Document 1Q2174Z0wDbGEyMgq3amD9gE
.V 1
APOOO14636
Voi. sya So. i
VINYt.-Cl
Vc- -C&fttS
X/ (
-yy <'HIDE-INDUCED LIVER DISEASE -- TIIOMA T AL
VINYL-CHLORIDE-INDUCED LIVER DISEASE
j
17 / ,
From Idiopathic Portal Hypertension (Banti's Syndrome) to Angiosarcomas
^
I .oils !'>. Thom w M.D.. FI \\s Poim'J.k. M.D.. Pii.D.. I'.u i. D. Berk. M.D.. Ikvim; Si i.iurnr. M.D.. as:. Hew r v! x. M.D.
Abstract H stoiogic exa.Tination ol liver tissue (eight autopsy and 18 biopsy specimens) and five spleens from 20 workers wart v.ny! ehlories oolymerizatton st.%s3 hepatic angiosarcomas <n to. In addition, a
peculiar pattern of progressive portal-tract, mconspicuous intralobular and conspicuous capsular fibrosis was observed in the five workers without angiosarcoma, in all the seven patients with angiosarcoma from whom tumor-fres portions of the liver were available, and in two tumor-free biopsies from patients subsa-
quentiy found lo havs angiosarcoma. Th? fibrosis was
accompanied by splenomegaly. Hypertrophy and hy perplasia of both neoatocytes and hepatic and splenic mesenchymal ceas were also seen. The histologic Simi larity to chronic inorganic arsenical poisoning, in which angiosarcomas also occur, and to idiopathic portal hypertension (Band's syndrome) suggests that the latter syndro'me at times results from unknown tox ic. possibly environmental, chemicals. (N Engl J Med 292:17-22.1975)
.t h'
THF. development of Itopitic angiosarcomas in work ers expos'd lu vinyl chloride gas in the manufacture
Maltoni*0 subsequently described angiosarcomas of the liver and other organs as well as nephroblastomas in ruts
of polyvinyl chloride Jus been well documented.'* Hisio-exposed to vinyl chloride gas. Recently, angiosarcomas of
logic study of Ivtutic and splenic specimens taken*!rom suchuorkeri stK^cstsui us. moreover, th:u other diseases
the liver have been seen in mice alter exposure to as little as 50 ppm of vinyl chloride.11
that have not in the past been related to industri.il ex
When specimens of human angiosarcoma from vinyl
posure muvjjgjiiyofyed. Specifically. n case will be made chloride polymerization workers were reviewed in the
for the concept that splenomegaly with portal hyperten Laboratory of Pathology of the National Cancer Institute,
sion associated with slight hepatic fibrosis. previously des the lesions in areas uf the liver not involved by an
ignated as Banti's syndrome,4 may be the result of ex giosarcoma appeared similar to alterations recently re
posure to known or unknown chemical agents.
ported in vinyl chloride workers in Germany.** in these
History or Tr Vinyl Chloride Liver Injury
patients inconspicuous portal and perisinusoidal fibrosis was associated with impressive hepatic capsular fibrosis as
Polyvinyl chloride, one of the must widely used syn seen by perit^"`*icoj>y. Hepatic-function te* wealed
thetic plastics, has been manufactured for more than 40 vears by polvmerization of gaseous vinyl chloride in dte United Staie* and in many other countries. Concern about untoward side effects in workers had centered
variable abnormalities. Clinical manifestations included portal hypertension with splenomegaly, thrombocyto penia and bleeding esoplugeul varices. This German re port focused our interest on the appearance of the liver
primarily on a disease, ncro-osteolysis,1 which is charac not only in patients with hepatic angiosarcomas but also in
terized by Raynaud's syndrome, dermal induration and other workers with ftepatic fibrosis exposed to vinyl chlo
bone lesions. Two reports^ also dealt wills nonspecific alterations of hepatic structure and function, and a lesion designated "chronic epithelial hepatitis" was found in
ride who had been diagnosed as having cirrhosis because of portal hypertension, vnriceal hemorrhage and spleno megaly.'
about 25 per cent of die examined workers in Russia.* Hepatic abnormalities, which did not attract major atten
By coincidence, tliere have been several recent reports of portal hypertension without obvious cause in patients
tion. Ijccume far more important because of the discovery with psoriasis who had i eceived an inorganic arsenic
of three can's of angiosarcomas of the liver, an mliei wise preparation. Fowler's solution, for prolonged peri-
very rare minor, in workers in a polyvinyl chloride pro otk,3 s These observations were interesting in view of
duction pl.uit in this l ouinrv.1 The imriKlm iion of a sur earlier reports from Germany ami France of hepatic an
veillance system in iliis plant dciettcd a total of sevencases of hepatic angiosarcoma.'* Animal experiments confirm
giosarcomas developing in vintners exjvoscd to insecti cides containing inorganic arstiic.u Roth's report in
die relation between hojxuic angiosarcoma anil exposure cluded -17 workers with chronic arsenic intoxication, Of
lugaseous iim/chloride. In 1P7I. Italian mu*.vtig;iior>re ihfcc, foul li.ul hepilic carcinomas, five had sarcomas fan
ported that pi o longed inhalation nl vinyl chloride pro- giosarcomas). ami l;l of 27 atUopsied by him had unusual
rimed carcinomas of the /ymli.il gland in r.us.1* ami ty peso) cirrhosis.'*
Fram ihc t_K>r.i.irt .! t*.etjali'?. N.iiion.it Cancer Instuutc. N.norul
ln-iiru*<->[ Mv.a.h, H.-iIic-C.., VIP. thr Mount .`-in 11 ScNviliif M cilicinc-if
the t il. rmtcj-in nr Nc* 'tuck.NV. the S.*,:i.ii ..ji l>ic.ise>of thi.-Li-i.-i.
