Document KRjRGoLVrrebL73DLdqMG97nr

! o CO CO oo C ! 2 -"4 C o m e r s ' r esea r ch^ Dr . Bober t A. Keboe Uni Ter sl t y of Ci nci nnat i Dept , of Pr event i ve Medi ci ne & I ndust r i al Heal t h. The Ket t er i ng Labor at or y Eden Avenue Ci nci nnat i 19, Ohi o /In education al, non-profit organ ization providin g un biased inform ation an d counsel to ultim ate con sum ers on the goods an d serv ices w hich they buy. UiRSHinCTOIUEUi JERSEY December 14, 1960 Dear Dr . Keboe: We ar e sendi ng you wi t h t hi s l et t er a copy of t he Januai y 1961 Consumer Bul l et i n whi ch car r i es on page 9, an emendat i on t o our ar t i cl e on di nner war e. The i t em i t sel f i s a br i ef one, and we t r i ed i n t he smal l space avai l abl e t o br i ng t he per t i nent poi nt s on t he mat t er t o t he at t ent i on of our r eader s. Thi s i s a br i ef ment i on, i ndeed, i n vi ew of t he mat er i al whi ch you sent us, but we pl an t o r et ur n t o t he subj ect agai n i n a f ut ur e i ssue of Consumer Bul l et i n. Ver y t r ul y your s, c ,, EA:NB Enc, Er ma A. Hi nei : \ \ \. O5 C\ BULLETIN The original consumer testing magazine THREE BRAND NEW COMPACTS Silver polishes, and prevention ol tarnish ELECTRIC HAIR DRYERS TESTED S p ark p lu g s--se le c tin g th e rig h t ty p e is im portant, hut not easy ELECTRIC HEATING FOR THE HOME Color p rin ts from K odacolor a n d Agfacolor film s Contact lenses, bifocal type N9701.01 inoperative plugs, your car certainly won't run, except perhaps downhill. But even though both plugs and gas and a good many other specific parts and supplies are essen tial to make cars go at all, it does not follow, as some advertisers seem to hope car owners will believe, that selection of the right brand of one or two of these products will cure all the ills of a gasoline engine. You should, of course, have properly selected plugs in your car. But the most important benefit from exercising the proper choice is that the plugs themselves will last longer. "H ot" and "cold" plugs For almost any car, there are various spark plugs that will fit physically into the engine, that is, plugs which have the right threads and thread lengths, and do not project far enough into the cylinder to interfere with motion of the piston. The most important difference among those plugs which.will fit is in the property called " heat range." Spark plugs get pretty hot when in use and this is desirable because the high temperature tends to " burn off" deposits which would other wise accumulate and cause fouling. On the other hand, if the plug becomes too hot, the materials of which it is made will be adversely affected and the plug's life greatly shortened. Also, if the plug's temperature becomes sufficiently high, a condition known as preignition may occur; the plug remains so hot as to ignite the gas-air mixture in the cylinder before the spark is fired. This means that: the explosion occurs too early in the engine's cycle, which greatly reduces efficiency and may cause serious damage to the engine under some circumstances. It may even cause an engine to continue running after the ignition has been shut off, a condition which could cause a serious accident. A seem ingly backward rule To avoid both excessive fouling and preignition, you should use a plug of the right heat range for your car and for the type of driving you do. The first type to try is naturally the plug recommended by the car maker, or an equivalent type made by any of the reputable automobile spark plug manu- F ig u re 1-- H e a t paths in d iffe re n t plugs. W h e n th e h e a t path (shown by th e heavy black lines and arrows) fro m th e center electrode to th e c y lin d e r head is lo ng, th e plug w ill ru n h o tte r. W hen th e path is short, th e heat can escape m ore readily and th e plug runs cooler. facturers. Garages and automotive parts stores have charts which show the plugs recommended for various cars. However, for any one or several of a variety of reasons, the heat range originally specified for the plugs in a particular car may not continue to be the best. In deciding what change to make, if any, you run into what seems to us best described (as an aid to memory) as the " backward rule"-- For hot engines, use what are called cold plugs. For "cool" engines, use hot plugs. Provision of plugs with different " heat ranges" is a technique for making all plugs run within the same range of temperatures, from about 900 to 1700 degrees Fahrenheit. A " hot" plug is one which tends to get hot; a " cold" plug tends to stay cooler. Thus if an engine runs relatively cool, you put in a plug designed to get hot (a socalled " hot plug") so that the tip of the plug will operate at a suitably high temperature. If the engine runs hot, you should use a " cold" plug, one designed to aid in the dissipation of heat so as to keep its own tip cooler. Hence the backward rule: a hot plug for an engine that tends to run relatively cool, and vice versa. The sketches in Figure 1 show differences in plug design which make a plug tend to retain or dissipate heat, and determine its heat range designation. Changing the heat range An experienced mechanic can tell a good deal by looking at a set of used spark plugs. If there is a {Continued on page 31) 2 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 0008330 mi ni mum of f at --pr ovi di ng 990 cal or i es a day--a f r act i on of t he usual cal or i e i nt ake, t hat enabl es t he user who can st i ck t o i t t o l ose hal f a pound a day. Doct or s, i t i s sai d, bel i eve t he pr oduct i s saf e f or t he aver age per son t o use and, i f t aken f ai t hf ul l y, i t shoul d r esul t i n r educ t i on of wei ght . Whet her i t i s a sound t echni que i s anot her mat t er . Sev er al doct or s have poi nt ed out t hat when t he wei ght i s down t o t he desi r ed f i gur e and t he di et er r et ur ns t o f or mer eat i ng habi t s, as many do, hi s wei ght wi l l go r i ght back up agai n, wi t h undesi r abl e ef f ect s on heal t h. Bet t er i s t he t echni que of adopt i ng new eat i ng habi t s t hat keep t he cal or i e i nt ake down, r e- educat i ng t he appet i t e so t hat i t wi l l be sat i sf i ed wi t h l ess f ood on a cont i nui ng basi s. *** REGULAR- GRADE GASOLI NE i s i ncr easi ngl y popul ar wi t h U. S. mot or i st s. A st udy by t he DuPont Co. , based on 4500 per sonal i nt er vi ews, i ndi cat ed t hat 58 per cent of t he per sons quer i ed r epor t ed buyi ng r egul ar - gr ade gasol i ne, as compar ed wi t h 50 per cent who di d so i n 1956. Fi l l i ng t he t ank wi t h " r egul ar " i s a good way t o save money, and many engi nes don' t need hi gh t est gasol i ne. Ther e i s no advant age i n usi ng i t when an engi ne does not act ual l y r equi r e i t . *** THE TOBACCO I NDUSTRY, whi ch has been t r yi ng t o f i ght of f char ges of mi sl eadi ng adver t i si ng and st udi es i ndi cat i ng t hat smoki ng i s a cause of l ung cancer , now has a new pr obl em on i t s hands. Accor di ng t o The Wal l St r eet Jour nal , ci gar et t e maker s ar e havi ng t r oubl e wi t h t obacco spr ayed wi t h a new agr i cul t ur al chemi cal MH- 30, a symbol f or mal ei c hydr azi de. Thi s chemi cal i s used by f ar mer s t o hal t t he gr owt h of sucker s on t obacco pl ant s t hat sap wei ght f r om t he bi g l eaves. Spr ayi ng el i mi nat es t he suck er s mor e compl et el y t han t he use of manual l abor t o do t he j ob, and cost s l ess. Tobacco compani es compl ai n t hat t he use of t hi s chemi cal r esul t s i n t obacco t hat i s def i ci ent i n ar oma and i n especi al l y dense l eaves t hat hol d excessi ve moi st ur e. For ei gn t obacco buyer s t hr eat en t o sl ash t hei r pur chases of Amer i can t obacco on t he gr ounds t hat t r eat ment wi t h MH- 30 pr oduc es soggy, sof t , badl y- f i l l ed, l oose- ended ci gar et t es. Tobacco compani es ar e st eppi ng up t he f l avor of t hei r pr oduct s by addi ng l i cor i ce, chocol at e, and essence of ger ani um t o gi ve a pl easi ng f l avor t o t he smoke. *** LABELS ARE CERTAI NLY CONFUSI NG t hese days. One of our subscr i ber s sent i n t hr ee t hat appear ed on a j acket t hat she pur chased. One r ead i n par t " Gal ey & Lor d' s Tar poon, Wash and Wear , Guar ant eed Fast Col or , Wat er Repel l ent , Guar ant eed Shr unk. " On t he same gar ment was anot her l abel r ead i ng i n par t " Shar pees, wat er r epel l ent , uncondi t i onal l y guar ant eed, dr y cl ean onl y. " The t hi r d l abel r ead " Shel l cot t on l i ni ng, Rayon & Acet at e i nt er l i ni ng, 70% r epr ocessed wool , 30% manmade f i br e. Or nament at i on 100% Or i on. Cuf f s Cot t on. " Per pl exed by t he cont r adi ct i on, she wr ot e t he manu f act ur er of t he gar ment who r epl i ed t hat t he " wash and wear " l abel appl i ed t o t he out er shel l of t he gar ment , whi l e t he ot her l abel r ef er r ed t o t he i nt er l i ni ng of t he gar ment , whi ch shoul d be dr y cl eaned. What can be done t o cl ean up such cont r adi ct i on and conf usi on i n gar ment l abel s? We al r eady have a l aw and t he Feder al Tr ade Commi ssi on t o enf or ce i t ! CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 3 SMOG on t he West Coast and i n ot her par t s of t he count r y may be r e duced t o some ext ent i n t he not t oo di st ant f ut ur e. Cal i f or ni a has passed a l aw r equi r i ng ever y new car r egi st er ed i n t he St at e t o be equi pped wi t h an ant i - smog devi ce wi t hi n a year af t er t he new Mot or Vehi cl e Pol l ut i on Cont r ol Boar d appr oves at l east t wo sui t abl e devi ces. Wi t hi n t hr ee year s, i t i s expect ed t hat al l car s and t r ucks i n t he St at e wi l l be equi pped wi t h such devi ces. The 1961 Lar k f or Cal i f or ni a del i ver y al r eady i ncl udes an ant i - smog devi ce. Ther e i s some debat e as t o j ust what smog i s, but t her e i s gener al agr eement t hat t he Cal i f or ni a var i et y i s caused by unbur ned gasol i ne or hydr ocar bons and ni t r ogen oxi des t hat st i ng t he eyes, poi son t he l ungs, and bl i ght l eaf y pl ant s. * * * THE USE OF X- RAY FLUOROSCOPES f or shoe- f i t t i ng pur poses shoul d be pr o hi bi t ed or at l east st r i ct l y r egul at ed. That r ecommendat i on comes f r om t he Publ i c Heal t h Ser vi ce, whi ch r epor t s t hat some 32 st at es and t he Di st r i ct of Col umbi a have t aken act i on t o pr ohi bi t or cont r ol such devi ces wi t hi n t he past t hr ee year s. The f l uor oscope, when used i n shoe- f i t t i ng machi nes, subj ect s cust omer s, and shoe sal esmen as wel l , t o pot ent i al l y har mf ul r adi at i on. *** WHAT I S A MANUFACTURER' S WARRANTY? Ther e i s no gener al agr eement on a pr oper def i ni t i on, and t her e i s a wi de var i at i on i n meani ng. One t r ade j our nal l ament s t he f act t hat a war r ant y has come t o mean a yar dst i ck f or qual i t y, and ur ges manuf act ur er s t o def i ne t he t er m cl ear l y and i n det ai l when an appl i ance i s i nst al l ed. I t suggest s t hat " war r ant y" and " guar ant ee" shoul d not be used i nt er changeabl y f or , mor e of t en t han not , cust omer s as sume a guar ant ee t o mean r epl acement wi t h a new appl i ance or 100 per cent r ef und i f anyt hi ng ser i ous goes wr ong. Hi gh on t he l i st of Bet t er Busi ness Bur eau compl ai nt s i s t hat guar ant ees or cont r act s ar e not f ul f i l l ed. Con sumer s shoul d make cer t ai n j ust what t he war r ant y or guar ant ee cover s when pur chasi ng a car , t el evi si on set , or househol d appl i ance. *** ' POTATOES ar e st i l l a popul ar f ood i n spi t e of al l t he t al k about r e duci ng. I t seems t hat t hey ar e bei ng pr ocessed i nt o f r ozen or dehydr at ed pr oduct s i n consi der abl e quant i t y. I ndeed, many pot at o f i r ms ar e pl anni ng expansi on i n vi ew of t he f act t hat mor e t han 12 mi l l i on 100- pound sacks of I daho pot at oes wer e pr ocessed l ast year i nt o pr oduct s such as f r ozen Fr ench f r i es, pat t i es, and hash- br owns, or dehydr at ed mashed pot at oes. * -X- * " TOURI ST TRAPS" al ong t he New Yor k t o Fl or i da r out e ar e r epor t ed t o be especi al l y numer ous i n Geor gi a. The i r r i t at i on of t our i st s wi t h t he cur r ent at t i t ude of Geor gi a l aw enf or cement of f i cer s i s so ser i ous t hat one busi ness gr oup has ur ged a r evampi ng of l egi sl at i on i n Geor gi a. At pr es ent , many Geor gi a sher i f f s dr aw no sal ar i es and ar e dependent f or suppor t upon a per cent age of t he f i nes t hey l evy. Legi sl at i on i s al so advocat ed t o r equi r e al l of f i cer s pat r ol l i ng hi ghways i n Geor gi a t o wear uni f or ms and use mar ked car s. Unt i l such t i me as condi t i ons i mpr ove, t our i st s t r avel i ng t hr ough t he St at e shoul d exer ci se gr eat caut i on and car r y suf f i ci ent money f or f i nes and bonds t hat may be r equi r ed. {The conlinualion of Otis section is on page 37) 4 CONSUMER BULLET.N JANUARY 1961 ^ 0008392 institution. It is organized and operates as a scientific, technical, and educational service for consumers. The organization has no support from business or industry. Its funds come solely from the ultim ate consumers who read Consumer Bulletin. Scientific and technical staff, editors, and associates: F . J. Schlink, R. Joyce, D . C. Aten, M . C. Phillips, Erm a A. Hinek, F. X. Hinek, Donald M . Berk, and A. R. Greenleaf. Editorial Assistants: M a ry F. Roberts, B. Beam, and Ellen J. Snyder. Business Manager: C. D. Cornish. Consumer Bulletin is issued monthly by Consumers' Research, Inc., at Washing ton, N . J. Copyright, 1960, by Consumers'' Research, Inc., Washington, N. J.; all rights reserved. Subscription price (12 issues), $5 per year, U.S.A . (Canada and foreign, $5.20). For libraries, schools, and colleges, a special subscription of nine monthly Bulletins (October-June, inclusive) is available a t $3; Canada and foreign, $3.20. For a change o f address, give your old address as well as your new one, includ ing postal zone num ber. Allow five weeks for the change to become effective. Responsibility for at! specific state ments of fact or opinion a t any time made by Consumers' Research lies wholly with the technical director and staff of the organization. Note: Consumers' Research does not" perm it the use of any of the material in its Bulletin for any sales promotion, publicity, advertising, or other com mercial purposes. Application for per mission to reprint for other purposes should be made by le tte r to Consumers' Research, Washington, N J . Listings usually are arranged in alpha betical order by brand name (not in order of m erit) under each quality or perform ance rating. A numeral 1, 2, or 3 a t the end of a listing indicates relative price, 1 being low, 3 high. W here the 1, 2 , 3 price ratings are given, brands in the 1, or least expensive group, are listed alpha- 1 oetically, followed by brands in price group 2, also in alphabetical order, etc. A quality judgm ent is wholly independent o f price. This publication is authorized to be mailed a t the special rates of postage pre scribed by Sec. 132.122, Postal M anual. Entered as second-class m atter, Novem ber 9, 1934, a t the Post Office a t Wash ington, N J., under the Act of March 3, 1879; additional entry a t Easton, Pa. Printed in U.S.A. VOL. 44, NO. i CONTENTS JANUARY 1961 Spark plugs-- some things one needs to know about them................. Selecting the right type is important, but may not be easy. Consumers' Research advises against buying high-priced ''special" kinds of plugs, or the w idely advertised devices that are really spark plugs, but called something else by their promoters 2 Silver polishes, old and new, and prevention of tarnish...................... O ld reliable products are still available-- and there are new ones that show great promise. O n e quite new and different kind of polish was outstanding in CR's tests 6 Three 1961 compact cars Buick Special...................................... . 10 Dodge Lancer.......................................................................................... 11 Rambler A m erican ............. ................................................................... 12 Bifocals in contact lenses............................................................................... 14 Electric hair dryers........................................................................................... Consumers' Research reports on tests of 1 0 new hair dryers for home use 16 Food-- soil characteristics affect its quality and wholesomeness----- Government officials claim that soils do not influence food quality. Read this article by Professor W illiam A . Albrecht to learn the facts 20 Recent reprints from Consumer B ulletin..................................................... 23 Electric heating for the hom e....................................................................... Some of the more important points involved in the installation and use of electric heat. Certain practices should be followed in construction of the house to bring costs of heating with electricity down to reasonable figures 24 Color prints, and the negative color films used in making them........ 3 9 FEATURES The Consumers' Observation Post. ............................................................ 3 O ff the editor's chest-- Do you like the new movies?........................ 33 W alter F. Grueninger's selection and interesting evaluation of current phonograph records................................................................. 34 Ratings of Current M o tio n Pictures............................................................ 