLUTIONS
B:W # Babcock Power
-BASF We create chemistry <11)1011) BELCO
^7 CalgonCarbon
CLARIAIMT
DURAG [DURR]
EpcqN
FIB industries
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Great Lakes O
SOLUTIONS^)
3 ED 001523 00005137-00003
IGCiC CLEAN AIR ,0M :'V\N il- c>
MEMBERS
HALDOP TQPSDE 1X1 Hitachi Zosen
CATALYSING YOUR BUSINESS
INOVA
A
ICL Industrial
PRODUCTS
Johnson Mat they Catalysts
Lhoist North America
a
to-Asr g.'on.'P
MET
Marsuiex Environmental Technologies
Mitsubishi
#m HEAVY INDUSTRIES, LTD
atlas i j
,
,, V/
' ""
'
MITSUBISHI HITACHI POWER SYSTEMS
^NALCO
An Ecolab Company
P"* -- SERVOMEX S
SOLWAY
asking mr,fe
rhp-r, str,'
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Thermo Fisher
SCIENTIFIC
Wunderlich-Malec
4 ED 001523 00005137-00004
rry4-ME'MBER'. lCTlCi, PERSPECTIVE
U M' nil lllr*i l*s -n ''.I h:!< 'M^/i 1 1,1
.llll'uvt iliMllt-l rill *\ Oil lllllHllJ.ll
t->
. tlx-processes bothi? controlled'!
'
Since the enactment of the CAAA's, ICAC member companies have been behind the design and deployment of technologies that make improvements in air quality possible.
TECHNOLOGY: where advancements m health, em ironmental 'protei'tuni- -c.-.
Creates Quality Jobs
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Grows the Economy, Reduces Pollution
Global Technology Exports
ED 001523 00005137-00005
' LEMA fr-
CC) MPA NIES
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00006
- jV >. CLEAN AIR
AT
VISION
To be //,'(- independent expert voice of the stationary source air pollution control and monitoring industry
Provide a forum for experts to come to a common understanding of industry challenges and opportunities.
Leverage the collective knowledge and project experience to advance technology
To achieve a balance between air quality and industrial growth by providing
credible
nn
Lncourage policies that are achievable and cost-dlecih o with technology innovation
Treat all stakeholders equally and with respect
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED_001523_00005137-00007
Delivering Clean Air
A 'Ac. ' always works in cooperation with industry; federal, regional, and state governments; and other stakAe tdw s to demonstrate and . pi y n ihnology.
Industry Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) Edison Electric Institute (EEI) Coal Utilization Research Council
Government Environmental Protection Agency Department of Energy State, Local, And Regional Governments
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00008
>*||U
[(/*: CUSTOMERS
--
Our Successes:
Utility & Industrial Emissions Dramatically Decline
ICAC Members' technology innovations have enabled:
Moreencry.v production More economic productivity
Together With:
Dramatically clrunt-r ;iir
Electricity Rates
USA Mexico
UK OECD Japan
0
10
20
30
Electricity Rates
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
US Air Pollution 1980-2013
loo.-,
P.PA O0M)
10
ED_001523_00005137-00010
A JOB-CREATING INDUSTRY
Environmental Standards Drive Job Creation:
Interstate ^suited in:
jbo Jobs
jobs Over 7 years
Engineers; project managers; boilermakers; steelworkers; fabricators; concrete makers; manufacturing of slurry pumps, fans, motors and catalysts; processing of reagents for pollution controls, such as hydrated lime, sodium bicarbonate, and activated carbon.
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
11
ED_001523_00005137-00011
Strong U.S. and Global Markets
US, Industrial Emission Control Market Size
2015
Global Environmental Technologies Goods and Services Market Size 2015
Note: Figures are all in USD and estimates for 2015 Source: http://www.trade.gov/topmarkets/pdf/Environmental_Technologies_Executive_Summary.pdf
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
tMlSiOn l S > n/honmontal tecnnclogies market size
$51,2 billion Value of e/ports from U.S. environmental companies
ED 001523 00005137-00012
' LEMA fr-
CC) MPA NIES
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00013
Innovation Leads to Economic Activity
Government Action Has Spurred Innovation in SOa Control. Technology.
Cost-effective policies have stimulated research collaboration between institutions, which has led to technological development (evident in the growth of patents filed).
Co-Authorships between Institutions
U.S. Patents Filed
Government 11
Profit R&D 8
Utility i 0
120
110
100 90
80
70
60
SO
40 SO
20
10 0
196S 1967 1969 1971 1973 1975 1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 19871989 1991 1993 1995
Year Filed
Sources:
https://www.researchgate.net/figure/9030073_fig6_Figure-7-Evolving-coauthorship-ties-between-organization-types-for-three-time-periods
14
https://www.google.com/search?q"S02+controt+technologies&source-lnmsStbm-isch8<sa`X8<ved`OahUKEwiZz62iy8TTAhVELyYKHVKsBnsQ_AUICygCSbiW"i3668<bih"662#imgrc-WL-V3NXl42n67M
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA- 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00014
Costs of Emissions Control Decrease Over Time with Increased Experience and Improvements
Example: Phase II Federal Acid Rain Program
EE11989 EPA1990
EPRI 1994/95
EPA 1994/95
EPRI1997
Source: http://www.powerlineblog.com/archives/2015/04/a-note-on-coal.php 17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Coal Use vs. 502 Emissions
1,200,000,000
35,000
30,000
25,000
1,000 tons
20,000
15,000
10,000
200,000,000 ;
, 5,000
o :
. .