'siw..i Jn-I..';! ol' .Vst-::i-. Ms'i.<K>lisin ..nJ [>:-.-*siivir ihst-.t-tfs. S.i-
li.in..' In-;.1 HU'-.<11i.'.il:h. h.'ifM-.u, MII. .ii'.l ih.1t -.ii.ir.uiJ liirlfi IH-Iitt.
j; I -.J.o-Ui.ii'v't. t V:u .. !.-r Pl.lMSf tortllol. .VI.lGt.l.
li V bill's- iv'poni
:> 11, lli.nv.-- >!
S.Oiiin.ii C'jn-cr
lua^ 11-.. ...It: v: i. u.-aw.-... mp:-hui
Pi IMnwi l .`.Mr:*. >.!'! if in Ki-ni.L'm.i.-, I'wO-irv. lmcrn.tlion.tl Ccn-
l.-i, S I'.mii.it
IU.m'.I-
Material Studied
Tin* ohM'rt.ttmm ivomicil litre .tie luted mi the study of lie-
pitii li-uio obtained [mm 20 vioikcrs wlu h;ul imUi-.ui.il e,s-
vim 11 Uloi jilt It ii' potli.ii^tii jivi iixK. iiMiatlv tutnlitii'
inn vr.u - .inti i virmlinu >i|> to l-S m*;ii -, Tlu* tl-Miv- weie l*i itrcl
Ikhii I "> |i.iiii'niN v.ii Ii
ivniii .uni live with lit pit i< liln in.
Iiui i./ili.iui
.m.i, Tlic iii.iftn in ol lln -c -|K-< ni.rvi- i>i
imli.illi tilii.inutl. -rutlii-il. .mil in mint i.i--'% u'jhhu-i! It. tilli
n'.1 J Inn .ill i>fit Milumitvil i`*(lit 1.,iLmiiatoiy il 1'.ulioS><gv, N.i-
APObOf4637
-HK NFAV F.NCl.ANb JOURNAL OF MKIJ1CINF
Jan. 2, 107.3
'.
s.
Si , -.7 ix*.
Figure i. Hepatic Artg iosarcoma in a Worker Engaged in Polymerization of Vinyl Chloride. A shows sinusoidal pattern progressing lo a papillary pattern (straight arrow) (hematoxylin and eosin stain x 100). Note envel
oping tumor cells separated by widened tissue space ol Disse (curved arrow). B shows small cavernous spaces with transition to anaplastic growth in angiosarooma in the upper part of the photomicro
graph and liver-cell pistes enveloped by sarcoma cells in the right lower corner (hematoxylin and eosln stain x 100).
tioiul Cancer Institute, for review. Recalle of the nature of our access to ilte material, ilicsespeciuiensdonoi represent a consec utive series and cannot l>cconsidered to indicate!he reUthe fre quency of these vinyl-chlorkle-associ.itcct lii-pa tic lostons.
Twenty specimens from the IS jutiems with angiosarcoma were reviewed, and IK rtf these (right autopn and 10 biopsi). showed ansriosurcuma. In addition, two of these patients hud pre vious livvr biopsies tli.n (tad been obtained six and three months before dor diagnmiiol Iwjntk angiosarcoma was made. In sewn of the patients (four uuto])-) and five biopsy specimens) sufficient liter tissue w;is |>re*vni outside die angiosarcoma and free r*f pressure effects inpt-itnii ;ui oval nation of die mnrpliolug) of the tuinor-fice portionsitfiiteliver.
laser iismu* was obtained In biopsy I fit e stirgicul und one ncedk-b'ops-v it|Kxiim-U'.) in the fixe patients with hepuk. iibriiMS whlmm known utiginsamima. In one patient in wlnnu lirp.ua fibnras h.itl lceiH>l>HTved in an iititi.il mu gkal itiopsy specimen, a fo!li>w-u]> iiiviUe l>inp%\ was obtained dm ing jm.-i itoiteosiopv aficr an intenal >>l iw.i sears, itie |>atiem lias ing had no lurtliei expoMiu" n vim ft itior idc
Ohscis.iiimis nf die splenic changes wt-te made on thtce surgh al and i wo auiop^s spe imens. All spitmicns wete fixed m (twm.ihn .mtl sindiixl bs t unsvuiioii.d mkinso>|maI Us lHits.
Observations
Angiosarcoma
Although the jiie'cmi' ol anu.ins.tt minus in \iti\l 11!>-
tide wen ket s lias piet imtsk been topni ted. the hislolngu
hai a< H i i't ii % id the i mix m s .ne brie!I\ < ! -- ihed in ,ui .\t-
tcm;>t ;> distinguish litem In.in hejMik .uigiosaimm.t-
apparently not induced by chemicals and to trace their
possible relation to iIk fibrottc lesions. Three basic pat terns, listed here in order of frequency, were seen in dif
ferent parts of the angiosarcomas.
Tiie first, the sinmahlnl pattern, was characterized by focal, often nmhicentric. dilatation of sinusoid*, with hy
pertrophic and hyperplastic sarcoma cells forming a lin
ing for the dilated sinusoids. The sarcoma cells enveloped liver-cell plates and bile ductules and infiltrated fihrmic
portal tracts (Fig. l.i). The enveloped hopatocytes were usually hypertrophic and hyperplastic anti ihuapjK*ared
its cords around dilated bile cuivalicnli. which often contailietl hiie plugs. IzHisciy arranged ivticulm and collagen
filn-rs were present in the widened tissue sjwc of lh*se to
gether with increased numbers of Jxon-nenplastic-apjK'aring Fibrnhiasts.md macrophages.