35 -fc'F 0008393 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 Old reliable products are still available--and there are some new ones. O ne new a n d d ifferen t k in d o f p o lis h sto o d o u t in C R 's tests. It has often been said by men that women will pay a premium price for something made of silver and thereafter complain regularly that too much work and time are required to keep it shining. There is another drawback of silver, one that can be quite annoying; serving dishes and bowls of metal often get too hot to handle comfortably, because metal conducts heat well. But to the lady of the house silver has traditional dignity and worth, and is beautiful--that is, of course, when it is kept well polished. Polishing silver pieces, while easy enough to do, is a time-consuming chore in many homes. Even though the best of today's polishes do a fine job of removing tarnish and shining silver, the work must be done again every few weeks if the silver is to gleam and sparkle. Many housewives will be glad to learn that this will not be necessary in the future, since there is now a product on the market that will solve, at least to a considerable degree, the problem of early tarnishing. "This is exciting," exclaimed one woman--as she polished her silver pieces--when told that she would not have to polish those pieces again for several months or possibly a year. The product that prompted this exclamation was Tarn-I-Shield, a new and different type of silver cleaner, which cleans and polishes well and at the same time protects the silver from tarnish for relatively long periods. The maker of this new product, however, does not recommend it for use on silver surfaces that will come into contact with food. This means that tableware, the inte rior of cream pitchers, vegetable dishes, and the like should not be cleaned with this material. However, for articles of silver that are used for display and as ornaments, such as candlesticks, the backs of trays or outsides of bowls, including cream pitchers and sugar bowls, Tarn-I-Shield will be a welcome addition to the household's shelf of polishing supplies. Tiffany and Company (Fifth Ave., N.Y.C.) have a new process that is said to keep silver from tarnishing indefinitely. The process involves depositing a thin, transparent layer of material on the silver. According to Tiffany and Company, who use the new method to treat silver pieces they sell, it will not peel or chip with age and it does not change the appearance of the silver, providing the silver is not scratched. The process adds 10 percent to the purchase price. Som e m etal polishes not safe for silver There are a number of useful and effective polishes sold for cleaning and polishing silver, but there are also others that should not be used on a metal as soft as silver. Such a product may often be identified by the manufacturer's recom mendation that it may be used for polishing all metals. If this claim is made, it is best to avoid using the polish on silver articles. (If the abrasive is suitable for the harder metals, such as stainless steel or nickel, it is likely to be too harsh for silver and will scratch it, perhaps in a very noticeable way. And, of course, if the abrasive is mild enough for silver, it will be relatively ineffective for polishing the harder metals.) Even more unsuitable for cleaning or polishing silver pieces is scouring powder--no matter what claims are made for its mildness of action--which some women have used for cleaning and polishing silver pieces. Then they wonder why surfaces have such a dull, m att or scratched appearance. Even the mildest of scouring powders will cause marked scratching, and when used on plated ware can remove the thin layer of silver plate and ex pose the base metal in a relatively short time. The photograph reproduced on page 7 will give some idea of the effect use of a scouring powder will have on your silver. Silver polishes differ in their method of appli cation; some require the use of dampened cloths or sponges with water to rinse off the polish; others are applied, allowed to dry, and simply wiped off with a dry cloth. This sometimes leaves a dust or powder that is unpleasant. Methods 6 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 0008394 Besides the pastes and liquid polishes, there are polishing cloths and mitts. These cloths or mitts Exam ple of degree of protection afforded to silver by some polishes generally contain an abrasive; some may contain a solvent also. While some cloths are suitable for removing relatively heavy coats of tarnish, with d u ring exposure of spoons to tarn ish-prod ucing gas. Before th e spoons were exposed to th e gas, th e y were rubbed w ith various polishes. T h e spoon on th e le ft had been polished w ith T a r n - IS hield, w h ich gave good protection against ta rn is h in g . Spoons a fair amount of rubbing, they are expensive when have been outlined to show more clearly against th e background. their short life is considered, and their best use will be found in occasional wiping and touching grocery stores and supermarkets. The solutions up of pieces that are only slightly tarnished. are acidic and contain the chemical thiourea. Polishing cloths or mitts are not fully suitable Thiourea is a potent poison, and should not be for polishing irregular surfaces, or surfaces with used on surfaces that are likely to come into con raised or incised or engraved designs. A cloth is tact with food. Besides, in the process of using a relatively ineffective for getting into recessed thiourea dip, hydrogen sulfide gas is given off, places or around ornamental edging. On the and this is so poisonous that it could be harmful other hand, with conventional polishes, one can if the dip-cleaner is used in a small and poorly clean recessed areas by use of a brush to carry ventilated room. The chemical-dip method should the cleaner or polish into the parts that would not be used for articles with ornamental French otherwise be hard to reach. gray or black antiquing. There are two other methods one can use for The second method is also chemical. It re I removing tarnish from silver, but neither of these gives a polishing action, and hence either method moves tarnish by electrolysis, that is, by bringing together a piece of a certain metal, usually alumi will leave the silver without a shine. num or magnesium, and the silver in a solution The first of these methods removes tarnish of a salt. In this process, the silver and the other chemically, simply by dipping the item to be metal act as poles of a battery producing a flow cleaned into, or sponging it with, a solution that of electric current that carries away the tarnish reacts chemically with the tarnish coating. Solu from the surface of the silverware. One satisfac '3'-?I tions of this type, commonly known as silverbrighteners or dip-type silver cleaners, were once tory way of applying this principle is to dissolve trisodium phosphate in water, one tablespoon for very popular and widely advertised. Their popu each gallon of hot water used. The pieces to be larity has waned, but they can still be bought in de-tarnished are placed in the hot solution and :: in contact with a piece of bright aluminum until i` the tarnish has been removed; the pieces are then rinsed thoroughly. Pieces with ornamental French gray or black antiquing should not be cleaned by this method. The method is not recommended for articles that are weighted or held together by filler or cement, since, with a hot solution, this ' -~v may be melted or softened. Tarnish preventive. Sterling silver or silver- 1 plated tableware can be protected from tarnish for considerable periods if wrapped in a specially- treated cloth, often called a silver cloth. One well-known brand is Pacific Silver Cloth which can often be purchased at jewelers, department stores, and mail-order houses. It is available by the yard or in bags, rolls, or wraps. It sells at about $2.50 per yard. In the listings, mention is made of those prod Scratches In above serving dish were caused by polishing w ith a scouring powder, m uch too harsh fo r silver. ucts for which the directions call for the use of water. The absence of such a comment indicates .S m K t- 00 oO-oo-.On CONSUMER B ULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 .. . .- . 7 on pieces which are likely to come into contact with food. *** Bonnie Bzite (Bonnie Brite Products Corp., N.Y.C.) 49c for S-oz. can. Cadie Cloth (Cadie Chemical Products, Inc., New York 27) 49c for 15 in. x 17 in. cloth impregnated with an abrasive. - Electro Silicon (Electro Silicon Sales Co., Brooklyn 15. N.Y.) 80c for 16-oz. jar. Use of a damp cloth and rinsing are required. use. Gold Seal Glass Wax (Gold Seal Co., Bismark, N. Dak.) 29c for 6-oz. can. Gorham Cream (The Gorham Co., Providence 7, R.I.) 27c for 8-oz. jar. Wetting and rinsing are required. Gorham Liquid (The Gorham Co.) 49c for 12-oz. can. ' Hagerty Foam (W. J. Hagerty & Sons, South Bend 16, Ind.) $3.95 for 32-oz. jar. Use of a damp cloth and rinsing are required. Brand Baker's Instantaneous Bonnie Brite Brite Silver Cadie Electro Silicon Ellanar Fabul-X Allmetal Gleamit Goddard's Goddard's Goddard's Gold Seal Glass Wax Gorham Gorham Hagerty Foam International JNT Noxon . Shino Silcreme Silbrite Silva Silverfleece Sterling Brite Tarn-I-Shield Wright's Type of polish: liquid, cream , etc. Paste Liquid Liquid Cloth Paste Liquid Spray foam Mitts Cloth Liquid Powder Liquid Liquid Paste Paste Liquid Liquid Liquid Cloth Liquid Cloth Cotton Liquid Spray liquid Paste Speed in rem oving tarnish j Fast Average Fast Average Average Average Fast Slow Average Average Average Average Average Average Average Average Average Fast Slow Average Average Fast Fast Average Average Brightness of shine Low Bright Bright Bright Bright Bright Low Bright Bright Bright Bright Bright Bright Medium Bright Bright . Medium Low Bright Bright Bright Medium Bright Bright Medium Relative protection against tarn ishin g Some Some Some Some None None None Some Some Some None Some Some None None Some Some Some None Some Some Some Some Good None ' 4 X 8 CONSUMER BULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 k 'P ^ 0 0 0 8 3 9 6 Silverfleece (Earl Products Co., Chappaqua, N.Y.) SI.59 for 5 in. x 9 in. cotton impregnated with an abra sive and a .solvent. Sterling Brite (Copper Brite Inc.) $2 for 8-oz. bottle with brush. Wright's Cream (J. A. Wright & Co., Keene, N.H.) 29c for 8-oz. jar. Use of a damp cloth and rinsing are required. C. Not Recommended Baker's Instantaneous (C. P. Baker Co., Philadel Use of a damp cloth is required. Gleamit (Gleamit Co., Great Neck, N.Y.) $1.35 for two mitts. More than a normal amount of rubbing was required in removal of tarnish. Noxon (Noxon, Inc., Jersey City 2, N.J.) 35c for 14oz. can. The abrasive in this product produced visible scratches on polished silver. Shino (The Pioneer Mfg. Co.,-Cleveland 4) 50c for 11 in. x 12 in. double cloth, having an inner layer im pregnated with abrasive. More than a normal amount of rubbing was required in removal of tarnish. Corrections and em endations to Consumer Bulletin Dinnerware Page 30, C ol. 2, Ju n e *60 B u lletin Colored Cerama-Sione earthenware should be listed under C. Not Recommended. A Los Angeles newspaper in late October re ported a danger to health in the Cerama-Stone dinnerware listed. Repeated use of colored dishes of the ware for acid foods, the newspaper said, on information from a health official, w'ould present danger to health through lead poisoning. This opinion wras based on reports received regarding their use by tw'o persons in Cincinnati. Another news story noted that the manufac turer had stopped production of this w'are and has asked retailers to return all unsold colored Cerama-Stone. White Cerama-Stone, it is re ported, is safe. Portable electronic flash units Page 24, Col. 2, Ju ly '60 B ulletin Change the rating of the Strobomite electronic flash unit from B. Intermediate to A . Recommended. Tests of several new samples of the Strobomite indicated that the original sample tested was not operating normally. In later tests, the Strobomite units could be flashed as soon as the ready lights came on. Electric clocks Page 21, A u g . *60 B u lle tin The Ingraham Co., manufacturer of the Harmony House (Sears) electric alarm clock listed, has in formed Consumers' Research that, through inad vertence, incorrect prices for replacement motor and crystal for that clock had been supplied to Consumers' Research. The correct prices to the consumer are $3.15 for the motor and 30 cents for the crystal. Refrigerator-freezer combinations Page 16, Col. 1, Aug. '60 B u lletin Change rating of Admiral Model 14RF65 from C. Not Recommended, to B. Intermediate. The first sample tested gave abnormally high freezer tem peratures. On the second sample, freezer tem peratures were satisfactorily lowr--freezer food temperature of 4F with refrigerator at 39 de grees at 90 degrees room temperature. Operat ing costs on an adjusted per-cubic-foot basis, however, were abnormally high for this type of combination. On the second sample, estimated monthly operating cost at 3J^ cents per kilowatthour for electricity: at room temperature of 80 degrees, $4; at 90 degrees, $5.30. Running time was 56 percent. These figures should be substi tuted for the figures of $3, $4, and 45 percent running time in the table a t the bottom of page 13 of the August 1960 issue. Also change tempera ture of frozen food (last column of table) from + 16 degrees to + 4 degrees. Refrigerator-freezers using gas for fuel Page 12, Col. 1, Sept. '60 B u lletin The automatic ice maker on the Norge Customatic Model CTGI-110, though it operated satisfac torily in general, produced ice very slowly in the original test. On subsequent tests it was found that the automatic ice maker, when operating correctly, wdll produce 1 pound of ice in 4.6 hours, instead of in 14.3 hours as it did in the original test. K'' 0008397 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 9 Buick Special A newcomer in the field of compact cars, the Buick Special, merits a high rating in handling qualities, riding comfort, acceleration, an d it shows good economy in use of gasoline. T h e Buick Special is a good, quiet car with good riding qualities for those who want superior ac celeration to that afforded by the cheaper lower horsepower compacts and good gasoline economy, and who are willing to pay its relatively high pur chase price (see " Prices"). Probably the most important feature of this car is the new aluminum alloy V-8 engine (shared by the Oldsmobile F-85 and the Tempest). The use of this lightweight engine reduces the front end weight and favors good handling qualities. (Cast-iron liners are used in the engine cylinders.) The transmission hump in the driver's com partment is low enough that three people can sit in fair comfort in the front seat, making the Special a 6-passenger car. The low height of the car Buick Special specifications Taxable horsepower Taxable weight, pounds Engine Type Piston displacement, cubic inches Rated maximum horsepower at stated rpm. Compression ratio Cooling system capacity with heater, quarts Chassis and body Over-all length, inches Width, inches Height, inches Tires Rear axle ratio Brake area, square inches turning diameter, feet Minimum road clearance, inches Trunk space, cubic feet O ther details Battery Gasoline tank capacity, gallons Type of gasoline required ..Curb weight, pounds 39.2 2610 V-8, aluminum alloy 215 155 at 4600 8.8 to 1 13.5 Unit 112 188.5 71.5 52.5 6 .5 0 x 1 3 3 36 to 1 (3.08 to 1 automatic) 124 38 4.9 22 12-volt 40-amp.-hr. 16 Regular 2740 made it. difficult for entry of tall persons. Leg room was adequate, and headroom was adequate in the front but not adequate in the rear for tall people. The action of the heater and defroster was very satisfactory. The new, simplified automatic transmission performed well. Over-all body and frame design was judged good. D isa d v a n ta g es Clock located on the top of the dash will be a definite hazard in the event a collision occurs. Signal lights instead of the more desirable meters were used for generator, oil pressure, and water temperature. Spare tire located flat on the trunk floor (not considered a good arrangement). Prices The car tested by CR was a Model 4119 4-door De Luxe sedan with automatic transmission, power steering, and 3.08 to 1 rear axle ratio. "Posted price," $3008.86, itemized as follows: Manu facturer's suggested list price, $2519; automatic trans mission, $189; power steering, $86.08; heater and de froster, $74.24; radio, $65.64; anti-freeze, $4.90; trans portation charge, $70. The price of the new compact Special is high fora car in the "economy" category; its selling price is about $250 above the Chevrolet, Ford, or Plymouth cars of regu lar size, and it is $625 above the Rambler American. Riding and handling qualities At speeds up to 60 miles per hour, riding quality was good except for a slight hop of rear wheels in passing over tar-filled expansion joints in roads, and over potholes. The car handled, parked, and cornered well. Seats were comfortable, and in ternal noise was low. Instrum ent errors ' Speedometer was about 3 percent fast at 30 miles per hour, 5 percent fast at 50 miles per hour. Odometer was about 3 percent fast. 10 C O NSUM ER B U LLE TIN J A N U A R Y 1961 ' - c T: Kg' 0008338 which have about the same horsepower but are about 30 percent heavier. descending hills was adequate, particularly in the " L" (low drive) position. Dodge L a n c e s r Judged a satisfactory car of its type, with ade (a desirable arrangement). Engine braking was quate acceleration and good gasoline mileage. not adequate on steep downgrades except with the transmission in the low or No. 1 position. T h e Lancer uses the same basic body and the same engine (101 horsepower at 4400 revolutions D isad van tages i per minute) as the Valiant. The optional engines, however, are different. Valiant uses a " power pack" to get additional horsepower (148 hp. at 5200 rpm.), but the engine regularly used on Plymouth 6 and Dodge Dart 6 can be provided on the Lancer at extra cost ($47.35). The main dif ferences between the two cars are in the metal work of the front and rear, and over-all length. The Lancer is 5 inches longer and 2 inches wider than the Valiant and is priced about $50 higher. The Lancer was relatively easy to enter and Over-all design was satisfactory, but workmanship could be improved, particularly in spot weld ing of the body. There were some sharp edges on the doors, and parts of the door latches fixed to the body were a potential hazard. An ammeter was supplied to indicate operation of the alter nator, but an indicating light was used instead of a pressure gauge for oil pressure. The glove com partment was rather small. Spare tire, located under the trunk floor, was not readily accessible. leave, but some persons may have difficulty enter ing the front seat because of the angle of the front door posts. The automatic transmission hump is low enough that three people can sit in fair com fort in the front seat, making this a 6-passenger car. (With standard transmission, only two can sit in the front seat.) Leg room, hip room, and headroom were satisfactory. Seats were com fortable, with no noticeable discomfort after 3 or 4 hours' driving. The automatic transmission was Prices The car tested by CR was a 4-door sedan, Model 770, with Torquefiite transmission and 3.23 to 1 rear axle ratio. "Posted price," $2488.25, itemized as follows: Manu facturer's suggested list price, $2151; Torquefiite trans mission, $171.55; heater and defroster, $74.40; back-up lights, $10.70; wheel covers, $15.95; anti-freeze, S3.65; transportation charge, $58. satisfactory. (For cars with engines in the 80- to 100-horsepower range, CR recommends, as pref erable, cars with manual shift transmissions.) The 3-speed automatic transmission had a " park" posi tion operated by a lever below the push buttons Riding and handling qualities At speeds up to 60 miles per hour on roads in good condition, the Lancer's riding quality was good, but on rough or " washboard" roads the ride was CONSUMER B ULLETIN 11J A N U A R Y 1961 ' Acceleration times were: 0 to 60 m.p.h. 20 to 50 m.p.h. 40 to 60 m.p.h. 20.5 sec. 13.5 sec. 10.5 sec. These times were within about 1 second of the figures obtained on last year's Valiant with stand ard transmission. Instrum ent errors Speedometer was about 4 percent fast at 30 miles per hour and 7 percent fast at 50 miles per hour. Odometer was about 4 percent fast. Gasoline m ileage under test conditions At a constant true speed of 50 miles per hour, the Lancer with automatic transmission gave 27 miles per gallon (good), in city driving, miles per gallon ranged from 21.5 to 24 (good). Brakes Service brakes were satisfactory, but the car was slightly nose heavy on emergency stops. The parking brake was of the step-on type, located at the left of the steering column, released by a con- The manually-operated pull-type brake operated and released by one hand is the only kind satisfac tory in an emergency situation. Dodge Lancer specifications Taxable horsepower Taxable w eisht, pounds 27.7 2595 Engine Type 6-in-fine, overhead valves Piston displacement, cubic inches 170 (225 with optional engine) Rated maximum horsepower at stated rpm. 101 at 4400 (145 at 4000 with optional engine) Compression ratio 8.2 to 1 Cooling system capacity with heater, quarts 12 (14 w ith optional engine) Chassis and body Type w heelbase, inches Over-all length, inches Width, inches Height, inches Tires Rear axle ratio Brake area, square inches Turning diameter, feet Minimum road clearance, inches Trunk space, cubic feet Unit 106.5 189 72.5 53.5 6.50 x 13 3.55 to 1 (3.23 to 1 automatic) 129 37.8 5.4 24.9 O tber details Battery Gasoline tank capacity, gallons Type of gasoline required Curb weight, pounds 12-volt 50-amp.