.0
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
Coal Use (+115%)
-*-S02 Emissions (-58%)
ED 001523 00005137-00015
Success of American Ingenuity
Declining Annual SO, Emissions
This graph shows
.tot*ali emi,ss.ions ,In
Significant Declines in Wet SOz
Three-Year Wet Sulfate Disposition
1989-1991
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
16
ED 001523 00005137-00016
Mercury Control Options from Coal to Stack
GAO
ornrtwraoo#
I'nila'd Nine.-, (.tih>rnim*n! Ar<-onla.hUiiv OffioReport to the Chairman, Subcommittee on Clean Air and Nuclear Safety. Commitlee on environment and Public Works. r.S. Senate
CLEAN AIR ACT
Mercury Control Technologies at Coal-Fired Power Plants Have Achieved Substantial Emissions Reductions
Halogen Additives
Sorbent Injection
I
Re-emissions FGD Process
Additives
Control
<.AO-l-17
Agao
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00017
Collaboration & Innovation Drove Actual Costs Down -90%
COAL-FIRED MERCURY CONTROL
studied by EPRI, EPA, DOE and others since 1990
1990s
MuLtipLe-poLlutant control laboratory & pilot-scale studies
Major issues with Hg measurement at low levels
Early 2000s
Introduction of haLogen-treated activated carbons
Measurement improvements & options expanded
Today
Identification of critical aspects of carbon that drive performance in mercury capture
Measurements still challenging and highmaintenance
Ongoing Development
Solutions tailored for specific circumstances to achieve optimal compliance solutions
2011 Q3 K.'..............
2011 Q4
'
v
2012 Q2
2014 Q4
0
1000
2000
; in SMillion
3000
Mercury control has been used on commercial coal fired power plants since 2007
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00018
' LEMA fr-
CC) MPA NIES
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00019
Substantial APC Advancements:
ICAC Members Pollution Control Technologies, Goods and Services
Mercury Controls NOx Controls VOC Controls
Particulate, S02, HCL Controls
Carbon Monoxide Controls
Consumable Products Emissions Measurement & Monitoring Engineering, Consulting, System Services
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Hg removal, demonstrated at go%+ NOx removal of 95%+ VOC typical destruction of g8%+ for a wide range of applications PM removal of >95% with wide range of technologies SO2 removaLof go+% with DSI, 95%+ with WESP Acid gas control using Dry Sorbent Injection of Alkaline Sorbents
HCl >90% control SO3 > 95% control
Carbon Monoxide ControLs CO control up to 99% DRE (>i,ooo power plants and industrial boiLers) Consumable Products Reagents, Sorbents, Hydrated Lime, Sodium Bicarbonate, Activated Carbon, Trona, Ammonia, Ammonium Sulfate, Urea
20 ED 001523 00005137-00020
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00021
OUR
TECHNOLOGY
S
VOC controls are deployed over a wide range of industries,
capable of up to 99% destruction.
DEPLOYED IN:
Petrochemical Chemical Pharmaceutical Wood Products Painting Coating Electronics Oil & Gas
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
2.2. ED_001523_00005137-00022
S02, Acid Gas and Particulate Controls
Modern
Pulverized Coal Dry FGD Power Plant Scrubber (SOi)
Fabric Filter Baghouse (Ash)
Stack
Selective Catalytic Reduction (N0X)
'Mil
Wet FGD Scrubber (SO?)
E/ecfmsfaf/c Precipitator (Ash) Additional Systems - Drv sorbent injection (DSIJ for Hg/503
" Boiler denning and auxiliaries
" Operation and maintenance
DSI/ACI with Fabric Filter
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00023
Emissions, Measurement, and Monitoring
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00024
' LEMA fr-
CC) MPA NIES
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00025
Continuous Innovation
^ Burner
Improved efficiencies Innovative materials Significant OPEX and CAPEX reductions
tinier moosi
8 .........:
Rotary Diverter Valve linletL^Y g.
A
te-A- "
Draft Fan " #
, wig Rotary Diverter
/'jr Valve {Outlet)
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00026
IMPROVING POWER PLANT EFFICIENCY
to Reduce Emissions of All Kinds
Wasted energy
t 60-70s, "
Useful electricity 30-40'
Most vo;ii piuni-; in the l Tnted Stale', were built before
U.S. utility-scale electric generating capacity by initial operating year (as of Dec 2016) gigawatts
" ..... .
50
:;;: .;y.
40
1 25% of iota! capacity average age 39 yeai
30
20
10
1930 and 1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
Rotating Soot Blower
2.7 ED 001523 00005137-00027
Commercial-Scale Clean Coal & Enhanced Oil Recovery Projects
WA Parish
Electrical Generating
Station
90% COz-free processed flue gas
CO? -Oil Separator
World s Laigest Coalmine-Mouth Methane Captuie Project
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
28 ED 001523 00005137-00028
' LEMA fr-
CC) MPA NIES
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00029
icric Ready To Be An indispensable
da:
- To The EPA & Industry
Technology Has No Agenda, iCAC Members Make It Happen,
These technologies have jobs and promoted ecor
i caliber c
Air pollution control technologies enable continuous progress toward:
Lower COST:
High Caliber 1
Greater Certainty for COMPLIANCE
EPA can help further the progress industry has made by providing certainty, a requisite for long-term investment in global leading technologies.
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
ED 001523 00005137-00030
A Presentation by
jte of Clean Air Comoanies
2,22 c:
www.icac.com
2200 Wilson BLvc! Suite 310 Arlington VA ;;
17cv1906 Sierra Club v. EPA - 6/22 Production
02-478-6188
ED 001523 00005137-00031