Tiie second, the
pattern. liad larger and move
irregular vascular spues. Loose strands of hepi lie eon Is enveloped hv sarcomatous cells projected into these
spaces. Antipin- and disappearance ol hepaiii cord cells
developed, with inci cased fihiosisol tiie widened spue ol Disse.
The third, the (muimin pattern. was rltaracteri/eil In even l.itger. hluod-lilied |i;is stinmindvd In iliiik, ii-
htnlit Hallsluicdln vtitoinaioiiscellsfFit;. Hi).
1 ti .uii It ii- hi. one loin i h til i he <ingios.it com.is h.itl nun e
solid nodules of anaplastic sanoniu. I liese nodules out-
t
AP00014638
Vol. 292 No. 1
V1NYI.-CP UDt ISDUCtO UVKK DISEASE -THOMA* "T AL.
19
proved lit? surrounding pnremhvmj, arid in one tumor, uiiapiasiic sarvonnt cell* invaded |*>ri,il-vein brunt lies,
1-^.u dilatation of sinusoid* with pmlilcTatinii arid ciii.;: icvtit mJ the sinusoidal tells associated with pt*ri^i-
->i.!u,u mm-M-ni .tnc.trK M-i-^r hi the cvolte i-i'll.i 1 his I> sj.<n v%,i noirti m of the tumor-lice loci [jcliihciis from patients
with ;^i' ii.i! miiu. .liul in t Ik- two biopsies taken before aiv^nI'.iKtinsa w.isdeteited. li was jlsoohservrdin twopa tient- mi whom .m^iMs.irumni has not developed. and in whom, accordingly, careful follow -up observation is indi cated. In the patient* with angii>sam>m;i. some o( the si* mitoidul lining cell* hud enlarged, atvpical nuclei and bul ky cMopluxn that was PAS negative in contrast to many of the lining cells in the uninvolved parenchyma (Fig. 2). There were gradual mmsittom Iwtwcen the areas of focal dilatation of miuisomU to multiple, microscopic-sized an giosarcomas with a sinusoidal pattern.
In three patients other organs besides the liver were in volved by angiosarcoma: the duodenum in one, the lung in a second, and Use lung, heart, kidney and lymph nodes in a third patient. Hepatic fibrosis1
All the livers without angiosarcomas and the unin volved portions of die livers with angiosarcomas showed
Fipur* 2 Focal Dilatation oi Sinusoids, wun Hyoerpiastic Hroatocytes (Arrow) and Excess Sinusoidal Unmet Calls. So'".? .vi;n Hvpefchromntic Nuclei (This Acceptance Con trast* with That oi Normal Sinusoids in tne Ri^nt Lower
CornBr)(Hematoxylin and osm Stam * i60j
the same basic changes, the extent of which varied widely within each specimen. Kxcess fibrous connective tissue caused variable enlargement of most portal tracts (Fig. J.-f). A rii.MiiH.tive feature wax the tendency for single liop.no> i n - .uid groups of hopatoev cos ,n ihe mar .jins of tlie : a:.i! i:.ii!> |o In' sep.iv.ned Imm adtutcut hepatic coni ieli> and surrounded by tills projji cssise hliiosis. IViiltivKiiiiuiol bile ducts was noted in these fibroiit portal tracts togedier with a variable in filtration of hinplimviis, Occusiniulh. the walls oi porial-vein brunches showed futul fibrosis. Adjacent portal tracts were often connected by connective-tissue septa in the sense of a perilobular fibrosis and some thin septa traversed the parenchyma and extended irregularly toward central veins. In two cases, both with angiosarcomas elsewhere in the liver, these septa separated pansof the parenchyma to produce nodules. The hepatic capsule showed focal thickening and nodular Hbrotic areas that often extended into subcapsular hepatic tissue to connect with adjacent portal tracts. The sinusoidal lining cells were focaily increased in number, especially in areas where sinusoids were dilated. Intralobular, perisinusoidal fibrosis, though inconspicu ous in heinaioxylin-eosin-stained sections, could be dem onstrated in these areas by special stains for reticulin and collagen fibers. In otherareas, groups of hepaiocytes, with no particular intralobular localization, varied conspicu ously in cellular and nuclear size, many of them being dis tinctly enlarged (Fig. Jfl). Binudear and multinudeate hepaiocytes. some with much cytoplasm, were intermixed with a few hepaiocytes that were smaller than normal. De generation and necrosis of hepaiocytes. although present, were not more conspicuous than in any routine surgical specimen, in the second biopsy specimen, obtained in one patient two years after cessation of exposure to vinyl chlo ride, these abnormal changes in both hepaiocytes and si nusoidal lining cells hid disappeared, but the capsular, portal-tract and intralooular fibrosis persisted.
Splanic Changas
The available spleens were large, weighing 560 to 1050 g, and showed on cutsection enlarged Malpighian follicles and a firm, beefy red pulp. Microscopically. the follicles were hyperplastic and had large germinal centers and wide perifollicular zones (Kig. 4). Occasionally, fresh hem orrhage teas found around penicillury arteries and folli cles. The red-pulp sinuses were witlened and often lined bya continuous layer ofcuboidal leticuloettdotltelciUells. The slightly thickened pulp cords contained mam lym phoid and histiocytic cell* us well ;u erythrocytes. Fibrosis of the red piilpwasabseni t>r inconspicuous, ami hemosiderinopltagcs wcreonlyttccasionaUyseen.