-hr. 13 Regular 2690 Rambler A m erican The Rambler American is judged to be a very good car of its type and is recommended for those who want economy both in purch ase price and in operation. Al t h o u g h the Rambler American for 1961 has new body styling, it is basically the same as the Rambler American that has established reliable performance over a period of several years. It will seat five people in comfort, it is relatively easy to enter and leave (in the front but not in the rear). Leg room and headroom are adequate for most people, though tall people wearing hats might de sire additional headroom in the rear. Heater and defroster action were very good. The new ceramic dual muffler and tail pipe are guaranteed to the 12 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 0008100 $ '.'V; -"r just for the sake of change and novelty. This policy should help to maintain good resale value. D isa d v a n ta g es The use of signal lights for generator and oil pres sure, instead of meters. The spare tire, located at the part of the trunk nearest the rear seat of the car, was not readily accessible. This is one of the few cars that still use an undesirable type of hood ornament (see M ay 1959 C o n s u m e r B u l l e t i n ) . Prices The model tested by Consumers' Research was a deluxe 4-door sedan with standard transmission, and with 3.31 to 1 rear axle ratio. "Posted price," $2052.05, itemized as follows: Manu facturer's suggested list price, $1894; heater and de froster, $74; anti-freeze, $3.80; transportation charge, $80.25. The Rambler American is about $80 lower in price than the Corvair and Falcon, $175 lower than the Lancer, and $120 lower than the Valiant, with equivalent equipment. Riding and handling qualities At speeds up to 60 miles per hour on roads in good to moderately rough condition, this car gave a very good ride. Riding and handling qualities on hilly, winding roads and cornering on sharp curves were very satisfactory. Seats were com fortable, and there was room for five passengers to ride in comfort. Road tests of accelerating ability Acceleration times were: 0 to 60 m.p.h., through all gears 15 sec. 20 to 50 m.p.h., high gear 11 sec. 40 to 60 m.p.h., high gear 8.5 sec. These figures were approximately the same as ob tained on the 1960, and the Rambler American was appreciably faster in acceleration in the 0 to Gasoline m ileage under test conditions At a constant speed of 50 miles per hour, the first car tested gave 28 miles per gallon. A second car of this make and model tested gave about 2}/^ miles per gallon less. Such differences are to be expected in tests of several cars of a given make and model. They are due to a multiplicity of small differences, including those in carburetors, details of the ignition system, variations of fits and finish of working parts. Brakes Braking qualities were satisfactory. The parking brake, located a t the left of the steering column, was of the hand-operated pull-out type and pro vided satisfactory action on the model tested. This type of brake is to be preferred to the step-on type of parking brake. Rambler American Deluxe and Super specifications Taxable horsepower Taxable weight, pounds Engine Type Piston displacement, cubic inches Rated maximum horsepower at stated rpm.* Comp.ession ratio* Cooling $ys.'em capacity with heater, quarts Chassis and body Type wheelbase, inches Over-all length, inches Width, inches Height, inches Tires Rear axle ratio Brake area, square inches Turning diameter, feet Minimum road clearance, inches Trunk space, cubic feet O ther details Battery Gasoline tank capacity, gallons Type of gasoline required Curb weight, pounds 23.4 2540 6-in-iine, L-head 195.6 90 at 3800 8.0 to 1 12 Unit 100 173 70 56.2 6.00 X15 (6.50 X15 optional 3.31 to 1 (3.78 to 1 optional 139.5 36 5.3 22 12-volt 40-amp.-hr. 20 Regular 2650 * C ustom model has a 125 horsepower engine, 8.7 to 1 com pression ratio. Food products labels Consumers' Research will be glad to receive from its readers interesting examples of labels which either do not give information they should, or conceal important information by various devices of color contrast, extra small type, or a location which makes the label difficult to find or to read. We shall also be glad to receive labels from pack ages of candy, much of which a t the present time has been so highly sophisticated by manufacturers and their chemists that popular candies contain a startling number of unfamiliar food modifiers and additives (highly questionable for children). 0008401 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 13 kind usually provides best vision for a distance somewhat beyond arm 's length. There are many persons who have difficult}7in reading fine print who have considered contact lenses. If " two-vision" type of conventional glasses have to be worn, then why not bifocal contact lenses? Before 1948, almost every person who tried con tact lenses suffered during the trial, most often because of the liquid or solution which had to be Used with each lens. However, a smaller size, fluidless type, of single-vision contacts was im proved about that time. Soon thereafter, re quests for contact lenses increased. Demands were heard daily. The thoughts formerly of " good enough for father" is being reversed to " if it's good enough for granddaughter, then I'm in!" Can an}- type of contact lens be tossed in an eye, haphazardly? Will every eye accept a contact lens? There have been instances where eyes have been damaged or ophthalmologists have had to remove an eye because the contact lens was incorrectly fitted or worn neglectfully. Several " opportunist-operators" who used their own exaggerated statements to establish them selves as " contact lens specialists" have been restricted by Federal Court orders. Some of these self-proclaimed specialists had only a mini mum of training with contact lenses, but the American public, which usually inquires carefully about who takes care of certain other health items, sometimes still buys from these charlatans simply because of their misleading and persuasive advertising. Difficulties associated with all kinds of contact lenses lie in poorly fitted, eyeballirritating lenses, or failure to recognize eye in juries received while wearing or due to contact lenses. An example is a foreign body that lodges on the numbed cornea of the eyeball under the contact lens. Or a numbed cornea allows infec tion to spread disastrously. A skinned cornea has resulted from unskilled handling of the lens by the fitter or by insufficient or inadequate instruc tion from the " salesman" who beguiling!}7sold an unsuspecting person. Some persons highly nearsighted and some fewer persons farsighted (in vision, that is) may easily wear single-vision contact lenses. Contact lenses arc worn most often for vanity or for psychological reasons. Occasionally contact lenses can improve vision when conventional lenses 14 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 refuse to prescribe bifocal contact lenses be cause, in their opinion, there is rarely an indication for them. The lenses are not suffi ciently perfected at the present time. Because the difficulties in wearing these tiny aspirintablet-sized lenses are many, Consumers' Re search presents additional information about contact bifocals. The author is Purman Dorman, M .D., an ophthalmologist of Seattle, Washington, a member of the Advisory Board of The Na tional Society for the Prevention of Blindness, and first eye advisor for the Federal Board of Vocational Rehabilitation. He has spent much time attempting to improve vision. He is one of the many ophthalmologists through out the country fitting contact lenses. cannot. That is true in keratoconus, the conical shaped cornea. It is particularly true after a cataract operation, for vision with contact lenses often is better than vision with glasses. The problems are the far greater difficulty for the usually older wearer to gain adequate wearing time as well as the extra cost of the lens. There must be an extra willingness of the patient to wrear this type of lens which is heavier and thicker than the usual contact lens. Most younger persons with single-vision contact lenses have a first jubilant exclamation " I can see! I can see!" Such expressions are rarely heard, with bifocal contact lenses. Bifocal or two-vision contact types are still under experiment. Single-vision and bifocal con tact lenses may seem similar but they are far from being identical. Most single-vision lenses are circular. Their usual diameter varies between 9.0 and 10.5 mm., depending on the desires of the fitter with relation to strength or correction, thickness of the lens, diameter of the wearer's cornea and other factors. Some experimental bi focals are circular. Others are circular with two parts lopped off or triangular with the corners rounded, or ovoid. The rounded-corner triangular design has its base at the bottom. The ovoid uses about half the vertical area for KF 0008402 tance vision being obtained through its center. This center area is about 3 or 4 mm. in diameter. The reading portion is a narrow band around the outer edge, on the front or back surface of the lens. Why can't bifocal contacts be worn as easily as regular bifocals? With conventional bifocal glasses the wearer has only to learn to use a certain area of the lens for reading. This area always stays in the same place. In addition, there is always a slight amount of combined head move ment and eye movement which helps the wearer to " adjust" his vision. This combined motion is essential to help the eyes " find the correct focus" but this assisting mechanism of combined motion cannot be easily utilized where one is wearing bifocal contacts. With contact bifocals, the circumstances are different. Every contact lens shifts slightly on the corneal surface. Such action permits tears to move freely and allows better metabolism of the cornea. As the upper lid moves downward to wet the eyeball covered by a contact lens, tears are swirled under that lens. As the lid returns, it usually sweeps the lens upward, slightly, definitely moving it away from where it had been before. A lens movement of 10 to 15 percent away from center may not interfere too much with vision for some single-vision lens wearers but may be extremely annoying for others wearing either single-vision or bifocal contacts. If a circular bifocal lens is fitted too loosely, it does not remain near enough to the center. It is comfortable for wear but not for vision. If fitted too tightly, the lens remains nearer the center of the cornea. However, irritation then often develops, dis comfort follows, and wearing time shortens or becomes non-existent. The older-aged person looks more often to comfort than to appearance, Sketches similar to some present or recent bifocal contact lenses In each Instance, th e shaded area represents th a t portion of th e lens used by th e wearer when reading. O f th e lenses illu s tra te d , th e one in th e up per r ig h t hand c orner is th e design being trie d by an overw helm ing percentage o f those persons a tte m p tin g to w ear or w earing bifocal co n tact lenses tod ay. T h is typ e m ay have th e reading portion on th e inside surface (next to th e eye) or on th e outside surface of th e lens. Sketches are of head-on views of th e lenses. and the older he becomes, the greater importance he gives to comfort. The older person says: " I should stick something in my eye as soon as I get up, in order to read the morning newspaper? How much do I want to punish myself?" This does not mean that bifocal contacts are not worn. Far from that. There arc some who own bifocal contacts. There are those who always want to be the first or who will " try anything." Yet there are relatively few wearers of bifocal contact lenses. There are some who have learned to wear single-vision lenses first, then learned to wear bifocal contacts later. Some have kept their bifocal lenses for varying lengths of time, then relegated them to a drawer. Too much bother. Bifocal contact lenses as offered today have but little useful purpose, even for those few who are willing to wear them. Ch an ge of ad d ress If you change your address, please notify Co n s u m e r B u l l e t in at least six weeks before the change is to go into effect, if at all possible. Be sure to give both the old and new addresses. It is best to type or " print" your name and ad dress, to insure maximum legibility. The address portion clipped from the wrapper of your latest copy of Co n s u m e r Bu l l e t in will be helpful. If your new city has postal zone numbers, be sure to include the zone number in your new address. It will help in getting your Bu l l e t in to you more promptly. KB 0008403 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 196t 15 waves and the casual haircuts now in vogue have stimulated the use of home hair dryers with their new hood attachments. The new home dryers have been improved in design so that the good ones will dry the hair about as rapidly as the commercial-type dryers used in beauty parlors. When Consumers' Research last tested hair dryers in 1954, only one kind of hood was tested, a " dryer cap" that was filled with silica gel, a drying chemical. Nowadays, almost every hair dryer for home use has a cap attachment intended to distribute the hot air around and over the head. Separate hoods to be used with dryers are also sold in drug stores, department stores, and the mail-order houses at prices around SI to $2. Hair dryers are sold in a wide range of prices. Those bought by Consumers' Research for this study ranged in price from S4 to $21. The lowestpriced ones were of the familiar type, a dryer (an electric fan and heater) with a handle, on a stand. Usually the dryer can be removed from the stand and held in the hand if desired. over the older designs. They are more stable. (Unfortunately, the older types were forever fall ' ing over on the table.) They have controls at the front or side that are easily' seen and operated. One of this kind tested, and other new models being advertised, also have an air outlet in the base, advertised as being useful for drying newly' manicured hails at the same time as the hair. One big disadvantage of the dryers of the new'er design is that they are sold at much higher prices than the older ones--two to three times as much, indeed. Nevertheless, it is unlikely' that the woman who can afford one would not choose a new-style dryer in preference to the old kind that must either be held in the hand or used with a hood that is essentially inconvenient. (See illustrations, pages 16, 17.) Hoods having a long unsupported tube-like extension have a real disadvantage in use. If the woman drying her hair turns her head, or doesn't locate the dryer properly in the first place, she will cut off the flow of air. Furthermore, The size of the hood or bonnet makes a difference T h e bonnet a t th e left was com fortab le on th e head, and fu rth e rm o re did n o t disarrange th e h air settin g . T h e hood a t th e rig h t was too s m a ll; i t was un co m fo rtable and tended to disarrange th e h air. T h e hoods shown belong w ith th e K enm ore and Lady C en tu ry dryers. 16 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 g ff 0008404 behind her, of course, the user cannot easily reach the controls, nor does she have much freedom of motion during the drying process because of the hood. She is, in fact, every bit as limited in her activities as she would be in a beauty shop. The flexible supported hose, found in the newer designs, on the other hand, makes it possible for the user to move her head around more or less at will. Some manufacturers have even gone so far as to provide a strap for their hair dryer so that it can be carried on the hip from place to place, within the limitation of the electrical cord. Manufacturers seem well aware that the older design leaves much to be desired. Most of those making hair dryers have announced newer models that are flatter and thus more stable and use a plastic hose to carry air to the head. Not all these new designs are available in retail stores, C R 's shoppers found, and at least one new model that was advertised when samples were purchased was not actually in production. Despite the important differences in design, the dryers were very similar in the basic essentials. Each had a heating element and a motor-driven fan; most of them had switches which gave " off," " cool," and " hot" settings. The dryers tested weighed less than pounds each. Plastic, which is light in weight and does not conduct heat as readily as metal (and thus remains cooler to the touch), was used in many hair dryers. The watts input (an indication of cost of electricity for operating the appliances) ranged from 215 to 440 watts. This means that the hair dryers tested would not cost more than about 13^2 cents per hour to use, a sum which most women would likely consider not significant. Consumers' Research included 10 hair dryers in the current study. Each dryer was used by three women on CR's staff. One had fairly short hair, another medium-length hair, and a third had a long page-boy bob. None had her hair cut during the testing of the dryers. During the tests, the dryer users sometimes washed and dried their hair twice in one day. The women were frank in expressing their likes and dislikes and found some things about the dryers that were a distinct annoyance. Un marked switches, switches inconveniently located, and hoods that were too small or difficult to put on were particular points of critical comment. 