Document 4vbR9N9B4RXNY5YJYY2rGXbNa

PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT AL-970 Refrialed from the A. if. A. Archives of Industrial Ueollh lume 1958, VoL IT, ft. 04-653 Copyright 1958, by Americaa Medical Associativa from An Epidemiological Study of 4ndusfR',v- Lung Cancer in Asbestos Miners ^ DANKl C MAUN, N.D* mmd f. DAVID TVUAH, M.A* NttaWgk tt. Pa- Ever since the pronounced increase in the incidence of lung cancer among males became apparent, there have been attempts to associate it with one or another of the various elements in the environment of man. The approach used by some workers has been to suspect one or several sub stances and then set about in an intensive search for lung cancer among persons who have had any exposure to those materials. In this connection, Smithn writes: "The tendency of authors reporting the coinci dental occurrence of primary lung cancer with silicosis or with any other theoretical etiologic conditions, has been to emphasize the percentage relationship in extremely small series of cases, with control cases which are not in any way comparable." It would seem inevitable that asbestos should come under scrutiny in this manner, because prolonged exposure to this material is known to cause a specific type of pneu moconiosis, and because persons who show this form of pneumoconiosis often come to autopsy and provide a ready source of material for study. It was in this way that reports of the simultaneous occurrence of lung cancer and asbestosis began to accu mulate after the report of a case by Lynch and Smith " in 1935. Within the next 10 years, about 15 additional cases were rel>orted, and in 1954 Mcrewether reviewed all deaths from asbestosis recorded in Eng land since March, 1924. Lung cancer oc curred in 16% of these cases. Gfoyne,41 Accepted for publication Jan. 20, 1958. Tins study was made possible through a grant fmni the Quebec Asbestos Mining Association. Medical Director (Dr. Braun) and Statistical Consultant (Mr. Truan), Industrial Hygiene Foundation. whose work is also frequently referred to as establishing a connection between asbes tosis and cancer of the lung, reported in 1951 that cancer of the lung was present in 14.1% of asbestosis cases examined by him. In 1941, Nordmann and SorgeTM claimed to have produced lung cancer in mice which they exposed to asbestos dust. Since 1951, additional cases of cancer of the lung coexisting with asbestosis have been reported, and, according to Hueper4* about 100 such cases had been reported up to 1955. As a result, an association between the two diseases appears to have been ac cepted by many authors, and several writers were using the term "asbestosis cancer" of the lung. Werber,** in 1952, stated cate gorically that in 7% to 17% of cases of asbestosis, after