Discussion
The relatively frequent development of hepatic angio sarcomas iti workers engaged in tlie polymerization nl ti nt I chloride Has now lteen cMuhlislied. lit this rojmrt die emphasis is on a {H*euliar hepttu' fibrosis in cm It woi kers and its rein ion km lie angiosarcomas. This fibrnsis. whUh
s to repu'seut a second hepitic lesion atn tin liable to vtwl chloride e\[v>nrc. was lomul in the iiiimn dne
20
THE NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MF.DL
Jan. 2. 1075
Figure 1 Subcapsular Portion of a Surgical Specimen of the Liver of a Worker with Portal Hypertension.
Note A the focal fibrotie thickening of the capsule and variable fibrotic enlargement of the portal tracts with fibrous connec tive tissue extending between periportal liver-cell plates. The lobular architecture is intaet (heractoxylin and ecain stain x 25). G shows indistinct groups of hepatocytes with enlarged cytoplasm and nuclei, sometimes binucleate. particularly in the upper pert of the photomicrograph in eontrest to smell hepatocytes. In pieces the sinusoidal lining cells are somewhat enlarged (ar
row) (hematoxylin and eosin stain x18Q).
portions of the liver of patients who had or were subse quent])' shown tohave angiosarcomas, and atso in patients without angiosarcoma who came to attention because of splenomegaly and manifestations of portal hypertension. The fibrosis is characterized by a conspicuous, focal capsu lar fibrosis, which is most impressive on gross inspection and was demonstrated in German workers by peritoneos copy.11 by a variable and irregular fibrosis of portal tracts, and by inconspicuous areas of intralobular, perisinusoidal fibrosis, This fibrosis is topographically related to prolif
eration and activation of sinusoidal fitting cells and cells in the {issue space of Disse. These changes are associated with focal hypertrophy and hy|x:rp].isin ut Iwpatocvtes. The hepatneues are not .severely injured, nor h reactive intralobular itilLun mation seen. The apparent imegritvof llte hep.mxvtes explains win hepatk' tests that indicjie lu'p.mx ell nlaralierat tons v ield erratic or even normal re sults bull is st.iie.r'l!'l'tiese tests, therifoi e. cannot he de pended tqx mi to deret I the hepatic fibrosis. In llte spleen pioltln.mnii ol Kinplioitl ami tem ulnemlmhclial cells is observed, hut libn wish uni seen.
Although the 4 hat . ret isi < hepatic fihiosis w.is pres,
eut in alU.tsc'oi .ingioviHoma in whit Iadequate hepnit lissin was available. ihere is no e\ idem i- I h.u all tases ni hepaiiv libroo pinned lo.mgios.iiiomas, In the wot kers
engaged in the polvmerization of vinyl chloride who were studied by us. the combination of hepatic angiosarcomas and fibrosis was more common than the fibrotic lesions alone. In other studies of workers exposed to vinyl chlo ride in Germany.4* Romania,1 and Russia* the fibrotic le sions without angiosarcomas have been more frequent, and a survey in this country revealed an increased inci dence or splenomegaly in such workers, dependingon the duration of their exposure.17
The relation of the fibrotic lesions to the development of angiosarcomas rx|uireftirt)ier study. However, a tran sition from tin.* fibrotic stage to angiosarcoma is suggested by theJocal proliferation ixrihof the sinusoidal lining ceils and of the hr|iuincyie<ith:it is seen in i he fibrotic stage hut becomes even more pronounced in the initial stages of an giosarcoma development. Further progression is indi cated by proliferation and piling up of atypical, samimaimis-appearing sinusoidal and perisinus<tidal cells that envelop proliferated hrpauxyies in t he areas of sinusoidal dilatation. These features. which elta ratteri/e tin* tmilticentric angiosarcomas with a sinusoidal pattern, can lw traced ftntber to the angiosarcoma*, with pupillarv and
cavernous giowth patients, in ouiv a few cases. omlttlcs comjHtsed of anaplastic sartonia cells are*lwerved. Thus, ihe evolution of tin* hejxuk lesions ;uul the enlargement
i I
AP00014640
I*?frlOOOdV
Tiftl `t l-lMMl'l l*| |rihH/\ pr.viv
Iip |> :<H<iuiao va :t|i*uiMqUi<'
ii|.asij i.sp .nioi/tiiajJ
{ ItlHlkMlIljajN fitSns IAji 1')ipn/unl .V| :<J AUiW.'j.Vl lUs*;|l-J-y (,)
Ufil "C>`U | j" | ojj j.vnJO 'pijo|t|.i |.uih ii nauisj pui'
5
-vSun; "ui'i*. irj jo Atuodxnj niuario.Mio :y
y
'-jj f,
j Llll V|\Vf ' lUl'til U<!)IVlJAkU1tlld.'>plJ0m.1 IMIIA I' fSJ.VlJ^Vi
I 3mouib 5*cjsip AfiniAH is \AO Mw*M -1f 'If H^U `H 1IM X
3 i%r!i,:*i9::KojoAinpw *i<u!ip
1 sjruopi?nt *rtp iwpc|tu up pnr| :w nn^et^A *1 uwafaJQ 'I n!jnS X
. ' 96l . 'iff I'CCIUjlgi P*W *S 'vjiiii-jd fc **4Ai ukti jo uojiAnpoid 9141 u{
j paSOua u*vo U| siwip |iq puc j<a|i aqi jo op.x>jjv IVO umsinj '9
j rtprci-PK
J paiuijiaqiv qaav 1| sojhsw9IXs aiAutpjqsjiij*! .Atnilijyiui'.j^
1 -pyom3|Auj,\ aiueuurtus aiq :ps ia *q uisis S *4'*f "30 *>n
WAX!