0008405 T h e long tu b e on th is hood w orks w ell o n ly w h en i t is k e p t s tra ig h t and th e a ir can travel freely. T h e Kenm ore dryer had this type of tube and hood. A flexible tu b e like th e one on th is hood provides both conveni ence and com fort. The General Electric, Lady C en tury, Lady S un beam , and Ronson dryers a ll used tubes of th is kin d . T h e s h o rt len g th of th e extension on th is hood p ractically ties th e user to th e dryer. The M iracle Vac and Tropic-A ire dryers had hoods of this type. CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 17 Switches should be marked! T h is switch on th e Tro p ic-A ire dryer controls only th e heating e le m e n t, which is tu rn e d on or off d epend ing on th e sw itch knob po sition . T h e s w itc h used should be of such design t h a t on and off positions can be clearly m arked; th e y could not on th e one show n. T h e m o to r ru n s w h enever th e d ry e r is plugged in ; it , too, should be c o n tro lle d by a s w itc h , prop erly m arked to show on and off positions. Small, close-fitting hoods tended to disarrange the hair settings and were especially objectionable. Quietness in operation was judged an important point. The hair dryers that were judged the noisiest were not necessarily most effective in removing moisture from the hair, though they sounded as if they were working harder. There was, in fact, no great difference between one dry er and another in time taken to dry the hair. The Sunbeam dryer, found noisier by the users than any other, did not dry their hair any faster than other less noisy dryers because none of the three women could tolerate the " hot" setting for any length of time. (They used the " medium" set ting.) __ As with all electrical appliances, safety to the user is of greatest importance in a hair dryer. All the dryers tested had low leakage current, an indi cation of negligible shock hazard, under room con ditions and under humid air conditions. All the dryers but one, the Osier Airjet, passed tests of electrical insulation under normal and high- humidity conditions. (The Oster failed the high- voltage breakdown test and therefore was given no further tests.) All but one of the dryers tested had some means for protection against overheating. The General Electric, Lady Century, and Lady Sunbeam dryers each had a bimetallic thermostat, which turned off the heating element in the event that the dryer became overheated, and turned it on again when the temperature went down. The Handy Hannah, Kenmore, Oster, and Ronson dryers each facturer, Handy Hannah, will supply a replace ment heating element for his hair dryer at $1, postpaid. The Tropic-Aire had a soldered link, two leaves which separated when the solder melted after \)/2 minutes of overheating. These two leaves could be soldered together again by any handy man, radio repairman, technician, or appliance repairman, in the event that they had separated in safeguarding the appliance from undue heating. The Chic had a fusible rivet that operated in much the same way. The Miracle Vac appeared to have no thermal protective device. All of the motors in the dryers were the brush less type except the Handy Hannah, Kenmore, Lady Sunbeam, and Oster. Brushless motors have several advantages over motors with brushes. The brushless motors do not cause interference effects on television or radio; in addition, they are noticeably quieter, and may be expected to have a longer trouble-free life. All were designed for operation at 110-120 volts, alternating current only, except the Handy Hannah and Oster which could be used on direct current also. Hair dryers are listed alphabetically within the 1, 2, and 3 price brackets in the A-, B-, and C rated groups. Prices given in parentheses are list prices; others are the prices paid for the dryers tested. A. Recommended Ronson "Hood 'N ' Comb," Model L (Ronson Corp., Woodbridge, N. J.) $14.99 ($19.95). . Description: 300 watts. Weight, lb. Pink plastic housing, with attached plastic stand. A plastic hose and hood, a comb attachment, and a plastic bonnet are sup plied. Adjustable vertically and horizontally. Two switches, "on-off" and "warm-cold," for control of fan and heating element. Had wire fuse to protect against overheating and possible burnout of heating element. Performance: Hair-drying ability, good. Hood easy to put on and take off. No radio or television interference. 2 General Electric, Model HD-1 (General Electric, Auto matic Blanket & Fan Dept., Bridgeport 10, Conn.) $20.82 ($24.95). Description: 400 watts. Weight, Vpi lb. Pink plastic housing, with foam-rubber bottom cushion and attached plastic hose. One sliding switch, marked "off-cool-low- 18 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 K 00 08 4.06 -.1 Co., Fort Wayne, Ind.) $3.99. Kit includes dryer 50) $16.29 ($26.95). {Model 12518) and hood. Description: 330 watts. Brush-type motor (brushes fairly Description: 215 watts. Weight, 2)4 lb. with stand (1% easily replaceable). Weight, 3)4 lb. Plastic housing lb. without stand). Chrome-plated metal housing, with with four attached rubber feet. There is an opening for wood handle, detached metal stand with rubber feet. drying fingernails in front. One rotary switch marked Adjustable horizontally and vertically. Pink cloth hood "off-cool-warm-medium-hot." Plastic hose and hood. with plastic covering supplied. Two toggle switches Had a bimetallic thermostat to protect against over marked "on-off" and "hot-cold." No instructions came heating. with the dryer. Lacked device to protect against over Performance: Hair-drying ability, good, but the dryer was heating. judged the noisiest in use of those tested. Hood a little Performance: Hair-drying ability, fair. Hood fairly easy tight over head when large curlers were used for hair to put on and take off, but felt tight and uncomfortable setting. The hose of this dryer cannot be replaced easily, on a head wit:; large curlers. No radio or television oj a disadvantage. Slight interference with TV picture interference. 1 when used near set; no effect on sound. Some radio interference. 3 Tropic-Aire, Model 786A1 (McGraw-Edison Co., Ber- sted Mfg. Div., Boonville, Mo.) $6.95. Hood available, Cat. No. 38104, $1.25. B. Intermediate Chic, No. 695 (Morris Struhl, Inc., New York 10) $5.95. Description: 215 watts. Weight, 2 lb. with stand (1% lb. without stand). Pink metal housing, with wooden han Description: 210 watts. Weight, 2)4 lb. Yellow painted metal housing, with wood handle. Detached metal stand. Adjustable horizontally. No control for fan, which runs as long as dryer is plugged in. Switch, un marked, turns heater on and off. Blue printed cloth hood supplied. Fusible link to protect against overheat dle, detached metal stand. Adjustable horizontally. Two switches, "on-off," "hot-cold." No hood provided. ing (two leaves soldered together, which could be re paired by the home handyman--see text). Had fusible rivet to protect against overheating. Performance: Hair-drying ability, fair. No radio or tele Performance: Hair-drying ability, fair. No radio or tele vision interference. 1 vision interference. No instructions came with the dryer. 1 Oster Airjet. Model 202-04 (John Oster Mfg. Co., Mil Handy H annah, Model 101 (Handy Hannah Products Corp., Whitman, Mass.) $9.99. Description: 440 watts. Brush-type motor (brushes not readily replaceable). Weight, 2)4 lb. Plastic housing, with attached plastic stand. Adjustable horizontally and vertically. Rotary switch marked "hot-off-cold." No hood. Had wire fuse to protect against overheating. (Replacement heating element, $1, postpaid.) waukee 17) $13.99 ($21.95). Description: 440 watts. Weight, 2 lb. Metal housing, with black plastic base. Adjustable vertically. Two switches, "on-off" and "cold-hot." Pink plastic hood supplied. Had wire fuse to protect against overheating. Performance: Hood fairly easy to put on and take off. This appliance failed electrical proof-voltage test; no further tests were applied. 2 Performance: Hair-drying ability, fair. Objectionable radio and television interference. (Interference was re duced when the dryer was used in a part of the house distant from the set.) No instructions came with the dryer. 2 Lady Century, Cat. No. HD-21 (Century Enterprises, Inc., New York 67) $17.01 ($29.95). Description: 225 watts. Weight, 3)4 lb. Plastic housing, with 4 felt-based feet. Sliding switch marked "off-coldwarm-medium-hot." Plastic hose and attached plastic Kenmore (Sears-Roebuck's Cat. No. 8--8727) $14.97, "bonnet." Hood had "air volume control" to regulate plus postage. air flow. Had a bimetallic protective device. Description: 440 watts. Brush-type motor (brushes not Performance: Drying ability, good; stability, good. In easily replaceable). Weight, 2)4 lb. Chrome-plated general, convenient to use. Sliding switch did not work * and yellow enameled metal housing, with attached plastic stand. Adjustable horizontally and vertically. Rotary properly. Hood could not be pulled or pushed to go on a head over the large-sized curlers, a disadvantage for switch marked "off, cold, warm, hot." Blue printed some users. Tight hood tended to cause air volume and plastic hood-and-tube supplied. Had wire fuse to pro control to be blocked (and to cause the dryer to over tect against overheating. heat). A hole and some deformation developed in the Performance: Hair-drying ability, good. Hood was easy plastic case near the hose connection where the case to put on and take off. Objectionable radio and tele became hot enough to soften and deform the plastic. vision interference. (Interference was reduced when No radio or television interference. 3 g- 0008407 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 19 *** W h e n nature puts different species of plants into different places so that grasses grow luxuriantly in some areas, and trees, shrubs and brush in others, she is demonstrating the different plantnourishing qualities that exist in the soils. Nature produced forests, built primarily of cellulose (woody fibers) with little value as food for warm blooded animals, on the well-watered calciumdeficient soils of the eastern United States. She produced tall grasses on the younger soil of the eastern prairies where the rainfall was moderate; she grew short grasses on the still younger semi arid soils of the western plains. The American bison, a beast noted for its massive bony structure and great strength, was the animal product characteristic of the plains area soils on which, a generation or so later, wheat was grown that was high in protein and in the mineral elements required to support the manufacture of protein by plants. Protein is an essential food substance, basic in the functioning elements of all animal bodies. The starch also present in the grasses represents only stored energy, and it plays a part in the building of ex cessive and abnormal fatty la3'ers in domestic animals, fat that is bad for the pocketbook and for the health of the consumer who buys the animal as meat. Organized knowledge about the locations and relationships of plants, animals, and human beings and their interactions with their environments is the basic outline of the expanding biological science called ecology. Among the chief environmental factors is the pattern of the fertility of the soils which fundamentally maintain all life. Nature's array of various interrelated life forms has been telling us for countless generations that the soil of each region is best suited to supplying the needs of the specific plant and animal life which thrives in that region. Each of nature's crops (plant or animal) represents a survival of the fittest, determined basically, if there are no disturbing factors, by what the local soil provides in nutrients. This fact was emphasized by Darwin a century ago. The wisdom of the anim al body Animals search out their feeds for quality in terms of health and growth. They test and choose soils Careful observation of the cow's misbehavior, as she seeks to eat where she is not supposed to, is very revealing. One finds that usually she is expressing a preference for grass growing on the virgin unharvested soils along the highway or the railroad right-of-way, as compared with the grass growing in the long-used, time-worn soils inside the pasture area. The cow's wisdom in seeking soil that grows feed of high quality carries an important lesson for men. When men moved their grazing animals such as cows, sheep, and goats to the fenced-in well-watered lands now customary, they failed to realize that animal physiology is such that the animals were not necessarily feeding well and living in good health. There were deficiencies, due to the insufficient fertility of the soil in the enclosed pasture areas, and continuing unplanned use of the land often increased the deficiencies and caused additional ones to appear. In due course, farmers often came to face the need of purchasing protein sup plements for animal feeding, even for the abnormal castrated animals that arc fed only to be fattened for slaughter. When it comes to judging the nutritive value of various grasses available for feed, appearances may be deceiving. Thus, in a fenced-in, humid Figure 1 A lth o u g h th e hu m m ocks of grass in th is field appeared lush and green, th e cow which fed here in stinctively preferred th e su r rounding forage w h ich , as explained in th e te x t, was m ore n u t r itio u s despite its less s u c c u le n t a ppearan ce. (P h o to by G . E. S m ith , D ep artm e n t of Soils, U niversity of M issouri.) 0008408 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 21 soils with chemical nitrogen. We labor under the delusion that a higher concentration of nitrogen in the fertilized vegetation is proof that the grass must contain higher concentrations of protein, but unfortunately, protein is not fully measured by nitrogen content, which may be but a crude and unreliable chemical symbol of the nutritive quality of feeds. Those who contend.that the crude protein in the grass grown by such fertiliza tion with nitrogen duplicates the nutritional qual ity of the protein which is grown by legumes fail to manifest the wisdom exhibited by the cow. On the semi-humid soils of the Plains and Western Prairies, the cow's droppings as fertilizers do not exhibit the disturbing effects that have been mentioned on the growth of the grasses, nor on the cow's choice of food, and no dark green spots in the pasture are in evidence. On the dryer soils, under only low to moderate rainfalls to change the character of the soil, little organic fertility has been leached away. Plenty of plantnutritive materia! is left to balance the added nitrogen. The crops actually growing, on account of the scant rainfall, have not acted to remove important elements of the fertility supply. Soil quality, not plant pedigree alone, determ ines the nutrient balance in a crop Those who contend that a given plant does as well on any soil on which it grows as it would on an other soil except for the volume or weight of crop produced, have a wrong understanding of the nature of plant inheritance. In one experiment, potassium (potash), recognized as an essential factor for the plant's production of carbohydrate and needed often for increased yield of plant ma terial, was added in various amounts to all but one of four plots of soil which were otherwise alike. Seeds from the same mother plant were used to give a constant genetic background. Of three crops, the first was not given legume bac teria for nodule production, while the seeds for the other two were treated with bacteria which estab lished prominent root nodules. In terms of crop yields, the first crop was a bountiful one, varying in quantity with the amount of applied potash. Nevertheless, in terms of total The third crop gave larger yields of dry m atter (plant materia] with moisture removed) than the second. Although the seeds for the second and third crops were identical in ever)'way, nutritional properties of the crops -were quite different because of differing soil characteristics. In the same experiment, measurements were also made of the amounts of sugar and starch in the various crops. The results (see Figure 2) show that within each group of identical and identically ticated seeds, characteristics of the soil had an important effect on the proportions of sugar and starch in the crops, (in the diagram, " B" and " C" indicate the seeds that were inocu lated with nodule-forming bacteria; the " A" seeds were not so treated.) These observations show the serious error of those who argue that soil is of no importance in determining the nutritional value of the crops grown on it. It is the soil which determines nu tritional value. The genetic factor present in the seed and transmitted to the growing plant merely sets limits to the range of variations the soil factors can produce. To argue, as have gov ernment officials, that the soil, however deficient in natural fertility, is of no significance in deter mining the quality of the crop is a confession of misinformation, not of scientific knowledge. A nim als, too, are greatly affected by soils Experimental work with rabbits has shown that the body growth of the animals and their bodv physiology, even the maintenance of sexual vigor, varied according to differences in the fertility of the soil on which crops for their feed were grown. Tests were made with hay grown on soil with no nitrogen, and other hay grown on companion lots, otherwise the same, which were treated with various sized doses of commercial fertilizer nitro gen. In repeated trials with lots of five rabbits (two males and three females), the animals were offered for choice equal amounts of four different hays along with constant quantities of corn. The rab bits regularly chose to consume the most hay from the check plot which had no nitrogen treat ment, and consumed decreasing amounts of the 22 C O N S U M E R B U L L E T IN J A N U A R Y 1961 Kg' 0008409 The data indicated that the animals were strug gling with poor nutrition and body growth and avoided the supposed protein supplement in the form of the artificial high nitrogen content in the hay, which, though it was nitrogen, did not corre spond to the high quality protein which they needed. The unbalanced nutritional quality of the feed obtained by some of the rabbits even produced sexual infertility, which was not present when the animals were on a diet which was known to be complete for growth. The facts that have been outlined will be ob served in nature by those who do not have precon ceived ideas about plant growth. The profes sional agriculturist unfortunately often views the effects of soils on the growth of plants with a dis tant outlook, as if the only problems were those of industrial manipulation of dead materials, with emphasis on the various technologies for economic advantages only. People who approach agricul tural research in this way have lost sight of agriculture as a biological demonstration by the forces of nature, where man is more a spectator than a manager in complete control of soil and produce. Such unrealistic views of agriculture have led to the expressions by high governmental officials of the view that soil is but a chemical and physical agent for the production of larger quantities of crops; they seem unaware that the soil of our planet is a complex material developed through Figure 2 T h e th re e groups of b a r graphs show th e effects of d iffe re n t soil tr e a tm e n ts on th re e successive crops of soy beans. T h e h e ig h t of each bar indicates th e to ta l yield of dry m a tte r from a given q u a n tity of seed. T h e solid section a t th e b o tto m of each bar represents th e a m o u n t of sugar in th e crop as d eterm in ed