a latent period of about 1)4 to 20 years, carcinoma becomes estab lished in the lung. On the other hand, not ail authors ac cepted this alleged association without reservation. Saupe 40 in 1939 reported that he had discovered no cases of lung cancer among 620 cases of asbestosis which he had examined; and in 1942, Holleb and Angrist41 expressed the opinion that the number of cases of asbestosis with lung cancer was too small for statistical evalua tion. In 1947, WegeliusM reported 126 radiologically diagnosed cases of asbestosis among 476 workers in Finland, and found no cases of lung cancer in this group. Goldblatt and Goldblatt in their section of Merewether's latest book,44 state: "But at no stage in all these impressive researches was any clue obtaiued which might have offered any support to the possibility that asbestos could act as a carcinogen. There 634 6C 1u 2 Sa X 5 3 3: 5 c c c bce B rz S i 113 ? 5 SI J e T S I C llsilS 8.1r 2 .S' 8gr t> -- 5 1 J* = I 1 a c 3J, y V s I a I*bej 2 Bgi;sa C *3 (S J " " I6 X-g x o .2 5 O Xv Oa -= g s ill I I H 1: 1 l' J: : ? -- *3 E.s .a wC e5 3 J5 -o p-JS 3 u *5 ?se !| & ^c XuV 8.x f 2 S 3 .2 u * ~ II r& f- tfj U " u (2 | 'i u ou .32 I 8= if -- *3 3 3| *8" 3 I ||E s -2* .*2-- : v .2 O v & w = o *x " o !e H *3 _ O Tg i -- v -8 5cs E S xO "^S|ei.9 | SiSI e 2. _ &" X oo = S' v> t a ^ o 2 ,- 3 C .s&s r " *ON.gM *Ue EI o e s3 S n., c fj D_ 3 s .3 fc w-- S e o* N oo 5 JS c o 4_ v> O 2 5 4\3,tr be 'S II i.8! D ~ 8c w=3 2ii '".s 8- 4 s .2 u K w> :o2 cS ." s'i 1 - | -- 4J " *3 be .=*3 LoEO . .g ^ IS-I 3 3 S= E Sc -- Vi *-. 3? -= 1 b *} Hi o 3 iit Sc e s a : *5 J - St .5 S fl g 8 I s S" -7. 3 o 21 > .2 _ :g .2. be ^ S .15O3 J*MB5 .S U Xfc e cx -- hr = .o . Se r* c 2 S -a n **. 3 **- o . > - S a a a -8 i : = t | u -s X i.B- fas 1 8.-jj b0 w N e ~ --nl Isa t S C o .s iS = .2 "S 3 B`& 35 3JS.^3Ss* _ow AcJ. >> ZI O *3 3 E g s B .> 3 '5-.45 sW? l^ =o2 i: >_ C9 5 : c -wwj _"c >o5 *325 = *% e = s g a 3 s i-i o E >< ( 2 *i3s gB |1 el g l ^3 ^ o5 >. hSe ^w o 2! = r -* j c 5*^ ,, r. X ^ a ' to i:-!* illU) 55 i-sir^ I5 I"I.' 3 8. iC5 !li ^SI' !=! .= il s tl J w U 1 I 2sto 3 Ei a > 3O 3 " Sf " S -I _ s "a u " M5 ^ -- 3 ^ .= S .5 3 X i be 3 'B = -^i owi - rt jre 3 l o x a u *i' " 2. 3 = Ills 3 4 .!-rt3rt _C5i --cn S a K JuS ~ S r U- -2 v* 3 *c E bo c r -a -5 S S ssi - rt *5 u 3 6 u *,0 .O3 3o cu J-2 0V *`0T i 6i; 0*5 si f8s 3 sr.22 = 111 s 8C .1u "8 3 ^_ *^St3f) y -co 8-fl *2 8tT."%n _o 88 Cou --- as! JS j 8 g -g 5 vX 5 o3 - bOe &! 3 6 g * 3 3 _ g i-S,s -- u --j "r 9 ^5 " .us x> x -- 9k I5!i a o c" .1 S 5 - | * 3 r.l 2 - o 3 W " 1 3 .2 1 C E ~ ^7 ^*8 ?5 E 3 w .2t ^ JJ i= rst ^ I --S v. s(j -2,,o Jr<" l. .33I 9 O^ ^oV) i* flj u . 3.2 c= 1 8 "5^11 a .2 a 8<:S X2 Jil' '.2 bi > "- a 1 x 38 f&B to f, E &a I I ^ C *3 -q i 3 E 8 I !' 