WiV lpsy Jtiag -sij.ujqn >>uiaii'd;>u,m>?ldS':0
>
ri`tin-men
ojjo* spijam>iAiHA ui jjai] syi jo ikuoajrwiXuv :<fci
*ld "H X
um`>s-Ci"kVKVf"* odva apuoiqs |Aui* tuiMonaj ja{| aqi jo muo.'uisoiiuv :0f jaoig
W `Itl-OiW paN***0f-appoN-'l*#!*^] AJfUMSjnUtlU *M1U| J9A|| J0XUi03JB>OrflJV INN UOlUWJflf l(AS*0 i
sasNinfi^
qioqjocuiojjcsois
-1m oncdaq jo atuojpuXs s.uucg jaipia aanpojd |[im s[B3i
uauc ucSjoui jo apjjojqs |Xut.\oi ajnsodxadiuojijj itqi
Aji|iqif*od aqi aicfiau iou caop lacj <;qi inq 'pauodaj uaaq
iou ceq ciuosjroiXug p iuauido|aAap uiuo umou^uh jo ouicjpuAt * nucg uj -sjojacj |tnuauiuojjAua Sutisadsns
joj uoccaj (cuoiuppe ut ri uonnquitip jiqdcjSoaS fiqj_
-t'Aia-viiuaixa patpms aje Xaqi ajaqM `ucdef put itioij
1 -JV quoK EpucSn as-n`qput ui'iuanbajj jaqiej ui inq ! rtPHOA tU9*C9A\ >M> ui A(p3tpejodc pa-uaqo ajt kxo
qanq -u.ou?tun n acnra aqi qaiqM ut tuopipuoa jc|ilu;s
jaqto axnta.icuifitjiuiaqs paijtiuaptun itqi ncaSSns sjes
tuaue stucSjou; jo spuoiqa {auiaoi jnodxa paSuojojd ,\q uoiunpui luajcddc tit `aiuojpUAS s^iung jo uo;suai
-jad.tq |Ruod attpedotpi aqi jo utSuo aqi jaAaieqAi
's;tojq!/jqntdex)nrpueje{nrdc3?qi.{q
tpiotnuit aq) jo rap put twojqij jcuod aqi Xq paiuaAajd
n saqautjq uiaA-pnJod jo uotiuainp avneaaq mo|j poojq
atitdaq paseajau; nqi aitpouiUHSOB 01 X|tqut ire jo
qnsaj aqi aq iqSiui uoisuauacKq jeiJOd 'MO!J poo|q autd aq put aiuafds ui ascajsttt luanbaraoacqitM `|[aj 3iua|ds
jo uotiiqnujTjsoi anp .\[c8auiouaidsaqXt;uj apuom? [auia 01 ajnsodxa pa8uo(ojd jost|nj aqi joauojrqi `ajojajaqi
'aiqtssod <; ]j iS*si|3a |ci|aqH)puao{ru;iaJ puc pioqdui.<|
3ui[rijo ufHTqmutK Xq nuauiuadxa ftuiiur ut paanpojd
uaaqaARq auiojpu.icsaputtg 8ui|quiaaj siioptpuoQ skk>
uno ui cnonaidsuoaiou (km uoica|siqi inq `(stsojaps jcuod -omiai|) taqauejq tit jo uta.\ jtniod atp jo |)cm aqi jo uop
-cjaqc vs.ijRpuosas jo rzAJcuiud e qii.tv un;suauadXq {ei
jod aqi araoonr: sjoqinc auios it'UtMsuaiJadXq jruod 3;
-qipdotpt rn paictt8tsap \|jimsn mou ajt pun uoistiaijad.vq
jtijcx! qiiM pnintjov^ratr aiuojpuXss mirg jo sasna ih>|\tt \(iiTriHiSAa sisotjj.ii.-) vq pa.nO|[Ojaq ,j.->a.'>.*oi| mtuj ij sis
<uqij Mion^idsmoiij tjit.M pairj.xKsn si .hi sisojtjij .liiixt.-iq
aqi sjpawjd AjrhatiKm.ijds aqi aunupiiAs s.iiucu ut 'J.iAij
.-nioqjjt.i aqi nt <unnr.t.i]|u .`iitunti'ipoui.iq mfi Xq posnmsj
tfiiia iiuapK nip ipiq * ui *sisoq ui.i iip*^.iui(Kt,>;i!s
<: 1'i`iiiiu) u[
| mii \ m pJMxlx-i s.i.'s| urn aim's 111
pau.v^jotiajtmid iraiiui-i [CDiiuapj ny (-ptntg (q paqu3<
-op auiojpu.is aqi vi uoixnauad.u| pruod pun i|t:8aui
->ua|ds Xq patunduto33n sisojqtj 3jlttdaq snonjidsuojiij
(On * w: uisoa pue utiAxeieiusu) psua>i3iu] Aim6i|S ie spjor d;rx3 -psj pue pauapiM aie sasnuig sioiuaj teunujsS efijei i-o>q
xepu* atijauj qaiq/* -sapino) ueiuGidiew duseidjacAu aicq