by analysis, and th e cro ss-lined section represents th e a m o u n t of starch . W ith in each group th e seeds used were id en tic al, and th e soils used were id e n tic a l except fo r increasing a m o u n ts of added po tassium p ro p o rtio n a l to th e n u m b ers , 0, 1, 2, 3, shown a t t he bo tto m s of th e bars in each gro u p . N ote t h a t differences in soil tre a tm e n t affect n o t on ly th e to ta l yields b u t also th e relative ratios of sugar and starch to each o th er and to th e to ta l yields. T h is d e m o n s trate s c le a rly t h a t c h a ra c te ristics of th e soil do havea m ark e d effect in d e te rm in in g th e n u tritio n a l q u a litie s of t he foods grown on it. many centuries, having the power of creation, not only for plants, but for everything that lives, moves and has its being upon the earth. W; '~" R e c e n t r e p r in t s fr o m CONSUMER BULLETIN T itle Foods and nutrition B ulletin issue '60-'61 Annual N o . of pases 9 P rice (stamps a c c e p ta b le ) 25c Refrigerator-freezers using gas for fuel Sept. '60 3 10c T itle Milk--an overrated food Part I Part II Softening the water we use B ulletin issue No. o f P ric e (stamp: pases accep tab le) Nov. '59 6 Mar. '60 5 20c 20c Feb. '60 7 20c Does ''buy now, pay later" cost too much? Aug. '60 Getting the most service from your rugs May '60 Rugs and carpets, selection Apr. '60 2 4 5 5c 10c 20c Encyclopedias for children Japanese transistor portable radios Automatic washing machines (revised) Dec. '59 Nov. '59 May '59 3 3 7 10c 10c 25c K t 0008410 CONSUM ER B ULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 23 kg*r r- looked with disfavor on this use of electric power because the added load on their lines was not a t tractive to them from a cost standpoint, they are now favorable to house heating by electricity. As an example, at the present time the Detroit Edison Co. employs 15 electric heating specialists whose function it is to inspect homes in which electric heat is to be used and recommend modifications or changes to the owner or contractor, as needed, so that the home will be properl)' constructed and contain adequate insulation and means for control of moisture. Electric home heating is not new, for there were a few homes using it in cheap-power areas in the Northwest over 45 years ago. Indeed, there were more than 2000 homes using electric heat in Tacoma, Washington, by 1920. In 1934, the Tennessee Valley Authority built 300 electrically heated homes, but the long-continued lack of popularity of this type of heat, even in an area with an abundance of cheap electric power, is attested to by the fact that in 1946 there were When are you comfortable? Whether or not a particular person finds a house comfortable will depend mainly upon the tempera ture of the air in it. The English, who seldom employ central heat, usually find our homes hot and stuffy. Elderly persons in the U. S. will often feel chilly in a well-heated room maintained at 72 degrees. There are also noticeable differences in the comfort conditions best suited to men and women. If, for example, your wife persists in lowering the thermostat setting, she is not being ornery; she is honestly1' too warm at a temperature at which you may feel nicely comfortable. One may also feel chilly even though the ther mometer indicates a suitable air temperature, if the walls of a room are much colder than the air. With cold walls, body' heat is lost to the walls by radiation at a faster-than-normal rate and, as a result, one feels chilly even in a room in which the air is at the most desirable temperature. There are, of course, other factors involved in HEAT pumped OUT Illustration courtesy General Electric Co., Electric Heating Section, Louisville, Ky. A heat p u m p heats th e hom e in th e w in te r and cools it in th e s u m m e r. Its tw o modes of op eration are shown in th e sketches above. QD0S4 f I24 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 ^ The role of insulation The proponents of electric house heating take a giant step forward in the cause of comfort with their insistance that adequate insulation be em ployed in the floors, walls, and ceilings in an electrically heated home. For many years, the amount of insulation it was economically justifiable to. install in a home was dependent principally upon the cost of the fuel to be used with the heat ing system. Naturally, where fuel was cheap, loss of a great deal of heat through exterior walls and roof did not involve much outlay and was often to be preferred to the expense and inconvenience of a good job of insulation. As the prices of fuels rose, the dollar value of the heat lost through poorly insulated walls, roof, and floors became so great that it became economical to provide good in sulation. Some persons may suppose that doubling the thickness of the layer of insulation will cut the heat loss in half and save half the fuel required to heat a house. This is not true. In point of fact, a 4-inch thickness of average insulation is only about twice as effective in retaining heat as a layer 1 inch thick, and a 6-inch layer is only slightly more effective than a 4-inch layer. Thus, the choice of the right thickness of insulation involves important economic considerations in any given region and with any given type of fuel. The amount best to use is determined principally by the prevailing prices for the fuel in the area, likewise upon the severity of the cold weather and the number of months of the year in which heating is required. The effectiveness of the insulation has a bearing also on the initial cost of the heating plant, since smaller and less expensive heating equipment can be used when good insulation and other factors combine to keep the heat loss lower. Thus there are not only savings in initial cost, but also savings of space, which has economic value in most homes. The importance of the part played by insulation in reducing the costs of heating a home is readily indicated by figuring the reduction in heat losses obtained with its use. Proper installation of 6 inches of good insulation in the ceiling should reduce the heating bill about 30 percent in a typical uninsulated home of frame construction of 1000square-foot area (3 inches of insulation would save about 18 percent). 3% inches of insulation in the installed, and then found that costs of electric heating were far beyond what they had expected. A t the present time, there is a noticeable change in the attitude of the electric power utilities, home builders, and consumers, as the advantages offered by this type of home heat ing become better known and details o f con struction of new homes are being modified so that electricity can compete better with o il or gas. It is evident now that use of electric heat in homes w ill continue to grow at a lively pace. This article discusses some of the more im portant points involved in the installation and use of electric heat and shows why it is impor tant that certain practices be followed in con struction of the house to bring costs of heating with electricity down to reasonable figures. Owners of o il or gas heating systems w ill also find much useful information in this article. exterior walls would effect a further reduction of over 10 percent of the original fuel cost figure*. The addition of storm windows, storm doors, and weather stripping account for slightly less than a 10 percent saving. The ceiling and wall insulation plus the tighter windows and doors would give a total of about 50 percent reduction. Thus, if it costs $200 to heat the uninsulated house, it will * It was form erly the case th a t th e various kinds of insulation used in homes did not differ greatly in their insulating value. New types have been developed in recent years, however; some of these are better and some not as good as those long used. As a result, it no longer suffices to specify solely th a t a certain thickness of insulation is to be used. One should aim a t a thickness of insulation which provides specific limits of heat loss for the house. In the past year, various m em bers of the electric heating equipment industry joining with the insulation m anufacturers ami electric utility companies have adopted a so-called "All-W eather Com fort S tandard for Electrically H eated and Air Conditioned H om es'*which sets certain m aximum rates for heat flow (" U" values) through ceilings, walls, and floors, and specifies a lim iting heat-loss factor per square foot of to tal floor area based upon the clim atic conditions prevailing in the urea. T he " U " value (not to be confused w ith the " K " value which is a m easure of the insulation value of th e insulating m aterial only) is the am o u n t of heat in B tu which passes through a one-square-foot section of a wall (including plaster, insulation, and siding) in one hour when the difference in tem p erature between the tw o surfaces is one degree F ahrenheit. A typical " U" value for the ceiling in an electrically heated home is 0.05. for a window with storm sash, 0.55. Thus, in a well-insulated home, the heat loss through each square foot of window will be 11 tim es th a t through each square foot of ceiling area. It thus clearly pays to keep window area to a minimum if heating costs are an im p o rtan t consideration, and of course to use throughout the house windows of the double-glazed ty p e or regular windows with storm windows. 0008412 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 25 electricity at 1.7 cents per kilowatt-hour; 7000 Btu for 1 cent with gas at 13 cents per therm and oil at 16 cents per gallon. The cost of electricity for heating The amount spent each year to heat any home is also dependent to a considerable extent upon the temperatures maintained, the size of the house, and the region in which the house is located. It is not difficult for a person with a head for figures to estimate with reasonable accuracy how much it will cost to heat a newly constructed home with gas or oil on the basis of his past experiences, provided, of course, he has kept accurate records of his fuel costs on the dwelling previously occu pied. Electric heating is comparatively new, how ever, and thus, except in a very few areas, there is little background information available upon which to base estimates of heating costs. In order to obtain useful information on this question, Consumers' Research wrote to several large utility companies throughout the country and requested data on their rates for electricity used for electric heating, the relative popularity of the different types of electric heating systems used in the homes they serve, and the approximate yearly charges for home heating. On the basis of the information received, Consumers' Research offers the following formula for estimating the annual cost of heating a home with electric heat. It is assumed that latest construction methods are followed with regard to use of insulating materials (for example, extra insulation is required in the ceiling where ceiling heat cables are employed), storm windows, weather stripping, orientation of the house, etc. y p FA x DD x CE 50,000 YC = yearly cost of heating by electricity FA = square feet of all floor area heated D D = average degree-days per year CE =cost in cents for 1 kwhr. of electricity For example, approximate yearly cost for heating a ranch home with 1500 square feet of heated area, located in the Detroit area (6400 degree-days), where electricity costs 2 cents per kilowatt-hour for electric heating, would be about:- 1500 x 6400 50,000 x 2 = $380. electrically heated home than in one in which gas or oil supply the heat. Don't be misled by the advertising claims of a few manufacturers, sales men, and contractors that electricity is as in expensive to use as gas or oil. In general, if an honest, unbiased evaluation is made, taking into consideration costs for fuel and insulation, it will always cost more to heat with electricity, except in a very, very few areas where the lowest known rates for electricity prevail. In any particular home, to be competitive with oil at 16 cents a gallon or natural gas at 13 cents a therm, electricity must be available for house heating a t cent a kilowatt-hour. This is a phenomenally low rate for electricity and would be available only in extremely limited areas of the United States. Thus, if you pay $200 a year to heat your house with electricity at lj-^ cents per kilowatt-hour, you could heat the same house at a cost for fuel of less than $75 with oil or gas at the prices mentioned (16 cents, 13 cents). _ There are, however, other charges involved in the installation and operation of a heating system, and these tend to reduce the wide differential between costs of electric heating and gas- and oil- fired systems when fuel costs alone are considered. For example, there is no direct need for a chimney in an electrically heated home, unless the home owner desires a fireplace for reasons of its aesthetic charm, or wishes to provide some means of warm ing the home in the event that power is cut off for a substantial period, a t times (this can happen most anywhere). (But a power outage can also put a gas, oil, or coal furnace out of commission, in many cases, since these heating plants commonly have electrical auxiliaries of some kind; they always do in the case of an oil burner.) There is a second advantage with electric heat that routine maintenance charges will be low, for there is no need for an annual cleaning job. More over, one's initial investment in an electric system will normally be less than in an oil- or gas-fired system; thus carrying charges will be lower also. Finally, because individual room thermostats are usually installed with electric heat, savings may be made by setting temperatures lower in unused or seldom used rooms. Owners, aware of the higher price they pay for " fuel," are likely to take advan tage of this latter characteristic of an electric sys tem and may thus effect some savings. 26 CONSUMER BULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 Kc 0008413 > for electricity have remained pretty constant for several years. In recent years, also, the electric companies increased their generating capacity to a considerable extent in order to take care of the peak loads created by summer air conditioning. As a result, they are interested in increasing their wintertime business so as to utilize their expensive power plant and distribution equipment to better advantage, and many companies now offer special rates to users of electricity for home heating. Primary among the areas in which electric heat excels, as claimed by the equipment manufacturers and power companies, is safety; there is no flame and little danger of flare up or explosion to be con cerned about. Possibly, too, electrically heated homes are cleaner and healthier and also safer because there are no products of combustion to be spread through the house. There are, however, in some instances, small amounts of vaporized chromium present in the air where high tempera ture heating units are used, and there is reason to suppose that these are potentially harmful from the standpoint of health. In a sense, these metallic vapors tend to bring some of the outdoor atmos pheric pollution into the home just as do the fumes sometimes present from an oil burner that is not operating well. As has been noted, the temperature of individual rooms can be better controlled with electric heat than with most other methods of heating, since it is much easier to install individual thermostats in each heated area. If it should turn out that some rooms are insufficiently heated, the necessary changes in equipment can be made without much difficulty in most instances (unless rooms are heated by the use of ceiling cables). Types of electrical heat system s Three general types of installation are in wide use at the present time and each kind offers certain advantages not provided by the others. Thus, any homeowner, in choosing his own kind of instal lation, will need to evaluate certain factors con cerned with operating cost, comfort, and con venience. Heat can be transferred from one area to another in three different ways, by conduction, by con vection, and by radiation. When you touch a hot lamp bulb and burn your finger, the glass of the bulb transfers heat to your finger by conduction. A typical electric w all-m o u n ted heating u n it. If the palm of your hand feels warm when you place it close to the bulb, radiated heat causes the warming effect. If you warm your hand in the stream of warm air rising from the bulb, that heat is carried by convection. Although conduction is the fastest and most efficient means to transfer heat from burner to pot on the electric range, it is not suitable for use in house heating. Thus most of the devices in use at present depend on con vection or radiation, or a combination of the two, to heat a room. Baseboard heaters are available which are simi lar in appearance to the usual baseboard radiation used with gas- and oil-fired hot-water systems. They have an enclosed and insulated resistance element which is heated when electric current flows through it. This heat is transferred to the air in the room mainly by convection currents which enter at floor level and are directed away from the wall, to an extent, by a baffle placed at the open top of the enclosure. Baseboard heaters provide a very satisfactory means for heating a room by electricity. They should be located preferably along the walls of a room which are exposed to the outdoors. When so installed, they tend to warm the walls and thus improve comfort conditions within the room. In some instances, where an adequate length of open wall space is not available, as in some kitchens and bathrooms, it may be necessary to employ heaters mounted in the wall between studs, or a heating means known as ceiling cable to provide the amount of heat needed to keep the room comfortably warm. A popular type of electric heating device is the heater mounted in the wall. A wall heater supplies heat usually by both radiation and convection. Some brands are equipped with fans which increase slightly the amount of heat carried by convection and also contribute a slight amount of noise to an 0008414 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 27 Photo courtesy General Electric Co., Electric Heating Section, Louisville, Ky. In a r a d ia n t-h e a t ceilin g panel th e h e a tin g cable is u s u a lly stapled to th e ceiling in th e fo rm of a large g rid , covering th e whole area. A fte r in s ta lla tio n , th e cable is covered by a sm o o th p laster coat o r by a second layer of gypsum board. otherwise completely quiet s3'stem. Wall-mounted units have the disadvantage that for effective operation the area of the room immediately in front of them should be kept clear of furniture and any other articles which might be marred or other wise spoiled due to elevated temperatures brought about by their immediate proximit}' to the heat generating device. For the person living in the house, radiated heat has the advantage that it warms, immediately, that side of a person which faces the source of radiation. Resistance wire embedded in the ceiling is also widely used for electric heating