5 oo 3 C y O g- a` ,, __ _5cT-=e o* * 1 5^ ?s = - .5 .S rn i 8" e. S 8' : X v ?O *2 3 s S| "S ^ z> " i = _ u '3O v> 2m .3:|| M *S 3 I * be SJ 1_ ^ S1 1v 5 _ c n M s J : w a fi : s x t c S o^Sl! ^ll. X 8 d &w y -^7 u J T3 "" 2i o X O Q. * a " a -a 4 Sc * C V" e> o c ? 6 a3: x J_ V xnn lsuc sgo o^-* ,, = 5 a |1 > 3 * O -- 5: s * 5f-tf 2 I . Sb >te m 8 oJtJ O = (A -- g 21 "a a 2y- 3rSt xU a .2 t>2 O e -iai S 8C = 8 O. ^ 3OO^) Uw x r2rtsot ,-33 >} 0 a: >4 5 * 2 . s "e a =3 -s!IC if. C <A .2 (AM < c re c o Sf .2 <. -*< 3ol Wv S>T.* 3 X= a c^ *3, wc ill * 5fl-S 5 2 Ts " 8 cx e be c I* "S .2^0 >* A * l&X >i . *2 <s II .2 u o "g | *| g ~ > E1 * t c ? |8S : o :.= v x % c jxig>>J:.CSr=e hge vc Osk u a aJ v) (0 5 -- O c, 5 o^ ll**i i 3 - 2 11 ii Jifj S ii v Hills > > 5 8 8 S3 To V a-s jf 5S 8 "5. be k C g -fe 9 g.'-o' 5 ^ M 'cC- Ucre Vc ;? gs a?I wji w3O c .s _ 5 J a- n ^ :2 a s 8.:sl| o _ 5 w .2 S * B g* I -sa & S * ? *6b 2 ** a v 85.\2= * 2 * oi lill| .2 & ' ESI' sre >e cc . c g-j i ! S a l15 22 (A t) *cA --x 83 S 3c Si '5 * 2 *2 V 2 < a o^ Xs 11 1O13 "X >b 1 --re -2 ..2 i S'ti' | .2 c. 5.-2 c3 o be c 2re _2 T3 " 22 U .= ro ,,3 - i: J (fi 1 K 1 .2 x o > 1 .> ' 3 E a C 2 O E E ES -- JS *c 2 c JaS E5 wE e u cVK ^ u CL O . 3X 85 "C be re re E JE JS c *" 2 .E 5 if. V JS = re >, Jb -- *o *I be re c re _ ^ uX re 2 > S c a. &aI lag. Sf5 & t i I I 2.1 |-g -a S o I 6 -- Q. S 82 V 8-E STB- - >. s n4i S E - g-S'-0 .2 o 8.2 :rs u re -- c. x ^ 2 x e - 2 is "vV *3 E s a tf) ^ re *A j^r -i II cc --*- .Sc .X > E ! 8$= w.i & c = <A X C g5 $ i -g .2 III= o 5 2vs ^re Jg re c K .S j; js o = .l O -8 1 JS >>'xx '~' t V 8 - c o 2 * e. ft. E x ? s . % < i = e i w -- -c It* 2O3 ai a: s' 8.w g s Hi:4 g 62 | sc V% -- a >2.: i| |2 c g S " " 'll | P3 &! 8 a:I E 8 g 2f js J5 8-1 '5 le > gjf heJS . ? g'S o. ^ i, i aa is * 5 8 Is O S a.s g 3 a i; S I'' mi f -go | f? a -g s o = a - lM " |/1 * re - !>!' S8S >v IA x C JS E a g K 8 u E-- I - a2Z J Sa_l iA V 9<A Kc c v u wO uIf) (MA . o g'5!. be u __ c> 8 * |, O re na a oo 8 ' vi ,2 > r *8 tr s 3 U ii t&iJ xV hH u_ 8^ w _ re u u S o ; u re x 5 * e ec. v^ =s Z!S8&c.1*:re?|=re 1 -,8 h " lit a. a. C rtsaP 42 - 8-|- tfi c<g c f 8 -= ^ S " a JS ^qI 9 2 o-3^ | g B +3 M U U 2 a | JSa 2 I -S f e 'c = . o^ iI (A c -5 be s re a to ,, be . j .3 O. S B 3 S- 3- *"i OO Uu L. ^ ^ ut f>t!. E o *, >< vu U i- = 8 -- *o > g O X--C oN A 00 g-&i A* X C f'i: AC 8 o. o _S 11 *i I 1 8 g i v 8" bo g> gJ 1.511 x -S " Z 2 2 n oC. *^-cJ Coc m r il^* S 3 g c re 3 Z oS rue are **r2e- "-5O 2 !-2 ;-- " C re J i x s-1 a (A X , I s .E - ._c2 c- -Xuo' , w 8.