*iso;oiJ snodan *i#J -poiq uiim jeifjoAit e jo uoa|ds pSAOuiay ^titsiGjng -9 sjpOij
- *saiXao)cdaq jo etftidaadXq put XqdoJuadXq pnoj pue nsojqtj jejnqoj CJiuj ppm 'stcojqtj jcijod a.AisujSojd Xjauinu -- apijojip [Xuia 01 patodxa siuaiiod aqi u; asoqi 01 JUjtuiis saSueqo anvdaq pa.uasqo n\ r,-pai4odaj tuaqi jo omi `uon njos s jp|mo4 qiiM vtsqjocd jo luauiiraj) uijai-Suoj jaije uotsuauadXq p*iJod qit.n stsojqtj aiindaq pjiui jo cases aajqi X||c3t8o|Oisiq Xpntc 01 ajqc aja.n a.* `ptuiqas put janaqss -f-j *cjcj jo Xnaurnn aqi qSnojq t -cisojqtj 3iicd -aq snonaidsuoout ampsud oqc Xeui 4apiJO|q3 |Xuia aqq
*q3tqM tS jn>s|r3iu3SJR oiur^joui Xq paonpiu tmuoojcsoiB ue 111 pa7isinjdiua ajc sajninaj jrjtiuis irat-paAjasqo ait qcojqij jo citaju je|n8dij; puc aitJcj qaiq.M ui (ifCJlojoqjJ uoisuadsnc apixoip umuoqi Xq pasnpui sriuoaincoiSuc ui mauiuiojd 3Jit sajninaj SuutopMtq -sXaxjns 3i8o|oiui
apida ui a.-ummcce jo aq Xnui suonc.vjcqo asaqx `Uj^uo jh)i ?n Api j<>h|,i | uma isutnitnsaintjtiu !iMus\|ii n it; ajuju
-juiojd sii|i |i> .AMi.istp: ajrp ij amaijadx.i |o sim*<] nqi uq
siqi
jii*j asmt.i UMmis|un jo i*t:u>3
-Jitsoijiiir .111 r<Inq jo s.isili \ii'|^ njmodsn .ipj.io|t|3 ]sills
xnjiului.is.qi ii'i|i sinuo).n*snitMii* nivdnq ju iiisijaiirjrq'i
m -'.t tniusl ijhnu^. ti'|njMi r ,;j 1 j.ujir l 'sj|.i) louin; j ;-.
j<> uj.iiii (l >j )m.
J;imiii[.T mm .i;(, j n.Hi.uintuud nq.x
3tu.i(<is pun .qmtaq j<> s.xKi (im.as.is un snn|ni|natu s;i ju apuo|i|3 (.stns Xq majja fiuurpiuins usiuji<inv uaajds aq] jo
\Z
"TV ~ vKOH "* iSVJSia WAIT 033naM-:f rHO''H3*lAN,IA
J * 86t F'A
zmiooodv
VII
|0 >*M|1 VUiOllK.liHIIM VM '*`1 1
1'l .M|l
p> .iiruiiiv.i |M<[n{i|.i^i|.uiitiiixrMi i|i iiinqii m |>,>-n .*> i,m , ,ih|iu
sin ii ji Mium Xiiii irv r .hij inumAivi vi< pm*,,ti.tir11 >.>i)\ ici jmi
qi.iiu .M) |
|^` qn\\ pAmliimivovi w.-viiil qr.i`n.Ni
|.M| win fiui|i|KOvi di^ -aviumIs .up pi iriji i| |>.ijnSiim) m-w
iii.hiiiI t|va go .v.ioi.iij \uioi
aiji \nnl f>-xi[ linn amiikIs
o*r.i jo.j vuiMjrriuno j|i* ui p.mii ajam osvrrui* (*,il|iH`Hl *mjioj
qiiw .no],1.140.1 iqHim imp ooih-j jnj *.him <n p.ii|iinu
ii.i.ni v|L>jiimi.iiiiiq 'Mii.'imi |i.iij ii`iii .up pi v|>ui`i|vni| piht
tailhii(. .iqi ji>i).un>.ti<>.>4.11(10.>i( | `Oii.it nxl .up J<> kMiqqiv Tin;\i|
VIC iji' jo p.ltkimoi ju(j
ulntutf |i4uuo <ix |>,ipn(.*nj.is't*" pur inuit'iu.ioj
ui .iji|rj|.i4iin .iinS iuaiir*d aiiQ (iainHiv,inl>*rM a.\i|i*|.u jaqmtir
joikkjikJ imp`ASIKkIv joHlj<|i>.i!>lii!UJ4nmmMii:uiJi|ininonr
nirusjuFi m*.v nianrd r
.unodkaj iua.i jad (>o J | fwnjiioj
ajnpo.Mud viq j '<iii4(>ii<m1'~ij-nun inoij uoiimiuojiii uri-rqioj jo
iionruuojiii .np \juav t p.inmpl.ipi u.X|) sr.w i.Mfqiii ipr^ `dlui
(irtii oM jaijv p.-iptiodiaj 51 |TU| (|V iuunM(iu.iddv pur .uuoi -5.i|jiMn>i jia;joicu| ,siiui|({i4iaip pur tauiodv- jpqi `uho Jiaqj
MuipjiioAJ SimniMipcanb t tuas aijwi tiuaiwd if \ jjy ja`| jo