in many areas of the United States. It functions principally by radiation, in that the heat is conducted from the wire to the ceiling mass--whether plaster or plasterboard--which then becomes slightly warm to the touch and a source of radiant heat over the whole room. The heat thus radiated is absorbed by anything within the room it strikes and then transferred to the room air mainly by convection. Such a system has the obvious disadvantage of a considerable lag between the time heat is called for and actually is available to warm a room (the other methods do not have this disadvantage). It should be noted that the embedded-resistancewire method of heating does not help effectively to correct the formation of cold drafts in the window areas, drafts which are one of the major sources of discomfort in homes. In another kind of system, a bank of electric resistance elements is located in a central furnace. Such.a system delivers heat to the rooms in the' same way as an oil- or gas-fired forced-warm-air lation is very costly, the heat pump, once installed, can supply heat at about one half the cost of other electrical devices in regions where the wintertime temperatures are usually above about 40 degrees. As temperatures go down, however, the efficiency of the heat pump goes down also, and it is necessay to supplement its heat-producing capabilities with resistance-type heating elements--usually built in--which are much more costly to operate. For this reason, heat pumps are far more popular in the South and Far West where winter tempera tures are only moderately cold. Electric heat isn't all peaches and cream. In addition to the disadvantages mentioned in regard to cost of operation, there are certain other limi tations connected with the special care required in respect to the construction of the home. For example, if heating costs are to be kept within . reasonable limits, such architectural features as open-beam type of construction, window-walls extending from floor to ceiling, a number of large picture windows, sliding aluminum glass doors, jalousies, and a fireplace may have to be sacrificed, for these all allow much heat to escape from the house. In addition, it will be worth while to pay particular attention to orientation of a house. Living quarters, for example, are best located on a southern exposure if large glass areas are desired; sleeping quarters should be on the north, because large window areas are not required there. In any case, over-all window area should be kept to a minimum if reasonably economical heating costs are to be realized. Readers interested in more complete information on certain aspects of electric home heating will find the following pamphlets well worth having. Electric comfort heating. Insulation and Design, 20 pages. Technical in nature. Available at 25 cents from the Electric Comfort Heating Section of the General Electric Co., Appliance Park, Louisville 1, Ky. Electric House Heating. 14 pages. A general discussion. Available at 15 cents from the Super intendent of Documents, Washington 25, D. C. Insulation Fundamentals and Insulating the Elec trically Heated and Air-Conditioned Home. Two pamphlets of general interest. Available a t 25 cents for both from the Wood Conversion Co., First National Bank Bldg., St. Paul 1, Minn. 28 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 f t If 034 c) (ASA 10) is a great disadvantage for many pur poses. A?iscochrome and Ektachrome, which are slightly coarser in grain, are three times faster, with an ASA speed of 32. Super Anscochrome and High Speed Ektachrome are used where the light level is low, or fast shutter speeds and small / stops are needed; they have high speeds of ASA 100 and 160, respectively. Kodacolor film has a speed of ASA 32 and Agfacolor, which is available in two emulsions, has speeds of ASA 20 for CN14 and ASA 40 for CN17. - A new booklet entitled " Clicking With Color," published by Eastman Kodak Co. and priced at 35 cents, is highly recommended by Consumers' Research as a well written and convenient guide for amateurs in the taking of color photographs. Processing of negative color films Kodacolor film is developed and printed by many processing laboratories in addition to those direct ly controlled by Eastman Kodak Company. Prices for this processing vary greatly, as does the quality of the finished prints. Consumers' Research checked the work of some well-known photofinishers who have run large ads in the popu lar photographic magazines, as well as one labora tory well known to CR for their processing of slide films. A roll of film was sent also to Eastman Kodak Co. a t Rochester, N.Y., for their process ing. Each roll of film included the same subjects taken with the same lighting conditions at the same time of day with the same camera. Expo sures were closely set on the basis of readings of a good exposure meter. The exposed films were then sent to the various processors for developing and printing. A roll of Agfacolor CN14 film was also exposed under the same conditions and was sent to Perfect Photo, Inc., in Philadelphia. (Per fect is the only processor that can process Agfacolor film in the U.S. at present.) When the finished film was received (and this took from 7 to 12 days), the prints were laid out on a table and a panel of persons, most of whom take pictures only on rare occasions, viewed them and chose the set that seemed to them to be best. This panel for the most part judged the pictures on a basis of personal appeal of the finished prints and did not take into account many of the short comings of the various processors' work, such as F ig u re 1-- T h e above photograph is fro m a p r in t m ad e d ire c tly from an Agfacolor CN14 negative. T h e b lack-an d -w h ite p rin t was m ade on Kodak M edalist No. 3 paper. scratches and spots, which were all too common. The choice between the two types of film went by a large margin to the Agfacolor film. The com ment made by most was on the " snap and sparkle" of the Agfacolor prints. However, the few experi enced amateur photographers on the panel chose the Kodacolor prints on the basis of good color rendition. As far as the quality of processing went, there were great differences among the various photo finishers. The results from Perfect Photo, Inc., on Agfacolor left much to be desired. Many of their prints bore very noticeable scratches and some were" spotted. The Kodacolor finishers pro duced varying results. Eastman Kodak made the best prints in our judgment, with Free Film Co. a close second. Others produced one or more blurred prints, or prints with poor color, and one set had a foggy haze on all the pictures. We would judge from the brief test that lowpriced photofinishing is no bargain, unless for pictures one does not prize greatly. Lord Film Labs, which advertises heavily in the photo maga zines a price of $2 for processing and printing a roll of eight Kodacolor pictures, returned prints that were approximately contact print size. (No size was mentioned in the ad.) All the others supplied so-called " 3x" size prints or prints about 3 x 4J^ inches. The original film was No. 120, with frames 2/xf x inches in size. The Lord CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 29 a projector or hand viewer to examine their pictures, but at best color prints still remain far below color transparencies in visual qual ity. This rule applies almost universally, since even the less careful and competent processors of color transparencies do a good jo b compared with processing work done at the present on color prints. Two exceptions to the above rule should perhaps be noted. Recently portrait photographers have produced direct-color prints (Type C) o f very fine visual quality and clean color. However, these are expensive. There are also still more expensive color prints, used in superior magazine and adver tising illustrations, but these are priced far out o f the range o f interest to amateur photog raphers-- except, o f course, to the very few to whom money is no object. These fine color prints, which may be used for preparing beautiful calendar and magazine illustrations in four-color halftones, cost from $50 to $200 each. The process used for these costly prints is entirely different from that which turns out mass-production prints on paper from either negative or positive color film. prints were not in sharp focus (the negatives were sharp) and the colors were poor. Free film? A new facet to Kodacolor processing is the offer of free film with each processing order. When the user sends in a roll of film for processing, the processing laboratory returns the finished prints and a new roll of the same kind of film, all for the price of processing alone. Some years ago this would have appeared to be a bargain, and if you arc one that buys films and processing at list price at the corner drug store, it is a bargain. List price of a No. 120 roll of Kodacolor film is $1.35 and processing of an eight-exposure roll by East man Kodak will cost $3.22, giving a total of $4.57. If you send your film to the Free Film Company, for example, this processing will cost $3.21, and they will send you a roll of fresh Kodacolor a t no and printing a t $2.25, then the Free Film plan does not offer any particular advantage. How ever, the catch to low-cost processing, and it is important, is the quality of the finished product. From what we have seen of low-priced photo finishers of negative color film, the results are likely to be highly variable and, for the most part, rather unsatisfactory. Agfacolor film would appear to have a great future if the quality of processing can be improved by Perfect Photo, Inc., and if they can consider ably reduce the time required for the service. (A 5 x 7 inch enlargement took over two weeks.) The following photofinishers are rated on Koda color processing only, except Perfect Photo, Inc , which is rated on Agfacolor processing. A. Recommended Eastman Kodak Co. (Rochester 4, N.Y.) $3.22 for developing and printing 8 pictures from a No. 120 roll. Prints, 3x size (3 x 4j/ in., approximately). Quality of work, very good; there were no scratches or spotting of prints. Free Film Co. (P. O. Box 1, Morris Heights Sta., New York 53) $3.21 for developing and printing 8 pictures from a No. 120 roll. Prints, 3x size. A "fresh-dated" roll of Kodacolor film was returned with the finished prints. No scratches or spots, but some of the prints were judged to be on the dark side. C. Not Recommended Lord Film Labs (P.O. Box 243, New York 51) $2 for developing and printing 8 prints from a No. 120 roll. Prints, approximately the same size as the original nega tive. The negatives were sharp, but the prints were not. Master Color Labs (General Post Office Box 30, Newark 1, N.J.) $2.25 for developing and printing 8 . prints from a No. 120 roll. Prints, 3x size. Prints ap peared to be somewhat veiled by haze. Colors were off; green grass appeared brownish. Perfect Photo, Inc. (P.O. Box 7100, Philadelphia 17, Pa.) $3.22 for developing and printing 8 pictures from a No. 120 roll of Agfacolor film. Prints, 3x size. While the prints had better than average sparkle and snap, some were scratched badly and some had spots on them. For the present, the rating given Perfect Piioto finish ing will apply also to Agfacolor film since at this time it can be processed only at Perfect Photo, Inc. CR will watch this film and its processing closely, anil if the quality of the finished product changes, a new rating will be given. 30 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 K Jr 0008417 of driving. The type of driving is important. Generally speaking, a plug will reach an accept able operating temperature at a certain driving speed, say 35 miles per hour in a particular case; then as the car's speed goes up, so does the plug temperature until a t some steady higher speed, perhaps 80 miles per hour, the plug becomes too hot, even reaches preignition temperatures. In another car, the limits of steady speed for proper spark plug temperatures might be, say, 20 and 50 miles per hour. Clearly, selection of the right plug depends in part on the kind of service the car will be used for, and the way the car is driven. A black deposit which is wet and oily on a plug indicates that the engine pumps oil, or perhaps that the plug was not firing, because of a defect in the ignition system or the plug itself. If the possibility of ignition failure is ruled out, the proper remedy is to find and correct the cause of oil pumping. Pending this, slight or temporary improvement of the condition can sometimes be obtained by use of a hotter plug. If you are using too hot a plug (remember this is one designed to dissipate heat slowly and thus to get hot), electrode wear, especially of the center electrode, will be too rapid. In judging the condi tion of the electrodes and deciding whether ero sion occurs too quickly, nothing can replace the experience of an expert who has seen thousands of plugs at various stages of normal wear. How ever, you can take as a rough guide the claims of plug manufacturers that their products, if prop erly cared for, should give good service for 10,000 miles. Actually, considerably longer service is often possible. If a plug can be cleaned and " regapped" to the proper distance between the metal electrodes, and no defect is apparent, there is no need to throw it away merely because of its age and honorable service. Proper care of spark plugs includes inspection, cleaning, and regapping a t regular intervals-- about every 5000 miles on a new car and more frequently as the car gets older, perhaps every 2000 to 3000 miles after the car has run 30,000 miles. Plugs should be handled with care to avoid cracking of the ceramic insulation. When practicable, use a round wire feeler gauge to set the gap; a flat gauge is not suited to the purpose because worn electrodes are not flat and hence the space between them varies. On cars with F ig u re 2-- T h e p ro tru d in g -n o s e ty p e of plug is show n In th e d ia g ra m on th e le ft; a c onventio nal design w ith s lig h tly recessed nose is on th e rig h t. (These d iag ra m s are fro m th e T e c h n ic a l M an u al of M o to r M aster Products Corp.) aluminum engines, don't remove plugs while the engine is hot. With plugs that require gasket washers, always use new washers when you put the plugs back in place. The washers are com pressed as the plugs are screwed in and this makes the seal. It is best to use a torque wrench in seat ing plugs, so they will be screwed in tight enough, but not too tight. If you don't have a torque wrench, use a wrench with a 10-inch handle. Tighten a solid gasket snug with the 10-inch wrench; a folded gasket should be compressed by about one half turn of the plug after it is " finger tight." Protruding nose design On some plugs, the nose of the insulator protrudes beyond the shell (see Figure 2). This is said to expose the insulator to the inrushing gas-air mix ture in the cylinder and provide some cooling ef fect which increases with engine speed. Such plugs are said to run hotter at slow speeds and cooler at high speeds than conventional plugs. The exposed-nose plugs are designed primarily for overhead valve V-8 engines, and with some other types of engines such plugs cannot be used be cause of space limitations. R eplace 'em all? If you have one or two bad plugs, should you replace them all? Not necessarily. If plugs of a set are equally old and some fail apparently due to age and wear, it may make sense to replace them all. However, contrary to some more or less legendary beliefs, it is not necessary to change all the plugs just so that all plugs shall be of the same make or even the same heat range. Equiva- K" 0008418 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 31 which have good reputations in the industry are: Acme, Auburn, Blue Crown, Leonard, Motor Master, and " private brands" of big mail-order firms such as Montgomery Ward and Sears. In certain cases, spark plugs of different heat ranges may be best for different cylinders, as judged by an expert observing the condition of the removed plugs. To facilitate consideration of this factor, one should keep plugs in order when removed for inspection and put each one back into the cylinder from which it came. It is help ful also to keep a record of the mileage reading a t which each plug is installed. Spark plugs that are " not" spark plugs There is a constant stream of advertising in maga zines and newspapers and by direct mail for vari ous novelty-type spark plugs, which it is claimed will do wonders for your car. Some of these de vices are said not to be spark plugs, but are called " igniters," or " fire injectors," or by other names. All such gadgets that we have seen are spark plugs in the sense that when one of them is used, the gas-air mixture in the cylinder is ignited by a spark. Fancy names and fancy claims notwith standing, the specialty plugs do not give signifi cantly better gas mileage, greater horsepower, or other improvement. N ovelty plugs cost m ore, don't last as long The main difference between novelty plugs and ordinary ones is that the special plugs don't come in appropriate heat ranges, and therefore don't stand up in service, unless you're lucky. One kind of plug is advertised as similar to aircraft plugs, and therefore somehow presumably supe rior for cars. W hat the advertisers don't point out is that radial engines for aircraft run much cooler than car engines, so that a plug type suit able for one use is not necessarily good for the other. The real differences in spark plug behavior occur after periods of use. The " special" plugs are no better than ordinary ones when new, and in general they don't stand up. An experienced service manager reported to Consumers' Research that he sees the various novelty plugs frequently in cars coming in for repair, and th at they are commonly in poor condition even after as little as 2000 or 3000 miles of driving. Comparative tests of performance with " in jectors" and ordinary spark plugs have been made lor special or novelty plugs. An interesting sidelight of the Science and Mechanics report is that " igniters" showed up exceptionally well on a spark plug tester even though the same plugs did not give better than ordinary results in an engine. This apparent anomaly leads to the question: W hat do the testers test? Spark plug "testers" Almost every auto repair shop has a device for testing spark plugs by firing them continuously by rapidly repeated high-voltage impulses in an enclosed chamber at various controlled air pres sures. A window made of heavy glass permits observation of the spark. When the pressure gets high enough, the spark is " quenched" and the pressure needed to accomplish this result is taken as a measure of the plug's performance. Such a test even at atmospheric pressure, or at relatively low pressures, will show up invisible cracks in insulation or electrical discontinuities in the high tension path within the plug. However, the conditions in a compression tester are not at all the same as those in an engine, and unless specific delects are exhibited, the results of tests in these devices need not be given any great weight in deciding whether or not to discard a plug. Used plugs can often be made quite suitable for continued use by light sandblasting (heavy blasts roughen the surface and speed up future deposits) and cleaning of the electrodes by filing or sandpapering the sparking surfaces--giving particular attention to the inside surface of the ground electrode because this surface is not likely to be much affected by sandblast cleaning. A plug rejuvenated in this way and properly re gapped will probably not show up as well in a tester as a new plug, because the sharp edges of the electrodes in a new plug help it to spark at higher pressures. But this difference is temporary and largely eliminated by spark erosion in a few hundred miles of operation. In short, a compression tester in expert hands can give useful information about certain defects of plugs, but don't let an ignorant or unscrupulous operator use the testing device merely as a gadget to promote sales of new plugs when perhaps your old ones are still capable of doing very well if cleaned and regapped. 