-o2 .S> 8 *8 ; rt e -g | Ubi3aU |C f3 3a--e <3 *o 5 >= & 5 o ' a u 4* " 2 c *-?. ~2 u. IA *3 $ v f J le :-. i E 8 r>j pu xr>e 5f2c_ yj c5 cbce 2c 0: c " O C re >-> u - g^ >> ^ IA . = tS Ill I ~ 8. X 3 .i--s&2. rUe- Jre > --O c 1 c fc 8 'S S' * :* O IIAA> j KI * C3 A K C lllflS O f INDUSTHIAI. llt.A L T H t 5 2-- -- 5 a i-g a 3 W <A 2 t. jj. = 2, o _ i 3 CK i-o 5 cuej 5: TL> s a-J cc o cc, LUNG CANCER IN ASBESTOS M IN ER S A m . A. AR C H IVES OF IN D U S TR IA L H E A LTH P1 s *4 =*2515 3 | "ass 1 a I u. o 1 -*=3'S a, 5 | "RSB is fts T T | =38813 sj | =88318 3 =SS= IS H "" ** II W I! e3ss 1 ! nit I *J5l -- W g l/> 3 J2I S > 30M0(i8 '/1 J S: <x- Xu *?o g 5s o s5 u it j; >> *i .S : JS * 2f '> o II= u -- .>! 1 a = O X -3 2 2 o3 p c " |! 6 U XS Ou-j 8V3 ^ S- 5 j: E = fi S 2 Si c 8 8TB O. E 'Hi PU8 --,, OU 15 . Um Xba --ra >4 8 I * ?8 si -I 1 Jl 1= i.g JS iti3-a 1 s | 3 i l8 ivt 1 - ab3 .js=4 a P= -3 |l as *lliss. SL ?i8x^>> _*e> i = |4 li si! H -S J! S >- 2 I U2 3 8 8 2Qa H 3=2, o -3 *uT 1- ><_ 15 a !! * 3 *4 - b.. ci e o i! O si-S 5y) --u . "6o c x s ctt og ~=8= __ ' 5 j . x *3 S - r2f mu S irt 4 1 S S2 , 5 Ef bA g o6 VM X -- ON lA ^ ox o "~ X= On aj .2 J; S 3c*. ,3 = | 84 - | sii s ts ?! NO - v 3 2x^ JS -5 - 5 S 8 = - O C (8 2ON c 35S"" 2 .a s i -2 So 18 o2 E4 TJ 2 0 *" X _ff CM ** l 3| -i: X 3 s - 2 # J 45;fc^ M 2 CU &v 51 * o| 2 tt: % : 121 1 1) w X ~1' S. I x co CO = E 0 S a .s <n ak V o --c La -r c O . 2 V X 2 Ji -a u. U .V l2 S 'o ^2 a * & 2 u "3 * .1 '= o - Si , 8 - 5u* twn .i=i CT c *0 2 c .2 .2 g -V *0 S CV ^ *S X" { c. a iort C2 o8 W5 u^o u La W .S o> >s . -- s -2 8 tel u 3 = ... r8--sS & E __ c Vo 84 E *8 ^N &i 11? si? N-SilS 111 |a1 2 a 5 1 S3rl?- = z 11 SB'IS 3 oo : : : mi ill "=5 i si3it a 3 ^ | aS5'l 11 1| 11 3*i*vaa*!l|aS | ^ :; :: A _ a 2 jjj| SS ~=3 =a a 81 So 44^^ V X3 : a2 S4 1 c s "^4 'S .2 * JW NJ Q J: ^ *0 *8 o z|=> S ji 5 ;o 4 . H" .=9 14,2 P .1 3is:=s c 3 . o * 13 3 &8._ 2 55 u WH 2 o"1 1-- o LVa fc. Ja. !tel o -5 a u--8< c > 2 * ;> te| a -o S uH -o Q ~ * te c K V E J 'o'S n.. c b w E " -= 4 13 H o"2ac0 &".o J S u SL JS - m ?a jj -e a 1 rt vJS.2" 8 v 2 n & 2 |22">4'i' -4 0 V a = * IS cCC ^^21 5. J<SA s | : 4 a? xo E_ % c ^4 8-2 0 -5 t- a ~ 6 o S* x & - 3X -= 2 0 o -S b 8.4 s = .2 -= 5 S' i .* y *8 2 x 81 c23 o *n W C 3V p XXX 3 S J-31-O c K u 5' o j. .2 ,, U 4 .5 _ 5 s, b 0 1411 K1/ N*? o v' (9 v 111 2 323 sa I =*3. | S ""3 i 3 "3 2 i S| | 3 ""8 | 3 "J | 8 ""3 I * "`3 sin 1 rib lung cancer in asbestos miners ARCHIVES OF IN D U STR IAL H EALTH i b %/*. t ! SS S5 ill It: Icx', 2 55 E -8 e e JsS * co M *5 & K *2 mS51 k I/'t C >.M iL M . . IP * 8 I'Si1 i:1*p o" S* e^ o -Sd| "Be! II, i SS MS JS 3 Ifw5TvJ ;> ^ ^ 2 J! 2 ii If -ii i~ e I 1 1 ill lll 1"1 s i 3 8is "" a s-l JSIS ii * I 31 *2 J o S 8-S n-i 2 ix o c 8 != or II Sjv E W * .** a s &*5 V Lm .8 s-O o& .,:xBst*i.-&t5 .5i8-1Sr be o a^ 8V 3 " CO * 11 | . 