Document J3erwqNe8Ry0mR60vnOvqNyLZ

fIGNER,HARVEY ' PLAINTIFF V. CELANE5E r CORPORATION CO CT CO DEFENDANT ET AL TO THE FOLLOWING NAMED DEFENDANT: 12/28/88 COURT OF COMMON PLEAS FRANKLIN COUNTY.OHIO COLUMBUS-,OHIO NO. C 88CV-12-8606 MONSANTO,COMPANY 800 N LINDBERG BLVD ST LOUIS MO ASSIGNED TO JUDGE CRAWFORD 63167 JAN 9 1989 YOU HAVE BEEN NAMED DEFENDANT IN A COMPLAINT FILED IN FRANKLIN COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, FRANKLIN COUNTY HALL OF JUSTICE, COLUMBUS, OHIO, BY: TIGNER,HARVEY 837 HART ROAD COLUMBUS OHIO 43223 PLAINTIFF(S). A COPY OF THE COMPLAINT IS ATTACHED HERETO. THE NAME AND ADDRESS OF THE PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY IS VANHORN.TERRY D CUM 595 EAST RICH STREET COLUMBUS, OH 43215 YOU ARE HEREBY SUMMONED AND REQUIRED TO SERVE UPON THE PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY,OR UPON THE PLAINTIFF,IF HE HAS NO ATTORNEY OF RECORD,A COPY OF AN ANSWER TO THE COMPLAINT WITHIN TWENTY-EIGHT DAYS AFTER THE SERVICE OF THIS SUMMONS ON YOU,EXCLUSIVE OF THE DAY OF SERVICE. YOUR ANSWER MUST BE FILED WITH THE COURT WITHIN THREE DAYS AFTER THE SERVICE OF A COPY OF THE ANSWER ON THE PLAINTIFFS ATTORNEY. IF YOU FAIL TO APPEAR AND DEFEND, JUDGMENT BY DEFAULT WILL BE RENDERED AGAINST YOU FOR THE RELIEF DEMANDED IN THE COMPLAINT. THOMAS U.ENRIGHT CLERK,COURT COMMON PLEAS F JY.OHIO BY: RETURN OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS I RECEIVED THIS SUMMONS ON 198 AT, O'CLOCK AND I HAVE-HAVE NOT MADE PERSONAL-RESIDENCE SERVICE UPON THE DEFENDANT MONSANTO,COMPANY ** PERSONAL - BY LOCATING HIM AND TENDERING A COPY SUMMONS AND ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS. DATE OF PERSONAL SERVICE: ** RESIDENCE- BY LEAVING AT HIS USUAL PLACE OF RESIDENCE WITH A PERSON OF SUITABLE AGE AND DISCRETION THEN RESIDING THEREIN, A COPY OF THE SUMMONS,A COPY OF THE COMPLAINT AND ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS. DATE OF RESIDENCE SERVICE: -V ** FAILURE OF SERVICE - I WAS UNABLE TO SERVE A COPY OF THE SUMMONS UPON THE DEFENDANT FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS: SERVICE $ MILEAGE COPY DOCKET RETURN TOTAL $ DATE: SHERIFF-BAILIFF-PROCESS SERVER BY DEPUTY RSV 0005037 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF FRANKLIN COUNTY, OHIO CIVIL DIVISION Harvey Tigner 837 Hart Rd, Columbus, OH 43223, Plaintiff, v. Celanese Corporation, or its successor in interest c/o C.T. Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and Monsanto Company 800 North Lindbergh Boulevard St. Louis, MO 63167, and B. F. Goodrich Company 500 South Main Street AXron, OH 44313, and Union Carbide Corporation Old Ridgebury Road, Section cr2 Danbury, CT 06817, and Uniroyal, Inc. World Headquarters Middlebury, CT 06749, and Dow Chemical Company, Inc. c/o C.T. -Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and JAN I 6 1969 o^bOVIT * 114Q Case No. 850 Judge Cain JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON ^ 00 0 Page 1 of 11 RSV 0005088 E. I. duPont deNemours & Company c/o C.T. Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and Chevron, U. S. A. c/o C.T. Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and Eastman Chemical Products, Inc. c/o C.T. Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and Shell Chemical Company c/o C.T. Corporation System 815 Superior Avenue, N.E. Cleveland, OH 44114, and Comprese, Polyvinyl facturer, unknown, Inc. chloride resin manu current address and John Doe I Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, \ and John Doe II Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current 'address unknown, and Page 2 of 11 RSV 0005089 John Doe III Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe IV Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe, Polyvinyl facturer, unknown, Inc, I chloride resin manu current address and John Doe, Polyvinyl facturer, unknown, Inc. II chloride resin manu current address and John Doe, Polyvinyl facturer, unknown, Inc. Ill chloride resin manu current address and John Doe, Polyvinyl facturer, unknown, Inc. IV chloride resin manu current address and John Doe Company I Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current ''address unknown, and Page 3 of 11 RSV 0005090 John Doe Company II Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe company III Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe company IV Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe Corporation I Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe Corporation II Polyvinyl chloride resin manu facturer, current address unknown, and John Doe Corporation III Polyvinyl chloride resin mamffacturer, current address unknown, and John Doe Corporation IV Polyvinyl chloride, resin manu facturer, current ^address unknown, and Defendants. Page 4 of 11 RSV 0005091 COMPLAINT This is a refiled complaint in accordance with Ohio Revised Code 2305.19, having been previously filed in this Court under Case No. 85CV-04-2279 and dismissed without prejudice on the 24th day of December, 1987. FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION: 1. The Plaintiff, Harvey Tigner, at all times pertinent hereto, was a resident of the State of Ohio. 2. The Defendant, Celanese Corporation or its successor', in interest (hereinafter "Celanese"), is a corporation incorporated in the State of Delaware and licensed to do business in the State of Ohio; at all times pertinent hereto, it has transacted business and maintained operations in Hilliard, Franklin County, Ohio, at the plant known as the Hilliard facility, that gave rise to the activities and claims set forth herein. 3. The Plaintiff was employed at the Hilliard facility of Celanese at all times pertinent hereto. 4. The Defendants, Celanese Corporation or its successor in interest, Monsanto Company, B. F. Goodrich Company, Union Carbide Corporation, Uniroyal, Inc., Dow Chemical Company, Inc., E. I. DuPont deNemours & Company, Chevron, U.S.A., Page 5 of 11 r$V 0005092 Eastman Chemical Products, Inc., Shell chemical Company, Comprese, Inc., John Doe I, John Doe II, John Doe III, John Doe IV, John Doe, Inc. I, John Doe, Inc. II, John Doe, Inc. in, John Doe, Inc. IV, John Doe Company I, John Doe Company II, John Doe Company III, John Doe Company IV, John Doe Corporation I, John Doe Corporation II, John Doe Corporation III, and John Doe Corporation IV, whose current addresses Plaintiff, with due diligence, has not been able to uncover (hereinafter collectively referred to as the MPVC resin manufacturers") are corporations, companies and/or individuals with a principal place of business in the State of Ohio, a foreign state, or a foreign country, which, at all times pertinent hereto, have been in the business of manufacturing, producing and selling to the Hilliard facility of Celanese products containing polyvinyl chloride ("PVC") resin, a substance containing the vinyl chloride monomer (hereinafter "VCM"), a toxic chemical and known carcinogen. 5. At all times since the commencement of his employment at the Hilliard facility of Celanese, Plaintiff ingested and/or absorbed into his body quantities of toxic and carcinogenic substances including PVC and VCM as a direct and proximate result of the activities he was required to perform in the scope and course of his employment at the Hilliard facility of Celanese. Page 6 of 11 RSV 0005093 6. The levels of toxic and carcinogenic substances including PVC resin and VCM to which the Plaintiff was exposed were above safe levels, above permissible exposure limits, and threshold limit values. 7. plaintiff's continuous and repeated exposure to toxic and carcinogenic substances including PVC and VCM has: (a) Caused Plaintiff serious permanent physical injuries; (b) Inflicted upon Plaintiff severe, continuing physical and mental pain and suffering and extreme emotional distress; (c) Rendered Plaintiff physically disabled so that he is unable to be employed at his maximum earning capacity; (d) Repeatedly required Plaintiff to obtain necessary hospital and medical care and will require him to obtain hospital and medical care in the future; (e) Increased the likelihood that Plaintiff will contract cancer; and (f) Shortened Plaintiff's life expectancy. V* 8. At all times since the Plaintiff's date of hiring, Celanese knew or should have known that the work performed by the Plaintiff at the Hilliard facility gave rise to the inhalation, ingestion, and/or absorption into his body of quantities of toxic and carcinogenic substances including PVC resin and VCM, the dangerous propensities of which were known to or should have been known by Celanese. Page 7 of 11 RSV 0005094 9. Celanese intentionally exposed the Plaintiff to toxic and carcinogenic substances, including PVC resin and VCM, at unsafe levels during the course of Plaintiff's employment at the Hilliard facility of Celanese, as a condition of contiued employment as a result of which Plaintiff sustained the aforesaid injuries and losses. 