pyf 1 ui pavou^ripajon tascaatp joiusjiad auvr.iiqhrj `uonny
jaicajQ ui <|R);dsot( i rr ciuattnd neait jaiua;} ai(j_ *1001(19
jrjipajv; pjrajrh 'AdRJMjXuoiinpcx joj JaiusQ}umfoqijo tpjo
mj aqi umjj paiimiapi aua* *aum icip ir paMojioj fonaq pur arcavip t^uc^Kpopi SuiAvq cr f-f- pun f(jo tafev aqi uaawiaq *do kj .iq paioukmp cuouad aiiq.H Xuiaji (fc `jg[ 'jaquiasaQ U(
saotixapj
Al.x xiv J.i.iur,) urHJiWY
H1 UK14J (ill | VX,() pjrwr ur pu* *9.'I14>;
.-MM'M s 1 Mni:|uj
4.vmi'*,T ta,MM|i*\ *iji uinjj ij-j;*!! X ,1 tul iui*j? fluiuii'ii i* h I'*"-. 1
*<j| | ;n v (V *U'iMij( **3iv UiilSuilunu __v*Hl|r.iH ,,Nliil jim*iii*SP,r'
-4i*H iM|oiUiApiU;( iniu.HtiiiisJ.'ii anui'.Y' ) '<1 oivts.iiif'.u .unJ.invijp
pi'i (i'on.%' |R.i;pai\ pirvii h 'iJi*j>*mu.*ii>'ipi'X Ji'iuivwii2.i(; aui pu>- id
-cj4J_ uojiiiip'y 4j
luiof >i(; pur 'inux iiipiAH ''K'ld S'.l `ami
iisu] i-iiurj) |i*ui*rii\s: `sjvj'urjj ui>unpi*x pun <sti'|LiiLu.ipid;^ aiji Wiin-iH
JO looM-'S pjr*4rH
(i* lu.iiupnlSQ l| : uiojj
A1.1.\j|M(li.1J '}MKip|lipi`JKII' p(JlH|pjUj,1 III SUH'iC
.ijtuomo.'XJi.'Mii ((i.iHiiu o) *s,->simxIs jiur *?iiii|<[j< -i.<liuuJ-;
uovi.nxiiuoi OMi
asiTKip s_in^H|nin jo
nuu.
p.1]|()J|lin.1 A[.1S((,1 K? sums .1511KHUl.liHH.KIV <v.1|(in .ipluuh
-.qir patiiwi! .iq u in him pur (itnr.iuoii .K| aiuu
j; uj.vn
MOIjri.Viim* ]>,1UH<I.U dip `1IH|J<
*.H[ OVJtl AKUI P^IVISip
11^111 Si |M>14 pilll
TltlH niliVH)I,H*S qilM p.lll'J.U.UO .il
-j.isji])3411 kaivij \iuoi3.i|[iviH>j_ *J{uipuijciiji p,iijc)cldnsmil
oaki| \i|rj.iu.iS `fcuu.ii|jui>.i qSnoqi ,,.c`saipni!! juanbasqns
j.iA.iMOH s'druuS ohr
ui dnv>ci(> oqi jo jnuidj jo
-ni|p piic ai^o|o3fiiq aii<i|(Mtup!d .\u\ patwSSnj sc iusSc
snon.iajui ur qii.muaimuoaci uonu.uanqocuu, ,'cuofijad pa/HuujjS|[ism>i-uou sc ascasip i ui^Spoj-j jo juauidopA
p jo 3|nj aqi tauin aajqi inoqr a.\cq .iUi033a|;i<Li0] -- jo AJOisiq r qit.ni sqnpc Stuno.\ jcqi pawodsj sc.m x X
(SZ61 `52-23:362 P*W P l6ug N) *esQ(o jbioos pooypjiqo ypM pajejajjoo si ass
sip s.ujqBpOH jo esneo e ;eu; OutjsaBOns `peseajoap
szis diiisqis S8 eseajoui
punoj sbm asea
-sip s.utxfipoH jo xsiu `2!S ZpuiBj. Aq psijipouj pue
jtaidiuoo s[ jo iBsneouou si jaima essasip s.ujxBpoh
pup *ujcnoe>;isuo} uBB.vaeq uoiiejej aq; jcg) seiiduii
uousiposse aqi jo aBuej am *Apnis joi-id b ujojj ejep
ui punoj sem azjs diqsqis tp)M oijbj m*M |0 uoijbijca
jeuuiis v 0M4 azis jo sdiqsqis it am, oiljiim Ajuo Au/oi
oailisuo) qi|M paiBioosse sbm eseesip jo xsij paeesjsuf pus *2is dtusqis 01 fiuipjoooa pajeedaj sbm sisZ|BuB Guijqis-Bsso eqx 'O'S-B O) I'-1 sbm }j uosued -ujoo 6u!iq|s*aseo b jo sieeq aqj uo :(sifuji| ouapij -uoo ;uao jad $5 `l l 01 s i) i'C sbm suosjod paziuioj
-deiijsuo: Cuoujb asaas;p s.uixBpon jo oijbj hsii aqi 'uosuedujoo esnotis-aseo a jo sisBq aqj uo `sesnods
OZ pus s6ui|qis gig jieqj. mjim sjuaqed jjnpe OunoA get.