32 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 KB 0008419 still during the spring because of the writers' the effect is the same." Oddly enough, this type strike, have begun to appear in greater numbers. of picture is not particularly profitable, according The present trend is toward what the trade calls to Variety, which reports that since Bridge on the " hard ticket" shows. These are movies, usually River Kwai and Young Lions no war drama has lavish productions, that are put on like a play, really " hit it big" at the box office, only twice a day, with tickets priced somewhat An excellent article in the American Legion above the run-of-the-mill rate. The best seller of Magazine, September 1960, by Howard Stephen- this type on the current scene is Ben Ilur, which son, raised the question as to whether the current runs for 4 ^ hours, with seats (Loew's, N.Y.C.) at practice of emphasizing crooks, including crooked $1.50 to $3.50. Following in the footsteps of Ben law enforcement officials, unethical businessmen, Ilur are The Alamo, Pepe, Exodus, Cimarron, and sordid environment, oppression of minorities, as Spartacus. well as murder, rape, infidelity, and homosexuality The " hard ticket" policy of presenting a motion may not be a definite propaganda technique to- picture in the same way as a theatrical production discredit American ideals. He points out that is reported to make money for the film producers, the net effect sought by the propagandists is to- but the technique does nothing whatever for the plant doubt in people's minds, to slant their ideas, local distributor in the neighborhood theater who and to brainwash them into thinking that the cannot get customers at such prices and must, film correctly portrays their economy, their therefore, depend on less spectacular pictures that political system, and that the American way of he can run for only two or three days. As we have life is corrupt, immoral, and generally decadent, noted before, good family pictures, for showing Certainly if the recent crop of motion pictures in what the trade calls the " nabes" (neighborhood were well patronized, some of these objectives houses), are hard to find. Even sophisticated might well be attained. critics have reported alarm at the sight of children As one critic pointed out, not every good whole standing in line to see Psycho. some screen play pays off at the box office, but The dean of motion picture critics, who has there have been outstanding examples in recent been a proponent of "adult pictures," has also com- years that might well be copied by other producers, plained about the subject matter of current mo- W alt Disney, for example, produced Shaggy Dog, tion pictures. Bosley Crowther in the New York Sleeping Beauty, and Pollyanna, which enjoyed Times decried certain " seamy little pictures," considerable success and were well worth family " vice and violent films," and the " distinctly viewing. The Alamo, which is currently playing vicious films" being shown in neighborhood to large audiences in the big cities, is a majestic theaters. John Crosby, television critic, of the portrayal of the battle to the death of one hundred New York Herald Tribune, and a vigorous op- eighty-five free men rebelling against a tyrant ponent of " censorship," denounced in forthright that is suitable for all but the very young, who terms the " multiple adulteries" shown in such might be emotionally upset by the tragic ending, films as From the Terrace and The Apartment, Exhibitors of sex and sin in technicolor are pointing out that it was " quite a problem nowa- given to crying " censorship" when there is the days finding a movie to take the children to." He slightest suggestion that youngsters and teenagers commented favorably on the French censorship should not be permitted to attend performances of TV based on the belief that a diet of violence of lurid sex dramas and brutal, violent, blood- is not good for grownups or children. thirsty crime melodramas. The fact that the The number of pictures that portray the grim public is staying home in droves from the movies and beastly side of warfare and take delight in seems to have escaped them completely. Now belittling patriotism is also excessive and the that the New York critics have indicated that theme is much overdone. As Variety, the leading they, too, are revolted or at the very least bored trade journal, reported last fall: " World Wars . with the excess of perversity shown in intimate One and Two, along with the Korean conflict are detail and at length, perhaps producers will lend about to be fought all over again on the nation's an ear and turn out good wholesome shows to screens. In addition to the three war dramas in which the whole family can go for an evening's- current release, no less than 13 more are either entertainment. 00034.20 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 3^ Klemperer. Angel S 35661. S5.98. Dramatic, heavy play ing of a lesser Beethoven symphony. The distant mike pickup, which has a tencjency to fuse the sound, doesn't aid matters. No question the interpretation is marvelous in its tvay. But don't overlook other ways and other record ings. A A Beethoven: The Middle Quartets (Op. 59 Nos. 1-3, Op. 74, Op. 95). Budapest String Quartet. 8 sides, Columbia M4S 616. $23.92. One of the outstanding sets of the season. Great music, performed by the most widely heard quartet the world has ever known. Though Roismann's tone, as first violin, and occasionally his facility, seem less effective than a decade ago, the group commands the ut most respect and admiration. Often the sound is rough, but that's in keeping with the music. Meticulous, but never over-fussy attention to details. Brilliant, crystal clear sound which discloses the slightest blemish in per formance. AA AA Brahms: Violin Concerto. Kogan with the Phil harmonia Orchestra under Kondrashin. Angel S 35690. $5.98. Kogan is one of the smoothest sounding violinists now recording, but he rarely gets beneath the surface of this deep, Germanic masterpiece. Look to three or four other recordings for that. The orchestra is no great shakes either, particularly the solo oboe. Satisfactory sound, with orchestra somewhat distant, soloist at the best sounding distance. BA Bruckner: Symphony No. 9. Columbia Symphony under Bruno Walter. Columbia MS 6171. $5.98. Bruckner died without completing this symphony, but the great concluding Adagio will long live in the hearts of those who know it. Bruno Walter uncovers the exaltation with all the skill at his command. His orchestra is first class. The sound is fittingly spacious, though the volume level is low, and the contrast between loud and soft passages is not as pronounced as in the best recordings. AA B Dvorak: Three Great Symphonies. Cleveland Orches tra under Szell. 6 sides, Epic BSC 109. $17.96. Included are Op. 70, 88, 95. Szell never dawdles over a sentimental phrase, preferring straightforward, disciplined interpreta tion. Some may prefer more flexibility and sentiment in these direct-to-the-heart, melodic, ingratiating symphonies that include just enough drama to keep the interest high. The engineers have produced a good compromise in sound, not too much hall, yet not too little. But the sound is a bit hard. AA Handel: VAllegro ed II Penseroso. Addison, McCol lum, Reardon, Orchestra and Chorus under Waldman. 4 sides, Decca DX 7165. $11.98. Handel's notable settings to poems of Milton depict the cheerful man {L'Allegro sung by tenor and bass) and the melancholy dreamer {II Pen seroso sung by soprano). Unfortunately, Adele Addison falls short of her difficult task. John McCollum emerges clearly as a gifted, knowledgeable tenor who finds an able associate in John Reardon. The direction rocks along, but doesn't inject the life into the score I believe is there. This is not a perfectly realized presentation. Fairish recording. BA Handel: Organ Concerti, Op. 4 Nos. 1-3. Kohler (organ) with the String Orchestra of the Leipzig Gewand haus Orchestra under Thomas. Epic BC 1101. $5.98. Enchanting, melodic works which pit the organ against the orchestra. Expressively played, transparently recorded, with justtheright balancebetween instruments. AA AA Mendelssohn: Symphony No. 4 & Brahms: Variations on a Theme by Haydn. Vienna Symphony under Sawallisch. Epic BC 1098. $5.98. To the ex perienced ear, it doesn't take many measures before you the stylus advanced, the promise became the fact. The Variations stand in the forefront of Brahms' orchestral works. No respectable library should be without them. Transparent, spacious recording. AA AA Mozart: Clarinet Concerto, De Peyer (clarinet), and Horn Concerto Nos. I and 3, Tuckwell (horn). London Symphony under Maag. London CS 6178. $5.98. The clarinet concerto, surely a masterpiece, is masterfully played. The phrasing, particularly, is beautiful. The Horn Concerto No. 1 I find a lesser work, but No. 3 recalls Mozart at his best and demands a first-class horn player. Tuckwell qualifies easily. The recording of the clarinet concerto sounds silky, but the horn concerti require a bit more volume, and fall a trifle short of the admirable sound overside. AA A Paganini: Caprices. Ricci (violin alone). London CS 6163. $5.98. Short pieces (24 of them) which tax the technique of the greatest violinists. Ricci"has been identified with this music for about 20 years. Though occasionally his playing sounds rough and a bit off pitch, he sins seldom. Most violinists will regard this as a MUST. Very well recorded, too. AA AA ** * Baker's Dozen. Don Baker (organ). Capitol T 1363. $3.98. For a decade Baker played the organ at New York City's Paramount Theater. Here he plays the mighty Robert Morton pipe organ weighing 17,000 pounds. But . it doesn't blast you out of the house unless you turn the volume too high. "Londonderry Air," "Riders in the Sky," "Adios," "The Moon Was Yellow," and other pleasant tunes played in good taste and well recorded. AA AA Germany Revisited. Carola Kraus (singer) and Alfons Bauer and Orchestra. Capitol T 10247. $3.98. Pleasant listening. Principally polkas and march tunes such as you might hear in a Biergarten. But there are modern twists, too, which make the disk unique. There's per sonality in the singer's voice and a strong umpha in the band. Yodels and a zither, naturally. AA A Informally Yours. Carmen Cavallero (piano). Decca DL 74017. $4.98. Continuous and varied music gliding from "Just One of Those Things" to "Falling in Love with Love," "I'll Follow My Secret Heart," "The Most Beau tiful Girl in the World." Easy listening and good record ing, though there is some background noise now and then. AA A Irish Sing Along (Mixed Chorus). London TW 91234. $4.98. The popularity of "sing along" disks gets a boost from this nostalgic release which includes "When Irish Eyes are Smiling," "Peggy O'Neill," "Mother Machree," "Macushla," and similar numbers. Very well recorded, as is its companion disk, German Sing Along, on London TW 91237. AA AA Soft Swaying Strings. The Knightsbridge Strings. Top Rank RM 341. $3.98. Arranged for string orchestra are 12 standard pieces which may suggest our 50th state. An Hawaiian guitar here and there brightens the scene and adds local color. The beat from the percussion section promotes dancing. Included are "South Sea Island Magic," "Honolulu Blues," "Trade Winds," etc. Expertly played and satisfactorily recorded. AA A The Connoisseur's Handel. Deller, Poulter, Brown, Bevan (singers) with the Handel Festival Orchestra under Lewis. Bach Guild BGS 5029. $5.95. A dozen arias and concerted numbers from operas and oratorios infrequently heard. Obviously these singers are experts in the style, and they produce most enjoyable sounds. Included is music from Jeplha, Serse, Orlando, L'Allegro, Rinaldo, Theodora. The engineering is good. AA AA 34 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 0008421 thus do not represent the judgment of a single person, but are based on an analysis of critics' reviews. car-- cartoon com-- comedy cri--crime and capture of criminals The sources of the reviews are: doc--docum entary dr-- dram a Boxojfiee, Cue, D aily N ews (N. Y.), The Exhibitor, Film s in Review, J o in t Estimates of fa n --fan tasy Current M otion Pictures, Motion Picture Herald, N otional Legion o f Decency, N ew York hist--founded on historical incident I Herald Tribune, New York Times, The N ew Yorker, Parents' M agazine, Release o f the D. A . R . Preview Committee, Reviews and Ratings by the P rotestant M otion Picture Council. The Tablet, Time, Variety (weekly). The figures preceding the title of the picture indicate the number of critics whose judgments of its entertainment values warrant a met-- melodrama m u$-- musical mys-- m ystery nov---dram atization of a novel rom--rom ance ' rating ofA (recommended), B(intermediate), or C (not recommended). set--science fiction soc--social-problem dram a Audience suitability is indicated by "A" for adults, "Y" for trav--travelogue young people (14-18), and "C" for children, at the end of each line. war--dealing w ith the lives of people in w artim e wes-- w estern ABC 6 5 2 Alamo, T h e..............................hist-dr-c AYC -- -- 3 4 1 All in a N igh t's Work.................... com-c A 8 A11 the Fine Young C an n ib als... .dr-c A -- 5 7 A11 th e Y oung M en...................... war-dr AY -- 2 1 Am azing Mr. C allaghan, T h e.mys-mel A -- 3 3 Amazing Transparent Man, _ 5 T h e.................................................. sci-dr AY 7 Angel Wore Red, T h e .........................dr-c A -- 1 3 Another Sky (B ritish)........................... dr A -- 5 2 As the Sea Rages (G erm an)..............dr AY -- 2 1 Aunt from Chicago, The (Greek)........................................... com A Y -- 3 6 Battle in Outer Space _ 3 (Japanese).......................................sci-c AY 9 Bell Boy, T h e .................... com AY 2 2 1 Belles and Ballets (F ren ch ).. . .doc-c AY -- 4 3 Between Time and Eternity _ 2 (G erm an)............................................dr-c A 3 Beyond th e T im e Barrier............ sci-dr AY -- 7 -- Boy Who Stole a Million, The _ 2 (Spanish)...................................cri-dr AYC 4 Breath of Scandal, A .......................com-c A -- 7 3 Brides of Dracula, The _ 3 _ (B ritish)..........................................mel-c AY Bridge, The (G erm an).......................... dr A -- 5 5 Butterfield 8........................................ nov-c A -- 2 6 Cage of Evil....................................cri-mel AY 1 5 5 C aptain's Table, T he (B ritish )..com-c A --- .-- . 3 Career G irl............................................dr-c A -- 6 -- Chartroose C aboose.................. com-c AYC .-- 3 -- C im arron........................................... nov-c AY -- 2 1 C inderFella............................... mus-fan-c AY -- 2 1 Circle of D ecep tion ............................... dr A -- 1 6 College C onfidential............................. dr A -- 4 5 Come Dance w ith Me (French).. .dr-c A -- 3 2 Confess, Dr. Korda! (G erm an).cri-mel A -- 2 2 Counterfeit Coin, T he (G reek)........ dr A -- 2 1 Counterfeit Traitor, T h e ... .war-dr-c AY -- 6 3 Crowded Sky, T h e .............................. dr-c A -- . 2 4 Crowning Experience, T h e ...................................... propaganda-c A ,_ 13 3 Dark at th e Top of th e Stairs, The .dr-c A .-- 3 -- Day of th e P a in ter......................... doc-c AY -- 6 4 Day They Robbed the Bank of _ 4 England, T h e (British), .mys-mel AYC 7 Desire in th e D u st.................................dr A -- 2 2 Dog, a Mouse, and a Sputnik, A ( F r e n c h ) ................................. com A A BC -- 3 2 D on d i.........................................................dr AY -- 7 2 Dreams (Sw edish)....................................dr A 1 2 1 Elevator to th e Gallows (F ren ch ).. .dr A 1 10 5 Elmer G antry.........................................dr-c A -- 8 2 End of Innocence (A rgentine).............dr A -- 3 6 Enem y General, T h e ...................... war-dr A -- 7 6 Entertainer, The (B ritish )....................dr A -- 3 -- Escape to Berlin (G erm an)................ dr AY 1 2 1 Exodus................................................. nov-c AY -- 3 -- Facts of Life, T h e .............................. com-c A -- 3 1 F anny....................................................mus-dr-cA -- 5 3 Fast and Sexy (French-Italian).co>n-e AY -- 2 1 Fedra, th e Devil's D aughter (Sp anish)............................................... dr A -- 3 1 Fever in the Blood, A ............................. dr A -- 3 1 Flam ing Star, T h e ........................... mel-c AY 1 2 3 Flute and theArrow, The (In d ia)............................................. dr-c AY -- 6 1 For the Love of M ike...............................dr-cAYC -- 5 2 Freckles.........................................................dr-cAYC -- 1 3 General Della Roverc (Italian), .war-dr A -- 5 2 G.I. B lu es..................................mus-com-c AY -- -- 3 Girl in Lovers' Lane, T h e ................... mel A -- 1 4 Girl of th e N ig h t................................soc-dr A -- 3 -- Go Naked in th e W orld.................... nov-c A -- -- 3 Goddess of Love (Italian ).................mel-c A -- 2 1 Goliath and the Dragon (Italian )............................................ adv-c A -- 2 2 Good Girls Beware (French)..............mel A -- 2 1 Grass is Greener, T h e ............................ dr A 1 3 --- Great Day, T he (S p an ish ).............. dr AYC -- 1 2 Great Im poster, T h e ............................dr A -- 2 1 Great K night, The (Ita lia n )........... dr-c AY -- -- -- Green Carnation, The (see Trials of Oscar Wilde) -- 2 1 G uns of the Navarone, T he. .war-dr-c AY -- 3 -- Half P in t, T h e .............................................comAYC -- 3 -- Hand in Hand (B ritish )..............................drAYC -- 3 5 Hannibal (Italian )...........................dr-c AY -- 2 5 Head of a Tyrant (Italian )................ dr-c A -- 6 3 Heaven on Earth (Ita lia n )........... dr-c AYC -- 4 1 Hell is a City (B ritish)....................cri-mel A 1 3 10 Hell to E tern ity................................ war-dr A -- -- 3 H ideout in th e S u n ......................cri-mel-c A -- 1 7 High Powered Rifle, T h e ..........cri-mel AY 1 7 6 High T im e.............................. mus-com-c AY CONSUMER B ULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 35 .. ' -: : (Sw iss).................................................... dr A 9 3 It Started in N aples............................dr-c A -- 2 1 Ivan the Conqueror (Italian) .kist-dr-c AY __ 2 2 Journey to the Lost City. .adv-c AY -- 12 3 10 I Jungle C at. .. ................................adv-c AYC -- 6 3 Key W itness....................................cri-dr A -- -- 4 Kill Her G en tly ................. .......... cri-mel A -- 3 -- Kill Me Tomorrow (B ritish). . cri-mel AY -- 5 6 Last Days of Pompeii, The (Italian ).................................................. dr-cA -- 2 2 Last Woman on Earth, The _ (B ritish)................................................mel-cA 1 4 Legions of th e Nile (Italian ).........mel-c A -- 5 7 Let No Man Write My E pitaph.soc-mel A 2 8 7 Let's Make Love....................................com-cA -- 3 -- Little Shepherd of Kingdom C om e...............................................dr-c AYC -- 2 1 Little Shop of Horrors, The __ (B ritish)...............................................cri-drA 3 Louisiana H u ssy.......................................mdA -- 1 3 Love Gam e, The (French)....................comA 3 Loves of a Greek in Paris (G reek). .dr A ~ 3 Ma Barker's Killer Brood........... cri-md A -- .-- 3 Madame X (Greek)....................................drA -- 3 .-- Magic Boy (Japanese)..................car-c AYC -- 4 3 M agnificent Seven, T h e ...............wes-c AY -- 3 -- M ajestic Isla n d .............................Irav-c AYC -- 3 1 Make M ine Mink (B ritish)........c-ri-com A -- 3 3 Marie Octobre (French)........... war-dr AY -- 3 1 M arriage-G o-Round............................com-cA -- 1 2 M enace in the N ight (B ritish).cri-md AY 1 8 3 M idnight Lace...........................mys-dr-c AY -- 2 1 M issile from Hell (B ritish)......... war-dr A -- 2 1 M istress, The (Japanese).........................drA -- 1 3 Model for Murder (British). . . .cri-mel A -- -- 3 Morals S q u a d ........................................ cri-drA -- 9 4 Murder, Inc......................................... cri-dr-cA -- 3 -- M ysteries of the D eep..................doc-c AYC -- 2 1 Naked and the Wicked, The (Italian )...................................................mdA 1 2 1 Naked N igh t, The (Sw edish)............. dr A -- 3 -- N atchez T race....................................hist-melA -- 3 2 Never Let Go (B ritish)......................cri-melA -- 6 4 Never on Sunday (Greek)..................... comA -- 4 2 Next to No Tim e (B ritish ).........com-c AY -- 5 2 N ight Fighters, T h e ................... war-dr AY -- 4 6 Nights of Lucretia Borgia, The _ (Italian ).................................................. dr-cA 1 3 No Morals (French)........................... cri-melA 1 4 1 North to A laska.................................... com-cA __ 7 8 Ocean's E leven................................... cri-dr-cA 2 S 5 Oscar Wilde (B ritish ).............................biogA -- 2 5 Ostrich Has Two Eggs, The (French).................................................... drA _ 2 1 P arrish........................................................ dr-cA 2 5 -- Pepe........................................... mus-com-c AY -- 1 5 Picnic on th e Grass (French)......... dr-c A -- 4 1 Please Turn Over (B ritish)......................drA -- 3 2 Plunderers, T h e........................................mdA ---- 4 Port of Desire (French)............................drA -- 2 1 Prisoners of the C ongo........................mel-cA -- -- .3 Private Lives of Adam and Eve, T h e........................................................... comA 2 9 3 P sycho..................................................mys-melA 6 2 Savage Innocents (B ritish). . . . doc-dr-c A 1 10 --1 ---- 2 School for Scoundrels (B ritish ). . . com A 4 Secret of th e Purple Reef, .mys-mel-c A V 3 See Naples and Die (Ita lia n )............ dr A -- 5 6 Septem ber S torm .....................................dr-cAY .-- -- -- -- 6 2 -- 3 1 3 5 -- Seven Ways from S u n d o w n .. .wes-c AYC Sex K ittens Go to C ollege............... com A Sexpot (French)..................................... dr A S hadow s..............................................soc-dr A --1 ---- --1 --4 --2 2 Shakedown, The (B ritish ).........cri-mel A 3 Sham eless Sex (Italian ).......................dr A 2 She Walks by Night (Germ an). . . . md A 1 Sign of Zoro..................................... adv A YC 1 Sin and Desire (French)......................dr A 1 10 --7 5 Sons and Lovers (B ritish)................... dr A 3 S.O.S. Pacific (B ritish)...................... mel A 4 -- 6 3 3 Spartacus...............................................dr-c A o1"2 Splendor in th e G rass....................... dr-c Squad C ar............................................-.md A A _ 4 2 Stop! Look! and L au gh !............ com AYC -- 4 6 Studs L onigan...................................... nov A -- 3 12 Subterraneans, T h e ................mus-com-c A -- 22 1 Sum m er of th e 17th Doll (British) . .dr A Sundowners, T h e ...........................dr-c AYC 6 6 3 Sunrise a t C am pobello....................... biog-cAY -- 4 7 Surprise P ackage........................... cri-md A -- 1 2 Sweet Life, The (Italian ).................... dr A 1 3 -- Swiss Fam ily R obinson.............. adv AYC 8 4 Tarzan, the Magnificent _ -- (B ritish).................................................mcl-cAY 3 . 1 Ten Who D ared.......................kist-dr-c AYC 7 4 13 G h osts...................................mys-mel AYC 1 6 7 39 Steps, The (B ritish)....mys-mel-c AY 2 1 Three Forbidden Stories __ 3 __ (Ita lia n ).......................................... soc-dr A Three Worlds of Gulliver, T h e.fan-c AYC -- 4 5 Three-Penny Opera, The (G erm an)..................................... mus-dr A 1 8 4 T im e M achine, T h e ................................sci-cAY -- -- 7 Trapped in Tangier (Italian )................................... cri-mel-c A Y 2 3 5 Trials of Oscar Wilde, The (B ritish ).......................................... biog-c A __ 3 3 6 Twelve to th e M oon................sci-md AYC Two Faces of Dr. Jekyll, The (B ritish)..............................................dr-c A 3 Unasham ed, T h e ................................... dr A -- 10 7 Under Ten Flags (Italian ).......... war-dr A -- 5 31 Village of th e Dam ned (British) . .sci AY Virgin Spring, The (Sw edish)...........dr A --3 Wackiest Ship in the Army, __ 7 T h e ......................... .................war-com AY 4 Walk Like a D ragon................................... drAY -- 2 5 Walk T a ll....................... wes-c AY -- 2 4 W alking Target, T h e ......................... cri-mdAY -- 1 2 Wasted Lives and the Birth of .- 4 T w in s............................................. soc-doc A 5 Weddings and B abies.................... doc-dr A -- 3 1 Where th e Boys A re......................com-c A Y -- 4 7 Where th e Hot Wind Blows (French) dr A -- 3 5 Why M ust I D ie?...........................soc-mel A -- 2 3 Wicked Go to Hell, T he (French), .dr A -- 3 07 Wild R apture...................................... Irav-docAY Wild Ride, T h e ..................................... mel A r_ 2 1 Wizard of Bagdad, T h e .............adv-c AYC -- 6 1 World of Apu (India)................................. drAY -- 4 3 World of Suzie Wong, T h e .............. dr-c A -- 2 8 Y oung Jesse J a m e s........................wes-dr A 36 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 Nat i onal Bonded Car s I nc. , and Sur e Car of Amer i ca I nc. Most buyer s of secondhand car s wi l l j ust have t o t r ust t o t hei r own j udgment i n maki ng a pur chase, or bet t er st i l l empl oy f i r st - r at e aut o mechani cs t o sur vey car e f ul l y t he car s t hey have i n mi nd t o buy. - *** THOSE NEW LABELS AND TAGS r equi r ed by t he Text i l e Fi ber Pr oduct s I den t i f i cat i on Act ar e causi ng conf usi on among consumer s. The f avor i t e st or y among sal es peopl e i s t hat of t he cust omer who pi cks up a gar ment and r e mar ks: " The l abel says t hi s i s Dacr on pol yest er , but I want pl ai n Dacr on. " She does not r eal i ze t hat Dacr on i s t he br and name of DuPont ' s pol yest er f i ber . I n Chi cago, accor di ng t o Women' s Wear Dai l y, l abel s showi ng mul t i pl e per cent ages i n chi l dr en' s wear have cr eat ed some cust omer doubt s as t o wear abi l i t y. The f i ber cont ent of a l abel i s usef ul t o a commer ci al dr y cl eaner or l aundr y, but t he aver age consumer want s t o know about shr i nkage, f adi ng, col or r esi st ance, and ot her f act or s of per f or mance i n use such as t hose pr ovi ded i n t he Amer i can St andar ds Associ at i on' s L22 st andar d, a mor e pr act i cal and meani ngf ul f r ame of r ef er ence f or i nf or mat i ve l abel i ng t han mer e f i ber names and per cent ages. *** HOME APPLI ANCES THAT CAN BE RENTED i nst ead of pur chased ar e bei ng t r i ed out i n a l i mi t ed ar ea. The mont hl y r ent al f ees i ncl ude ser vi ce. Leasi ng f or t he f i r st t wo year s cost s about t he same as mont hl y payment s i n buyi ng on t he i nst al l ment basi s i f you i ncl ude depr eci at i on, ser vi ce, and i nt er est char ges. Af t er t hat per i od, l easi ng char ges cost i ncr easi ngl y mor e t han appl i ances bought on t he i nst al l ment pl an. Busi ness and i ndust r y ar e usi ng t he l ease t ype of ar r angement f or t ypewr i t er s, addi ng machi nes, comput er s, car s and t r ucks, and a number of i ndust r i al i t ems. Per haps t he l easi ng t echni que wi l l pr ove popul ar f or many ki nds of home appl i ances al so. 0008424 You won't throw money away, if You subscribe to CQMSIKi! BULLETIN! Of course, you need to do more than read our reports and ratings on products by brand name. As one subscriber wrote us recently, "Ilow I wish I had followed your recommendations about auto mobiles. You were so right!" It will help you save money and get the make or model best suited to your needs, if you consult CONSUMER BULLETIN and the big ANNUAL before you make a final decision. I t costs only $5 a year to be a subscriber ($2 more brings the big 224-page ANNUAL that provides a convenient buying guide on a wide range of subjects). Just turn the page for a convenient order form. Fill it out today while you are thinking about it. If you already are a subscriber, tell a thrifty friend about us. CONSUMER B ULLETIN J A N U A R Y 1961 37 i ng out a new model wi t h some i mpr ovement s i n or der t o meet U. S. compet i t i on bet t er . ' *** THE NI CKEL CI GAR may not di sappear ent i r el y. The Wal l St r eet Jour nal r epor t s t hat sci ent i st s have devel oped some new chemi cal s t hat can be bl ended wi t h t obacco t o make an i nexpensi ve ci gar wr apper . The new pr ocess uses scr ap t obacco i nst ead of hi gh- pr i ced l eaf . The r esear cher s have t r i ed out t he new wr apper s t hat cont ai n as much as 50 per cent addi t i ves, and r e por t no evi dence of t oxi c si de- ef f ect s. The t hr ee new chemi cal agent s f or use i n homogeni zed wr apper mat er i al ar e var i at i ons of hydr oxymet hyl phenol , ami nomet hyl phenol , and pol yest er s. Cer t ai nl y t he desi r abi l i t y of smoki ng t obacco cont ai ni ng t hese subst ances may be open t o quest i on. Thei r pr es ence shoul d i n any event be shown on t he l abel of t he ci gar and i t s pack age. Fl avor agent s such as r um and mapl e ar e al so t o be added. *** SERVI CI NG APPLI ANCES i n or der t o keep t hem r unni ng i n t he home i s t he subj ect of many di scussi ons and conf er ences. At a meet i ng of t he Amer i can Home Economi cs Associ at i on, Mr s. Kat her i ne B. Bai l ey of t he Wi sconsi n Ex t ensi on Ser vi ce r ecommended what she cal l ed " pr event i ve ser vi ci ng, " whi ch i ncl udes t hor ough i nst r uct i on on t he car e and pr oper use of equi pment . The homemaker who under st ands how an appl i ance per f or ms can gi ve f act s and sympt oms t o a ser vi ceman so t hat he can l ocat e t he sour ce of t r oubl e' mor e qui ckl y. Thor ough r eadi ng and f ol l owi ng of t he i nst r uct i on book ar e i m por t ant f act or s i n sat i sf act or y oper at i on. *** THOSE BROWN SPOTS THAT HAVE APPEARED ON RUGS i n t he bat hr oom, bedr oom, or any ot her pl aces wher e cosmet i cs ar e appl i ed may be due t o t he new ar t i f i ci al t anni ng l ot i ons. The Nat i onal I nst i t ut e of Rug Cl eaner s r epor t s t hat Man Tan, Posi t an. and Magi c Tan, and no doubt si mi l ar pr oduct s whi ch t ur n t he ski n a br owni sh col or , wi l l al so have a si mi l ar ef f ect on wool r ugs. Such a spot i s di f f i cul t t o r emove, al t hough i t can be bl eached out , by an exper t , wi t h hydr ogen per oxi de. Unf or t unat el y, t hi s t echni que wi l l al so r emove t he col or al ong wi t h t he st ai n. Consumer Bulletin W ASH ING TON, NEW JERSEY Please enter my order as checked. I am enclosing my check (or money order) for $_______ !__ Begin subscription with .issue. N A M E __ STREET. C IT Y & ZONE. .S T A T E ______________ 1-61-S Please check your preference: I I I enclose $7 (Canada & foreign, $7.20) for -- one year's subscription to Consumer Bulletin monthly (12 issues) AND the big 224-page Annual Bulletin, ready in September 1961. CD New Renewal | [ I enclose $5 (Canada & foreign, $5.20) for -- one year's subscription to Consumer Bulletin monthly (12 issues). CD New CD Renewal | | I enclose $2.50 (Canada & foreign, $2.75) for -- a copy of the big Annual Bulletin alone, when it is ready in September 1961. 38 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 KfT 0G08425 \ \ u sed for m ak in g color prin ts Wh e r e a s the advanced amateur photographer ex poses most of his color shots on a type of film which will be turned into a slide or transparency, a great many family snapshots are made on nega tive film, which affords means for making rela tively inexpensive color prints. The advent of Kodacolor film some years ago opened the field for color prints for the persons who take most of their pictures on Easter Sunday, Christmas Day, at graduation ceremonies, and on the days of parades, celebrations, and other public events. The avail ability of film of the Kodacolor type has made the color snapshot a popular medium for the family photograph album. Kodacolor film is a negative film, that is, the developed image appears as a negative, which has dark areas where there were light ones in the scene; the negative is printed by direct-contact or by projection on another sensitized sheet to form the positive print. Slide or transparency films, such as Kodachrome, Ektachrome, and Anscochrome, are positive or reversal films; the developed trans parency slide that gives the colored picture is the original film that was exposed to the subject; Such slides must be viewed in an illuminated hand viewer or projected on a screen. Negative color film has a number of advantages to the photographer. The first, mentioned above, is the presentation of the finished picture in easily viewed print form needing no projector or hand held viewer. Negative color film has the great advantage of simplicity in use in that the same film is used in daylight and for flash. Flash pic tures are taken with the ordinary clear flash bulbs. (In contrast to this, the same slide film cannot be used advantageously for both outdoor pictures and flash pictures unless corrective filters or bulbs are used in making the exposure.) Errors in ex posure can be corrected in the printing process. Black-and-white prints as well as color slides in any desired number can be made. Slide films, on the other hand, are not tolerant of errors of expo sure, since the finished picture is the original ex posed film, and one gets only one picture, a trans parency, from one exposure or frame of the film. If you want duplicates of the slide, the best way to obtain these is to take the picture over again the desired number of times. While color prints can be made from slides, they are more expensive than those made from negatives. However, slides made from negatives are generally not as good as slides that were originally made on positive slide film. W hich type of film to use? The choice of negative vs. positive color film should be determined by the final use to be made of the film. It is our recommendation that any one whose primary interest is in color prints should choose negative color film. If the end re sults are to be color slides for projection, then a positive film such as Kodachrome, Ektachrome, or Anscochrome is the choice. Within the two classi fications of color film lies an additional decision: which of the many types or brands of each should be used? Until this year the choice of a negative color film was easy, since the only brand available in the U.S. was Kodacolor. Now there is another brand, Agfacolor, from Germany. Tests by CR showed that with Agfacolor the amateur can ob tain satisfactory color prints as well as good blackand-white prints. Black-and-white prints are easier to make from Agfacolor negatives since the absence of a built-in color mask (the orange color of Kodacolor negatives) permits the use of ordinary black-and-white printing papers (see Figure 1, page 29). Kodacolor requires the use of a special (Panalure) printing paper which must be handled in almost complete darkness during processing. A wdde range of color films is available for the making of color pictures on slides or transparencies. Kodak makes Kodachrome, Ektachrome, and High Speed Ektachrome. Ansco makes Anscochrome and Super Anscochrome. All of these are available in special emulsions for particular lighting situa tions, such as daylight, flash lamps, or flood lamps. It is well to bear in mind that no color film exactly reproduces the original colors in a scene. There fore, the choice of film for color rendition alone is one that necessarily involves a considerable ele ment of personal taste. Use of Kodachrome is a necessity when the picture is intended for firstquality reproduction by printing processes, for (Continued on page 29) KE 0008426 CONSUMER BULLETIN JANUARY 1961 39 COMING IN FUTURE BU LLET I N S Mobile hom es How to choose one, with ratings of mobile homes of some leading makers Children's shoes Boy Scout Buster Brown Classmate Dr. Posner Educator Edwards Fleet-Air Flying Aces Kali-sten-iks Kinney's Little Yankee Pol! Parrot r o - t e k - t iv Storybook Stride Rite Thom McAn Stainless-steel flatware Continental Cutlers Guild Ekco Georg Jensen Gorham International Majestic Montgomery Ward Oneida Reed & Barton Scientific Sears Roebuck Wallace 1961 autom obiles Buick Le Sabre Ford Falcon Chevrolet Corvair " 700" Mercury Meteor 600-6 Chrysler Newport Oldsmobile F-85 Chrysler Valiant Oldsmobile Dynamic 88 Pontiac Catalina Waste (garbage) disposal units Chambers Frigidaire General Electric Hotpoint Kelvinator National Sears Kenmore Westinghouse Whirlaway Youngstown Con su m er BuUetin The pioneer consumer magazine, testing and reporting on products since 1928. Published by Consumers' Research, Inc., Washington, New Jersey. KE 0008427 61.10