10. During the course of Plaintiff's employment with Celanese, Celanese intentionally withheld and/or concealed from the Plaintiff material information and warnings concerning the toxic and carcinogenic substances to which Plaintiff was continuously and repeatedly exposed, including PVC resin and VCM, specifically including information as to the dangerous propensities of such substances, the effects on human health of *rf\ overexposure to such substances, signs and symptoms of overexposure, and the precautions to take to avoid overexposure; Celanese knew or should have known of the material nature of the information described herein, information concerning which Plaintiff was unaware and unknowledgeable. 11. Celanese knew or should have known of the serious health hazards to Plaintiff which would result from continuous, repeated exposure'to the toxic and carcinogenic substances, including PVC resin and VCM, to which the Plaintiff was exposed at Celanese--health hazards which could have been prevented had Celanese fulfilled its duties and obligations enumerated herein. Page 8 of 11 r$V 0005095 12. Celanese, by its intentional conduct, failed to provide Plaintiff with a safe place to work. 13. Celanese, by its conduct, acted in willful and wanton disregard for the life, health and safety of Plaintiff. 14. As a direct and proximate result of the intentional conduct of Celanese, Plaintiff sustained the injuries and losses aforesaid. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION: 15. Plaintiff realleges paragraphs 1 through 14 of this Complaint and incorporates them herein by reference thereto as though fully set forth herein. 16. The PVC resin manufacturers negligently failed to take proper steps to instruct and warn Plaintiff of the dangers of overexposure to PVC resin and VCM? failed to provide Plaintiff with information on the dangerous carcinogenic propensities of PVC resin and VCM? neglected to*inform Plaintiff of the effects on human health of overexposure to PVC resin and VCM? failed to instruct or warn Plaintiff concerning the signs and symptoms of overexposure to PVC resin and VCM? and failed to provide information to Plaintiff as to precautions to prevent overexposure to PVC resin and VCM. Page 9 of 11 0005096 RSV 17. PVC resin and VCM are inherently dangerous products as to which the PVC resin manufacturers are strictly liable; PVC resin and VCM were sold by the PVC resin manufacturers in a defective condition unreasonably dangerous to Plaintiff; said PVC and VCM reached Plaintiff without substantial change from the condition in which they were sold. 18. The aforesaid acts and omissions of the PVC resin manufacturers were in willful and wanton disregard of the life, health and safety of the ultimate users of their product, including Plaintiff. 19. As a direct and proximate result of the acts and omissions of the PVC resin manufacturers, Plaintiff sustained the injuries and losses aforesaid. THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION: 20. Plaintiff realleges paragraphs 1 through 19 of this Complaint and incorporates them herein by reference thereto as though fully set forth herein. * 21. Defendants, jointly and/or severally, have been unjustly enriched as a result of their aforementioned actions at the expense of the Plaintiff. Page 10 of 11 RSV 0005097 FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION: 22. Plaintiff realleges paragraphs 1 through 21 of this Complaint and incorporates them herein by reference thereto as though fully set forth herein. 23. The Defendants, jointly and/or severally, have negligently and/or intentionally inflicted emotional distress on the Plaintiff. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against the Defendants jointly and/or severally in the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000.00) as and for compensatory damages, and the amount of Seven Million Dollars ($7,000,000.00) as and for punitive damages, and attorney fees, expenses, and such other rel: Columbus, OH 43215 614/463-9444 Attorney for Plaintiff JURY DEMAH Plaintiff demands a trial by jury this matter. Terry DJ) Van Horn (VAN05) Attorney for Plaintiff Page 11 of 11 RSV 0005098