3 *> = i j s 8~ s o * Io st 3 b s-5i 1 S * ai e S g.fi III gM.2 T? c JO O g !1 a to Jji ill eu w Si . i* *o bt A e 1 e -S j;I _ 0 *o jj2 s -".Egi,, * o u^ a. co E j3 5c .2 sis O g g ui E1 SI^S. w <uA .tcX US rt 1 ii l1 l* I = " . Ii&, Cm"? Si. i .19 Z u c 18-Sl IS. ii. H -E1 J! X rt l>iiV f8 3 : <o ti 3 s JS Jgl -5 *r3 3ce tg a te s I J E '5 t = & 2= IS wsow - t ,i S 8 & xC E io?5 *= a.= * s X 8 *i tl; 8s a c *> Q. JS * _w c - Jo Mk. Tc>i V Si :*!; ^ C>. o t> t il he 1 l&' 8 E^ *Q oe S iri 1 g t: sli.fi1 U * X.2 rt u V 3 s sa S' 8 j: s r s j -g S St 3 | ii t = |3 " o 2 c UJ!5S CO JS he g j: US -- *rce 25 -p -8_ 5aEc.*^s5.. 48 lv. rt ic a wS 'li ft E , 5 JS JC < ** i fc, tg-s .-4 " =*! al 3a_j < *{iuj iH ;4 ^a: b] -s. jcf "* ,6i i 3<2 "S > *6 cS *3 js Mc s `3 ?-o VS5 .-riff _ ' Si1? 2-ty 32vtf'< I y .S jin jJi S So! !|:- u f IR | !? *i! '-ll 'i^-S 111 s1l i I i.r-^: jSa-8 S <n S t 1 3 * | J 3 "l * | N J-S~ a flu < C 3 f <2 O t Si2ll.8 J . i; iE iI i; l Sl0,2!!!-^ .Ji-3 **<3 ,,-i t-i | s u- g ^|i-x|xilxs D 22 u C ilfi c LUNG CANCER IN ASBESTOS MINERS Health Monugniph No. 36, P. 1(. S. Publication 75. Mcreweiliir, K. K. A.: Annual Reports of No. 452, U. S. Public Health Service, 1955. he Qiief iu>|*evUir of Factories, 1 His 59. Hueper, W. C.: Environmental Causes of Cancer of tlie Lung oilier than Tobacco Smoke, Dis. Qtest. 30:141-158 (Aug.) 1956. 60. Isselbuclier, K. J.; Klaus, H., and Hardy, Majesty's Stationery Office, 1947. 76. Merewetiier, E. R. A., editor: Industrial Medicine and Hygiene, London, Butlerwurtli & Co.. Ltd., 1956, Vol. 3. H. L.: Asbcstosis and Brondiogenic Carcinoma: Report of One Autopsted Case and Review of Available Literature, Am. J. Med. IS :72l-732 77. Nordmann, M.: Tle Industrial Cancer of Workers in Asbestos, Ztsclir. Krebsforck 47:288302, 1938. (Nov.) 1953. 78. Nordmann, M., and Sorge, A.: Pulmonary 61. Kennaway, E. L, and Kennaway, N. M.: A Cajicer Produced by Asbestos Dust in Experi Study of the Incidence of Canoer of the Lung mental Animals, Ztschr. Krebsfordt 51:168-182, and Larynx, J. Hyg. 36:236-267 (June) 1936. 1941. 62. Kennaway, E. L., and Kennaway, N. M.: 79. Phillips, A. J.: Mortality Iran Cancer of Studies of Incidence of Cancer of the Lung and the Lung in Canada (1931-1952), Canad. M. A. J Larynx, Brit J. Cancer 5:153-158 (June) 1951. 71:242-244 (Sept) 1954. 63. Klotz, M. O.: Association of Silicosis and 80. Saupe, E.: Further Contributions to tlie Carcinoma of the Lung, Am J. Cancer 35:38-49 Roentgenological Diagnosis of Asbestoms, Ardi. (Jan.) 1939. Gewerbepath. u. Gewerbehyg. 9:391-406, 1939. 64. Lana, A. J.; McConnell, W. J, and Fehnel, 81. Smith, K. W.: Pulmonary Disability in J. W.: The Effects of the Inhalation of Asbestos Asbestos Workers, A. M. A. Arch. Indust. Health Dust on the Lungs of Asbestos Workers: Pre 12:196-203 (Aug.) 1955. liminary Study, Pub. Health Rep. 50:1-12 (Jan. 4) 82. Small, L. W.: Pneumoconiosis and Lung 1935. Cancer with Special Reference to Silicosis and 65. 