jo uosuadujoo Aq pajBBqsaAui sbm esBasjp s,u;x6poH pue Aujopaiiisuoj jo uoijeposse m lOKJjsqv
noj dniHj onv `
4`koskhoI**3 Hdiv^ *a'I\' `n'd
"K'S `khosktllio adkvji;
3ZIS A1IKVJ QMV AW01D3TIISNOX *3SY3Sia &KI30QOH
f96t jomutvH *i^V `/iiiu> pjqMui suuijtp c r iiurg tnqnjow =X IH^S `SC
rt6l *M ^)l |Oi*d>H |W>lu*04inQ uuv 'Ru^iaqins Mtip a;pS*uioup|dk ta|
vuttp aioj np ]> >iu q *p tanbiuioimir ni.iadsv -H Jnoqiy *q jBiriu-( * [f
W6J `fff-fltn WJHun A|rtlun*u9|d\ jraidoj) Aiqi'rdoipi
ui uou.u>uadAi( (cuod :ie o 'X uus "Y uotvoui^ (j mqii'M 'K
(Ml
'MjiAiMjaitiiB `uopuo^ 'A|tiS>wou>|d^ juliikui '-KB nni'Y HV nuig
r*w 8-y 9|i*uod uoi<uaudX(] :|t* is -y wnux `B K'Ui>||inQ `jf nouirquag 'K
AVM Sfriiiwt (Stinisi |ouaidiondaH wiy *|<u*:h>t(H(.*>pui! vaSojiia Xq p>.inpiji auiojjvu^1. >i(i|-iiurg :|i-1 *x <i!X `X nvirx 'j oui'uin.q XT
WM'nw-rwASi *J,>s uv (MMuaji- |v|4od*i4ird>i() M>ot|4Jir lnowim U''i'-u9:J5k! 14 |< l.'i'd .'Mi'U
AiTJ.ui P|* 'fJii] i|'* 19 `Ts '4A15>( t H Uipunuip3 -d.il "i,'irVl1K YC
0.61 'iiZ-ZZZ'`O jaii-j J4*'Jd 'ripu] ui ssrsvip 4*n 0s. Xp4|-\ 'A iun*i,`i>l'ui|i-ui<T( 'fj
4Vfl1 'yv-lt'VV |*HV UJflUl UUV U*5*ri41s|.'UlAs flHod .I'lld.141:41
VS pur V|kdl|44(.1 JO UM*uaiJ8fi Vd
SU'. Vi'". U"i*J'-.`Xr'S UOIUa|
.-Adiv jrj4'Hl S'Vl'iJoip] :(> IA -<V - 1-* K `,;N
*` ' `VJ };
SiAl \r.Z .ZZ 1.1 " .1`J`h .
. 0
VW I|ur0 8i*aipr|em 1*1 p siuauomnd 1 vacihij'ir ssivjo.j v ikui'a`kC
Uufi! '"i-fli'i:
iS-U'-J uoimiov \,4>|av03 64 uofir.iiwoui sius'jr nmuij.* a.'., j.->*'| jo nuiogji" jn|4)Oiuji>i*urujiH -p-1.1 f nuidvO'fi uii>| uovjsSPjj H
SuM 'Uir-k'Hr luiovwd V3JV uonsafu!
>41 mijci ue<< ;j 4Ai| aqi jo vmosjrs joovro %ou r Ktvejiojoqi) p[
voip w(tuot|i (ipo(|09Xq poumuwmu uifuofU(9Kr7 ;f ruc>H BAffscp 'IC
Ct6l`MI*Jd :08 Ivl rUB9S (ou^usiw (oquid b>v tniaiitd afi|\oi(Vuinuoiji ui
unoumi4Mi||HiV4Ai[joXio|CM(indoi'!t|(i o;H
'fiPf^JVA 'Oc
***! `iK`ll t-C
-univjaui aqi jo aiham pun ara e jo uodau :mai{ -qi jo muoiiAviiop
UMiSuuuiAq *)iuad(
uoiuijof `Q[ fuiuiqj *vi p|8juun|g *(]
tifI TBf-kirCil
"V
-ja!| jo tioiiim ji!|rmnA tumtfj|t\ :|S npfvH 'OV ioaoh `OA UJCPV 'SI
IVMijd
uij 1,15 ptv AN uuv 'ur'lio* opooiv.*1 |iuiAV|od pun apuu|(|> |<uia fimue maiip jo aauap-Aaid tjc i *vh utnoapuy '% uinro `B VID 11
liAl `flVlCVt'lVB-'^PJ
-vqai^l 7 '<uui!|9viopuoi^uruii*Hi :u4ocbx*i*M!V,1'U!KJV 3 Wv'B 91
-.: -- - --.`'.(j
SuniJl?4SAUa-.4V J.1liS'lk04lp--i*- - S'..--
< .*.
airui'd ?i|.ii!iv(Jii/-iv.'iu avj .p' .1 \ 4.i-".'i'X *3 jaiM*' ! f * .u-sj y |
flftl 'f6-"K'*o. s..-u.iiiuM4.iJ - Jod
.niiiq4Ji.iuou pun pivs'/y |v v;
-j\ piu:q*s -^J
*. 1
rpj is.'. : -!L*.i<'4|i''(J u.
_ j - :v: -.,. . . -.2,
JJU-.4 -I ui*u |'Tiv'"ui'.`.,i ; r
t
U t .*, 4;
C;M >itMlv:->6-'V-"VJV?u,Vk
paiH aquio ui'UUnpiUdOAH J3P U444Y unpnjsuaq1
aq3MXutm(.iiiui>4qj :( 12 *x iailPK `Mv. qinqisT TH i8li>i'Ji*K 7! (M.ijd u{1 Alo|OJai
uaojivrQ 2pou|q,i |XuiaOi amvodxi paftuotujd 6ui*>ii|pij viuapoj puc
wrw U| emos/nvoiBm; ,iiieeH :(i: i Q
g-j >iuajov|X *3Q uopuo^ - | |
Ci6! `S l
JN.jiaiK io TYNUnof QNV-10N3 M'4N 3Hi
bb