1mm a. J., editor: Silicosis and Asbcstosis, Asbcstosis, Compem. Med. 2:3-10 (Nov.) 1949. New York and London, Oxford University Press, 63. Smith, W. E.: Survey of Some Current 1938. British and European Studies of Occupational 66. Lew, E. A.: Use of Life Insurance Com Tumor Problems: Part III. Asbestos, A.M.A. pany Records for Cancer Studies, A. M. A. Arch. Arch. Indust Hyg. S:242-263 (March) 1952. Indust. Hyg. 5:198-203 (March) 1952. 64. Stoll, R.; Bass, R., and Angrist, A.: 67. Liiubach, A. J., and Wedler, H. W.: Occu Asbcstosis Associated with Bronchogenic Car pational Cancer among Asbestos Workers, Arch, cinoma. A.M.A. Arch. lot Med. 88:831-634 path. AnaL 307:387-409,- 1941. (Dec) 1951. 68. Lynch, K. M* and Smith, W. A.: Pul monary Asbcstosis: Carcinoma of Lung in Asbesto-Silicotis, Am. J. Cancer 24:56-64 (May) 1935. 69. Lynch, K. M^ and Smith, W. A.: Pul monary Asbcstosis: A Report of Brondiial Car 85. Teleky, L: Occupational Lung Cancer, Acta Union internat contre Cancer 3:2S3-273, 1938; also, Zentralbl. Gewerbehyg. 27:33. 1940. 86. VorwaM, A. J.; Durkan, T. M.t and Pratt, P. G: Experimental Studies of Asbestos!*, A.M.A: Arch. Indust Hyg. 3:1-43 (Jan.) 1951. cinoma and Epithelial Metaplasia, Am. J. Cancer 87. Wedler, H. W.: Asbcstosis and Lung 36:567-573 (Aug.) 1939. Cancer, Deutsche med. Wchnschr. 69:57S-576 70. Lynch, K. M., and Cannon, W. M.: Asbes (Aug. 6) 1943. tosis : Analysis of 40 Necropsied Cases, Dis. Chest 88. Wegelius, G: Changes in the Lungs in 126 14:874-889 (Nov.-Dee.) 1948. Cases of Asbcstosis Observed in Finland, Acta < 71. McPheelers, S. B.: A Survey of a Group radio!. 28:139-152, 1947. of Employees Exposed to Asbestos Dust, J. 89. Werber, M.: Pulmonary Asbcstosis Asso Indust. Hyg. 18:229-239 (April) 1936. ciated with Carcinoma, Zentralbl. Arbeitsmed. u. / 72. Merewether, E. R. A.: The Occurrence of Arbdtsschutz 2:179-180 (Nov.) 1952. Pulmonary Fibrosis and Other Pulmonary Affec 90. Wood, W. B., and Gloyne, S. R.: Pulmonary tions in Asbestos Workers, J. Indust. Hyg. 12: Asbestosis Complicated by Pulmonary Tubercu 196 (May); 239 (June) 1930. losis. Lancet 2:954-956 (Oct 31) 1931. 73. Merewether, E. R. A., and Price, C W.: Report on Effects of Asbestos Dust on the Lungs and Dust Suppression in the Asbestos Industry, London, His Majesty's Stationery Office, 1930. 74. Merewether, E. R. A.: A Memorandum on Asbestosis, Tubercle 15:109; (Dec.) 1933; 15: 152 (Jan.) 1934. 91. Wycrs, H.: Asbcstosis, Postgrad. Med. 25: 631-638 (Dec) 1949. 92. Wynder, E. I*. and Graham, E. A.: Etiologic Factors in Bronchiogentc Carcinoma with Special Reference to Industrial Exposures; Report of 857 Proved Cases, A.M.A. Ardu Indust Hyg. 4:221-235 (Sept) 1951. Bram Tnum PrimUd vU AWwM m Ik Uiud 5Mti tf Amttriem 653 \ c0 V/i r- x V> r* /